News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by NicoJuicy on Saturday April 13, 2019 @05:51AM (#19652012)
Samsung spend 130 million on research on bendable phones.

It got stolen by China. How can that be justified?

https://edition.cnn.com/2018/11/30/tech/samsung-china-tech-t...

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by pbhjpbhj on Saturday April 13, 2019 @06:31AM (#19652137)
There's a few ways to justify it I imagine. One is "it saved $130M from being spent again on the same thing".

And sure there are arguments against that justification (and for it).

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by NicoJuicy on Saturday April 13, 2019 @07:19AM (#19652307)
It's called R&D, spending too innovate is what it does.

Stealing it, is not R&D, it's theft and punishable by law.

Eg. Nintendo Wii, Xbox Kinect and PlayStation Move are the same concepts with a different approach.

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by geofft on Saturday April 13, 2019 @08:27AM (#19652611)
Is the world a better place because of that?

What if the Kinect and Move had spent their research budget building on top of the Wii instead of reinventing it? Would the world be a better place?

(Personally, I find it baffling to see people espousing "research should be private because it yields better outcomes" on a site for an industry so deeply indebted to open source. We have empirical evidence about which approach works better, and it's not the closed private research lab one.)

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by 0815test on Saturday April 13, 2019 @08:40AM (#19652666)
Stealing and violating privacy via industrial espionage is not "open source". You're free to make your own research public, or to pay a company for full IP rights on their research and then release the results openly. But what the Chinese are doing is not the same. Even making access to their domestic market conditional on releasing proprietary IP, is in fact a hidden tariff which is not in line with free and fair trade.
Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by geofft on Saturday April 13, 2019 @08:56AM (#19652752)
Yes, I'm not claiming that violating the laws and norms is a good thing. I'm asking if the laws and norms are defensible and produce a better society. If not, then the argument needs to be "We follow unjust laws for the sake of the broader principle of the rule of law, and we work to change unjust laws so respect for law is maintained," not "These outcomes are bad."
Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by 0815test on Saturday April 13, 2019 @09:05AM (#19652784)
The problem is that we're not just talking about a relatively-benign violation of things like copyrights, patents or trade secrets ("IP"): Chinese hacking is a severe violation of privacy; and their practice of forcing IP releases from foreign firms is blatantly unfair given that no reciprocity is involved, and indeed China apparently claims that they're uniquely allowed to engage in such policies because of their status as a "developing country" - itself a rather dubious claim given their reported economic performance. Privacy (and protection of physical property, in general) and fairness in trade are basic principles and far from "unjust".
Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by geofft on Saturday April 13, 2019 @09:50AM (#19652999)
Privacy of companies or of individuals? I don't think privacy of companies is a right, so that argument isn't convincing to me. (Specifically, I believe companies have no particular inherent right to existence the way people do. Companies are creations of law to serve specific goals that benefit people; we should give them whatever privileges are necessary to accomplish that, and not what's not. Privacy of certain things like customer data and things like HR conversations seems pretty clearly helpful, but mostly because that's a proxy for privacy of individuals, not because violating it would violate the company's "privacy.")

There's an easy solution to reciprocity: abandon IP protection in the US, too. My entire claim is that that would lead to a better world. If we want to not do that, we should either defend that it would lead to a worse world, or admit that we're not making arguments based on what's best for society. That's why I found the argument about "but IP protection brought us Kinect and Move" unconvincing: it's not clear at all to me that the outcome was better than in the world where the US didn't recognize IP protection.

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by NicoJuicy on Sunday April 21, 2019 @06:57AM (#19711516)
A better world by removing IP protection or the cheapest copycat wins by removing IP protection.

I just think it has to be tweaked for preventing abuse. But it had it's advantages.

If you remove IP protection, why would a company spend millions on research on R&D to innovate something.

Look at the products that got copied from Kickstarter by China before they launched, those people really got their dream crushed.

Ps. Kinect was just an example, look for the bigger picture ;)

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by 0815test on Sunday April 21, 2019 @07:11AM (#19711546)
> Look at the products that got copied from Kickstarter by China before they launched, those people really got their dream crushed.

Ideas are cheap. These Chinese companies are supposedly taking pre-validated (via crowd funding) ideas from Kickstarter and then manufacturing them. How is this a bad thing? It introduces a desirable competition for the best ability to execute on those plans.

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by NicoJuicy on Sunday April 21, 2019 @04:11PM (#19714268)
You obviously have not much experience creating something.

They already did more than "an idea". 3d models, marketing ( eg. Video), product iterations,..

They mostly want funds to manufacture the product, because not everyone can spend money for a MOQ manufacturing run...

