News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by jacek on Thursday December 13, 2018 @05:01AM (#18671162)
Big corps love to brag about "adding jobs", but don't like to brag about the "tax incentives" they are getting. There are usually huge costs for the whole community.

Austin tax incentives for Apple seem to be relatively small [1], but Foxconn factory in Wisconsin is an extreme case. I highly recommend the Replay All podcast episode on this [2][3]

[1] https://www.statesman.com/news/20120901/austin-council-oks-8...

[2] https://www.gimletmedia.com/reply-all/132-negative-mount-ple...

[3] https://www.theverge.com/2018/12/6/18128133/foxconn-deal-wis...

Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by sschueller on Thursday December 13, 2018 @05:08AM (#18671186)
I saw this video about LA a few days ago and it is very sad how these tax incentives are ruining entire states. [1]

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RWTic9btP38

Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by usermac on Thursday December 13, 2018 @10:26AM (#18672926)
Oh, I saw that too! Did the link come from HN? Can't recall but I was shocked.
Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by christopherwxyz on Thursday December 13, 2018 @09:10AM (#18672373)
If one state didn't offer a tax break, then another would and win the business. There are 50 states, and most of them compete for businesses with tax incentives fairly competitively.
Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by rectang on Thursday December 13, 2018 @09:46AM (#18672607)
This is only true because there are always officials in some other state willing to take bribes (in the form of campaign or allied PAC contributions).

It is possible that the bribe-for-tax-breaks exchange actually provides benefit for the community, but that's not necessary for the transaction to take place.

Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by kalleboo on Thursday December 13, 2018 @09:23AM (#18672453)
This is why the EU has laws against this kind of race to the bottom between nations
Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by purple_ducks on Thursday December 13, 2018 @07:46PM (#18677488)
> This is why the EU has laws against this kind of race to the bottom between nations

No, it doesn't.

Every country in EU sets it's own corporate, sales & income tax rates. as well as _EVERY_ other rate.

Every country in the EU can & does offer incentives & future tax payment agreements to companies who meet certain conditions. These are not inter-EU agreements nor do they need prior approval by any EU establishment.

Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by biztos on Thursday December 13, 2018 @10:18AM (#18672844)
Somebody better tell Ireland...
Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by ovatsug25 on Thursday December 13, 2018 @09:39AM (#18672561)
Can you elaborate on these laws?
Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by kalleboo on Thursday December 13, 2018 @10:50AM (#18673151)
Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by bunnycorn on Thursday December 13, 2018 @01:36PM (#18674779)
And so far... nothing has happened but yellow journalism.

Apple is always "going to pay", but they never did (and wouldn't make sense in any way), and Ireland also haven't paid and it doesn't look like it is.

Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by cenal on Thursday December 13, 2018 @10:19AM (#18672851)
There is another great video that goes into detail on his Louisiana is trapped in a tax incentive hell because of how they award these credits:

https://youtu.be/RWTic9btP38

Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by jpadkins on Thursday December 13, 2018 @06:13AM (#18671443)
it's weird to frame net new revenue as a "huge cost the whole community"

Taking less money from someone who is building a business in your area is not a cost. They have a choice on where to build, and tax burden is one of many factors in that choice.

Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by dmos62 on Thursday December 13, 2018 @06:36AM (#18671557)
I see what you're saying, but, to paraphrase the article, giving a billion dollar company an 8.6 million tax break when you're shutting down social programmes can be a tough pill to swallow.

On a parallel note, I'd like to underline just how good the tech giant has it. Since it can move anywhere, you have to give it excessive gifts for him to come to you. So the giant gets those rewards, simply because he's a giant.

Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by ricardobeat on Thursday December 13, 2018 @06:42AM (#18671579)
Why is it tough? The choice is not between those 8.6m and the discounted taxes, it is between that and _zero_. Revenue doesn’t come out of thin air.
Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by mikeyouse on Thursday December 13, 2018 @03:05PM (#18675529)
Neither do costs.. The concern is that adding a huge new "customer" to the community without adding any additional revenue can be a losing proposition. The roads, sewers, power lines, schools, hospitals etc. all see increased demand and in extreme situations, the municipality sees zero extra money to pay for it. So the existing "customers" in the community see degraded service to make way for an outside organization.
Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by minikites on Thursday December 13, 2018 @07:02AM (#18671668)
That's not the choice either. How about no tax breaks for companies, we enforce existing corporate taxes on those companies, and we raise the marginal income tax rate on very high earning individuals?
Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by rayiner on Thursday December 13, 2018 @07:07AM (#18671702)
At the state and local level, that just means companies will leave your state and go somewhere else. In a globalized world, the same thing is true for countries. There is a reason France has an effective 11% corporate tax rate: https://www.npr.org/2017/08/07/541797699/fact-check-does-the... (Chart 2).

