News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by colordrops on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:10PM (#16949217)
> While the researchers were certain the disembodied brains did not regain consciousness

I'm curious how they were able to verify this. I am under the (perhaps incorrect?) impression that consciousness is neither well defined nor a binary function.

Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by Karlozkiller on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:41PM (#16949317)
It's not well defined, but we can compare a dead brain to a brain in comatose to a fully awake and perceptive brain.

I assume, given what they say in the article, that the pig brain activity in the experiment was somewhere close to the activity of a dead brain or a brain in a coma.

They also explained that the blood-replacement they used contain a lot of inhibitive substances probably preventing the brains from being active even if they could.

Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by swebs on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:19PM (#16949250)
They measured brain waves via an electroencephalogram. The lack of brain waves reflects a lack of brain activity.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neural_oscillation

Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by herpderperator on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:17PM (#16949241)
I was also curious, but as I kept reading it seems they may have answered that.

> After initially shocking results indicating the brains were partially conscious – which later turned out to be mistaken – the scientists concluded they were producing a flat brain wave comparable with someone in a comatose state.

> “That animal brain is not aware of anything, I am very confident of that,” said Dr Sestan.

Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by cmrdporcupine on Saturday April 28, 2018 @05:35PM (#16949525)
You have to wonder if the evidence of lack of consciousness could just as easily be a result of the lack of any sensory input whatsoever.

I mean what does a brain do with absolutely no external stimulus at all?

Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by Baeocystin on Saturday April 28, 2018 @06:50PM (#16949855)
It hallucinates its own patterns.

the tl;dr is that a healthy brain produces a significant amount of activity, even absent of sensory stimulation.

https://www.quora.com/What-happens-in-the-brain-during-senso...

Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by Razengan on Saturday April 28, 2018 @09:23PM (#16950294)
> what does a brain do with absolutely no external stimulus at all?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dream

Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by rocqua on Saturday April 28, 2018 @05:44PM (#16949567)
How would we stimulate such a brain? Would you put electrodes on nerves going into the brain-stem?
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by newshorts on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:16PM (#16949237)
Agreed. It may not be observing itself but there was obviously some brain function.

This is fascinating research.

Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by blueprint on Saturday April 28, 2018 @05:12PM (#16949436)
How do you define consciousness such that pigs have actual consciousness on their own (without having spent some significant amount of time with humans)?
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by Shikadi on Saturday April 28, 2018 @05:55PM (#16949616)
What exactly does spending time with humans have to do with consciousness? Asking for a friend
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by caf on Sunday April 29, 2018 @10:05AM (#16952034)
A friend you haven't seen in a while?
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by blueprint on Sunday April 29, 2018 @08:40AM (#16951754)
I'll tell you later
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by staticassertion on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:17PM (#16949238)
"the scientists concluded they were producing a flat brain wave comparable with someone in a comatose state."
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by krona on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:18PM (#16949242)
Simply that certain brain waves correlate with some definition of awareness of your surroundings.

I'd imagine its pretty hard to be certain that a brain-dead person can't perceive his or her surroundings, however.

Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by monkpit on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:44PM (#16949327)
How would a disembodied brain even be capable of being “aware of its surroundings” without any sensory information?
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by Razengan on Saturday April 28, 2018 @09:22PM (#16950292)
Some sense of touch/pressure/temperature as the skin does, perhaps?

Consider how we can feel physical sensations in dreams without any physical source, or “phantom limbs” that amputees are sometimes said to feel.

Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by digi_owl on Saturday April 28, 2018 @11:14PM (#16950527)
That is not being aware, that is the brain making stuff up from noise.
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by swiley on Sunday April 29, 2018 @09:24AM (#16951890)
Human brains can’t sense any of that, idk about pig brains.
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by ghkbrew on Sunday April 29, 2018 @09:42AM (#16951949)
Fun fact: the retina and optic nerve are outgrowths of the developing brain, and commonly considered part of it. So technically a bare brain can see.
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by TomMckenny on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:28PM (#16949276)
But someone with far less brain activity than, for example, an unconscious patient on an operating table is not going to be more conscious.
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by Waterluvian on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:31PM (#16949284)
Its a rational, intuitive assumption. But we learn new things all the time.
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by zipwitch on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:57PM (#16949383)
Given that there are people walking around living perfectly normal lives who have only a small fraction of normal brain mass, I'm always skeptical of definitive pronouncements regarding conciousness.
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by logicallee on Sunday April 29, 2018 @07:04AM (#16951521)
>Given that there are people walking around living perfectly normal lives who have only a small fraction of normal brain mass,

Could you find a link perhaps? I Googled the end of what I just quoted but didn't find anything...

Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by no1youknowz on Saturday April 28, 2018 @05:10PM (#16949426)
I'm surprised no one has mentioned Psycho-pass just yet [0].

The Sibyl System is made up of networked human brains giving tremendous computation ability.

Would not surprise me that the answer on what's beyond silicon is actual living brain tissue being the CPU.

[0]: https://www.imdb.com/title/tt2379308/

Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by digi_owl on Saturday April 28, 2018 @11:20PM (#16950546)
Not quite.

The setup is that the brains come from people that "broke" the system, and are wired up to look for others that match their kind.

They are effectively there much like Neo and Zion are to the Matrix, a way to rebalance the system over time.

Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by kpil on Saturday April 28, 2018 @05:52PM (#16949595)
Spintronics.

It's possible to build compact neuromorphic devices using spintronics... Denser and more energy efficient.

Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by repsilat on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:28PM (#16949277)
The article mentions "ethical implications" a few times, but doesn't really hint at anything potentially negative. Obviously the potential to save or prolong lives is an enormous potential benefit, and any negative consequences would need to be elaborated on to be weighed against it.

Is it just that the technology smells like scary sci-fi stuff?

Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by thaumaturgy on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:55PM (#16949375)
One group of concerns is probably around unintentional harms -- for instance, only discovering much later that the process causes the brain to experience unimaginable pain or fear and without any way to communicate it or take action against it or even escape it by dying. It would be a form of hell that should terrify even the most stalwart of us.

The other would be intentional harm. Imagining the technology developing into the hopefully-far future, it's fair to also imagine interest from organizations like the CIA, who are so very fond of finding new ways to cruelly torture people while pretending they get good intelligence from it.

Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by saulrh on Saturday April 28, 2018 @07:27PM (#16949964)
I'm surprised that nobody's pointed out how... breathlessly far-fetched both of those scenarios are? You'd find out the "unimaginable pain and fear" thing the first time you woke someone up, and standard anesthesia already has this issue. And for the CIA, wouldn't "take out their brain and hook wires into it" kind of constitute "major surgery without consent or medical reason"?
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by theonemind on Saturday April 28, 2018 @08:04PM (#16950078)
We haven't reached the point of waking anyone up. Presumably, if this progresses, they could perhaps get better/more life-like/normal brainwave patterns, and THEN you have to work out I/O, like communication. So, I don't see that as far-fetched at all in the intermediate stages of developing it in a practical direction.

As for the CIA, MKULTRA? Bay of Pigs? Drug trafficking? You seem to imply a simple ethical boundary would stop them. I don't see much historical basis for believing that.

Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by thaumaturgy on Sunday April 29, 2018 @11:57AM (#16952520)
They are approximately as far-fetched as the ideas that AI will eventually destroy humanity or GMO crops will cause ecosystem collapse. Which is to say, it takes a new technology and contextualizes it with past bad behavior to try to imagine what the worst possible future looks like.

If this technology is developed further and eventually becomes available to more than a tiny number of people, I don't think we can guess what the positive or negative effects on society will be.

We never can; we live in a surveillance state, but it doesn't look like Orwell's 1984. We have advanced technology that the dreamers of the 1950s never foresaw, but no jetpacks or flying cars -- just miniaturized, globally-connected pocket computers designed to capture as much attention as possible. The global climate has continued to worsen since alarms were broadly sounded in the 1980s, but most of us that have the luxury of discussing the topic are sitting in nice little homes and offices and blissfully untouched by it all. We have high-tech network-connected systems and a mix of severely concentrated wealth and a much larger impoverished group, but none of this looks like cyberpunk genre fiction.

Bad futures tend to happen gently enough for them to seem perfectly acceptable. A lot of people even come to defend them.

Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by digi_owl on Saturday April 28, 2018 @11:29PM (#16950568)
Anyone get that Metallica(?) video going through their head, about the soldier?
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by digi_owl on Saturday April 28, 2018 @11:27PM (#16950563)
Gets me thinking of the prison in Minority Report.

What do pre-crime do to someone they grabbed for what they were supposed to do if pre-crime didn't intervene? Put them in a stasis tank while they get to watch their supposed future crime on repeat.

What would even be the goal of such a prison?

Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by joe_the_user on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:39PM (#16949303)
"The ethical implications are left as exercise for the reader".

Keeping a brain alive outside the body might be have the problem that it in constant pain and unable to act in the world in any meaningful way. What more terrifying experience could imagine than being aware and utterly "disembodied"?

But then again, it might have the implication that the brain might installed in a new body with the slight problem that existing brain is evicted. Sure, some healthy bodies with dysfunctional brains can be found but that's only a short term problem.

Nothing that hasn't covered by the scariest horror movies you can think of. The movie "get out" occurs to me - old people parasitizing younger bodies, rich people parasitizing poorer bodies, etc.

Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by pmoriarty on Saturday April 28, 2018 @05:04PM (#16949408)
"in constant pain and unable to act in the world in any meaningful way"

This is how many factory farmed animals already live.

Where is the outrage?

Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by sizzle on Sunday April 29, 2018 @10:29PM (#16955251)
Great point, reminded me of the stress hormones that their animal brains release into the meat I mindlessly consume. I think I'm gonna be vegetarian for a while...
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by gtirloni on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:53PM (#16949368)
"Altered Carbon" also poses this problem.
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by fencepost on Saturday April 28, 2018 @06:24PM (#16949736)
Is prolonged solitary confinement considered torture? How about if it's in a sensory deprivation tank? Then add paralytics.

Now contemplate consciousness with no sensory input at all (not even your own heartbeat or normal bodily sensations when you move, etc.) leaving only whatever phantom sensation the traumatized nerves generate, like amputees' phantom limbs and phantom pain, but for your only sensation.

On an individual basis this may be the most terrifying thing I could ever imagine.

Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by lostlogin on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:42PM (#16949321)
CPR can be ethically complicated, this is a step more so. How does consent work? Who can give it? What if the revived brain somehow asks to be switched off - is that suicide or assisted suicide or neither? Does it have rights? Property rights? Can it make decisions about the things it owns? How do those decisions get authorised?
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by homonculus1 on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:46PM (#16949340)
Why should any of those answers be different than for a person under normal circumstances?
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by lostlogin on Saturday April 28, 2018 @09:23PM (#16950293)
Euthanasia isn’t legal many places and life as a brain is probably not for everyone. How do you communicate with it or know what it wants. How does that get into a legal document. There is little about it that is comparable with a normal human existence.
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by vivekd on Saturday April 28, 2018 @06:29PM (#16949762)
This is the part I'm wondering about - my uncle died of a malignant brain tumor recently. I wonder if it would be possible to use a technique like this to transplant parts of a healthy donor brain to his brain. I read about two being done on wikipedia but it seems like something that is largely out of reach for now.
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by p1esk on Saturday April 28, 2018 @08:17PM (#16950116)
I think it might be easier to transplant a whole brain than to transplant a part of a brain. I'm not even sure the latter is possible at all.
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by rocqua on Saturday April 28, 2018 @05:47PM (#16949576)
Is a disembodied but conscious human brain a pig? If so, suppose it is in pain? It certainly stands to reason that a brain without a body would be very confused. At the very least, fear would be a logical reaction.

None of this is certain, but I think little of this is very controversial.

Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by spydum on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:35PM (#16949289)
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by cup-of-tea on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:25PM (#16949267)
This is truly horrifying. Makes me think of _I Have No Mouth, and I Must Scream_.
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by anvandare on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:51PM (#16949360)
They haven't figured out how to interact with the nerves to create any kind of sensory input (vision, hearing, taste, smell, touch, balance, ...), so no Altered Carbon-like virtual reality where you can be tortured to death over and over again.

Well, not yet, anyway.

Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by Sharlin on Saturday April 28, 2018 @05:49PM (#16949586)
The point is we don’t know what sort of horribly torturous experience it might be to be a conscious mind disconnected from all sensory input.
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by anvandare on Saturday April 28, 2018 @06:28PM (#16949756)
That's what sensory deprivation tanks are for. As the brain is a constant pattern-matcher and input-filter, depriving it of fresh inputs seems to turn it a bit hallucinatory, it starts to make up stuff (could be described as boredom, perhaps?). Feynman seemed to enjoy the experience somewhat (described in "Surely you're joking, mr Feynman").

Of course, every person's experience could be unique and different.

Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by x3haloed on Sunday April 29, 2018 @12:29AM (#16950699)
I have an idea. Try dissociatives.
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by x3haloed on Sunday April 29, 2018 @12:38AM (#16950719)
Or if you buy into social drug stigmas, then research dissociatives.
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by rocqua on Saturday April 28, 2018 @05:42PM (#16949561)
> “To ensure the success and social acceptance of this research long term, an ethical framework must be forged now”

It seems to me like the ethical framework surrounding this depends rather a lot on the outcome of these experiments. We have no idea what a disembodied consciousness experiences. Nor do we know what, if anything, they would express. To me, the answers to these questions determine the ethics of this to a very large degree.

One might argue that the possibilities are so horrible that we should not proceed. And yet I cannot help but be curious.

Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by ItsMe000001 on Sunday April 29, 2018 @09:00AM (#16951814)
> We have no idea what a disembodied consciousness experiences.

Try sensory deprivation (or isolation) tanks, or just solitary confinement. Both and especially the latter obviously are just a tiny fraction as bad. You don't spend much time in a tank, and the solitary confinement still leaves you with your senses. But already getting too much of either is pretty bad.

As an exercise for yourself: Just sit completely still in a completely quiet and dark room for as long as you can (try the cellar).

Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by x3haloed on Sunday April 29, 2018 @12:41AM (#16950727)
We should experiment on ourselves instead of animals if we expect to reap all the benefit. We do have an idea. Try dissociatives. Or at least read about them.
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by x3haloed on Sunday April 29, 2018 @12:45AM (#16950736)
Hint: it CAN be extremely terrifying.
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by mirimir on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:18PM (#16949245)
Here it comes ... pig-brain powered autopilot.

OK, maybe not pig brains. Maybe dog brains. Dogs are pack animals, and quite trainable.

Remember the watchdogs in Cryptonomicon :)

PETA would not be happy, however.

Edit: No, that was Snow Crash. How embarrassing :(

Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by Someone on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:29PM (#16949279)
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by mirimir on Saturday April 28, 2018 @06:14PM (#16949686)
I don't think that you'd actually want a dog driving your car. But yes, the anti-tank dogs didn't work out. So maybe you don't want dog brains.
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by gamw_mana_sou on Saturday April 28, 2018 @05:20PM (#16949465)
PETA might be the most known animal welfare-related organization, but they aren't really worthy to be a drop-in replacement for the generic term.

Also, allegedly, China experiments on humans. Human rights organizations probably wouldn't be happy to see the resulting scientific papers.

Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by mirimir on Saturday April 28, 2018 @06:19PM (#16949712)
Maybe human brains would work in China. But that'd be pushing the envelope.

In Hannu Rajaniemi's Flower Prince trilogy, he posits that the minds of billions of people will get uploaded, and that all but a few rich ones will end up as slaves. Basically apps.

Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by noir_lord on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:36PM (#16949294)
Or Rat Things from Snow Crash.
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by mirimir on Saturday April 28, 2018 @06:14PM (#16949693)
Yes, that's what I meant. They were dogs.
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by Herodotus38 on Saturday April 28, 2018 @07:40PM (#16949991)
While I am not sure how long the Soviets were able to keep the dogs alive for (they say "hours"), there is a very interesting film about reanimation of dogs from decades ago.

Warning that the film does show a decapitated dog being artificially kept alive through a bypass device. A much different era.

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=KDqh-r8TQgs

Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by theonemind on Saturday April 28, 2018 @07:57PM (#16950058)
I have seen this. I tend to question whether they actually did it, and whether this represents an authentic film.

Consider, say, the space race. They have a clear motivation to demonstrate superiority close to this era. I have also gotten the impression that the classic soviet government didn't exactly have a reputation for sterling honesty, and this doesn't seem wildly far afield from something you could achieve with practical effects.

