News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Avoid Google Maps with Gnome Maps on GNU/Linux by korginator on Sunday April 15, 2018 @09:42AM (#16842578)
Much as I would like to avoid google, the routing on OSM or graphhopper leaves a lot to be desired.

There's no routing using public transport. Half the buildings I've tried looking up either don't exist on OSM / Gnome maps, or result in an address half-way across the globe.

That said, I prefer using HERE maps as it works very well in offline mode, including voice navigation, compared to anything else I've tried.

The fact is that getting a global mapping and navigation solution right takes tremendous effort and money (Apple can tell you a lot about how their attempts worked out for them), and I want an application that I can trust and that just works when I'm behind the wheel or at an unfamiliar location.

I'm sure OSM and alternatives will continue to improve over the years, and I'll play with them occasionally, but I will still go back to HERE, waze or google maps for the important stuff.

Re:Avoid Google Maps with Gnome Maps on GNU/Linux by my123 on Sunday April 15, 2018 @10:35AM (#16842801)
Even Apple struggles a bit with their maps despite financial resources. MS got help from HERE to get good maps...

Building these things is hard

Re:Avoid Google Maps with Gnome Maps on GNU/Linux by astrange on Sunday April 15, 2018 @09:12PM (#16846035)
Every time someone mentions HERE, I check Tokyo and see that it's still entirely missing.
Re:Avoid Google Maps with Gnome Maps on GNU/Linux by nerdponx on Sunday April 15, 2018 @06:50PM (#16845464)
The biggest problem with these open source maps is that there is no painless way to contribute updates.
Re:Avoid Google Maps with Gnome Maps on GNU/Linux by jmkb on Sunday April 15, 2018 @07:26PM (#16845632)
Updating OpenStreetMap is incredibly easy. Create an account, click edit (iD, the javascript-based map editor, is intuitive and highly functional), make changes, click "save."

The hard part is learning how to map well. The documentation is fragmented: There's a multi-language wiki with a lot of inconsistencies in the translations. There are dozens of mailing lists for various regions and sub-topics. There are IRC channels. There's a web forum. There's a subreddit. There's a Stack-Overflow-style Q&A help site. There are Youtube videos. And you can often find a different answer to a simple question in each of these resources! A little chaotic. But I wouldn't quite call it painful.

Re:Avoid Google Maps with Gnome Maps on GNU/Linux by alsetmusic on Sunday April 15, 2018 @10:33PM (#16846305)
> Updating OpenStreetMap is incredibly easy. Create an account…

Creating an account is a pain point for some people. I notify companies and individuals all the time about typos, dead links, bugs, etc. In any instance where I am not an established user, the process halts when I have to create an account. I’m giving freely of my time and knowledge; the process for me to do so should be as close to effortless as possible.

Re:Avoid Google Maps with Gnome Maps on GNU/Linux by jmkb on Sunday April 15, 2018 @11:07PM (#16846419)
> Creating an account is a pain point for some people.

Fair enough. And even fairer, if you're not an experienced mapper you may easily be able to spot a problem but not be sure how exactly to fix it. OSM has you covered -- right-click the map and select "Add a note here". Add a quick note with all relevant info. It won't appear on the map, but mappers who are working in the area will (hopefully) see it and fix it.

Not sure if Gnome Maps implements this functionality, but most phone-based OSM clients do.

Re:Avoid Google Maps with Gnome Maps on GNU/Linux by craftyguy on Sunday April 15, 2018 @11:08PM (#16846421)
It's literally like wikipedia. Anyone can contribute, provided they make an account. There has to be some accountability with edits, hence the requirement. Your dream requires accepting anonymous edits, which opens the doors wide open to abuse.
Re:Avoid Google Maps with Gnome Maps on GNU/Linux by marssaxman on Monday April 16, 2018 @01:50AM (#16846904)
You don't need an account to help with wikipedia. I've never created an account, but I've fixed many typos, anonymously.
Re:Avoid Google Maps with Gnome Maps on GNU/Linux by rmc on Monday April 16, 2018 @03:25AM (#16847252)
OSM used to have anonymous edits, but that was disabled more than 10 years ago

https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Anonymous_edits

Re:Avoid Google Maps with Gnome Maps on GNU/Linux by probably_wrong on Monday April 16, 2018 @03:40AM (#16847305)
> There's no routing using public transport.

