News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by logicx24 on Thursday May 09, 2019 @07:00PM (#19873316)
San Francisco legislators' complete inability to understand economics never fails to amaze me. There are twenty different taxes and bonds proposed every single year by the city to "build affordable housing." And every year, that money is squandered in regulation and red tape, while housing prices continue to rise.

The issue here is, first and foremost, supply and demand. San Francisco has made the process of building new housing so incredibly onerous that, once a developer finally succeeds in erecting a building, the only ones they can sell to are the wealthy. If it was easier to build in SF, with less regulation, less restrictive zoning, and less expense, then housing would be built for the middle class. Then, the city could apply affordable housing policies to reserve units in middle income buildings, and the housing crisis could be averted.

But instead, our legislature continually enacts nonsense like this, which accomplishes little beyond rabble rousing.

Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by abalone on Thursday May 09, 2019 @08:27PM (#19873919)
Do you have sources for these claims? I feel this narrative is often repeated on HN and it becomes kind of an echo chamber. Then I read in the SF Chronicle that there’s permitted and approved projects that developers are not moving forward with, like around the new hospital off of Van Ness, due to the “tightening of capital markets” and “soaring construction costs.”[1] Not NIMBYs or government regulations.

And then I dig a little deeper into the “it’s just supply and demand, dummy” narrative and find articles that document how luxury housing development actually is associated with a rise in rents for the working class.[2] Who would have thought macroeconomics is complicated?

I feel the narrative here is highly politicized around are particular market-driven philosophy, so much so that people feel comfortable posting unsourced polemics. In the spirit of HN I would like to steer us toward a real analysis of the facts in the ground.

[1] https://www.sfchronicle.com/bayarea/article/Turns-out-SF-s-b...

[2] https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/economy/in-expensive...

Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by mrep on Thursday May 09, 2019 @09:13PM (#19874195)
Not OP, but Seattle is almost as big as SF [0] (825,000 people in SF compared to 775,000 people in Seattle), Seattle has 2.5x the number of cranes up compared to SF [1] (65 cranes in Seattle compared to 26 in SF), Seattle rents have actually gone down recently because of so much new supply [2], and Seattle's average rent is only 57% of SF [3]. I'm not going to say it's just NIMBYism, but whatever they are doing, they are a prime example of what not to do.

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_States_cities_b...

[1]: https://www.seattletimes.com/business/real-estate/seattle-to...

[2]: https://www.oregonlive.com/business/2019/01/apartment-rents-...

[3]: https://www.investors.com/etfs-and-funds/personal-finance/hi...

Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by asveikau on Thursday May 09, 2019 @10:22PM (#19874522)
I have lived in both places and I think Seattle makes for an interesting, worthy comparison. However, also worth noting that Seattle has a larger land mass. Also, that 57% rent comparison is less impressive when you consider that Seattle has been cheaper than SF for decades - both places have spent most of the current decade raising rents, Seattle starting off at a lower point in the beginning of the trend.
Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by abalone on Thursday May 09, 2019 @09:29PM (#19874275)
Ah, thank you for the sourcing. I shall read them but I was wondering if you have a response to this critical analysis, "Seattle — A Cautionary Tale for Supply-Side Housing Advocates."[1]

It notes how Seattle is often cited by deregulation advocates, but that "in spite of decades of indisputably strong development, Seattle’s share of cost-burdened renters has barely budged." And "by overbuilding housing for the wealthy, Seattle has achieved some short-term improvement in affordability for the middle class, at the expense of substantial displacement and continued upward pressure on the most vulnerable."

This I think is at the heart of what in SF some call the YIMBY vs. PHIMBY[2] debate. YIMBYs tend to skew towards more privileged techie types (happy to dig up sourcing on this.. I recall the YIMBY national meeting being called overwhlemingly white). Whereas the PHIMBYs or whatever you want to call them, the deeply affordable housing advocates, see flaws in that simplistic trickle-down economics model based on lived experience in working-class neighborhoods undergoing gentrification.

[1] https://knock-la.com/seattle-a-cautionary-tale-for-supply-si...

[2] https://yahbayarea.org or https://twitter.com/YahBayArea

Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by solidsnack9000 on Friday May 10, 2019 @12:36AM (#19875082)
I upvoted you, although I disagree with you. You made an argument, deepened the discussion and offered some sources -- it's more than most people do.

Regarding the second site that you linked, and the PHIMBY idea in general -- if it's summed up by "housing is a human right", then there is a certain weakness built into it from the start. If you do not have a house, can you sue someone? Can you sue the government, for example? That is an important part of what a right is -- it provides a "cause of action", a basis for suit, when it is abridged. If it doesn't provide that, then it is not a right.

Freedom of movement within the United States, guaranteed by the Privileges & Immunities Clause of the Constitution, is a right. When someone writes something like "by overbuilding housing for the wealthy, Seattle has achieved some short-term improvement in affordability for the middle class, at the expense of substantial displacement and continued upward pressure on the most vulnerable.", they seem to be operating from a frame where it is the government's responsibility to provide housing, but it's not clear where the government gets that charter. Not every nice or good thing needs to be effected by government agency. However, respecting the right of people to move in -- to buy or rent property on the same terms as non-residents -- would seem to be completely in line with a broad commitment to the equality of all American citizens, regardless of their place of birth, before the law everywhere in the country.

Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by abalone on Friday May 10, 2019 @04:15AM (#19876028)
The essential view of PHIMBYs is that government should invest in housing, which is the mechanism by which the postwar generation achieved housing security (HUD had a huge budget).

Thanks for the upvote. Allow me to critique your argument. You focus solely on interpreting the term “right” and suggest that it is beyond the charter of government to provide housing, which is just completely and utterly ahistorical.

Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by solidsnack9000 on Friday May 10, 2019 @01:39PM (#19880217)
When you say my argument is ahistorical, do you mean that in the past, people have generally been able to sue for not having a house?

Calling housing a right is extreme and inaccurate.

Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by shuckles on Thursday May 09, 2019 @10:10PM (#19874471)
You need to argue the counterfactual. You can build housing and have rents increase because demand was still greater than supply. None of your links show that rents increased more than they would have without building housing.
Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by irq11 on Thursday May 09, 2019 @10:02PM (#19874423)
Careful, you’re bringing facts to an opinion fight.

