News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by quickthrower2 on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @04:14AM (#19561685)
What is there to believe or not believe in? It is what it is. Bitcoin is a perfectly functional means of financial exchange, and has use cases that beat regular cash, and other use case where it sucks compared to cash.
Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by chx on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @05:03AM (#19561882)
> and has use cases that beat regular cash,

Tell me.

Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by stale2002 on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @06:30AM (#19562215)
Censorship resistant electronic, financial transactions.

The evidence shows that it is much easier to censor a credit card payment, or bank transaction, than it is to censor a crypto transaction.

Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by arcticbull on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @12:50PM (#19564913)
Which only matters if you're trying to do illegal things on an international scale. Locally, you've always got cash.
Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by stale2002 on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @01:24PM (#19565233)
There are lots of perfectly legal things that get censored all the time, by both the government and private companies.

Adult content is one area that comes to mind. If you run a business in this area, on the internet, which is perfectly legal, you will quickly find that every major financial institution refuses to do business with you.

Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by arcticbull on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @01:25PM (#19565250)
There are payment processors that cater to that market. They charge large fees (up to 20%) for card transactions, though that's actually due to the crazy-high chargeback risk. People's spouses tend to discover their subscriptions, then they declare it wasn't them, their card was stolen, and a chargeback follows.
Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by stale2002 on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @04:29PM (#19567001)
Indeed, that's my point.

If you do business in one of these controversial areas, then you will quickly find that you are being charged extremely high costs and/or kicked off of their network.

Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by arcticbull on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @05:15PM (#19567321)
They're not extremely high, they're the cost of doing business.
Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by stale2002 on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @05:33PM (#19567425)
And the world would be a much better place if it was harder to impose higher costs of doing business on controversial, but legal businesses.

Which is why I support solutions that undermine attempts by a couple monopolies to impose larger costs on legal, but controversial businesses.

Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by arcticbull on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @06:16PM (#19567703)
Fair, though this isn't the technology that'll solve that. You've just centralized the decision making to the PRC which controls more than 51% of hash power. All it takes is a strongly-worded memo from Beijing and they can censor payments and rewrite the blockchain.

That said, with $1.26 transaction fees + 1-2% to buy BTC vs. even 20% for a credit card in this high-risk MCC, the breakeven is ~$7, and while I'm not sure what adult content costs on a monthly basis, I'd imagine the fee difference isn't a whole lot.

It's also not an imposition, nobody is required to use credit cards. Adult content is largely and lucratively ad-supported. Some businesses choose to offer content on a subscription model like the NYT paywall, and some choose not to. I don't see anything inherently wrong with the status quo. The cost of doing business is being passed down. They accept credit cards because even at a 20% fee, it's in their interests to do so. If it wasn't they'd stop. Either way, they're recovering their fees from customers.

Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by stale2002 on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @07:28PM (#19568095)
I mean, buying a bunch of miners in order to 51% attack a network is significantly more difficult than making a phone call to a Visa or MasterCard executive.

It is also not enough to censor a singular Blockchain. You'd have to get the hardware to attack all the chains, because then people would just move to the other ones.

This is still not impossible. That's why I used the words "censorship resistant". But it is certainly much more difficult than a phone call to 2 or 3 executives who control the major financial companies.

This is proven by the fact that censorship just isn't happening on most Blockchains. The actual state of the network proves that it is difficult, because it isn't happening.

You can talk all you want about theoretical attacks, but those attacks aren't happening, so it works. Whereas there are many examples of the "phone call to Visa" that are happening right now.

Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by arcticbull on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @08:29PM (#19568382)
My understanding is 2 or 3 miners in the PRC have all that 51%, and in China, when Beijing says jump you say how high or you may end up escorted from your penthouse at the four seasons in Hong Kong to seek medical treatment on the mainland and never be heard from again (https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.nytimes.com/2017/01/31/worl...)
Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by arcticbull on Thursday April 04, 2019 @12:18PM (#19574066)
To circle back 80% of all hashpower is concentrated in 6 pools, 5 of which (>70%) are in the PRC. (https://news.bitcoin.com/chinese-mining-threatens-bitcoin/)
Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by stale2002 on Sunday April 07, 2019 @04:47AM (#19595629)
And yet, those pools aren't censoring anything.

