Sounds like BS to me.
Running burns about 100 Calories / mile[0] (62.5 Calories / km).
100 km means 6250 Calories burned.
Fat is 9 Calories per gram, so 6250 Calories is 1.5 lbs (0.694 kg) of fat. Even if the calorie burn rate is way off - say by 50%, there is no way any of those athletes is in danger of running out of body fat.
And that doesn't even count the carb gels and other food runners typically eat on runs.
___
0. https://www.runnersworld.com/nutrition-weight-loss/a20784289...
Okay, at least that blog post is written by someone with a phd, but you can't really take this at face value either. It's probably reasonably true in general (obviously still highly dependent on the person doing the running), but you seem to be assuming that this rate is the same on short runs and long runs, which sound suspicious. I wouldn't at all be surprised if the rate of energy expenditure increased as the time/distance of the race increased. Also if they're running instead of sleeping, I imagine that is probably increasing energy use as well.
I'd also be pretty surprised it the 100 calories/mile was taking into account the person's resting metabolic rate. That could easily add another one to two thousand (more depending on the person) calories per day.
Finally, even with your analysis coming to 1.5lbs of fat, that's quite a lot of fat in a trained athlete. I'd expect most of the men running these races are well below 10% body fat, and the lower your body fat is the more resistant the body tends to be when it comes to losing more. Losing 1.5 or more lbs of fat would probably be moving their body fat percentages down quite noticeably, which is not easy to do at such low levels.
So maybe it is all bs, but I don't think it can be ignored so easily either.
You're way off
> This study compares body composition characteristics with performance among participants in a 161-km trail ultramarathon. ... Mean (+/-SD) BMI (kg x m(-2)) was 24.8+/-2.7 (range 19.1-32.2) for the men and 21.2+/-2.1 (range 18.1-26.7) for the women. Among the three fastest runners, BMI values ranged from 22.1 to 23.4 for men and 21.5 to 22.9 for women. [0]
___
I understand that they are different things. Unless these are bizarrely jacked ultra-marathoners, BMI should work just fine.
>> Mean (+/-SD) percent body fat values for men and women were 17+/-5 (range 5-35) and 21+/-6 (range 10-29) , and ranged from 6 to 14 and 14 to 27 among the fastest three men and women.
I would imagine the fastest finishers are not "bizarrely jacked" (they usually look pretty scrawny), but their BMI is not very well correlated with their body fat percentage.
> We conclude that despite wide variations in BMI and percent body fat among ultramarathon participants, the faster men have lower percent body fat values than the slower men, and finishers have lower percent body fat values than non-finishers.
So I do stand corrected that not all of them are significantly below 10% body fat, but some definitely were (I don't see a breakdown anywhere giving an indication of how many), including some of the top finishers. I'd also imagine the ones at higher percentages who performed well probably have higher floors to begin with for how little body fat they can reasonably reach.
In any case, it is not at all abnormal for BMI to have nothing to do with body fat percentage or how jacked someone looks, especially with athletes. BMI is probably one of the most meaningless health metrics in common use.
I am surprised no one has mentioned Ann Trason that won 13 (iirc) Western States and used to win many ultras outright.
It's a small sport with not much competition.
Totally depends on the runner. An 85lb female athlete will burn X per km. A 300lb male, covering the same distance/speed, will burn at least 4X and probably 6X.
He was on Joe Rogan at least twice: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5tSTk1083VY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BvWB7B8tXK8
This flies in the face of conventional wisdom because all of the original studies were only done on men.
Off the top of my head, I'm not sure if women do have a harder time losing weight than men, but I know that a woman's body reacts to starvation differently. That may play a role.