At the same time, I found OSM much more reliable when it comes to finding public transport stops in small cities. True, it's not great when it comes to "how do I get to X", but it's great for "what's the closest public transport stop near X" in cities that Google Maps doesn't/won't support.

Re:Avoid Google Maps with Gnome Maps on GNU/Linux by aesh2Xa1 on Sunday April 15, 2018 @10:05AM (#16842656)
You can contribute better directions/addresses!
Re:Avoid Google Maps with Gnome Maps on GNU/Linux by brudgers on Sunday April 15, 2018 @11:28AM (#16843046)
When a person is lost or misdirected, the priority is usually figuring out how to get where they wanted to go. Fixing the map is a low priority. Learning the complexities of the OSM API's and toolings is even lower. The process is complicated with many moving parts and tailored toward commercial level development not end map users. OSM, like any sophisticated database is complex and requires a substantial degree of technical commitment.
Re:Avoid Google Maps with Gnome Maps on GNU/Linux by maxerickson on Sunday April 15, 2018 @11:50AM (#16843150)
Adding a couple addresses using the editor built into the website should take 15-20 minutes (the first time, to register and do the walkthrough and such, just a couple minutes after that).

No need to muck directly with APIs and so on to make a quick contribution.

Re:Avoid Google Maps with Gnome Maps on GNU/Linux by brudgers on Sunday April 15, 2018 @06:27PM (#16845348)
The structure of these projects is a long way from abstractions that deal with "Oh Shit, I'm lost and I'm late" well. The projects are largely inward focused and there's a lot of developers talking among themselves instead. The Open Street Maps page has no "Fix an Error" link. It has Help. Typing in an address and getting irrelevant data isn't a user error. It's a bug. Help is the wrong abstraction.

Gnome Maps is a layer of abstraction on top of that. Not only is there no "Fix an Error" link, there's no clear path for an end user reach the Beginner's page in the OSM Wiki explaining how to edit data.

Re:Avoid Google Maps with Gnome Maps on GNU/Linux by rmc on Monday April 16, 2018 @03:34AM (#16847285)
> The Open Street Maps page has no "Fix an Error" link.

If you right click on the map, or click the "add a note" button on the right hand side, you can add a note to the map describing a mistake. You don't need to be logged in

Re:Avoid Google Maps with Gnome Maps on GNU/Linux by brudgers on Monday April 16, 2018 @12:09PM (#16850029)
How do I right click on my phone? While a bit tongue in cheek, the assumption that I'm on a computer when using a map is about a decade past the tipping point. Ignoring that, while it's good to know adding notes is a possibility, the channel by which it is conveyed, a Hacker News comment hours later, is exactly why the absence of a "fix an error" button is so frustrating. Nobody outside the OSM community looking at "add a note" would know that it is a good way to record an error.
Re:Avoid Google Maps with Gnome Maps on GNU/Linux by rmc on Monday April 16, 2018 @03:31PM (#16851969)
> How do I right click on my phone?

On osm.org on my Firefox on Android I can long press and get the same popup which allows me to "Add a note". There is also the button on the right hand side for adding a note.

> a Hacker News comment hours later

My apologies, I'm in Europe and timezones, eh?

> Nobody outside the OSM community looking at "add a note" would know that it is a good way to record an error.

Can you suggest a better wording? or icon? Or system?

FTR, when you click on "add a note to the map" you get text saying:

> Spotted a mistake or something missing? Let other mappers know so we can fix it. Move the marker to the correct position and type a note to explain the problem.

Re:Avoid Google Maps with Gnome Maps on GNU/Linux by brudgers on Monday April 16, 2018 @05:05PM (#16852770)
Better wording "Fix an Error".
Re:Avoid Google Maps with Gnome Maps on GNU/Linux by squiggleblaz on Sunday April 15, 2018 @09:59PM (#16846199)
Hear hear. When I'm on a computer I usually go to Google because if I go to OSM and type in a nearby major road, it gives me a list of addresses. And the one I want is probably thirtieth on the list and has a form that is obscure. If you can't search for street names in OSM, it shouln't let me try. Instead of giving me useless results, it should direct me to how I can obtain useful results.

