News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by realradicalwash on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @07:43AM (#18390450)
The quote is a bit out of context. The sentence right above it:

>It makes almost nothing worse and almost everything better, finally bringing the Mac Mini into the modern age.

So, no, it's not "yayy" because it "hasn't gotten worse", it's "yayy", because "[it makes] almost everything better".

Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by drcongo on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @09:03AM (#18391012)
Anyone who owns a MacBook Pro with Touch Bar will definitely be saying "yay it hasn't gotten worse!" about these.
Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by simonh on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @05:32PM (#18395515)
And now the top thread is dominated by an argument about laptop keyboards, for a device that isn't a laptop and doesn't even come with a keyboard.
Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by Nexxxeh on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @08:09AM (#18398839)
But to be fair, the device is made by Apple and the discussion speaks to how Apple treats its consumers.
Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by crad on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @10:02AM (#18391554)
I'm pretty happy with mine, but thanks for speaking for us all with your sweeping generalization.
Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by phaus on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @11:38AM (#18392529)
I work at a company where most of us use Macs. Everyone that has upgraded from a 2013-2015 MBP to the touchbar model absolutely hates it, including me. There's gotta be someone around here that actually likes it, but I haven't met them yet.

Its OK if you like it. I'm sure lots of people do, but you know damn well significantly more people have had issues with this laptop than normal, so I'm not sure why you're implying otherwise.

The keyboard is by far the worst I've ever used, and I've owned a variety of $200 Wal-Mart black friday laptops and a couple of netbooks, in addition to some high end stuff. I had a friend with an older MBP attempt to show me something using my computer and he could barely type on it without frequent mistakes. Within a minute he was getting frustrated. It just feels terrible. I never thought anything would be worse than typing on a touch-screen but Apple's engineers have accomplished a horrifying miracle. Its like they intentionally tried to design something that's as loud as a mechanical keyboard while still having worse tactile feedback than a $5.00 rubber dome keyboard.

On top of that, its not noticeably faster, after 4.5 years it still maxed out @ 16GB Ram (They fixed this in 2018 but its too late), which is not enough for my use case + it died after 3 months (Not the keyboard, it was a power issue).

This is both the most expensive and the worst computer I've ever owned. The 2013 MBP I'm using now as a loaner while I get my new one fixed is, to quote Steve Jobs "Like getting a glass of ice water in hell." It just works.

Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by reaperducer on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @11:46AM (#18392609)
The touchbar made me realize that I have a habit of resting my fingers up there. I came to this realization because when I didn't think I was typing anything, stuff would happen. Eventually I realized I was touching virtual buttons on the touchbar.

I don't hate it, but I wish more of the tools I use took advantage of it.

I think it could be massively improved by shortening it a little on the left to make room for a physical escape key. That's about 95% of my problem with it.

Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by wild_preference on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @12:09PM (#18392827)
Consider mapping CapsLock to Esc (and Ctrl when long-pressed) with Karabiner. I haven't used my physical Esc key since 2014 or something. Might help with your issue.
Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by philwelch on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @12:36PM (#18393084)
You don't need a third party tool; System Preferences does this for you already. (Maybe not the long-press, but I'm vim, not emacs).
Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by copperx on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @12:45PM (#18393182)
If you remap CapsLock to Esc, what key do you use for Control for doing Control A, Control E, Control K, Control Y, Control N, and Control P in every application?
Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by wild_preference on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @01:16PM (#18393466)
I tried to address this in my parentheses, but Karabiner specifically lets you bind CapsLock to both: Esc when tapped alone, and Ctrl when held down in combination with other keys.

And your post also answers you sibling comment: Ctrl modifier is useful outside of just Emacs.

Try it out. I believe the API changed in the macOS release before Mojave, so they relaunched Karabiner under the name Karabiner Elements. This option is under the "Complex Modifications" tab.

