News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Taxpayers Should Never Subsidize Stadiums by ajross on Saturday January 05, 2019 @03:16PM (#18833953)
How would one propose to make it illegal for an elected government to finance construction of a public building? I mean, yeah, sports stadiums are wasteful. But how would you draft that such that it wouldn't eliminate libraries and museums?

I mean, I agree with you in spirit but at the end of the day the whole point of a democratic government is that it's empowered to work to better our collective lives. And that has to include dumb-but-popular boondoggles as offerings to attract football teams.

Re:Taxpayers Should Never Subsidize Stadiums by wongarsu on Saturday January 05, 2019 @04:07PM (#18834269)
Sure, allow the government to construct sports stadiums. The government can then make it free for any sports team to use (though preferential treatment of any one team has to be prevented), and since it's a public building any revenue generated from ticket sales goes towards operating the building, with leftovers going back to the government (just like libaries, museums etc). There's nothing really wrong with that. Naming rights also obviously stay with the government, anything else would be silly.
Re:Taxpayers Should Never Subsidize Stadiums by ahallock on Saturday January 05, 2019 @05:57PM (#18834877)
There is something really wrong with that. The government is taking on concerns outside its core responsibilities. Sports are non-critical entertainment and that's something the government should not be creating. We can discuss regulations, zoning, and other ways government could be involved, but a lot of people don't use these stadiums, and I'm sure they'd prefer their tax money and gov resources be spent on more crucial infrastructure.
Re:Taxpayers Should Never Subsidize Stadiums by LukeShu on Saturday January 05, 2019 @06:26PM (#18835057)
Don't all of those arguments also apply to libraries and museums?
Re:Taxpayers Should Never Subsidize Stadiums by wongarsu on Saturday January 05, 2019 @07:24PM (#18835397)
Libraries and museums serve the purpose of educating the masses, which is something the government should be and is involved in (mainly because an educated populace is crucial for democracy)
Re:Taxpayers Should Never Subsidize Stadiums by sbuk on Sunday January 06, 2019 @05:56AM (#18837705)
And sport doesn’t provide education? Sport teaches self discipline and resilience, surely to traits that are essential to democracy.
Re:Taxpayers Should Never Subsidize Stadiums by around_here on Sunday January 06, 2019 @10:07PM (#18842465)
so does math, or public gyms. All without the funneling of even more public money in to already wealthy hands.

You want stadiums? Sure. Public gets the profits with the owner renting the space.

Re:Taxpayers Should Never Subsidize Stadiums by Brakenshire on Saturday January 05, 2019 @04:12PM (#18834300)
There’s a huge corpus of jurisprudence on this in the EU, where such funding is illegal:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/State_aid_(European_Union)

Re:Taxpayers Should Never Subsidize Stadiums by twelvechairs on Saturday January 05, 2019 @04:23PM (#18834356)
Doesnt stop them giving land for free and supporting infrastructure though. Which can be a huge part of the cost. Aalianz Arena (munich) is a good example
Re:Taxpayers Should Never Subsidize Stadiums by Brakenshire on Saturday January 05, 2019 @04:36PM (#18834419)
It’s not a terrible thing to improve transport infrastructure for a part of the city. Similarly I was reading that the council local to Tottenham’s new stadium are improving public squares around the area, but they’re spending only £30m relative to a stadium cost of £850m. And it is public squares which are being improved.

Governments can usually spend to improve general resources around a project, but not contribute to the project itself. With the idea of preventing market distortion from subsidy and a race to the bottom between different states.

I’m surprised they can give land for free, I’d have thought that would fall foul of the legislation.

Re:Taxpayers Should Never Subsidize Stadiums by xfitm3 on Saturday January 05, 2019 @03:47PM (#18834144)
I don’t think funding is the problem. It’s misappropriation and lack of oversight. I was involved in the construction of two stadiums and the money is unlimited during construction. Very wasteful.
Re:Taxpayers Should Never Subsidize Stadiums by paulie_a on Saturday January 05, 2019 @03:37PM (#18834073)
Pretty easy, private corporations are different than public non profit organizations. Football stadiums may weasel into non profit. But it is absolutely a for profit organization. I've never been to a library that requires an ultra expensive tickets. Museums have a reasonable rate for expenses in conjunction with donors.

It's a two part but simple questions for lawmakers: are you a profit making entity or are you not. if you are, please explain the benefits you will provide to the taxpayer, and it better wow me.

If it does go forward there should be contractual guarantees on jobs and tax revenue with fines for not producing.