"Commercial Road" - no relevant results in two pages.

"Commercial Road malvern" - no results at all. It turns out in Malvern, Commercial Rd is called Malvern Rd. It seems cruel that OSM requires me to tell it exactly what I'm searching for and to get it right. Giving related information to help the search doesn't help it find the location.

"Sydney Road" - no relevant results.

"Sydney Road brunswick" - finally, the first result is listed as "Sydney Road, Brunswick, City of Moreland, Greater Melbourne, Victoria, 3052, Australia", but it's death by too much information. (a) It's buried in a list of very similar results and I can't quite be sure the one I got is the one I want - this becomes a bigger problem with a minor street. (b) who cares that it's in the city of Moreland? If you're going to list the local administrative district name, why not also the state electoral division? Address are place names, and "City of Moreland" simply isn't a place name. It's the name of the territory controlled by the Moreland City Council, but it's not a placename. Combining (a) and (b), take a look at "Sydney Road, Sparta Place, Brunswick, City of Moreland, Greater Melbourne, Victoria, 3039, Australia". What's that even supposed to mean? I cry.

Google suffers the problem in the opposite way, normalising addresses to the most obscure and ambiguous form they could find, preferring road numbers to names, and using "Melbourne" instead of the suburb name. But at least it finds the place I'm after. OSM is barely useable. Not for want of data, but because it just doesn't care to tell me how to find what I'm looking for. It's exhausting. OSM is useless for practical purposes. I want to use it for a variety of reasons, but I can't.

Re:Avoid Google Maps with Gnome Maps on GNU/Linux by jmkb on Monday April 16, 2018 @01:19PM (#16850775)
The default search functionality on OSM ("reverse geocoding" in mapspeak) does, indeed, need a lot of improvement. It's actually a separate project called Nominatim[1]. It's on Github and you can browse the issues and see a lot of similar complaints.

It's a daunting problem, parsing a free text query that may be in any language and trying to best match it with addresses that are standardized a hundred different ways all over the globe. In its current state it isn't good enough for everyday use. It's annoying how often a Google Maps search sends me to the wrong state or even the wrong country. But with Nominatim it's almost a given.

This underscores one of the fundamental features/bugs of the OSM project: It's pretty good at attracting mappers, developers, and 3rd-party projects that use its data and APIs, but it's never really been designed to meet the needs of end users. UX, according to the classic OSM schema, is to be implemented by the various 3rd parties in whatever way suits them best. If someone wants to develop and host a Google Maps replacement using OSM data they're welcome to do it (and they can provide their own reverse geocoding solution if necessary) but that's not an immediate goal of OSM itself, according to the current leadership.

[1] https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Nominatim

Re:Avoid Google Maps with Gnome Maps on GNU/Linux by maxerickson on Monday April 16, 2018 @10:26AM (#16849195)
Sure, but that's a funnel problem, not a problem with the level of learning required to do a basic contribution. Someone with a modest level of commitment will probably make it through the sign up and tutorial.

Apparently there's an issue where you think the beginner walk through should be better advertised outside of the sign up process?

Re:Avoid Google Maps with Gnome Maps on GNU/Linux by brudgers on Monday April 16, 2018 @11:57AM (#16849884)
The "funnel problem" manifests itself as a data problem. More importantly, the "funnel problem" is a social problem. A modest level of commitment to learning software is much more modest than a modest level of commitment to fixing software. Learning how to use open source mapping software is based on the immediate practical value of getting from A to B. Learning how to fix open source mapping software requires a different set of values, it requires a commitment to a philosophy/ideology/goal of arguable merit. I'm not arguing for or against it. Only pointing out that taking the moral high ground leads to the idea that signing up and working through a tutorial is a reasonable act by ordinary users when the alternative is Google Maps.
Re:Avoid Google Maps with Gnome Maps on GNU/Linux by maxerickson on Monday April 16, 2018 @12:24PM (#16850198)
I honestly don't expect it of ordinary users.