If you want to pay for the safety net, do what Europe does and tax middle class people who can't just move to a lower-tax jurisdiction. E.g. in Germany, the 42% tax bracket (just shy of the top 45% bracket) kicks in at around $70,000, and there is a 20% VAT.

Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by perfmode on Thursday December 13, 2018 @07:37AM (#18671855)
The fundamental problem is that capital is permitted to cross borders, but people are not. Not in the same way.

So, corporations can vote with their feet, but people cannot.

Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by rayiner on Thursday December 13, 2018 @08:21AM (#18672083)
The U.S. and the Schengen Area each comprise regions of 300-400 million people where people are free to move internally. You would think that would create a similar pressure to reduce internal income taxes to attract residents, but it does not. People, unlike corporations, have roots in places and by and large don't want to move to chase lower tax rates.
Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by perfmode on Thursday December 13, 2018 @08:24AM (#18672107)
Corporations don’t have to physically move when they move. They just file paperwork elsewhere.
Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by rayiner on Thursday December 13, 2018 @08:26AM (#18672120)
That's not really true. You can't just decide to be an Irish company if you have no presence in Ireland. The wave of corporate inversions in the U.S. was accompanied by lots of companies moving their headquarters (and their top executives) to Switzerland, the U.K., etc.
Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by perfmode on Thursday December 13, 2018 @06:18PM (#18677041)
Tim Cook doesn't need to live in Ireland to benefit from its tax code.
Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by rayiner on Thursday December 13, 2018 @06:56PM (#18677255)
Income from capital gains is taxed at the rate of where the person lives. Tim Cook is a great example: it was reported that one of his recent bonuses was taxed at 50%.

Not that many people, even ones who make a lot of money, can take advantage of various tax avoidance measures. (That’s why e.g. getting rid of the preferential treatment of capital gains would raise less tax money than getting rid of the mortgage interest deduction.) CEOs mostly cannot, unless they run investment companies.

Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by perfmode on Thursday December 13, 2018 @07:07PM (#18677316)
My point is that Apple can take advantage of Ireland for tax purposes but Tim Cook doesn’t need to live in Ireland. The corporation enjoys benefits not conferred to people. This is why there is consternation and conflict around Apple’s repatriation of capital.
Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by minikites on Thursday December 13, 2018 @08:19AM (#18672072)
https://www.theguardian.com/inequality/2017/nov/20/if-you-ta...

>Only about 2.4% of US-based millionaires change their state of residence in a given year. Interstate migration is actually more common among the US middle class, and almost twice as common among its poorest residents, who have an annual interstate migration rate of 4.5%.

Companies follow people, not the other way around.

Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by bunnycorn on Thursday December 13, 2018 @01:43PM (#18674839)
You are totally right.

45% tax bracket at $70K?

That's cute.

In my country (Portugal, which is also in the Eu), it kicks right in the 40.5k€ for 45%.

And we have a VAT of 23%.

https://www.economias.pt/escaloes-de-irs/

Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by unethical_ban on Thursday December 13, 2018 @10:58AM (#18673231)
Then punish the corporations that abandon countries to avoid taxes.

Life and society is about the people. Corporations shouldn't be respected like people.

Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by gok on Thursday December 13, 2018 @12:17PM (#18673985)
…and much higher social insurance taxes.
Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by 6cd6beb on Thursday December 13, 2018 @10:54AM (#18673197)
>do what Europe does and tax middle class people who can't just move to a lower-tax jurisdiction

Well, that's why Europe is blanketed in riots right now.

Disenfranchised people enraged at the governing concept of "taxing middle class people who can't just move to a lower-tax jurisdiction"

Taxing the hell out of foreign goods would just mean the company now plays a two pronged game - manufacturing where the least regulation is present, and selling at the country with the highest price point who doesn't outright refuse to let you extract their nation's wealth.

It's a tricky problem but your answer to it is untenable unless you want people to riot more.

Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by moorhosj on Thursday December 13, 2018 @11:19AM (#18673462)
>Well, that's why Europe is blanketed in riots right now.

Can you provide a source for this claim? I know of the riots in France (a country well known for civil disobedience/riots), but haven't heard of the entire continent being "blanketed".

Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by apatters on Thursday December 13, 2018 @08:16AM (#18672051)
Tech giants can't go just anywhere. They need to locate their offices in cities which have large, highly educated, tech savvy workforces (or at least the infrastructure to relocate, satisfy and sustain those workforces).

