News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by zitterbewegung on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @05:47PM (#16749648)
I don't know who is in a worse position. Apple has the problem of a possible trade war. Google on the other hand is going to be regulated with GDPR and whatever the current administration will have to pass due to Facebook. I think I am leaning toward Google having a worse situation due to this move.
Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by closeparen on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @06:21PM (#16749914)
Google has effectively been GDPR compliant or close to it for years. Takeout, view and edit your ads profile, industry-leading internal controls on production data access, etc. They’re a first party, not a data broker, so will have an easier time with “legitimate interest” arguments. They also helped develop the law. GDPR is not a big deal for Google. It’s a big deal for similar organizations that have to suddenly catch up to Google’s security and privacy posture.
Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by CobrastanJorji on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @06:30PM (#16749990)
I mostly agree with you, but the penalties for non-compliance are so staggeringly large, the requirements are so vague, and the EU's love of fining American tech companies is so great that Id' be awfully nervous about GDPR if I were a large American tech company.
Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by tekkk on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @07:29PM (#16750425)
Now that is just being prejudiced. It's not EU's agenda to try and bring down American tech companies for the sake of malice (or protectionism). You do not think they have not been at some fault? Or that there is something good about GDPR too?

While it's easy to start mulling over why and how things are or could have done differently I'd argue that there is no animosity towards American companies per se. The data of its citizens however is a very sensitive issue for EU and in the light of Snowden leaks maybe they are rightfully fearful of US having too much technological hold over them. There is silly people over both sides of the ocean but let's not start willfully feeding rash preconceptions for no reason.

Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by ucarion on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @08:44PM (#16750854)
The claim that EU may have a populist-fueled agenda against American tech companies is not entirely without basis. It's not lawless anti-Americanism, but the tone has certainly changed.

Consider what the Economist has to say about Margrethe Vestager, who runs Europe's trustbusting agency.

https://www.economist.com/news/business/21728979-she-rich-wo...

Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by allenz on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @01:20AM (#16752175)
The Economist criticizes Vestager for fining Google and Apple. It concedes that both were anticompetitive, but complains that there is no proof "that consumers were denied a superior service as a consequence". But that's an impossibly high bar: no one can guarantee that competition will emerge; regulation can only provide a level playing field. So I don't think that this is a good article to prove your point.
Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by mtgx on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @02:04AM (#16752371)
I know where those comments come from. It was the NYT mainly and I think Reuters or Bloomberg doing it a bit, too - they were pushing this angle that the EU is doing it out of "jealousy" and nothing else.

Some people have actually bought that idea. But I imagine they'd want the US government to exhibit some of that jealousy against Facebook right about now, too...especially with Facebook now announcing that they won't implement the GDPR globally.

Ironically, it's the same media entities that seem to have essentially admitted they got it wrong with all the negative posts they've published against Facebook recently, and I think those sorts of articles will continue against Google and other privacy-violating companies, too, in the near future.

Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by hueving on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @01:03AM (#16752102)
I've seen constant protectionist sentiments from Europeans, Americans, and everyone else. You are delusional if you think it doesn't exist and it's critical to address it on its face when considering legislation.
Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by joejerryronnie on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @08:15PM (#16750715)
You're right, it's not the EU's agenda to try and bring down American tech companies - it is strictly Margrethe Vestager's political ambition to ride the hardline, protectionist stance against American tech straight to the EU President's office. Thankfully, she's burned so many political bridges that her own country is railroading her plans.
Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by smueller1234 on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @02:58AM (#16752602)
One counter example would be Booking.com. It's a Dutch company through and through[0] and pays the vast majority of its taxes in the Netherlands. Yet at least one of the European competition (!) authorities has already tried to use GDPR as a means to try and prove wrongdoing before GDPR is even in effect.

This is to say: you don't have to be an American company to end up in the crosshairs of overzealous and downright populist regulators.

Source: used to work there, had to help respond to a rather ludicrous 40-page list of questions.