I was explicitly pushing back against your depiction of contributing: Learning the complexities of the OSM API's and toolings is even lower. The process is complicated with many moving parts and tailored toward commercial level development not end map users. OSM, like any sophisticated database is complex and requires a substantial degree of technical commitment.

20 minutes for a moderately motivated person is worlds away from what you said.

Of course OSM would benefit greatly from further lowering the bar, but like you say, that's a lot of work.

Re:Avoid Google Maps with Gnome Maps on GNU/Linux by nerdponx on Sunday April 15, 2018 @06:52PM (#16845472)
Until you can do this from your phone it's kind of irrelevant. I am certainly the type to update an address database, but rarely the type to remember to do it when I get home.
Re:Avoid Google Maps with Gnome Maps on GNU/Linux by maxerickson on Sunday April 15, 2018 @06:54PM (#16845485)
There's a learning curve, but Vespucci is a full featured editor for Android. There's no full featured ios editor.

Maps.Me and OSMAnd will both edit POIs (for adding a shop or whatever).

Re:Avoid Google Maps with Gnome Maps on GNU/Linux by jmkb on Sunday April 15, 2018 @07:30PM (#16845643)
Go Map!! (https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Go_Map!!) is pretty good for iOS.
Re:Avoid Google Maps with Gnome Maps on GNU/Linux by a3_nm on Sunday April 15, 2018 @09:42PM (#16846134)
The parent comment was also complaining about the lack of public transport routing, and this is not something that you can fix easily, as far as I know: there is no software support for public transportation timetables/routing as far as I know.

(Edit: in fact there is work in progress about this in Gnome Maps https://gitlab.gnome.org/GNOME/gnome-maps/issues/25)

Re:Avoid Google Maps with Gnome Maps on GNU/Linux by afuchs on Sunday April 15, 2018 @06:06PM (#16845259)
I've tried fixing some obvious errors on OSM only to have my changes reverted. The project isn't exactly welcoming to new contributors.
Re:Avoid Google Maps with Gnome Maps on GNU/Linux by lucb1e on Sunday April 15, 2018 @06:24PM (#16845333)
I've never heard this before. My edits certainly aren't rejected, and aside from a few top contributors I doubt anyone recognizes usernames (so I nor others would have such bias). It's extremely rare that I have to undo some of someone's work because there are real mistakes.

Could you link the changeset perhaps? I'm curious now.

Re:Avoid Google Maps with Gnome Maps on GNU/Linux by a3_nm on Sunday April 15, 2018 @09:41PM (#16846128)
Could you please provide a link to the changes that you had made? This would be useful for OSM editors to understand what has gone wrong.
Re:Avoid Google Maps with Gnome Maps on GNU/Linux by diggan on Sunday April 15, 2018 @10:20AM (#16842720)
So how do you actually do this? Can you just open up Google Maps with OSM side-by-side and copy addresses? Or you need to source it from somewhere else?
Re:Avoid Google Maps with Gnome Maps on GNU/Linux by Krasnol on Sunday April 15, 2018 @10:52AM (#16842892)
There are also nice tools like this: https://github.com/westnordost/StreetComplete

It's quite easy to use and if you don't plan to draw new roads this is the fastest way to fill gaps wherever you are.

The more advanced app would be this: https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Vespucci

Though I don't have experience with it.

Re:Avoid Google Maps with Gnome Maps on GNU/Linux by hanbura on Sunday April 15, 2018 @10:30AM (#16842774)
Copying from Google Maps would violate copyright. Ideally you visit the place in question and correct them in OSM based on your observations. There are also some satellite maps that are licensed for use as OSM source (and that are often integrated in OSM editors)
Re:Avoid Google Maps with Gnome Maps on GNU/Linux by extra88 on Sunday April 15, 2018 @10:35AM (#16842803)
Facts like street addresses are not copyrightable. The visual drawing of roads and other features on maps can be, however.
Re:Avoid Google Maps with Gnome Maps on GNU/Linux by rmc on Sunday April 15, 2018 @11:52AM (#16843160)
In the USA, yes there is clear precedent saying that. But other places (e.g. UK) don't have this case, so it's not so clear. EU law has created [sui generis] "database right", which is is like copyright for a collection of facts.

OSM is not a place to explore the grey areas of international copyright law.

