News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by fogzen on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:40PM (#16949313)
It’s odd people talk about ethics here but have no problem torturing and killing pigs so they can eat them.
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by Karlozkiller on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:47PM (#16949341)
I did find the experiment a bit more eerie than 'killing for food'. But that aside, some of the ethical problems they discussed in the article were regarding whether the possible revival of ones brain would mean that the person and his juridical status as a person would also follow, as well as his thoughts etc.

As opposed to if we experiment on some dead persons liver, if we experiment on his revived brain we might actually be experimenting on a conscious being (human), is what I believe is the main thing here.

Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by pavelrub on Saturday April 28, 2018 @05:55PM (#16949622)
Why is it odd? Those are very different kinds of "torture". This is like saying that it's odd that people are against waterboarding, but are fine with keeping people locked in prisons, even when done for purely retributive reasons.

Vegans have this bizarre tendency of reducing human ethics to a bunch of incorrect generalizations (i.e. a dog is sort of like a cow, therefore it's "odd" that people eat cows but consider it wrong to eat dogs), and are then baffled that the world doesn't follow their artificial ethical formalism.

Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by thret on Saturday April 28, 2018 @06:50PM (#16949854)
I don't think it's the eating they object to, but the killing. They protest this by not consuming, which lowers demand and reduces the need for violence against animals.
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by teaneedz on Saturday April 28, 2018 @07:42PM (#16949994)
Why is it incorrect?

Why is it artificial?

Very curious about your reasoning?

Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by jacquesm on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:44PM (#16949328)
Pigs are not typically tortured before they are killed for consumption.
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by fogzen on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:48PM (#16949342)
Yes, they are. We can split hairs over what qualifies as torture, but I invite you to familiarize yourself with how commodity pigs are raised and slaughtered.
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by jacquesm on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:51PM (#16949356)
I am quite aware of that and it's a good reason why I consume very little meat. But it is as nothing compared to keeping a brain alive outside of the body. If we did that to a human without their consent there would be blood in the streets.

Keep in mind that the whole reason pigs were used for this experiment is because they are biologically similar to humans.

Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by jonknee on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:54PM (#16949373)
> If we did that to a human without their consent there would be blood in the streets

The same could be said for almost anything we do with pigs

Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by jacquesm on Saturday April 28, 2018 @05:00PM (#16949392)
There is a big difference between the way pigs are treated for consumption and what is happening in this experiment. For all we know the rest of the pig was discarded.

To me there is a huge difference between killing animals for food and conducting ethically questionable experiments on them. Another bothersome element here is that pigs are super smart and even though they state they are sure the pig(s) never regained consciousness you have to wonder what kind of extreme stress they would have cause if that had not worked out.

Animal research is something that I hope we can do without in the near future. And if we all ate less meat (or none at all) then that would be for the better as well, though ironically that would likely mean that there would be no more domesticated animals kept for food at all except for cows (for milk) and chickens (for eggs).

Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by jonknee on Saturday April 28, 2018 @05:06PM (#16949413)
It sounds like they literally took the brains from slaughtered pigs. I don't know why they wouldn't have processed the meat as normal.

> Brains rescued from a slaughterhouse had their circulation restored with a system of pumps, heaters and artificial blood.

Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by tao_oat on Saturday April 28, 2018 @05:25PM (#16949488)
It’s not really possible to separate the egg and dairy industries from the meat industry. What do you think happens to chickens or cows when their production levels start falling?
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by scottie_m on Sunday April 29, 2018 @10:07PM (#16955191)
More than that, male chicks are overwhelmingly not raised and just killed because they’re not particularly worth the money. Buying mass produced eggs means a lot of chicks died to make it efficient at the start. With cows the males who are not going to be used for breeding (very few are raised as bulls) are generally raised for veal.

As you say, they are inextricably linked on the large scale. At least for eggs though, you can definitely patronize small farms that don’t need to employ such aggressive economies of scale.

Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by throwaway413 on Saturday April 28, 2018 @05:08PM (#16949419)
You’re ignoring the method of killing the animal for food. It’s not just “killing them for food”. It’s the entire industrial process of slaughter at scale. Look into it sometime.
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by dghughes on Saturday April 28, 2018 @05:32PM (#16949515)
> pigs are super smart

Until they smell blood. If you ever go into a pig pen and cut yourself the pigs will attack you and probably kill you. Chickens are similar but of course being smaller they attack each other.

People these days more than ever want to anthropomorphize animals they like. But when instinct kicks in many of those animals are, well, just animals.

Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by georgyo on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:59PM (#16949389)
I suppose we could pack hundreds of non consenting humans so they are always touching each other on a metal grates for flooring and no sunshine, no access to bathrooms, and no ability to move around.

No one would complain about that. /s

Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by jacquesm on Saturday April 28, 2018 @05:01PM (#16949398)
Humans have done worse than that to other humans. And are doing so as we are having this conversation.
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by wutbrodo on Saturday April 28, 2018 @05:09PM (#16949424)
That level of inhumanity generally _is_ accompanied by "blood on the streets", as you put it in your original comment.
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by Sharlin on Saturday April 28, 2018 @05:40PM (#16949550)
So? That makes doing the same to animals morally acceptable?
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by dghughes on Saturday April 28, 2018 @05:25PM (#16949489)
Have you ever been on or near a farm ever, or even talked to (not shout at) a farmer? Pigs squeal for no reason and they squeal all the time I'm sure non-farmers assume squealing means pain.

I live in a rural area with lots of farming. A few people I know come from families that raise pigs and no they do not torture them. Even to the point of having a controlled access entry to the barn to prevent disease coming in from the outside (disinfectant tray for shoes).