They aren't stopping any transactions, and have never done so, in the 10 years that crypto has been around.

This is in comparison to visa and mastercard which censor people all of the time.

So for whatever reason that those pools aren't censoring anything, and have never done so, but the major finance companies are censoring transactions, is the reason why crypto is valuable.

Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by Semaphor on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @05:13AM (#19561909)
Transferring money from one continent to another.
Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by raverbashing on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @05:30AM (#19561980)
Calculate the full chain of costs then come back here with how it compares to Transferwise or other methods
Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by Semaphor on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @06:18AM (#19562172)
Well… Cost:

a) BTC-BTC Transfer: Only BTC transfer fee. Beats TransferWise by a large Margin.

b) BTC-USD: Depends on many variables, including if the receiving country taxes BTC to fiat. Considering how expensive transferwise is, it's probably a wash.

Speed depends on if GP literally meant Cash. If so, BTC is obviously far faster and easier as you still need to get you cash into your bank account. Otherwise… Transferwise takes a few hours, BTC 10-20 minutes I think?

Privacy: The Banks and TW know who sent how much to whom. With BTC everyone knows that A sent X to B, but not necessarily who A and B are. As this transaction is public forever, I'd probably prefer TW from a privacy perspective, this of course changes with something like Monero.

Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by arcticbull on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @12:34PM (#19564776)
Nobody takes BTC in exchange for goods and services, absolutely nobody. In this context it's at best an intermediate representation with huge FOREX risk. That means (a) is a false equivalence as unlike (b) it only represents a small slice of the transaction.
Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by alphast0rm on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @03:34PM (#19566471)
That's not true, there are large retailers that directly accept BTC, like Newegg [1] and Overstock [2]. There are also services like Bitrefill to purchase gift cards using various cryptocurrencies for use at places that don't directly accept BTC: Amazon, Ebay, Walmart, Best Buy, and Target to name a few of the 750+ supported [3].

[1] https://promotions.newegg.com/nepro/16-6277/index.html

[2] https://help.overstock.com/help/s/article/Bitcoin

[3] https://www.bitrefill.com/?hl=en

Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by arcticbull on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @03:37PM (#19566505)
There are more that did and stopped than do. And to your own point of the ones that do, the vast majority do so via intermediary like bitpay because they dont want BTC they just want money. The trajectory of acceptance has a negative slope. Even Overstock doesn't accept BTC on mobile according to their help page.

Further, since you've got to foot the transaction fee (~$1.50) instead of the merchant and the merchant has already padded their prices for a 3% credit card fee, you're getting royally screwed. I pay with my 2% cash back credit card, get all sorts of warranties and protections, and you pay 3% + $1.50 and get nothing but losing your ability to file your taxes with TurboTax because they dont support crypto on Form 8949.

Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by alphast0rm on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @04:27PM (#19566993)
> Nobody takes BTC in exchange for goods and services, absolutely nobody.

I was simply trying to show that your original statement was hyperbole, as there are clearly notable retailers that do.

Also as a consumer, I don't see why your point about intermediaries is relevant (barring the marginal price difference between them). If you are planning on purchasing something from a business you don't really care if they are using Intuit or Square to process credit cards transactions, just that they accept credit cards for payments.

Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by arcticbull on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @05:18PM (#19567342)
My point about intermediaries is that you are paying more to use Bitcoin than I am to use my credit card, and getting a lot less for it.

COGS: $10.00, retail after CC markup: $10.30. I get a 2% rebate, so I paid $10.09, and for that $0.09 I get a one-month interest free loan, chargeback abilities and numerous warranties.

COGS: $10.00, retail after CC markup: $10.30. You have to buy the $10.30 from an exchange for $10.51 (assuming 2% fee). You then pay another $1.26 for the BTC transaction and get back nothing, for a total of $12.07. That means your total fees paid are 23X the total fees I paid. No chargebacks, no warranties, no loan, 23X higher fees. Then, you have to report your cost basis to the IRS and can't do your taxes easily. That makes your payment method inferior for any normal, legal purchase. That's one of the reasons buyers don't want it. Sellers don't want it because it exposes them to enormous FOREX risk.