Re:Avoid Google Maps with Gnome Maps on GNU/Linux by pksadiq on Sunday April 15, 2018 @10:56AM (#16842914)
> Facts like street addresses are not copyrightable.

Google says it is[0]. It might be true because when you get street address from Google, you are also getting the mark on the map for the location. Whether it's true legally or not, it's better to stay away from their data. That is, if you use Google maps, you agree their terms and thus you are not allowed to copy the data.

And btw, I have seen (possibly deliberate) mistakes in street address markers in Bing maps (which is the recommended map[1] to follow for Open street map editors). So don't think that they won't find you if you copy their data).

[0] https://developers.google.com/maps/terms#6-googles-proprieta... (The definition of Content is explained in the following section, which says "... and places data (including business listings). ")

[1] https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Bing_Maps

Re:Avoid Google Maps with Gnome Maps on GNU/Linux by maxerickson on Sunday April 15, 2018 @11:02AM (#16842934)
Bing Maps aren't recommended for use in OSM.

Microsoft has generously provided permission and server resources for use of Bing Aerial Imagery since 2010, but that's different than their map product.

Lately there's a bunch more imagery providers that give permission for use in OSM. Mapbox, Digital Globe and ESRI all provide imagery layers with global coverage. There's also quite some government imagery available, OSM editors will show them as an option in the areas they cover, so be sure to check when editing.

Re:Avoid Google Maps with Gnome Maps on GNU/Linux by extra88 on Sunday April 15, 2018 @11:55AM (#16843176)
Violating T&Cs is not the same as copyright infringement. What you linked to are terms for the API, the Google Maps/Google Earth Additional Terms of Service [0] would be the more relevant document. But again, violating Google's Terms is not the same as copyright infringement.

I don't know whether Bing Maps uses trap streets [1] or not.

[0] https://www.google.com/intl/en_us/help/terms_maps.html

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trap_street

Re:Avoid Google Maps with Gnome Maps on GNU/Linux by hanbura on Sunday April 15, 2018 @10:46AM (#16842862)
An individual fact isn't copyrightable, a collection of facts can be. Details vary by jurisdiction, but in an international project like OSM you have to comply with the strictest jurisdiction
Re:Avoid Google Maps with Gnome Maps on GNU/Linux by extra88 on Sunday April 15, 2018 @11:47AM (#16843140)
But the subject was an individual adding a street address for a route. That's not a collection of facts.
Re:Avoid Google Maps with Gnome Maps on GNU/Linux by dingaling on Sunday April 15, 2018 @03:44PM (#16844521)
The address alone is a single fact, but its context on a map that allows it to be found is a collection of facts

As an OSM contributor in the UK myself and my peers only use clean-room data ( firsthand visit ) or data from public sources ( planning applications etc )

Re:Avoid Google Maps with Gnome Maps on GNU/Linux by kuschku on Sunday April 15, 2018 @10:27AM (#16842753)
You need to source it from somewhere else, usually your own knowledge – go to places, photograph them, add them in OSM.
Re:Avoid Google Maps with Gnome Maps on GNU/Linux by jorvi on Sunday April 15, 2018 @10:31AM (#16842775)
Despite what others might tell you, Google does not own addresses and associated information (opening hours, phone number etc.), so you’re free to copy them side-by-side. Uploaded photos are a no-go though.

Edit: for all people blindly ramming that downvote button, see my explanation below.

Re:Avoid Google Maps with Gnome Maps on GNU/Linux by maxerickson on Sunday April 15, 2018 @10:33AM (#16842787)
No, don't do this.

OpenStreetMap isn't an experiment in the legalities of copyrights, database rights and terms of service. Only use sources with clear provenance and clear permission.

Re:Avoid Google Maps with Gnome Maps on GNU/Linux by jorvi on Sunday April 15, 2018 @11:31AM (#16843068)
Person A copies information on opening hours, the address, postal code, phone number etc. from the website (or even multiple sources) of a business onto Google Maps. Person B then copies this information from Google Maps to OpenStreetMap. The copyright either lies in the public domain or with the original website, not Google (Maps). This should be crystal clear and is in no way ‘an experiment’.
Re:Avoid Google Maps with Gnome Maps on GNU/Linux by maxerickson on Sunday April 15, 2018 @11:34AM (#16843084)
Okay, so now address the Google TOS (no extraction) and database rights.

