News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:IRC turns thirty by subhro on Thursday August 23, 2018 @09:56PM (#17832184)
I am invariably going to see in the world of Slack, "IRC, why don't you die already".

No, IRC is not going to die. FreeNode is alive and well. And while you busy slamming and wishing death of IRC, just check the memory usage of your Slack client.

Re:IRC turns thirty by sithadmin on Thursday August 23, 2018 @09:59PM (#17832197)
How does the memory usage of my Slack clients in any way impact the utility of the tool? Private and public communities that are active, relevant, and directly impact my livelihood are on Slack, so I'm also on Slack.

I'm also on IRC, Discord, and Telegram.

This isn't a zero-sum game.

Re:IRC turns thirty by superkuh on Thursday August 23, 2018 @10:50PM (#17832425)
The problem is that those communities chose to use Slack. And now they're locked in to a proprietary protocol controlled by a single company with perverse incentives for censorship.

In prior years those communities would've chosen IRC. But nowdays everything has to be pretty hand hold your hand for you (ie, host your images, assume you know nothing of how to participate on the 'net by yourself).

It is a zero-sum game. And Slack has done the embrace, they done the extend, and they've started the extinguish (by cutting off IRC bridges).

Re:IRC turns thirty by ryanisnan on Thursday August 23, 2018 @11:00PM (#17832463)
Slack is perfect for organizations, whereas IRC is not. And no, we're not locked into anything.
Re:IRC turns thirty by Razengan on Friday August 24, 2018 @12:29AM (#17832804)
> Slack is perfect for organizations, whereas IRC is not.

Why not? Organizations can host their own IRC server(s). Won't that be better than relying on a third-party's services?

And if needed, they can write their own bots, clients, or even their own specific extensions to the protocol.

Re:IRC turns thirty by dmitriid on Friday August 24, 2018 @12:42AM (#17832843)
Because the last thing organizations eant to do is host their own infra for a chat, implement their own search for a chat, re-implement the bits, the hooks, the integrations for a chat etc.?
Re:IRC turns thirty by adrianN on Friday August 24, 2018 @08:18AM (#17834428)
Hosting things on their own infrastructure is very popular for large companies. They tend to take security a lot more serious that the average startup.
Re:IRC turns thirty by Spivak on Friday August 24, 2018 @02:23PM (#17836775)
True and that's why hosted services focus a lot of effort on compliance.

https://slack.com/security

Re:IRC turns thirty by tehbeard on Friday August 24, 2018 @01:47AM (#17833045)
Listen, you want to convince my boss to spend more on the infra. For in house chat w/ drag and drop file hosting, and boost my pay for now having responsibility to manage that, be my guest :)
Re:IRC turns thirty by ntnn on Friday August 24, 2018 @01:31AM (#17832994)
> Slack is perfect for organizations, whereas IRC is not. How so?

> And no, we're not locked into anything. How so?

Re:IRC turns thirty by pingec on Friday August 24, 2018 @03:35AM (#17833407)
I wish there was a way to ignore certain users / bots, this is such a pain for me, it makes slack too spammy and noisy for me so I only ever read private messages.
Re:IRC turns thirty by emilsedgh on Thursday August 23, 2018 @10:34PM (#17832361)
I'm on all of them. IRC is by far my favorite.

Kind of like HN. When someone is commenting on HN I automatically have more interest than eg Facebook vs. Twitter as the primitive experience of HN (Which I personally love) filters out a lot of "noise".

There's great communities out there on IRC.

Just head to #postgres on freenode and see how helpful they are over there.

Re:IRC turns thirty by yeukhon on Thursday August 23, 2018 @10:34PM (#17832362)
Because communication should not be expensive.
Re:IRC turns thirty by CookieMon on Friday August 24, 2018 @12:56AM (#17832887)
Is there a reason IRC couldn't look like slack to the user?

kiwiirc is an opensource webUI IRC client (demo at https://kiwiirc.com/). To my untrained eye it looks slack-ish, but not being a slack-native I'm not really sure what Slack's draw is and whether its something webUI clients for IRC can't do.

Re:IRC turns thirty by dewey on Friday August 24, 2018 @04:31AM (#17833578)
There's not, and there are services like https://www.irccloud.com/ that "slackify" IRC so you don't have to deal with ZNC, making your logs searchable,...
Re:IRC turns thirty by rakoo on Friday August 24, 2018 @03:36AM (#17833409)
The UI is the easiest thing to fix and as you have shown already has been for some time. What separates IRC and the rest is all the features you would expect by default in a messenger of the 21st century:

- history

- with search

- logins

- simple bots

- automatic content fetching (wiki/youtube Links, pics and gifs)

- file transfers that just work

- image pasting

- message editing

And probably others. Yes, those features exist in one way or another in IRC. The point is not whether you can or not; the point is how much time and energy do I want to spend to install and maintain those. I may have had the patience to do it a few years back, but I value other things now.