I have limited specialist domain knowledge, but the head doesn't really have a power source. Blood can give the brain oxygen, but hours seems a bit far-fetched. They definitely skip a lot of detail here, like where/how they oxygenate the blood without lungs. The head has the brain, which takes a lot of energy to run for its size, and probably doesn't carry out the metabolic processes of energy production, with the blood/brain barrier. So, you have a big power draw, and no engine. Hours of observable or verifiable life seems like a lot for stale blood with no power source and a big power draw.

I also don't know the authentic history of the video to verify it didn't come as a complete fabrication of a historical curiosity at a later date.

I would like to see credible verification, but it doesn't really add up.

Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by Herodotus38 on Saturday April 28, 2018 @11:51PM (#16950620)
Thank you for your response. I do have some domain knowledge as it seemed to be a crude form of ECMO (https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extracorporeal_membrane_oxyg...) , but it made me dig deeper into the history of extracorporeal perfusion. I think you will enjoy the link below which has a lot of information about the video.

The scientist in the beginning of the film is the famous physiologist Haldane, which is why I originally believed the video. However your response led me to find out he was a Marxist! Now I was torn and had doubts.

Turns out that while the film was propaganda aimed toward Western Scientists, it was real and did work.

http://perfusiontheory.com/who-really-invented-the-heartlung...

Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by theonemind on Sunday April 29, 2018 @12:16AM (#16950680)
Thanks for the link! It was interesting. I could never really figure out if it was real. Seems pretty advanced for the time. I definitely didn't know about ECMO.
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by ItsMe000001 on Sunday April 29, 2018 @09:06AM (#16951834)
> However your response led me to find out he was a Marxist!

You say that as if you just found out he was a member of ISIS and killed women and children by burning them alive. I can't find anything in Karl Marx' teachings that could cause such a response, even when you disagree with him completely.

Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by Herodotus38 on Monday April 30, 2018 @11:18PM (#16964359)
I think there is a misunderstanding about what is surprising, I'd be just as surprised if he was an Ayn Rand card-carrying objectivist (is that what they call themselves?). My surprise was that I didn't think Haldane would have any political bias to cause doubt about the authenticity of the video.
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by YaxelPerez on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:27PM (#16949270)
Is there any research being done into putting living neurons on a chip and having them process information?
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by gscott on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:58PM (#16949386)
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by ColanR on Saturday April 28, 2018 @06:07PM (#16949663)
I saw some research into that back in ~2004 (?), where researchers put rat neurons in a petri dish that had an electrode array inside. Had great success, the neurons were able to drive a little rc car around and fly a jet simulator.

I've seen nothing about it since then. I like to imagine the scientists are working on Terminators for DARPA.

Edit: guess I should've read the link in the other reply. :)

Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by acd on Sunday April 29, 2018 @09:29AM (#16951911)
Somebody will connect a neural interface to the pig brains. Then run neural programs on the brains as that will be power efficient. This seems like a scene from the movie the matrix.
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by vpribish on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:50PM (#16949354)
cool. but that's a lousy article just playing up the ick factor for clicks. I'd guess that this makes studying the living brain much easier - but they don't get into any detail.
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by CocoaGeek on Saturday April 28, 2018 @09:31PM (#16950321)
This is really disturbing :(
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by liveoneggs on Saturday April 28, 2018 @08:25PM (#16950135)
finally wilbur will be able to survive without charlotte.
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by georgeecollins on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:24PM (#16949264)
Brain in a jar!
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by fogzen on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:40PM (#16949313)
It’s odd people talk about ethics here but have no problem torturing and killing pigs so they can eat them.
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by Karlozkiller on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:47PM (#16949341)
I did find the experiment a bit more eerie than 'killing for food'. But that aside, some of the ethical problems they discussed in the article were regarding whether the possible revival of ones brain would mean that the person and his juridical status as a person would also follow, as well as his thoughts etc.

As opposed to if we experiment on some dead persons liver, if we experiment on his revived brain we might actually be experimenting on a conscious being (human), is what I believe is the main thing here.

Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by pavelrub on Saturday April 28, 2018 @05:55PM (#16949622)
Why is it odd? Those are very different kinds of "torture". This is like saying that it's odd that people are against waterboarding, but are fine with keeping people locked in prisons, even when done for purely retributive reasons.

