News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:YouTube and Netflix ‘Throttled’ by Carriers by scarejunba on Wednesday September 05, 2018 @10:51AM (#17918480)
Part of the problem is that when you point out things like this, Americans on the Internet frequently react as if you are insulting their nation and invent nonsensical reasons for why their Internet must be slow.
Re:YouTube and Netflix ‘Throttled’ by Carriers by toasterlovin on Wednesday September 05, 2018 @12:29PM (#17919462)
The flip side of this is that there's a contingent of Europeans who look down their noses as Americans, while having basically no comprehension of how utterly ridiculous it is to do something like compare the United States to Switzerland on any metric.
Re:YouTube and Netflix ‘Throttled’ by Carriers by phobosdeimos on Wednesday September 05, 2018 @01:11PM (#17919945)
As I see it people in the US believe that the whole of the country needs to be treated equally. If you live in rural Kentucky your internet speed has to be the same as someone who lives in NYC. Pointing out that New York is the economic engine the US runs on and deserves to get priority makes everyone upset.
Re:YouTube and Netflix ‘Throttled’ by Carriers by brightball on Wednesday September 05, 2018 @01:46PM (#17920303)
Let me fix this for you:

Nobody likes to hear that they are lower on the priority totem pole, however, everybody understands when new businesses go after the biggest markets first.

If somebody is going to be upset by investing first in the areas with the most people...then you really have to disregard their point of view.

I live in a rural suburb and have had one of those cell-phone-over-ethernet setups in my house to handle the poor signal. I understand.

Re:YouTube and Netflix ‘Throttled’ by Carriers by phlakaton on Wednesday September 05, 2018 @01:34PM (#17920189)
I think you could not be more incorrect about this. The FCC does sponsor efforts to make sure that less developed areas are getting broadband. However, I would argue that this is similar to electrification programs a century ago, and is more about access than equality.

From my experience, Americans care very much about what speed and reliability is available within their neighborhood. They care very little about access outside of their neighborhood.

Re:YouTube and Netflix ‘Throttled’ by Carriers by weberc2 on Wednesday September 05, 2018 @01:19PM (#17920030)
I thought the meme was that Americans were fiercely individualistic and that Europeans were outcome-egalitarians? Of course the picture is more nuanced than that, but I've never heard the reverse before.
Re:YouTube and Netflix ‘Throttled’ by Carriers by scarejunba on Wednesday September 05, 2018 @01:18PM (#17920024)
There most certainly are a bunch of Europeans who act holier than thou. That's silly on their part. But you most certainly can compare the countries.

Their relative differences are factors in the comparison. The US also has smaller administrative units you can compare with other countries with appropriate caveats.

Re:YouTube and Netflix ‘Throttled’ by Carriers by toasterlovin on Wednesday September 05, 2018 @03:59PM (#17921394)
You're not getting this at all. They are incomparable at so many levels:

1. There is a vast difference in population density, total population size, and total land mass, as discussed up thread.

2. Switzerland has a homogenous culture that has been extant for several hundred of years at a minimum and you could make an argument for over a thousand years. The western half of the US wasn't settled by Europeans until 150 years ago.

3. The U.S. has had both massive immigration from abroad as well as massive internal migration for the last 200 years. Aside from a few cities in the north east and south, there is essentially nowhere near the level of cultural continuity in the US that exists in most European countries.

4. Aside from the shared language, the cultural differences between various regions of the US are akin to the differences between Western, Southern, and Eastern Europe. Do Hungary and Germany agree on most political issues? Do Sweden and Italy?

5. The US culture is dominated by a settler/pioneer mentality because, up until about 50 years ago, if things weren't great wherever you were, you just uprooted yourself and moved West to find new opportunities. Nobody has been able to do this in Europe at a comparable scale for 1000+ years.

6. Switzerland does not have anywhere near the level of racial heterogeneity that the U.S. has. Not only does the US have a huge, underprivileged ethnic group that is descended from slaves, we have obtained a new huge underprivileged ethnic group in the last 60 years.

[edit] 7. Almost forgot to add: most US infrastructure, especially on the West Coast, was built during the automobile era.

So, no, they are not even remotely comparable.