What they do is unethical.

Here's some more info: https://qz.com/771727/chinas-factories-in-shenzhen-can-copy-...

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by NicoJuicy on Saturday April 13, 2019 @10:49AM (#19653296)
1) Why would the world be a better place? What a nonsense question that has nothing to do with anything.

I said: the consumers have more options. Personally, I prefer the Kinect. So yes, I'm for diversity.

2) In a forum of "open source" people.

What does this has to do with it? I find it baffling you don't see the difference.

How do you earn your money? Work at a traditional company or did you create you own open-source product with donations?

I'd be damned if you are one of the 0,01% here that earns all his income through open-source.

I find it baffling you don't see the simple difference between software parents and IP ( without software).

Fyi. You are not earning your money through open-source. Otherwise you would know that if not the golden life either.

3) Research should be public?

Wtf? So every company should share everything?

Wtf? How realistic is that???

Answer: it's not. It's never going to happen. Stop dreaming and come back to reality please.

----

In a lot of the responses here, I honestly think that I have to explain it to a 12-year old. Because they don't seem to grasp reality. Or trolls, or Chinese state sponsored propaganda. I really don't understand the low quality of responses, constant Whataboutism ! Unrelated responses). That baffles me at this moment.

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by TaylorAlexander on Saturday April 13, 2019 @01:31PM (#19654452)
I believe strongly that privatization of so much we depend on is harmful. I think people are suffering because of this, making the situation urgent. I see that we can develop the technology we need all as open source. Funding is an important challenge but one I believe is possible to overcome. Look at Prusa Research and their all open source 3D printer with rave reviews. They’ve funded research, development, customer service, manufacturing, and worldwide promotional tours all with a machine that is open source. Why can’t we do that with medical equipment and computers and automobile and factory automation? In fact we could. And thus I strongly advocate that we invest great effort in this. I wish to withdraw as much as possible my support of a closed proprietary privatized system and put my daily efforts in to something open for everyone.
Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by NicoJuicy on Saturday April 13, 2019 @06:01PM (#19656018)
Privatisation and open source are 2 different things.

If you are against privatisation, great. Go to a communist country and prove it. Don't forget the 996 debacle or Jack Macs response to it.

You only want open-source? Great. Quit your job and prove me wrong that your can get an income there.

You know you won't do any of those both things. But probably you have an excuse. Great, then adjust to reality and stop believing in fairy tales. Adjust your opinion to something realistic.

Open-source takes a long road to profitability, it's not that easy. And probably, because your designs are online, some lower-cost Chinese company will take it and produce it cheaper. Except, if you have build a big community around it, it will work out for them. But the chances are really small.

Open-source always had an Enterprise/cloud option also to earn money. Currently, it's the only stable way ( donations are not a stable source of income)

Now, we are going back in circles about what was the issue...

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by geofft on Saturday April 13, 2019 @07:25PM (#19656442)
> You only want open-source? Great. Quit your job and prove me wrong that your can get an income there.

Um, can't you also work at Red Hat or Mozilla or somewhere? Or even USDS or NASA? (Remember, OpenStack came out of a joint project between NASA and a for-profit company, and plenty of people in both organizations were paid to work on open-source full-time to make it happen....)

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by NicoJuicy on Sunday April 21, 2019 @07:05AM (#19711536)
Red hat = IBM, so that doesn't make any sense.

Firefox is probably the only one. But they can only hire a limited amount of people and their resources depend on their market share of I'm correct.

A big part of that is the "default search engine setting" ( paid based on market share), so open-source still doesn't pay the bills at the end of the day.

My argument is still valid.

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by geofft on Saturday April 13, 2019 @02:08PM (#19654667)
1) If you do not think the legitimate purpose of laws is to make the world a better place and nothing else, we do not agree on fundamentals, and I see you as a dangerous enemy, someone who would be a dictator or oppressor if they could. Using the government's monopoly on violence to make you happier with no concern for the rest of society is an evil thing.

Why is the legitimate purpose of laws to make you happier as a consumer?? What does that have to do with anything? (And, to the point I was originally making, why do you believe you wouldn't be even happier in the world I describe? You'd get a Kinect researched with awareness of what the Wii and Move tried and didn't, so it'd either be better or cheaper or perhaps both.)

2) Again, the legitimate purpose of government is not to preserve the way I make money, either. You're making the "Yet you participate in society!" argument. Yes, I do. The fact that I think a certain course of action is individually rational for me to preserve life and health does not mean I think the availability of that course, to the exclusion of other possible courses, is inherently good or worth preserving.