Vegans have this bizarre tendency of reducing human ethics to a bunch of incorrect generalizations (i.e. a dog is sort of like a cow, therefore it's "odd" that people eat cows but consider it wrong to eat dogs), and are then baffled that the world doesn't follow their artificial ethical formalism.

Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by thret on Saturday April 28, 2018 @06:50PM (#16949854)
I don't think it's the eating they object to, but the killing. They protest this by not consuming, which lowers demand and reduces the need for violence against animals.
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by teaneedz on Saturday April 28, 2018 @07:42PM (#16949994)
Why is it incorrect?

Why is it artificial?

Very curious about your reasoning?

Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by jacquesm on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:44PM (#16949328)
Pigs are not typically tortured before they are killed for consumption.
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by fogzen on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:48PM (#16949342)
Yes, they are. We can split hairs over what qualifies as torture, but I invite you to familiarize yourself with how commodity pigs are raised and slaughtered.
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by jacquesm on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:51PM (#16949356)
I am quite aware of that and it's a good reason why I consume very little meat. But it is as nothing compared to keeping a brain alive outside of the body. If we did that to a human without their consent there would be blood in the streets.

Keep in mind that the whole reason pigs were used for this experiment is because they are biologically similar to humans.

Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by jonknee on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:54PM (#16949373)
> If we did that to a human without their consent there would be blood in the streets

The same could be said for almost anything we do with pigs

Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by jacquesm on Saturday April 28, 2018 @05:00PM (#16949392)
There is a big difference between the way pigs are treated for consumption and what is happening in this experiment. For all we know the rest of the pig was discarded.

To me there is a huge difference between killing animals for food and conducting ethically questionable experiments on them. Another bothersome element here is that pigs are super smart and even though they state they are sure the pig(s) never regained consciousness you have to wonder what kind of extreme stress they would have cause if that had not worked out.

Animal research is something that I hope we can do without in the near future. And if we all ate less meat (or none at all) then that would be for the better as well, though ironically that would likely mean that there would be no more domesticated animals kept for food at all except for cows (for milk) and chickens (for eggs).

Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by jonknee on Saturday April 28, 2018 @05:06PM (#16949413)
It sounds like they literally took the brains from slaughtered pigs. I don't know why they wouldn't have processed the meat as normal.

> Brains rescued from a slaughterhouse had their circulation restored with a system of pumps, heaters and artificial blood.

Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by tao_oat on Saturday April 28, 2018 @05:25PM (#16949488)
It’s not really possible to separate the egg and dairy industries from the meat industry. What do you think happens to chickens or cows when their production levels start falling?
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by scottie_m on Sunday April 29, 2018 @10:07PM (#16955191)
More than that, male chicks are overwhelmingly not raised and just killed because they’re not particularly worth the money. Buying mass produced eggs means a lot of chicks died to make it efficient at the start. With cows the males who are not going to be used for breeding (very few are raised as bulls) are generally raised for veal.

As you say, they are inextricably linked on the large scale. At least for eggs though, you can definitely patronize small farms that don’t need to employ such aggressive economies of scale.

Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by throwaway413 on Saturday April 28, 2018 @05:08PM (#16949419)
You’re ignoring the method of killing the animal for food. It’s not just “killing them for food”. It’s the entire industrial process of slaughter at scale. Look into it sometime.
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by dghughes on Saturday April 28, 2018 @05:32PM (#16949515)
> pigs are super smart

Until they smell blood. If you ever go into a pig pen and cut yourself the pigs will attack you and probably kill you. Chickens are similar but of course being smaller they attack each other.

People these days more than ever want to anthropomorphize animals they like. But when instinct kicks in many of those animals are, well, just animals.

Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by georgyo on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:59PM (#16949389)
I suppose we could pack hundreds of non consenting humans so they are always touching each other on a metal grates for flooring and no sunshine, no access to bathrooms, and no ability to move around.