[0] Headquarters in Amsterdam, culturally strongly influenced by the Dutch, the biggest concentration of staff and virtually all product development in Amsterdam, albeit owned by an American company.

Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by sbuk on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @06:23AM (#16753444)
> "before GDPR is even in effect."

This is a common misconception - GDPR is already "in effect". It will be enforced from 25 May...

Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by philwelch on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @06:40PM (#16750076)
That'll hurt Google's competitors, and hence help Google, more than it hurts Google.
Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by namelost on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @07:12PM (#16750310)
Or Google and Facebook will be held to a higher standard of compliance.
Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by philwelch on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @10:42PM (#16751462)
Quite possibly, but Google and Facebook are known entities that can afford flotillas of lawyers. The next up-and-coming startup to reach the "backlash" stage of the hype cycle will be a much more vulnerable target to European regulators. And if it's too easy for some hated target to comply, then the government can ratchet up the regulations even higher, and Google and Facebook will have the resources to keep up while the newer market entrants will be fucked. Google and Facebook will only be at risk if they deliberately flout regulations the way e.g. Volkswagen did.
Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by ucaetano on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @08:16PM (#16750719)
Which goes back to the point of loving to target American companies.
Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by amorroxic on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @09:01PM (#16750952)
European here and I feel this is a bit shortsighted. Not really sure the sentiment is to target US companies (if for nothing else ours are quite open/interconnected economies and there's lots of fondness for US services - check both market share as well as revenues) but really.. Facebook's tax of 5k/year in the UK, the double irish with a dutch sandwich, the backroom deals from the 80s with the Irish govt.. these are global practices which truly devastate everyone in the long run. I actually trust bureaucrats to step in and audit - and subjectively think they very often do a decent job of explaining rationales given europeans' known tendency of bickering on pretty much everything.
Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by ucaetano on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @09:11PM (#16751006)
> European here

Same.

> Facebook's tax of 5k/year in the UK, the double irish with a dutch sandwich, the backroom deals from the 80s with the Irish govt.. these are global practices which truly devastate everyone in the long run.

And are all legal, and designed as so by the government. Auditing won't make a difference, since it is legal. Don't like it? Make it illegal. Simple as that.

> actually trust bureaucrats to step in and audit - and subjectively think they very often do a decent job of explaining rationales given europeans' known tendency of bickering on pretty much everything.

Oh, no issue with that. My issue is with this:

> Or Google and Facebook will be held to a higher standard of compliance.

Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by andy_ppp on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @10:55PM (#16751514)
They are (making it illegal) but they are making the law broad enough that it’s going be difficult to circumvent by lobbyists.
Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by ucaetano on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @09:42AM (#16754558)
Lobbyist don't circumvent the law, politicians do.
Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by amorroxic on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @10:20AM (#16754913)
This would be a valid point or topic of debate should the subject be an actual law (the 70 years copyright law for instance?)

What we're dealing with here is loopholes and nothing more under various incarnations - take patents in the US or the lax tax policies of Malta or Isle of Man as an example - and you'll get a sense on why a bit of cleaning up is sorely needed.

Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by ucaetano on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @02:36PM (#16757591)
> What we're dealing with here is loopholes and nothing more under various incarnations - take patents in the US or the lax tax policies of Malta or Isle of Man as an example - and you'll get a sense on why a bit of cleaning up is sorely needed.

Oh, I agree, it definitely needs cleaning up.

Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by amorroxic on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @12:29PM (#16756306)
> Or Google and Facebook will be held to a higher standard of compliance.

Than whom else? VK? Baidu? ICQ?

Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by _jal on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @09:12PM (#16751012)
If you also attribute, say, US rules about lead content in children's toys to a "love of targeting" Chinese companies, then sure.

Otherwise, it would be a good idea to at least accept the possibility of sincerity when different polities want different rules than the US.

Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by TheOtherHobbes on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @06:37AM (#16753505)
Indeed. It's about targeting misbehaviour.

