News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Who controls glibc? by bhhaskin on Monday May 07, 2018 @08:04PM (#17017589)
I agree with RMS on this. People need to grow up. It's ok to be offended, but not ok to try and correct everyone just because you are offended. A line needs to be drawn somewhere and this is harmless.
Re:Who controls glibc? by geofft on Monday May 07, 2018 @08:16PM (#17017663)
Nobody who removed the joke said they were offended by it, they just said that they didn't believe it was the sort of thing that belonged in technical documentation. If anyone is offended, it is RMS, in the sense that he seems personally affronted that he doesn't carry the line-item veto power he thinks he had over all of GNU and people did not ask him before removing something he added 25 years ago.

Not everyone who disagrees with something is offended by the thing they disagree with. Shall I say that someone who prefers writing documentation in man pages instead of Markdown is offended by Markdown? Is Project Zero offended by buffer overflows?

Re:Who controls glibc? by roenxi on Monday May 07, 2018 @08:46PM (#17017845)
Technical documentation isn't the place for a joke full stop. Documentation is for people who are typically busy, uncertain and potentially dealing with something that is going wrong.

They want clear, concise and accessible help. They don't want or need tasteless jokes. It is disrespectful to their time to include random garbage.

This is supposed to be read by people who need it, not people who know what is going on and want to enjoy a good laugh.

Re:Who controls glibc? by jonhendry18 on Monday May 07, 2018 @10:26PM (#17018349)
"Technical documentation isn't the place for a joke full stop"

This is a bad take. When wading through dry technical documentation a little humor can make it much less laborious.

As long as the humor doesn't result in ambiguity, there's no problem.

Something like "You can tune a filesystem, but you can't tune a fish." at the end of a manpage may elicit a chuckle but doesn't reduce understanding.

Re:Who controls glibc? by geofft on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @07:03AM (#17020086)
For what it's worth, at least one member of the glibc steering committee appears to agree:

"I agree with removing this joke. A bit of humor is fine - indeed, the manual could use a bit more than it has - but this attempt at humor does not work. The manual should be high-quality, and that includes high-quality jokes."

https://sourceware.org/ml/libc-alpha/2018-04/msg00604.html

Re:Who controls glibc? by humanrebar on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @07:19AM (#17020157)
For what it's worth, that only high quality jokes bit made me laugh more than Stallman's joke.
Re:Who controls glibc? by rtpg on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @03:23AM (#17019426)
Yeah, it should probably be more

"your technical documentation should have a consistent tone"

I appreciate light-hearted asides in documentation. But more if I expect it than when it's unexpected. Like you wouldn't want to end up confusing some ESL programmer who goes ask a lawyer whether they should be worried about this?

Or if you're really ambitious, make all your docs super funny! But if you mix the tone it's disorienting and maybe bad writing.

Re:Who controls glibc? by stronglikedan on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @09:56AM (#17020873)
> a little humor can make it much less laborious

Here, here!

I would even go so far as to say that Why's (Poignant) Guide to Ruby directly contributed a great deal to Ruby's popularity because of the witty content alone.

Re:Who controls glibc? by thiagoharry on Monday May 07, 2018 @09:01PM (#17017935)
The TexBook was a technical documentation for TeX written by Donald Knuth. The book had a lot of jokes, and I enjoyed reading it.
Re:Who controls glibc? by geofft on Monday May 07, 2018 @09:14PM (#17018028)
Leaving aside the question of the nature of its jokes, the TeXBook is the sort of thing you read straight through. It's a narrative about how some code came to be. It's not the same sort of reference as the glibc manual, and I think a narrative form of documentation benefits from a casual tone and a four-sentence standalone reference about a function (especially where one of those sentences is "Preliminary: | MT-Safe | AS-Unsafe corrupt | AC-Unsafe lock corrupt") benefits from a terse tone.
Re:Who controls glibc? by hapnin on Monday May 07, 2018 @09:14PM (#17018029)
Knuth is actually funny.
Re:Who controls glibc? by krylon on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @12:04AM (#17018733)
What is and is not funny, is highly subjective. (Just to be clear, I really like Donald Knuth's sense of humor.)
Re:Who controls glibc? by enriquto on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @12:28PM (#17022184)
Knuth has a great sense of humor in his books and exercices. I also like Stallman's jokes, but I can concede that they are sligthly less funny than Knuth's.
Re:Who controls glibc? by djsumdog on Monday May 07, 2018 @09:20PM (#17018058)
I'm not that hardcore about it, but I still agree this really shouldn't be in the official docs. Maybe in a tutorial or a set of slides.

