Anyone who doesn't see that is going to be caught off guard when the money runs out, the buybacks stop, and the market crashes "overnight". In reality, the market is crashing right now, it's just hidden behind trickery designed to artificially inflate the value of the market. It's like if I lost my job but kept financing my same lifestyle out of my savings account. Eventually that savings will run out and reality will hit like a ton of bricks, and no one will have seen it coming.
[1] https://www.fool.com/investing/general/2014/12/05/share-buyb...
[2] https://www.fool.com/investing/2018/12/09/why-investors-shou...
1. Distribute cash back to shareholders via buybacks or dividends
2. Increase R&D spending on new initiatives
3. Acquisitions
Buybacks are at least much more tax effective than issuing dividends. Large acquisitions tend to fail and I imagine it could be hard for an established company to regain the "growth mindset" of a startup.
Should a company load up on debt or pursue buybacks way above intrinsic value? Probably not. But, if a company is paying a 4% dividend, and can borrow at 3.5%, buying back stock reduces the dividend payout, and the company avoids lowering the dividend per share (something that is considered sacrilegious in America).
It's also essentially an arbitrage opportunity at 0.5% gain. The company is borrowing money, buying its own shares, and then using less than 100% of the dividend it would have paid on those shares to pay the interest on the debt, and having the rest left over.
That revenue stream goes away as interest rates rise -- you can't arbitrage 4% ROI against 4.5% borrowing costs -- but it takes time before that has to happen. If the company borrowed by issuing ten year bonds, they're effectively still paying the original (e.g. 3.5%) interest rate until the bonds mature.
At that point they either have to re-borrow the money (which only makes sense if interest rates are still low) or re-issue the shares. But even if they re-issue the shares at that point, they're still better off than having not done it, because they still have the ten years worth of arbitrage profits.
This makes even more sense for the companies that have a pile of cash sitting around making <1% returns, because then the arbitrage profits are even higher (and continue to exist even if interest rates rise more), and they don't even have to pay anything back at the end.
Could it be that the expectation for all companies, everywhere to grow at a constant rate is not reasonable?
The difference being that your example would at least enrich the soil and potentially improve future yields (like R&D), while buybacks are essentially just propping up the stock price with no fundamental contribution to future success.
Big tech companies hoard cash because much of their business model depends upon being able to buy up potential competitors before the competitor can take over their market, and they need liquidity to do it because things move very fast in tech and delaying even a couple weeks can mean the price goes up $100M. That's why you see purchases like Instagram for $1B, YouTube for $1.5B, DoubleClick for $3B, or WhatsApp for $19B. And they often make rates of return far, far in excess of the purchase price of these - YouTube is estimated as being worth $75B now. They're not holding cash for the sake of holding cash, they're holding cash as a punctuated-equilibrium investment strategy where they spend a lot when the right opportunity comes along and sit back and wait for the right opportunity to come along the rest of the time.
They didn't just write a check for $19B.
https://qz.com/393093/the-mysterious-fund-in-the-desert-that...
Too much cash can also lead to behavioral finance issues down the road as well such as companies making ill-fated acquisitions such as Microsoft did under Ballmer's helm.
This is true. It is always better to return money to shareholders if there aren't any avenues of future growth.
But, on the flip side there are companies which are knowingly using their portfolios to create similar situations. A good example is Broadcom. They have cutback on R&D spending. Using huge amount of debt to grow via acquisitions and share buyback.
Why are buybacks much more tax effective? Is this due to the way the accounting is done on them?
https://mebfaber.com/2016/05/02/much-dividends-costing/
>>> In a taxable account dividends could have cost you anywhere from 0.3% to over 3.0% in returns PER YEAR since 1974.
Even better is that as long as the shareholder holds, they have increased value, but can defer taxes.
The worst case scenario is a company with declining market share, that is cash flow negative, and is buying back shares with debt because the executives set their bonuses based on an earnings per share target.
I strongly suggest novice investors is to look at shares outstanding for a company over time. Just as one could claim share buybacks mask a companies problems, you can make a case that issuing new shares steals money from existing shareholders. Indeed, there are public companies which have been around 10+ years and stay afloat solely by creating new shares and have generated 0 return for long term shareholders.
When a company buys their own stock, there are simply fewer shares free-floating, in the hands of owners. The company's profits therefore are divided among a smaller group, and each share receives a larger percentage of those profits.