There is a massive need for "foundational" studies to be redone with women. The assumption that men and women have the same metabolism has been shown to be wrong, and it has a lot of broad and overarching implications, especially in the field of medicine.
note: this does not claim one can only burn 2lbs of fat/day only that resulting CO2 from burning some amount of fat must fit in the exhaling budget
Anyway, here's the source: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/15615615
It states the maximum conversion is (290+/-25) kJ/kgd. It's been a while since I last worked on this subject but I believe that works out to somewhere in the range of 0.8% to 1% of body fat that can be converted into energy per day at most.
Of course there were some experimental controls in the study that don't always map exactly into the real world. There always are but this should be close enough for the discussion here.
From personal experience there is a difference and it is a big difference.
They have seen evidence that these diets can retool the body to more readily use fat as an energy substrate. While this doesn't translate to performance gains, it can mean that on a multi-hour/multi-day effort that a self-supported athlete might need to have a bit less food in their packs as well as foods with a higher proportion of fat that are lighter. Lighter pack = faster athlete.
But...even low intensity exercise over long duration is going to result in the recruitment of FTa/FTb muscle fibers that run almost exclusively by glycolyis. So an athlete counting on fat to be the primary energy substrate has be really highly trained, practiced, and know their pacing thresholds really well to keep the recruitment of those muscle fibers to a minimum.
Best paper I know of on the subject is this one: https://static1.squarespace.com/static/55b7ffebe4b0568a75e33...
Best book I know of on long-duration effort is this one: https://www.amazon.com/Training-New-Alpinism-Climber-Athlete...
I follow TFTNA (Training for the New Alpinism) and Uphill Athlete (Steve/Scott's new book) training regiments that Parent mentions.
They do talk about retooling your body to use fat reserves more than carbs. While I'm sure the evidence shows that keto diet might make this switch faster and easier, someone on a non-keto diet (carb based) can also do this.
My other very favorite resource is Shawn Bearden's Science of Ultra podcast, which is where I learned of the research paper I linked in my first post. Here's the one on fat adaptation: https://www.scienceofultra.com/podcasts/19 . He has lots of pretty hardcore exercise scientists and researchers on. It's one of my favorite things to listen to while grinding up a hill. :)
Have you tried? I always run before eating (not as part of a regimen, it's just convenient), as I expect many do. And my diet is closer to inverse-keto than keto.
I think that your comment falls into the noise category and is undesirable because of that. If you had explained personal experiences to show how you reached your conclusion, It think you would get a better reaction. If you also showed how other possibilities could be rules out, then I think people would find it very interesting and you would get many up votes.
Also, looking at comments, often I see only upvote and no downvote button. Why is that?
I'm not saying my personal experience should be considered universal, that'd be foolish. Just recounting that.
But it makes sense given how metabolizing fat and metabolizing sugar works. Insulin response, etc.
You should absolutely train in a glycogen depleted state just so you will know what it feels like and can deal with it. But it's not how you would ever start a race.
In the marathon distance or shorter, being fat adapted would be a bad thing, as you couldn't train at upper capacities. But where you are running purely aerobically for very long periods of time (12+ hours), this may be an advantage.
The secondary (or even primary) advantage would be a low carb or ketogenic diet is that it is anti-inflammatory. People who run ultra distances do huge volumes of training, and it may be enabled by a lack of inflammation.
I successfully completed a marathon 3 months after reading his book after having never run more than 3 miles in my life. (Stu Mittleman - Slow Burn)
https://www.thecut.com/2016/09/the-obscure-endurance-sport-w...
> Women have more body fat than men in both elite (Vernillo et al. 2013) and recreational (Hoffman et al. 2010a, b) athletes. In both elite and recreational runners the percentage of body fat is higher in women compared to men (Blaak 2001). It could be argued that fatty tissue may be used as an energy reserve and this could be an advantage for ultra-distances since runners tend to lose body fat during multi-hours running competitions (Karstoft et al. 2013; Schütz et al. 2013). Women might benefit from their higher percentage of body fat since both sexes lose a similar amount of fat during an ultra-endurance performance such as a 100 km ultra-marathon (Knechtle et al. 2010a, b, 2012a, b).