News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Astronaut’s DNA No Longer Matches His Identical Twin’s Af... by loufe on Wednesday March 14, 2018 @09:36PM (#16589904)
The article headline is practically fake news. The article isn't very clear on it either. It's not someone's DNA that changes, that would be astounding if all the trillions of cells in your body underwent the same genetic mutations. No, this is a change in epigenetics. The things that change what parts of your DNA are expressed and are much easier to coordinate, change, and adapt in the short-term.

Epigenetics are not that foreign a concept that people should assume the average reader won't understand them or will find it any less amazing.

Re:Astronaut’s DNA No Longer Matches His Identical Twin’s Af... by purple-again on Wednesday March 14, 2018 @09:44PM (#16589945)
I consider myself to be very armchair scientifically literate (zero real applied knowledge but I have consumed just about all of the pop culture created on the subject in the last 30 years).

I have never heard the word epigenetics until now and am still confused about what exactly happened to this guy.

Re:Astronaut’s DNA No Longer Matches His Identical Twin’s Af... by db48x on Wednesday March 14, 2018 @10:42PM (#16590098)
Every gene can have a tag attached to it which prevents the gene from being used to create RNA (the tag is a methyl group, so this is called "methylation"). Since the RNA would then be used as instructions for creating a protein molecule, inactivating a gene by tagging it generally causes the cell to stop producing particular proteins. Since each protein has one or more specific jobs to do in the cell, this causes the behavior of the cell to change. There are a huge number of known proteins (millions maybe? I don't actually know), and a vast potential number of proteins (if you just consider all possible ways of arranging the 20 amino acids into a chain), so there are a vast number of ways that cell behavior can change over time. Indeed, this is how we manage to have different types of tissues at all, including our very complicated immune system with cells that act autonomously to protect against disease.

Also, it's well established that there are plenty of feedback loops here. An active gene can code for the production of a protein that activates or inactivates other genes. There are numerous pathways by which external stimuli can amplify or inhibit all of these feedback loops, so external conditions often result in changes to which genes are tagged.

As you can imagine, the state-space of all of this is immense; far larger than just the number and type of genes that you have. Mapping it all is a vast project that might easily take thousands of years.

Re:Astronaut’s DNA No Longer Matches His Identical Twin’s Af... by ggoss on Wednesday March 14, 2018 @11:30PM (#16590235)
The well goes deeper still. Another mode of epigenetic regulation involves histones, the proteins around which DNA is wrapped, and the many ways they can be modified (by methylation, acetylation, ubiquitiylation, sumoylation, etc.). Both DNA methylation and histone modifications modulate how DNA wraps around histones, and thus how readily any given segment can be accessed and transcribed into RNA (and eventually translated into a given protein).

This barely scratches the surface. This process, along with others that modify how DNA is folded, brings certain genes closer together (while moving others farther apart), increasing (or decreasing) the likelihood of all sorts of first, second, and third order (...) interactions between them and their products.

And we've only just begun...

Re:Astronaut’s DNA No Longer Matches His Identical Twin’s Af... by Chris_Jay on Thursday March 15, 2018 @09:59AM (#16592882)
Epigenetics are fascinating. In my D&D headcanon, the reason Drow Elves are so obsessed with spiders is because they picture DNA as a three dimensional web whose spatial arrangement is central to gene expression.
Re:Astronaut’s DNA No Longer Matches His Identical Twin’s Af... by psychobabble on Thursday March 15, 2018 @01:29AM (#16590603)
> This well goes deeper still

> This barely scratches the surface. This process, along with others that modify how DNA is folded, brings certain genes closer together (while moving others farther apart), increasing (or decreasing) the likelihood of all sorts of first, second, and third order (...) interactions between them and their products.

> And we've only just begun...

Horribly vague, care to elaborate mathematically or at least provide some study links? The 'DNA folding' you propose begs resolution from some study using quaternions or attractors, or ... ?