I do agree with some professionalism in things that want to be taken seriously. I don't even really like the "Apt with super cow powers."

I do agree this isn't about political correctness. At one time GNU tools were just a bunch of devs trying to write open source tooling for fun or to learn. But with it being such a huge part of our industry now, it does need to grow up.

If you're working on your own small open source projects, have fun with the docs and comments. But don't be like Stallman. Realize if your tools are really successful, those quips might get cut out one day. c'est la vie

Re:Who controls glibc? by dfox on Monday May 07, 2018 @09:47PM (#17018185)
My feeling is that most of GNU manuals in texinfo format are borderline useless because the structure is simply wrong, the random jokes are somewhat tangential issue.
Re:Who controls glibc? by sandov on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @03:31AM (#17019458)
I Don't know if we're talking about the same thing but I've found the format of man pages to be absolutely useless for me. Maybe I'm too dumb/noob to understand them, but then what's left for the folk who just switched to linux and wamts to learn about commands.
Re:Who controls glibc? by grzm on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @03:34AM (#17019467)
Texinfo and man are different.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Texinfo

> "Notably, man is not available as an output format from the standard Texinfo tools. While Texinfo is used for writing the documentation of GNU software, which typically is used in Unix-like environments such as GNU/Linux, where man pages are the traditional format for documentation, the rationale for this is that man pages have a strict conventional format, used traditionally as quick reference guides, whereas typical Texinfo applications are for tutorials as well as reference manuals. As such, no benefit is seen in expressing Texinfo content in man page format. Moreover, many GNU projects eschew man pages almost completely, referring the reader of the provided man page (which often describes itself as seldom maintained) to the Info document."

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Man_page

They can take some getting used to if you're not familiar with them, but given how much documentation is available in these formats, it's worth taking a few hours to become accustomed to them. A lot of it is duplicated online as well, so you can often use your favorite search engine.

Re:Who controls glibc? by majewsky on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @08:07AM (#17020350)
Word. GNU texinfo is so fucking confusing that I only ever invoke it as

  info --subnodes -o - $PROGRAM | less
That dumps the entire manual for $PROGRAM into `less`, where I can then use regex-searches like a normal humanbeing.
Re:Who controls glibc? by zeveb on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @11:21AM (#17021529)
It's wonderful to use in emacs, and back before I started using emacs ISTR that pinfo was a great way to read info.

I used to hate how GNU manpages would point me at the info docs, but honestly nowadays I prefer info. It really is nice — like a pre-CSS, pre-JavaScript HTML, only it can be beautifully typeset too.

Re:Who controls glibc? by keiyakins on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @01:00PM (#17022504)
Yeah, I hate info, but the problem is info(1), not the entire texinfo stack. The html output is pretty good and I already know how to navigate it, so I usually use that
Re:Who controls glibc? by __s on Monday May 07, 2018 @09:13PM (#17018016)
Yeah, Python docs need to stop using variable names like 'spam' & 'eggs', Monty Python's too jokey, no room for it in docs
Re:Who controls glibc? by geofft on Monday May 07, 2018 @10:03PM (#17018258)
If you genuinely believe that these are comparable situations (and you're not just making a strained comparison to argue in favor of the side you favor), I'm not sure how to explain my position to you.

Although I think I would start by saying this: where "spam" and "eggs" is used in Python, it is in the place of any other word, usually a nonsense word like "foo" or "bar", and its presence does not distract. I doubt anyone thinks of actual SPAM or actual eggs when they run across it, and I seriously doubt the documentation authors intended or expected anyone to.

The (so-called) joke in this glibc discussion is a) essentially a pun on the name of the function, i.e., introducing mental confusion; b) a political subject; c) an ill-explained reference to a political subject (did you know it's about the global gag rule? do you know what the global gag rule is?); d) intended to make you think about that subject instead of tuning it out.

Python's use of "spam" and "eggs" adds some character, that's about it. (Python's insistence on "eggs" and "wheels" and "cheeseshop", on the other hand... I find the names cute but if you wanted to get rid of them all in favor of slightly more descriptive words, I'd honestly be in favor.) This joke serves no purpose other than, at best, to distract the attention of the person looking up documentation onto a completely different subject.