Yes, it's hyperbolic, however the fraction of businesses accepting BTC is already practically zero and falling, it's not unfair to round it to zero. Otherwise we would just be happy with Overstock.com gift cards as a medium of foreign exchange. After a 2% cash back rebate on a credit card their cost is negative.

Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by Semaphor on Thursday April 04, 2019 @11:18AM (#19573311)
Eh, if you really want to take cherry pick examples, let's take the lower 0,4% fee I pay to buy BTC. I get 0% cashback for my credit card (cashback is an exception in Germany, not the rule), and Coin Tracking Unlimited for one year is 0.037BTC (~$180.6525) instead of $185 paying with USD. And suddenly the point is 100% reversed and BTC is the clear winner and obviously far superior to Creditcards -.-
Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by arcticbull on Thursday April 04, 2019 @11:35AM (#19573543)
IMO I was picking a representative US example, but working one in Germany yields very comparable results. The difference is the interchange is capped 0.3% which means that the cash-back portion is irrelevant.

COGS: $10.00, retail after CC markup: $10.03. In Germany I would get a 0% rebate, so I would pay $10.03, and for that $0.03 I would get a one-month interest free loan, chargeback abilities and numerous warranties.

COGS: $10.00, retail after CC markup: $10.03. You have to buy the $10.03 from an exchange for $10.07 (assuming 0.4% fee). You then pay another $1.26 for the BTC transaction and get back nothing, for a total of $11.33. That means your total fees paid are 44X the total fees I paid. No chargebacks, no warranties, no loan, 44X higher fees. In Germany no tax liability is incurred AFAIK when using it as currency. That makes your payment method inferior for any normal, legal purchase. That's one of the reasons buyers don't want it. Sellers don't want it because it exposes them to enormous FOREX risk.

Companies that offer crypto discounts are unicorns. Why would they? It's more expensive and more risky to offer it. The only reason I can think of to offer a crypto discount is if you're not reporting to tax authorities like cash-only restaurants. Your one counter-example is by no means representative, and in Germany, you're even worse off than in the US in the average case, by double.

Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by Semaphor on Thursday April 04, 2019 @02:06PM (#19575303)
> Why would they? It's more expensive and more risky to offer it.

How? Risky? When the customer has literally zero way of doing a chargeback? And most businesses instantly transfer the received amount to cash, so there is no wallet complication.

> Sellers don't want it because it exposes them to enormous FOREX risk.

No, because the time they actually hold crypto is measured in seconds to fractions of them.

A streamer I watch allows you to donate with crypto and buy food for people. The Paypal way gives you less resulting money to buy food for people with because of tx fees. Crypto for them is safer and cheaper.

> In Germany no tax liability is incurred AFAIK when using it as currency.

I wish. You have to hold for 1 year, then whatever you do is tax-free. Before that, anything you do (incl. trading) counts for your income tax.

And FWIW, a) I don't buy anything with BTC, if anything I'd pay with ETH, Nano or any of the alts that have fast and cheap TXs but I'd buy things with a CC anyway because I find it too be simpler. b) Where I work the best tx fee we can get for CC Payment for 10€ is 0.395€

Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by arcticbull on Friday April 05, 2019 @01:26AM (#19579950)
The risk is in holding it for any length of time due to its wild fluctuations and the fact seller taxes are due based on the amount of the purchase at the time it happens, not when the crypto converts to fiat. If they convert it to fiat via payment gateway crypto barely factors into this for them doesn't it? If there was a gateway that accepted goats and gave sellers cash, I mean, it doesn't really matter to the seller. They never see the goats anyways.

Re: the streamer, I don't think you're doing the math right. With a 0.4% + $1.26 transaction fee, PayPal's 3% would break even at ~$45. Whether they buyer or the seller pay the fee is irrelevant, the fee is paid. Either the buyer asks for more or the seller sends less, the net is the same. The difference here is fixed vs. percentage fee payment which reaches a break-even point pretty high up there for most purchases.