This acts as a check on just how much of a tax break a municipality is able to give them, as public funds are needed to support that infrastructure. Austin, Seattle and Culver City seem to be striking the right balance.

Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by mkirklions on Thursday December 13, 2018 @08:35AM (#18672168)
>This acts as a check on just how much of a tax break a municipality is able to give them, as public funds are needed to support that infrastructure.

Well I suppose its Apple, so when they do cronyism, it must be okay. /s

Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by Latteland on Thursday December 13, 2018 @09:58AM (#18672697)
I haven't heard of any tax breaks in Seattle here.
Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by QuotedForTruth on Thursday December 13, 2018 @10:09AM (#18672778)
The problem is that the companies get municipalities to compete to provide the best incentives package. With sufficient competition and assuming well meaning, rational government officials, the winning municipality will have to reduce their "margin" (new tax dollars - incentives) down to a very small amount. These incentives often require the government to take out large loans that they will be paying down for decades before realizing any actual new "profit."

Then factor in the fact that their will always be some municipalities with government officials who are willing to overspend (other people's money) for personal political points. When they win an RFP for a big factory, sports team/stadium, movie production, or corporate headquarters they get to have a flashy press conference touting all the jobs. This helps them in their political career which is often over well before the actual net value of the deal can be realized in 20 or 30 years.

Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by AlexTWithBeard on Thursday December 13, 2018 @10:53AM (#18673189)
20 years sounds like a reasonable time for the investment to pay off.

It's not mindblowingly tremendous, but not a catastrophe either.

Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by QuotedForTruth on Thursday December 13, 2018 @11:08AM (#18673344)
Sure, but the city is taking on risk that the business, sports team or factory is still around generating revenue for that entire time and after.

Factories are often purpose built for whatever they will build. Retooling can be very expensive. Why would Foxconn for instance pay to retool their factory from LCD production to OLED or whatever new technology emerges in 10 years when they can just get another government to build them a new factory somewhere else?

Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by ip26 on Thursday December 13, 2018 @06:27AM (#18671500)
If they are adding people to your community- what roads will these new people be driving on? What schools will their children be attending?

The additional revenue is not being added in a vacuum.

Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by scarface74 on Thursday December 13, 2018 @06:29AM (#18671509)
The new people will be paying sales taxes, property taxes and state income taxes.
Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by yurishimo on Thursday December 13, 2018 @06:45AM (#18671597)
Though usually not enough to make up the difference in incentives. If we take the Amazon NY incentives at face value, each employee needs to pay $25k in taxes to make up the difference just on the initial tax break alone. That doesn’t count extra expenditures for expanded public transportation or nearby development. That’s also if amazon hires the proposed 40k new employees on day one, which they won’t.

There’s a good argument to be made that spending that money elsewhere would provide better outcomes and on shorter timelines than giving one of the largest companies in the world a tax break.

Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by C1sc0cat on Thursday December 13, 2018 @07:43AM (#18671882)
Which given FANG salaries they will do.

And the state and NYC preying in aid the problems with its tube system is deeply cynical, maybe try to be 1 less corrupt and competent

Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by alistairSH on Thursday December 13, 2018 @09:12AM (#18672387)
The highest marginal tax rate in NYC is 3.65%. The effective rate on a $140,000 salary is about 2.6%. Leaving a local tax liability of about $3500.

On the same income, NY state has a marginal rate of 6.45% and an effective rate of about 4.3%, for a liability of $6,000.

So, in year one, that's a bit over $9000 in revenue from a highly compensated employee. If the $25k figure stated above it true and a one-time incentive, it takes 2.5-3 years to pay off. Employees earning less than $140k will take 3+ years to pay off. If the incentives are recurring in any way, then the payoff is pushed out even more.

But, as mentioned, the employee doesn't just have to "pay back" the initial incentive, she has to produce tax revenue to pay for increased services and infrastructure demand, pushing the timeline out even further.

Anyway, the NYC deal doesn't sound to bad. Even at a 5-8 year pay-off, if the positions are relatively long-lived, it's a long-term positive. But, when we consider the Foxconn deal in the Mid-West, ouch, that one's going to sting the local community for a long time.

Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by gok on Thursday December 13, 2018 @12:24PM (#18674080)
The deal requires an average wage of $150,000. [1] And with the nature of variance in salaries combined with progressive taxation works out even better for the state; one $100K and one $200K employee will result in more revenue than two $150K employees.

[1] https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/5096409-New-York-Agr...

Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by Faark on Thursday December 13, 2018 @01:03PM (#18674471)
More citizens mean more cost for the state, aka the thing taxes are supposedly collected for. Amateur here, so I might just missed it, but where did you account for those marginal cost?