Suggesting that US companies should be above reproach or oversight, by definition, or that the EU would treat local or Asian companies who tried to pull the same stunts more generously is not based on evidence.

If US corporates try to flout European law, they'll suffer consequences. Market cap does not provide a free pass for being a bad actor.

Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by ucaetano on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @09:45AM (#16754592)
Nobody is suggesting that, quite the opposite, actually:

> Or Google and Facebook will be held to a higher standard of compliance.

Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by ucaetano on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @09:44AM (#16754582)
Again, I don't see an issue with different rules, I see an issue with this:

> Or Google and Facebook will be held to a higher standard of compliance.

Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by brisance on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @10:15PM (#16751327)
This is an insightful comment. It costs a lot of money to stay in compliance. One of the charges leveled against the ISO was that it was designed to be hindrance for Japanese companies to compete, because the organization ha(s|d) a lot of influence from Western entities.
Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by andy_ppp on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @10:53PM (#16751507)
Some would say the EU’s single market operates in a similar way... but only for countries outside of that group :-(
Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by jacksmith21006 on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @10:51AM (#16755245)
Exactly. Google has the perfect setup as do not need personal data for their ads. Search gives ads based on what you search.
Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by dmitriid on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @03:08AM (#16752646)
I wonder if you know that as of this week the US government can request any data on any user ID an American company even if that user and their data are not on American soil?

(Possibly thanks to GDPR) companies may object to that request if it costs local laws.

But yeah. Go on pretending that the EU lives to target American companies. From a European's point of view, American companies are not find enough as they view privacy, data, sovereignty etc. as some abstract concepts that don't apply to them.

Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by TheForumTroll on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @08:14PM (#16750714)
They don't target American companies. American companies makes themselves targets. If anything it is the US that tries to hurt European companies (actually any business that isn't American). If US law can't control a business like Facebook, somebody has to. One can only hope it rubs off on American citizens too so they get a bit more privacy (let's forget NSA for a second).
Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by icelancer on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @08:22PM (#16750743)
>> They don't target American companies. American companies makes themselves targets.

Sometimes the only reason they make themselves a target is because they make money, and American companies are the largest players in the space, not EU ones.

Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by paulie_a on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @06:37PM (#16750049)
< Id' be awfully nervous about GDPR if I were a large American tech company.

They should be and that is a great thing.

Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by pjschlic on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @07:11PM (#16750305)
Yours is not a unique sentiment, but I find it so disheartening. Vague laws enforced selectively are bad for the rule of law. Is the schadenfreude from sticking it to whatever American company is selected worth that?
Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by jacquesm on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @07:41PM (#16750500)
No, it's just that American companies as a rule tend to have a dim view of privacy and some pushback against that is welcome.

As for enforcement, if you're a European company you have much more to be worried about since it is going to be much easier to go after you.

Selective enforcement is hopefully going to be limited to going after a couple of very prominent offenders after which the remainder will fall in line.

Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by Barrin92 on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @09:12PM (#16751014)
>Is the schadenfreude from sticking it to whatever American company is selected worth that?

No, but a correction is long overdue to signal to international companies that the primacy of politics still exists. How companies conduct themselves is determined by European law and European citizens, not businesses.

Companies have only themselves to blame for having brought it on. Whether it's skirting taxes, mistreating user-data or assisting in election-meddling, if companies are not willing to self-regulate they will be regulated. That's an overdue message to send.

Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by brisance on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @10:19PM (#16751349)
That is a pretty naïve view of affairs. Practically all the banks even the European ones like HSBC, RBS etc have been complicit in committing all sorts of crime and continue to do so with impunity.
Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by Drakim on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @09:42AM (#16754559)
That's too close to what-about-ism for my tastes. I want those banks to be held responsible too, but I'll take just one or the other if I can't get both right now.
Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by pm90 on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @09:47PM (#16751197)
It is not the business of companies to self-regulate. Unless there is some kind of certification involved. Eg the gaming industry self regulates by having different ratings for games depending on their content. Such a thing is likely not possible everywhere, and especially for something as general as data, and thus legislative rememedies are required
Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by IAmEveryone on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @09:08AM (#16754305)
i've previously researched this idea because it comes up rather frequently.