I based my tax treatment implications on this article: https://www.bna.com/germany-reaffirms-crypto-n73014476891/ ("But when the digital currency is used as a means of payment, or when it’s exchanged or sold, it will be exempt from Germany’s 19 percent VAT.") but I guess the capital gains still need to be paid?

The alts have even more risk due to their even more wild fluctuations and dreadful past performance.

Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by raverbashing on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @06:40AM (#19562253)
USD-BTC and BTC-USD (or any currency) have a cost and a delay as well
Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by Semaphor on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @06:54AM (#19562315)
Yes, I mentioned that.
Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by xtracto on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @09:15AM (#19563028)
MXN to GBP : I can't do it.

BTC to BTC :I can do it.

Non of the fancy services allow me to send money from Mexico to the UK.

It is crypto or paying for SWIFT, Western Union or similar. With very high costs.

Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by arcticbull on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @12:28PM (#19564723)
Totally can, FairFX and TorFX (both UK-regulated money transmitters) will safely and securely make an MXN to GBP transfer for right around 2.5% and believe it or not Western Union is usually quite competitive. Next time check out cuex.com which compares options for you.

BTC is a nightmare. You have to find an exchange in Mexico (which won't run away with your money a la Quadriga) and they'll take 1-2% and sit on the transfer for a few days. Then you have to transfer from there to another exchange in the UK paying a BTC exchange fee, then cash out in the UK, they'll take another 1-2%. In the week the exchanges have been camping on your money if you ever see it again, the forex risk is astronomical as it regularly swings +/- 20% weekly. Then due to the inevitable change in value of BTC during the week your transfer takes, you now have reporting obligations to your local tax authorities in BOTH Mexico AND the UK. This may require hiring an accountant to resolve which adds yet another mess of fees.

Pay a service 2-2.5% and be done with it or:

1-2% fee to Exchange 1 + a few days FOREX risk + the current BTC fee of $1.26 + 1-2% fee to exchange 2 + the risk anyone in the chain is going to ruin you because they're totally unregulated fly-by-night operations then learn the nuances of both Mexican and UK tax law in regards to capital gains.

This is a common crypto shill talking point. It's been thoroughly disproven that crypto is better for international remittences than existing solutions. It's a solved problem.

Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by xtracto on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @02:24PM (#19565864)
> Totally can, FairFX and TorFX (both UK-regulated money transmitters) will safely and securely make an MXN to GBP transfer for right around 2.5% and believe it or not Western Union is usually quite competitive. Next time check out cuex.com which compares options for you.

I tried both of them and I can't (I am living in Mexico). I don't understand why you think BTC is a nightmare. For me, living in Mexico, and dealing with MXN and GBP (my brother is in Northen Ireland) it has worked wonders.

You are assuming that Bitcoin exchanges in Mexico are unregulated, when they are VERY regulated. You are making negative assumptions for every Crypto step while making positive assumptions for every step in your scenario. I does not make sense.

Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by arcticbull on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @03:48PM (#19566610)
I'm not sure what you mean by it not working. I haven't tried but they're a regulated system, are you sure it's not on your end? Have you been reporting your capital gains and losses over the course of the transaction on both sides? If not the tax authority may have some serious questions for you.

And why wouldn't I make negative assumptions of crypto [1], [2], [3], [4]. There's a scammer at every single level and being intentionally resistant to censorship, control and authority makes that impossible to stop. It's designed to support scams.

Remember the man who lost $420,000USD while attempting to use Quadriga to exchange USD for CAD when moving to Canada using exactly the approach you're describing? [0] It's like asking me why I've got negative associations with the "Titanic II." Something about what happened to the first Titanic.

Last, based on my research, it appears Mexican crypto exchanges aren't regulated yet, and that regulators are about to shut them all down [5]. "Because cryptocurrencies are such complicated technologies, the argument goes, average citizens can’t understand how they work and should not, therefore, be allowed to buy them." I'm 100% with your regulators.