If I was writing a list of tricks for macOS power users to try, this would be my number one. Up there with binding a global show/hide hotkey for iTerm (I use Ctrl-Space, thus CapsLock-Space).

Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by Fnoord on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @02:50PM (#18394335)
I prefer Magic Trackpad 2 (or native MBP 2015 trackpad) to any other way of navigation but Vi keybinds -if available- work as well.

I currently use Karabiner for this as well, but a slightly different configuration.

The two rules I use are:

* R-Cmd + hjkl are arrows (which works great with HHKB but even on native MBP it requires less movement of hand from trackpad or typing hand than the arrow keys)

* Caps solo is Esc while Caps with another key equals Ctrl.

Is there a way to do this in Linux as well? I currently have to use Linux regularly and I rebind Caps to Ctrl however for Vim it isn't ideal. So I'd like to have the same functionality I have with Karabiner on Linux (Xorg / console).

Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by tincholio on Thursday November 08, 2018 @07:28AM (#18405788)
You can use xcape on linux to do this. I use it to map CAPS to CTRL/ESCAPE, and right shift to RIGHT SHIFT/COMPOSE
Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by dark_star on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @03:16PM (#18394542)
I use Karabiner Elements to bind backtick (grave accent) to Esc, Command-backtick to Command-backtick as normal (so you can switch between windows of the same app), and Option-backtick to backtick.

It's not optimal, but I do it because backtick is about the same position as a hardware Escape key. It makes using vim feel ok again.

This option is available from the KE Complex Modifications tab.

Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by bobbyi_settv on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @04:32PM (#18395080)
Note that this means you lose the ability to use option-backtick for diacritic marks. Normally option-backtick followed by a makes "à", Option-backtick followed by e makes "è", etc
Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by malloryerik on Thursday November 15, 2018 @11:15PM (#18466350)
This isn't working for me in Mojave; you haven't had a problem?
Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by jimmcslim on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @05:49PM (#18395608)
In this mode... if you hold down CapsLock as Ctrl and then don't decide to press another modifier... does it still fire CapsLock as Esc?
Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by philwelch on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @09:11PM (#18403897)
I already have a ctrl key, though. Whatever works for you, though--personally, I prefer not installing extra third-party systems-level software over making ctrl marginally more convenient to press.
Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by michaelmrose on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @01:48PM (#18393789)
Are you denoting control+shift+a as control-A?
Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by copperx on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @08:55PM (#18396595)
No, I was just typing on a phone. I meant control+a (start of line), control+e (end of line), etc.
Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by dmix on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @03:06PM (#18394454)
Capslock is ctrl for most developers I know (because it's by far the most used key in terminal/Vim/emacs/etc).
Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by copperx on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @04:53PM (#18395208)
Yes. Although in a Kinesis Advantage keyboard (the "official" Emacs keyboard), because the Control is under the thumb, it is useful to remap the CapsLock to Esc.
Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by dkonofalski on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @05:20PM (#18395428)
You should snag an app called BetterTouchTool. Makes the TouchBar an amazing addition to the laptop. It's just a shame that Apple didn't build in a tool like it but I hope the developer gets lots of love.
Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by reaperducer on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @08:42PM (#18396523)
I have BTT for my machine at home, but the IT security department won't approve it for the work machines.
Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by xvector on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @07:32PM (#18396201)
Doesn’t BTT require enabling unsigned kernel extensions?
Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by tcfunk on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @05:25PM (#18395462)
Yes! I am constantly holding down the escape key without realizing it. Not a problem very often but occasionally causes some really confusing things to happen.
Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by artursapek on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @12:50PM (#18393228)
Doesn't it also get very distracting with how often it flashes into different states? I've heard this drives people crazy.
Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by copperx on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @04:54PM (#18395216)
When you remap it it doesn't flash at all.
Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by reaperducer on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @08:43PM (#18396530)
The touchbar? I find it more amusing than distracting.
Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by Gorbzel on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @02:31PM (#18394185)
> Its OK if you like it. I'm sure lots of people do, but you know damn well significantly more people have had issues with this laptop than normal, so I'm not sure why you're implying otherwise.