Re:Astronaut’s DNA No Longer Matches His Identical Twin’s Af... by Sharlin on Thursday March 15, 2018 @05:05AM (#16591305)
I see your username is accurate.
Re:Astronaut’s DNA No Longer Matches His Identical Twin’s Af... by fnl on Thursday March 15, 2018 @04:20PM (#16596207)
This view that epigenetics is a gene switch is actually pretty misleading at least, and probably just plain wrong, as recent research published this year has shown. It is far more a structural and inheritance guiding factor, as it was conclusively shown that methylated promoters very much do still allow for gene expression, contrary to "popular" belief.
Re:Astronaut’s DNA No Longer Matches His Identical Twin’s Af... by db48x on Thursday March 15, 2018 @04:30PM (#16596264)
That doesn't surprise me in the least; practically everything in biology has turned out to be more complicated than it first looked.
Re:Astronaut’s DNA No Longer Matches His Identical Twin’s Af... by toufka on Wednesday March 14, 2018 @10:04PM (#16590010)
It has started to come up a lot recently in order to produce the above-like click-bait headlines. Here's my standard copy-pasta quoting myself from when it shows up around here:

Epigenetics. It's the make-file for your genetic source code. Certain conditions can cause certain parts of your genetic code to be uncommented or commented-out within any given cell or set of cells. There are actually a number of different kinds of 'comments' (histone modifications [1]) - each set of marks are particular to a different compiler, in different contexts. And these comments/marks are copied with some fidelity to daughter-cells/children along with a high-fidelty copy of the underlying genetic code itself.

So the genes (DNA) themselves are not being heritably altered, rather the recipe for which gene is produced, when, and where can be subtly changed. But again, the same mechanisms that permit the change in expression of those genes during a lifetime (of an organism, or a cell) can be subsequently changed in the next just as easily.

In this way you can store the code for some trait or capability over many generations without having it always be running. It can manifest itself in individual organisms or cells as having very different phenotypes even while possessing the same underlying genetic code.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Histone_code

Re:Astronaut’s DNA No Longer Matches His Identical Twin’s Af... by Retric on Thursday March 15, 2018 @08:54AM (#16592373)
It's arguably much closer to RAM than a make file.

Picture a Glucose detector wrapped around a DNA segment that encodes something to break down Glucose. If you zero Glucose inside the nucleus you stop producing stuff to deal with it.

The difference for this analogy is cells never stop compiling. On the other hand if you think of cell division as a reboot it's a better fit.

Re:Astronaut’s DNA No Longer Matches His Identical Twin’s Af... by fnl on Thursday March 15, 2018 @04:33PM (#16596286)
Your epigenetic state very much starts off inherited from your parents. Also, it's not just a gene switch, and in fact that probably is it's least relevant role, if any. Rather, and besides being a hereditary factor, it determines the structure/packing of your nucleosomes, and therefore determines the integrity of your cell as a whole, not just your gene expression levels.
Re:Astronaut’s DNA No Longer Matches His Identical Twin’s Af... by tmsldd on Thursday March 15, 2018 @12:30AM (#16590409)
Thanks for the analogy, I’m actually copying & pasting for future references ;)
Re:Astronaut’s DNA No Longer Matches His Identical Twin’s Af... by Rescis on Wednesday March 14, 2018 @09:56PM (#16589978)
Epigenetics is the idea that genes can express themselves differently based on the environment they are put in.

It is how you can have the same genetic code in your brain as you skin, but the cells the genes are part of are completely different.

It's how you can have a hard drive with a ton of information on it, but choose to read only small portions at a time

Re:Astronaut’s DNA No Longer Matches His Identical Twin’s Af... by clon on Wednesday March 14, 2018 @10:20PM (#16590017)
Genes are the data, epigenetics talks about the program instructions, notably proteins called transcription factors. The latter are of course also encoded for in genes.

The similarities to Von Neumann architecture are .. unsettling.

Re:Astronaut’s DNA No Longer Matches His Identical Twin’s Af... by psergeant on Wednesday March 14, 2018 @09:50PM (#16589965)
You might enjoy reading Seveneves
Re:Astronaut’s DNA No Longer Matches His Identical Twin’s Af... by bwb on Wednesday March 14, 2018 @10:03PM (#16590007)
Great book, another rec here too!
Re:Astronaut’s DNA No Longer Matches His Identical Twin’s Af... by nemacol on Thursday March 15, 2018 @09:20AM (#16592545)
Youtube's SciShow gave me my introduction to epigenetics.