Imagine an extreme case where McDonald's buys every single share but one. That remaining stock-owner will therefore own 100% of McDonald's, and get every last profit made from the world's obese.
All this requires no ongoing buybacks from the company. You do it once, and because the denominator shrinks, each stock appraises. After that, as long as profits remain stable, earnings per share will, and so should, absent external factors, the stock price.
Technically true, but the company had a choice about how to return profits to investors and chose the buyback over the dividend, so the remaining owners don't get a larger percentage of profits unless the company also issues a dividend. It's generally an either-or these days.
Imagine an extreme case where McDonald's buys every single share but one. That remaining stock-owner will therefore own 100% of McDonald's, and get every last profit made from the world's obese.
Not all McD's stock is publicly traded. Moreover, a fair amount of McD's stock cannot be legally sold due to it being owned by ESOPs. That being said, the remaining stock owner would not own 100% of McDs, they would own 1 share of McDs (and 100% of then-outstanding stock). There would still be several million shares authorized and in reserve that could be sold or re-issued at a moment's notice. The decision to sell/re-issue those shares is made by the company, not the owner, and the fact that he theoretically owns 100% of the company at that time is meaningless because he owns only a fractional percent of the company's authorized shares and thus has no actual power.
Who, if anyone, owns the shares that are held in reserve?
Surely they can’t be used to vote, unless they are held as an asset by the company in the same way the company might hold shares in other companies as assets.
Do they exist on the balance sheet?
While in reserve, they are neither assets or liabilities or really even anything other than a hypothetical number. Many companies used to disclose the number of shares in reserve, so that shareholders were aware of the potential dilution of their investment, but in an era of buybacks, that has become less popular.
>a company buys their own stock... [and] each stock appraises
That lines up exactly with what I've described. If you're saying I'm wrong, you're going to have to be more specific because I don't see where we disagree.
There is nothing inherently wrong with performing stock buybacks, from a cashflow perspective it is equivalent of paying a dividend, in fact it can be prudent from a tax perspective. You did imply that it is a continuous process when you suggested:
> when the money runs out, the buybacks stop
Performing a stock buyback based off the proceeds of debt in a down market makes perfect sense actually because you can significantly reduce your cost of capital if you believe your future cashflow will be strong enough to continue making coupon payments. You can issue debt at say 3.5% and buy out shares that require 7% cost of capital and as long as interest rate and credit risk don't drastically deteriorate significantly increase the value of your company from a simple capital markets operation.
I guess you assumed I was arguing that companies who do buybacks must dump all of their money into buybacks, which I certainly did not mean to imply. Big difference between "able to" and "must".
The point is, if you as a company are trying to manipulate your share price in a down market by buying back stocks and you choose to continue buying your stock until the market rises again, you're taking the risk that you will run out of money before the stock market rises again. At that point your share prices fall no matter what.
No, wrong again. People take issue with your representation of stock buybacks as "short-term market manipulation". The major effect of buybacks comes not (just) from the increase in demand, but from lowering the denominator future profits are divided by. It directly increases earnings per share.
I never said companies must spend all their money on stock buybacks, yet that argument is being used to paint me like an idiot.
I never said every company who does buybacks is doing it to manipulate the market, yet that argument is being used to paint me like an idiot.
I never said anything about dividends or profits or ownership, in fact I literally said I'm just criticizing companies who do buybacks in order to increase their share price during a down market, yet the argument that "not everyone who does buybacks is manipulating the market" keeps getting thrown at me like that thought has never crossed my mind. I know you think I'm an idiot but I did say words that have meaning and I used those words intentionally to convey the exact meaning that society has agreed those words are supposed to mean. It is not my fault you intentionally choose to ignore those words and their meaning.
I've had enough of it. Either read my words then comment or don't comment at all. I'm sick of this, defending my comments against people who only have bad faith and want to pretend that they're smarter than me because they purposefully misread my comments.
Your entire argument is based on an intentional misreading of words I never said and in direct response to the comment where I argued against that intentional misinterpretation and I'm not engaging with this any more.
Shares issued to investors are considered "outstanding" shares. Shares bought back from investors reduce the number of outstanding shares, and usually the bought-back shares go into the pool of "reserved" shares to be re-issued later.