Yup, that's exactly what the HN groupthink would like to believe. What is by definition a small user demographic complains repeatedly/loudly that their problems are the most important, indicative of "everyone", and Apple is doomed because so-and-so bought a Surface Pro/Dell/System76. The hyperbolie is kicked up a notch here, as clearly any $200 Walmart laptop keyboard is better.

As is typical, there's never any data to support the claims and a significant number of counter anecdotes are dismissed absent critical reasoning ("you know damn well...!"). Instead, the echo chamber resonates unabated by logic.

Throw in an out of context Steve quote and you can identify this drivel pretty uniformly. It's usually best to ignore, though at times a response is merited when it's completely off topic and unhelpful (as it is here, the new Mac mini seems awesome regardless of a hater's two year old take on the tbMBP).

Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by Damogran6 on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @03:06PM (#18394460)
I like the feel of the keyboard. I did not like the trip to the Mac store at 8 months whereby they very gingerly lifted the spacebar and removed whatever crumb was under there making it mushy.

I also like the touchbar. The touch-slide volume is a nifty improvement...I use the touchbar for the occasional screengrab...and that's about it. As someone mentioned above, I too would really like a physical Escape key

Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by phaus on Friday November 09, 2018 @08:52AM (#18414295)
If you go back and read my comment, I didn't say that out of Apple's entire customer base, more people dislike the keyboard than like it. I said that more people are having issues with this computer than a normal Apple MBP.

Just like your comment, this is an anecdotal opinion on the Internet. I didn't read your response and come away with the conclusion that you were attempting to represent it as a peer reviewed white paper, so I'm not sure why you're holding my random Internet comment to the same standard.

My anecdotal evidence is that all of the typical places people go to talk about technology on the Internet(reddit, hacker news, blogs, etc.) seem to have to more complaints about the keyboard on the new MBP than I recall seeing about the old model, which was almost universally hailed as the best laptop on the market.

Included with that anecdotal evidence is my own experience in a company with hundreds of people that use MBPs. There might be other companies where everyone loves them.

It would be really helpful if we could trust Apple to publish accurate, relevant data on the new MBP vs the old one, but they have a history of hiding, denying and/or lying about issues with Apple products.

>The hyperbolie is kicked up a notch here, as clearly any $200 Walmart laptop keyboard is better.

This isn't hyperbole. Its just my opinion and it was presented as such. I've been using computers since the early 90s. I've never used a keyboard that felt worse to me than the MBP. When I say that I don't mean that its one of the worst keyboards I've ever used, I mean that its THE worst keyboard that I have ever used, which is obviously just my opinion.

>Throw in an out of context Steve quote and you can identify this drivel pretty uniformly

This isn't a case where reusing a quote is changing the context of what he meant. I wasn't saying that Steve Jobs agrees with my opinion of the new MBP. This should be pretty obvious. The original context was that Steve Jobs felt one product was so superior to another one that getting the former was like getting a glass of ice water in hell. Its a perfectly relevant quote used in the same way that he did. I just happen to be comparing different products.

>It's usually best to ignore, though at times a response is merited when it's completely off topic and unhelpful (as it is here, the new Mac mini seems awesome regardless of a hater's two year old take on the tbMBP).

1. Its perfectly on-topic to discuss the quality of Apple products in a post about an Apple product. The reputation of their products is pretty valid when people are discussing whether to buy a newer product.

2. I didn't bring up the MBP, someone else did and I responded.

3. Not liking a single Apple product doesn't make me a "hater". I loved my 2013 MBP, I loved all of my iPhones/iPads, and I love MacOS. Apple released a product that I have an issue with. Lots of other people are having the same issue. I'm not sure why you have to react to that like a personal attack.

