News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by mabbo on Thursday September 27, 2018 @03:30AM (#18082649)
At what point do we finally draw the line on Oracle and say enough is enough, we're forking?

Oracle clearly seem interested only in trying to exploit Java developer and users. Why are we still stuck to them?

Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by pron on Thursday September 27, 2018 @08:57AM (#18083964)
Not before someone else is willing to fork over hundreds of millions of dollars to sponsor Java. OpenJDK is Big Open Source. The majority of the hundreds of developers building it[1] do it as their day job, and the vast majority of those are employed by Oracle (and others by Red Hat, IBM, Intel and others). Oracle has sponsored OpenJDK for the last 8-9 years, and has now completed open sourcing all of the previously closed bits of the JDK, some dating back to Sun, and some to BEA's JRockit (JFR, now part of OpenJDK 11), not to mention all the new work on the language and JVM including new GCs like ZGC and the new compiler, Graal (I just hope you don't feel too exploited by all this). Companies like Amazon, Netflix, Google, Twitter, Apple and many, many others (some of them have even forked OpenJDK internally) have not contributed significantly, despite depending so heavily on OpenJDK.

So, like it or not, this is the reality of open source. A lot of companies are happy to use it freely but less happy to contribute the significant resources necessary to build it.

(I work at Oracle on OpenJDK, but I speak only on behalf of myself)

[1]: http://openjdk.java.net/census

Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by akerro on Thursday September 27, 2018 @07:31AM (#18083511)
>Why are we still stuck to them?

Because even literally the most used Java library - JUnit is struggling financially, because everyone wants to use great technologies for free and donations and open-source contributions are never considered.

I worked in huge financial institutions once, they heavily relay on some ant plugin. The plugin had a bug, probably like a day of fixing for me. The company decided to stop using the plugin, rewrite the whole configuration in bash, which took almost 4 weeks of 4 people, than contribute to opensource during working hours and fix the bug for everyone.

Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by brookhaven_dude on Thursday September 27, 2018 @10:03AM (#18084551)
How is C++ doing so great then?
Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by pjmlp on Thursday September 27, 2018 @11:37AM (#18085494)
Thanks to the money Apple, Google, IBM, Microsoft, Red-Hat, Intel, Cray, SGI, ARM, HP, Sony, Nintendo, AMD, NVidia, TI,CodePlay... put into ISO work, developer conferences, gcc/clang and their own compilers.
Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by kjeetgill on Thursday September 27, 2018 @03:59AM (#18082745)
I get all the hate for Oracle the company, but they've taken the time to systematically open source every closed source thing they've had: JFR, ZGC, GraalVM (partially), and finally the crown jewel the TCK.

They've even been involved in getting the open community up and running.

I sincerely can't imagine what more you could want from a corporate steward.

Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by CaptainZapp on Thursday September 27, 2018 @04:53AM (#18082969)
I sincerely can't imagine what more you could want from a corporate steward.

A different business model than suing their customers?

Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by tonetheman on Thursday September 27, 2018 @07:14AM (#18083432)
There are not enough upvotes for this comment in the world. Oracle is cesspool.
Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by threeseed on Thursday September 27, 2018 @05:19AM (#18083033)
They are only suing customers who refuse to pay licensing fees or remove offending software.

Don't forget many of their customers are pretty dodgy/incompetent also.

Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by CaptainZapp on Thursday September 27, 2018 @05:32AM (#18083092)
They are only suing customers who refuse to pay licensing fees or remove offending software

https://www.businessinsider.com/oracles-cloud-sales-2015-7

https://www.businessinsider.com/oracle-customer-explains-aud...

Enterprise licensing is extremely complex. Add to that that vendors often play hardball with customers.

If I, as a vendor, want to find you in breach of the licensing agreement. I will.

Source: I worked for a database vendor and was stunned about the dirty tricks pulled in enterprise software sales.

Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by hannasanarion on Thursday September 27, 2018 @06:54AM (#18083368)
They demand their customers pay licencing fees to licenses they don't own, like the Java language itself which is not subject to copyright under US law.

The suit against Google was filed within a month of the Sun acquisition, it was part of their reasoning for buying Sun in the first place: so that they can sue Java users and get tons of money for nothing.

Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by pjmlp on Thursday September 27, 2018 @09:04AM (#18084014)
Sun would have tried to squash Google just as they did before with Microsoft, but they were out of cash, sadly as we could have gotten a proper JavaSE mobile platform instead of the craziness of Android development and incompatibilities with OpenJDK.

Gosling interview on "Oracle vs Google".

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZYw3X4RZv6Y&feature=youtu.be...

Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by geezerjay on Thursday September 27, 2018 @06:10AM (#18083229)
> They are only suing customers who refuse to pay licensing fees or remove offending software.

That's the point: they are suing users because they demand those users pay licensing fees.

What other programming language and/or software stack comes with that risk?

Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by pjmlp on Thursday September 27, 2018 @06:53AM (#18083364)
Delphi, Common Lisp, C, C++, .NET, Smalltalk, SQL Server, Informix, DB 2, Informix, Rational, WebSphere, IBM i, IBM z, ClearPath, Aix, HP-UX,INTEGRITY OS,.....