[0] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019-02-09/software-...

[1] https://www.theglobeandmail.com/business/article-gerald-cott...

[2] https://www.chepicap.com/en/news/4366/roubini-on-tether-it-s...

[3] https://www.theverge.com/2018/3/22/17151430/bankruptcy-mt-go...

[4] https://www.forbes.com/sites/cbovaird/2019/03/22/95-of-repor...

[5] https://coincenter.org/entry/new-regulation-would-effectivel...

Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by xtracto on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @08:10PM (#19568308)
> I'm not sure what you mean by it not working. I haven't tried but they're a regulated system, are you sure it's not on your end? Have you been reporting your capital gains and losses over the course of the transaction on both sides? If not the tax authority may have some serious questions for you.

It is actually very simple: A lot of these services do not provide services in Mexico. Really, the passive aggressive comment is not necessary.

I assume that you live in the UK or the USA. Usually what happens is that people that live there live in a "technological bubble" where all of those first-world services are available. But most of them do not have service in most of other countries.

I work in a B2B payment company and have had the opportunity to deal with these kind of issues. Believe me that cross-country payments is nowhere a solved problem. The blockchain technology definitely has something on it if used correctly.

Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by arcticbull on Thursday April 04, 2019 @02:29AM (#19569787)
Sorry, it wasn't intended to be passive-aggressive, I was curious what the issue was, since by reading their documentation it should work. The tax question was a separate issue with using crypto, not an implication it was related. You didn't really address any of my criticisms however including the pending shutdown of crypto exchanges in Mexico or how reporting requirements factor into your cost calculations.

Either way, another legitimate option for you to consider is an Interactive Brokers account which has great forex options (interbank rates) and Mexico is a supported country. They charge a commission of 0.2 basis points (0.2/100 of a percent) with a minimum of $2USD per order. There really are a lot of legitimate options that don't require cryptocurrency. People have been trading currencies for hundreds of years.

There's a great writeup on the way you can do it here: https://gfmasset.com/2018/09/better-than-transferwise-saving...

For interest you can even do USD-CAD exchanges with zero spread via Norbert's Gambit (https://medium.com/young-wild-and-cheap/the-norberts-gambit-...)

Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by chx on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @07:18PM (#19568052)
> MXN to GBP : I can't do it.

Both https://www.currenciesdirect.com/ and https://www.smartcurrencyexchange.com can do it.

Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by xtracto on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @08:16PM (#19568342)
Currencies Direct: https://ibb.co/BTzRGq3 nope

SmartCurrencyExhcange: https://ibb.co/4RGXvbc also nope

They don't have MXN/Mexico, along with a lot of other currencies from Latin America, Africa and Asia

Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by chx on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @08:40PM (#19568429)
Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by dractori on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @01:28PM (#19565272)
Paypal?
Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by dzhiurgis on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @06:55PM (#19567905)
Interactive Brokers easily beats Transferwise
Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by chx on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @10:55PM (#19568961)
IB is a stock and similar trading platform and not a transfer company. What am I missing?
Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by dzhiurgis on Thursday April 04, 2019 @07:15AM (#19570895)
You can do forex at interbank rates. Major gotcha is to have bank accounts in both countries with your name. Just fund your acc from one country, do forex, withdraw in another.

https://gfmasset.com/2018/09/better-than-transferwise-saving...

Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by mruts on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @06:01AM (#19562107)
Buying drugs, avoiding taxes, money laundering, etc.
Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by PhilippGille on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @05:40AM (#19562025)
Micropayments on the web without users having to create an account. For example paying a few cents for reading a news article, without an account on the news site and without the high fees for a payment processor. (Via Lightning Network)

Example news site: https://yalls.org Example browser extension for great UX: https://github.com/wbobeirne/joule-extension

Or even nanopayments for single API calls, between the browser and a server or between servers.

Example pay-per-call web service / API: https://lightning.ws (disclaimer: my project, based on another project by me: https://github.com/philippgille/ln-paywall)

Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by mruts on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @06:04AM (#19562118)
Seeing how slow and expensive both BTC and ETH are, micropayments aren’t really viable, tbh.