There's this phenomenon where if lots of people have an issue with something and then a random person buys the product and has a good experience, that person decides to dismiss everyone that has had an issue, pretend its impossible the issue existed, and then act like there must be something wrong with the people that had the issue. I don't really understand that because with any product that sells thousands or millions, its typical for some people to have issues even if most like it. In this case, it just happens to be a product where a slightly larger percentage than normal is having an issue.

Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by ako on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @01:51PM (#18393822)
I don't understand all the hate for the touchbar. I can never remember the functions performed by the function keys, so having icons indicating which functions are available seems really useful.
Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by fipple on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @03:34PM (#18394683)
The problem is that most serious computer users use a laptop docked, so it’s useless 70-90% of the time, which means the software can’t rely on it, which means it’s an afterthought in all apps.
Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by dkonofalski on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @05:22PM (#18395441)
>most serious computer users

Ahh... the good 'ol Scottsman shows his face yet again! Right on time!

Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by rusk on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @06:03PM (#18395669)
A Scotsman would be to say “No true computer user ...” - this was a generalisation. An apt one IMHO
Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by dkonofalski on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @11:38AM (#18400252)
No it wasn't. Define "serious". What makes one computer user more "serious" than another. The point of the no true Scottsman is that the term is never defined by the statement and so it's completely subjective.
Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by rusk on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @02:32PM (#18401596)
That’s not how it works.
Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by dkonofalski on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @07:45PM (#18403541)
Actually it is: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No_true_Scotsman

Refuting the initial generalization by saying that no "serious" computer users use their Touch Bar because their computers are closed is nearly a textbook example of the fallacy.

Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by rusk on Thursday November 08, 2018 @04:22AM (#18405241)
that's not what he (or she) was doing.
Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by dkonofalski on Thursday November 08, 2018 @06:44PM (#18411083)
I don't see how much more clearly I could breakdown what happened. Their entire argument was predicated on the fact that most "serious" (replace "true") computer users don't use the Touch Bar because their lids are closed.

I'll compromise. We'll call it the no "serious" computer users fallacy instead of the no serious Scotsman fallacy.

Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by spiritcat on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @05:41PM (#18395577)
why close it when 'docked'? mouse on right, keyboard in middle, touchpad and touchbar on left
Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by sixstringtheory on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @02:15PM (#18394036)
Do you have to look down to use those icons on the Touchbar? This is something I don’t have to do as a touch-typist. Repeatedly craning your neck to look down will result in RSI. I spend a little effort to learn new hotkeys every so often and the benefit far outweighs the cost: I’m much faster and keep my good ergonomics.
Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by ako on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @05:17PM (#18395411)
I don't use the function keys much, so yes, i do look at the keyboard when using them.
Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by kayoone on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @02:06PM (#18393975)
Comparing the keyboard with a $200 walmart netbook is a joke. It might not be everybody's taste, but it's far from terrible. I actually like it and at my company where 95% of engineers have one, there is not more complains than usual about the new model. People that really can't stand the keyboard will usually use external peripherals at their desk.
Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by Friedduck on Thursday November 08, 2018 @09:30PM (#18411961)
I share in the hate. It’s the worst keyboard I’ve used in memory. The trackpad is first rate however.

The touchbar is so much less functional than the keys it replaces. Some key combinations now require serious acrobatics, and you can’t touch type as easily.

We’re not buying any more macs until it improves.

Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by poulsbohemian on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @02:30PM (#18394170)
>the touchbar model absolutely hates it

What kind of work do you / your teammates do? I walked into an Apple store last week prepared to hate the keyboards and touch bars, but was very pleasantly surprised. My ladyfriend wanted to see the Air, but was so taken with the Touch Bar for photo work that she will be buying an MBP instead. While it might not be everyones cup of tea, I think Apple may have figured is demographics correctly on this one.

Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by phaus on Friday November 09, 2018 @08:37AM (#18414202)
I don't have a problem with the touchbar, its the keyboard that they introduced on the same model.
Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by city41 on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @05:22PM (#18395442)
I also think the new MacBook Pro is the worst laptop I've ever had. I hated it so much I switched to a Thinkpad. Thankfully these are company issued laptops and I could do this pretty easily. Had I bought a personal one I'd be quite distraught.
Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by rbanffy on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @06:28AM (#18398459)
Anyone who hates the touchbar has never chased a chat window for the mute button (it's there). Also, no need to leave the keyboard to click on dialog box buttons - they also get there.

It could be better - it could require a bit more of pressure to press buttons and could have haptic feedback like the touchpad, but I bet someone is working on that, even if it means extending haptic feedback to the whole chassis (which is not a bad idea anyway).

Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by xenihn on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @05:17PM (#18395412)
I have a 2013 15" MBP, a 2015 13" MBP, a 2016 15" MBP w/ Touchbar, and a 2017 15" MBP w/ Touchbar. I vastly prefer the 2013 and 2015, even though they are bare-bones specced and the newer MBPs are top-of-the-line. The touchbar MBPs are provided to me by my employer. I just bought my 2015 13" this year, after considering getting a newer model, and I'm planning for it to be my main personal laptop for years to come.

I don't like the touchbar, I don't like the new keyboard, and I don't like the new ports.

I think there is something wrong if, now two years later, there are still people like me who not only don't see a clear benefit to upgrading, but see it as a net-negative.

Ideally, there should be nearly no one (if anyone) who prefers the previous iteration.

Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by tw04 on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @04:17PM (#18394986)
It makes things universally worse imo. Everything was by touch for me previously, including adjusting sound. I had the keyboard memorized. Now I constantly have to look down. A keyboard shouldn't require me to change my focus, that defeats the entire purpose.
Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by d35007 on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @01:49PM (#18393794)
Same. I bought a 2018 MacBook Pro with the Touch Bar this July. Before that, I owned a 2014 MacBook Pro, the last one with the mechanical trackpad. My new machine is absolutely better than my old one.
Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by seunosewa on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @02:03PM (#18393935)
In what ways is your new machine better, apart from being thinner and just a bit lighter?
Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by d35007 on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @03:29PM (#18394654)
The dimensions aren't really a selling point for me at all. Both laptops are thin enough and light enough for me to carry them to and from work comfortably.

Performance is better across the board (6-core i9 vs 4-core i7, 32GB vs 16GB, faster SSD). It has a larger, pressure-sensitive track pad. The display is better.

I have a slight preference for the old keyboard, but I don't dislike the new one. I could take or leave the TouchBar. I was never a big user of the F keys and IntelliJ, where I spend a lot of my time, has good TouchBar support. I like having Touch ID. I'd prefer to have a real escape key, but the button is still in the same place so I haven't had to retrain my fingers to hit it.

USB-C with a Thunderbolt 3 hub is marginally more convenient than a Thunderbolt 2 hub plus a MagSafe power cord. I do miss MagSafe though.

Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by andrestan on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @04:57PM (#18395243)
These are almost exactly my thoughts as well coming from a 2015 MBP. I would only add that for me, I actually like the new keyboard. The low/firm travel of the keys is actually preferable for me. I felt like the old keyboards were "mushy". That's obviously a personal preference, however.
Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by threatofrain on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @12:05PM (#18392792)
drcongo is making a statement about the population, and readers can be trusted to not be so confused as to think that this is the official speech of the people.
Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by d35007 on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @01:52PM (#18393836)
> Anyone who owns a MacBook Pro with Touch Bar will definitely be saying "yay it hasn't gotten worse!" about these.

If drcongo doesn't mean to speak for "Anyone who owns a MacBook Pro with Touch Bar", drcongo should refrain from using those exact words. And you should probably refrain from speaking for drcongo.

Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by lovehashbrowns on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @02:29PM (#18394155)
It's pretty common to make sweeping generalizations in casual conversation, which this is. I find it really annoying when someone says something like "everyone likes cats!" and then someone, inevitably, will hop in and reply with "ACTUALLY, I hate cats." This isn't a mathematics proof.
Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by __d on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @03:17PM (#18394553)
Sure, it's not necessary to completely accurate in casual conversation, but you can say "heaps of people like cats!" or "most people like cats!" or "almost everyone likes cats!" and make your point just as effectively, and without trying to invalidate or dismiss the dislike of cats.
Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by rthille on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @07:09PM (#18396083)
http://surveys.ap.org/data%5CGfK%5CAP-GfK%20Petside%20Like-D... "almost everyone like cats!" Would definitely be false :-)
Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by d35007 on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @06:17PM (#18395745)
> It's pretty common to make sweeping generalizations in casual conversation, which this is

It's interesting that you chose the term "sweeping generalization". It almost always carries a negative connotation. In fact, it's considered to be a logical fallacy (see https://www.logicallyfallacious.com/tools/lp/Bo/LogicalFalla...).

> I find it really annoying when someone says something like "everyone likes cats!" and then someone, inevitably, will hop in and reply with "ACTUALLY, I hate cats."

I'm sorry I annoyed you. I find it annoying when someone speaks for me and gets my opinion wrong.

edit: Is it really "inevitable" though? It happens every single time? (just kidding)

> This isn't a mathematics proof.

No, but communicating clearly and honestly is important, even in casual conversations.

[dead]
Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by d35007 on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @09:42PM (#18396766)
You know what? I love hash browns too. One of the best uses of a potato imo.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BPX-wuplDvc

Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by pentae on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @11:23AM (#18392359)
I'm terribly unhappy with mine and so is everyone else I know, so i'm pretty pleased with it
Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by copperx on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @04:59PM (#18395261)
I like the Touchbar more than most of my other colleagues like the Touchbar. And I hate the Touchbar.
Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by sergiotapia on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @12:23PM (#18392969)
The new macbook pro keyboard is flimsy and easily broken. I bought my own macbook pro, delete key stuck.

Got a new one from my new job, keyboard stuck.

My brother bought a new one, keyboard stuck.

Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by briandear on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @02:43PM (#18394267)
Clearly, you are holding it wrong.
Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by bborud on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @05:16PM (#18395407)
You are liking it wrong :)
Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by simonh on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @05:16PM (#18395398)
HN: This is the worst Apple product ever and Apple has abandoned satisfying their customer with the things they actually want.

Reality: Apple product breaks sales records.

Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by fogetti on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @07:02PM (#18396027)
McDonald's also makes record sales in Japan right now. So by your logic that must be the best hamburger in the market.
Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by simonh on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @04:41AM (#18398082)
Would you suppose that price and convenience might be factors aside from food quality?

This is the thing - narrow single issue analysis that doesn't even acknowledge that other factors of consideration even exist, inevitably will result in conclusions with very limited applicability.

Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by rootusrootus on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @10:31AM (#18391852)
I don't mind the touchbar. It has it's moments. I just wish they had included it in addition to the normal keyboard, rather than replacing the top row.
Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by dwaite on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @01:54PM (#18401251)
I think really the goal was replacing the top row in the first place - the function keys are generally useless except for ancient legacy compatibility, advanced user's macros, and media control.

But the sides of the function keys are the escape and power keys, so the row itself couldn't go away

I wish the Touch Bar was farther offset, 50-100% taller for a better display area, and that the escape and touch id/power buttons were distinct. I also wish there was a standard way for applications to advertise functions for it (I have some really useful tools that are third party, such as mic mute).

Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by wlesieutre on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @09:23AM (#18391187)
I don't dislike the touchbar, I'm just annoyed at having to pay so much for something I'm ambivalent about.
Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by rorykoehler on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @09:56AM (#18391504)
I don't understand why it isn't just an option. If you want it give you can pay for it.
Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by wild_preference on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @11:04AM (#18392158)
Hate it or not, Apple has to make it relatively commonplace if they want macOS apps to bother developing for it instead of ignoring it. Their short-term goal is 100% of MBP users, and surely, eventually 100% of all macOS laptop users.