But just so you know: I maintain systems infrastructure for a hedge fund, all based on open-source software (Debian, OpenStack, Ceph, etc.). The hedge fund operates on secrecy of market data and insights but not on secrecy of fundamental research (and also making e.g. Linux available to everyone makes everyone more productive, but making our ideas about alpha available to everyone makes the alpha go away). To be clear, working at a hedge fund does not mean that I think the existence of hedge funds is inherently good or that I am opposed to societies where hedge funds don't exist, any more than working at Blockbuster means you're opposed to Netflix existing. My work is all on things that would benefit the world more if they were public and would benefit my employer no less; it's just difficult to maintain a separation between publishable work and sensitive algorithms, so I don't do as much as I'd like. But I'd like to do more, and I've quite loudly disagreed with our internal policies on this, because I think I can do better for the world and for our company if allowed to be public about everything. And my work, in any case, is keeping them running, not creating new private ideas. The public knows how to create sandwiches, and yet Subway is profitable.

And it is beyond clear that my company would be less profitable if open source software did not exist, or if we used a proprietary stack/vendor for everything.

3) Yes, it's realistic. You haven't presented an argument beyond "Nyeh, it's not," so I say, "Nyeh, is too."

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by 0815test on Saturday April 13, 2019 @11:48AM (#19653673)
> Research should be public?

> Wtf? So every company should share everything?

> Wtf? How realistic is that???

That's not what "research should be public" means. It just means that the existing institutions which the public funds for research (universities and research labs) should have their remit expanded to include "private" R&D for public benefit; and that, additionally, the public sector should routinely buy out valuable private R&D, perhaps via formally-established "prizes" - instead of merely allowing it to be monopolized via IP protection. We spend a lot of tax money already to fund private R&D by firms, that could instead be directed to fund these mechanisms.

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by NicoJuicy on Saturday April 13, 2019 @06:10PM (#19656064)
We are talking about Samsung's research in the thread. Please don't change to subject to your liking.

Private firms are mostly subsided by government for employment, not for their research

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by greedo on Sunday April 14, 2019 @11:53AM (#19660108)
In your world, we wouldn't have multiple terminals in *nix, cuz why wouldn't open source devs just expand on vi instead of wasting resources and time on developing emacs...
Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by geofft on Monday April 15, 2019 @05:00PM (#19668874)
That doesn't follow - both vi and emacs have been able to be aware of each other and if necessary incorporate techniques from each other, and yet they both exist separately. At no point did I argue that we should prevent people from making two separate products if they want. I only argued that we should prevent people from keeping research and discoveries secret, and gave an example that different products could build on each other. vi and emacs have in fact had that opportunity, so this example supports my point that it's a reasonable way for the world to work. Sometimes building on each other means collaborating; something it means friendly and open competition for the sake of taking multiple approaches to a goal (which is different from competition-for-the-sake-of-competition by forcing your competitors to walk the same path you already walked, but several steps behind you).

Also, spacemacs.

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by PedroBatista on Saturday April 13, 2019 @08:33AM (#19652631)
I’m sure you don’t mind if I break into your house and start living there. I mean, you already spent the money there’s no need for me to spend it again on the same thing.
Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by geofft on Saturday April 13, 2019 @09:56AM (#19653034)
This is a frustrating line of argument because it ignores the entire reason that opponents of intellectual property are opponents of intellectual property: that intellectual property can be duplicated without harm to the owner. Protection of real estate or other physical property is rooted in the principle that depriving the original owner of the use of their property is unjust. "Theft" of intellectual property does not deprive the original owner of anything; it simply (perhaps) makes the potential market more competitive.

I really wish we would be able to move past these extremely basic arguments and have some discussion of the topic that isn't repeating the same thing over and over. It's fine to disagree with the duplication argument, but it's a waste of everyone's time to pretend it doesn't exist.

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by shshhdhs on Saturday April 13, 2019 @10:55AM (#19653331)
Duplication does harm the owner, because Samsung needs to recoup the R&D money they spent and the thief does not. Because they stole the tech, the thief can undercut Samsung on pricing, ensuring that Samsung never can be profitable enough to recoup their R&D.
Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by geofft on Saturday April 13, 2019 @01:37PM (#19654487)
There are other ways to solve that problem. One of the more straightforward ways (with precedent in US law) is a compulsory license: allow anyone to get a license to use the invention if they pay Samsung, without giving Samsung the opportunity to refuse.