I have a hard time believing original residents actually benefit that greatly from those deals as well. Yes there are benefits of getting more people and well paying jobs into the region and some competition to keep taxes reasonable seem fine. But to me this still mostly seems like a transfer of wealth and power to big cooperation, boosting societal problems we already have a hard time dealing with.

Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by alistairSH on Thursday December 13, 2018 @01:09PM (#18674543)
The 4th paragraph.
Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by bdhess on Thursday December 13, 2018 @08:21AM (#18672086)
$25k in state and local taxes would be high even for FANG in NYC
Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by Eridrus on Thursday December 13, 2018 @08:59AM (#18672319)
They'll pay that in income taxes alone in 2 years.
Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by alistairSH on Thursday December 13, 2018 @09:14AM (#18672397)
Probably not; 2 years is overly optimistic. See my reply above.
Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by jen20 on Thursday December 13, 2018 @08:54AM (#18672292)
Pertinent to the headline of this article: Texas has no state income tax.
Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by karmajunkie on Thursday December 13, 2018 @10:05AM (#18672748)
They also cost a great deal in required infrastructure, drive up competition for affordable housing, and create complications in other ways. Texas has no income tax so there's no revenue from that. The city will end up net negative from most corporate incentives.
Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by Alex888 on Thursday December 13, 2018 @09:17AM (#18672425)
Aren't roads funded from gas tax?

And schools are almost entirely paid by the local property taxes, at least in the communities where most of Apple employees will live.

Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by karmajunkie on Thursday December 13, 2018 @10:01AM (#18672723)
Texas has a"Robin hood" school finance system, where districts with high property values are subject to recapture, where they send a large percentage of the property taxes collected to the state to be used for districts in less wealthy areas. If memory serves, Austin ISD sends almost half of its billion dollar budget back to the state.
Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by goldmouth on Thursday December 13, 2018 @10:25AM (#18672907)
$670 million this year. Due to our our exploding home values and decling enrollment.
Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by peatmoss on Thursday December 13, 2018 @09:41AM (#18672574)
> Aren't roads funded from gas tax?

No. Not much at all. Highways, once upon a time, mostly. Local roads not really ever. https://frontiergroup.org/reports/fg/do-roads-pay-themselves

Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by jandrewrogers on Thursday December 13, 2018 @10:00AM (#18672714)
How roads are funded depends on the State and locale. In some States, all highways are funded solely by use (gas and car) taxes as a constitutional requirement. Local roads, on the other hand, are funded almost arbitrarily -- it does include a gas tax in many places but in many places it does not.
Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by bogomipz on Thursday December 13, 2018 @07:08AM (#18671705)
>"Taking less money from someone who is building a business in your area is not a cost"

Let's look at what that someone will be expecting of your area - working roads, a fire department, a police department, public transportation, a school system, a library, a park, emergency services. How is an influx of of potentially much more people consuming those services not a cost?

Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by kiallmacinnes on Thursday December 13, 2018 @09:20AM (#18672437)
That certainly is a cost. But it's not what the parent poster was saying... I'll bet the costs you speak of are covered by income taxes and the corporate tax, with a little leftover per employee (so - a large pot of extra money at the end of the day).
Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by bogomipz on Thursday December 13, 2018 @10:48AM (#18673137)
>" I'll bet the costs you speak of are covered by income taxes and the corporate tax, with a little leftover per employee (so - a large pot of extra money at the end of the day)."

So you believe all local governments run a budget surplus? You can't be serious. You realize there operating expenses and capital expenses right? Maintaining an existing bridge and building aa new bridge are very different budgetary consideration.

Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by kiallmacinnes on Thursday December 13, 2018 @12:49PM (#18674339)
Of course not..

But .. What on earth does that have to do with what amounts to giving a quantity discount to large employers?

Yes, if they didn't give a discount, and somehow managed to keep the "sale" anyway, there would be more money in the register - great! However the reality is that without the discount, there is no sale, and no additional money in the register.

It may be that the discount is too great, that's entirely possible. I don't think we have the info to judge this.

Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by bogomipz on Thursday December 13, 2018 @02:26PM (#18675187)
>"But .. What on earth does that have to do with what amounts to giving a quantity discount to large employers?"

It's mostly certainly not a "quantity discount." These corporation aren't "buying" anything from these cities.

If Apple comes in sets up shop on 100 acre campus in your town and gets tax breaks to do so then your town forfeits the equivalent tax revenue another company would have paid for the same parcel of land. There is a huge opportunity cost involved, nothing is free.

Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by kiallmacinnes on Thursday December 13, 2018 @04:56PM (#18676513)
> It's mostly certainly not a "quantity discount." These corporation aren't "buying" anything from these cities.

The city is selling its land (in quantity) and talent pool (in quantity), and is giving a tax break (a discount).

> If Apple comes in sets up shop on 100 acre campus in your town and gets tax breaks to do so then your town forfeits the equivalent tax revenue another company would have paid for the same parcel of land.

If Bestbuy sells Microsoft 1000 laptops at a 30% discount, Bestbuy has forfeited the revenue they would have made from doing 1000 single unit+no discount sales. Despite the business making far less than maximum revenue, businesses choose to do this all the time as it created greater value for them in the end. Cities are doing essentially the same thing with big companies.

You just can't look at a discount and naively equate that to a $ loss in the city bank account, just as a business can't do this when they sell a physical good.

Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by bogomipz on Thursday December 13, 2018 @06:00PM (#18676937)
>"The city is selling its land (in quantity) and talent pool"

No the city is not selling land. Where in that article is it stated that Austin is selling Apple land? The city isn't "selling" it's talent pool. Companies will always gravitate towards where there's a steady supply of talent.

>If Bestbuy sells Microsoft 1000 laptops at a 30% discount"

Yeah your analogy is absurd, taxes are a "recurring" revenue stream for a city. It's not at all similar to a single retail transaction.

>"You just can't look at a discount and naively equate that"

It's not a "discount", there are no goods being sold. Future recurring revenue is being forfeited. And when there's a future budgetary short fall(and there alway is) it will be made up by the individual tax payer.

Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by longerthoughts on Thursday December 13, 2018 @03:23PM (#18675708)
You're making drastic assumptions about the relative quantities of your variables. It's feasible that the math works out but far from guaranteed.
Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by kiallmacinnes on Thursday December 13, 2018 @05:30PM (#18676733)
I am, I tried to make that clear with the "I'll bet..".. we don't have anywhere near enough insight to know for sure!
Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by karmajunkie on Thursday December 13, 2018 @10:06AM (#18672755)
No income taxes in Texas.
Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by specialist on Thursday December 13, 2018 @07:55AM (#18671947)
Is it fair for the Goliaths to get special consideration? Why doesn't everyone get the same deal?
Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by longerthoughts on Thursday December 13, 2018 @03:19PM (#18675666)
Because the Goliaths bring more to the table in terms of revenue and bragging rights for politicians who can say they brought [insert high number here] jobs to their city. I'm skeptical of these deals and not sure the math works out for the average taxpayer but I'm not surprised that cities are operating this way.

From a city's perspective, why should companies of vastly different sizes, impacts, and expected lifetimes have the same leverage in terms of negotiating tax benefits today? Companies are getting the same "deal" in the sense that they will be eligible for these benefits when they bring enough to the table to make a city desperately want them.

I'm not saying it's just, but creating the "same deal" for all companies is only likely to occur if it's federally enforced - otherwise there will always be cities willing to offer these incentives.

Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by Avshalom on Thursday December 13, 2018 @01:47PM (#18674879)
It's never just 'not taxes' because significant businesses bring significant infrastructure needs with them. It's x-ty million dollar overpasses to allow better freeway access and new police/fire substations and running new utilities and ongoing maintenance on those. 'beautification' efforts to make real estate developers on the limn happy.
Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by bryanlarsen on Thursday December 13, 2018 @11:08AM (#18673350)
It's a huge cost to the whole community, if by the "whole community" you mean the entire US.

Let's say that Apple pays municipal tax of $X-$Y to Austin because of incentive $Y instead of $X to Denver (for example)

Then Denver loses $X while Austin gains $X-$Y and Apple gains $Y. Sure, the Denver loss is only theoretical but Apple has to build somewhere so American municipal taxpayers lose as a group. A "race to the bottom" has real costs.

The municipal governments are behaving rationally; it's the federal government who represents all municipalities as a collective; they're the ones who should be passing a law banning this type of behavior.

Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by briandear on Thursday December 13, 2018 @11:57AM (#18673814)
Actually Denver doesn’t lose anything. The loss isn’t even theoretical. It’s like saying I lost billions on Apple stock I didn’t buy. That just makes no sense. You could also, using your theoretical logic, say that Berlin lost money too. Or Marseille. Or Dubai.

Apple could have built new facilities literally anywhere they wanted. So should the international government pass a law against the US having lower taxes than France? The only people that should have a say in the tax rate of a place are the people paying the tax rate of a place.

