News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:In which Apple destroys my daughter’s iPad forever by gambiting on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @05:16AM (#17132529)
Tbf - I feel really sorry that this happened to him, but on the other hand, I am extremely glad that a once-locked device can never be unlocked by anyone without a purchase receipt. I'm sure it deters the theft of iPhones/iPads at least a bit if they know the device will become completely useless once locked out.
Re:In which Apple destroys my daughter’s iPad forever by Nition on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @05:59AM (#17132748)
Even if they know the username and password though? A thief shouldn't know your username and password, and if I have the username and password to a device, I expect to be able to get in.
Re:In which Apple destroys my daughter’s iPad forever by developer2 on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @06:36AM (#17132940)
I believe the OP uses the word "password" incorrectly; they're talking about the device passcode. The details provided in the post indicate they do not know the Apple ID's password, and are unable to perform account recovery (ie: password reset) which requires answers to security questions and/or access to the email address's inbox.

Edit: Another comment chain noted that the OP says the Apple ID was locked as well. It's possible they did know the account's password, but it looks like certain situations may require one to perform account recovery to unlock an account[1].

[1] https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT204106

Re:In which Apple destroys my daughter’s iPad forever by Nition on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @07:22AM (#17133155)
Ah, in that case I read it wrong, thank you. That's never spelled out in the article, especially with lines like:

> My daughter knows her account name. She knows her password. She did not forget either one.

Re:In which Apple destroys my daughter’s iPad forever by acire on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @09:24AM (#17133942)
My daughter knows her account name. She knows the password for the account. She knows her passcode for the lock screen.
Re:In which Apple destroys my daughter’s iPad forever by Nition on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @04:10PM (#17137754)
Right, well in that case I'm sorry that so many people here are misreading your post, and I agree it's ridiculous that you cannot gain access to the account. You've spelled it out plenty clearly so I figured they must have some additional knowledge about how the system works, but it sounds more like the situation is just so silly that people don't want to believe it.
Re:In which Apple destroys my daughter’s iPad forever by watwut on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @05:38AM (#17132647)
It just seems to be easier and more likely to have tablet locked forever, especially for a child, this way then have it actually stolen. Also, a mean schoolmate can lock kids device forever if the kid is not looking.

Which sounds like a good reason not to password protect the device.

Re:In which Apple destroys my daughter’s iPad forever by matthewmacleod on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @05:42AM (#17132662)
That's really only the case if the owner isn't able to show that they own the device, and hasn't set up a password recovery mechanism to demonstrate they own the account.

I do feel bad for them, but it's kind of a confluence of a lot of different mistakes that led to this point.

Re:In which Apple destroys my daughter’s iPad forever by watwut on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @07:04AM (#17133075)
I would have hard time to find tickets for older devices (which are the ones kids use).

Locking your device forever is quite damaging action no matter what "poor decisions" lead to it. Especially when those poor decisions are quite natural if they have no idea this might happen.

Re:In which Apple destroys my daughter’s iPad forever by falsedan on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @05:59AM (#17132751)
Don't blame the user for poor product decisions.
Re:In which Apple destroys my daughter’s iPad forever by matthewmacleod on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @06:04AM (#17132777)
I'm not sure it _is_ a poor product decision though.

There are a large number of hurdles between "I have a functioning device" and "I can no longer use my device". Passcodes, password resets, account ownership claims, device ownership claims. There's an extensive path of steps to follow which allow a legitimate user to regain access.

In this situation we have:

- Someone who has disabled their access, probably through entering the wrong password a few times

- No knowledge of the security details on the linked account

- No access to the email address associated with the account

- No proof of ownership of the device

In other words, from Apple's perspective, the user in question could easily be using a stolen device.

I'm curious though – what's the 'correct' product decision that should have been made here? Is it possible to build a system which is both secure and allows _any_ user to gain access to their device, no matter how many safeguards they have avoided?

Re:In which Apple destroys my daughter’s iPad forever by ghaff on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @06:48AM (#17133002)
Make it easy to regain access to a device under these sorts of circumstances and, instead of this story, you have one about how a thief was able to gain access to my stolen device even though they had almost none of the information they should have needed.

The more forgiving you are the more exposed you are to social engineering and other attempts to work around security systems.

Re:In which Apple destroys my daughter’s iPad forever by Gupie on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @06:31AM (#17132916)
Couldn't Apple make it be standard to provide a name and address when buying such a product? You could then for example take ti to your local apple store with some ID to get it unlocked.
Re:In which Apple destroys my daughter’s iPad forever by matthewmacleod on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @06:45AM (#17132991)
And then you sell it to someone else (as happened in this case) and don't update the record, and suddenly you're locked out again.