Other options include collective funding of R&D (either the government-funding model, popular in the US for landing on the moon and creating the internet and taking a photo of a black hole, or the voluntary-collective model, popular in the US for creating basically all the technology we're using to have this conversation). If collective funding is more productive, this compensates the participants for R&D. And it may be subject to a prisoner's-dilemma problem, where any one entity can profitably defect even if everyone would be better off if no one did. Creating prisoner's-dilemma situation doesn't seem like a just use of the powers of government.

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by 0815test on Saturday April 13, 2019 @11:30AM (#19653544)
True, but this harm is handily offset by the benefit of an expanded use for the original tech, due to the very fact of its lower price. Critically, the more the thief is able to "undercut" e.g. Samsung on pricing, the higher this benefit. IP protection is thus more socially beneficial for tech that is expensive per se, because then there is too little "undercutting" to matter, and more like a direct transfer in value away from the creators. Folding phones are an interesting case; they obviously cannot be duplicated "costlessly", but their raw manufacturing costs are low enough that IP protection for them might still be somewhat undesirable.
Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by tw04 on Saturday April 13, 2019 @11:43AM (#19653634)
That logic only applies in the case that the inventor built something for their own use, put in all the effort for their own use, and never planned on making a living off of it. The second that they invented something to profit off of/make a living off of, they are absolutely harmed when someone else copies it. I don't understand why this is even debatable.

Per the other commenter, unless you're suggesting that private property just shouldn't exist, then your argument falls apart. And if you are arguing private property shouldn't exist, I think you'll find very few takers.

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by geofft on Saturday April 13, 2019 @01:31PM (#19654450)
This is a different argument for property than the one I was referencing. (I'm not arguing it's wrong, just that it's different.)

The argument I'm talking about is that the right to private property is the right to ownership/control. If I have X, and I am deprived of it / it is taken from me, it is unjust.

The argument you are referencing is that the right to private property is the right to exchange it at a certain value, and a negative impact on its market value is unjust. I can see some cases where this is true (e.g., buying a name-brand purse and finding it's an equally functional counterfeit), some where it's debatable (e.g., buying a house in a quiet neighborhood that gets loud), and some where it's not (e.g., buying a large quantity of a psychoactive substance that isn't controlled and then having it become controlled). So it seems like a weaker argument to me. I think you can still defend it by saying that the not-unjust cases are because there's a greater good / more important right being protected. But I also think you can just hold to the other definition of the right to private property.

In kindergartener terms: if I bring candy to school and my teacher takes it from me and eats it, that's wrong, that's stealing. If I bring candy to school with the intent to give it to other kids to boost my popularity, and the teacher tells me I can't do that and have to keep the candy in my bag, that doesn't seem like stealing.

I agree that compensating inventors is important. I disagree that treating inventions as property is the only way to do it.

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by tw04 on Saturday April 13, 2019 @08:34PM (#19656735)
>Iagree that compensating inventors is important. I disagree that treating inventions as property is the only way to do it.

So what is this magical means of Samsung being compensated for their multi-billion dollar investment that China stole that you don't think is a big deal?

As for your analogy, it's patently false that anyone involved wants the candy shared. It's been stolen.

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by geofft on Saturday April 13, 2019 @11:27PM (#19657420)
> So what is this magical means of Samsung being compensated for their multi-billion dollar investment that China stole that you don't think is a big deal?

My claim in this thread is that not treating ideas as private property is a defensible and reasonable position to take. When you say that Samsung needs to be "compensated," you make it clear that you're not treating ideas as private property, either. The market value of property is the amount of benefit/enjoyment it provides someone else, not the amount of effort that went into making it. If I spend two hours making a cake, and you spend 30 minutes making a cake, and people want to pay both of us $10 for it, there is no violation of my property rights that I'm not compensated for spending 4x as long. You might casually say that my cake is "a steal," but the cake is definitely not being stolen from me.

If you were arguing about property rights, you would be asking about why Samsung isn't getting paid the fair market value of their ideas, not about why they aren't recouping the investment they put into creating them. (And I've even suggested elsewhere in this thread that compulsory licenses are a way to do this.)

But if you're interested in Samsung recouping their investment, well, we can discuss that but it's absolutely not property rights that are helping them do that today. If we want to discuss that, I'd simultaneously ask how to compensate people for multi-billion dollar investments that don't yield marketable products but are still good for humanity to have done the research.

> As for your analogy, it's patently false that anyone involved wants the candy shared. It's been stolen.

Not sure I follow. Samsung wants to trade phones for money. Samsung does want the phones shared: that's the entire basis of the argument The kid wants to trade candy for reputation. If you prevent Samsung from selling as many phones, no phones are being stolen. (Actually it turns out I didn't even need the analogy here.) If you prevent the kid from giving candy to classmates, no candy is being stolen. Why do you think the candy is being stolen?

