News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by rcw4256 on Saturday April 13, 2019 @07:14AM (#19652293)
As a result of this 'theft', consumers now have more bendable phone options.
Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by sgt101 on Saturday April 13, 2019 @07:44AM (#19652405)
But in the future they will see less innovation as R&D is further slashed.
Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by izacus on Saturday April 13, 2019 @09:31AM (#19652896)
I see this thrown around all the time when we talk about monopolizing IP and having huge corporations put their lawyer boots on smaller company throats... but is it really true? Will making IP protection weaker actually stifle innovation? Was innovation in industrial era hugely stuffled by not protecting every single patent a huge multi-national conglomerates throw out?
Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by sgt101 on Saturday April 13, 2019 @12:23PM (#19653914)
Well, yes, hence the development of patents.

"The English patent system evolved from its early medieval origins into the first modern patent system that recognised intellectual property in order to stimulate invention; this was the crucial legal foundation upon which the Industrial Revolution could emerge and flourish." ([1]Wikipedia)

Without patents what you do is create trade secrets, patents publish the concepts that are protected, they are fully disclosed (or the patent is junk) and after 25 years anyone can use them. The 25 years is the time that you have to get payback on your invention - forcing investment in development now before your monopoly expires.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Patent

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by NicoJuicy on Saturday April 13, 2019 @06:18PM (#19656097)
Yes, the biggest open source corporation is known for Enterprise solutions ( red hat).

Please find me an example that open-sourced everything, with their Enterprise solution.

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by ionised on Monday April 15, 2019 @05:55AM (#19664222)
They are already seeing less innovation from phone makers. Phone makers have been short on ideas for a long time now.

It didn't require any IP theft for that to happen.

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by NicoJuicy on Saturday April 13, 2019 @07:17AM (#19652299)
It's all the same tech, what are you defending??

I would hate if this happened to the Nintendo Wii, Xbox Kinect or Playstation Move.

Which triggered HTC Vice and the Oculus adoption, later on: Hololens. ( So AR and VR)

They got so much better with actual competition and their own R&D instead of just stealing and hurting the innovator.

Us as customers got a lot more options because of competition, not because of theft.

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by umvi on Saturday April 13, 2019 @09:15AM (#19652834)
That's so short sighted... If companies R&D is free game for competition, they will be more reluctant to innovate
Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by johndough on Saturday April 13, 2019 @11:04AM (#19653388)
Why would they be more reluctant to innovate? Couldn't it also be the opposite? For example, companies could spend more on R&D to stay ahead of the competition and lead the field instead of releasing copies of a product months or years later.
Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by kwxza on Monday April 15, 2019 @11:16AM (#19665924)
How can a company lead the field if their R&D is free for the competition to take?
Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by ionised on Monday April 15, 2019 @05:57AM (#19664225)
Nobody ever backs up this assertion.
Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by AlexTWithBeard on Saturday April 13, 2019 @07:47AM (#19652422)
Right. And as a result of outsourcing all electronics manufacturing to China, US consumers now have cheaper TVs.

They've lost factories, lost jobs, lost growth momentum, but got cheap TVs.

Hooray?

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by ineedasername on Saturday April 13, 2019 @08:52AM (#19652727)
I hate when I see this argument about lost US manufacturing. The truth is, the US industrial output has risen consistently over the years outside of recessions [0] The number of employees required to produce all of this has, however, fallen.[1] Not because of China, but because of more efficient methods of production and automation. I still don't like their IP theft though.

[0]https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/INDPRO [1]https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/MANEMP

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by ABCLAW on Saturday April 13, 2019 @04:51PM (#19655640)
>Production indexes for a few industries are derived by dividing estimated nominal output (calculated using unit production and unit values or sales) by a corresponding Fisher price index; the most notable of these fall within the high-technology grouping and include semiconductors.

You might hate the argument, but it's because the argument is accurate. The increase in US-based production isn't caused by the manufacturing industry kicking ass. It's because they fudge the numbers. They consider a CPU that's sold for twice the $ to be double the production. If you remove the high technology grouping, the US manufacturing base has cratered.

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by ineedasername on Saturday April 13, 2019 @08:50PM (#19656800)
Do you have disaggregated stats that demonstrate this? Because a lot of that tech sector output isn't in the US. Sure, Intel may design their chips here, but they're manufactured internationally. Partly in the US, but also Ireland, Israel and China. So that doesn't count in favor of our industrial output index.
Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by ABCLAW on Monday April 15, 2019 @01:28PM (#19667039)
The full disaggregation + analysis has been linked in related discussions on HN in the past, but I don't have it. If I had to get the numbers or die, I'd search HN for manufacturing related articles from the past year.
Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by AlexTWithBeard on Saturday April 13, 2019 @09:01AM (#19652772)
It's quite possible that I'm just fooled by the ubiquitous "Made in China" stamp.

But another way of looking at your stats is that outsourcing labor-heavy jobs to China indeed decreases the amount of jobs available to local people. Industrial output, on the other hand, only grows because of the automation.

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by ineedasername on Sunday April 14, 2019 @11:58AM (#19660126)
That's pretty much exactly what I mean. Sure, some jobs have left the country, but those no longer count in our industrial output index referenced in my parent comments. And I'd argue many of these jobs would have been eliminated with automation if they'd staying in the US anyway.

Our native industrial output has increased but via automation that actually made jobs decrease. The situation with Carrier, manufacturer of HVAC systems, is a perfect example. They were given a tax break to keep a manufacturing plant in the US, but explicitly stated they'd be investing $13 million in automation that would reduce the number of jobs needed. No other country is getting these jobs instead of the US. The jobs are simply gone, through automation.

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by geofft on Saturday April 13, 2019 @08:30AM (#19652623)
Jobs aren't an inherent good. They're a way for people to have money, which they can in turn exchange for things they need or want, which is the inherent good. Making it harder for people to get things they need or want simply so they can have jobs risks being self-defeating, and it assumes there will never be other ways to get people access to things they need or want.
Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by AlexTWithBeard on Saturday April 13, 2019 @08:53AM (#19652733)
No. Job is a way of manufacturing things people need or want.

When you're well off, as a person or as a country, you can always find people or countries who will manufacture things for you.

But they will want something back. Your real estate. Your universities. Your best people.

It's a high price to pay for a bending phone.

Re:As China Hacked, U.S. Businesses Turned a Blind Eye by geofft on Saturday April 13, 2019 @09:51AM (#19653008)
Jobs are one way of manufacturing things people need or want. They're not the only way, unless we're playing semantic games by defining "jobs" in one sentence as "people offering 8h/day of their labor in the free market" and in the next as "people doing things"—and even if we are, let's at least be honest about the difference between "people doing things that are actually inherently productive and efficient" and "people doing things that are inefficient because we want the excuse to pay them for it." Job growth because it enables manufacturing is one thing; job growth because it enables paying people is quite another. As we become more efficient and automated in manufacturing, we'll have to decide what to do when there simply aren't enough jobs to go around. There are ways to continue giving people money to buy the things they need or want—or perhaps enable them to get the things they need or want without money—without requiring them to have jobs, or making that money proportional to the market value of their work. And they seem quite ethical.

That's why I say that jobs aren't an inherent good. They're a means to an inherently-good end. That makes them conditionally good, so long as they continue to serve the end. Prioritizing the means over the end would be a mistake.

There is no comparable alternative to giving people the things they need or want. I can think of a few (e.g., drugging people, plugging them into the Matrix) and they're unethical.