The parent is wrong, and is cherry-picking data. Seattle rents may have gone down “recently”, but they’ve been amongst the fastest-rising rents in the US until about a year ago. They’re far higher than they were a few years ago, let alone a decade ago.

Also, saying that prices are lower than San Francisco is utterly meaningless. San Francisco is a different economy. It was more expensive than Seattle twenty years ago, and it’s more expensive now. You can’t make the comparison without controlling a bunch of variables.

Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by UnpossibleJim on Thursday May 09, 2019 @10:41PM (#19874595)
I'm genuinely confused as to why you're being downvoted. I live in Seattle, having bought a couple of houses in the last 10 years, watching the market pretty carefully and you aren't wrong. This is one of the most expensive markets in the country.... fourth or fifth. It's kind of ridiculous. The "drop" is in the last 3 years after a 12 year steep rise, and it's not even really a drop, more of a leveling off instead of a continued steep incline. A lot of that has to do with over investment in companies buying properties for apartment complexes, on speculation that population growth would continue at a steady rate instead of curve like real world models.
Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by shuckles on Thursday May 09, 2019 @11:01PM (#19874692)
Starting a comment with a put down like the parent did is not well-received by the community.
Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by abalone on Thursday May 09, 2019 @11:10PM (#19874727)
I started mine by politely thanking for the sourcing and I still got downvoted. I think there are politically motivated downvoters on this topic.
Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by shuckles on Thursday May 09, 2019 @11:32PM (#19874837)
You have more reason to be "genuinely confused" than the parent, who I was responding to.
Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by irq11 on Friday May 10, 2019 @05:24AM (#19876283)
The phrase “bringing facts to an opinion fight” is no more or less an “insult” than saying that your argument has no factual basis. People just don’t like to be told that they’re wrong, they really don’t like to be told so in a pithy way, and pearl-clutching provides an easy way to justify censorship.
Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by manfredo on Thursday May 09, 2019 @09:15PM (#19874205)
> I read in the SF Chronicle that there’s permitted and approved projects that developers are not moving forward with, like around the new hospital off of Van Ness, due to the “tightening of capital markets” and “soaring construction costs.”[1] Not NIMBYs or government regulations.

No doubt that construction costs exacerbate the problem. But there absolutely are people deliberately blocking housing construction. There was a proposition to outright block private housing construction in the Mission that got ~40% yes votes. For further examples, see the infamous case of the developer that wanted to replace a laundromat with an apartment building:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ExgxwKnH8y4

> And then I dig a little deeper into the “it’s just supply and demand, dummy” narrative and find articles that document how luxury housing development actually is associated with a rise in rents for the working class.[2] Who would have thought macroeconomics is complicated?

This is a fundamentally dishonest objection. New housing is "luxury" housing because the housing market is so expensive that even 1 bedroom apartments rent for $3-4K. Blocking "luxury housing" is blocking all housing, because the market is so expensive that even the smallest units are expensive enough to be considered luxury. Seriously, even 300 sq foot studios rent for 2.5K: https://sfbay.craigslist.org/sfc/apa/d/san-francisco-immacul...

Of course "luxury housing" is correlated with rising rents. When rents rise, newly constructed units get more expensive too and get pushed into the "luxury" price bracket. This is essentially a tautology, and it is not at all indicative that building more housing increases rents.

Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by dahdum on Thursday May 09, 2019 @09:04PM (#19874145)
Soaring construction costs are in no small part due to government regulations and NIMBYs. Labor shortage is partly to blame, but labor is short partly because of the housing shortage. [1]

[1] https://www.bizjournals.com/sanfrancisco/news/2018/01/24/sf-...

Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by abalone on Thursday May 09, 2019 @09:13PM (#19874193)
Actually your source says "A lack of construction workers is a legacy of the 2008 recession, when many people left the industry as development froze." I.e. a meltdown of the unregulated market was a major factor in the shortage -- again, your source.

Additionally the Chronicle article I posted concerns approved projects still facing delays due to labor and tightening capital markets. That undercuts the "it's just due to NIMBYs & regulations holding up approvals" narrative.

Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by shuckles on Thursday May 09, 2019 @10:02PM (#19874419)
Regulation, in particular rules on sourcing along with uncertainty of permit timelines, are a driver for labor expenses: https://ternercenter.berkeley.edu/uploads/San_Francisco_Cons...

Intuitively, how is it that Seattle can afford to build high rises while San Francisco cannot even though the selling and rental prices of a high rise is meaningfully greater than that of Seattle? Shouldn't all that Seattle capital just move to developing in San Francisco instead?

Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by abalone on Thursday May 09, 2019 @11:44PM (#19874878)
I read your citation and it does not appear to support that claim with respect to approved projects. In fact it leads by referencing the slow rebound from the recession for skilled labor vs all the demand as the primary driver in labor costs. Where it mentions permit delays it’s only in reference to delayed projects being at a disadvantage, not approved ones.

As for your second question I can only refer you what I’ve already cited on construction costs, tightening capital markets and other factors beyond mere permitting or “NIMBY” issues. Intuitively, approved projects would move forward if the math made sense.

Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by shuckles on Friday May 10, 2019 @01:22AM (#19875273)
I feel like we’re talking past each other. In the section about labor costs, it cites at least the following:

1. Slow uptake of skills, lower productivity. Related to recession.

2. Hard to get bids due to uncertain approval process. Entirely caused by city policy. Now you say let’s condition on approved projects: however, given that it can take up to half a decade to gain approval (infamous historic laundromat was just under 5 years), controlling for approved projects is misleading. In five years, construction costs doubled and a project that might have penciled out at inception may no longer. The developer would have to propose a more dense, taller, etc. building for the project to make sense, but that would be another half-decade round trip through city planning.

3. City rules about prevailing wage, local sourcing, etc. limiting the available labor pool which directly drives up labor cost. This is entirely a local control problem.

Are you saying 2 and 3 are not consequences of local regulation?

Additionally, most of what you’ve cited is true across the nation. What you fail to provide is a reason these macroeconomic factors seem to have a disparate impact on SF’s ability to build which is evident in, e.g., the number of new housing units per capita it has delivered vis a vis a comparable city such as Seattle.

Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by abalone on Friday May 10, 2019 @04:55AM (#19876186)
I hear you on local sourcing but they mentioned it last and didn’t quantify the impact. The stalled project mentioned in the Chronicle article was approved in under two years, not five. So I don’t think these are strong points vs what the source clearly emphasizes as the primary driver of labor cost: “number of workers relative to the number of units being built is still below the historical average.”

Which would be exacerbated if workers cannot afford to live in the region. I once saw a map set that visualized where you could transit to in various metros in under an hour from an affordable neighborhood. Even in NYC you could get to most of Manhattan, from the outskirts of Brooklyn or Queens. SF really stood out. You could only reach a few blocks around the BART stops. The whole city is cut off from a labor supply. It’s affecting staffing at restaurants and retail too — Nopa advertises for cooks in its menu because who wants to ride a motorcycle to San Leandro at 3am.

Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by 1024core on Thursday May 09, 2019 @11:28PM (#19874814)
Construction costs have also gone up due to the fires of last year: Paradise, Ojai, Malibu, etc. We're getting our house remodeled, and it was a royal pain to find architects and contractors. Most were booked up to a year in advance!
Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by austenallred on Thursday May 09, 2019 @08:43PM (#19874009)
The amount of housing in the most expensive housing market in the world is going down because of lack of capital? That passes a sanity check for you?

Or maybe the regulations are so insane you spend millions in legal fees before you even have a glimmer of hope and eventually say “this isn’t worth it.”

Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by abalone on Thursday May 09, 2019 @09:05PM (#19874153)
See, this is what I mean. I posted sources that literally interviewed developers and researched the causes for construction delays on approved projects -- "project was approved in late 2016 as construction costs were escalating more than 10 percent a year and lenders were tightening their criteria for loans." And you responded with unsupported political talking points.

Let's bring this back to a fact-based discussion, ok? That's what HN is supposed to be about.

Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by austenallred on Thursday May 09, 2019 @09:56PM (#19874397)
There’s such an enormous mountain of evidence on the other side I’m genuinely unsure where to start
Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by shuckles on Friday May 10, 2019 @01:30AM (#19875307)
I find responses like this fairly patronizing. I think it’s preferable to not respond at all or substitute a link to an article like Kim Mai’s (in)famous TechCrunch piece instead of this veritable shrug.

Edit: After seeing your profile, I feel even more disappointed. Imagine if a Lambda School student asked a plausibly sincere question and they were met with a response which amounted to, “That is so stupid, I don’t even know where to start.” Let’s strive for better.

Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by austenallred on Friday May 10, 2019 @01:42AM (#19875364)
There’s a pretty big difference between chatting on a message board and a student asking a question of a school. I’m currently at Disneyland with my family and don’t believe the parent response was earnest, but here: https://techcrunch.com/2014/04/14/sf-housing/
Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by shuckles on Friday May 10, 2019 @01:46AM (#19875376)
I’ve learned a lot from HN, so perhaps I don’t view the environs as so different. I suspect the parent may not be entirely sincere, but perhaps it’s better to call that out directly. Enjoy Disneyland and best of luck with your company!
Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by zachsnow on Friday May 10, 2019 @07:27AM (#19876769)
I found this to be a very interesting survey of the different things affecting the SF housing market. Whether you agree with all of the points brought up it's hard to deny that it's a complex issue.
Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by sbov on Friday May 10, 2019 @12:22AM (#19875032)
Start with the early 70s. The housing problem started around then. Some years they went up by 20-30% in value. My parents were on track to lose their relatively modest 1800 square foot house in San Jose just 6 years after moving there despite being dual income tech workers at the time.

Note that it predates prop 13, so I hope that doesn't play a central role in this enormous mountain of evidence.

Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by jessedhillon on Thursday May 09, 2019 @09:32PM (#19874289)
> “For-profit developers have predominantly built for the luxury and higher end of the market, leaving a glut of overpriced apartments in some cities,” said Diane Yentel, president and chief executive of the National Low Income Housing Coalition, an advocacy group.

I can't read the chronicle article, but your wapo article is mainly just the opinions of interested people like this. For example, nowhere does it give the actual number of "luxury" units built in Seattle, SF, or Portland -- those would be important numbers if you're trying to comprehend the argument being put forward.

Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by abalone on Thursday May 09, 2019 @09:51PM (#19874373)
The Chronicle article is worth reading but you can trust me that it points to capital markets and labor shortages as holding back approved projects.

Here is a deeper analysis of the Seattle market with specific housing construction figures.[1] It argues "there is no general housing shortage, that the catastrophic figures above are a product of the Great Recession and the normal lag in construction. Because the market appears to be duly responding to demand, efforts to 'free' the housing market are not as effective as efforts to shape the market toward more just ends."

This is consistent with the causes cited in the SF Chronicle article that hold back approved projects, as well as the SF Business Times(!) article pointing to the 2008 recession as a cause of the labor shortage, cited previously.

[1] https://www.theurbanist.org/2016/11/22/what-housing-shortage...

Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by vamos_davai on Thursday May 09, 2019 @10:51PM (#19874636)
I investigated into developing in Half Moon Bay, which is zoned by San Mateo County. There's wide swathes of land up for grabs, but the county or the council forbids development unless you buy enough land and come up with a proposal. This ends up costing in $5-$10 million of undeveloped land alone (no sewage line connection and no electricity). And these lands are planned unit developments, which in practicality means homes only for the wealthy.
Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by chrisdhoover on Friday May 10, 2019 @12:07AM (#19874976)
San Mateo and Marin have always opposed development. It has given us great open spaces up 101 down 280 and along 1. Its an odd position to defend, no development in Marin and San Mateo, but increased developement in San Francisco yet thats my view
Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by wbl on Friday May 10, 2019 @01:42AM (#19875362)
Even in the spaces that are not open space San Mateo opposes apartments.
Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by ultrarunner on Thursday May 09, 2019 @08:39PM (#19873990)
Your first article attributes those quotes reasoning about the lack of construction to speculation by “neighbors”. There is also a traffic problem created in part by construction of a bus line that is 18 months overdue. It seems a bit quick to be using that as justification for SF housing policies, especially as they don’t seem to be working.

Your other article is paywalled, but I imagine that tightly planned cities introducing only new luxery housing is the same general situation and would be similarly vulnerable to the very arguments you’re responding to.

Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by Aloha on Thursday May 09, 2019 @08:41PM (#19874002)
How much construction does a 'bus line' take exactly?
Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by BrandonM on Friday May 10, 2019 @01:49PM (#19880347)
I live a couple blocks away from Van Ness. Here's the project: https://www.sfcta.org/projects/van-ness-improvement-project. They're moving to dedicated bus lanes, allowing the buses to load and unload safely without blocking other traffic. As with all significant projects, they've lumped in a bunch of other maintenance that has been put off for too long, like upgrading utility lines.

Construction generally blocks a lane of traffic on one side of the street, rerouting the other lanes and pedestrians, for several weeks at a time. Then they move on to the next block or to the other side of the street.

Just from a layman's perspective, it seems incredibly tricky to try to construct a housing development with that going on around it. The "bus line" construction has already put additional pressure on traffic up and down Van Ness, and it's got to be very tricky to get permits for parking spots, dumpsters, and other necessities with everything else that's going on. And anyway the city could probably just come through and close everything down for weeks or months so that they can perform another stage of "bus line" construction.

(I'm putting "bus line" in quotes because they haven't even really started on that part. This whole project is a pretty incredibly yak shave that's taking 5 years and hundreds of millions of dollars for a bus line.)

Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by Aloha on Thursday May 09, 2019 @08:41PM (#19873998)
I think the onus is on you to disprove them, not just to merely question their veracity.

Anyone who has built a house in any urbanized area with an highly environmental conscious outlook can tell you that building a house is difficult - I think anyone can also tell you that San Francisco has a large amount of demand - I think there would also be universal agreement that San Francisco is also basically built out. Upmarket housing tends to get built first when market demand is high, and its expensive to build in a place, because its harder to recoup the costs on cheaper housing.

Without significant densification (which has proven untenable politically) no significant amount of new housing will be built - so you can pass all the affordable housing bonds in the world, but until you change the zoning (regulatory) construct - nothing will change.

Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by msbarnett on Thursday May 09, 2019 @08:50PM (#19874052)
> I think the onus is on you to disprove them, not just to merely question their veracity.

This generally is not how reasoned debate occurs. The onus is on the person making an assertion to provide facts supporting it, not on everyone else to disprove an unsourced claim.

Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by throwaway400 on Thursday May 09, 2019 @09:01PM (#19874125)
As if it's possible that some other scenario is not at play. Do you think housing is being erected at a record pace and yet still can't keep up with demand? Is it possible that people just don't want to build in SF, because... reasons that aren't red tap?
Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by msbarnett on Thursday May 09, 2019 @09:07PM (#19874164)
I haven't made any argument one way or the other.

I will point out that there is an article on the front page of HN right now in which multiple economists argue that "it's supply and demand" provides an insufficient explanation for, and solution to, the problem of affordable housing in San Francisco: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19872015

So arguing that we must accept the "it's just supply and demand" argument by acclamation with no sourcing seems flimsy. Educated minds are arguing otherwise, and providing evidence to back up their claims. It hardly seems unreasonable to expect the other side of the argument to do similar.

Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by Wowfunhappy on Thursday May 09, 2019 @09:02PM (#19874133)
I think you're asking the GP to prove a negative?
Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by baddox on Thursday May 09, 2019 @07:47PM (#19873664)
To the extent that economics is about how incentives influence behavior, to assume that SF legislators don’t understand economics is itself probably a misunderstanding of economics.
Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by ladberg on Thursday May 09, 2019 @08:03PM (#19873776)
There are people working for the City of SF who know economics, but that doesn't mean the people passing the laws do. I took an urban economics class taught by Ted Egan, the chief in-house economist for the City of SF, who knows pretty much everything about the subject and if he was put in charge of housing laws for the city I am certain housing quality and quantity would improve. However, he and people like him don't get to pass the laws. Instead, we have extremely vocal NIMBYs who lobby to get laws passed that benefit the rich minority of residents and harm everyone else.
Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by brianwawok on Thursday May 09, 2019 @08:19PM (#19873874)
> benefit the rich minority of residents and harm everyone else

But is that true? As a Midwesterner, I have no skin in the game. But is it ever OK for city to say "We like the size we are, we don't want drop zoning and turn our entire coastal town into 100 story mega-skyscrapers?"

I don't think the end game of every city has to be to become Tokyo. As prices rise, more industry moves out of the city. Seems like a valid case for a local resident to want?

Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by ZainRiz on Thursday May 09, 2019 @08:29PM (#19873932)
+1 to that (and I don't live in California either)

It seems more like the proponents of cheap housing want to encourage lots of people to move into the city (which is how the existing supply becomes insufficient), at the expense of the people who were already living there.

Though what I haven't been able to understand is why these groups are not in favor of creating housing further off where the land is cheaper? In the bay area why is "goodness" only measured in distance from downtown?

This is a sincere question, I'd love to understand.

Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by throwaway55554 on Thursday May 09, 2019 @08:41PM (#19873996)
> It seems more like the proponents of cheap housing want to encourage lots of people to move into the city...

No. The person pouring coffee to the wealthy shouldn't have to drive 50 miles to work one way. Or live in an apartment with 7 roommates.

That's not encouraging people to move there, that's taking care of the people already there.

Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by brianwawok on Thursday May 09, 2019 @09:28PM (#19874272)
In a free market, wages would raise until either you are paying the guy pouring coffee $30 an hour - or someone is willing to commute the required distance?
Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by shuckles on Thursday May 09, 2019 @10:05PM (#19874443)
In a free market, a developer could demolish a SFH to build a tall building with lots of micro units so that low income workers could live near where they work with relative dignity.
Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by throwaway55554 on Friday May 10, 2019 @09:39AM (#19877559)
Is the market really free anymore? Supply and demand is so out of whack now that there's so much money flooded into the world economy. The wealthy are buying up real estate and other assets left and right. The middle class and poor can never keep up. There's a vortex sucking money from the middle class straight to the wealthy and everyone seems to be OK with that.
Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by shuckles on Thursday May 09, 2019 @10:16PM (#19874492)
For starters, it's never OK for a city with pension plans like San Francisco to reject growth, since that growth was factored in when determining ability to pay those pensions. SF is able to tread water with its pensions while Oakland next door is not[1] almost entirely due to the tech industry.