Stock of a corporation is not an indicator of % ownership, especially not for publicly traded companies or companies with multiple classes of stock. % ownership isn't particularly relevant to the corporate form of business; you're probably thinking of the partnership or hybrid business forms (including LLCs) where, due to the pass-through nature of the form, everything flows to the owners on a % basis.
For corporations, very little flows through to the owners directly, so % ownership matters very little on a practical basis. While allocations of dividends are generally based (directly or indirectly) on % ownership of outstanding stock, the stock that carries the most voting rights (i.e., control rights) usually has the lowest dividend participation rights (i.e., profit rights).
The certificates says how many shares the person owns, not the percentage of the company they represent.
No, a corporation cannot own itself.
Edit: Quote from your link
By reducing the number of outstanding shares, a company's earnings per share (EPS) ratio is automatically increased – because its annual earnings are now divided by a lower number of outstanding shares.
Would you, please, apply your point to the original statement, namely:
they would hold the same percentage of profit and control that their stock certificate was originally issued for.
Then, pray tell, in your opinion, when a company buys back one of two remaining shares, making you the sole owner of the company, does this
a) Have absolutely no effect on your share
b) makes your share more valuable, because it has become a rare collectors' item
or
c) doubles the future percentage of profits your receive, from 50% to 100%, because irrespective of any profits distributed via dividends or not, the question was only about the share of those profits and not their absolute amount, and even under that strange misreading, even the profits you receive in absolute terms would double under the typical assumption of "all else being equal" and "nobody is really that stupid"
B) No, because there are still plenty of authorized shares being held in reserve by the company that it can reissue.
C) Theoretically yes, because dividends are allocated pro rata on a % basis of outstanding stock (assuming 1 class of common stock). If there are multiple classes, or preferred stock, or the company reissues shares, or a million other things, then this may or may not still be true.
In the real world, the company would simply reduce the size of the dividend so his take-home is the same.
It’s just the opposite of issuing stock. Even when done with borrowed money, it is simply replacing one source of funding (investment) with another (debt). When interest rates are low, the latter becomes attractive. If/when they rise, trouble may ensue. But for a profitable company, the normal, entirely adequate, reaction would just be the reverse transaction, retiring the remaining debt with newly issued stock.
How is a declining market threatening a profitable company that, at some point in its past, bought back shares? There are no on-going financial commitments a company has that are tied to the daily fluctuations of the stock market.
Even if they have taken on debt to finance a buyback, a future decline of the stock market has no bearing on them, except to possibly make it less lucrative to issue new stock.
As long as they make a profit in their core business, and those profits allow them to pay the 3% or 4% interest on any debt, they are completely save. A rise in interest rates does have a meaningful impact here, yes. But (a) interest rates have been rather stable for going on 40 years now, and this is a well-known risk that is an obvious part of any decision to take on debt. It can, and often is, also be hedged by agreeing to fixed interest rates, or hedging.
The unsustainable part is giving investors the impression that, while the Dow plunges 500 points, your stock remains stable. Then when your buybacks stop and your shares plummet with the rest of the market, it gives the impression that something suddenly happened and your company is in a dire situation.
Either you keep buying shares to inflate the value (which gets expensive) or you stop and accept that your shares will go down (which looks worse now that your stock price has not declined with the rest of the market). Either way, if you're using buybacks to keep your stock price up in a market that's down, you're going to get burned eventually.
If they want to reward shareholders, they can issue a dividend. If they think the company will grow, the can invest in growth. The "argument" made is that companies think their stock is undervalued by the market and want to capture that price growth. Why would so many companies think their stocks are "undervalued" in 2018 after a 10 year bull market?
Before 1982, we viewed buybacks as market manipulation and it was illegal [1]. In reality, companies do this in order to increase their stock price and earnings per share, the two things for which executives are typically compensated. If you take the same earnings and divide over fewer shares, you have magically increased your EPS without improving the actual business.
[1] https://www.forbes.com/sites/aalsin/2017/02/28/shareholders-...
Equity carries more risk, because stockholder are paid after bondholder in the event of bankruptcy. Therefore, equity investors (stockholders) demand higher returns than lenders. Depending on a few other factors, borrowing is the better option to raise operational capital than issuing stock. Conversely, when your need for capital decreases, you no longer want to pay for it.