Re:YouTube and Netflix ‘Throttled’ by Carriers by GW150914 on Wednesday September 05, 2018 @04:12PM (#17921508)
What do 2-6 have to do with the actual subject of telecommunications? I’m not even going to bother with the details of 2-6, I’m just curious what point in context you thought you were making.
Re:YouTube and Netflix ‘Throttled’ by Carriers by toasterlovin on Wednesday September 05, 2018 @04:36PM (#17921682)
Telecommunications are infrastructure, building out or changing infrastructure requires political will and collective coordination. It’s much, much harder to gather political will in a place as politically and culturally heterogeneous as the US.
Re:YouTube and Netflix ‘Throttled’ by Carriers by wdr1 on Wednesday September 05, 2018 @11:41AM (#17918943)
> Americans on the Internet frequently react as if you are insulting their nation

I'm surprised someone on HN would make such an overly broad, and with it, inaccurate statement.

Personally, I've seen a lot of debate. Not all of it constructive, but rarely (if ever) anything like "omg, you bastard. #murica ruelz"

Re:YouTube and Netflix ‘Throttled’ by Carriers by scarejunba on Wednesday September 05, 2018 @12:11PM (#17919272)
It's rarely that. It's usually a superficially constructive claim - America can't do it because it's not dense, America can't do it because it's too populous, America can't do it because its cities are too dense or too sparse or too far apart or too old or too new, America can't do it because Americans prefer what they have.

They'll usually have some irrelevant statistics. Presumably total population, total surface area, some other such superficial analysis.

I never engage in these discussions. This is the first time, and probably the last. But I've seen them time and time again.

Re:YouTube and Netflix ‘Throttled’ by Carriers by tracker1 on Wednesday September 05, 2018 @07:27PM (#17922718)
It probably should be left to individual states to work out to a large extent. That said, I really do think that common carrier rules should have been applied and stuck to very early on.
Re:YouTube and Netflix ‘Throttled’ by Carriers by ucaetano on Wednesday September 05, 2018 @11:49AM (#17919025)
> someone on HN would make such an overly broad, and with it, inaccurate statement

You must be new here!

Re:YouTube and Netflix ‘Throttled’ by Carriers by drharby on Wednesday September 05, 2018 @12:09PM (#17919248)
I really dislike the double standard on HN. Such statements are given an echo chamber effect if it fits a certain narrative.

Sure, something can be said about inherent community biases and the like, but it doesn't change the fact that minority opinions are drowned out many times while noncontributing noise is upboated bc it pokes fun at America, Trump, Bezos, or whatever boogeyman exists.

But here we arw

Re:YouTube and Netflix ‘Throttled’ by Carriers by GW150914 on Wednesday September 05, 2018 @12:21PM (#17919375)
Re:YouTube and Netflix ‘Throttled’ by Carriers by Trav5 on Wednesday September 05, 2018 @11:41AM (#17918947)
Not all of us. The US is great, but not perfect. I love hearing about how other places are better. It gives hope and a goal for improvement here.

I pay $435/month for my office and home internet as well as 3 mobile phones.

Re:YouTube and Netflix ‘Throttled’ by Carriers by munk-a on Wednesday September 05, 2018 @02:38PM (#17920774)
Wat.

In Canada I pay a total of 88$/month for home internet and 2 mobile phones, with the internet being high capacity and pretty fast even for large data transfers.

That is CAD as well, so that's about 66$ USD

Re:YouTube and Netflix ‘Throttled’ by Carriers by ionised on Friday September 07, 2018 @07:19AM (#17933399)
$435 per month just on internet!?
Re:YouTube and Netflix ‘Throttled’ by Carriers by Trav5 on Saturday September 15, 2018 @12:43PM (#17994929)
$30 of that is for an iPhone contract, so really only $405... $145 for office, $75 for home, the rest is for mobiles.
Re:YouTube and Netflix ‘Throttled’ by Carriers by ectospheno on Wednesday September 05, 2018 @10:57AM (#17918544)
I'm an American and I understand why my internet is slow. So do all of my friends and coworkers. What do you propose we actually do about it?
Re:YouTube and Netflix ‘Throttled’ by Carriers by scarejunba on Wednesday September 05, 2018 @11:12AM (#17918681)
Support things like this https://savecompetition.com and similar initiatives that are constantly being brought up. Enable providers like Sonic to survive by telling your representatives.
Re:YouTube and Netflix ‘Throttled’ by Carriers by skh on Wednesday September 05, 2018 @11:08AM (#17918655)
Vote and encourage others to vote. Also, it’s worth pointing out comparisons to Europe and Japan to help dispel the myth that we are a shining light to the rest of the world and that we are number 1.
Re:YouTube and Netflix ‘Throttled’ by Carriers by Teknoman117 on Wednesday September 05, 2018 @11:50AM (#17919035)
As an American I really wish I had enough money to start my own ISP which had ground rules that all it'd ever be is an internet provider with the sole goal of continuously improving internet service.
Re:YouTube and Netflix ‘Throttled’ by Carriers by js2 on Wednesday September 05, 2018 @12:46PM (#17919651)
It requires some money and resources obviously, but neither do you need to be Google or a Telco to setup an ISP:

