It's also essentially an arbitrage opportunity at 0.5% gain. The company is borrowing money, buying its own shares, and then using less than 100% of the dividend it would have paid on those shares to pay the interest on the debt, and having the rest left over.
That revenue stream goes away as interest rates rise -- you can't arbitrage 4% ROI against 4.5% borrowing costs -- but it takes time before that has to happen. If the company borrowed by issuing ten year bonds, they're effectively still paying the original (e.g. 3.5%) interest rate until the bonds mature.
At that point they either have to re-borrow the money (which only makes sense if interest rates are still low) or re-issue the shares. But even if they re-issue the shares at that point, they're still better off than having not done it, because they still have the ten years worth of arbitrage profits.
This makes even more sense for the companies that have a pile of cash sitting around making <1% returns, because then the arbitrage profits are even higher (and continue to exist even if interest rates rise more), and they don't even have to pay anything back at the end.
Could it be that the expectation for all companies, everywhere to grow at a constant rate is not reasonable?
The difference being that your example would at least enrich the soil and potentially improve future yields (like R&D), while buybacks are essentially just propping up the stock price with no fundamental contribution to future success.
Big tech companies hoard cash because much of their business model depends upon being able to buy up potential competitors before the competitor can take over their market, and they need liquidity to do it because things move very fast in tech and delaying even a couple weeks can mean the price goes up $100M. That's why you see purchases like Instagram for $1B, YouTube for $1.5B, DoubleClick for $3B, or WhatsApp for $19B. And they often make rates of return far, far in excess of the purchase price of these - YouTube is estimated as being worth $75B now. They're not holding cash for the sake of holding cash, they're holding cash as a punctuated-equilibrium investment strategy where they spend a lot when the right opportunity comes along and sit back and wait for the right opportunity to come along the rest of the time.
They didn't just write a check for $19B.
https://qz.com/393093/the-mysterious-fund-in-the-desert-that...
Too much cash can also lead to behavioral finance issues down the road as well such as companies making ill-fated acquisitions such as Microsoft did under Ballmer's helm.
This is true. It is always better to return money to shareholders if there aren't any avenues of future growth.
But, on the flip side there are companies which are knowingly using their portfolios to create similar situations. A good example is Broadcom. They have cutback on R&D spending. Using huge amount of debt to grow via acquisitions and share buyback.
Why are buybacks much more tax effective? Is this due to the way the accounting is done on them?
https://mebfaber.com/2016/05/02/much-dividends-costing/
>>> In a taxable account dividends could have cost you anywhere from 0.3% to over 3.0% in returns PER YEAR since 1974.
Even better is that as long as the shareholder holds, they have increased value, but can defer taxes.
1. Distribute cash back to shareholders via buybacks or dividends
2. Increase R&D spending on new initiatives
3. Acquisitions
Buybacks are at least much more tax effective than issuing dividends. Large acquisitions tend to fail and I imagine it could be hard for an established company to regain the "growth mindset" of a startup.
Should a company load up on debt or pursue buybacks way above intrinsic value? Probably not. But, if a company is paying a 4% dividend, and can borrow at 3.5%, buying back stock reduces the dividend payout, and the company avoids lowering the dividend per share (something that is considered sacrilegious in America).