The above logic doesn't apply to pensions exclusively, either. Much infrastructure, in CA especially which has Prop 13, needs growth to sustain.

Stasis is neither natural nor sustainable.

[1] https://www.sfchronicle.com/bayarea/philmatier/article/In-Oa...

Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by jsymolon on Friday May 10, 2019 @09:42AM (#19877581)
> Stasis is neither natural nor sustainable

Neither is perpetual growth. Observation of nature shows that growth has bust cycles. aka, population grows till resources run out (food) and then the bulk starve and die.

Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by shuckles on Friday May 10, 2019 @11:05AM (#19878465)
Humanity has been engaged in perpetual growth for millennia now. Heck, the universe has been growing since day zero!
Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by _ah on Thursday May 09, 2019 @09:30PM (#19874283)
No, it's not ok.

Cities are dynamic, and always changing. They are either growing or dying. A very few may have found temporary equilibrium.

If a city wants to stay the same size, what they usually mean is that they wish to stay the same size at the same affordability level. However, since change is constant, their best attempt regulates growth. The natural result is economic stagnation (leading to eventual death), or city growth in spite of the regulation (leading to runaway prices).

Every city has the right to choose HOW they will change. They do not have the right to insist that they WON'T change, or that such a thing is even possible.

Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by danans on Thursday May 09, 2019 @09:21PM (#19874231)
> But is it ever OK for city to say "We like the size we are

Sure, and cities "say" what their preferences through their elected representatives, at the local and state level.

> I don't think the end game of every city has to be to become Tokyo.

Nobody said that has to be the endgame for every city. San Francisco's politicians and residents aren't debating the aspirations of your Midwestern city, they are debating the aspirations of their own city and region. If the balance of political power turns toward pro housing policies in San Francisco, maybe it becomes more Tokyo like. If not, maybe it moves in the other direction.

But dynamic cities by their nature don't stay still, so you can be assured things will move in some direction.

Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by baddox on Thursday May 09, 2019 @08:41PM (#19873995)
> But is it ever OK for city to say ...

It's important to be a bit more rigorous. What is "the city" in this thought experiment? The city government? The "will of the people" (what does that even mean, does it require a majority or a plurality to decide the size of the city)?

Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by throwaway55554 on Thursday May 09, 2019 @08:39PM (#19873992)
Ok, but when they allowed high paying companies to set up shop, they had to know the people serving coffee would be pushed out of a place to live.
Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by joejerryronnie on Thursday May 09, 2019 @10:05PM (#19874445)
Whoa, whoa, whoa - are you saying that long time property owners should have a say in how their neighborhood and city develop? And that we shouldn’t blindly appease a bunch of people who have just moved to town chasing the almighty dollar and are pissed they can’t rent a luxury appt or purchase a home in one of the most expensive cities in America?!! You do realize you’re logged into HN, don’t you?
Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by baddox on Thursday May 09, 2019 @08:37PM (#19873975)
> Instead, we have extremely vocal NIMBYs who lobby to get laws passed that benefit the rich minority of residents and harm everyone else.

My point is that my basic economic understanding makes me expect this to be how the legislators behave regardless of what the legislators know about economics. They may not in fact have any understanding of economics, but I wouldn't expect this to affect their behavior either way.

Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by deelowe on Thursday May 09, 2019 @08:22PM (#19873887)
> There are people working for the City of SF who know economics, but that doesn't mean the people passing the laws do

> Instead, we have extremely vocal NIMBYs who lobby to get laws passed that benefit the rich minority of residents and harm everyone else.

The politicians understand economics perfectly well, they just know who puts food on their table.

Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by pbourke on Thursday May 09, 2019 @07:42PM (#19873618)
How to make housing more affordable: 1) cut red tape 2) relax zoning requirements. Both are politically unpalatable, so around and around we go appropriating money that governments don’t even know what to do with.
Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by halbritt on Thursday May 09, 2019 @07:50PM (#19873681)
Are there historical instances of 1) and 2)being successful in reducing housing prices in a high-demand area?
Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by ekianjo on Thursday May 09, 2019 @07:56PM (#19873726)
Reducing, maybe not, but stabilizing, definitely. Look at most major cities in Japan, they keep building new apartment towers all the time and prices are more or less stable. Tokyo is an exception right now because of the olympics bubble.
Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by haroldp on Thursday May 09, 2019 @08:04PM (#19873780)
Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by halbritt on Saturday May 11, 2019 @01:38AM (#19884745)
Excellent example.

I was reminded of this video as well when Tokyo was mentioned:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iGbC5j4pG9w

Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by jpadkins on Friday May 10, 2019 @07:09AM (#19876699)
https://www.zillow.com/houston-tx/

https://law.yale.edu/system/files/documents/pdf/hier1948.pdf

https://www.dallasfed.org/~/media/documents/research/houston...

Houston is a nice natural experiment on zoning laws impact on affordable housing. I believe Houston has more net immigration that SF or Seattle, but has much more affordable housing.

Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by rajacombinator on Thursday May 09, 2019 @08:56PM (#19874084)
I believe you’re misunderstanding the incentives and goals of these govt officials, and the people who vote for them. It’s much worse than a mere ignorance of economics, and totally intractable.
Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by TheMagicHorsey on Thursday May 09, 2019 @09:47PM (#19874359)
You'd be surprised how many socialist-minded people there are in SF, who always invent some cockamamie reason why more government requirements are the answer. Its always more and more regulation. Like the last twenty years of affordable housing regulation didn't do anything. So lets try another twenty years of experiments.

Though I live in SF, I really hope they do implement some of these asinine punitive taxes and finally kill the tech industry here. Then all these Nimbys can enjoy an empty city devoid of activity.

Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by malandrew on Friday May 10, 2019 @12:50PM (#19879633)
...And those of us that enjoy working in tech will finally be able find interesting engineering jobs in cities that aren't SF.
Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by bassman9000 on Thursday May 09, 2019 @08:43PM (#19874010)
And yet, the same people keep getting elected.

Whose fault is it?

Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by adrr on Thursday May 09, 2019 @08:02PM (#19873769)
vote them out then. People complain about their local politicians but no effort to remove them from office like donating money, or volunteering.
Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by mc32 on Thursday May 09, 2019 @08:20PM (#19873876)
It’s a one party town. Whoever you vote in does the same as the previous supe. They’re into high-profile, low-impact pet projects the likes of which are reminiscent of ideas high school students would propose to solve issues.

Ban plastic straws, but don’t prosecute people who defecate on the street. That’s SF politics. Nothing of consequence happens except when something has the potential to propel them into state politics, and again it’s a high viz low impact issue.

Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by refurb on Thursday May 09, 2019 @11:41PM (#19874861)
They’re into high-profile, low-impact pet projects the likes of which are reminiscent of ideas high school students would propose to solve issues.

This is exactly it. When you look at initiatives pushed by SF politicians, they remind me of model government in high school.

“Let’s van keeping goldfish as pets”

“Let’s ban fois gras”

“Let’s ban company cafeteria’s.”

I really makes you wonder if the city is run by a bunch of amateurs.

Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by bruceb on Thursday May 09, 2019 @08:36PM (#19873972)
I dont want people defecating in the streets either, but how you going to prosecute that? If you have reached that level, do you care about a fine you cant pay? Is govt going to fine them the $250 they dont have?

Also where are they supposed to go to the bathroom, not like there are many readily available in SF, especially at night.

Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by chrisdhoover on Friday May 10, 2019 @12:23AM (#19875038)
There is a theory that says the cheap plastic bags were reused to contain shit. Now with the bag ban the shit is on the streets.
Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by komali2 on Thursday May 09, 2019 @10:40PM (#19874593)
> but don’t prosecute people who defecate on the street

"Well, it's time to poop and there's no public restrooms open at 3am. Hmm don't wanna get prosecuted though. I guess I'll just shit myself."

Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by mc32 on Thursday May 09, 2019 @10:47PM (#19874623)
That must be why it’s a problem in other cities... Dog owners know to use a bag and pick up. People can also use a bag and dispose sanitarily, but no. Why, I can just do it on the sidewalk. But, oh no, what’s that, a plastic straw?

If the city can afford injection sites and needles I’m sure they can afford to have bag dispensers or ports johns, if it’s an unmet scute need.

Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by komali2 on Friday May 10, 2019 @12:04AM (#19874958)
People are pooping in bags, sometimes. Or suitcases.

The city is also putting up portable restrooms. The biggest obstacle is neighborhoods protesting restrooms being put nearby. I guess residents like shit on the sidewalks more than restroom trailers?

Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by mikeash on Thursday May 09, 2019 @09:33PM (#19874297)
They have primaries, don’t they?
Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by mc32 on Thursday May 09, 2019 @11:03PM (#19874697)
For citywide elections? The choice is usually progressive and lesser progressive, not even “Clinton Democrat”. Some “Mavericks” will run as Libertarian or even Repub (but never win) just to stick out or get in the ballot.
Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by bassman9000 on Thursday May 09, 2019 @08:49PM (#19874046)
It’s a one party town.

We got what we deserve, then.

Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by cubecul on Thursday May 09, 2019 @08:19PM (#19873871)
It's not that simple in SF. Lots and lots of neighborhood associations and local groups like that who are really loud and who hold a lot more power than their equivalents in other cities.

There's a whole infrastructure on one half of the political spectrum in SF that you have to defeat.

Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by chrisdhoover on Friday May 10, 2019 @12:20AM (#19875023)
You cant vote them out because the process is captured. This was recognized years ago and term limits were created but it is not the individual candidate, those are interchangeable, it is the machine. The machine keeps turning. The only solution is a revolution but no one has the stomach for that. And besides most revolutionaries are hopeless utopian romantics believing in silly ideologies.
Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by deathanatos on Thursday May 09, 2019 @08:20PM (#19873877)
I would, but I can't afford to live in the city!
Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by throwing838383 on Thursday May 09, 2019 @07:32PM (#19873554)
can someone please pin this at the top of every housing related post?
Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by eanzenberg on Thursday May 09, 2019 @07:39PM (#19873602)
That would only solve part of the problem. There’s still the influx of homeless from outside the city and state to deal with.
Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by jordonwii on Thursday May 09, 2019 @07:45PM (#19873648)
Do you have source for calling it an "influx"? According to the city's annual survey (from 2017)[1], 70% of the current homeless population lived in SF county before becoming homeless, 21% lived in another CA county (which may include, say, Berkeley or Oakland), and only 10% came from outside CA. I'd hardly call 10% of the current homeless population an influx.

[1] http://hsh.sfgov.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/2017-SF-Poin...

Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by throwawaysea on Thursday May 09, 2019 @07:58PM (#19873737)
Isn’t this based on self-answered surveys and not hard verifiable information to establish residency? The homeless and activists/nonprofits advocating on their behalf have an incentive to make it look like they’re mostly local.
Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by nerfhammer on Thursday May 09, 2019 @09:04PM (#19874141)
Is there any systematic evidence of the oft-repeated idea that homeless are being bussed in from every corner of the country? Besides an anecdotal case or two? If not, why should we believe that it happens with any degree of frequency?

Do you believe that estimates of the total counts of homeless people might be more or less accurate, since there's no supposed incentive for activists to discount it? SF's homelessness per capita is actually not particularly high compared to other major cities, which is not at all what you would expect if homeless were swarming en masse to SF from those other places: https://medium.com/hatchbeat/homelessness-a-tale-of-three-ci... . What's really high in SF and other West Coast cities is the percent of unsheltered homeless. It may be that it only seems like there are more of them because they are more visible because besides SF's dislike of building housing they also don't build sufficient homeless shelters: https://www.sfgate.com/bayarea/article/Bay-Area-homeless-uns...

Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by throwawaysea on Friday May 10, 2019 @02:55PM (#19881035)
If you talk to homeless people (at least in Seattle), you'll find that almost all of those you speak with moved here from elsewhere. Bad data is worse than no data, and these surveys are bad data intended to skew the conversation - they have a very obvious flaw, which is that there is no verification of the identity of homeless people and where they lived before. And when most people around you have the same anecdotal observations and the data says otherwise, it is yet another sign the data needs to be scrutinized or tossed out until something better comes along.

> If not, why should we believe that it happens with any degree of frequency?