Re:Who controls glibc? by djsumdog on Monday May 07, 2018 @09:23PM (#17018070)
I think that's a little different. Even with the fun variable names, the Python docs are pretty damn professional.

They haven't always been that way. The Python docs back around 2000 were not that great. A lot of work has been put in by people in the community to get them to the state they're in.

Re:Who controls glibc? by dfox on Monday May 07, 2018 @09:53PM (#17018216)
Python docs are very good and professional, but somewhat chaotic unless you have pretty good grasp on what belongs where.

Just last friday I tried to find authoritative definition of the leading underscore mangling behavior in the docs and was not able to do so.

Re:Who controls glibc? by MrsRobot on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @12:35AM (#17018843)
Not the same thing. "spam" & "eggs" are very neutral. If they used politically charged terms, and inserted example code like "if brains(republicans) == 0 # always true!" then the situation would be similar. The difference is between neutral light-heartedness and non-neutral political message.
Re:Who controls glibc? by pferde on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @04:26AM (#17019624)
How do you know which words will and will not become politically charged in fourty years?
Re:Who controls glibc? by geofft on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @05:21AM (#17019770)
You update the docs in forty years as needed.

In any case that question seems wildly unrelated to the question at hand, which is about a joke that's intended to be a present-day political reference.

Re:Who controls glibc? by keiyakins on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @12:56PM (#17022469)
The same way you know what technical details will be needed in forty years: By actively maintaining the documentation, as they're doing.
Re:Who controls glibc? by DoofusOfDeath on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @09:17AM (#17020660)
They're probably just trying to give wide berth of the world's most dangerous joke.
Re:Who controls glibc? by pishpash on Monday May 07, 2018 @09:32PM (#17018126)
The early days of computing was very informal and full of jokes. Didn't stop people from creating some of the most long-lasting and technically successful tools.
Re:Who controls glibc? by TeMPOraL on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @01:16AM (#17018968)
Maybe even helped them. Those tools create in informal atmosphere seem much more robust and useful than what the present day brings.
Re:Who controls glibc? by majewsky on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @08:08AM (#17020353)
I think a large part of this is survivorship bias. We just don't see all the crap that was created back in the day because it didn't stick around.
Re:Who controls glibc? by TeMPOraL on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @08:21AM (#17020402)
Come to think of it, I guess you're right.
Re:Who controls glibc? by keiyakins on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @12:52PM (#17022434)
A well-constructed joke can make documentation more useful. I can't think of an example off the top of my head, but there've been plenty of times that something made me laugh and go "NOW I get it!" to the technical material.

This isn't a well-constructed joke in that sense - it's likely to cause confusion, not increased understanding.

Re:Who controls glibc? by chillingeffect on Monday May 07, 2018 @09:12PM (#17018009)
We're humans, not robots. We don't run on information alone.
Re:Who controls glibc? by analogmemory on Monday May 07, 2018 @09:17PM (#17018044)
Hey meatbag, even robots like a good joke
Re:Who controls glibc? by lrl939ndj on Monday May 07, 2018 @09:56PM (#17018232)
Agreed with RMS in spirit

Disagree with his application in this context

I don’t give a damn about your politics when I’m trying to solve a problem unrelated to them

Re:Who controls glibc? by flukus on Monday May 07, 2018 @08:40PM (#17017791)
> they just said that they didn't believe it was the sort of thing that belonged in technical documentation

I've been dreading the day OSS projects became as soulless and boring as corporate ones. If we can't have jokes in technical documentation then it seems that day has come.

Next the FOSS HR department will be asking them to rename the abort function.

Re:Who controls glibc? by geofft on Monday May 07, 2018 @08:57PM (#17017911)
There's certainly something lost here, I won't deny that.

But glibc, and huge other parts of the FOSS ecosystem, has been a corporate project for years. Maintenance comes from stodgy companies like Red Hat who install glibc on the sort of extremely stodgy companies who are Red Hat customers.

And for those of us whose day jobs involve using glibc and reading its documentation, we deserve the benefits of free software as much as everyone else. If it is an ethical imperative (as RMS says!) for all software to be free and for proprietary software to die, it follows that the primary battleground is the servers of soulless, boring corporations. Your hobbyist laptop is important, too, because everyone deserves free software. But if free software weren't around, you would have installed a pirated copy of Windows with a keygen with some hentai as its background image and enjoyed the non-HR-compliance of the process, and Microsoft would have been quite okay with it because you would be locked into their proprietary software.