Basically any software stack sold with a commercial license.

Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by godelmachine on Thursday September 27, 2018 @07:59AM (#18083638)
I am specifically interested in an example that shows C and C++ users were sued. Please do.
Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by pjmlp on Thursday September 27, 2018 @08:58AM (#18083970)
Anyone using pirate versions of Visual Studio, Intel, IBM, HP, TI, ARM,... C and C++ compilers, caught during a software inspection by the respective fiscal authorities.
Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by thanatos_dem on Thursday September 27, 2018 @11:21AM (#18085331)
So no example in particular then?
Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by pjmlp on Thursday September 27, 2018 @11:25AM (#18085370)
If it makes you happy that I don't have access to the press or published reports of all countries where fiscal authorities actually do their job, then no.
Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by godelmachine on Thursday September 27, 2018 @11:46AM (#18085592)
Not that anyone is happy, but at least I am astounded to know that such a thing exists.

I know Oracle had sued Google for using Java some 3 years ago, and that amount ran into billions, but I thought that must be some issue exclusive to Big Corps.

Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by pjmlp on Thursday September 27, 2018 @02:10PM (#18087152)
Yes such a thing does exist.

https://www.bsa.org/?sc_lang=re-EM

https://www.assoft.org/pt/

Occasionally they organize surprise audits in collaboration with the respective countries customs police.

Here is an old report (in Portuguese) about 40 000 illegal copies being caught from several businesses.

https://www.policiajudiciaria.pt/pirataria-informatica/

Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by godelmachine on Thursday September 27, 2018 @02:19PM (#18087256)
>>"managed to seize about 40,000 illegal copies of software" recorded on optical disks "containing : videogames "cinematic" musical works and computer programs "as well as 20 computers with the most sophisticated software and hardware for reproduction. This result was all the more important since "File servers" were dismantled and contributed to the "large-scale" public disclosure of such protected material.

This is just normal piracy as we know it. They don't appear to be developing anything using FOSS like C, C++?

Am I missing anything here?

Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by pjmlp on Friday September 28, 2018 @10:34AM (#18093678)
Yes, that there are commercial compilers for C and C++, products that people actually pay money for.
Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by geezerjay on Thursday September 27, 2018 @07:49AM (#18083579)
Can you state a single example of a Delphy/Common Lisp/C/C++/C# user who has been sued for developing software with those languages?
Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by pjmlp on Thursday September 27, 2018 @07:57AM (#18083621)
Anyone that used pirate versions to sell software and was caught doing it by the national agencies like BSA in UK.
Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by seanhunter on Thursday September 27, 2018 @08:46AM (#18083900)
In what sense do you mean a pirate version of C or C++? The languages are not subject to a license and therefore cannot be pirated. The ISO/ANSI standard is a copyrighted document, but that doesn't mean the language is copyright. There are proprietary runtimes and toolchains and if you're using a proprietary toolchain or runtime without a license then you are indeed violating copyright in exactly the same way as anyone doing this with any other sort of software.

That's not what we're talking about Oracle doing here to users of Java.

Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by pjmlp on Thursday September 27, 2018 @08:55AM (#18083954)
First of all, yes the languages have a ISO copyright, that you are supposed to pay for if you want to get ISO document, even in PDF.

Any compiler writer that wants to write a conformant implementation needs to buy the ISO document, otherwise there is no guarantee that the compiler is actually ISO compliant.

Additionally most compiler vendors that care about ISO certification need to pay extra to companies that sell ISO validation suits like Dinkumware.

Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by betaby on Thursday September 27, 2018 @09:31AM (#18084260)
Drafts and pre-standards are often free. http://www.open-std.org/jtc1/sc22/wg14/www/docs/n1548.pdf for example. This technically it's possible to implement standard compliant implementation without paying.
Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by pjmlp on Thursday September 27, 2018 @11:13AM (#18085258)
In theory yes, in practice there are zero guarantees that the draft and ratified standard are word per word equal.
Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by geezerjay on Thursday September 27, 2018 @11:39AM (#18085511)
So, where are your examples? Do you actually have concrete example of any case remotely similar to Oracle's persecution of Java users? Or will you keep inventing outlandish and unrealistic hypothetical scenarios without any basis on reality?
Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by pjmlp on Thursday September 27, 2018 @02:13PM (#18087185)
The example is very easy, get the latest ISO C++ draft, pay 198 CHF for the final version and do a PDF diff.

https://github.com/cplusplus/draft

https://www.iso.org/standard/68564.html

See I am even saving you the trouble to search where to buy it.

Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by scarface74 on Thursday September 27, 2018 @08:31AM (#18083813)
How do you “pirate” .Net?
Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by pjmlp on Thursday September 27, 2018 @08:44AM (#18083891)
By pirating Visual Studio before .NET went open source.

Express versions were only allowed for education purposes, and only started to be available around Visual Studio 2008.

