News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by arcticbull on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @12:50PM (#19564913)
Which only matters if you're trying to do illegal things on an international scale. Locally, you've always got cash.
Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by stale2002 on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @01:24PM (#19565233)
There are lots of perfectly legal things that get censored all the time, by both the government and private companies.

Adult content is one area that comes to mind. If you run a business in this area, on the internet, which is perfectly legal, you will quickly find that every major financial institution refuses to do business with you.

Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by arcticbull on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @01:25PM (#19565250)
There are payment processors that cater to that market. They charge large fees (up to 20%) for card transactions, though that's actually due to the crazy-high chargeback risk. People's spouses tend to discover their subscriptions, then they declare it wasn't them, their card was stolen, and a chargeback follows.
Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by stale2002 on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @04:29PM (#19567001)
Indeed, that's my point.

If you do business in one of these controversial areas, then you will quickly find that you are being charged extremely high costs and/or kicked off of their network.

Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by arcticbull on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @05:15PM (#19567321)
They're not extremely high, they're the cost of doing business.
Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by stale2002 on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @05:33PM (#19567425)
And the world would be a much better place if it was harder to impose higher costs of doing business on controversial, but legal businesses.

Which is why I support solutions that undermine attempts by a couple monopolies to impose larger costs on legal, but controversial businesses.

Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by arcticbull on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @06:16PM (#19567703)
Fair, though this isn't the technology that'll solve that. You've just centralized the decision making to the PRC which controls more than 51% of hash power. All it takes is a strongly-worded memo from Beijing and they can censor payments and rewrite the blockchain.

That said, with $1.26 transaction fees + 1-2% to buy BTC vs. even 20% for a credit card in this high-risk MCC, the breakeven is ~$7, and while I'm not sure what adult content costs on a monthly basis, I'd imagine the fee difference isn't a whole lot.

It's also not an imposition, nobody is required to use credit cards. Adult content is largely and lucratively ad-supported. Some businesses choose to offer content on a subscription model like the NYT paywall, and some choose not to. I don't see anything inherently wrong with the status quo. The cost of doing business is being passed down. They accept credit cards because even at a 20% fee, it's in their interests to do so. If it wasn't they'd stop. Either way, they're recovering their fees from customers.

Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by stale2002 on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @07:28PM (#19568095)
I mean, buying a bunch of miners in order to 51% attack a network is significantly more difficult than making a phone call to a Visa or MasterCard executive.

It is also not enough to censor a singular Blockchain. You'd have to get the hardware to attack all the chains, because then people would just move to the other ones.

This is still not impossible. That's why I used the words "censorship resistant". But it is certainly much more difficult than a phone call to 2 or 3 executives who control the major financial companies.

This is proven by the fact that censorship just isn't happening on most Blockchains. The actual state of the network proves that it is difficult, because it isn't happening.

You can talk all you want about theoretical attacks, but those attacks aren't happening, so it works. Whereas there are many examples of the "phone call to Visa" that are happening right now.

Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by arcticbull on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @08:29PM (#19568382)
My understanding is 2 or 3 miners in the PRC have all that 51%, and in China, when Beijing says jump you say how high or you may end up escorted from your penthouse at the four seasons in Hong Kong to seek medical treatment on the mainland and never be heard from again (https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.nytimes.com/2017/01/31/worl...)
Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by arcticbull on Thursday April 04, 2019 @12:18PM (#19574066)
To circle back 80% of all hashpower is concentrated in 6 pools, 5 of which (>70%) are in the PRC. (https://news.bitcoin.com/chinese-mining-threatens-bitcoin/)
Re:A16Z is re-registering as a financial advisor, renouncing... by stale2002 on Sunday April 07, 2019 @04:47AM (#19595629)
And yet, those pools aren't censoring anything.

They aren't stopping any transactions, and have never done so, in the 10 years that crypto has been around.

This is in comparison to visa and mastercard which censor people all of the time.

So for whatever reason that those pools aren't censoring anything, and have never done so, but the major finance companies are censoring transactions, is the reason why crypto is valuable.