If free software is an ethical imperative - or even if it's not, but even if open source is simply a better way to develop software - then everyone who wants a job in software engineering and is qualified for it should be able to have a job in writing and maintaining FOSS. Human society has determined that if we want everyone to participate in an activity, things work better if everyone agrees to uphold a few norms. They don't have to be the same norms as boring corporations uphold (and you can quite easily argue that the norms of boring corporations aren't that good, actually, at making sure everyone is welcome to participate on equal terms). But the fact that we open our shared infrastructural work to accountability and public judgment is sort of how civilization works.

Hobbyist projects are still as possible as ever. Twenty years ago, you wouldn't have been able to get inappropriate jokes in the technical documentation for Solaris libc, or into MSDN, or whatever, but you could work on some upstart free software project with your friends and do whatever you want. You can still do that. If you want to be the young, upstart libc with some off-color political jokes that's being an alternative to the boring corporate libc, more power to you. Not everyone will participate, but that's what you want. Meanwhile, the libc whose goal in life was to displace the corporate libcs has won - and needs to step into its role.

Re:Who controls glibc? by __s on Monday May 07, 2018 @09:16PM (#17018035)
You see it too in people going around telling people to stop saying master/slave for clusters

https://github.com/antirez/redis/issues/3185

Re:Who controls glibc? by keiyakins on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @01:09PM (#17022574)
I think you're looking at the wrong axis. This isn't an order-vs-chaos question, it's one of constructive vs destructive. This particular joke makes the manual worse, not better, at being a manual. Cut it and move on, and always keep an eye out for places it could be improved, whether that be through better descriptive prose or a good, understanding-building joke.
Re:Who controls glibc? by makomk on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @06:48AM (#17020036)
The main justification for why it shouldn't be there is that it was offensive. The idea that software should not be political is, in fact, itself just as offensive to the community of campaigners who've joined the calls to have this removed as this joke is. The last big controversy I saw was the entire console jailbreaking community being declared a bunch of bigots because someone mocked the idea that code could have views on LGBTQ rights.
Re:Who controls glibc? by geofft on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @07:02AM (#17020080)
> The main justification for why it shouldn't be there is that it was offensive.

This is simply untrue; you can look at the patch's commit message and the review thread. The primary justification was that it wasn't appropriate, and the secondary one is that it wasn't actually funny and was tasteless. Nobody said "offensive". You can read the thread yourself.

https://sourceware.org/ml/libc-alpha/2018-04/msg00595.html

(The April history shows the conversation between maintainers regarding the patch itself; if you want to see RMS' reply, go to the May index. RMS and Alexandre Oliva, the two people defending the joke, brought up the concept of "offense", and people repeatedly say in reply that they're not offended. Oliva later says he's offended by other people in the discussion.)

Of course, you're also welcome to believe that everyone who disagrees with you must be offended; you're entitled to your opinions.

Re:Who controls glibc? by RIMR on Monday May 07, 2018 @08:08PM (#17017614)
I agree with RMS's pro-choice opinion, but I honestly see no reason a 20-something year old joke about abortion needed to remain in the documentation.

The consensus was that it be removed. It was removed. Just because HMS is a FOSS legend doesn't make him God.

Re:Who controls glibc? by 8_hours_ago on Monday May 07, 2018 @08:26PM (#17017722)
> Just because RMS is a FOSS legend doesn't make him God.

According to RMS he does have ultimate authority over all GNU packages, including Glibc: https://lwn.net/Articles/753661/

Re:Who controls glibc? by justonepost on Monday May 07, 2018 @08:45PM (#17017828)
He probably owns some root certs. Likely if he were to start exercising such authority without being an active developer, there would be a fork soon enough.

Isn't that what happened to emacs?

Re:Who controls glibc? by favorited on Monday May 07, 2018 @09:08PM (#17017978)
It happened with GCC. Today's GCC is actually a fork of the original, which became the "blessed" version once the forkers and RMS worked out resolved some issues that led to the fork.

The unforked (for lack of a better term) GCC was set aside, and the fork became the official version.