Denver never had it in the first place. Money not earned isn’t the same as an actual cost. The people of Denver are in exactly the same shoes they were yesterday; they aren’t worse off.

And why should the federal government tell individual cities how they should tax? I’m afraid you don’t understand what federalism is, nor freedom for that matter. If a hypothetical Austin wants to give Bezos the key to the city what business is it to the people of Boise? Boise didn’t lose anything.

Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by bryanlarsen on Friday December 14, 2018 @08:13AM (#18680553)
Denver didn't lose. America did. You know full well they weren't going to build anywhere outside of the US.
Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by taobility on Thursday December 13, 2018 @12:55PM (#18674391)
Then Apple can contribute $X out of US, like China, India etc.
Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by C1sc0cat on Thursday December 13, 2018 @07:40AM (#18671870)
And many states in the US compete in the same way eg the states that have much lower state income taxes its ok for them.

Its the same in the EU where Ireland had very low CGT - that's one reason Google has a big office there - access to an educated English speaking work force is another

Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by disgruntledphd2 on Thursday December 13, 2018 @07:44AM (#18671889)
I believe you mean corporation tax, not captial gains tax, as CGT is well above the European average here in Ireland, while corporationtax is quite low.
Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by C1sc0cat on Thursday December 13, 2018 @10:31AM (#18672955)
Sorry your right my bad
Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by jrs95 on Thursday December 13, 2018 @05:39AM (#18671302)
Well, there's going to be tax revenue coming from those jobs even if there are less or no taxes to the business itself, before you even consider the money that those employees and potentially even the business itself will spend within the community. I don't think it's as simple as tax incentives inherently being a cost for the community.
Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by nostrebored on Thursday December 13, 2018 @05:44AM (#18671324)
You're being downvoted, but nobody is engaging with the sensible points that you're making.

While viewing these in the lens of a corporate handout, it is definitely a practice that deserves a close look, pretending that entire state governmental bodies in the US are acting outside of their own best interest (both fiscally and politically) deserves a conversation

Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by state_less on Thursday December 13, 2018 @06:28AM (#18671508)
Like people, states might decide to form a union to increase prosperity for their citizens by bargaining with corporations as a collective. It makes it more difficult for adversaries to overpower individual states in a union. This could consist of an obligation to uphold revenue (taxes) which is used to provide certain living standards (e.g. medical expenses, feeding grandma, etc...) through a social guarantee.

How does corporate bargaining power work? Suppose two states and one corporation operating in both states. The corporation says to each state, "I'm reducing the employee count in your state unless you reduce my taxes." The threat is credible and is in neither state's interest. Unless the two states talk to each other and both agree to not reduce the tax rate, a social guarantee is in jeopardy. A union or cooperation of the states disallows the corporation the ability to punish and reward individual states, reducing the means to manipulate each individual state's tax rate to the corporations liking.

Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by C1sc0cat on Thursday December 13, 2018 @07:46AM (#18671898)
But that would give up states rights - and it doesn't stop bullying by central government to place offices in "for the governing party" desirable areas.

Why do you think BT has a big engineering presence in all 4 parts of the UK? or why the BBC was forced to move to Manchester

Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by state_less on Thursday December 13, 2018 @09:54AM (#18672664)
> But that would give up states rights

When states unite and cooperate they are exercising their right to self assemble or self association. Often individual states exercise this right after chronically being picked apart by a powerful adversary and find they don't want to leave behind the benefits the union provides.

I don't know enough about specifics in the UK to answer your questions. Union members typically vote on the direction of the union or leadership positions and so these members are responsible for their decisions or leadership.

Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by thaumasiotes on Thursday December 13, 2018 @05:59AM (#18671380)
https://www.vox.com/2018/11/16/18098479/amazon-tax-breaks

> A normal way for governments to raise revenue in the United States is with property taxes. If you build a gigantic new office tower somewhere, then you are going to owe a lot of property taxes to the local government.

> So if you’re smart and have good lobbyists, you’ll say, “Hey, we were thinking of building a huge office tower in your city, but your taxes are so high. Maybe instead of paying the 8 percent property tax rate that’s on the books, we could pay 2 percent instead for the first 20 years.”

> The city may well agree to this proposal because 2 percent of a giant office tower is still a lot more than 8 percent of a parking lot. What’s more, bringing your office tower to town is going to generate a lot of sales tax and income tax revenue while probably helping to bolster property values across the board. So while reporters are going to write, accurately, that your company got millions of dollars in tax breaks in order to build your office tower, the city still ends up with more tax revenue than it would have had if you hadn’t come to town.