The original .NET SDK was a bare bones command line SDK without any of the tooling that actually makes development in .NET actually worthwhile.

Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by scarface74 on Thursday September 27, 2018 @01:27PM (#18086695)
The original link is dead, but the following post quotes from it.

https://forums.asp.net/t/1204510.aspx?visual+studio+express+...

Can I use Express Editions for commercial use? Yes, there are no licensing restrictions for applications built using Visual Studio Express Editions.

Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by pjmlp on Thursday September 27, 2018 @02:14PM (#18087199)
Express version did not support Visual Studio plugins.
Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by manigandham on Thursday September 27, 2018 @06:43PM (#18089510)
...so? You can still build applications with it. Obviously functionality will be limited but plugins are not required to get things done.
Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by scarface74 on Thursday September 27, 2018 @03:08PM (#18087655)
Which video studio plugins did you need to do development?

We couldn’t use it in 2008 because we needed to use the Windows Mobile emulator.

Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by pjmlp on Saturday September 29, 2018 @03:30AM (#18099146)
DirectX debugging, IIS integration, SharePoint, architecture modelling tools, database management.
Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by scarface74 on Tuesday October 02, 2018 @06:59PM (#18126421)
IIS integration - you publish your website to IIS

Database management - sql server management studio has always been a free tool.

Architecture modeling tools - not required for development.

Directs debugging - how many enterprise developers are doing anything with DirectX?

Share point - you couldn’t pay me enough to do Sharepoint development. That’s not exactly a popular use case these days.

Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by scarface74 on Thursday September 27, 2018 @07:43AM (#18083551)
You’ve never had to pay a “licensing fee” to use .Net.
Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by pjmlp on Thursday September 27, 2018 @07:55AM (#18083613)
So you were pirating Visual Studio?
Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by scarface74 on Thursday September 27, 2018 @08:28AM (#18083796)
You’ve been able to download msbuild for free for at least 10 years that I’ve been using it. You don’t install Visual Studio on your build server.

But, until .Net Core, .Net was considered a part of Windows. There was no separate license.

As far as the support lifecycle, you get three years of support for the LTS releases of .Net Core and you don’t pay MS for it.

https://www.microsoft.com/net/platform/support-policy

For .Net Framework, it’s tied to the support lifecycle of the version of Windows it was introduced with.

Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by geezerjay on Thursday September 27, 2018 @10:25AM (#18084787)
> You’ve been able to download msbuild for free for at least 10 years that I’ve been using it. You don’t install Visual Studio on your build server.

There is also, of course, projects such as Mono.

I don't recall Mono developers having ever been sued. In fact I recall that the people behind Mono were actually hired and paid a big chunk of cash to work for Microsoft.

Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by pjmlp on Thursday September 27, 2018 @11:28AM (#18085401)
Mono is a partial implementation of .NET, no serious .NET shop ever considered using it for production work until they got bought by Microsoft.

I did several ports from .NET to Java as means to have the software run on UNIX platforms.

Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by shakna on Thursday September 27, 2018 @11:39AM (#18085515)
So the difference is, Microsoft bought Mono, whereas Oracle sued their customers... Still not seeing how using .Net would open me up to a lawsuit, but any Oracle license might.
Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by pjmlp on Thursday September 27, 2018 @02:17PM (#18087234)
"Microsoft filed a lawsuit late Friday against an IP address, alleging that an individual or group of individuals has been using that IP address to illegally activate copies of Windows, Office, and other products without the proper license."

https://www.geekwire.com/2017/microsoft-just-sued-ip-address...

Same thing, Oracle only sued companies using Java licenses illegally.

Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by shakna on Thursday September 27, 2018 @02:40PM (#18087430)
Microsoft suing Comcast for bruteforce-activating thousands of licenses, is not nearly the same as Oracle suing a customer because their definition of general computing is loosely defined.
Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by scarface74 on Thursday September 27, 2018 @12:27PM (#18086048)
And Mono now supports .Net Standard 2.0...
Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by manigandham on Thursday September 27, 2018 @06:47PM (#18089545)
Mono has been used by Xamarin and Unity for years, before any Microsoft acquisition. It's been production ready for a very long time. It's also a freely licensed version, even if you don't like it for whatever reason.
Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by pjmlp on Thursday September 27, 2018 @08:48AM (#18083908)
> You don’t install Visual Studio on your build server.

Ah, you never used Enterprise frameworks with VS plugins it seems.

The joy of building Sharepoint plugins

.NET applications are for the customers, not for running on our computers.

Before it went open source we surely needed Studio to do any kind of meaningful development and respective production deployments.

Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by scarface74 on Thursday September 27, 2018 @09:10AM (#18084064)
And you didn’t have to pay continuing license fees for use or support. I worked for two companies that used Visual 2008 for years after newer versions came out because we had to support ruggedized Windows Mobile devices and that was the last version that supported it.

They just ended support for VS 2008 in April of this year.

https://blogs.msdn.microsoft.com/visualstudio/2017/04/10/end...

Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by HelloNurse on Thursday September 27, 2018 @09:13AM (#18084084)
You are confused. Pirated Visual Studio is like pirated IntelliJ: an advanced and optional development tool, not what everybody but you is discussing.

The new commercial JDK is like Microsoft suddenly asking expensive license fees for using .Net "in production" (which they actually do indirectly, and with clear-cut boundaries, through expensive enterprise Windows SKUs)

Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by scarface74 on Thursday September 27, 2018 @09:19AM (#18084143)
.Net Framework is clearly on life support. .Net Core is the wave of the future. It’s open source, supported for at least 3 years and no license fees...
Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by artimaeis on Thursday September 27, 2018 @10:23AM (#18084753)
The .NET Framework is healthier than ever.

Every revision since 4.5.2 follows the support lifecycle of the parent OS (which generally is much more than 3 years)

.NET Framework has never had a license fee. An argument could be made that part of the cost of Windows OS is a .NET Framework licensing fee, but the fact is if you're developing for Framework then Windows is already in your purview.

Admittedly, the .NET Framework is not open source. But a good amount of its source code is available for review:

https://github.com/Microsoft/referencesource

https://referencesource.microsoft.com/

Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by scarface74 on Thursday September 27, 2018 @05:59PM (#18089168)
I’m not saying .Net Framework is going to be abandoned by Microsoft. But few companies are going to invest money in new .Net Framework initiatives, and Microsoft’s energy is definitely focused on .Net Core and just making sure .Net Framework stays up to date with .Net Standard.

I wouldn’t bet my career on .Net framework or desktop development in general anymore than Webforms.

The last time I was looking for a job, there were companies that offering me architect positions paying $10K - $15K more than the job I accepted to lead projects that were doing ASP.Net MVC, Sql server, etc hosted on IIS using .Net framework.

I saw the writing on the wall, I took a job that was more or less a vertical salary move, and “self demoted” so I could jump on newer tech.

Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by maxlybbert on Thursday September 27, 2018 @08:38AM (#18083855)
Starting with XP, all versions of Windows have included a C# compiler in the .Net framework, if you’re willing to use the command line. And Mono has been usable for most things for a long time. And Microsoft has offered free versions of Visual Studio — which may have feature restrictions, but which can be used for production — for more than a decade. And, if you prefer the command line, you can find free SDKs that include everything you might want.

Although Microsoft makes a lot of money on development tools, it seems to think that giving away versions of those tools can help drive demand for Windows. Sun tried the same thing, but then advertised Java as making the operating system and hardware irrelevant, so free JDKs don’t appear to have sold many Solaris systems.

Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by pjmlp on Thursday September 27, 2018 @08:52AM (#18083934)
99% of the typical .NET apps aren't buildable with that bundled compiler, due to lack of associated tooling, windows services and additional libraries.

Those free versions of Visual Studio weren't allowed for production when they were called Visual Studio Express.

Visual Studio Community only allows production use for companies up to 5 employees, with a specific yearly revenue. Better read the licenses.

Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by scarface74 on Thursday September 27, 2018 @09:14AM (#18084097)
How so? That same tooling is used on the build server that compiles the app. From looking at job postings, .Net on the desktop is basically dead. Most companies that are still using .Net are doing it on the server.
Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by pjmlp on Thursday September 27, 2018 @11:21AM (#18085327)
Completely wrong, WPF is quite active in Europe, specially in health sector for laboratory automation devices, factory management systems, control panels in IoT devices and similar.

And on the server, majority of .NET Web applications are a typically variation of Sharepoint, SiteCore, Orchard and similar CMS, usually deployed on IIS.

.NET Core might do the circles around HN and Reddit, but it is still largely ignored in the typical .NET shops.

Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by geezerjay on Thursday September 27, 2018 @01:09PM (#18086505)
> Completely wrong, WPF is quite active in Europe, specially in health sector for laboratory automation devices, factory management systems, control panels in IoT devices and similar.

That's news to me, and not only I'm from Europe but also I've actually worked on developing UI applications for laboratory equipment.

I have seen zero instances of WPF being used anywhere at all. Ever.

At this point I'm thoroughly convinced that you're just trolling HN and wasting everyone's time with a constant stream of jibberish.

Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by pjmlp on Thursday September 27, 2018 @02:43PM (#18087462)
Ask and you will be served.

https://www.zeiss.com/microscopy/int/products/imaging-system...

https://books.google.de/books?id=U5AMFXjNmugC&pg=PA247&lpg=P...

https://lifesci.com/

https://www.labmanautomation.com/

As for trolling, I find sad that on a web site created for people starting business, many feel entitled to get their tools for free, unlike every other professionals.

Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by scarface74 on Thursday September 27, 2018 @03:21PM (#18087749)
How large is that industry in the grand scheme of things? How many job openings? How much investment in going into making Windows desktop apps in 2018?

You have to compete with the market as it exists. All of the focus of development and all of the money is going into web and mobile. Every platform vendor except Microsoft is giving away their development environment.

I’m a .Net fan but I can’t imagine living in the hell like landscape of doing WPF development knowing that the industry is passing me by.