Why should we believe they are from here by default? We should assume they are not until it is proven, and therefore feel no obligation to create more levies against local law-abiding tax-paying residents to support out-of-town homeless, or permanently nomadic lifestyles, or willful drug abusers who often commit petty property crimes to feed their addictions. We should only provide that aid if we know they are long-term residents of the area, and otherwise enforce laws against them strictly.

> It may be that it only seems like there are more of them because they are more visible because besides SF's dislike of building housing

I'm sorry but if someone moved to SF or Seattle within the last 7 years, they really should have displayed more personal responsibility and known what they're signing up for cost-wise and whether they can afford it. These are some of the most desirable places to live on the planet, and are rightfully expensive. The cities are not obligated to change their character or density to accommodate others who want to move there but can't afford it, just like I don't have a default right to live on the beach in Maui. And as such, I feel these cities don't have to do anything other than enforce the law except when someone is a proven long-term resident who was swept up in increasing costs.

Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by tjalfi on Thursday May 09, 2019 @09:26PM (#19874257)
Nevada sent at least 500 homeless people to Los Angeles and San Francisco[0].

[0] https://www.motherjones.com/politics/2015/10/nevada-settles-...

Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by jordonwii on Thursday May 09, 2019 @08:27PM (#19873924)
> Isn’t this based on self-answered surveys and not hard verifiable information to establish residency?

True, though collecting hard verifiable proof of prior residency from homeless folks seems beyond what can be expected from a one-day citywide survey. :)

If you know of a survey that did collect that information, I'd certainly be interested in the results.

> The homeless and activists/nonprofits advocating on their behalf have an incentive to make it look like they’re mostly local.

I suppose a high out-of-county population might make locals stingier, but getting caught providing bad data also seems like a pretty bad outcome for any of the local non-profits that helped conduct the survey.

Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by ultrasaurus on Thursday May 09, 2019 @08:54PM (#19874072)
No political angle, but to expand on the data from that report (pages 22-23):

* Sixty-nine percent (69%) ... were living in San Francisco at the time they most recently became homeless... 8% had lived in San Francisco for less than one year.

* Of their previous living arrangements: 32% with friends or family, 11% in subsidized housing, 8% in a hotel, 6% incarcerated, 3% in hospital, 3% in foster care.

So it's probably more accurate to think of at most 50% of the population as having come from stable housing situations in SF.

Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by evanlivingston on Thursday May 09, 2019 @07:55PM (#19873712)
This is a really strange comment to unpack. On one hand, housing supply and people without homes are related, at least nominatively. So semantically it feels as if you're making a point.

On the other hand, I can't identify any logic or argument to your comment. As far as I can tell your unspoken logic goes a little like this:

"The difficulty in building housing causes a constrained housing supply. Making it easier to build housing would solve part of the problem. The other part of the problem with the constrained housing supply is people without existing housing moving to the city. But I don't mean people without housing who can afford housing. I mean people without housing who can't afford housing. They constrain the housing supply in the city further."

Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by toasterlovin on Thursday May 09, 2019 @08:05PM (#19873790)
FWIW, when people complain about the homeless, they are usually referring to people who live on the street, in tents, panhandle, etc. This is the vernacular meaning of the word. Not the much larger population of people who are homeless in the sense that they don't have a permanent place of residence, which is what you're referring to. The people who comprise the vernacular sense of the word are primarily afflicted by mental health and/or addiction issues. Fixing the cost of housing will not get them off of the street.
Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by outside1234 on Thursday May 09, 2019 @07:59PM (#19873742)
Oh they understand. They are not actually trying to solve the problem, but inflate the problem. They own real estate, the regulations give them a lever to get contributions from developers, higher property prices equals higher tax revenue, and doing something dumb like this IPO stunt makes foolish property-less people think that they are on the same side of them.

They are not -- they are on the side of property prices going up.

Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by robertAngst on Thursday May 09, 2019 @08:38PM (#19873983)
Apply this to Federal Healthcare.

Physicians want to get paid 300k/yr. Pharma is obsolete by computers and paid over 100k/yr.

Not to mention the pharma companies and hospitals.

Its why healthcare only gets worse with legislation.

Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by AnimalMuppet on Thursday May 09, 2019 @09:01PM (#19874123)
Pharmacy is obsolete by computers? Not yet, it's not. I mean, retail pharmacy, maybe, mostly, but all of pharmacy? No.

And pharma companies? You think computers are going to automate drug discovery? Not for a long time, they won't.

Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by bdcravens on Thursday May 09, 2019 @09:44PM (#19874341)
To be fair, many physicians went into significant debt based on an ROI of making $300k a year.
Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by germinalphrase on Thursday May 09, 2019 @09:56PM (#19874392)
Maybe that too is a problem.
Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by adventured on Thursday May 09, 2019 @10:43PM (#19874607)
The most important thing the US needs to do to its healthcare system, is cut costs by 1/3 to match the top end of what the other wealthiest developed nations are spending.

That will require hammering downward what doctors (for one example) are earning. No more radiologists making $650k per year.

The side conflict to that, is you have to simultaneously make it a lot cheaper to become a doctor, otherwise you generate a shortgage of doctors that gets worse by the year.

As the Federal and State governments take on ever larger responsibility in the US healthcare system, I'll be curious to see how this problem is dealt with. I suspect at first they'll simply avoid the conflict entirely, and try to keep paying healthcare workers what they're presently earning. However, you can't have universal healthcare in the US in any manner at the current expense levels, it's financially impossible. Something will have to give, and it ultimately will have to be the costs in the system.

Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by ericd on Thursday May 09, 2019 @11:24PM (#19874798)
I think the other thing is that it's not only expensive to become a doctor, but fairly grueling as well. Some number will still do it for altruistic reasons, similar to how you get some amazing teachers despite the terrible pay, but it'll probably be a lot harder for most extremely effective people to justify doing that over another, more lucrative field.

One thing that might help is eliminating the undergrad requirement before medical school.

Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by bdcravens on Thursday May 09, 2019 @10:42PM (#19874605)
I've long held that if you want to get healthcare costs under control, if you end up impacting provider salaries, you have to tackle the education side of the equation as well.
Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by austenallred on Friday May 10, 2019 @01:44AM (#19875372)
It’s only a tiny, tiny part of the problem.
Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by wbl on Thursday May 09, 2019 @09:07PM (#19874166)
SF property tax revenue does not rise when prices do.
Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by rsuttongee on Friday May 10, 2019 @12:24AM (#19875041)
The parent is saying that the council members themselves are the property owners - that they are profiting directly, not the city.
Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by jseliger on Thursday May 09, 2019 @08:35PM (#19873967)
It is a sort of grim form of comedy to watch it: http://seliger.com/2017/08/30/l-digs-hole-slowly-economics-f...
Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by dgzl on Thursday May 09, 2019 @08:26PM (#19873914)
As a fourth-gen Southern Oregonian, my family is perpetually irritated that Californian policies eventually end up here as well.
Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by hellllllllooo on Thursday May 09, 2019 @07:14PM (#19873430)
It might effectivly reduce demand.
Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by halflings on Thursday May 09, 2019 @07:18PM (#19873462)
How? How many people would not come to the Bay Area because they might get taxed if they IPO?
Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by jdavis703 on Thursday May 09, 2019 @08:10PM (#19873806)
I moved to California despite the high taxes. In doing so I was able to go from earning $55k per year to $150k a year. No amount of tax cuts would have given me that income boost. As long as people can make more after-tax money in SF and California than everywhere else the place will remain competitive.

Now, I’m not endorsing this particular tax proposal, just merely defending the general high tax policies here.

Edit:

I probably spend about $40/month on transportation. I do not own a car and bike to work and most other places. I spend $2700/month (market rate rent, no rent control) for a 1 bedroom apartment in a very walkable location. While the cost of living is higher, it's not so high as to make my life in the Bay Area worse than back home.

Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by kfriede on Thursday May 09, 2019 @08:18PM (#19873865)
Simply knowing salary tells us almost nothing about the benefit(s) of your move. How much more/less do you spend on:

* Vehicle Registration, Public Transportation, Gas

* Housing (rent/mortgage)

* Sales tax

* Etc.

The housing is a huge factor, given that 30% of $55k is $1300/mo (A decent house in most of America), yet 30% of 150k is $3750/mo (A nice cardboard box in the bay area)

Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by alain94040 on Thursday May 09, 2019 @08:39PM (#19873989)
Sure, but the numbers still favor the bay area if you are a software engineer: https://thestartupconference.com/2018/09/21/about-that-silic...
Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by souprock on Friday May 10, 2019 @12:04AM (#19874961)
No, they favor the bay area if you are a software engineer who is willing to sacrifice quality of life. That article starts off with this horrific line: "rent a room and move in with some friends". OMG. That is the sad situation we might expect for an unskilled high school drop-out with a felony conviction.

That article continues on with "Start a Family [...] It’s been 10 years". It is indeed common that people in high-cost areas feel unable to start families earlier, but that isn't something to just accept as normal. It is better to have kids when you have energy for them and when birth is safer. Starting earlier also allows for the possibility that you might end up wanting a larger family than you had initially expected. For example, I sure didn't imagine I'd be having 12, but that probably could not have happened in the Bay Area.

In 10 years, one ought to have paid off a house.

The article mentions college, which can be had cheaply, but neglects to mention private schooling. Normally this would be the larger expense by far.

The "middle of nowhere" comparison also seems a bit low for salary. It might be right if you tossed a dart at a map of the USA to determine your location, but not if you chose a low-cost area with a suitable industry.

Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by imtringued on Friday May 10, 2019 @08:09AM (#19876967)
>In 10 years, one ought to have paid off a house.

I agree but people have gotten used to constantly rising house prices and started depending on it to pay off their home. In an environment with rising house prices your best strategy is actually to avoid paying as much as possible. Low down payments and 30 year loans mean that if you spend $50K on a 2 million dollar house and it appreciates by 10% to $2.2 million you have received a 4x return on your investment. If the house price tanks by more than $50k your mortgage is underwater and because you never planned to repay the entire loan, you will have to apply for bankruptcy.

Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by bravoetch on Thursday May 09, 2019 @08:45PM (#19874020)
$3700 a month is my rent for a large one bedroom condo in Rincon Hill, SF, with my own parking spot in the building. If you think that making $95k more doesn't tell you anything then you're bad at math. Even if housing costs 3x, the rest is effectively surplus. Why on earth do you think you only get a cardboard box for that money btw? I live in luxury for that price.
Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by kfriede on Thursday May 09, 2019 @11:58PM (#19874927)
$1300 will get you a 1300+ sq ft house with a 2 car garage in many places outside of California. A one bedroom condo does not scream luxury to me, especially at $3700 a month.
Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by eanzenberg on Thursday May 09, 2019 @07:32PM (#19873555)
No, they would not move to SF when less SF jobs are created due to this law.
Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by davidw on Thursday May 09, 2019 @07:41PM (#19873616)
Ah, the "North Korea" strategy to make San Francisco affordable. Yeah, that would probably work. Kind of a roundabout way of doing things with a lot of other bad consequences, though.
Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by perseusmandate on Thursday May 09, 2019 @08:00PM (#19873748)
Great idea- let's just ban the jobs while we are at it and the problem will be solved
Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by hellllllllooo on Thursday May 09, 2019 @08:02PM (#19873770)
Supply and demand issues can be addressed at both ends. The US is a large place and only a few cities have these issues. What's wrong with the jobs being elsewhere in the US in cities with more capacity if people are moving to the jobs anyway?
Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by hellllllllooo on Thursday May 09, 2019 @07:20PM (#19873484)
People move to SF to work. If companies decide to start elsewhere it spreads out demand for housing.
Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by dmode on Thursday May 09, 2019 @08:35PM (#19873965)
San Francisco has build way more housing in the last decade compared to rest of the Bay Area and the state. Look at the entire east side of the City. Areas like SOMA, Mission Bay, Dogpatch were industrial wastelands. Now they have so much housing. Blame really lies in the rest of the Bay Area cities that haven't built their fair share of housing.
Re:San Francisco proposes “IPO tax” on eve of Uber offering by g9yuayon on Friday May 10, 2019 @12:45AM (#19875114)
Of course they understand economics. They just don't think it matters or don't care as long as their constituents support them. Well, their constituents do support them -- it's easy peasy anyway. People in California hate Republicans to the bones. As a result, we don't really have check and balance. Without check and balance, we get all kinds of ridiculous policies.

In a word, we get what we vote for.