I don't want my fonts, plugins, user agent, or detailed HW/graphics features (e.g. canvas/WebGL hash) being known. Those can uniquely identify me according to https://panopticlick.eff.org.
So does your resolution. And that's hard to mask because JS usually needs to know it.
If you're not using the browser fullscreen, chances are that you're using a unique innerWidth+innerHeight.
As unsatisfying as it is, the current best solution seems to be not to care about privacy most of the time, and then take privacy seriously when you do. Whonix is excellent for this.
Weirdly, I tried to measure how unique my window.innerWidth/Height was, but panopticlick no longer seems to measure this. It only uses my full screen resolution, which of course is much less unique than canvas dimensions.
If you're not masking your IP, resolution and anything else is largely irrelevant for tracking you.
Say everybody uses one of four resolutions equally. That's two bits: 00, 01, 10 and 11. Now let's say that people's gender is also binary, distributed 50/50 and independent from what resolution someone uses. You can just tack that bit onto the two you already got and now you have three (the ability to distinguish between 2^3 = 8 individuals).
I won't go into the details, but if you have an estimate for the probability distribution of browser resolutions, it's fairly easy to extract the proper amount of bits of entropy. Being independent is a bit harder to make sure of, but as long as you pick things which aren't too obviously correlated, you can just take a safety margin and use, say, 40 bits to identify people, and it's probably fine (and for tracking purposes, a false positive isn't the end of the world, either).
That said, while I support the concept and idea behind panopticlick, I've always felt it overestimated the unicity of my browser. Or maybe I just really underestimate it myself. I don't know.
> window.outerWidth
1168
> screen.width
1920idk - it seems like that can't be enough?
No offense, but advice like this is useless. It reduces to, "someone I don't know thinks the average person with no special risk factors should think this way about their personal privacy based on who knows what priors."
Different people have different reactions to risk, have different actual exposures to risks, different competencies, and different tolerances for the hassles of opsec. And potential future risks of data slopping about are unknown.
There is no such thing as a "best solution" when talking about this.
What do you mean by this?
Indeed, it will surely make resize look less sexy (jumping by 32s instead of pixels), and you might waste a few pixels of screen real estate on some sites at some times -- but it's the kind of tradeoff that some people happily do for more privacy.
Related, does anyone know if privacy badger include "screen size determination" in its heuristics?
Mozilla/5.0 (Macintosh; Intel Mac OS X 10_13_3) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/67.0.3396.62 Safari/537.36
Looks fairly generic, I think I'm running a mainstream chrome browser on a mainstream OS.So the site should really only take into account your OS, maybe its major version, and browser version (which changes frequently so trackers can’t rely on that). Or at least not count any that are not used anymore.
I suspect it's partly because these plugins don't function fully in a private window?
I've yet to come across an extension that does something like this so I'm presuming it's not possible via extensions?
Are Mozilla working to make this more granular and let me whitelist individual features on a per site basis?
I'd far rather lose tracking than get the very minor benefit of a (slow loading) web font or en-GB over en-US. Especially if I can opt in the few I trust or need those features.
I remember reading an article about how Richard Stallman interacts with the internet a while back. I remember thinking that it seemed totally insane. But in light of the reality of 2018, I am coming around. The way I see it, I can keep tweaking privacy settings in a browser, or opting out of collection, or doing any number of other things to attempt to protect my privacy, _or_ I could just stop using services that do not respect my privacy in the first place. Perhaps certain aspects of modern life have taken too much, and they need to be abandoned until they are reformed?
One of these you mean?
The difficulty of course is right now it's nearly everyone at it. Too early to say if GDPR will make an appreciable difference, though it seems like it should. So that leaves few choices outside of gnu everything or layers of hacks and browser extensions. I have hope that many services will start being much more careful in what tracking and data they actually need after recent events.
I think this one is no longer working with the newest FF versions, but check back in on it every once in a while.
For Chrome: https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/random-user-agent/...
Not as configurable as I'd like, but it gets 25% of the job done.
Time to give the chrome one a look, thanks.
Apple can do it. There's no reason why Firefox can't. And if there is a reason, it should have been dealt with years ago.
--
¹ i just noticed that in Firefox 60, the setting is no longer as hidden as it used to be. Good!
That, and the user is likely used to having less-than-ideal browsing experiences if they run any adblockers. I do agree that the article should outline what the consequences would be for disabling browser fingerprinting; they simply have one sentence recommending it, and nothing else.
Unfortunately most websites don't understand this simple idea and show the cookie notice indiscriminately (or, perhaps, they just all use cookies for tracking in which case the notice should be there).
I’d be so keen for the solution to lie in the browser UX- in the same way as we currently request location information - rather than the current mish-mash of badly implemented, often disingenuous site overlays that have become the modern equivalent of the ‘enter site’ splash screen...
Have you actually seen examples of that? sad...
How is this not essential though? You can't effectively run a business without some understanding of your traffic and where it's coming from. Also, you can use Google Analytics in a way that doesn't store PII.
I'm not associated with EU so I haven't pondered on this as much as others. My first thought is that this should really be up to the browsers and their users on what info Analytics software is able to work out just from the user being on the page.
Users should just assume that every business will absorb all available information. At least then we wouldn't see those ridiculous cookie notices everywhere.
As a web developer, I'm kinda surprised 3rd party cookies ever became a thing in the first place.
Users don't know what "available information" is. And frankly, not even the browser developers do - we keep discovering new ways to track people (e.g. using ETags) with features that weren't intended for that. So it's quite hard to claim the user can simply decide what to share.
Because when ordinary users ask "what can I do to protect my privacy?" you have two possible answers:
a) "Nothing, you're not smart enough to do this, you're screwed"
b) "These things"
B has a high learning curve, but telling people about it scares them off. If you care about your friends privacy and want to get them past that learning curve, it's better to let them stumble into issues and be there to answer questions.
I have quite a few of these switches on. First party isolation for example breaks the paypal payment flow on some, but not all, shops. It also breaks quite a few pages that recognize it as an adblocker. I know what to do if that happens, but I would never just recommend enabling that switch.
Or just donate if you can’t do any of those things.
I'm an engineer working on Firefox Platform (Gecko). In the linked blog post, the author recommends Firefox (thanks!) and links to a "privacy recommendations" for it, which include items such as "resistFingerprinting" settings.
I'd like to remind everyone that turning on this setting has far fetched consequences to how you experience the Web. Your dates, timezones, preferred languages will all be masked which will result in weird experiences.
The option is behind a flag and without UI precisely because it is a pretty complex feature, that we didn't iron out yet, and which should be well understood before being used.
It concerns me to see it being references and recommended without any explanation whatsoever.
Of course I'm likely biased because I'm on the receiving end of bug reports from people who experience the Web in weird languages and with wrong timezones because they followed some tutorial that recommended it. :(