Re:Who controls glibc? by chx on Monday May 07, 2018 @10:46PM (#17018433)
Just for the sake of completeness: the EGCS fork you are talking about was alive 1997-1999.
Re:Who controls glibc? by pzone on Monday May 07, 2018 @08:56PM (#17017909)
A few times, but so far GNU has held on.
Re:Who controls glibc? by lsh123 on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @12:53AM (#17018909)
Fork, take maintainers and contributors with you, convince others to use your fork.
Re:Who controls glibc? by matthewbauer on Monday May 07, 2018 @08:11PM (#17017629)
Yes I'm 100% with you on this. I mainly dislike how the LWN article is framed.
Re:Who controls glibc? by jcranmer on Monday May 07, 2018 @10:11PM (#17018298)
One thing that may not be well-appreciated:

This is walking very close to the line of outright political advocacy. If you read the entire email thread, one of the examples [1] clearly crosses that threshold. Once that threshold is crossed, it is illegal for a government employee to contribute to glibc in an official capacity, or even a private employee contracted by the government. This includes things like people who need to modify glibc to get them to run on government supercomputers.

[1] Someone suggests blocking out code with #ifdef REPUBLICANS.

Re:Who controls glibc? by chris_wot on Monday May 07, 2018 @10:32PM (#17018376)
Actually, GNU is a 501(c)(3) organisation. They can’t really be politically active and maintain such a status.
Re:Who controls glibc? by im3w1l on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @12:30AM (#17018828)
501(c)(3) can support issues but not people in election for office.
Re:Who controls glibc? by fulafel on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @12:28AM (#17018822)
Most worthwhile things are political. If there really is such a rule in some country, it should not condemn organisations to self censorship & apathy.
Re:Who controls glibc? by ubernostrum on Monday May 07, 2018 @09:27PM (#17018098)
I wish I could make RMS, and you, and everyone who agrees with you, live in a sort of reverse-Kantian world, where whatever you advocate for as acceptable behavior when you do it becomes a universal law of conduct for other people to use when interacting with you.

No matter how much of a "thick skin" you may think you have, I'd lay money that in a world which truly worked this way, you'd last under an hour before abandoning your position and calling for stronger social norms against being an ass to people.

Re:Who controls glibc? by ciupicri on Monday May 07, 2018 @11:06PM (#17018528)
I think RMS has been "attacked" quite a lot of times since he founded FSF and even before it, yet look at him, he's still advocating for what he believes in.
Re:Who controls glibc? by pydumpsterfire on Saturday May 19, 2018 @10:44PM (#17110898)
Ah, but aren't you pretty famous yourself for being just that?
Re:Who controls glibc? by craigsmansion on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @06:12AM (#17019926)
> I wish I could make RMS, and you, and everyone who agrees with you, live in a sort of reverse-Kantian world, where whatever you advocate for as acceptable behavior when you do it becomes a universal law of conduct for other people to use when interacting with you.

You want to transport me back to the 70's MIT AI lab? I'm so there!

Re:Who controls glibc? by p_l on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @08:38AM (#17020474)
Considering the stories of the breakdown of MIT AI Lab, you might be... surprised.

(No, Levy's book was not honest to the facts)

Re:Who controls glibc? by paulmd on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @09:06AM (#17020599)
I don't know the context of this, explanation?
Re:Who controls glibc? by p_l on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @05:09PM (#17025131)
"Hackers: Heroes of the Computing Revolution" is probably the most common source for those who "weren't there" about AI Lab, and it paints a story of the lab being destroyed by Symbolics, proprietary software etc. - I have personally seen the meme of "AI Lab hackers got bought out" with referrals to the book itself.

What a lot of people don't know is that one of the descriptions used by RMS to talk about how "AI Lab lost people", the story of how he couldn't meet people at lunch, isn't because they left AI Lab for "evil corporations". It was because a lot of people avoided RMS, especially after lawsuit often considered more crucial for the creation of GNU than the Xerox printer story (Stallman violated Symbolics-MIT source licensing deal).

From better sources, I have met two AI Lab members from 1970s - one even claimed to have been RMS' supervisor back when RMS was Harvard Undergrad working part-time (and if certain war story is to be believed, is indirectly responsible for Emacs happening) - the impression left was that a lot of RMS' AI Lab contemporaries wouldn't shake hands with him since 1980s.

