It seems more like the proponents of cheap housing want to encourage lots of people to move into the city (which is how the existing supply becomes insufficient), at the expense of the people who were already living there.
Though what I haven't been able to understand is why these groups are not in favor of creating housing further off where the land is cheaper? In the bay area why is "goodness" only measured in distance from downtown?
This is a sincere question, I'd love to understand.
No. The person pouring coffee to the wealthy shouldn't have to drive 50 miles to work one way. Or live in an apartment with 7 roommates.
That's not encouraging people to move there, that's taking care of the people already there.
The above logic doesn't apply to pensions exclusively, either. Much infrastructure, in CA especially which has Prop 13, needs growth to sustain.
Stasis is neither natural nor sustainable.
[1] https://www.sfchronicle.com/bayarea/philmatier/article/In-Oa...
Neither is perpetual growth. Observation of nature shows that growth has bust cycles. aka, population grows till resources run out (food) and then the bulk starve and die.
Cities are dynamic, and always changing. They are either growing or dying. A very few may have found temporary equilibrium.
If a city wants to stay the same size, what they usually mean is that they wish to stay the same size at the same affordability level. However, since change is constant, their best attempt regulates growth. The natural result is economic stagnation (leading to eventual death), or city growth in spite of the regulation (leading to runaway prices).
Every city has the right to choose HOW they will change. They do not have the right to insist that they WON'T change, or that such a thing is even possible.
Sure, and cities "say" what their preferences through their elected representatives, at the local and state level.
> I don't think the end game of every city has to be to become Tokyo.
Nobody said that has to be the endgame for every city. San Francisco's politicians and residents aren't debating the aspirations of your Midwestern city, they are debating the aspirations of their own city and region. If the balance of political power turns toward pro housing policies in San Francisco, maybe it becomes more Tokyo like. If not, maybe it moves in the other direction.
But dynamic cities by their nature don't stay still, so you can be assured things will move in some direction.
It's important to be a bit more rigorous. What is "the city" in this thought experiment? The city government? The "will of the people" (what does that even mean, does it require a majority or a plurality to decide the size of the city)?
But is that true? As a Midwesterner, I have no skin in the game. But is it ever OK for city to say "We like the size we are, we don't want drop zoning and turn our entire coastal town into 100 story mega-skyscrapers?"
I don't think the end game of every city has to be to become Tokyo. As prices rise, more industry moves out of the city. Seems like a valid case for a local resident to want?