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by HillaryBriss on Saturday April 13, 2019 @10:45AM (#19653270)
> without harm to the owner

i don't quite see it.

if company A aims at the global market with a uniquely innovative product and then company B brings a copy of that product to the global market ten years later, then company A has enjoyed profitability of a unique product for ten years.

but what if company B spies on company A's process and steals copies of its designs and so brings a copy of that product to market ten months later?

isn't that depriving the original owner, company A, of some profits?

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by geofft on Saturday April 13, 2019 @01:42PM (#19654511)
Depriving someone of potential profits isn't legally actionable harm. Otherwise we'd have to say that entering a market as a lower-cost and/or higher-quality competitor is a violation of the property rights, a theft of profit, of the existing participants.

You may or may not have a right to a fair market, and fairness may or may not include the right to secret research and development, but it's not because an unfair market harms your property rights or is "theft."

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by HillaryBriss on Saturday April 13, 2019 @02:43PM (#19654921)
ok, but ... you originally said "harm" and now you're saying "legally actionable harm"
Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by geofft on Saturday April 13, 2019 @03:15PM (#19655143)
What sense of "harm" would it count as? If you entered a market and an existing competitor said "You harmed me, apologize," would you? If you were a doctor with an oath to "First do no harm," would you feel ethically obligated to never take business from another doctor?
Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by HillaryBriss on Saturday April 13, 2019 @06:58PM (#19656295)
I'm just thinking about profitability.

e.g. If I were a consultant to, say, Nvidia, and I told them that they were wasting valuable IT personnel time and resources by locking down and protecting their R&D documents, that all of the computers containing such info were needlessly and wastefully secure, and that, in short, there is no harm in making that info available to the public, including to Intel and AMD -- I mean, I just wonder how I would convince them.

Wouldn't they say something like "No. Releasing that info would be harmful to our bottom line, shareholders, and employees whose bonuses depend upon profitability."

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by geofft on Saturday April 13, 2019 @07:17PM (#19656401)
If you were a consultant to the British East India Company in 1850 and told them that the world would be a better place for everyone if India were independent and not colonized by Britain, would you expect to convince them?

If you failed to convince them, would you then conclude that colonization is actually totally fine?

In particular, if someone were advocating for the independence of India in 1850, would you think the British East India Company could justifiably say "You're harming us"? (Sure, they can say it and they probably would say it, but would they have a point?)

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by HillaryBriss on Saturday April 13, 2019 @08:51PM (#19656804)
I thought we were talking about "harm to the owner" of some IP, not making the world "a better place for everyone." A judgment or evaluation of what would be "totally fine" ethically for the whole world is a different discussion, I think.

I don't feel that the arguments you're presenting would be persuasive to the companies whose secrets are revealed. But, I may well be missing something. In any case, my takeaways from this discussion are:

1. You believe these companies don't have a solid legal case, that they cannot prove "harm" in the legal sense.

2. You believe that the system of protecting IP the US currently (in theory) embraces is sub-optimal for the well-being of the world.

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by geofft on Saturday April 13, 2019 @11:29PM (#19657431)
Okay, fine, rephrase "without harm to the owner" as "without injustice to the owner" if that helps make my comment more understandable. I grant that there is a sense of "harm" under which deposing a dictator from his comfortable life harms the dictator, even if he isn't punished and is allowed to start a new life as a private citizen, and that's not the sense of "harm" I mean. I don't think there's a way you can argue that deposing him would be an injustice towards him.
Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by NicoJuicy on Saturday April 13, 2019 @11:08AM (#19653413)
Your logic only works if you can create digital copies of products ( products are not documents that aren't supposed to be distributed. Products are supposed to be distributed)

Eg. Product = movies

Eg. Not product = the nude selfies your girlfriend send to you.

It's not applicable to hardware and R&D. Also, it's seriously taken out of it's context to defend piracy.

You are generalizing the slang to everything, which isn't right.

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by geofft on Saturday April 13, 2019 @01:41PM (#19654504)
This is a bad argument (as in, an argument that if followed leads to harmful conclusions) because it says the reason that redistribution of private naked selfies is bad is it harms the market value of naked selfies. It leads to all sorts of exciting nonsense like using the DMCA to stop revenge porn, and useless situations like the copyright owner of nonconsensual naked selfies being the photographer and not the subject.

Let's instead say that people have a right to control of their naked image for reasons that aren't about the property rights to the photo.

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by NicoJuicy on Saturday April 13, 2019 @06:14PM (#19656087)
But you are wording it differently to your liking.