Heard also interesting stories on RMS' mismanagement of early Hurd initiative and how it resulted in close to 0 work being done.

Re:Who controls glibc? by bhhaskin on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @12:44AM (#17018875)
You should practice what you preach, because your statement doesn't make me feel very welcome or safe right now. You seem to make a lot of assumptions about me and the world I live in.

I just said I agree with RMS on this, and you straight up attacked me personally.

Re:Who controls glibc? by ubernostrum on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @02:35AM (#17019247)
I just said I agree with RMS on this, and you straight up attacked me personally.

The worst thing I would wish on you is for you to live a while in a world run according to your own espoused values.

If you feel that's an attack, it's a problem with your values.

(at least, that's how I think I'm supposed to respond here, since people aren't supposed to "feel attacked" or "get offended" by such things, apparently)

Re:Who controls glibc? by sandov on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @03:48AM (#17019505)
You're basically saying his values are wrong without any explanation of how you came to such a conclusion. You're also making wild statements about how he would react to some imaginary world.

Probably not the right way to have a discussion.

Re:Who controls glibc? by ubernostrum on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @05:20AM (#17019767)
The comment was "People need to grow up", accompanied by blaming people for being offended.

I do think that's wrong. And I do think having to live in a world where everyone operated by those values would quickly cure the original commenter of believing this sort of thing. In fact, I think it's a very easy way to communicate what's wrong.

Re:Who controls glibc? by ajross on Monday May 07, 2018 @10:12PM (#17018304)
Yeah, this is one of those spots where RMS is stubbornly and stupidly standing up for principle in a context where the rest of us just clearly see that it shouldn't matter and he's just being a jerk.

But... damn if he's not right about this. The joke has meaning. It still means what he meant when he wrote it. The issue is an important one (to RMS, at least). And no one else has a real argument here other than "it's unprofessional and embarassing and we want it gone".

Same old, same old. The crusty bearded guy is a jerk, but he's right.

Re:Who controls glibc? by smsm42 on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @02:56AM (#17019319)
> And no one else has a real argument here other than "it's unprofessional and embarassing and we want it gone".

No one needs any better argument. It's unprofessional, and it's embarrassing (both as poorly executed joke and as political advocacy bolted onto the technical manual). RMS has a perfectly good personal site and lots of speaking engagements where he is very welcome to advocate whatever he likes and people are happy to see him to do just that. And nobody has a problem with it - nobody ever, as far as I know, demanded to close his site or protested him speaking anywhere, let alone demanded him to be banned. His advocacy (the fact that he's doing what he's doing) is very accepted even among people who disagree with him. However, he insists on doing in in the place where people don't want it. That's just being annoying and stubborn for no other reason but "because I want it so".

Re:Who controls glibc? by craigsmansion on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @05:43AM (#17019824)
> No one needs any better argument. It's unprofessional

I do. If you want professional, there are plenty of professional proprietary vendors out there. Or if you insist on Free Software, probably the BSDs are more professional.

GNU is a social project first, with quality and professionalism being secondary considerations.

The whole argument is about the removal of a statement against censorship (interpreted by some as an "abortion joke"). Of course a GNU project shouldn't remove such a thing for reasons of "being professional". I agree with rms here.

On the other side is the scope. Why is rms being so difficult here? Even though I think he's right, why not shrug it off? Why even bother?

I would disagree with rms here, were it not that in the past he's often been ridiculed for being quirky and irrational about minutiae, and yet here we are, with Facebook and Google controlling the internet, each one of us carrying a personal tracking device and loving it, and e-books being deleted remotely from devices we thought we owned.

So maybe this silly, trivial disagreement about some documentation is more important than I give it credit for at this moment.

rms is known for being difficult, not for being wrong.

Re:Who controls glibc? by smsm42 on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @03:51PM (#17024246)
> If you want professional, there are plenty of professional proprietary vendors out there

I do not see existence of other professional vendors a valid reason for behaving unprofessionaly. Nobody says RMS should behave professionally because otherwise there would be no professional vendors left. He should behave professionally because it's the right thing to do in this context, not because of availability concerns.

> GNU is a social project first

No, not really. Almost all effort is dedicated to code and surrounding matters (yes, GPL too), and very little is dedicated to societal change as such.

> with quality and professionalism being secondary considerations.