But it's possible that there are specific lessons to learn here, so it's always worth examining failure cases!

Re:In which Apple destroys my daughter’s iPad forever by Gupie on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @06:56AM (#17133034)
That's true, the article was unreachable so I had only read these comments. But what I don't understand is why her iCloud account was locked.
Re:In which Apple destroys my daughter’s iPad forever by gambiting on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @06:02AM (#17132769)
I just don't see this as a poor product decision - the mechanism here is extremely simple - if you lock out your device completely, Apple will only ever unlock it for you if you can prove it's yours. How is it different to cars for example? If I lost both of my keys to my car, Mercedes would only produce a duplicate and re-program the ignition if I could prove that the car is indeed mine. I don't want someone to be able to just roll into the dealership and go "hey I just got this car, can you reprogram the ignition for me please thanks".
Re:In which Apple destroys my daughter’s iPad forever by toast0 on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @11:52AM (#17135121)
For cars, in the US, each state (to my knowledge) runs an ownership database, issues certificates of title, and compels buyers, sellers, and users of vehicles to update the database when ownership changes. Apple devices don't have a similar ownership database.
Re:In which Apple destroys my daughter’s iPad forever by Redoubts on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @12:13PM (#17135309)
Sure they do, it’s called Apple ID.
Re:In which Apple destroys my daughter’s iPad forever by toast0 on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @02:26PM (#17136653)
That's missing the step to compel usage. It sounds like apple doesn't even check periodically that your address is valid.
Re:In which Apple destroys my daughter’s iPad forever by jasonkostempski on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @06:49AM (#17133011)
Can't the device be reset another way? Im sure most phone theft is to sell hardware, not get data.
Re:In which Apple destroys my daughter’s iPad forever by gambiting on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @07:00AM (#17133052)
Nope, at least not on the devices equipped with the secure enclave. The device can still be sold for parts, but so far I don't think there is a technical solution to unlocking the system or even wiping it.
Re:In which Apple destroys my daughter’s iPad forever by jasonkostempski on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @07:21AM (#17133151)
Hmm, sounds like a fun DOS attack for frienemies. Personally, I'd rather take the risk. Is there a way to disable that?
Re:In which Apple destroys my daughter’s iPad forever by scarface74 on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @07:50AM (#17133323)
If everything were backed up to iCloud (it is by default), you can literally throw your device in the trash, get a new one, log in and the new device will look and act like the old device with all of your data in check.

The issue was that she had maxed out her icloud account and kept dismissing messages. The blame for that is shared between her parent not ponying up $10 a month for 2TB of storage that can be shared by the whole family and Apple's stingy free tier that only gives you 5Gb a month per account no matter how many devices you have.

Re:In which Apple destroys my daughter’s iPad forever by jasonkostempski on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @08:39AM (#17133613)
I know that, its the hardware I care about, its not cheap. And what if you buy used? There no papers to prove you bought it to Apple. And the fact there's a way for Apple to reset it, but not me, is also highly annoying. To me, the risk of setting a pin is greater than my phone getting stolen or my data being exposed. Also, $10 a month is a rediculous price, a kid will fill up 2TB within a year and then managing what's in the cloud and whats on the device will be just as big a pain as doing your own backups, which would be extremely easy and cheap if Apple would expose the file system in a standard way (without requiring iTunes) over usb like a proper device thats not trying to sell you cloud storage.
Re:In which Apple destroys my daughter’s iPad forever by scarface74 on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @09:00AM (#17133757)
Yes you can reset the device yourself. (https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT204306). The device will be locked to your account and you have to use your account credentials to use it.

In this case, you're talking about backing up what's on your device. No device has 2TB of data to backup.

If Apple exposed the file system unencrypted, that kind of defeats the whole purpose of encryption. How many people are really going to manually connect to a computer and backup?

What's the state of backing up Android? Can you just log in to a new Android phone and have all of your data - including app data restored?

Re:In which Apple destroys my daughter’s iPad forever by jasonkostempski on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @02:38PM (#17136784)
Looks like I misunderstood about the resetting.

So the cloud storage is only to back up what can fit on your devices? I think the cloud storage required to backup/transfer whatever device you purchased should be free especially at the premiums they charge for a few extra built-in GBs. Charging for proper backups, that would let users easily take/copy their files somewhere else, I'm all for.