In the meantime, it's just the same. It's you and you have the rights to it.

It solves a problem. Your solution is weird and not generic

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by geofft on Saturday April 13, 2019 @07:15PM (#19656387)
No, I identified two specific reasons why it's not the same: 1) in the US at least, copyright infringement is only criminal if done for financial gain (or a few other exceptions) 2) in all jurisdictions with the Berne definition of copyright, the copyright of a photo is owned by a photographer. So even if it's you, you don't have the rights to it if you didn't take the picture, and you can't pursue a copyright violation. So if your ex took a picture of you with your consent at the time, and is now spreading it on the internet, he has every right to do that, according to copyright.

Your solution doesn't solve these problems. If you want to solve these problems, you can't use copyright.

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by rhegart on Sunday April 14, 2019 @01:02AM (#19657693)
Theft removes the incentive to do r&d. If you are just going to get it stolen, others will just invest in stealing. No one will waste on r&d. There are reasons we have laws. You are making infantile arguments for pro theft with no thought to the obvious consequences. The fact that you’re getting upvoted on HN is alarming.
Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by geofft on Sunday April 14, 2019 @03:15PM (#19661115)
> If you are just going to get it stolen, others will just invest in stealing. No one will waste on r&d.

Okay, why does Linux exist? And why is it competitive with every proprietary OS kernel? And why does it get development from for-profit companies?

> There are reasons we have laws.

Of course there are. Many of those reasons are not good. In the specific realm of intellectual property law, some of those reasons are "because Disney has lobbyists".

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by alexanderdmitri on Sunday April 14, 2019 @02:39AM (#19657936)
I'm not sure this is historically supported. There's a long list of innovators who do not end up making the lion's share off of their achievements. I think innovation is just what we (humans ... or maybe even life in general?) do best and cultural values and need dictate how resources are allocated in this respect.
Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by z3phyr on Saturday April 13, 2019 @09:27AM (#19652886)
I would not mind if you copy my house internals and my way of life in a cheaper and more efficient manner. I would also not mind if you improve upon those designs(I would encourage you to do so). Find and Reverse Engineer my designs and improve them.

I would mind if you break into my house.

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by NicoJuicy on Saturday April 13, 2019 @11:39AM (#19653596)
Then you should distribute the plans.

R&D documents are not distributed fyi. Totally different things.

PS. I do agree the example isn't that good, because everyone has other opinions. But then again, i don't know if your architect would appreciate it, if you give your plans to someone else.

Because he created it, not you.

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by AsyncAwait on Saturday April 13, 2019 @08:42AM (#19652680)
That's a terribly poor analogy. If you break into my house and start living there, you occupy space and resources I could use myself, IP theft does not deprive the originator of the invention or even first mover advantage profits. It just prevents IP from being used to keep 3rd world nations there.

The U.S. did the same to Europe in the 17/18th centuries when IT need to bring itself up to par, so did Japan in the 70s/80s - so did the Europeans to the Chinese before that.

China will, (and already does to an extent), innovate and enrich the world, it just needs to catch up fast and this is the best way to do it.

[dead]
Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by AsyncAwait on Saturday April 13, 2019 @01:52PM (#19654568)
IP theft would be like looking at my house and building a very similar one, or perhaps even peeking inside via the windows to note down the exact furniture. I'm not trying to say that it is a flawless way to go about it, or that anybody's 'evil', but please stop pretending that it is not a stage of every country's development at some point. Europe did it, Russia did it, the U.S. did it, Japan did it and now China does it.

Perhaps that should tell you something. In the end, this helps a country to move past sweat shops and the like faster and am certainly not going to protest too loud against that.

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by pbhjpbhj on Sunday April 14, 2019 @08:39AM (#19659047)
I absolutely don't mind you copying my house and living in that copy, which is equivalent. However, the parent asked for a justification, not for my opinion or position.
Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by freeflight on Saturday April 13, 2019 @07:26AM (#19652336)
The same way any state-sponsored industrial espionage is being justified, even among supposed "friends" [0].

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ECHELON#Examples_of_industrial...

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by NicoJuicy on Saturday April 13, 2019 @07:32AM (#19652366)
Almost all of the world is protected by copyright.

You mention 1 example where copyright failed ( 20 years ago...). Nothing is perfect also and it doesn't mean it's wrong to protect innovative companies.

But you lack the fundamental understanding that nothing in China has this protection. While our allies do.

Ps. Except if you count the clothes of Ivanka Trump of course, that won copyright infringement case in China.... Which was no way a political intervention to appeal to someone with the trade war happening ;)

https://www.nytimes.com/2018/05/28/business/ivanka-trump-chi...