The mining and gas fees for BTC and ETH respectively are going to be higher than the cut a payment processor would take.

The one advantage that you might be alluding to is that bitcoins are divisible into satoshi’s, which are much more granular than cents.

Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by PhilippGille on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @06:28AM (#19562210)
I was specifically talking about the Lightning Network, a second layer that facilitates Bitcoin's smart contract capabilities to enable off-chain payments via so called payment channels. There's no mining involved during transactions in the channel - only for opening and closing a channel, making the transactions almost instant. Thanks to proper routing you can reach most of the peers even with a single channel. It even adds some privacy because it uses onion routing, and the payments are not less secure because each off-chain transaction can be used as valid on-chain transaction should either party wish to do so, closing the channel.

There's much more to it, many smart people have put a lot of thought into LN, so I recommend reading the whitepaper and other documentation about it.

Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by arcticbull on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @12:59PM (#19565000)
Not enough thought. With 7tx/sec it will take 35 years to open a channel for everyone on earth and another 35 years to close it assuming nobody is born. I believe that's in the white paper, actually. Either way you'll be paying $1.26 to open a channel and another $1.26 to close it, so paying Stripe 2.9% + $0.30 makes the fee break-even point vs having a wallet on your micropayments server funding with $76, any less, Stripe wins.
Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by PhilippGille on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @01:38PM (#19565351)
Search for "channel factories" - it allows multiple channels to be opened with a single on-chain tx.

And looking at how many people use a custodial Bitcoin wallet today (e.g. Coinbase), many will probably use custodial LN wallets as well, with only the wallet service requiring a channel. Not recommending this of course.

Also, my use case was regarding micropayments (e.g. for reading a news article) and nanopayments (e.g. for an API call). That's below $0.30. If you're now going to say that you could top up some balance (like $20) and just deduct a cent from that for every payment, that was exactly the other point of my use case: No accounts required, neither in the DB of the news or API service, nor in the DB of some payment processor that must keep your credit card data.

So it's not just about fees, it's also about privacy.

Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by arcticbull on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @01:42PM (#19565397)
To your point, micropayments aren't a limitation of the existing financial system. People just don't want them. The issue is that people have a limited capacity to make decisions [1], and having to decide if every single site they visit or article they want to read is "worth" the $0.005 just sucks. It's the reason that Netflix and Apple Music is so successful while buying individual songs and videos via the iTunes store is cheaper in the long run, and probably even in the short run. The real value is being able to roll up the content into a monthly pass model and handling the payouts not as micropayments but what they are -- accounting. Has there ever been a successful micropayments system?

The reason we don't have micropayments isn't an accounting issue, fee-related or a technical issue -- or even a privacy issue -- it's a human biology issue. IMO hooking it up directly to a wallet without topping off isn't going to change that, especially since you still have to top off the BTC wallet regularly as you get paid in real currency. Boat-anchoring two things that are complex and people don't really want (crypto + micropayments) isn't going to make the two work all of a sudden.

The only way to really solve the news business model with something other than ads is a Netflix-for-news. I hope that Apple News becomes that because newspapers deserve to exist.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Decision_fatigue

Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by Semaphor on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @06:22AM (#19562187)
While I don't agree that crypto is currently generally usable for micropayments, I'm not sure the current ~$0.045/transfer fee for ETH is really more than a payment processor would take.

And that's if you want really fast confirmations.

Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by gruez on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @10:13AM (#19563460)
With Bitcoin I recently sent a $30 transaction (non lightning) for around $0.05 in fees. That's 0.1%. It wasn't "low fee" either - it was confirmed within the next block. Bitcoin transactions are charged by the byte, so I could have sent a million dollars for $0.05 as well.
Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by arcticbull on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @01:01PM (#19565014)
Fees are $1.26 right now, domestic ACHs are largely free. What was your FOREX risk? Did you figure in that you now have to report your transaction on Form 8949, can no longer use TurboTax and will have to spend hours figuring out your reporting obligations or paying an accountant? If you're just going to break the law the rest of the calculus probably doesn't matter as much.
Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by russelldc on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @08:58PM (#19568507)
As of 2019, you can definitely use TurboTax to report Bitcoin transactions. And if you use Coinbase, there's deeper integration there, as well.
Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by arcticbull on Thursday April 04, 2019 @02:20AM (#19569760)
TurboTax Deluxe I assume? The up-sell cost does still have to be factored in, though it's good to know, thanks!
Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by xtracto on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @09:24AM (#19563097)
That hasn't been my experience. I pay some services with BTC via CryptoPay and is really fast.

What is the alternative? Card? 2% + .3 fee. That's expensive. ACH? takes 5 days to be processed.

What is the fast, cheap digital alternative?

Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by phamilton on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @10:04AM (#19563384)
Venmo and the like. Any ledger will work just fine if it's built for fast payments. That ledger doesn't need to be distributed and/or decentralized. Solving trust is an oversold benefit of BTC in my opinion.
Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by gruez on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @10:20AM (#19563513)
>Venmo and the like.

Works great if you're settling transferring between friends doesn't work for buying/selling goods[1], otherwise you get charged the same 3%. Also, the "free" transaction aspect is most likely a loss leader.

[1] https://help.venmo.com/hc/en-us/articles/217532097-Can-I-use...

Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by thinkmassive on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @11:13AM (#19563992)
Solving trust is the only benefit of Bitcoin, but I think you’re underestimating the importance of financial sovereignty.
Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by arcticbull on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @01:02PM (#19565020)
Lack thereof is currently working for 7.5 billion people. Bitcoin works for basically nobody.
Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by thinkmassive on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @02:47PM (#19566055)
If you think present financial systems are working well for every inhabitant on the planet, you probably spend a lot of time in a very comfortable bubble.

Besides, talking worked well for thousands of years, what use would humanity have for the Internet? /s

Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by arcticbull on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @03:34PM (#19566475)
Well, that depends, is the internet worse than writing letters? Because bitcoin is worse than money.

The reality is that for the rest of the world bitcoin is missing the initial distribution problem. Nobody in Venezuela has bitcoin. How are they going to get it? If they can trade with other countries, they would just get USD and be better off. If not, then net, it's zero sum. That's really all there is to it. Even after that, it's like cash if cash had a $1.50 transaction fee for handing it to your buddy. Not exactly tenable in countries where thats basically a daily wage.

Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by thinkmassive on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @04:19PM (#19566928)
You might have a point if that were true, but it’s not... https://twitter.com/btcven

Edit: ...and LN transactions are essentially instantaneous and free. Also you can’t program cash without a middleman.

Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by arcticbull on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @05:08PM (#19567273)
Nothing about the twitter account refutes what I'm saying about Venezuela. There's a certain quantity of BTC there already, and it's not nearly enough to replace all the money down there. They can't mine any because any big clusters of compute get nationalized [1], [2] and rewards are going down. That means they can either trade with outsiders, and in that case, doing so for USD they'd be 5X better off over the last two years. Or they trade with each other, in which case, it remains zero sum. Unless they are somehow more efficient at mining BTC than the Chinese who control more than 51% of the hashpower?

Nothing in that twitter account refutes that in Venezuela the minimum wage is $6.70USD per MONTH [3] so a single transaction fee is nearly a WEEK of wages. And that's up from $2.20 per MONTH so a single transaction fee was THREE WEEKS of wages.

LN transactions are "instantaneous and free" once you open a channel ($1.50) and lock in your balance, then close out your channel ($1.50). Again, two weeks wages.

Bitcoin is not a solution to the problems of Venezuela. Changing the government is. They're totally disconnected.

[1] https://bitcoinist.com/venezuela-now-requires-bitcoin-miners...

[2] https://www.newsbtc.com/2018/05/31/officials-in-venezuela-be...

[3] https://www.reuters.com/article/us-venezuela-politics-wage/v...

Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by thinkmassive on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @05:34PM (#19567429)
You claimed "Nobody in Venezuela has bitcoin." I provided evidence of a group making a difference in Venezuela using Bitcoin, so it does refute your previous statement.