No one would complain about that. /s

Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by jacquesm on Saturday April 28, 2018 @05:01PM (#16949398)
Humans have done worse than that to other humans. And are doing so as we are having this conversation.
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by wutbrodo on Saturday April 28, 2018 @05:09PM (#16949424)
That level of inhumanity generally _is_ accompanied by "blood on the streets", as you put it in your original comment.
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by Sharlin on Saturday April 28, 2018 @05:40PM (#16949550)
So? That makes doing the same to animals morally acceptable?
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by dghughes on Saturday April 28, 2018 @05:25PM (#16949489)
Have you ever been on or near a farm ever, or even talked to (not shout at) a farmer? Pigs squeal for no reason and they squeal all the time I'm sure non-farmers assume squealing means pain.

I live in a rural area with lots of farming. A few people I know come from families that raise pigs and no they do not torture them. Even to the point of having a controlled access entry to the barn to prevent disease coming in from the outside (disinfectant tray for shoes).

It's hard work to maintain and raise animals for food farmers aren't going to spend time and effort torturing pigs which are their income. No business person is going to damage their product for kicks. A wheat farmer doesn't drive over his crop and flatten it. Fishermen don't throw dynamite into the water for fun.

Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by fogzen on Sunday April 29, 2018 @12:58AM (#16950758)
Yes, yes I have.

At minimum pigs are castrated, transported and imprisoned against their will, and slaughtered against their will. Small, independent or family farmers do take care to minimize suffering. Minimize, not eliminate.

That's not at all the case at industrial farms. Sows are raised and slaughtered in dismal conditions. Gestation crates, forced and early weaning, artificial insemination, etc. Sows raised for slaughter can experience physical abuse, sexual abuse, and psychological abuse in a number of ways.

Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by throwaway413 on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:49PM (#16949347)
Seconded and proud that fellow HNers are ethically conscious of their food.
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by throwaway413 on Saturday April 28, 2018 @06:22PM (#16949727)
Wow, most downvotes I’ve ever gotten, for simply showing support for other people on this site, nice...keep ‘em coming!
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by horsecaptin on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:46PM (#16949338)
Do you not think that hitting them, packing them into cramped conditions, transporting them in similar conditions is torturous?
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by gtirloni on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:50PM (#16949355)
People eating pork don't think their meat as coming from such conditions and/or want/expect that to happen. So it's not fair to say "people" are okay with that and not the brain experiment. Producers might be okay but that's a different argument to which the one you're replying in this thread.
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by Sharlin on Saturday April 28, 2018 @05:43PM (#16949563)
People don’t want to know what’s going on on factory farms about it because it makes them uncomfortable. A textbook example of cognitive dissonance. From ethics point of view that’s better than wholeheartedly endorsing it but not by a large margin.
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by jacquesm on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:52PM (#16949361)
There is plenty wrong with the bio-industry but to compare that and this experiment is not helping the discussion.

It's the same as saying that what was happening at Guantanamo bay was no worse than what was happening elsewhere so why all the fuss?

Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by horsecaptin on Saturday April 28, 2018 @09:06PM (#16950248)
Could you provide more specific examples of "what was happening everywhere else"?

An animal doesn't know if it is being raised for experimentation or food. They are simply being treated cruelly until they are slaughtered. They may even be leading a better life if they are being raised for experimentation than for slaughter. We on the other hand are trying to wipe our conscious clean by rationalizing the reasons behind the slaughter and putting food over knowledge. We don't need to eat meat to survive or thrive, so saying "but it is for food" holds no higher a moral ground than "but it is for an experiment".

Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by red75prime on Saturday April 28, 2018 @06:23PM (#16949731)
On the plus side they aren't being eaten alive as it happens in the wild.
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by horsecaptin on Saturday April 28, 2018 @08:57PM (#16950224)
In the wild, they get to be free until the day they are killed by a predator. In captivity they are treated cruelly, fattened, and slaughtered with no chance of escape. How is that a "plus side"?
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by red75prime on Sunday April 29, 2018 @12:34AM (#16950714)
The alternative lifestyle for them is not frolicking on a green grass, but non-existence. We are the cause that they exists. They don't know about "no chance of escape", you do. I'm all for labgrown meat, but mixing your own feelings and objective information about their assessment of quality of their own life (which you don't have) is not helping your cause.
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by horsecaptin on Wednesday May 02, 2018 @12:46PM (#16978807)
Feelings are there for a reason, mate. Mine tell me that an animal would rather not exist than being born into a life of torture followed by slaughter.
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by red75prime on Thursday May 10, 2018 @11:26PM (#17044773)
So a next step should be redesigning biosphere to eliminate suffering or eliminating all sufficiently intelligent animals. Their life is a struggle for survival followed by death, after all.
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by staticassertion on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:58PM (#16949387)
The people talking about ethics here are not necessarily people who would have no problem torturing and killing pigs for food.
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by clavalle on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:45PM (#16949336)
I'd prefer an animal not be tortured before I eat them.