It's hard work to maintain and raise animals for food farmers aren't going to spend time and effort torturing pigs which are their income. No business person is going to damage their product for kicks. A wheat farmer doesn't drive over his crop and flatten it. Fishermen don't throw dynamite into the water for fun.

Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by fogzen on Sunday April 29, 2018 @12:58AM (#16950758)
Yes, yes I have.

At minimum pigs are castrated, transported and imprisoned against their will, and slaughtered against their will. Small, independent or family farmers do take care to minimize suffering. Minimize, not eliminate.

That's not at all the case at industrial farms. Sows are raised and slaughtered in dismal conditions. Gestation crates, forced and early weaning, artificial insemination, etc. Sows raised for slaughter can experience physical abuse, sexual abuse, and psychological abuse in a number of ways.

Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by throwaway413 on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:49PM (#16949347)
Seconded and proud that fellow HNers are ethically conscious of their food.
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by throwaway413 on Saturday April 28, 2018 @06:22PM (#16949727)
Wow, most downvotes I’ve ever gotten, for simply showing support for other people on this site, nice...keep ‘em coming!
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by horsecaptin on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:46PM (#16949338)
Do you not think that hitting them, packing them into cramped conditions, transporting them in similar conditions is torturous?
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by gtirloni on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:50PM (#16949355)
People eating pork don't think their meat as coming from such conditions and/or want/expect that to happen. So it's not fair to say "people" are okay with that and not the brain experiment. Producers might be okay but that's a different argument to which the one you're replying in this thread.
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by Sharlin on Saturday April 28, 2018 @05:43PM (#16949563)
People don’t want to know what’s going on on factory farms about it because it makes them uncomfortable. A textbook example of cognitive dissonance. From ethics point of view that’s better than wholeheartedly endorsing it but not by a large margin.
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by jacquesm on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:52PM (#16949361)
There is plenty wrong with the bio-industry but to compare that and this experiment is not helping the discussion.

It's the same as saying that what was happening at Guantanamo bay was no worse than what was happening elsewhere so why all the fuss?

Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by horsecaptin on Saturday April 28, 2018 @09:06PM (#16950248)
Could you provide more specific examples of "what was happening everywhere else"?

An animal doesn't know if it is being raised for experimentation or food. They are simply being treated cruelly until they are slaughtered. They may even be leading a better life if they are being raised for experimentation than for slaughter. We on the other hand are trying to wipe our conscious clean by rationalizing the reasons behind the slaughter and putting food over knowledge. We don't need to eat meat to survive or thrive, so saying "but it is for food" holds no higher a moral ground than "but it is for an experiment".

Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by red75prime on Saturday April 28, 2018 @06:23PM (#16949731)
On the plus side they aren't being eaten alive as it happens in the wild.
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by horsecaptin on Saturday April 28, 2018 @08:57PM (#16950224)
In the wild, they get to be free until the day they are killed by a predator. In captivity they are treated cruelly, fattened, and slaughtered with no chance of escape. How is that a "plus side"?
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by red75prime on Sunday April 29, 2018 @12:34AM (#16950714)
The alternative lifestyle for them is not frolicking on a green grass, but non-existence. We are the cause that they exists. They don't know about "no chance of escape", you do. I'm all for labgrown meat, but mixing your own feelings and objective information about their assessment of quality of their own life (which you don't have) is not helping your cause.
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by horsecaptin on Wednesday May 02, 2018 @12:46PM (#16978807)
Feelings are there for a reason, mate. Mine tell me that an animal would rather not exist than being born into a life of torture followed by slaughter.
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by red75prime on Thursday May 10, 2018 @11:26PM (#17044773)
So a next step should be redesigning biosphere to eliminate suffering or eliminating all sufficiently intelligent animals. Their life is a struggle for survival followed by death, after all.
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by staticassertion on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:58PM (#16949387)
The people talking about ethics here are not necessarily people who would have no problem torturing and killing pigs for food.
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by clavalle on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:45PM (#16949336)
I'd prefer an animal not be tortured before I eat them.

And that's the concern, here; torture.

Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by trhway on Saturday April 28, 2018 @05:31PM (#16949507)
industrial scale meat production is basically a life-long torture for animals. Note: i gave up on pork and beef, still eat chicken, fish. Hope to get easy on chicken with time too. Artificial meat can't come too soon. Its impact on our civilizations would hardly be possible to overestimate. We'll be able to go off the hypocrisy of "only humans have soul" and finally look with open eyes and meet other intelligent creatures beside ourselves (i mean i hope we're intelligent creatures).
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by QML on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:45PM (#16949331)
It’s one thing to kill a pig; it’s another to bring them back.
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by joe_the_user on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:43PM (#16949323)
Most people would not be concerned if this were somehow just something people did and could only do to pigs. But the thing is that this is clearly showing what might be possible to do with people in a little bit.
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by dschuetz on Saturday April 28, 2018 @05:16PM (#16949449)
Hmm, but killing plants and fungi is totally OK then, yes?
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by tao_oat on Saturday April 28, 2018 @05:23PM (#16949478)
Yes. There’s a huge difference between a sentient being and a plant. I don’t think anyone seriously believes that these are morally equivalent.
Re:Pig brains kept alive outside bodies for first time by dschuetz on Saturday April 28, 2018 @05:34PM (#16949521)
How do you distinct sentient beings? There are some plants which display indications for rudimentary sentience, some molds and fungi can also be sentient. Does your rather bold statement also apply there?