Cities don't need to attract football teams. Football teams should be begging cities to allow them there.

Re:Taxpayers Should Never Subsidize Stadiums by ianai on Saturday January 05, 2019 @04:40PM (#18834447)
On jobs, I’m unconvinced that stadiums create many jobs. At least at the stadiums I’ve lived near, they seemed to be fully staffed with far fewer people than other social venues - say casinos (though I don’t see a US government making a casino) or even a mall.

I’d rather localities invest in community centers, libraries, museums, etc than stadiums.

Re:Taxpayers Should Never Subsidize Stadiums by GordonS on Saturday January 05, 2019 @05:53PM (#18834839)
There will be a lot of jobs during construction, but it's perhaps worth noting that those will not necessarily be for locals. In operation, I agree that thr number of jobs is likely fairly low, and mostly low wage.
Re:Taxpayers Should Never Subsidize Stadiums by ianai on Sunday January 06, 2019 @11:02AM (#18838937)
Those construction jobs are invalid for inclusion because they’re temporary unless the building is going to be destroyed and rebuilt regularly. The only jobs created that can be included in the decision to build or not are the long term jobs.
Re:Taxpayers Should Never Subsidize Stadiums by celticninja on Saturday January 05, 2019 @04:54PM (#18834517)
Or you could make teams pay for their own stadiums. They take the revenue so why shouldn't they? The equivalent is Amazon requiring local government to provide them with automated warehouses for them to relocate to (or remain in) that locality.
Re:Taxpayers Should Never Subsidize Stadiums by hammock on Saturday January 05, 2019 @03:47PM (#18834143)
>dumb-but-popular

Do you have a recent example of a new football stadium that had popular support among the constituent taxpayers? My memory can only recall ones opposed by the general public.

Re:Taxpayers Should Never Subsidize Stadiums by seanmcdirmid on Saturday January 05, 2019 @03:56PM (#18834193)
I remember the Seattle vote back in the mid-90s, we clearly rejected it but they went ahead with it anyways.
Re:Taxpayers Should Never Subsidize Stadiums by rnd0 on Saturday January 05, 2019 @04:46PM (#18834485)
I lived there then; as I remember it was put to the ballot two or three times -and when it kept getting voted down they basically just said "screw it" and built it anyway.
Re:Taxpayers Should Never Subsidize Stadiums by seanmcdirmid on Saturday January 05, 2019 @06:07PM (#18834938)
They passed a hotel occupancy tax by council vote alone to build it if I remember correctly...and the tax is still going on today. I'm far from a anti-tax conservative, but I feel like this is the wrong thing to be taxing for.
Re:Taxpayers Should Never Subsidize Stadiums by dwighttk on Saturday January 05, 2019 @04:33PM (#18834399)
Cowboys stadium in Arlington. It was funded by a referendum, so it at least had popular support among local voters.
Re:Taxpayers Should Never Subsidize Stadiums by positr0n on Saturday January 05, 2019 @04:01PM (#18834220)
Don't they vote on them? In my hometown of Arlington TX there have been two stadiums* built with part public financing in the last decade. Both were ballot issues in a normal election. I thought that's how it was done everywhere.

* Jerry Jones's $1B monstrosity for the Dallas Cowboys was narrowly approved around 2008 and the new Texas Rangers stadium was voted on this past year, not sure the margin or cost.

Re:Taxpayers Should Never Subsidize Stadiums by smt88 on Saturday January 05, 2019 @04:03PM (#18834235)
To my knowledge, they're not on ballots in most cities.
Re:Taxpayers Should Never Subsidize Stadiums by prostoalex on Saturday January 05, 2019 @07:20PM (#18835371)
Los Angeles has a new stadium planned for Inglewood with all of the risk borne by developers who then get to enjoy a cut of the future tax earnings

https://www.welikela.com/proposed-inglewood-football-stadium...