I pity someone who is so offended by a simple technology.

Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by arcticbull on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @06:10PM (#19567673)
Again, if they can trade with foreigners, they're better off with real currencies. I'm not offended, I'm exasperated. Bitcoin has been a solution in search of a problem for a decade, and each time it stumbles on an idea it's proven not to be effective and it's off to the next goalposts. This time it's Venezuela for some reason. They have real problems, and they need real solutions, not magic internet beans. If they really wanted to help the Venezuelans they'd do it using the best system, not their system -- this helps them, and hey, if the Venezuelans are better off for it, I guess that's fine too.
Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by thinkmassive on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @06:30PM (#19567783)
You're using Venezuela as an example of the success of "real currencies" hahaha

Look at Bitcoin's yearly lows, and tell me more people aren't finding it useful every year. Again, YOU mentioned the Venezuela example, and IT IS BEING USED THERE. I never claimed it would save that country, nor have I heard anyone else make that claim. Clearly some people there find it more useful than other alternatives to their hyperinflationary fiat currency.

Bitcoin doesn't care about Venezuela nor any other specific use case. It keeps existing because people keep running the software. You can deny this, but there's no point being exasperated over it. Just let it go and concentrate on whatever you do care about.

But don't go around claiming fiat currencies are the final solution when situations like Venezuela are happening right before our eyes.

Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by arcticbull on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @06:49PM (#19567876)
I don't claim Venezuela's currency is an example of success. I'm saying that their currency's failure is a result of the failure of their government, and even waving a wand and switching everyone over to BTC (which again, the initial distribution problem) won't magically make their government work. They can't control BTC but they sure can control the populace. They'd make it illegal and beat everyone with BTC until they handed it in to the central government, and smash everyone's computers. Bitcoin's weakness there is still a rubber hose. I'm saying that trading existing BTC between themselves is a zero-sum problem since the total quantity of BTC and the total quantity of Bolivars (hence the total value) remains exactly the same within Venezuela, and mining isn't an option due to nationalization and low yields.

Trading with other countries opens up many different options for storing value like fiat currencies backed by 'stable' governments like AUD, CAD, NZD, USD, EUR -- or assets like gold, equities, real estate, etc. Each of which would have stored value 5X better than BTC over the last 2 years. However, the real issue remains, you have to trade to obtain either these assets or BTC and nobody wants to trade anything for Venezuelan Bolivars because they in turn don't believe they'll get anything for them. That won't be solved until the government is replaced.

Until the government is replaced any BTC "solutions" for the Venezuelans are efforts to legitimize BTC and increase the value of the holdings of the "helpers," not to really solve the problems on the ground there. If they were trying to help, they'd just raise money for NGOs.

Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by thinkmassive on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @08:10PM (#19568313)
What does any of that have to do with Bitcoin?
Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by arcticbull on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @08:35PM (#19568406)
Ah, we’re on the same page! It solves nothing for the Venezuelans.
Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by quickthrower2 on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @05:16AM (#19561923)
Anonymous transactions at a distance.
Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by icey on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @07:48AM (#19562561)
Sometimes it's nicer to send money than it is to authorize someone to take money from an account, especially if you're unsure of the recipient's ability or desire to protect that account information (credit card number, bank account info, etc). For me, Bitcoin has effectively replaced cashier's checks.
Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by arcticbull on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @12:50PM (#19564922)
Popmoney, Venmo, Square Cash all allow you to do that without the massive FOREX risk and tax reporting requirements.
Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by icey on Thursday April 04, 2019 @03:16PM (#19576066)
Cool, and I use some of those too; but there have been cases _for me_ where BTC has been a lot easier.
Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by navigatesol on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @06:38AM (#19562248)
>Bitcoin is a perfectly functional means of financial exchange

Okay. So where is the Venture Capital going, and where will the returns stem from?

Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by wheelerwj on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @09:49AM (#19563261)
how are those things related? do all mediums of financial exchange require venture funding? does all crypto qualify as fincial exchange?