If I were going to do desktop development in 2018, it’s going to be working in C/C++ writing really specialized, highly optimized software where I could command a huge premium.

Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by pjmlp on Friday September 28, 2018 @10:41AM (#18093736)
Enough to keep people employed, paying their bills and adding up to their pension funds.

Not everyone does fashion driven consultancy development.

Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by scarface74 on Thursday September 27, 2018 @12:33PM (#18086117)
The majority of web apps are SharePoint? I’m far away from the HN bubble and it’s true that .Net Core’s adoption is in its infancy. But the oldest corporate web deployments that people are using is Web Forms, then ASP.Net MVC 3/4 on top of .Net framework and the corresponding Web API framework before they were merged into one with ASP.Net 5 (ASP.Net Core)
Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by pjmlp on Saturday September 29, 2018 @03:32AM (#18099151)
> variation of Sharepoint, SiteCore, Orchard and similar CMS

After the comma I have listed other .NET Web platforms.

Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by thrower123 on Thursday September 27, 2018 @10:18AM (#18084684)
I don't really think that is accurate... There's a lot of desktop .NET development going on still. And for all the buzz that Core is getting, it's still not feature-complete with the 4.5+ full desktop framework.
Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by scarface74 on Thursday September 27, 2018 @01:32PM (#18086756)
Where is all of this desktop .Net development for new projects? There is no momentum for .Net or practically any other desktop development. The only major companies still making any real money on the desktop are Microsoft and Adobe. Anyone else looking for desktop developers are doing internal apps and they are trying to move as quickly to the web as possible.
Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by pjmlp on Thursday September 27, 2018 @02:45PM (#18087483)
Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by maxlybbert on Thursday September 27, 2018 @01:39PM (#18086825)
Those are different terms from what I remember for Express. I don’t know if my memory is faulty or if the switch to Community changed things. Wikipedia says Community was meant to be open source friendly at the expense of some commercial projects.

It looks like today you’re explicitly allowed to use the free Visual Studio for open source work, noncommercial work, academic work, and small commercial work (“small” defined in terms of team size). If that doesn’t cover your project, you have to try to fit in the BizSpark rules for a temporary fee waiver.

Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by artimaeis on Thursday September 27, 2018 @10:29AM (#18084832)
https://web.archive.org/web/20080406140317/http://msdn2.micr...

> 4. Can I use Express Editions for commercial use?

> Yes, there are no licensing restrictions for applications built using the Express Editions.

Visual Studio Express (and now Community) editions have always allowed for commercial development.

Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by pjmlp on Thursday September 27, 2018 @11:31AM (#18085424)
Did you bothered to actually read what is supported regarding enterprise development, the typical .NET customer?
Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by artimaeis on Thursday September 27, 2018 @01:25PM (#18086683)
FTA:

> With Visual C++ 2005 Express you can build both native and managed applications. Using the .NET Framework you can easily create Windows Forms, console, and class library applications. By downloading the Windows Platform SDK (freely available) you can build applications that take full advantage of the Win32 API. Web developers should use Visual Web Developer 2005 Express Edition.

I mean, I'm pretty sure Win Forms, Console apps, and class libraries were all most of us were using .NET for back in 2005 (I wouldn't know for sure as I was in high school still).

Don't get me wrong, there were and are advantages to the non-free versions of Visual Studio. Notably, until 2017 I believe, was extensions. But there's just a lot of misunderstanding in this thread about the general licensing model of .NET and its toolchain.

Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by scarface74 on Thursday September 27, 2018 @01:34PM (#18086769)
I wasn’t in high school and that was all most people were doing.
Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by scarface74 on Thursday September 27, 2018 @12:43PM (#18086208)
What’s missing from the Express Edition that most “enterprise software” needs?
Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by dhd415 on Thursday September 27, 2018 @08:38AM (#18083851)
VS has never been required to develop on the .NET platform. E.g., CSC works fine for C#.
Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by pjmlp on Thursday September 27, 2018 @08:45AM (#18083897)
Developing in .NET is much more than writing CLI apps in C#.
Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by Ygg2 on Thursday September 27, 2018 @04:38AM (#18082909)
> I sincerely can't imagine what more you could want from a corporate steward.

To generally not try to pull the rug from under you by changing licenses?

Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by jerven on Thursday September 27, 2018 @05:21AM (#18083043)
This was not pulling the rug from under you. This was them clearly stating they where going to pull the rug, you ignoring all their shouts, signs and warnings and then blundering. I think the onus is on us for not reading and listening.
Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by giancarlostoro on Thursday September 27, 2018 @06:13AM (#18083237)
Meanwhile .NET Core is MIT Licensed and the language spec for C# is still standardized and open to re-implement (hence something like Vala is possible). If you didn't want to drink Microsoft's koolaid it's free as in free beer and as in freedom, can't say the same about Oracles.
Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by pjmlp on Thursday September 27, 2018 @06:55AM (#18083370)
.NET Core is a nice step from Microsoft, but even 2.1 still only supports a fraction of .NET enterprise software, let alone Java comparable software solutions and host platforms.
Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by giancarlostoro on Thursday September 27, 2018 @07:04AM (#18083401)
We're roughly what 3 years in? It's to be expected, but what it does currently support is fairly impressive. Having used ASP .NET Core on a couple of projects I would say it covers enough for web development, right after Python I'd much rather do web development in C# as a result.