Re:Taxpayers Should Never Subsidize Stadiums by jahewson on Saturday January 05, 2019 @03:23PM (#18833987)
Simple: make them free to enter.
Re:Taxpayers Should Never Subsidize Stadiums by jimhefferon on Saturday January 05, 2019 @03:32PM (#18834045)
Museums aren't free to enter.
Re:Taxpayers Should Never Subsidize Stadiums by uabstraction on Saturday January 05, 2019 @03:40PM (#18834097)
Many public ones are
Re:Taxpayers Should Never Subsidize Stadiums by abrowne on Saturday January 05, 2019 @04:08PM (#18834280)
And some non-public ones, like the Minneapolis Institute of Art https://new.artsmia.org/
Re:Taxpayers Should Never Subsidize Stadiums by blakeley on Saturday January 05, 2019 @03:39PM (#18834091)
Perhaps they should be.
Re:Taxpayers Should Never Subsidize Stadiums by prostoalex on Saturday January 05, 2019 @07:23PM (#18835386)
Libraries are, but in larger cities like LA or SF they tend to evolve into coworking spaces for the homeless, at which point they cease to be public spaces that people feel comfortable taking their families to.
Re:Taxpayers Should Never Subsidize Stadiums by matt4077 on Saturday January 05, 2019 @10:53PM (#18836461)
Why? Do homeless people eat children?
Re:Taxpayers Should Never Subsidize Stadiums by surfmike on Saturday January 05, 2019 @03:35PM (#18834057)
Might be a way to do it with a tax on private stadium construction. Allow deducting (private costs - all public subsidies). So for any local subsidies you receive, you have a commensurate increase in taxes.

Similar problems exist with subsidies for factories, although at least those are producing something at the end of the day.

Re:Taxpayers Should Never Subsidize Stadiums by stale2002 on Saturday January 05, 2019 @10:24PM (#18836366)
> But how would you draft that such that it wouldn't eliminate libraries and museums?

That's easy! You just make the law only apply to stadiums.

I am sure it would be perfectly possible to include a detailed description of what a stadium is, in the law.

Re:Taxpayers Should Never Subsidize Stadiums by JumpCrisscross on Saturday January 05, 2019 @03:19PM (#18833965)
> How would one propose to make it illegal for an elected government to finance construction of a public building?

State constitutional amendments requiring a referendum.

Re:Taxpayers Should Never Subsidize Stadiums by ajross on Saturday January 05, 2019 @03:30PM (#18834035)
Well, sure. That works if these things are unpopular. They're not. That's the problem.

Lost in the discussion of how many hundreds of million dollars St. Louis lost in its relationship with the Rams is the fact that the city loved that team and the stadium construction was a huge deal and a big political victory.

The underlying flaw in the reasoning here is that it's all based on a personal feeling that "My government is spending my tax dollars on something I don't like but other people do". Well... yeah. That's the cost of living under a government. The government's job is fairness, not pleasing everyone.

Re:Taxpayers Should Never Subsidize Stadiums by JumpCrisscross on Saturday January 05, 2019 @06:14PM (#18834980)
> That works if these things are unpopular. They're not.

I don’t have a comprehensive statistic, but almost every time I read about stadium subsidies being put to a vote (or a poll), the funding is rejected [1][2][3][4].

[1] http://www.golocalprov.com/politics/golocal-statewide-poll-j...

[2] https://profootballtalk.nbcsports.com/2016/07/28/poll-finds-...

[3] https://www.ktnv.com/news/political/ktnvrasmussen-poll-voter...

[4] https://amp.smh.com.au/politics/nsw/voter-revolt-on-stadiums...

Re:Taxpayers Should Never Subsidize Stadiums by kodablah on Sunday January 06, 2019 @12:24AM (#18836714)
Hrmm, most of the time I've seen them on ballots locally they are approved.
Re:Taxpayers Should Never Subsidize Stadiums by logifail on Saturday January 05, 2019 @04:19PM (#18834340)
>> the city loved that team and the stadium construction was a huge deal and a big political victory

Can you quantify "the city loved"?

I'm sure the construction was "a huge deal", large construction projects almost always are.

Something professional politicians choose to support != something that a majority of voters would choose to support, given the chance.

Re:Taxpayers Should Never Subsidize Stadiums by cmorgan31 on Saturday January 05, 2019 @04:54PM (#18834518)
You can’t quantify love or sentiment unless you accept brand loyalty and subjective measures. It seems like a silly thing to request but perhaps that is your point. If these were ballot initiatives for funding similar to public transport you would see a bit more rejections from anyone outside of the city centers. If we go by popular vote you will likely see most cities vote to keep their teams because we’ve all been raised to think of them as ours despite owning nothing.
Re:Taxpayers Should Never Subsidize Stadiums by logifail on Saturday January 05, 2019 @05:28PM (#18834681)
>> If we go by popular vote you will likely see most cities vote to keep their teams

Source?

>> because we’ve all been raised to think of them as ours despite owning nothing.

Not sure why there should be a connection between public funding for teams and teams staying in any particular city.

If all cities stopped public funding for privately-owned sports teams, the teams would still need a place to call "home".

The owners would just be slightly less rich.