About a year ago, FOA was contacted by Greg Turton of Cordele, GA. who was curious about what was involved in creating a FTTH network. Greg is a real estate developer who also owns several local hotels. Where he lives and builds homes is way outside of a service area that anybody wants to build good broadband, forget FTTH. Cordele itself has a population of only about 15,000 and is one of those small cities along the Interstate highway that are everywhere in the US.

We answered Greg's questions and led him to some of the FOA Guide web pages and YouTube videos about FTTH to get him started. More conversations discussed how to get connections as an ISP, types of components and suppliers, etc. Fortunately the local electrical utility has lots of fiber but they were restricted from building their own FTTH network because Georgia was one of 19 states where lobbyists for the incumbent providers got laws passed restricting their ability to operate a FTTH system themselves. But they were more than willing to lease dark fiber to Greg at really good rates. And there were good choices on getting an Internet connection.

...

http://www.thefoa.org/tech/ref/appln/FTTH-DIY.html

Re:YouTube and Netflix ‘Throttled’ by Carriers by kuwze on Wednesday September 05, 2018 @12:55PM (#17919784)
You might want to checkout the YC startup Necto[0].

[0]: https://apply.nectolab.io/

Re:YouTube and Netflix ‘Throttled’ by Carriers by thx11389793 on Wednesday September 05, 2018 @12:02PM (#17919165)
my cursory research seems to indicate that it's pretty reasonable to start a local wireless ISP, with a lower bound wrt minimum number of clients to make the venture worth it being 50 or so according to someone.
Re:YouTube and Netflix ‘Throttled’ by Carriers by jessaustin on Wednesday September 05, 2018 @01:23PM (#17920067)
Shut down FCC. That's all it would take.

Sure, your FM radio would stop working, but that's a small sacrifice to make, to get actual competition in something as important as telecommunications.

Re:YouTube and Netflix ‘Throttled’ by Carriers by jsgo on Wednesday September 05, 2018 @01:39PM (#17920246)
Dunno, having an actor to oversee the behavior of telecoms would be an advantage, not the opposite.

In our neighborhood, we're waiting on Spectrum to finish their infrastructure install. We were initially in talks with AT&T to come in too, but they backed out when we couldn't do community agreements (beyond easement) again and we wouldn't agree to them using the existing infrastructure (which was terrible) from the previous provider below. No other provider, asides from HughesNet, is willing to come in now that there is a non-exclusive agreement with Spectrum for easement access. Moral of the story, companies aren't going to act with consumers' interests at heart. Didn't Charter or someone have some agreement where part of some merger approval required that they built out into rural areas? A requirement they didn't comply with?

The provider we had before was absolutely terrible with $90/month spent on a basic DishTV package + 3Mbps internet. They had an exclusive easement, but due to constant outages because the infrastructure couldn't support the community, we were able to finally get out of it after 6 years and lots of lawyer involvement. FCC wouldn't get involved, but having the government take a more active oversight role would be a good thing, in my experience.

