News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by cornholio on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @07:40AM (#16800578)
You certainly don't need blockchains and distributed databases to reward creators, centralized solutions like Patreon work perfectly fine. If you want Netflix style monetization, that is not a technical problem but a social one, Netflix relies on the concept of copyright. Any community that does not respect copyright will switch to the free alternative, leaving voluntary donations as the only monetization option.

Maybe there is a blockchain niche where content is offered freely but ad supported, with the experience painless enough not to motivate users to switch to the ad-free alternative. The revenue would then be necessarily modest, but would be redirected to the creators almost in full, compensating the massive Youtube cut.

Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by koonsolo on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @07:50AM (#16800623)
I don't agree with your Netflix story. Most people don't prefer free, they prefer convenience.

Spotify almost works properly as a centralized platform because almost all music is on there. But I know a few albums that aren't, and it's too bad.

For Netflix, I have a subscription. But guess what I do when I want to watch the latest Walking Dead or Game of Thrones. I want it convenient, preferably legal, but most of all convenient.

Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by fredley on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @08:18AM (#16800751)
For Game of Thrones it's not such an issue, but I do feel bad if there's e.g. an old BBC film I want to watch, but there's no way to get it legally, sometimes at all. Other times it's £20 for a DVD. No way I'm paying three months of Netflix subscription (or a large fraction of a license fee) for that.

The BBC has such an extensive and amazing back catalogue of content they wholly own. Why they don't chuck it on iPlayer is beyond me. I know they have it all on a digital platform internally already, format is not an issue.

Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by gaius on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @10:40AM (#16801686)
The BBC has such an extensive and amazing back catalogue of content they wholly own. Why they don't chuck it on iPlayer is beyond me

The infuriating thing is, we’ve already paid for it. Anything BBC should be “free” to anyone who had paid their TV license in the last year it was broadcast. We own it already, it’s sheer extortion to make you pay full price for a DVD.

Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by Mindwipe on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @12:38PM (#16802739)
> The infuriating thing is, we’ve already paid for it.

No you didn't. For the example, the BBC typically only pays independent production companies (which is about 40% of their output) a fraction of what the content costs to make because the indie retains distribution rights afterwards and can make up the rest with sales. Same with scriptwriters, or actors.

Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by Mindwipe on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @10:15AM (#16801522)
> The BBC has such an extensive and amazing back catalogue of content they wholly own.

No it doesn't. The BBC wholly owns virtually nothing.

http://webarchive.nationalarchives.gov.uk/20140603125500/htt...

http://www.bbc.co.uk/archive/contributor_rights.shtml?chapte...

https://www.theguardian.com/law/2010/nov/25/bbc-archive-onli...

And more importantly, the things it does wholly own, it very rarely knows, legally, that it does wholly own, as the records aren't reliable. So it would involve a vast amount of legal time and risk to investigate.

Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by nabeards on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @10:40AM (#16801689)
It would be awesome if blockchain could solve the issue of rights management at the scale of media content. Tracking ownership of the individual parts (script, logos, video, etc) as well as the transfer of ownership of those parts.
Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by duskwuff on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @12:36PM (#16802714)
The underlying data is unreliable. Throwing technology at it doesn't change that.
Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by nabeards on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @01:09PM (#16802996)
Agreed; but could we start with new media? This is a real nightmare for the industry.
Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by toyg on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @08:29AM (#16800811)
> Why they don't chuck it on iPlayer is beyond me.

Because they would devalue new productions. The more license-payers watch old movies, the less they will watch Top Gear or Strictly or whatever it's supposed to be big now. This would mean less interest in new productions, less stuff sold by BBCWorld (or whatever it's called these days), less money going around... like all companies and organisations, the BBC wants to grow, not to stall.

Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by neffy on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @10:09AM (#16801474)
No, it's not that. The BBC is tied up in the same licensing mess as everybody else in the media industry. Everything is licensed... scripts, individual rights, director rights, ownership is transferred, tracked, ends up with third parties. It's a complete, unholy, worldwide mess of ownership spaghetti under the hood, and that's at some level why the only alternative is torrents.
Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by ghaff on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @10:37AM (#16801670)
And much of it predates people even thinking about this stuff. Thus, you have a TV series like Northern Exposure for which the music was a fairly integral part and you can't even buy DVDs with all the original music included.

Even today, I was reading that one Black Mirror episode for which the closing song was just so on had licensed it for 15 years. Which is a long time but hardly forever.

Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by ada1981 on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @12:06PM (#16802401)
Wierd to License something like that for only a few years. What happens in 15 years? They have to renegotiate a license or re-edit the show?
Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by Mindwipe on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @12:40PM (#16802749)
Yes.

Which is quite common (Scrubs for example has had to re-edit library music into most of it's episodes for most uses, instead of the original tracks).

Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by ada1981 on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @12:47PM (#16802807)
What a pain in the ass.

If you own the song, seems like you'd want to avoid leaving money on the table. I wonder how common relicensing is vs. editing.

Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by ghaff on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @01:32PM (#16803223)
The problem is that when it comes time to relicense, there's probably very little value in the show left to the studio. And whoever is negotiating the relicense couldn't care less about the artistic vision of the 10 year old show's creator who picked the original songs. And whoever the right holder of the music is probably doesn't want to offer steep discounts because it weakens their negotiating leverage on other matters.
Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by Mindwipe on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @05:43PM (#16805770)
The main issue is that it's very rare for someone to "own" a song. The publishing, label, composition, mechanical and performance rights might all belong to different entities in different territories and sometimes even in different windows. Relicensing is pretty common for films, but less common for TV, because there's less margin. And collective licensing for broadcast happens in lots of territories and not for on-demand or internet distribution.
Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by ghaff on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @12:46PM (#16802797)
Licensing is generally complicated but it's often for some fixed period of time. I expect part of the problem is in the incentives. I get the credit if I can negotiate a lower licensing cost today. If the license expires in 10 years rather than 50, that's probably not my problem.
Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by rbanffy on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @08:55AM (#16800971)
This idea is based on the assumption people who'd watch stuff from BBC's old catalogue would, instead, watch Top Gear or Strictly. These are probably a couple different demographics, distinct enough to warrant separate delivery options.
[dead]
Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by toyg on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @09:47AM (#16801293)
The Charter calls for "distinctive output" but it also calls for umpteen other things including innovation in service delivery. They cannot "distort the market" but if the market is minuscule or simply does not exist (how many streaming services have access to the BBC back-catalog?), there is nothing to distort.

I do share the political outlook but I don't think that's what really matters in this particular circumstance. There might be occasional issues with royalties/copyrights and whatnot (production contracts in the media industry are notoriously byzantine), but imho the main factor remains a strategic choice.

Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by nailer on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @09:47AM (#16801289)
Perhaps a commercial BBC that could actually sell it stuff to people who want it would help a) the BBC b) people who want it?

> Tories are always looking for an excuse to shutdown the BBC so their donors can pillage the public commons and eat the corpse.

Or maybe it's because it's not the government's job to run TV channels and radio stations, nor is it the public's job to fund them?

Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by vinceguidry on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @10:01AM (#16801402)
> Or maybe it's because it's not the government's job to run TV channels and radio stations, nor is it the public's job to fund them?

Public broadcasting is great, so many wonderful shows in the US would not have been able to have been made without it. But go ahead, sacrifice public media to the god of market economics. You might not miss it when it's gone, but it will be a sad day indeed.

Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by nailer on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @10:26AM (#16801599)
Comparing PBS to the BBC doesn't make sense: PBS isn't publicly funded nor is it mandatory to donate to PBS.
Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by vinceguidry on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @10:36AM (#16801662)
Feels to me like a distinction without a difference. Public arts funding has always been something we want more of.
Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by nailer on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @03:39PM (#16804496)
Then it sounds like you'd be OK with the BBC moving to a PBS style funding model. Great, me too.
Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by vinceguidry on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @03:52PM (#16804642)
I don't know what part of "more public arts funding" made you think that, but whatevs.
Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by nailer on Wednesday April 11, 2018 @04:18AM (#16809053)
The fact you were happy with the PBS funding model in the comment I replied to.
Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by paulie_a on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @11:01AM (#16801844)
The creators of iPlayer must have had a meeting with the specific goal of making it worse than realplayer
Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by fredley on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @11:08AM (#16801882)
Is it that bad? Compared to any other TV services' online offerings, it's leagues ahead.
Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by ghaff on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @08:15AM (#16800739)
How is subscribing to HBO inconvenient?

It's a combination of price and convenience. There's some upper limit to the monthly price you (and everyone else) is willing to pay for content.

Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by prepend on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @08:30AM (#16800818)
HBO Now is a much worse experience than torrents. The navigation is slow, the updates to new episodes are poorly placed under a bunch of clicks, there are ads for other hbo shows over and over (even after I watched every single West world episode they still show me ads about a “new show”), streaming bugs (Although this improved quite a bit).