Note that this is a FAQ:

https://wiki.osmfoundation.org/wiki/Licence/Licence_and_Lega...

Re:Avoid Google Maps with Gnome Maps on GNU/Linux by ryanlol on Monday April 16, 2018 @05:30AM (#16847729)
At least there was this recently https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2018/01/ninth-circuit-doubles-...

Obviously that only covers one specific angle though.

Re:Avoid Google Maps with Gnome Maps on GNU/Linux by jorvi on Sunday April 15, 2018 @11:49AM (#16843146)
The point here becomes that the original data source(s) are freely available and often unlicensed. Same example: the local bakery is not going to license their website information (or often the site is copyrighted by the creating company). You can copy this information to OSM. You can copy this information to Google Maps and OSM at the same time. Google cannot put this information under their license with a ‘no extraction’ rule because they don’t own that information. I get that OSM has to be cautious but no sane judge would ever rule in Google’s favor in this case.
Re:Avoid Google Maps with Gnome Maps on GNU/Linux by jmkb on Sunday April 15, 2018 @07:57PM (#16845740)
After spending some time adding info to OSM, you'll start to see plenty of cases where Google and Yelp have info for an establishment that's nowhere to be found on their website. And even for some businesses that don't have a website at all. Some of it's extracted from their street view imagery, but some of it clearly isn't. I can walk by my local bakery and their phone number and hours aren't posted anywhere visible. Maybe they're on the takeout menu. Maybe a business card. Maybe they're printed on the receipt. Maybe you actually have to ask someone.

You can't assume that everything on Google Maps is from scanning public web sites. Sometimes, apparently, they do some actual investigation.

Plus, Google's not always right anyway! Nothing's more embarrassing than being caught copying incorrect information. So do your own research. Obviously copying info from a public website is fine, but info on the ground is going to be more complete and reliable. (Plenty of businesses are sloppy about updating their websites.)

Re:Avoid Google Maps with Gnome Maps on GNU/Linux by rmc on Sunday April 15, 2018 @11:56AM (#16843185)
Yes you can copy it into OSM from the original source. But not if it's gone through Google.
Re:Avoid Google Maps with Gnome Maps on GNU/Linux by progval on Sunday April 15, 2018 @12:01PM (#16843207)
> Google cannot put this information under their license with a ‘no extraction’ rule because they don’t own that information.

So what prevents someone from extracting all of Google Maps' data to OSM?

Re:Avoid Google Maps with Gnome Maps on GNU/Linux by rmc on Sunday April 15, 2018 @11:55AM (#16843178)
> so you’re free to copy them side-by-side.

The OSM community will delete your contributions if you do this. And you risk being banned. Please don't bring copyright infringment into OSM

Re:Avoid Google Maps with Gnome Maps on GNU/Linux by kuschku on Sunday April 15, 2018 @10:45AM (#16842847)
That is theoretically true in some jurisdictions, absolutely wrong in others, and completely untested in most.

Open Street Map specifically bans doing so, and if you’ve done any edits based on this, they should be reversed, as they threaten the legality of the entire project.

Re:Avoid Google Maps with Gnome Maps on GNU/Linux by jrnichols on Sunday April 15, 2018 @11:22PM (#16846472)
I use the "Report an issue" feature with Apple Maps quite often, and I've noticed that they've become a lot faster with updating things. even things such as "pin in the wrong location." I've added new businesses and found them on the map just a few days later.

Apple Maps has improved so much. but it's only as good as the data it's fed.

Re:Avoid Google Maps with Gnome Maps on GNU/Linux by romanovcode on Monday April 16, 2018 @05:08AM (#16847653)
> Apple can tell you a lot about how their attempts worked out for them

Worked out pretty fine in the end if you ask me. I'm using apple maps all the time and it works just fine.

Re:Avoid Google Maps with Gnome Maps on GNU/Linux by movedx on Sunday April 15, 2018 @06:27PM (#16845351)
Have you tried asking people for directions?