This was in anti-trust, because privacy-related enforcement is actually left to the EU states and doesn't actually happen very often.

But in anti-trust, there is no evidence of any bias against US companies. The distribution of (the sum of) fines among EU, American, and Asian companies actually tracks closely with their respective market shares in the EU.

The only divergence I found was slightly fewer/lower fines being levied on US companies, and slightly higher numbers for Asian companies. I would attribute this divergence to the far more advanced oversight in the US vs. most Asian countries: the EU doesn't need to get involved if these companies are well-regulated in their home countries.

It'd be interesting to do a similar analysis for the US. As a German, I've heard similar grumbling regarding the fines against Volkswagen and Deutsche Bank. Personally, I doubt that those fines are motived by nationalistic motives. They might just show different approaches to corporate wrongdoing, with Germany either being too chummy with its industry, or possibly putting too much trust in the force of negative publicity alone to change behaviour.

Privacy will invariably generate more headline-worthy conflicts with US companies, simply because that's where all the large companies are located. But if you're in the US, I'll also point out a certain bias in what you'll see reported, considering EU fines against exclusively EU companies are unlikely to make the US news.

Trust me when I say that privacy happens to be a major concern of many voters in the EU. There is robust and constant debate regarding, for example, data collection by governments and law enforcements. In Germany, there is major opposition against the increased use of video surveillance, the use of phone location data in law enforcement, and EU legislation requiring the retention of communication data.

There is a low-hum undercurrent of anti-Americanism in some discussions of Facebook, Google et al, possibly more so in France than Germany or the UK. But Europeans are constantly exposed to US media and such familiarity breeds trust. If Facebook where Chinese, or Google were Russian, distrust and call for regulation would be far stronger than it is.

Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by seanwilson on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @10:06PM (#16751280)
> I mostly agree with you, but the penalties for non-compliance are so staggeringly large, the requirements are so vague

It'll be interesting to see how the first few non-compliance cases go. I would like to think if a requirement was vague, a company had made a reasonable interpretation of it and the company was responsive in making changes to become compliant that no fines would be issued.

Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by Angostura on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @10:05PM (#16751276)
Which requirements do you think are ‘vague’?
Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by closeparen on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @11:16PM (#16751593)
Essentially the entire law rests on subjective judgements like “reasonable,” “legitimate,” and “appropriate.”
Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by ocdtrekkie on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @07:43PM (#16750518)
This is true of certain parts of Google's business, but definitely not with other parts. It seems Google is hoping websites will agree to make Google a "co-controller" of their sites, and get their users' permissions for Google to collect data on them.

The entire ad business, aka, most of their money, is not really GDPR compliant. Collecting tracking data from third party sites is not okay.

Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by Eridrus on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @08:05PM (#16750666)
3rd party ads are only 15% of Google's ad revenue, far from the majority.
Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by mtgx on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @02:01AM (#16752353)
> Google has effectively been GDPR compliant or close to it for years

True, sort of. They only did that because the EU started an anti-trust investigation against them, though. And now they risk paying a $2.8 billion fine, so maybe Google is still worse off in the end?

Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by halflings on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @02:19AM (#16752435)
Not really. Google has been following these practices waaaaaay before the EU fine. Both the export tools, logging of all your activities (and ability to actually delete them), and automatic expiration of all data derived from user signals.
Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by gman83 on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @05:58PM (#16749754)
I think Apple is so many years behind Google in AI that they have little hope of catching up. Their bet will be that consumers are privacy-focused enough to not mind the fact that their products have less AI-focused advancements (e.g. Google Photos).