I do agree though it isn't a completed product yet, but what's already there is fairly capable depending on what you're working on.

Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by pjmlp on Thursday September 27, 2018 @07:14AM (#18083437)
It is impressive, and I do spend most of my time on it, but there is still lots of work to be done.

.NET 3.0 will close the gap, but there are lots of .NET Framework features that aren't even on the migration roadmap.

Enterprise stacks are a different animal than plain web sites, where integration between existing platforms plays a major role.

The likes of SAP, Oracle, Rational, Enterprise Architect and similar software are not yet there.

Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by filomeno on Thursday September 27, 2018 @10:45AM (#18084990)
Well, OpenJDK is also free in both ways, GPL licensed, so I don't think there's any difference.
Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by solarkraft on Thursday September 27, 2018 @08:09AM (#18083692)
Can you explain how Vala builds on C#?
Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by giancarlostoro on Thursday September 27, 2018 @08:25AM (#18083774)
It's mostly inspired by the syntax of C# but the spec of C# is standardized so I could see them or someone else going further with it. The real value in C# is the underlying stack aka the .NET Framework that gives you all the tools and toys to get things done.
Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by saturn_vk on Thursday September 27, 2018 @07:30AM (#18083510)
You are thinking of Mono. Vala is a completely different language
Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by giancarlostoro on Thursday September 27, 2018 @09:03AM (#18084007)
Mono recreates the framework, I'm thinking of the syntax of C# not the run-time.
Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by pron on Thursday September 27, 2018 @12:15PM (#18085879)
The change of license was closed source -> open source. It's legitimate that you don't like open source but still, how is that "pulling the rug"?
Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by kodablah on Thursday September 27, 2018 @08:36AM (#18083840)
> but they've taken the time to systematically open source

Most of that is so they could wash their hands from the maintenance burden.

> finally the crown jewel the TCK

Can you give me more info here? I heard about EE, but I was not aware the full Java TCK (i.e. the one denied to Apache Harmony) is completely open now.

> I sincerely can't imagine what more you could want from a corporate steward

Simple, don't try to profit from the language itself. Imagine a commercial Go version, or imagine if some AOT parts of the .Net compiler were part of an enterprise edition, or imagine if a test suite for WASM compliance were selectively given only to some, etc.

Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by skgoa on Thursday September 27, 2018 @04:48AM (#18082948)
> Oracle clearly seem interested only in trying to exploit Java developer and users.

Oracle are just not giving users of obsolete, deprecated versions of Java free patches anymore. They want everyone to keep up to date with the current version. The likes of Apple, Microsoft and Google just force push updates to achieve the same goal, but Oracle doesn't have that kind of control.

Yet even though Oracle don't want to support old versions anymore, they still offer support contracts for those organizations that truly need it. Which is a completely normal thing in the tech industry. What part of that is exploitation?

Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by Nursie on Thursday September 27, 2018 @06:12AM (#18083235)
> Oracle are just not giving users ... free patches anymore

IIRC they are also making commercial (non-development) use of Oracle JVMs 11+ something that they will charge for.

I don't think this was true of earlier versions.

Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by repolfx on Thursday September 27, 2018 @08:38AM (#18083850)
Lots of people are so confused by all this.

From Java 11 onwards the "Oracle JVM" is exactly the same as the "OpenJDK JVM". The only difference is that one has the Oracle name on it and if you buy it, has long term commercial support.

It's actually the other way around to what you think. Earlier versions had proprietary features you had to pay for. Now there are no proprietary features anymore. The only thing you pay for is support.

Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by Nursie on Thursday September 27, 2018 @09:35AM (#18084289)
> The only difference is that one has the Oracle name on it and if you buy it, has long term commercial support.

And that you need to pay for it if you want to deploy the "Oracle" version. It's not optional paid support.

I am aware Oracle produce both, and that the OpenJDK build is every bit as 'official', I have no problem with this.

Please don't call me confused, my original statement is still true - Oracle branded JVMs will no longer be free for production use.

Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by yourapostasy on Thursday September 27, 2018 @12:25PM (#18086015)
> ...Oracle branded JVMs will no longer be free for production use.

I was confused by the indignation in this thread. A JetBrains blog post [1] seems to say that if you have been coasting on OpenJDK in production, as long as you don't plan to use any OracleJDK-specific features now or in the future, and as long as you use Java 11 in all your implementations, then the license change is not a material difference to you. Not supporting older Java specs for free sounds reasonable to me, is there something wrong with that posture that someone can care to enlighten me upon?

[1] https://blog.jetbrains.com/idea/2018/09/using-java-11-in-pro...

Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by Nursie on Thursday September 27, 2018 @12:37PM (#18086150)
I'm honestly not sure either.