I find talking to other people and asking for directions is better because you (sometimes get shortcuts and) meet new people, find out interesting facts, get updates like, "Yeah it's over there but it's closed due to flooding" or, "over there mate but if you go around the back you'll skip the queue." Aint no online system telling you those gems.

I've also found reading a static map and or remembering the directions given to me, or discovering them through exploration, solidifies the knowledge and I remember them long term.

We rely too much on GPS.

Re:Avoid Google Maps with Gnome Maps on GNU/Linux by TheDong on Sunday April 15, 2018 @11:14PM (#16846443)
This anti-technological-advancement stance comes up often enough and always seems ridiculous to me.

> We rely too much on GPS.

A slightly more extreme variant of this argument would be "Have you ever set out a rain-catcher and drunk your own water? It has more bacteria so your guts are more hardy, and not having enough water builds character. We rely on the water system too much".

There are various other arguments along that line that could be made, but they're all basically "Why not ignore technical advances and do things in a more time consuming and error prone way to build character (or have a more genuine experience or something)"

There is nothing wrong if a person wishes to do this. I know map enthusiasts who like to learn roads and maps and cities' grid systems because it's a hobby.

However, encouraging people to ignore technological advancements is silly; for someone who wants directions from A to B, digital maps are obviously superior, and it's time-saving measures like these that add up to advance society and improve our lives.

> Aint no online system telling you those gems.

Google maps and reviews do tell you if a place is closed, if you should go in a different way, or if there are secret menus often as not, but this tiny factual bit isn't my actual gripe, but rather the tone of the comment as I responded to above.

Re:Avoid Google Maps with Gnome Maps on GNU/Linux by movedx on Sunday April 15, 2018 @11:44PM (#16846530)
I never said don't use GPS. GPS is excellent in a lot of ways. Google's consumer options in this space are world class and incredibly useful. I used them my self this past weekend in Melbourne. They worked.

I'm saying don't rely on it too much. Don't expect it to always be there. Have fun with other options. Learn to read a map because it's a fun and useful tool, and so on.

Use technology.

> This anti-technological-advancement stance

Please don't put words into my mouth or tell me what I am or am not. I'm literally a programmer working in tech who uses Google Maps at least once per week.

Re:Avoid Google Maps with Gnome Maps on GNU/Linux by sn on Sunday April 15, 2018 @06:43PM (#16845429)
Unfortunately asking for directions is not an option for everyone, to put it lightly.

https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2018/04/15/602598119...

Re:Avoid Google Maps with Gnome Maps on GNU/Linux by spraak on Sunday April 15, 2018 @08:06PM (#16845766)
I don't really understand the down votes to your comment. It truly is difficult to be black in America lately
Re:Avoid Google Maps with Gnome Maps on GNU/Linux by movedx on Sunday April 15, 2018 @09:06PM (#16846008)
No solution is a solution for everyone.
Re:Avoid Google Maps with Gnome Maps on GNU/Linux by dannyw on Sunday April 15, 2018 @06:59PM (#16845511)
We do rely too much about GPS, but asking people for directions isn’t exactly a mapping solution.
Re:Avoid Google Maps with Gnome Maps on GNU/Linux by dominotw on Sunday April 15, 2018 @06:32PM (#16845374)
There are no people on the streets in USA. This technique works in India though.
Re:Avoid Google Maps with Gnome Maps on GNU/Linux by nickserv on Sunday April 15, 2018 @06:39PM (#16845413)
It works in India, but you need to ask at least 5 people and go with the majority opinion ;-)
Re:Avoid Google Maps with Gnome Maps on GNU/Linux by dman on Sunday April 15, 2018 @06:49PM (#16845453)
But you just made 5 new friends for life :)
Re:Avoid Google Maps with Gnome Maps on GNU/Linux by TheDong on Sunday April 15, 2018 @11:15PM (#16846445)
And if you look rich enough, "for life" is about another 20 minutes.
Re:Avoid Google Maps with Gnome Maps on GNU/Linux by movedx on Sunday April 15, 2018 @09:08PM (#16846014)
Thanks for the downvotes (for having an opinion and offering another solution to a local problem.)

I know not everyone can ask for directions. Not everyone can even use a mobile phone but that doesn't mean I can't offer it as a solution to a problem.