Re:YouTube and Netflix ‘Throttled’ by Carriers by jessaustin on Wednesday September 05, 2018 @01:58PM (#17920414)
The fact that no provider will serve this neighborhood without exclusivity is contingent upon the woeful state of telecom competition in USA. If it were regulated like e.g. automobiles (basic requirements, but nothing about a particular vendor "owning" some portion of the market or the road), then you'd have a choice of WISPs. You might not get a wired connection, depending on density etc. As you can see from the European contributions to this thread, wireless can actually be very good. If the neighbors wanted to go in together for a really big fat wireless connection in higher portions of the spectrum, the "last block" could still be wired. That would be an easy upgrade to fiber once that made sense. Market forces would still govern that deal, because of those WISPs.
Re:YouTube and Netflix ‘Throttled’ by Carriers by eigenloss on Wednesday September 05, 2018 @01:27PM (#17920105)
This is the worst solution posed here. If we had no FCC, large companies would be thrown into an arms race to pump as much RF as possible into the air while smaller ones (radio stations, anybody?) would simply be drowned out and crushed.
Re:YouTube and Netflix ‘Throttled’ by Carriers by jessaustin on Wednesday September 05, 2018 @01:34PM (#17920183)
Just like in the wifi band... oh, wait.

I'm not saying that radio use can't be regulated. I'm saying that FCC is the worst possible organization that could be imagined to do that regulation. To understand that, simply compare Europe to USA.

Re:YouTube and Netflix ‘Throttled’ by Carriers by GW150914 on Wednesday September 05, 2018 @01:34PM (#17920191)
Shut down FCC. That's all it would take. Sure, your FM radio would stop working, but that's a small sacrifice to make, to get actual competition in something as important as telecommunications.

Good idea, I was just thinking that I hate how emergency services can talk to each other, and my cellphone works. People are so damned soft, they should have to release a homing pigeon if they want to call 911! Sure, a few people might die and life will be a dark and terrible nightmare of RF interference, radio astronomy will end, and modern civilization will grind to a halt, but that’s a small price to pay for my libertarian wet dream.

Re:YouTube and Netflix ‘Throttled’ by Carriers by jessaustin on Wednesday September 05, 2018 @02:12PM (#17920520)
FCC is uniquely bad among USA government regulatory agencies. I'm fine with EPA, FTC, OSHA, FAA, etc. All of those place reasonable limits on human action. They don't say, "this market will be 40% VZN and 45% ATT!" Any number of other agencies could keep the emergency services bands online. Most of the actual regulation of how devices radiate signals is already controlled by voluntary associations of manufacturers.

Please don't discuss your wet dreams in this forum.

Re:YouTube and Netflix ‘Throttled’ by Carriers by plandis on Wednesday September 05, 2018 @03:49PM (#17921319)
The person legitimately asking for differences in the two countries has yet to be given an answer, if you’d like to constructively answer instead making broad generalizations about users from entire countries.
Re:YouTube and Netflix ‘Throttled’ by Carriers by drharby on Wednesday September 05, 2018 @11:08AM (#17918658)
That's ignorant of you to say
Re:YouTube and Netflix ‘Throttled’ by Carriers by frockington on Wednesday September 05, 2018 @11:04AM (#17918614)
I pay ~$25/month for my phone. My internet is slower because I don't care about watching Netflix or youtube on my phone, but I could pay more if I wanted. As an American, I don't really care what Europe has because it in no way affects me. I would suspect most Americans also don't care about Europe as it is an ocean away and is made up of tiny nations that most Americans couldn't be bothered to spell
Re:YouTube and Netflix ‘Throttled’ by Carriers by tw04 on Wednesday September 05, 2018 @11:06AM (#17918638)
When providers are claiming they CAN'T do something, you absolutely should care when half of the Western world already has that thing they claim can't be provided...
Re:YouTube and Netflix ‘Throttled’ by Carriers by peterwwillis on Wednesday September 05, 2018 @11:57AM (#17919093)
There are significant logistical differences between the US and Switzerland.

One has 327 million people and an area of 9.8 million square kilometers (36 people per Km2). The other has 8.4 million people and 41 thousand square kilometers (216 people per Km2).

Switzerland has one of the highest and fastest internet penetration rates in Europe. If you rent an apartment, cable is often thrown in as part of the cost. The rest of the people's landlines are ADSL (which isn't very fast unless you use the latest ADSL2 dslams), or VDSL, which you can only get if you're very close to a CO. Finally, fiber is easier to roll out when you have a smaller population in a smaller area.

Most Americans cannot get VDSL, and the DSLAMs are old. Cable is pretty fast, and fiber is slowly getting rolled out, but it's a big freaking country, meaning this is expensive as hell.