And that's the concern, here; torture.

Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by trhway on Saturday April 28, 2018 @05:31PM (#16949507)
industrial scale meat production is basically a life-long torture for animals. Note: i gave up on pork and beef, still eat chicken, fish. Hope to get easy on chicken with time too. Artificial meat can't come too soon. Its impact on our civilizations would hardly be possible to overestimate. We'll be able to go off the hypocrisy of "only humans have soul" and finally look with open eyes and meet other intelligent creatures beside ourselves (i mean i hope we're intelligent creatures).
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by QML on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:45PM (#16949331)
It’s one thing to kill a pig; it’s another to bring them back.
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by joe_the_user on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:43PM (#16949323)
Most people would not be concerned if this were somehow just something people did and could only do to pigs. But the thing is that this is clearly showing what might be possible to do with people in a little bit.
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by dschuetz on Saturday April 28, 2018 @05:16PM (#16949449)
Hmm, but killing plants and fungi is totally OK then, yes?
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by tao_oat on Saturday April 28, 2018 @05:23PM (#16949478)
Yes. There’s a huge difference between a sentient being and a plant. I don’t think anyone seriously believes that these are morally equivalent.
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by dschuetz on Saturday April 28, 2018 @05:34PM (#16949521)
How do you distinct sentient beings? There are some plants which display indications for rudimentary sentience, some molds and fungi can also be sentient. Does your rather bold statement also apply there?
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by nukeop on Saturday April 28, 2018 @05:31PM (#16949509)
I don't see this being any more unethical or unnerving than keeping a liver a or a lung or a heart alive outside of a body. A brain is just another organ, it's not a mind. It is a vital organ, to be sure, but the article equates it with the "essence" of a living being. This involves too many assumptions.
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by codingdave on Saturday April 28, 2018 @06:17PM (#16949706)
Assuming it is not a mind and isn't in massive pain is also too many assumptions. If your stance can be proven, fine - but the ethical problem is getting to that proof without creating disembodied minds living a life of absolute torture, with no senses or possible actions or communications... just an endless experience of pain.
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by cheez on Saturday April 28, 2018 @07:45PM (#16950015)
I would suspect that being deprived of sensory input, you would become a vegetable after going crazy at some point.
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by creep on Saturday April 28, 2018 @05:51PM (#16949593)
This is true. The "mind" could very well exist outside of any organ system.
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by kpil on Saturday April 28, 2018 @05:54PM (#16949614)
No it can't.
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by creep on Saturday April 28, 2018 @07:16PM (#16949941)
Prove it?
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by Tade0 on Sunday April 29, 2018 @08:06AM (#16951685)
The sheer amount of energy used by this organ is a major hint.

Also damage to the brain has immediate and profound effects on one's mental capabilities as opposed to damage to any other organ.

Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by creep on Sunday April 29, 2018 @01:47PM (#16953032)
There are theories that the brain is just an interface for the mind-- as in, it exists apart from the brain, but the brain facilitates its expression in physicality. If the brain were damaged, the interface would thus be damaged, and you could no longer access the information provided by mind. There are theories that there is no such thing as mind. You didn't prove anything.
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by Tade0 on Sunday April 29, 2018 @06:51PM (#16954347)
Citation needed.

Where is the mind then according to these theories?

Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by creep on Tuesday May 01, 2018 @04:35PM (#16971279)
I'm not trying to prove that these people are right or wrong. The point is that no one knows.
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by yeukhon on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:16PM (#16949236)
“However, Dr Sestan has since said he does not wish to elaborate on the findings of his pig brain experiment, as he is awaiting publication of the results in a scientific journal.”

Hmm why? No spoiler? I wouldn’t mind sharing it right away.

Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by mirimir on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:20PM (#16949254)
Some journals are very picky about that. As in refusing to publish, if too much gets leaked.