And just as you may repay a loan (early) in that case (if you are debt-financed), you may buy back shares, if you are financed by equity.
You're betting that your company's financials and stock price will improve, so you get debt to buy back the stock. It's no different than an individual getting into debt to buy say Nvidia stock because they think the price of the stock will keep rising. This is always a mistake in the long term, and it should be discouraged - for both individuals and companies.
It's even worse when you see companies like Apple with tens or hundreds of billions of dollars in cash getting debt to buy back its stock. Come on. This is a disaster waiting to happen. We shouldn't have to wait until the economy slows down/a recession arrives to figure this one out. It's clearly dysfunctional/a bad thing to have in an economy.
The wisdom of privately buying stock with debt stems from a consideration of the risks involved. But a company is going to shoulder its risk of operations, no matter how you turn it.
I also don't get your criticism of Apple's practice: It's well understood that it happened for tax considerations, and surely them holding billions of dollars in cash cannot, in anyway, be worse than not having billions of dollars in cash? In any case, the current tax "amnesty" seems to be in the process of resolving that particular accounting nightmare of yours.
A smarter investor would acquire large stakes in companies capable of issuing debt and lobby the boards to perform buybacks, allowing a form of corporate raiding with less capital invested and dramatically more reward.
Both of these strategies rely on the greater fool hypothesis, but in a period with historically low interest rates and an implicit hedge that the fed would stimy any wide spread defaults it's a valid investment strategy.
That said, I also do not see "reward shareholders" as necessarily sinister. Many companies this late in the cycle are sitting on a LOT of cash (income from operations) and do not see enough opportunities to invest in long term growth. Thus they are using it to pay dividends or buy their own stock. In fact, "reward shareholders" is exactly what the company should be doing in such case and neither of this is a sign of the problem. Problems may still happen, but I doubt about buybacks being the primary cause. My 2c.
Using debt instead of equity is a rational thing for companies to do if debt is really cheap.
The 'higher stock price' as a result of the buybacks is effectively an adjustment of the equilibrium to that fact: the company is taking advantage of cheap sources of financing.
If the company is doing sneaky things like hiding problems, or if the lenders are failing to do due diligence .... then yes, this can be a problem.
Or of companies are over-leveraging - again a potential problem.
But tapping into cheap debt, even combined with stock-buybacks - this could definitely be characterized as an intelligent kind of financial engineering, I don't think that it should be in and of itself viewed as suspicious or negative.
It's just the CFO doing their job, mostly.
Also ... stocks are quite expensive right now by most measures, so I'm not sure how much buybacks make sense in that context at this moment.
This article is from 2012 but illustrates the point (it's also why I left the company, they restructured debt, issued a dividend which, even though they're publicly traded they were(are?) 75% held by Carlysle Group so it was basically a self bonus, then cut employee benefits) https://www.forbes.com/sites/abrambrown/2012/07/11/booz-alle...
Anytime a company pays a dividend AND increases their outstanding debt in the same time period, you could draw ths conclusion that they financed the dividend using debt.
Check out the financials for Vector group...
https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/VGR/financials?p=VGR
On the summary page you can see they pay about a 15% dividend. On their income statement you can see their net income is less than $100 million USD. On the balance sheet, you can see the long term debt has increased by a serveral hundred million over the last few years. That dividend sure sounds like it is financed by debt, although you'd have to dig into what is really going on to know for sure.
https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-09-05/apple-ret...
I'm curious why this would be done on margin. Are they using call options then for their own stock?
Total corporate debt has swelled from nearly $4.9 trillion in 2007 as the Great Recession was just starting to break out to nearly $9.1 trillion halfway through 2018, quietly surging 86 percent, according to Securities Industry and Financial Markets Association data. Other than a few hiccups and some fairly substantial turbulence in the energy sector in late-2015 and 2016, the market has performed well.
"Reward shareholders" is code for stock buybacks - the practice of a company using ultra-low interest financing to buy its own stock on margin. It's an unsustainable way to manipulate the price/earnings ratio, and thereby make a company look like a better buy than it is.
Buybacks in turn have been a major source of funding for the stock market's unprecedented run:
https://seekingalpha.com/article/4156578-buyback-bubble-will...
I suspect those looking for a soft landing here haven't considered the reversible nature of this debt-fueled stock market rally. Nor have they considered the amplifying effect of debt on the upside and downside.