The mobile providers in Switzerland only have to provide a very small number of broadband equipment and mobile towers compared to that needed to cover the US. Also, the same equipment used in Switzerland covers up to 6x more subscribers, because of increased population density.

The US has to provide much more equipment and installation over a much larger area to cover a comparatively smaller number of subscribers. So you have to literally buy more equipment to cover more area, and then you make less money because the equipment covers less subscribers on average. Upgrading the equipment then also becomes significantly more expensive.

One is extremely expensive, time-consuming and difficult to cover with high speed broadband, the other is not.

Re:YouTube and Netflix ‘Throttled’ by Carriers by einr on Wednesday September 05, 2018 @12:06PM (#17919212)
There are significant logistical differences between the US and Switzerland.

One has 327 million people and an area of 9.8 million square kilometers (36 people per Km2). The other has 8.4 million people and 41 thousand square kilometers (216 people per Km2).

Okay, but here in Sweden, with a population density of 22 people/km2, my mobile 4G internet plan has unlimited data, unlimited calls and messages for $55/month. I use it for both my phone and my 4G router at home. It's my only Internet connection since I live in a very rural place (a village of ~150 inhabitants in the north). I get about 13 Mbps downloads -- it would be much better if I was closer to a tower.

In cities in Sweden, which are all very small and not very dense, you can usually get 100 or 1000 Mbps fibre connections for something like $40 a month.

I am also not aware of a single cell data provider in Sweden that has ever tried to disable or charge for tethering.

Re:YouTube and Netflix ‘Throttled’ by Carriers by peterwwillis on Wednesday September 05, 2018 @12:30PM (#17919477)
Sweden has the 4th highest internet usage in the world, the 5th highest mobile broadband usage in the world, and the second fastest average internet speeds. So, you may not be the best comparison either.

In Wyoming, USA, the population density is 2.31/km2. But 100% of the people can get at least 10Mbps internet, 79% have >25Mbps internet. But again, big states, bigger country, and due to both governmental differences, differences in internet providers, and the different costs of providing service in different regions, we don't spread the cost of service out evenly.

It looks really easy when you're looking at the problem from 40,000 feet. On the ground, it's much more complicated.

I don't get the deal with tethering here, either, but I think there are probably reasons for it. If any provider here just threw tethering in for free, while undercutting the cost of the competitors, people would flock to them. The fact that this doesn't happen means it's probably hard to make money on it, for reasons unknown.

Re:YouTube and Netflix ‘Throttled’ by Carriers by usefulcat on Wednesday September 05, 2018 @12:47PM (#17919657)
I've had tethering for years from t-mobile in the US. I've had at least two different plans over that time, and I don't recall ever having to explicitly request it or pay extra to get it.
Re:YouTube and Netflix ‘Throttled’ by Carriers by peterwwillis on Wednesday September 05, 2018 @03:27PM (#17921111)
Like all the other US providers, plans change frequently, very few have unlimited plans, and none that I know of have unlimited-speed unlimited-data tethering plans.

Currently, for $45, the best you can get on T-Mobile is 4GB of unlimited-speed tethered data, and for $70 you can get 512KB/s tethering. The cheapest mostly-unlimited data plan (including fewer limits for tethering) for one line costs $95. Older plans, which had cost less and had less limits, have been mostly phased out.

Another sad irony is to get the cheaper plan, you have to get a credit check, which dents your credit score, just to acquire a "pre-paid" plan. Also, T-Mobile's website seems to have been scrubbed of their prepaid plans, so probably you can only find details via interrogating their salespeople.

Re:YouTube and Netflix ‘Throttled’ by Carriers by checkyoursudo on Wednesday September 05, 2018 @03:13PM (#17921020)
In 2006~ish, I think I had to pay t-mobile about $10-20/mo to be able to tether my Moto Razr at fairly low speeds but unlimited data. By the time I jailbreak'd an iPhone for use on the network, I didn't have to pay anything extra beyond the plan data, so it's been quite a long time.
Re:YouTube and Netflix ‘Throttled’ by Carriers by frockington on Wednesday September 05, 2018 @01:05PM (#17919885)
I don't want any of those features and bill is 75% less. I am relatively frugal and prefer to invest/save vs spend. I am very happy not spending $100/month for a cell phone