Keeping it optional indefinitely, then, defeats this goal.

Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by Wowfunhappy on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @12:22PM (#18392946)
Then is it going to come to desktop machines too, where people often use battery-powered Bluetooth keyboards, or peripherals not made by Apple? What about the tiny 12 inch Macbook?

I don't see how this thing is practical across the entire Mac line.

Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by wild_preference on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @02:07PM (#18393976)
The 12-inch Macbook has an F-key row which is what gets replaced with the touch bar.

I only estimated that they were going for 100% laptop coverage. But I can imagine a future where Apple keyboards have a touch bar option. Though not as important because Macbook touch bar penetration can drive developers to integrate with it, alone.

At which point it's not much different than gestures when it comes to answering your questions. What happens when you use a Logitech mouse on your macOS desktop instead of a Magic Trackpad?

Note that touch bar integration cannot have unique features, so it's never required. The challenge is to get developers to care about it which is the prerequisite for users to care about it.

Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by antsar on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @12:26PM (#18392988)
From Apple's perspective, extending this to desktops kills two birds with one stone.

    1. Widespread touchbar adoption
    2. Increased sales of Apple keyboards
Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by copperx on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @12:48PM (#18393211)
I don't see how you can add the Touchbar to desktops without creating a wired keyboard or adding an expensive big battery to it and jacking the price to $200.

Actually, I do: They'll raise the price of the cheapest iMac configuration and include the keyboard in the box. After seeing the starting Mac Mini prices, it makes total sense.

Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by bunderbunder on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @10:33AM (#18391882)
Probably because it can't be made to be "just an option".

Having seen teardowns of a MacBook, I'm pretty sure that one without a touchbar would be more-or-less a completely different computer - different keyboard, yes. To accomplish that, though, you'd need to also make a different housing to accommodate it, and a different motherboard, too, because this stuff's all soldered together as a single unit these days.

And for all that, people would still be griping about the keyboard and the monoport.

Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by robotresearcher on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @10:42AM (#18391967)
They sell a version without a touchbar.

https://www.apple.com/shop/buy-mac/macbook-pro

Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by wlesieutre on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @10:49AM (#18392021)
A low end 2-port version, yes.

They ignored those for the 2018 MBP refresh, probably because the new Macbook Air was coming. I'd bet on the full keyboard MBP getting discontinued now that it's out, or best case having the 2017 hang around while the touchbar models continue to see updates.

Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by dwaite on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @01:57PM (#18401268)
I doubt the "MacBook Escape" (13" non-touchbar) will be revved, because it will either be met by the air or an eventual revved MacBook focusing on ultraportable demographics.

The Escape has higher powered CPUs than the Air or MacBook, but I don't think anyone is buying from those three based on horsepower.

Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by bunderbunder on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @10:57AM (#18392100)
Right. But, echoing what I said, it's not "just an option" - it's a whole different model that they happen to be selling under the same name. Different CPU options, different monitors, different port configuration, etc. They don't even have the same number of microphones.
Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by sigzero on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @09:52AM (#18391459)
Exactly!
Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by stephenr on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @11:06AM (#18392178)
I don't have a problem with the Touch Bar. It's kind of handy for occasional things that are context specific and normally involve using the mouse.
Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by babypuncher on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @12:15PM (#18392886)
I think the thing people have a problem with is the atrocious new keyboard
Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by stephenr on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @12:29PM (#18393019)
It's taking me some time to get used to, I'll grant you that.

I'll be getting a 2018 Mac Mini once they're available for order here, so this machine will see much less use then, just basically if I need to be able to do something while travelling (which isn't that frequent).

Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by Elidrake24 on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @11:12AM (#18392247)
Chiming in to agree that it wasn't a problem here. Though I also never understood why someone would be crazy enough to leave ESC as the default keybinding anyhow.
Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by leoc on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @01:59AM (#18397522)
You'd think that Courage Incorporated would have had the gumption to officially move Escape to where Caps Lock is.
Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by TomVDB on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @11:55AM (#18392681)
Some people use both ESC and Caps Lock all the time.

How else would you bind ESC?

Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by leoc on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @03:10AM (#18397734)
Well, tbh, if it's simply a choice of which key to map to the currently-Caps Lock key then Escape should be the winner even if exiling Caps Lock to the Touch Bar would cause significant annoyance to some heavy users.

However, while users are mostly just faced with perhaps-hard choices about how to remap the given keys, the keyboard manufacturer and integrator Apple had many other options. Caps Lock is currently 2U wide on both ISO and ANSI layouts https://i.ytimg.com/vi/3tJagPz-xIw/maxresdefault.jpg , so it could fairly comfortably be split into a 1U Esc and Caps Lock. You could even give Escape the outside position: that's not a big reach, just the mirror-image of the ISO English # key and more convenient than Esc's existing position in both ANSI and ISO, and there's an arguable case for not putting Esc on too much of a hair-trigger position near the home row anyway. Alternatively you could carve a 1U key out from the right of the right Shift, which is pretty uselessly overlong on both ISO and ANSI.

Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by rthille on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @07:20PM (#18396147)
Caps-Lock is a waste of a key. NeXT had it right by using Command-Shift (without any other keys) to turn on/off Caps-Lock.
Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by TomVDB on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @11:35AM (#18400229)
I learned high speed touch typing in the eighties, with included heavy use of the caps-lock.

There is nothing wasteful about it when you've been trained that way.

Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by cptskippy on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @09:51AM (#18391449)
I don't think that really changed the implication. Regardless of whether he's speaking specifically about the Mac Mini, about Apple products in general, or about the entire industry; he's still saying that it's bucking the trend of "being a series of compromises and disappointments sold as innovation" and that almost everything is genuinely an improvement.
Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by solidr53 on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @01:45PM (#18393752)
I'm going to hold on to my Mid-2015 MacBook Pro for dear life.

I'm hoping it will be good for 3 more years.

Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by lurcio on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @02:04PM (#18393944)
You might be alright - I'm still on a 2009 MBP 13" (4Gb SSD) and a 2010 17" (8Gb, SSD) hands down the best money I ever spent.
Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by nonamenoslogan on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @06:19PM (#18395752)
I'm using a 17" 2010 at work with an i7, SSD upgrade, and 16Gb of RAM and its plenty fast still. At home I've got a 2010 Air that begs for more RAM yet still runs as well as when I bought it including 3+ hours of battery life depending on if I am surfing or writing. 2010-2012 was a high point in Mac laptops.
Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by JohnBooty on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @04:04PM (#18394879)
You're not alone. I actually bought one refurb from Apple this year and I plan on extending the AppleCare to the full 3 years.
Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by bookofjoe on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @09:02PM (#18396628)
My mid-2012 MacBook Pro works like a dream and has never had a problem, FWIW.
Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by Tactic on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @10:20AM (#18391751)
Given the use of the word "donglage" I suspect it was a somewhat snarky reference to the iphone and the disappearing head phone jack.
Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by chaosphere2112 on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @10:25AM (#18391812)
It's actually a reference to the USB-C ecosystem for the laptop line; Marco and his cohosts on the Accidental Tech Podcast have burned a lot of time griping about the state of connecting things to a laptop. Not so much time on the head phone jack, which was mostly a no-op for them (since it was paired with the airpods).
Re:2018 Mac Mini Review by maggit on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @09:52AM (#18391462)
No, that quote is not out of context at all. The expectation that Apple would in some way ruin the Mac Mini in the next update is the topic of several of the first paragraphs in the article. The gist is indeed "It hasn't gotten worse! Yayy!"

Granted, that's not all of it. He is celebrating that it's gotten better, but he is also specifically celebrating that it hasn't lost many advantages.