Android exposes the file system when you explicitly allow it from the device. Obviously that doesn't help when you've locked yourself out, but that's why you do regular backups. iOS does the same thing, but only for the DCIM folder and it's not in a standard way, Linux requires special software to access it and that's usually broken for a while after iOS updates. I backup my family photos and video locally and in cold storage at $0.78 a month for 174 GB. The process would only take me 5 minutes of work a month if it wasn't for 1 or more iOS devices misbehaving every time I try.

I use Android but I'm not sure on the state of their backup, I don't have any Google Cloud stuff enabled. I backup up my entire phone once in a while if I have data I think I'll care about that isn't photo or video (which is rare in my case).

All this ranting is really only because it's very frustrating that I can't control my mobile devices like I can my PCs. Android is better than iOS in that regard, but far from perfect.

Re:In which Apple destroys my daughter’s iPad forever by scarface74 on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @04:10PM (#17137755)
iCloud is used for more than just backing up your device. It can also be used like Dropbox.

You can backup your data on Android, but you can't just backup and restore the app data. Google tried that with apps that weren't built for it and it was an awful mess now it's opt-in and not all apps support it (https://www.howtogeek.com/140376/htg-explains-what-android-d...)

If my phone is dropped into a lake, I go into the Apple store and buy another one. My settings, apps, location of my apps on my home screen etc. will be just like I left it. Some apps rightfully choose for files not be backed up to iCloud. For instance it would make no sense for my podcasts to be backed up to iCloud.

As far as not having enough storage to backup your device - I agree. That's why I said Apple's free tier is "stingy".

Re:In which Apple destroys my daughter’s iPad forever by wombatpm on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @10:43AM (#17134557)
Actually that is not true. They talk like it is a full incremental backup, but it is not. Apple will maintain a list of the apps you have installed. If that app is no longer available in the app store then you are out of luck. Sure pictures contacts and downloads are available, but settings within apps not so much. The move to iCloud over PC backups is great for Apple (the got my money for the 2TB plan, but only sorta good for consumers.
Re:In which Apple destroys my daughter’s iPad forever by scarface74 on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @10:51AM (#17134609)
It's not the app they backup. It's the data inside the apps. The restore process redownloads the apps and restores the data inside the app.

Each app has three kinds of storage:

- files that should be copied to iCloud.

- files that should be permanently stored on the device

- temporary files that can be deleted by the OS to clear space.

The developer decides which types of files should have which retention policy.

iCloud only backs up the first kinds of files per app.

Re:In which Apple destroys my daughter’s iPad forever by ghaff on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @07:36AM (#17133242)
Only by not setting a passcode.
Re:In which Apple destroys my daughter’s iPad forever by TekMol on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @05:23AM (#17132565)
I have carried around laptops and smartphones for decades now. Not a single one was stolen. Even if one was stolen now, what's the average cost of 'Stuff being stolen' over the years?

I had Laptops with me since the 90s. For over 20 years. If my iPad Pro gets stolen now, that's $1000 over 20 years = $50/year. I don't mind.

I really would love if a Linux distribution would support the iPad so I know I can do with it whatever I like forever.

Re:In which Apple destroys my daughter’s iPad forever by madeofpalk on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @05:26AM (#17132583)
Same. I've never had a phone/laptop/tablet/etc stolen.

Yet, "The number of smartphones stolen dropped by 50% in London, 27% in San Francisco and 16% in New York in 2014, according to an announcement by officials in the three cities" since the introduction of these anti-theft measures https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2015/feb/11/london-sm...

Re:In which Apple destroys my daughter’s iPad forever by stuaxo on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @07:02AM (#17133059)
I saw a slightly suspicious looking cyclist come going past me, with a mask on ... he grabbed the guy in front of me's phone and cycled off!

That was in a pretty nice bit of London.

I've managed to let my laptop get taken when I was really drunk at a pub too <shrug>.

Re:In which Apple destroys my daughter’s iPad forever by comboy on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @05:56AM (#17132735)
"30 years I've been driving without a seat belt, not a scratch!"
Re:In which Apple destroys my daughter’s iPad forever by amrrs on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @05:47AM (#17132687)
I am not sure if you ever happen to be in India (or any developing nation for that matter). I live in Bengaluru, the silicon valley of India. Recently my colleague's smartphone was stolen while he was commuting in a Public transport Bus. Few Months earlier, Another calling was talking over the phone and walking and it was snatched from him.

Bottomline: Devices are stolen always and It is heart wrecking when you know the most intimate device where you might have your intimate pics or your family's is in the hands of someone who's not ethical. What Apple doing here, MATTERS a lot!