Good rules are better than ego-interventions for the 1% every day of the year.

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by ionised on Monday April 15, 2019 @05:54AM (#19664213)
> But you lack the fundamental understanding that nothing in China has this protection. While our allies do.

You asked for a justification and you've answered your own question.

It happens because there are no protections for these thins in China. It is not in their culture to assign intellectual property protections in the way US culture does.

There's your justification. Their culture is different and they see yours as ridiculous and unenforceable.

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by NicoJuicy on Monday April 22, 2019 @04:22PM (#19722557)
China has no IP-protection because they copy and go. As soon as they would be innovators, they would adopt it.

Right now, they have a lot of luck that they are> 1 billion people and stealing everything they can without punishment.

IP-protection would happen for Chinese firms, just not outsiders. Don't change my words.

"This" protection = global protection. China just has "Chinese" protection. It's not in laid out in rules with them, but it means in 99% of the cases that they are an advantage for Chinese firms.

Ps. Blocking the market is an extreme form of IP-protection, it's even just stealing and adjusting the rules ( required Chinese partnerships). They adapted in a very bad way, they also get previous generation tech because firms don't trust it

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by rcw4256 on Saturday April 13, 2019 @07:14AM (#19652293)
As a result of this 'theft', consumers now have more bendable phone options.
Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by sgt101 on Saturday April 13, 2019 @07:44AM (#19652405)
But in the future they will see less innovation as R&D is further slashed.
Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by izacus on Saturday April 13, 2019 @09:31AM (#19652896)
I see this thrown around all the time when we talk about monopolizing IP and having huge corporations put their lawyer boots on smaller company throats... but is it really true? Will making IP protection weaker actually stifle innovation? Was innovation in industrial era hugely stuffled by not protecting every single patent a huge multi-national conglomerates throw out?
Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by sgt101 on Saturday April 13, 2019 @12:23PM (#19653914)
Well, yes, hence the development of patents.

"The English patent system evolved from its early medieval origins into the first modern patent system that recognised intellectual property in order to stimulate invention; this was the crucial legal foundation upon which the Industrial Revolution could emerge and flourish." ([1]Wikipedia)

Without patents what you do is create trade secrets, patents publish the concepts that are protected, they are fully disclosed (or the patent is junk) and after 25 years anyone can use them. The 25 years is the time that you have to get payback on your invention - forcing investment in development now before your monopoly expires.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Patent

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by NicoJuicy on Saturday April 13, 2019 @06:18PM (#19656097)
Yes, the biggest open source corporation is known for Enterprise solutions ( red hat).

Please find me an example that open-sourced everything, with their Enterprise solution.

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by ionised on Monday April 15, 2019 @05:55AM (#19664222)
They are already seeing less innovation from phone makers. Phone makers have been short on ideas for a long time now.

It didn't require any IP theft for that to happen.

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by NicoJuicy on Saturday April 13, 2019 @07:17AM (#19652299)
It's all the same tech, what are you defending??

I would hate if this happened to the Nintendo Wii, Xbox Kinect or Playstation Move.

Which triggered HTC Vice and the Oculus adoption, later on: Hololens. ( So AR and VR)

They got so much better with actual competition and their own R&D instead of just stealing and hurting the innovator.

Us as customers got a lot more options because of competition, not because of theft.

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by umvi on Saturday April 13, 2019 @09:15AM (#19652834)
That's so short sighted... If companies R&D is free game for competition, they will be more reluctant to innovate
Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by johndough on Saturday April 13, 2019 @11:04AM (#19653388)
Why would they be more reluctant to innovate? Couldn't it also be the opposite? For example, companies could spend more on R&D to stay ahead of the competition and lead the field instead of releasing copies of a product months or years later.
Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by kwxza on Monday April 15, 2019 @11:16AM (#19665924)
How can a company lead the field if their R&D is free for the competition to take?
Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by ionised on Monday April 15, 2019 @05:57AM (#19664225)
Nobody ever backs up this assertion.
Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by AlexTWithBeard on Saturday April 13, 2019 @07:47AM (#19652422)
Right. And as a result of outsourcing all electronics manufacturing to China, US consumers now have cheaper TVs.

They've lost factories, lost jobs, lost growth momentum, but got cheap TVs.

Hooray?

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by ineedasername on Saturday April 13, 2019 @08:52AM (#19652727)
I hate when I see this argument about lost US manufacturing. The truth is, the US industrial output has risen consistently over the years outside of recessions [0] The number of employees required to produce all of this has, however, fallen.[1] Not because of China, but because of more efficient methods of production and automation. I still don't like their IP theft though.