If it were true, GNU projects would die long ago. Nobody needs a compiler or a shell that is social project first and quality software second. Nobody would use it (ok, maybe a dozen or so of people would, but that's it). Fortunately, it is not the case at all.

> rms is known for being difficult, not for being wrong.

He's known for both. He has been wrong plenty. He also has been right plenty, including in many important things, but that doesn't make him infallible.

Re:Who controls glibc? by dralley on Monday May 07, 2018 @10:33PM (#17018377)
>The joke has meaning

Only if you're American and also have the requisite background knowledge to understand it, which many don't.

If you don't know the context, it's meaningless. Which is not a good thing to have in technical documentation.

Re:Who controls glibc? by gkya on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @01:34AM (#17019027)
I am not American but get the joke. Also, I can think of only a handful countries w/o any significant amount of opposers to abortion, and even those probably have quite a bit of them.
Re:Who controls glibc? by ryanlol on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @05:36AM (#17019807)
I'm European and we learned about the global gag rule in HS.

You really have to be clueless to not get the joke.

Re:Who controls glibc? by dingaling on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @06:02AM (#17019889)
'Clueless' is an offensively derogatory word in this context. An incredibly niche piece of legislation that applies to 5% of the World's population?

I had no idea it related to abortion . I have no knowledge of or interest in abortion laws. I assumed it was something related to US munitions export laws.

Re:Who controls glibc? by TeMPOraL on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @01:19AM (#17018979)
Laws seem to be the main export of the US these days, so you probably have the context. You definitely should have it if you work in computing, as almost everything in this industry is defined by how US of A sees things.
Re:Who controls glibc? by ajross on Monday May 07, 2018 @10:38PM (#17018397)
> Only if [you...] have the requisite background knowledge to understand it, which many don't.

It's literally the C library reference manual. That's true of the whole thing!

The point is that it has meaning, however obscure, and reflects a particular principled intent of the author. And the request to remove it is cosmetic. And you resolve that by holding to the author's intent and not just polishing it to fit your sense of aesthetics.

Your argument would be an excellent reason to reject a submitted joke that didn't reflect a consensus of the active maintainers; not so much to remove one decades after the fact.

Re:Who controls glibc? by __blockcipher__ on Monday May 07, 2018 @11:02PM (#17018509)
I find your line of reasoning vague and...I don't know the word, it seems very one-sided.

what do you mean by the "C library reference manual"? The glibc man or something else? Cause to me glibc is just GNU's implementation of the C standard.

RMS can decide what goes in the GNU manual, sure. But you didn't even address the fact that the joke is not understandable unless you're from a very specific background (how many people are familiar with US imperialistic politics and the global gag rule?)

Re:Who controls glibc? by dragandj on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @04:55AM (#17019701)
> (how many people are familiar with US imperialistic politics and the global gag rule?)

Many of us are, more or less. RMS's intention may be to inform more people about such rule(s), since US politics affects the whole world and it is good to be informed.

Re:Who controls glibc? by dralley on Monday May 07, 2018 @10:58PM (#17018491)
>It's literally the C library reference manual. That's true of the whole thing!

You have to know about the global gag rule prohibiting health providers that receive federal funds from discussing abortion with their patients to understand the entire C library reference manual? News to me.

Re:Who controls glibc? by ajross on Monday May 07, 2018 @11:18PM (#17018562)
No, the manual is a dry retelling of software capabilities without tutorial content, so its readers might reasonably be expected to be familiar with the idea of a section or two requiring some external context to interpret.

All you're telling me is that you'd prefer to be googling for strftime() examples on StackOverflow than reading an explainer on US abortion rights policy. Which is fine. But it's not like it would hurt you to learn a little extra stuff along the way, and RMS thinks it would be good for you. And he wrote the manual.