> So you can’t really say things like, “Instead of handing out millions in subsidies to Jeff Bezos, we should invest in the subway.” The subway doesn’t need a tax break; the subway needs actual money. And the tax breaks don’t represent money in hand that could be spent.

> What we want is a healthy form of competition where companies try to locate in cities that provide a high quality of public services relative to their tax revenue, so that cities have an incentive to try to govern themselves well. The current dynamic not only allocates too much surplus to rich companies, it undermines that healthy form of competition. Amazon doesn’t need to care whether New York City has cost-effective government or not; it just opts out of paying the costs.

> But the very fact that mayors are inclined to hand out these subsidies should teach them a lesson about tax policy.

(The lesson being that, if giving these tax breaks out is beneficial, maybe you should have been taxing something else in the first place.)

Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by scarface74 on Thursday December 13, 2018 @06:34AM (#18671545)
In some cases they are. There was an episode of Planet Money where they were discussing Kansas City Kansas and Kansas City Missouri competing for the same companies and companies going back and forth across the state border to whoever would give them the best deal.

The companies were squeezing all of the benefits from having the company be there out of the city.

It took decades for some cities to wise up and realize that having a sports franchise wasn’t worth all of the incentives they give the leagues.

Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by dwighttk on Thursday December 13, 2018 @06:48AM (#18671611)
I guess (e.g) Las Vegas, Atlanta, and Seattle didn’t get the memo. Odd since Seattle and Atlanta recently lost franchises that they’d add new ones if it wasn’t worth it.
Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by InitialLastName on Thursday December 13, 2018 @10:25AM (#18672910)
I'm a bit lost. What major sports franchise is Atlanta adding? Looking at [0], I see new(ish) soccer, Overwatch and arena football teams, but none of those are really among the "big money" sports in the US, nor do any of those require the sort of support from the city/state that, say, a new NFL stadium would require.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sports_in_Atlanta

Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by moorhosj on Thursday December 13, 2018 @11:27AM (#18673531)
The new Atlanta soccer team, Atlanta United, actually plays in the new NFL stadium that the state spent $1.6 billion to build [1]. Average attendance was 53,000 for Atlanta United this year.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mercedes-Benz_Stadium

Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by InitialLastName on Friday December 14, 2018 @08:42AM (#18680697)
I'm not deeply familiar with the history, but I assume that the stadium was mostly built to support the Falcons? What are their attendance numbers?

Also, per the same article, the stadium's nominal capacity for soccer is 41K, so average attendance of 53k is pretty damn good.

Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by dwighttk on Thursday December 13, 2018 @12:36PM (#18674215)
Yes. Lost the NHL and gained the MLS
Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by Latteland on Thursday December 13, 2018 @09:41AM (#18672577)
Seattle didn't lose Amazon, if that is what you are thinking. We have enough Amazon already, it goes a long way.
Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by InitialLastName on Thursday December 13, 2018 @10:29AM (#18672940)
I think GP is talking about the Supersonics (NBA team) which moved from Seattle to Oklahoma City in 2008.
Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by dwighttk on Thursday December 13, 2018 @12:36PM (#18674211)
Yes lost the SuperSonics, gaining an NHL team
Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by ghaff on Thursday December 13, 2018 @05:51AM (#18671351)
I suspect subsidies are often excessive, in part because they often arise as part of a bidding war. But that doesn't mean that localities should never provide incentives to encourage companies (and jobs) to locate in a particular location. To think otherwise more or less means that it's not the job of government to take specific actions to encourage job growth, which doesn't seem like a generally sensible opinion.
Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by ip26 on Thursday December 13, 2018 @06:24AM (#18671489)
If we presume that taxes are set to the level required to provide agreed-upon levels of service (roads, safety, schools, etc) and a new company gets to pay less taxes per capita, what happens now as the citywide average tax income per head starts to decline due to sweetheart tax breaks?

Additional tax income needs to cover the additional demand for services, otherwise it's a net loss for the community's standard of living.

Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by bluecalm on Thursday December 13, 2018 @06:39AM (#18671569)
But they aren't especially tax on company profits. There are many big inefficient polluters who pay lower wages and little profit tax. The additional demands will be covered by taxing relatively big salaries Apple pays and sales taxes those new employees pay.
Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by youdontknowtho on Thursday December 13, 2018 @10:45AM (#18673108)
Dallas did something just as stupid for Hunt Oil several years ago. At the same time they were cutting wages for city employees. It's short sighted in the extreme.
Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by distant_hat on Thursday December 13, 2018 @07:02AM (#18671678)
There should be an MFN like law to these incentives. Any incentives given to a company should be given to every company. The government should not be picking and choosing.
Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by ethbro on Thursday December 13, 2018 @08:42AM (#18672215)
From that perspective, one way of looking at these tax breaks is as a rebate of government time & money saved by dealing with a single entity (vs 10 or 50 for the same sized economic impact).
Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by jpttsn on Thursday December 13, 2018 @05:52AM (#18671357)
VIPs don’t have to pay to get in to nightclubs. Do you think that’s a huge cost? If so, why would club owners agree to it?
Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by epanchin on Thursday December 13, 2018 @06:03AM (#18671400)
Not a very good example. VIPs don’t increase the cost for other punters.
Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by wastedhours on Thursday December 13, 2018 @06:30AM (#18671513)
Often VIPs are paid by the clubs to appear, which is indirectly passed onto other punters as a marketing cost.