[0]https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/INDPRO [1]https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/MANEMP

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by ABCLAW on Saturday April 13, 2019 @04:51PM (#19655640)
>Production indexes for a few industries are derived by dividing estimated nominal output (calculated using unit production and unit values or sales) by a corresponding Fisher price index; the most notable of these fall within the high-technology grouping and include semiconductors.

You might hate the argument, but it's because the argument is accurate. The increase in US-based production isn't caused by the manufacturing industry kicking ass. It's because they fudge the numbers. They consider a CPU that's sold for twice the $ to be double the production. If you remove the high technology grouping, the US manufacturing base has cratered.

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by ineedasername on Saturday April 13, 2019 @08:50PM (#19656800)
Do you have disaggregated stats that demonstrate this? Because a lot of that tech sector output isn't in the US. Sure, Intel may design their chips here, but they're manufactured internationally. Partly in the US, but also Ireland, Israel and China. So that doesn't count in favor of our industrial output index.
Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by ABCLAW on Monday April 15, 2019 @01:28PM (#19667039)
The full disaggregation + analysis has been linked in related discussions on HN in the past, but I don't have it. If I had to get the numbers or die, I'd search HN for manufacturing related articles from the past year.
Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by AlexTWithBeard on Saturday April 13, 2019 @09:01AM (#19652772)
It's quite possible that I'm just fooled by the ubiquitous "Made in China" stamp.

But another way of looking at your stats is that outsourcing labor-heavy jobs to China indeed decreases the amount of jobs available to local people. Industrial output, on the other hand, only grows because of the automation.

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by ineedasername on Sunday April 14, 2019 @11:58AM (#19660126)
That's pretty much exactly what I mean. Sure, some jobs have left the country, but those no longer count in our industrial output index referenced in my parent comments. And I'd argue many of these jobs would have been eliminated with automation if they'd staying in the US anyway.

Our native industrial output has increased but via automation that actually made jobs decrease. The situation with Carrier, manufacturer of HVAC systems, is a perfect example. They were given a tax break to keep a manufacturing plant in the US, but explicitly stated they'd be investing $13 million in automation that would reduce the number of jobs needed. No other country is getting these jobs instead of the US. The jobs are simply gone, through automation.

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by geofft on Saturday April 13, 2019 @08:30AM (#19652623)
Jobs aren't an inherent good. They're a way for people to have money, which they can in turn exchange for things they need or want, which is the inherent good. Making it harder for people to get things they need or want simply so they can have jobs risks being self-defeating, and it assumes there will never be other ways to get people access to things they need or want.
Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by AlexTWithBeard on Saturday April 13, 2019 @08:53AM (#19652733)
No. Job is a way of manufacturing things people need or want.

When you're well off, as a person or as a country, you can always find people or countries who will manufacture things for you.

But they will want something back. Your real estate. Your universities. Your best people.

It's a high price to pay for a bending phone.

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by geofft on Saturday April 13, 2019 @09:51AM (#19653008)
Jobs are one way of manufacturing things people need or want. They're not the only way, unless we're playing semantic games by defining "jobs" in one sentence as "people offering 8h/day of their labor in the free market" and in the next as "people doing things"—and even if we are, let's at least be honest about the difference between "people doing things that are actually inherently productive and efficient" and "people doing things that are inefficient because we want the excuse to pay them for it." Job growth because it enables manufacturing is one thing; job growth because it enables paying people is quite another. As we become more efficient and automated in manufacturing, we'll have to decide what to do when there simply aren't enough jobs to go around. There are ways to continue giving people money to buy the things they need or want—or perhaps enable them to get the things they need or want without money—without requiring them to have jobs, or making that money proportional to the market value of their work. And they seem quite ethical.

That's why I say that jobs aren't an inherent good. They're a means to an inherently-good end. That makes them conditionally good, so long as they continue to serve the end. Prioritizing the means over the end would be a mistake.

There is no comparable alternative to giving people the things they need or want. I can think of a few (e.g., drugging people, plugging them into the Matrix) and they're unethical.

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by chronogram on Saturday April 13, 2019 @06:21AM (#19652101)
https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-11-29/south-kor...

It got stolen by South Korea, how can that be justified?

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by NicoJuicy on Saturday April 13, 2019 @06:45AM (#19652192)
South Korea charged nine people and two companies of illegally selling Samsung Electronics Co.’s bendable screen technology to a Chinese rival.

> The sale is the reward, the assignment came earlier.

Ps. South Korea was the judge, you are not reading it correctly.