News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by fredley on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @08:18AM (#16800751)
For Game of Thrones it's not such an issue, but I do feel bad if there's e.g. an old BBC film I want to watch, but there's no way to get it legally, sometimes at all. Other times it's £20 for a DVD. No way I'm paying three months of Netflix subscription (or a large fraction of a license fee) for that.

The BBC has such an extensive and amazing back catalogue of content they wholly own. Why they don't chuck it on iPlayer is beyond me. I know they have it all on a digital platform internally already, format is not an issue.

Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by gaius on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @10:40AM (#16801686)
The BBC has such an extensive and amazing back catalogue of content they wholly own. Why they don't chuck it on iPlayer is beyond me

The infuriating thing is, we’ve already paid for it. Anything BBC should be “free” to anyone who had paid their TV license in the last year it was broadcast. We own it already, it’s sheer extortion to make you pay full price for a DVD.

Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by Mindwipe on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @12:38PM (#16802739)
> The infuriating thing is, we’ve already paid for it.

No you didn't. For the example, the BBC typically only pays independent production companies (which is about 40% of their output) a fraction of what the content costs to make because the indie retains distribution rights afterwards and can make up the rest with sales. Same with scriptwriters, or actors.

Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by Mindwipe on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @10:15AM (#16801522)
> The BBC has such an extensive and amazing back catalogue of content they wholly own.

No it doesn't. The BBC wholly owns virtually nothing.

http://webarchive.nationalarchives.gov.uk/20140603125500/htt...

http://www.bbc.co.uk/archive/contributor_rights.shtml?chapte...

https://www.theguardian.com/law/2010/nov/25/bbc-archive-onli...

And more importantly, the things it does wholly own, it very rarely knows, legally, that it does wholly own, as the records aren't reliable. So it would involve a vast amount of legal time and risk to investigate.

Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by nabeards on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @10:40AM (#16801689)
It would be awesome if blockchain could solve the issue of rights management at the scale of media content. Tracking ownership of the individual parts (script, logos, video, etc) as well as the transfer of ownership of those parts.
Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by duskwuff on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @12:36PM (#16802714)
The underlying data is unreliable. Throwing technology at it doesn't change that.
Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by nabeards on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @01:09PM (#16802996)
Agreed; but could we start with new media? This is a real nightmare for the industry.
Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by toyg on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @08:29AM (#16800811)
> Why they don't chuck it on iPlayer is beyond me.

Because they would devalue new productions. The more license-payers watch old movies, the less they will watch Top Gear or Strictly or whatever it's supposed to be big now. This would mean less interest in new productions, less stuff sold by BBCWorld (or whatever it's called these days), less money going around... like all companies and organisations, the BBC wants to grow, not to stall.

Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by neffy on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @10:09AM (#16801474)
No, it's not that. The BBC is tied up in the same licensing mess as everybody else in the media industry. Everything is licensed... scripts, individual rights, director rights, ownership is transferred, tracked, ends up with third parties. It's a complete, unholy, worldwide mess of ownership spaghetti under the hood, and that's at some level why the only alternative is torrents.
Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by ghaff on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @10:37AM (#16801670)
And much of it predates people even thinking about this stuff. Thus, you have a TV series like Northern Exposure for which the music was a fairly integral part and you can't even buy DVDs with all the original music included.

Even today, I was reading that one Black Mirror episode for which the closing song was just so on had licensed it for 15 years. Which is a long time but hardly forever.

Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by ada1981 on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @12:06PM (#16802401)
Wierd to License something like that for only a few years. What happens in 15 years? They have to renegotiate a license or re-edit the show?
Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by Mindwipe on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @12:40PM (#16802749)
Yes.

Which is quite common (Scrubs for example has had to re-edit library music into most of it's episodes for most uses, instead of the original tracks).

Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by ada1981 on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @12:47PM (#16802807)
What a pain in the ass.

If you own the song, seems like you'd want to avoid leaving money on the table. I wonder how common relicensing is vs. editing.

Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by ghaff on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @01:32PM (#16803223)
The problem is that when it comes time to relicense, there's probably very little value in the show left to the studio. And whoever is negotiating the relicense couldn't care less about the artistic vision of the 10 year old show's creator who picked the original songs. And whoever the right holder of the music is probably doesn't want to offer steep discounts because it weakens their negotiating leverage on other matters.
Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by Mindwipe on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @05:43PM (#16805770)
The main issue is that it's very rare for someone to "own" a song. The publishing, label, composition, mechanical and performance rights might all belong to different entities in different territories and sometimes even in different windows. Relicensing is pretty common for films, but less common for TV, because there's less margin. And collective licensing for broadcast happens in lots of territories and not for on-demand or internet distribution.
Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by ghaff on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @12:46PM (#16802797)
Licensing is generally complicated but it's often for some fixed period of time. I expect part of the problem is in the incentives. I get the credit if I can negotiate a lower licensing cost today. If the license expires in 10 years rather than 50, that's probably not my problem.
Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by rbanffy on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @08:55AM (#16800971)
This idea is based on the assumption people who'd watch stuff from BBC's old catalogue would, instead, watch Top Gear or Strictly. These are probably a couple different demographics, distinct enough to warrant separate delivery options.
[dead]
Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by toyg on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @09:47AM (#16801293)
The Charter calls for "distinctive output" but it also calls for umpteen other things including innovation in service delivery. They cannot "distort the market" but if the market is minuscule or simply does not exist (how many streaming services have access to the BBC back-catalog?), there is nothing to distort.

I do share the political outlook but I don't think that's what really matters in this particular circumstance. There might be occasional issues with royalties/copyrights and whatnot (production contracts in the media industry are notoriously byzantine), but imho the main factor remains a strategic choice.

Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by nailer on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @09:47AM (#16801289)
Perhaps a commercial BBC that could actually sell it stuff to people who want it would help a) the BBC b) people who want it?

> Tories are always looking for an excuse to shutdown the BBC so their donors can pillage the public commons and eat the corpse.

Or maybe it's because it's not the government's job to run TV channels and radio stations, nor is it the public's job to fund them?

Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by vinceguidry on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @10:01AM (#16801402)
> Or maybe it's because it's not the government's job to run TV channels and radio stations, nor is it the public's job to fund them?

Public broadcasting is great, so many wonderful shows in the US would not have been able to have been made without it. But go ahead, sacrifice public media to the god of market economics. You might not miss it when it's gone, but it will be a sad day indeed.

Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by nailer on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @10:26AM (#16801599)
Comparing PBS to the BBC doesn't make sense: PBS isn't publicly funded nor is it mandatory to donate to PBS.
Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by vinceguidry on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @10:36AM (#16801662)
Feels to me like a distinction without a difference. Public arts funding has always been something we want more of.
Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by nailer on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @03:39PM (#16804496)
Then it sounds like you'd be OK with the BBC moving to a PBS style funding model. Great, me too.
Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by vinceguidry on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @03:52PM (#16804642)
I don't know what part of "more public arts funding" made you think that, but whatevs.
Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by nailer on Wednesday April 11, 2018 @04:18AM (#16809053)
The fact you were happy with the PBS funding model in the comment I replied to.
Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by paulie_a on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @11:01AM (#16801844)
The creators of iPlayer must have had a meeting with the specific goal of making it worse than realplayer
Re:YouTube and Facebook Are Losing Creators to Blockchain-Po... by fredley on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @11:08AM (#16801882)
Is it that bad? Compared to any other TV services' online offerings, it's leagues ahead.