Re:IRC turns thirty by caf on Friday August 24, 2018 @08:54AM (#17834599)
As a sidebar, from what I can tell the term "bot" for an automated agent accessible through chat originated on IRC.
Re:IRC turns thirty by rakoo on Friday August 24, 2018 @09:59AM (#17834961)
For sure, credit where it's due. However IRC doesn't beat the ease of installation that Slack providers for bots.
Re:IRC turns thirty by jenscow on Friday August 24, 2018 @08:45AM (#17834561)
To many, not having such features on IRC is a bonus.
Re:IRC turns thirty by lmm on Friday August 24, 2018 @07:48AM (#17834304)
IRC can't ever have authentication, because most clients won't support it. You can't have conversations that rely on rich text, code blocks with syntax highlighting, embedded images, or web previews: these things are possible (in some cases there's more than one way of doing them) but some users will always be using clients that don't support them, and will regard you as the problem if you try to create an expectation that clients should support those things. In turn this makes useful integrations hard: you can have a bot that sends an alert message that heap usage is high on your server, but it's not going to be able to include a graph. IRC can't ever have server-side history and synchronise read status between devices; you can run another server that does that for you (whether that be IRCCloud, ZNC or something else), but at that point you're not actually using IRC, you're using that server's protocol.
Re:IRC turns thirty by nobleach on Friday August 24, 2018 @08:57AM (#17834626)
Having to share Gists instead of inlining code blocks, and (of less importance) reaction gifs, was a huge non-starter.
Re:IRC turns thirty by detaro on Friday August 24, 2018 @07:52AM (#17834317)
"Most" important clients support SASL authentication already.
Re:IRC turns thirty by lmm on Friday August 24, 2018 @08:05AM (#17834371)
Sure. But good luck persuading a network to go authenticated-only, or even configuring your private server that way. It's not impossible but it's very much not the culture and not where the documentation/support will guide you.
Re:IRC turns thirty by russdpale on Friday August 24, 2018 @02:03AM (#17833087)
Wow, that is pretty darn nice for an IRC client!
Re:IRC turns thirty by jillesvangurp on Friday August 24, 2018 @07:07AM (#17834164)
Irc is all but dead. I see less and less places where it is used. In the same way NNTP is dead as a doornail and completely irrelevant. Last time I saw that used for something else than filesharing was something like 10 years ago. The same place also used IRC.

Both failed to modernize or keep up with progress. The only places where this stuff is at all still used/tolerated is places where the average age is well above forty and where the audience is engineers only. Most millennials that I work with don't even know what this stuff is because they simply never encountered anything where this is still in use. The ones that do tend to be male and heavily involved with OSS. It's a somewhat elitist thing at this point.

People seem to like to hate slack and similar solutions. The OSS way to deal with stuff like this is to build something better and not get too nostalgic about decades old stuff that did not keep up with a changing world.

Here are the design goals for a modern team chat solution: - It must be stupidly easy to create a private team. Think minutes. This is not something you put an engineer on either. That would be a waste of time/resources. - There must be zero admin overhead. This is the first thing you do in a new project. SAAS is the way to go here for most places; sign up, click, click done. There's absolutely no excuse to waste any time setting up software, servers, and committing to managing that for the vast majority of teams. - It has to be inclusive. Anywone should be able to jump in. Especially non technical people. Like your manager, designers, users, etc. - It has to have mobile apps that are usable and fully featured.

Re:IRC turns thirty by yoz-y on Friday August 24, 2018 @07:24AM (#17834226)
IRC may be elitist but that can be an advantage. For me it is the place where I feel most confortable to have a social chat with strangers.

(Note: there is IRCv3 and irc cloud both of which bring quite a lot of Slack features into IRC)

Re:IRC turns thirty by kabacha on Thursday August 23, 2018 @11:22PM (#17832550)
My problem with Slack is that while it's much more advanced client it still doesn't feel native, is slow and often bloated. The only thing I miss is markdown, sometimes a bit of formatting is vital to getting the message across.
Re:IRC turns thirty by ailideex on Friday August 24, 2018 @03:24AM (#17833362)
I like slack quite a bit, but it's not designed to be a replacement for general use case of IRC - it focuses on specific use cases and can be manhandled into other use cases with a lot of pain towards the users.

matrix.org/riot.im seems like a more sensible alternative to IRC - but their systems are overloaded and slow - multi second latency is the norm.

Re:IRC turns thirty by Qwertie on Friday August 24, 2018 @03:59AM (#17833503)
The speed has gotten better recently. It usually sends messages in under 1 second. The UI is still a little laggy when switching tabs but everything is slowly getting more polished and faster.
Re:IRC turns thirty by Un1corn on Friday August 24, 2018 @09:21AM (#17834752)
They are also working on a new server written in Go instead of Python which will hopefully make it faster
Re:IRC turns thirty by namibj on Friday August 24, 2018 @09:33AM (#17834816)
I'd blame it on using python to implement the server...

Yes, sure, good for a PoC, but there are reasons ejabberd exists.

Re:IRC turns thirty by pteraspidomorph on Friday August 24, 2018 @09:05AM (#17834667)
Some time ago I tried to start a federated homeserver, connected to it and joined the main matrix channel (at the matrix server). Thirty seconds later (IIRC) my client (riot) gave up on the attempt. Nothing showed in the channel. I was told the servers (synapse) were syncing the required information. I checked the logs and, true, a lot of stuff was being sent back and forth.

One hour later, a lot of stuff was still being sent back and forth. I still could not join the channel, and there was still no user-friendly feedback on the failure.

These are fundamental flaws in usability and design that really need to be addressed before the system can gain more widespread acceptance. Have they since been corrected, or have improvements been made to mitigate them?