Re:In which Apple destroys my daughter’s iPad forever by martin-adams on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @05:34AM (#17132624)
Parent: >> I'm sure it deters the theft of iPhones/iPads at least a bit if they know the device will become completely useless once locked out.

>> Not a single one was stolen

The interesting question with the popularity of people having high values phones, tablets and laptops now, does the security measures of those devices keep the rate of theft low. If I were to correlate your statement (none stolen) with the theory (locking devices deters theft), it matches up. But, I get the feeling that isn't the point you wanted to make :)

Re:In which Apple destroys my daughter’s iPad forever by gaius on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @05:30AM (#17132599)
have carried around laptops and smartphones for decades now. Not a single one was stolen

Good for you. Meanwhile in London a common crime is for moped riders to snatch phones out of people’s hands. Sometimes there’s a passenger on board who will also spray the victim with acid. Maybe you would mind that?

Re:In which Apple destroys my daughter’s iPad forever by sgift on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @06:01AM (#17132761)
Yeah, I mind that. The solution is an effective police force. Maybe you've heard of it.
Re:In which Apple destroys my daughter’s iPad forever by coldtea on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @07:07AM (#17133088)
Yeah, please tells us more about your crime statistics in the states with this more "effective police", and how they're so much better than Europe/London...
Re:In which Apple destroys my daughter’s iPad forever by sgift on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @08:08AM (#17133423)
I'm not living in the States, so I have no idea about the situation there, but Germany has very save cities. I'm sure you are able to input crime statistics Germany in your search engine of choice, if you are curious.
Re:In which Apple destroys my daughter’s iPad forever by coldtea on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @11:36AM (#17134979)
I was curious. This is what I found:

Overall Crime and Safety Situation

U.S. Embassy Berlin does not assume responsibility for the professional ability or integrity of the persons or firms appearing in this report. The American Citizens’ Services unit (ACS) cannot recommend a particular individual or location, and assumes no responsibility for the quality of service provided.

The U.S. Department of State has assessed Berlin as being a MEDIUM-threat location for crime directed at or affecting official U.S. government interests.

Please review OSAC’s Germany-specific page for original OSAC reporting, consular messages, and contact information, some of which may be available only to private-sector representatives with an OSAC password.

Crime Threats

Crime rates throughout Germany have been comparable to those in most first-world countries, and comparative analysis of crime data for the U.S. and Germany reveals only marginal differences. The Bundeskriminalamt’s (BKA) 2016 Police Crime Statistics for Germany indicated only minor changes in the number of the majority of recorded offenses with an increase of 0.7% overall. This resulted in reported crime being at its highest level since 2005. However, when discounting the “Aliens Act-related” crimes (which saw a 21.1% increase in 2016), a fall of 0.7% in recorded offences was registered. Significant increases were seen in violent crime (6.7%) including murder and attempted murder (14.3%), rape (12%), bodily injury (8.1%) and serious bodily injury (9.9%). Increases were also seen in drug offenses (7.1%) and weapons offenses (14.8%). Significant decreases were seen in burglaries (9.5%), shoplifting (3.3%) and economic crime (5.6%).

Some observers have suggested that official statistics may not always provide an accurate accounting of the level of crime, and not all crimes reported to the police are captured in the form of an actual police report. There have been reports of police dissuading victims from making formal reports citing little chance of capturing the suspect. Such a practice may create a disincentive to report criminal activity. Outspoken representatives of police unions have stated the number of crimes is often drastically under reported. In 2015, the head of the German Detective Union (Bund Deutscher Kriminalbeamter) accused politicians of “leaving the public in the dark as to the true level of criminality.” He claimed that only 75% of domestic burglaries were reported and that sex crimes and cybercrimes were under reported.

There have also been reports of crimes, in effect, being de-criminalized due to their frequency and impact on resources. One such report involved a community declaring petty crimes, such as shoplifting, would no longer be investigated by the authorities. To tackle high-profile criminal activities, such as violent crimes and burglaries, police have reallocated and/or increased resources in certain areas, resulting in less emphasis on investigating and detecting less serious crimes, such as fraud.

It is not uncommon for visiting Americans to be victims of purse snatching or pickpocketing in high traffic and tourist areas (in train stations, internet cafes, crowded restaurants, and outdoor market places), but violent crimes against Americans have been relatively infrequent. Carry a copy of your passport while maintaining the original in a safe location. While personal assaults do occur, there is no evidence that such crimes were driven by anti-American sentiment.

https://www.osac.gov/pages/ContentReportDetails.aspx?cid=237...