Re:Taxpayers Should Never Subsidize Stadiums by cmorgan31 on Saturday January 05, 2019 @05:59PM (#18834890)
I’m not implicitly agreeing that a connection should exist, but I’m also not going to pretend it doesn’t. Sports are a huge part of American culture and is one of the least contentious elements. I don’t have a source which empirically states “most cities would vote for the team” other than brand loyalty statistics which don’t correlate perfectly to this conversation. I’m attempting to discuss the less tangible aspect of this arrangement and why it is a bit of a radical variable in anyone trying to address this lopsided agreement. If you discount sentiment you aren’t even attempting to see why sports teams appeal to people and why they haven’t revolted at the thought of subsidizing them. I am not speaking in favor of subsidizing them or maintaining a status quo but instead I am trying to help quantify a city’s love of a team. I won’t even broach the topic of college stadiums and athletic fees but it might be one area that does have research on this topic.
Re:Taxpayers Should Never Subsidize Stadiums by SpikeDad on Saturday January 05, 2019 @04:37PM (#18834437)
The underlying flaw is that the public allows their politicians to spend their money on personal political victories.

There's no payback for politicians that waste tax money either explicitly or via tax breaks. Nor for them misstating benefits or outright lying about them.

So yea if politicians around the country are not held responsible then complaining is indeed a waste of time.

Re:Taxpayers Should Never Subsidize Stadiums by golemiprague on Saturday January 05, 2019 @03:29PM (#18834032)
The government should be limited to provide things which are better as a monopoly like some roads or electric grid and for things that are essential and the market fails to provide from some reason. And yes, museums are not necessarily essential and in many cases should not be provided by the government but rather by a private entity.
[dead]
Re:Taxpayers Should Never Subsidize Stadiums by existencebox on Saturday January 05, 2019 @03:36PM (#18834067)
This is such an absurd comment I have to counter it.

The library near me is wonderful, and my wife regularly goes there just because of how peaceful it is and how broad their e-book collection is for her bus rides. I'm in a normal no-name township, nothing particularly wealthy. Same goes for the library where I grew up, and from visits back, it's in about the same state. Volunteer work there was integral to my growing up, and accessibility to the books there was 100% of the reason I became such an avid reader.

Just because you don't like libraries, and you may have seen some bad ones, doesn't mean you should seek to remove one of the remaining bastions of government services that purely serve to better the quality of life accessible to all. (I'd cite PBS as well)

I'd say the same about museums. To abscond from a public duty to educate and provide information, we religate ourselves to the unfortunately trend of a citizenship lacking in critical thinking and inquisitiveness.

If govt spending is such a key issue, it's mind-boggling that one would focus on such trivial non-%'s as opposed to the largest allocations, of which there are MANY well-discussed inefficiencies.

Re:Taxpayers Should Never Subsidize Stadiums by AceyMan on Saturday January 05, 2019 @06:12PM (#18834965)
Countering anecdotal experience:

I live in a wealthy (high COL, at least) area, and I see what the GP referred to.

Housing here is very expensive, ergo, living spaces are small, so I tried to go to the library to get some "real studying" done on my own time — every time the city library was slap full (all booths and chairs occupied) with 95% homeless folk.

I love and appreciate city run libraries but IME they are directly suffering from the lack of social support and affordable housing to that portion of the population.

(me: lives in West Los Angeles/Beach Cities area)

Re:Taxpayers Should Never Subsidize Stadiums by spunker540 on Saturday January 05, 2019 @05:39PM (#18834737)
My first job was in a superb suburban library in the Midwest which was open from 9am-9pm (except on sundays which was noon-5pm).

However I now live in NYC, the city that never sleeps, and can’t believe that local libraries in Manhattan are generally open 10am-6pm making them hard for students to visit if they have extra-curricular activities and nearly impossible for anyone working to ever take advantage. The hours alone seem to indicate the libraries are mostly for the retired or unemployed.

Re:Taxpayers Should Never Subsidize Stadiums by masonic on Sunday January 06, 2019 @06:06PM (#18841327)

  I'm in a normal no-name township
... which generally means it attracts fewer homeless.
Re:Taxpayers Should Never Subsidize Stadiums by tylersmith on Saturday January 05, 2019 @04:36PM (#18834426)
You're getting heavily downvoted but at least here in san jose what you're saying is true. Many libraries are now literal homeless shelters. My wife is a librarian and her libarary just became a shelter despite the constant problems that are the homeless. She has to clean human shit off the childrens' computers but they keep inviting this mess in.
Re:Taxpayers Should Never Subsidize Stadiums by krapp on Saturday January 05, 2019 @04:46PM (#18834483)
Getting rid of public funding for libraries because homeless people seek shelter there only deprives the homeless of shelter (which they have a right to, however badly they smell) and it deprives the public of the amenities public libraries provide. It doesn't solve any problems.