At the end of the day, the only way AI systems currently train themselves is if a lot of users share their data, like Google-users do. Apple provides more of a firewall, but handicaps potential AI systems from using training data in doing so.

Also Google has massive mindshare in the AI community with TensorFlow.

Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by majormajor on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @06:13PM (#16749874)
I use both Google Photos and Apple Photos and honestly, most of the "suggestions" from Google Photos are uncompelling. When I switched back to iOS a few months ago, I didn't find anything keeping me from moving primarily to Apple's solution. The most impressive automatic-photos-adjustment thing I've seen is in Lightroom now - and Adobe wouldn't be my first guess for AI leader.

I find this to be a general trend with Google: they may have more advanced AI, but haven't yet figured out super-useful ways to apply it.

They also are perfectly willing to undercut their own AI to serve business goals: the Assistant on my Pixel wouldn't even let me do "hey google set a timer for five minutes" if I didn't give Google my full location history. Because you need that to set timers...

Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by gman83 on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @06:36PM (#16750040)
OK I guess we have a different experience. As an iPhone user who uses Google Photos I find it to be quite a lot ahead of Apple's solution. It isn't really the filters it's more the search feature. I can search for "pets with children" and it will give me accurate results. Apple doesn't come close.
Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by majormajor on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @06:44PM (#16750110)
That would explain it. I do my photo browsing by time, not by search.

I've _tried_ searching in Google Photos before, it just didn't work reliably enough for me try it more frequently (usually searching for more specific stuff than something like "pets with children," though I can't recall any exact examples right now). Searching for location works well, but that's not very hard.

Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by Baeocystin on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @08:43PM (#16750846)
Anecdata, perhaps, but I have noticed that Google's photo searching by content has greatly improved as of late. Searches that failed for me around Christmas of last year now work perfectly.
Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by kcorbitt on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @06:34PM (#16750032)
For me, the killer ML use case in Google Photos is object recognition.

For example, I took a picture of my driver's license a year or so ago, and needed the number on a form recently. I just went to Google Photos and searched for "driver's license." Sure enough, the old picture showed up, even though I never manually tagged it.

Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by DeRock on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @06:50PM (#16750154)
The same is done in the photos app on iOS and macOS, all locally on device. I don’t have a picture of a drivers license, but I just tried “license plate” and “receipt” and both brought back all relevant results.
Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by ucaetano on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @08:21PM (#16750740)
Which is mostly useless when you have only 20GB of storage.

OTOH, if I ask Google Photos to show me pictures of me on the beach with my friends X and Y, it shows me a picture from 2005, of exactly what I asked. (literally "me on the beach with X and Y").

And if I ask for pictures of me and my friend Z in a party, it shows me pictures of me at Z's wedding 4 years ago. (literally "me with Z in a party").

Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by mrexroad on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @09:11PM (#16751007)
Assume you mean the 20GB limitation being iCloud storage? Both iOS and macOS Photos can “optimize photos storage” and will build index of full library without needing to keep photos on device after they’re analyzed / indexed.
Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by ryanmonroe on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @08:30PM (#16750788)
Luckily iPhones 7 and up have up to 256GB of storage
Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by lostlogin on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @08:44PM (#16750855)
Which photos seems to think is full whatever I do.
Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by bduerst on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @06:46PM (#16750127)
Yep, I did this exact same thing and was pleasantly surprised it was able to pull up my passport photo.
Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by username223 on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @09:06AM (#16754295)
Don't you carry your driver's license in your wallet? It's just weird to me that someone would think "I need my driver's license number, so I'll search through an online photo archive."
Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by culturestate on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @09:33PM (#16761021)
I’m not OP, but I’ve had similar experiences. I don’t carry my license in my wallet because I live in a foreign country where my license is useless (we have a different form of government ID), but I do still need it for occasional administrivia back home.
Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by jsemrau on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @06:28PM (#16749964)
You should try Adobe's iPad apps. They use AI enhancements very wisely throughout this ecosystem.
Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by richforrester on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @06:31PM (#16750005)
Some logic (be it faulty or not) brought me to wonder; isn't Google's lead in AI a direct result of sitting on figuratively all the data in the world?