It wasn’t the price that moved me away from HBONow, it was their lack of convenience compared to a torrent rig.

It ended up being HBO’s design was more for themselves rather than me (“we want to show you ads” vs “you want to watch your shows”). It was still very old in its philosophy of content.

Netflix however is awesome because it’s very UX focused.

Ultimately, I think only OSS/pirate are closest to the use desires.

Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by ryanianian on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @10:07AM (#16801455)
> Netflix however is awesome because it’s very UX focused.

Except for the thousands of A/B experiments that incessantly drive you to spend every ounce of attention on Netflix. E.g. the auto-playing preview that starts whenever you stop moving the active selection. It strongly encourages you to start playing the thing rather than being thoughtful about whether you actually want to or not. Personally I hate this - it drives my anxiety nuts - and I find HBO's tactics much less user-hostile (although agreed the ads for HBO's own content are outright stupid).

Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by paulie_a on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @09:54AM (#16801343)
HBO has long been against providing streaming service, and only seemed to begrudgingly with a "fuck you, this is going to be an awful experience" attitude
Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by sbov on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @12:04PM (#16802380)
Yeah, the HBO UI is terrible. Netflix is great except it seems to constantly change what it is showing on Roku. Sometimes my "continue watching" is up top. Sometimes it is nowhere to be found. I've had to literally search for a show I started the day before to continue watching it.
Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by kerng on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @10:33AM (#16801645)
>>Netflix however is awesome because it’s very UX focused.

I find the Netflix UI, especially the one for Xbox utterly slow and too jammed with information. Its not that great.

Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by TylerE on Wednesday April 11, 2018 @12:24PM (#16812714)
If you have Amazon Prime, you can subscribe to HBO via Prime Video and watch it in Prime, both the library and live streams.
Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by wuliwong on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @10:35AM (#16801654)
I agree about HBO's ads but I think the UI/UX is fine on the Apple TV. I have not had any streaming bugs.
Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by rusk on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @08:23AM (#16800778)
Well for me, in my jurisdiction HBO just simply isn't available. That's hands down about as inconvenient as you can get.

In jurisdictions where it is available it's often only available as a part of a larger cable package. If you're signed up with another provider that's pretty inconvenient also.

There is a well worn cartoon on this topic that sums up the position of many quite well [0]

[0] http://theoatmeal.com/comics/game_of_thrones

Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by lilbobbytables on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @08:30AM (#16800816)
You'll notice that in the HBO Go screen there was an option to subscribe if you don't already have it through your cable plan.
Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by rusk on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @11:01AM (#16801843)
Don't even know what a "HBO Go" is - never seen or heard of one before.

EDIT Actually, I'm going to put aside disingenuity for a second.

I actually have the closest equivalent of HBO with my provider, it's called "Sky Atlantic" and it's only available through Sky, of course.

So I'm fully paid up and legit as far as GoT is concerned but only coincidentally. If a competing network were to start showing $competing_popular_tv_show you can be guaranteed I wouldn't be switching, or taking on a second subscription ...

Take my $$$ by all means, but if you get greedy you'll get nothing.

Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by amdavidson on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @08:41AM (#16800890)
That was to subscribe to HBO from your cable provider if/when they decided to offer HBO GO, the streaming service.

When this comic came out(2011) HBO Now (confusingly separate from HBO Go) did not exist.

Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by smoe on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @11:03AM (#16801856)
"HBO GO. It's HBO. Anywhere."

click

"To access HBO GO℠, you must reside within the fifty states of the United States of America."

Some time ago while traveling I actively tried to find a way to pay to watch Game of Thrones. I failed miserably.

Also I really don't like having to have and manage subscription for various providers, nor do I like to be locked in with one. I would love to have a single subscription or even better pre-paid option somewhere which can be used across services and my money gets distributed accordingly.

Same with news media. I would be more than willing to pay a set amount per year for consumption, but I'm not willing to pay that amount exclusively to you.

Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by jjrh on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @12:47PM (#16802808)
Basically this - a lot of the time the options just aren't there for the rest of the world.

I think stuff like Netflix, Spotify, Steam, etc have proven that when content is priced right and delivered in a convenient manner folks are more than happy to pay.

News media is one of the worst for not figuring out how to adapt. I'd love to read some newspapers, watch a couple news networks, etc - but i'm not willing to plop down $100 a month and deal with a bunch of different apps to do this so I stick with online.

Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by freeone3000 on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @10:06AM (#16801441)
In order to subscribe to HBO in Canada, I'd need to call CTV, get a cable hookup to my apartment, schedule a time for the cableman, stay there while he's there, he'll hook up some box to the wall, I'd set up one account with CTV then another with HBO, and then after paying two companies and a real-world three-week delay, I'd be able to watch HBO. (Not to mention this would cost around $80/mo.)
Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by koonsolo on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @09:11AM (#16801057)
First of all I live in Belgium, so no HBO here (some other European countries do have it I see, it's basically a lottery).

There is indeed an upper limit for everyone. If I need to pay >50 euros/month and still get ads, no thanks.

Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by rhino369 on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @09:03AM (#16801015)
People are willing to pay for convience, but only so much. A lot of what gets torrented is easily and very conveniently available on iTunes, Playstore, or Amazon Instant, but it costs 5 bucks.

What isn’t convient about HBO Now (assuming you are in the USA)?

Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by ams6110 on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @09:21AM (#16801117)
Pay per view is not convenient. You have to make a decision each time "do I really want to watch this, is is worth it" and then have buyers remorse afterwards.

Pay a monthly, automatically recurring, fixed fee is convenient. Out of sight, out of mind.

Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by Spivak on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @09:46AM (#16801276)
I generally feel the opposite. It's much easier for me to buy a movie or box set outright than subscribe to a streaming service. It's pretty much the same with all fixed recurring payments -- I always feel pressure to use the service and I'm constantly evaluating whether its worth it.
Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by rhino369 on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @10:08AM (#16801464)
That sounds like price anxiety to me. If you didn’t care about cost you’d just buy. If Netflix cost 100 bucks a month you’d have the same anxiety.
Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by ghaff on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @10:42AM (#16801702)
I'm very skeptical about arguments that it's about convenience and not price. Yes, especially outside the US, there is some content that is difficult to get legally for any amount of money. But there's also some upper limit to what I'm willing to pay for physical media that I'll watch once (even if I can acquire it with one click on Amazon) or what I'm going to pay for a monthly subscription even if it were a hypothetical all digitized content ever made for one monthly fee.
Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by wuliwong on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @10:39AM (#16801683)
I don't understand your point, HBO Now is monthly and automatically recurring.
Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by bobwaycott on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @08:34AM (#16800849)
> For Netflix, I have a subscription. But guess what I do when I want to watch the latest Walking Dead or Game of Thrones. I want it convenient, preferably legal, but most of all convenient.

What is inconvenient about subscribing to HBO Now? You have to do more work to find/download an episode of GoT compared to streaming via HBO Now. Or you could stream the episodes from Prime. Same with Walking Dead. There are rarely inconvenient streaming options.

Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by koonsolo on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @09:06AM (#16801032)
I live in Belgium, and so it already ends there.
Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by bobwaycott on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @09:15AM (#16801082)
Ah. Yeah, region limitations are a really annoying issue.
Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by tjoff on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @09:01AM (#16801000)
Exactly, convenience is the most important part and here is where netflix et al has failed miserably.

1. All clients suck immensely.

2. The catalog is really poor.

3. DRM. I don't think you could describe inconvenient better than with those three letters.

If I could pay, say $30 a month, to legally pirate (not from any official source even) any movie/series I want I'd pay that in a heartbeat ($30 is still more than I consume if I were to buy it in a store). But now I don't have any service because it isn't worth it. I don't get the convenience and I don't get a decent catalog and I would have gotten it with DRM.

Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by kelnos on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @09:07AM (#16801037)
I'll grant you #2 since tastes vary and even the catalog varies from month to month. But for the vast majority of people, #1 isn't true, and #3 is irrelevant. Neflix's (growing) subscriber numbers are all the evidence you need for that.
Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by Spivak on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @09:49AM (#16801304)
Netflix's client has some warts but if you're looking for a specific movie or show it completely gets out of your way. HBO and APV have somehow managed to make it difficult to find things you know are already there.
Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by tjoff on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @09:15AM (#16801081)
That #1 and #3 is "acceptable" is simply because there are no (legal) alternatives.
Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by kelnos on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @06:48PM (#16806327)
I'm not really sure what you're looking for, then. Your wish for the ability to "legally pirate" content makes no sense, since by definition that's an oxymoron.
Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by tjoff on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @07:25PM (#16806608)
What I'm saying is that pirating is still much more convenient and results in a vastly superior experience than paying. Which is rather sad.
Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by kelnos on Saturday April 14, 2018 @05:52AM (#16836662)
I don't agree with that. I'm a technically inclined person who has in the past done a ton of pirating, but nowadays I will always reach for a legal streaming service first. I actually do find, say, using Netflix much more convenient than firing up a usenet or torrent client and pulling down a video that takes 5-10 minutes to download.