Here, you're essentially bringing in a whole bunch of new burden on infrastructure, but getting proportionally less back in order to support it (waiting on some inflection based on future sales tax or property taxes etc is not a guarantee, especially as campuses can be out in the sticks so drawing workers from a wider area). Either you take hits on that, or pass the extra needed cost onto other taxpayers.

I'm not sure whether or not the net is positive or negative, but the second order effects do need to be paid for somehow.

Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by ricardobeat on Thursday December 13, 2018 @06:46AM (#18671601)
The new employees are also going to be taxpayers. Does any city heavily rely on tax revenue from businesses to maintain critical infrastructure? It should come almost entirely from individual / property tax revenue / federal grants, corporate tax usually accounts for a minor slice of total budget.
Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by RedPill007 on Thursday December 13, 2018 @11:39AM (#18673647)
This is not about "Big Corps" but more about the voter mentality. For some unknown reason people across the political spectrum totally buy into the claims of "creating jobs" and "protecting jobs".

None of the average voter bothers to actually do the math to see the cost of the job. Trump's tariffs for example might have protected 500 jobs at the cost of $500M to American consumers. But this math is beyond most people.

Corps will surely love low tax regions and I think that is a good thing. Big Taxes only lead to bigger government than invariably leads to disasters for small people like us.

Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by AlexTWithBeard on Thursday December 13, 2018 @09:30AM (#18672503)
Tech employees are very cheap for the community. They take very little government aid, their use of roads is quite moderate (and is getting lower as "working from home" picks pace), and they usually pay enough property taxes to pay for local schools.

On the other hand the benefits they bring to the community are enormous.

Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by lawnchair_larry on Thursday December 13, 2018 @09:39AM (#18672559)
That isn’t my observation. They displace other communities entirely by driving up cost of living.
Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by karmajunkie on Thursday December 13, 2018 @10:06AM (#18672760)
As an engineer in Austin, I mostly concur.
Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by goldmouth on Thursday December 13, 2018 @10:23AM (#18672886)
As a native austinite and engineer I completely disagree. The eastSide was a terrible place before. Going into pan am park was a no go at any time of the day. Comunities and infrastructure were dying in eat Austin. Also, It had extremely low home ownership rates so the lower class didn’t even own homes in these areas but made money for westside landlords.

South congress was full of crackheads and prostitutes as early as the 90’s. We had real urban decay. Now we are growing like crazy and if you’re willing to work hard any immigrant can get a construction job and make a great living for themselves.

Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by moorhosj on Thursday December 13, 2018 @11:34AM (#18673601)
>Also, It had extremely low home ownership rates so the lower class didn’t even own homes in these areas but made money for westside landlords.

How will increasing rents (and property values) across the city help solve this lack of ownership? Is it possible the problem gets worse by adding more "rich" workers?

>South congress was full of crackheads and prostitutes as early as the 90’s.

Isn't it likely that there were also working class people struggling to get by who appreciated low rents?

>any immigrant can get a construction job and make a great living for themselves.

And what will they do when construction slows due to recession or other factors?

You might want to re-asses this comment from the perspective of the people who actually lived in these "terrible places" that were a "no go at any time of the day". They might have a different view than you.

Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by karmajunkie on Thursday December 13, 2018 @11:30AM (#18673557)
See parent. I was here intermittently in the late 90s and have an aunt with a midcentury house off SoCo bought in the early 90s. You may not have seen those communities as having intrinsic value but the people that live there did. And now most of them can't afford to live there anymore because "the market" has decided to make room for gentrification.

Those communities had economic problems, sure. But you're kidding yourself if you don't think the replacements for them have a different sort of economic problem. And just because they're whiter and richer now doesn't make them a better set of problems.

Re:Apple to build campus in Austin and sites in Seattle, San... by kthejoker2 on Thursday December 13, 2018 @01:52PM (#18674932)
So much for Keep Austin Weird ...