I'm just noting the change in licensing. As I mentioned in the other fork of this thread we're going to move from Oracle 8 to OpenJDK 11 soon, and that's great. No problem at all.

Literally all I've tried to say is that there is a license change on the Oracle branded version, and you need to take note of it if you have been using the Oracle branded version and were going to continue. This is not really a complaint!

I'm not sure why this seems to be controversial.

Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by brown9-2 on Thursday September 27, 2018 @08:42AM (#18083876)
The “free” Oracle JDK is also coming with a license that limits its usage, which is what the parent poster is referring to.
Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by repolfx on Thursday September 27, 2018 @08:46AM (#18083901)
Yes but my point is (and I do think their branding is dumb here), there's no difference between Oracle JDK and OpenJDK anymore except the name.

Simple rule: if it has "Oracle" in the front now, you have to pay to use it in production. If it has "Open" you don't.

Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by pjmlp on Thursday September 27, 2018 @06:57AM (#18083377)
It was, many Oracle JDK features were only freely available for development, like the Flight Control, for example.
Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by Nursie on Thursday September 27, 2018 @09:36AM (#18084307)
> many Oracle JDK features were only freely available for development,

Sure, but you could use the Oracle-branded JVM in production, AFAICT, for free before.

Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by krzyk on Thursday September 27, 2018 @09:47AM (#18084411)
But the difference between Oracle branded and OpenJDK is almost non-existent anymore.

Do you use Oracle specific features that are not in OpenJDK?

Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by Nursie on Thursday September 27, 2018 @09:56AM (#18084494)
No, and we'll be fine moving to an OpenJDK build when we move to Java 11 (from 8) in a month or so.

Please don't mistake my comments for complaints - I'm just noting that things have changed in the licensing terms for Oracle-branded JVMs.

There is an easy and simple way forward, to use OpenJDK, it's important to note the change and act accordingly. That's all.

Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by MaxBarraclough on Thursday September 27, 2018 @04:27AM (#18082863)
> At what point do we finally draw the line on Oracle and say enough is enough, we're forking?

But we already have OpenJDK. What would be gained by completely cutting ties with Oracle?

Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by afroboy on Thursday September 27, 2018 @07:23AM (#18083476)
And who is going to pay the great minds behind JVM? you are missing the point that there is great engineers working on Java that need high pay and apparently only Oracle that can do that. see GraalVM as an example of how Java become more good under Oracle yes Oracle is evil but for god sake they are the best thing happened to java (the language and the JVM).
Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by pjmlp on Thursday September 27, 2018 @06:47AM (#18083348)
When you get the money to pay the Oracle engineers working on JVM and Graal.

Also apparently many have a short memory regarding Sun and IBM's Java business pratices and hating Oracle is fun.

Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by tajen on Thursday September 27, 2018 @06:50AM (#18083357)
But not acting could be worse, it could ruin the whole sector of Java, Scala and the JVM, be it discredit or economic irrelevance.
Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by oblio on Thursday September 27, 2018 @03:35AM (#18082665)
They own the trademark, they own the TCK and Java itself is a huge amount of tech, not something easy to fork.

Plus it would be really hard to get adoption for the fork. The Java brand is huge and many of its users are late adopters or even laggards.

Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by kjeetgill on Thursday September 27, 2018 @03:54AM (#18082728)
The TCK was recently open sourced!
Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by kodablah on Thursday September 27, 2018 @08:40AM (#18083861)
Link? Surely we're talking about the regular TCK to confirm my Java impl is compliant and not EE.
Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by alanfranzoni on Thursday September 27, 2018 @10:50AM (#18085040)
Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by kodablah on Thursday September 27, 2018 @11:02AM (#18085163)
That's EE. Not the TCK that people have complained about their subjective licensing of (e.g. Apache Harmony). When they really open the TCK, that would be nice. In the meantime, this is just for EE stuff of which licensing matters little these days.
Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by oblio on Thursday September 27, 2018 @04:02AM (#18082761)
Oh, interesting. Didn't know that.
Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by krzyk on Thursday September 27, 2018 @09:50AM (#18084441)
Why do you need to fork OpenJDK? You can just contribute there.

I don't see why the uproar about Oracle branded OpenJDK. We can use normal OpenJDK which is almost the same.

Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by adrianmonk on Thursday September 27, 2018 @01:53PM (#18086977)
There is a big trade-off to consider here.

Previously, Oracle supplied the engineering resources to develop new features and to maintain old releases.

Now, Oracle provides the first but not the second. The community can step in and do the second. If it is forked, then the community needs to step in and do both.

So getting free of Oracle has a cost, the cost of losing engineering resources for new features. Whether it's worth it would depend on how much value you place on those two things.

Clearly Oracle is trying to steer people toward revenue-generating things. I don't see a problem with that in and of itself, especially if the community can provide a free alternative.

It seems like this could push things either direction. On the one hand, many companies may just pay Oracle for support and that may become a common (and expected) practice. So that would shift some control toward Oracle. On the other hand, Oracle is stimulating the community to get involved in maintenance, and that may build some momentum for community contributions, causing the community a larger role in Java development, which would shift some control away from Oracle.

Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by Pyxl101 on Thursday September 27, 2018 @04:21AM (#18082841)
The latest versions of Java will continue to be free. All you need to do to "pay" for that is remain up to date. Only maintenance on older versions of Java will be subscription based.

Why is Oracle obliged to provide long-term binary support and updates for old free software? If you want long-term support for old Java versions, then I think it's reasonable to say: pay for a subscription (or don't complain). RedHad uses a similar business model.

Or keep using the latest versions which will continue to be free, and stay up to date. It seems like a reasonable proposition to me. I don't see what Oracle has done wrong here.

Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by keypusher on Thursday September 27, 2018 @05:24AM (#18083052)
The complaints have nothing to do with staying up to date or support. OracleJDK is no longer free for commercial use. OpenJDK has always been been free for whatever use (it's GPL, with exceptions). The danger is that a developer is already using OracleJDK, and upgrades or inadvertently uses OracleJDK (because it was installed by their package manager perhaps), and then Oracle shows up and claims they owe a bunch of money.
Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by pjmlp on Thursday September 27, 2018 @07:00AM (#18083384)
Anyone with professional experience knows that licenses aren't set in stone, which is why any sane legal department does routine control of existing software deployments.
Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by filomeno on Thursday September 27, 2018 @10:49AM (#18085024)
Lol, I wish I could keep getting my _Oracle_ JDK updated from the package manager. Unfortunately that stopped being a thing after Java6 with some licensing changes that made it impossible for distributions to package Java (if I recall correctly).
Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by repolfx on Thursday September 27, 2018 @08:42AM (#18083879)
Oracle JDK has never been "packagable" in that way. Some people did it anyway or they hard-coded cookies into scripts and things, but those scripts and packages are all for fixed versions anyway. Linux distros do it right and ship OpenJDK. They'll upgrade to OpenJDK 11 without issue.

As far as I can tell Hacker News and reddit are overrun with hysterical developers who are desperate to believe Oracle is evil, but whose entire rationale boils down to "but I don't want to read I just want to download whatever I randomly find on the internet", a rationale that is oddly not sympathised with when open source license violations occur.

Oracle JDK doesn't even have any DRM or other controls to ensure license compliance, it's all trust based. And the download page even tells you to go download OpenJDK if you want the GPLd non-commercially-supported version. I'm starting to understand now why companies have to audit their customers. Apparently the world is full of employees who feel it's perfectly legitimate to ignore straightforward, trust based license agreements out of some odd sense of entitlement?

Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by danieldk on Thursday September 27, 2018 @04:26AM (#18082856)
The latest versions of Java will continue to be free. All you need to do to "pay" for that is remain up to date. Only maintenance on older versions of Java will be subscription based.

Only free for non-production use. This was on HN yesterday:

https://blog.joda.org/2018/09/do-not-fall-into-oracles-java-...

Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by Pyxl101 on Thursday September 27, 2018 @04:35AM (#18082896)
I believe you're mistaken. The article is saying that there are two versions of Java, and one has the license that you mentioned while the other is free and open source. From that article:

https://blog.joda.org/2018/09/do-not-fall-into-oracles-java-...

> As well as their commercial JDK, Oracle produce an OpenJDK build. It is $free, zero-cost and GPL licensed (with Classpath exception so safe for commercial use). Download $free Java here: https://jdk.java.net/11/

jdk.java.net/11 in turn says:

> This page provides production-ready open-source builds of the Java Development Kit, version 11, an implementation of the Java SE 11 Platform under the GNU General Public License, version 2, with the Classpath Exception.

Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by smarx007 on Thursday September 27, 2018 @05:11AM (#18083007)
Exactly! https://www.oracle.com/technetwork/java/javase/downloads/jdk... clearly says in a RED box that

"With JDK 11 Oracle has updated the license terms on which we offer the Oracle JDK. The new Oracle Technology Network License Agreement for Oracle Java SE is substantially different from the licenses under which previous versions of the JDK were offered. Please review the new terms carefully before downloading and using this product.

Oracle also offers this software under the GPL License on jdk.java.net/11"

Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by balefrost on Thursday September 27, 2018 @10:19AM (#18084699)
To be fair, the relevant quote from that article (and from the terms) is:

> You may not: use the Programs for any data processing or any commercial, production, or internal business purposes other than developing, testing, prototyping, and demonstrating your Application;

Which seems to suggest that you can use the Oracle JDK to develop, test, prototype, and demonstrate your application, even in a commercial setting. You just can't run Oracle JDK in production without a license. But IANAL.

As for the JRE, I haven't really kept up. I'm not sure if there will be a separate Oracle JRE11 and what its license terms will be. Right now, only JDK11 is posted for download.

Re:The future of Java and OpenJDK updates without Oracle sup... by grigjd3 on Thursday September 27, 2018 @11:17AM (#18085306)
Hard to ditch Java if you run hdfs and anything built on top of that.