If so many people have such a problem with homeless people in libraries, maybe their city needs more homeless shelters that serve the same needs. I mean, they camp out under bridges and overpasses as well, should we demolish the roads too?

Re:Taxpayers Should Never Subsidize Stadiums by tylersmith on Saturday January 05, 2019 @05:00PM (#18834548)
I didn't say anything about funding, just that in San Jose at least libraries are absolutely homeless shelters.
Re:Taxpayers Should Never Subsidize Stadiums by krapp on Saturday January 05, 2019 @05:13PM (#18834601)
Fair enough, I was replying to you and the GP.
Re:Taxpayers Should Never Subsidize Stadiums by tokai on Saturday January 05, 2019 @05:09PM (#18834588)
It is a bad argument against having public libraries whether it's true or not.
Re:Taxpayers Should Never Subsidize Stadiums by masonic on Sunday January 06, 2019 @04:58AM (#18837542)
Plus, San Jose allows porn to be viewed on the public computers without even privacy screens.
Re:Taxpayers Should Never Subsidize Stadiums by krapp on Saturday January 05, 2019 @03:38PM (#18834086)
>Maybe we should. These days, public libraries are little more than homeless shelters.

Odd, I've been in plenty of public libraries, and I've been able to access a number of useful services in them, and none have been homeless shelters, either literally or figuratively.

> and printed books are largely irrelevant in today's world anyway

No they're not, no more than movies, television, radio, or any other form of media that exists despite digital media.

Maybe your personal, limited experience doesn't scale up to a general view of human culture as well as you think it does.

Re:Taxpayers Should Never Subsidize Stadiums by SpikeDad on Saturday January 05, 2019 @04:43PM (#18834464)
Jeepers what a cruel and ill-informed person you are. As someone who works in a public library in some places the public library is the only institution left to be available for the benefit of the underrepresented folks like homeless.

Our print book circulation remains strong regardless of other electronic services we provide. There are millions of books that never get e-book versions.

Most museums and public libraries are indeed operated with non-profit organizations responsible to the local government authority (including mine).

You should get yourself into a library as soon as possible.

Re:Taxpayers Should Never Subsidize Stadiums by KingMachiavelli on Saturday January 05, 2019 @03:33PM (#18834051)
Libraries provide dozens of services to those in low-income areas. Lots of people utilize the library for internet service.
Re:Taxpayers Should Never Subsidize Stadiums by dangerbird2 on Saturday January 05, 2019 @04:16PM (#18834325)
As it turns out, homeless people can't easily keep laptops on them and afford to hang out at Starbucks all day. Public libraries give them and other low income people opportunities to develop skills and education, and electronic resources to find a long-term career that can take them out of poverty.
Re:Taxpayers Should Never Subsidize Stadiums by prostoalex on Saturday January 05, 2019 @07:48PM (#18835520)
If that is truly a massive trend (and it seems like it would be reasonably easy to measure), the current setup of libraries is not that conducive to employment preparation (mine still features books on Macromedia Flash and Office XP).

One can probably run it more efficiently as an Internet access room at a local community center, with access to printing/faxing/tutoring/resume building and other services.

And, just as you said, some zip codes will benefit from this setup more than others.

Re:Taxpayers Should Never Subsidize Stadiums by scarface74 on Saturday January 05, 2019 @04:36PM (#18834420)
As it turns out, homeless people can't easily keep laptops on them and afford to hang out at Starbucks

And heck, with what happened recently, neither can Professional people who are minorities and look like they don’t belong....

https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2018/apr/16/arrest-of-tw...

Re:Taxpayers Should Never Subsidize Stadiums by i_am_proteus on Saturday January 05, 2019 @03:38PM (#18834080)
I am sorry you have had bad experiences with public libraries. My local (suburban) public library does not resemble a homeless shelter. The population therein usually consists of younger (15-25) and older (50+) people who are generally clean and quiet. If physical books were irrelevant, publishers would all be out of business, and also the books I'm looking for in the library would never be unavailable due to already being borrowed by another user.
Re:Taxpayers Should Never Subsidize Stadiums by impendia on Saturday January 05, 2019 @03:45PM (#18834132)
> public libraries are little more than homeless shelters

This was totally false at each of the five public libraries that I've visited over the last two years.