That must account for a huge portion of their advances, right?

Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by Jyaif on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @08:11AM (#16753947)
Their advance is because they have two geeks at the helm that have been dreaming to have AI to respond to search queries since pretty much the beginning of the company.
Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by andy_ppp on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @12:35AM (#16751961)
Yes, the most data and the best AI people together means Google is always miles ahead IMO.
Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by Osmium on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @06:40PM (#16750077)
> I think Apple is so many years behind Google in AI that they have little hope of catching up.

We are so early on in the AI revolution, it seems very premature to make this claim.

I would wager we can't even imagine the scope of the kind of data we'd have available in the coming decades, let alone how the latest AI tech will use it, or which company will lead the way with its application.

Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by mcphage on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @06:06PM (#16749823)
> I think Apple is so many years behind Google in AI that they have little hope of catching up.

That’s been used to describe every dominant technology company at some point, most of which have been supplanted by now (or else supplanted a company which was previously described in similar terms). Maybe this time it’s true—and Apple certainly has their work cut out for them—but history implies that it’s probably not. Maybe it won’t be Apple, but it’ll probably be somebody.

Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by gman83 on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @06:45PM (#16750116)
"I think Microsoft is so many years behind Google in search that they have little hope of catching up"

I can think of more examples.

I agree, and Microsoft is a good example, that a paradigm shift can totally change the playing field. A desktop software oriented company like Microsoft couldn't or wouldn't take their dominance into an internet oriented market.

However Google has managed to transition to mobile and demonstrated they can manage such changes.

From what I've seen of fuchsia they're thinking ahead again.

Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by yoklov on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @07:09PM (#16750284)
I'm not sure MS vs Google in search is a good example, since by and large many people still have the impression that Bing isn't very good.

Last time I used it, this was the case. I don't know if it's changed, I'd be willing to believe either way.

Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by Baeocystin on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @08:44PM (#16750856)
Bing's general search still lags Google's, but its image search is miles ahead. IMO.
Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by smallhands on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @12:45AM (#16752011)
+1 for bing image search is incredible
Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by LeanderK on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @06:39PM (#16750071)
I don't think this is true. I do specialize in ML and you are probably talking about neural networks ("deep learning"). While they do require a lot of data for most tasks, it's still finite and after a certain size the improvements are not significant anymore (the definition of significant is up to you..). I don't know what Apple is working on, but i think for most of the ML-applications they are interested in, getting the training data is not that hard (like suggestions on the photos-app or autocorrect). It's still apple.

If I remember correctly, sharing analytics info etc. with apple is opt-in? If 1% of the users share the relevant data (or you've got money for annotating data in asia/africa, like tesla), this might enable you to solve most of your problems.

this does not mean that the quality of apples solutions is the same as googles, i just doubt it's the training data. Google is A LOT (not even comparable) more visible in the ML-community and i bet they have better and more researchers.

Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by microtherion on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @07:43PM (#16750517)
Not disagreeing with you that Google has advantages in some areas. However, Apple has some advantages as well, especially in its hardware/software integration in end user devices, which allows it to deploy e.g. hardware neural network acceleration or specific sensors, as in the iPhone X.
Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by brisance on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @10:21PM (#16751359)
Is your background in AI/machine learning? Because it is a very common trope that is rolled out and I strongly disagree with it. There isn’t such a thing as an insurmountable lead.
Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by SuoDuanDao on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @06:44AM (#16753529)
Given the public desire to make AI largely open source - which Apple could easily bankroll and gain goodwill while doing it - I'd say the odds of catching up are fairly good. Not necessarily over 50%, but probably better than it would look from counting patents.
Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by Apocryphon on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @05:49PM (#16749671)
And Amazon has a personal presidential vendetta against them...
Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by brisance on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @10:40PM (#16751457)
Don't think it's a vendetta. More of him playing to his voter base. The man has no scruples and would sell his mother twice if he could.
Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by jldugger on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @02:04AM (#16752373)
Yes, but what about Trump?
Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by abc_lisper on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @02:14AM (#16752413)
Found the redditor!
Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by RestlessMind on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @07:35PM (#16750462)
Among all the data-dependent tech companies, I believe Google is one of the best situated to comply with GDPR. Mainly because they have lots of cash to tackle regulations in terms of resources and manpower. Also, Google has revenue streams (Cloud, Play store, non-personalized Search ads) which are not as user-data dependent as some others (eg. FB, startups with ads-based business model).
Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by debt on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @06:29PM (#16749986)
AI itself is so far behind than most people realize. Most AI-branded products do an extremely small subset of tasks. I argue that it isn't AI rather using arcane statistical methods to hopefully ascertain the human requirement for the context.

AI doesn't yet exist anywhere that I know of. Hiring an AI guy is symbolic move used to signal to investors that they're making moves in a certain space.

Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by Baeocystin on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @08:48PM (#16750881)
>that it isn't AI rather using arcane statistical methods to hopefully ascertain the human requirement for the context

One of the big problems the field of AI has in terms of marketing itself is that is soon as a problem is understood and put in to use, people no longer see it as 'AI'. It's the god of the gaps, so to speak. But that does not render the actual advances not-AI. It is a perceptual problem, not a real impediment.

Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by bri3d on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @09:10PM (#16750997)
Google's big problem is straight antitrust, followed by that they're an adtech revenue engine locked in a multi-front war against companies who sell real products. Their GDPR story is actually pretty good and their transition away from adtech revenue seems to be progressing well too.
Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by jacksmith21006 on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @10:50AM (#16755229)
Do not think Google mhas anything to worry about. They can just tie ads to the content instead of the person. Plus search does not require other data as ads are associated with what you are searching.
Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by nevir on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @02:41AM (#16752527)
On the flip side, JG is an awesome hire for any company
Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by 1024core on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @09:24PM (#16751085)
And why won't GDPR affect Apple?
Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by jtmcmc on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @06:11PM (#16749863)
GDPR still is an opt-out mechanism. Though work for google I don't think it will fundamentally affect them that much...
Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by phn on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @06:31PM (#16750004)
Could you elaborate on GDPR being opt-out? The main point I keep reading about seems to be unambiguous separate consent for every use you use any piece of data for. (on mobile, but I’ll come back with references if needed)
Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by closeparen on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @09:17PM (#16751046)
Consent is one basis for collection. “Legitimate interest” is another. You need consent when you don’t have a strong enough argument under legitimate interest or another lawful basis.

I am not a lawyer, this is not legal advice.

Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by wastedhours on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @11:58AM (#16755957)
IANAL either, but my research confirms this also. A lot of companies up to now have used opt-out as their skewed version of consent. GDPR raises that barrier much higher, however, some of those use cases of "older style consent" may very well fall into legitimate interests or performance of a contract.

One of the main things about GDPR though is getting companies to give a monkeys about the rationale for the data collection - even if they use the legitimate interests argument, part of it is that they now have to actively prepare for that, show the legitimate interest and rationalise it to regulators.

Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by phn on Wednesday April 04, 2018 @06:52AM (#16753568)
Thank you for the keywords, that actually makes some sense.

I guess the crux of the question is in ambiguous terms like "personal freedoms", etc. that the regulation says should be weighted against "Legitimate Interest" of whoever collects data.

Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by trevyn on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @06:06PM (#16749829)
I think Apple and Google are their own worst enemies. Neither is lead by a founder who cares, which matters a lot.
Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by saagarjha on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @07:00PM (#16750222)
> Neither is lead by a founder who cares

[Citation needed]

Re:Apple Hires Google’s A.I. Chief by zealsham on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @06:27PM (#16749958)
Did you read the article or you just skimed through it.