And that's just me. The masses of non-tech-savvy people out there don't want to deal with pirating things. For these people, paid services are far, far superior.

Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by tramGG on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @09:41AM (#16801239)
Patreon has on a multitude of occasions exercised its centralized right to block creators and payments across its platform. This is why centralization is bad.

With centralization we're delegating the act and responsibility of filtering to third parties.

Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by neuromantik8086 on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @12:44PM (#16802781)
> With centralization we're delegating the act and responsibility of filtering to third parties.

Assuming that third parties have better information than the average person, that's not a bug, but rather a feature. The issue is that information asymmetry makes it difficult for average consumers to know which third parties actually do have better information and which ones are just gatekeepers collecting tolls.

In general, I'm inclined to believe that centralized third-parties are better at keeping out shysters and low quality content than a free-for-all. People always like to claim that 5-star scales driven by normal consumers are adequate filters, but the fact is that these are easily gamed by sockpuppets or the end-user's ignorance of what they're rating (i.e., you can go to one dentist with many 5-star ratings who was a good bedside manner, then go to a better dentist who has to undo all the fuck-ups that the first dentist made, and which you, as a non-specialist, were ignorant of). Crowdsourcing doesn't triumph over the groupthink, pluralistic ignorance, and other failings of collective intelligence.

Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by TangoTrotFox on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @07:58AM (#16800658)
The primary reason decentralized solutions are enticing is because of a lack of centralized control. That control not only functions as a single point of failure, but also as a single point of corruption or otherwise negative influences.

Patreon has had, to a much smaller degree, the same issue as YouTube. Somebody posts something somebody else doesn't like on the site. One group argues for removal, another group argues against it. In the end the company can do literally nothing to please everybody. Decentralized solutions remove any notion of implied endorsement and so what is there is simply what is there. And of course there are monetization issues. Companies want to increase their profit, users want to pay as little as possible (outside of what is donated). These interests can and do come into conflict. But more importantly, even if they had not had such issues, experience is showing us that it's only a matter of time until they would. So by suggesting some alternative to Patreon, it's just kicking the can rather than actually solving anything.

Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by bitxbitxbitcoin on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @08:05AM (#16800695)
Lack of centralized control = inability to be censored.
Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by rusk on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @08:26AM (#16800790)
Which often leads to calls to censor the platform altogether. Further down the stack then you do have centralisation, e.g. ISP, where this censorship can occur. We've seen this with various torrent sites in the last few years.
Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by roadbeats on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @08:40AM (#16800886)
Patreon works only for artists in a few countries. The point of cryptocurrency is to be inclusive; anyone in anywhere can benefit from it.
Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by m52go on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @10:13AM (#16801503)
Patreon does not work perfectly fine. It has already shown it will ban people it doesn't like.

Part of the promise of distributed, permissionless protocols is the lack of top-down censorship.

Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by mtgx on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @10:11AM (#16801483)
Not so well for small amount donations, in case you forgot the recent controversy surrounding Patreon.

Also, I think it's better not to depend on a single company for such transactions (remember PayPal, and it's awful censorship?). Plus, I believe cryptocurrencies offer much better liquidity once you start to use any cryptocurrency.

Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by 1337biz on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @07:51AM (#16800631)
Most of the torrenting happens at best in grey areas. That's what makes semi-anonymous payments so attractive.
Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by syrrim on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @12:19PM (#16802510)
>centralized solutions like patreon work fine

Patreon, like existing solutions, is willing to remove people they don't like. In order to fully disassociate yourself from the whims of a corporation, you need to have a decentralized solution.

Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by jadedhacker on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @10:45AM (#16801720)
The other monetization option is of course public funding of the arts which could neatly avoid the issue of copyright and make shows legal to copy.
Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by JulianMorrison on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @09:36AM (#16801207)
Patreon is better, because a few relatively wealthy supporters can fund zero-cost release of cultural products for the many free riders.
Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by rhino369 on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @10:10AM (#16801476)
Paetron can be better. But it’s not going to fund something like Game of Thrones.
Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by JulianMorrison on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @10:12AM (#16801488)
Nor is anything besides mega-scale capitalism. But TBH, if I had to do without super shiny movies to end capitalism, I'd give them up in a heartbeat.