Re:Who controls glibc? by keiyakins on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @01:17PM (#17022656)
It's never helped anyone understand the technical material and it's caused at least one instance of confusion (https://stackoverflow.com/questions/48445031/why-would-it-be...), that's reason enough. Jokes in documentation are good, but only if they serve the documentation.
Re:Who controls glibc? by komali2 on Monday May 07, 2018 @08:17PM (#17017669)
I disagree with RMS because I don't think the joke adds to my ability to understand the usage of the function.
Re:Who controls glibc? by rurban on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @01:39AM (#17019049)
Then you didn't read the fine line. He was making a subtle reference to power politics how to abort a process. Properly or abrupt. A certain fraction of the group wanted to forbid this abrupt termination and only go through signals, so that everyone involved can have their say and be informed. This particular function sidestepped it, and as such was politically loaded. Removing this reference would remove the questioning of proper usage and the politics behind. But since current glibc maintainers are more worried about their profile than good documentation RMS vetoed.
Re:Who controls glibc? by komali2 on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @01:21PM (#17022681)
The joke doesn't really make sense to non-Americans
Re:Who controls glibc? by rurban on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @06:59AM (#17020069)
The proper term for the first variant is "kill all children", which is equally loaded. Next would be to change kill child to something worse, and go away with master slave.
Re:Who controls glibc? by smsm42 on Monday May 07, 2018 @08:31PM (#17017753)
This is harmless - probably true, nobody would die or suffer harm from having irrelevant content in the manual. We could splice full seven books of Harry Potter into it, and provided it is clearly marked up, it won't cause any serious harm. But glibc technical manuals are not exactly the place for RMS - or anybody else - to wage political advocacy campaigns, criticize US federal government or joke on the topics unrelated to the technical content. It's not harmful (which is a very high bar), but it's also not appropriate. Do we want to see political debate and advocacy in glibc manuals, commit messages, code comments and other places? Probably not. There are ample venues for this - and especially for a person with the name recognition RMS deservedly enjoys - to advocate anything he likes. He doesn't need the venue of glibc manuals for that, and shouldn't use it.
Re:Who controls glibc? by llukas on Monday May 07, 2018 @09:00PM (#17017931)
Try reading GPL license... is a political statement itself.

Is joke in documentation useful? Probably not...

Re:Who controls glibc? by smsm42 on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @12:22AM (#17018806)
True (which is one of the reasons I don't use GPL for my personal projects) but that doesn't mean GNU technical space should be a venue for every other political discussion in the world. There are far better venues out there.
Re:Who controls glibc? by TeMPOraL on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @01:21AM (#17018986)
Maybe, maybe not. I think the core issue is that RMS doesn't believe in that strong "technical" vs. "political" separation - to him, the whole GNU project is a political endeavour, including all the tech in it.
Re:Who controls glibc? by smsm42 on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @02:43AM (#17019274)
> that RMS doesn't believe in that strong "technical" vs. "political" separation

I do not believe that for a second. RMS is completely capable of seeing it, and he himself on his own site has this separation, and in there's no indication he is incapable of distinguishing between UNIX API and political advocacy. He just wants to use his considerable technical capital to promote his political agenda. In places, where such promotion is not appropriate.

Re:Who controls glibc? by rndgermandude on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @06:45AM (#17020029)
That's up for the people in the "GNU technical space" to determine.
Re:Who controls glibc? by rndgermandude on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @06:44AM (#17020024)
>But glibc technical manuals are not exactly the place for RMS - or anybody else - to wage political advocacy campaigns, criticize US federal government

What I write or not write in my manuals is not for you to decide. If I want pro-choice or pro-life advocacy in there, that's my decision. If I want "I'm with Her" or "MAGA" in there, still my decision. If I make a sucky hoke, you cannot and should not be able to force me to stop telling it.

Of course, you're free to criticize me, or offer feedback on how to improve, or just go with or create a competitor to my stuff, or even just resort to call me a "poohead" if you prefer. But don't ever presume you can just dictate to me what is OK, or "professional".

Same goes for RMS, whom I agree with in his argumentation in favor of his joke, but utterly wrong for trying to dictate to the actual maintainers of the glibc to keep it in against their wishes.

Re:Who controls glibc? by chris_wot on Monday May 07, 2018 @10:30PM (#17018366)
I doubt anyone cares hugely about political messages in commit comments.
Re:Who controls glibc? by smsm42 on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @12:20AM (#17018801)
Not hugely, probably, as one doesn't care hugely about stepping in dog's turd while walking on the street. Not the end of the world. Still better to have turd-less streets?
Re:Who controls glibc? by keiyakins on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @12:50PM (#17022412)
I read it the other way around, with RMS being the one offended and trying to correct everyone: the people maintaining glibc agreed to change part of the documentation because it wasn't serving a useful purpose, either as technical material, core philosophical material, or as material reinforcing one of those two (which can include a carefully-crafted joke, don't get me wrong). RMS got offended and tried to force them to keep it.