Perhaps the science has advanced since this video was created, but I think it is a fine primer on the subject.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kp1bZEUgqVI

Re:Astronaut’s DNA No Longer Matches His Identical Twin’s Af... by fouc on Wednesday March 14, 2018 @11:22PM (#16590208)
I know about epigenetics because of many articles in Popular Science or Discovery.
Re:Astronaut’s DNA No Longer Matches His Identical Twin’s Af... by koonsolo on Thursday March 15, 2018 @05:26AM (#16591374)
Ok, that explains a lot, because my imagination was going wild with these 2 things:

According to the article: Preliminary results from NASA's Twins Study reveal that 7% of astronaut Scott Kelly's genes did not return to normal after his return to Earth two years ago.

According to my memory, and now looked it up: Chimps and bonobos in particular take pride of place as our nearest living relatives, sharing approximately 99 percent of our DNA, with gorillas trailing at 98 percent.

Good thing they put a picture in the article of the guy, haha.

Re:Astronaut’s DNA No Longer Matches His Identical Twin’s Af... by grondilu on Thursday March 15, 2018 @05:42AM (#16591445)
> According to my memory, and now looked it up: Chimps and bonobos in particular take pride of place as our nearest living relatives, sharing approximately 99 percent of our DNA, with gorillas trailing at 98 percent.

I thought of that as well while reading about the 7% they mention, but then I assumed they were talking about 7% of the genes that are specific to human kind.

Re:Astronaut’s DNA No Longer Matches His Identical Twin’s Af... by vkou on Thursday March 15, 2018 @06:22AM (#16591588)
Indeed. If 7% of your genome were replaced with something else, it would be incredibly unlikely that you would still be alive.
Re:Astronaut’s DNA No Longer Matches His Identical Twin’s Af... by grondilu on Thursday March 15, 2018 @06:28AM (#16591613)
Though now that I think about it, if 7% of the human-specific genome was changed, then it must mean that 7% of the rest was changed too. I mean it's not like cosmic particles specifically target human genes, is it?
Re:Astronaut’s DNA No Longer Matches His Identical Twin’s Af... by mrmondo on Thursday March 15, 2018 @04:05AM (#16591112)
While I think it’s important to disagree with news that might be less than factual and better yet - think with a skeptical mindset, I think it’s rather anti-intellectual to blanket misleading or factually lacking news as ‘fake news’.
Re:Astronaut’s DNA No Longer Matches His Identical Twin’s Af... by Elrac on Thursday March 15, 2018 @05:39AM (#16591427)
Good thing he didn't do that!
Re:Astronaut’s DNA No Longer Matches His Identical Twin’s Af... by teekert on Thursday March 15, 2018 @08:03AM (#16592045)
Exactly, I would expect this person to perhaps have some additional mutations (in his superficial tissues so no body wide mutation of course) due to radiation, or perhaps due to selective pressures working differently on them in 0 G. Also I'd expect expression changes (RNA quantity changes), also related to 0 G or maybe to his diet. Also, it is often claimed that chimp DNA is only 1% different from ours. Which is also bull of course, it depends, (as here) on how difference is defined. The telomere story is interesting but from the text it sounds like we already expect that from radiation and calorie restriction.
Re:Astronaut’s DNA No Longer Matches His Identical Twin’s Af... by im3w1l on Thursday March 15, 2018 @04:20AM (#16591160)
> would be astounding if all the trillions of cells in your body underwent the same genetic mutations.

spoiler: they won't all undergo the same epigenetic changes either.

Re:Astronaut’s DNA No Longer Matches His Identical Twin’s Af... by emiliobumachar on Thursday March 15, 2018 @04:49AM (#16591237)
Are you sure? Might there be a coordination mechanism of sorts?
Re:Astronaut’s DNA No Longer Matches His Identical Twin’s Af... by Erlangolem on Wednesday March 14, 2018 @09:49PM (#16589960)
I think the issue for the article is that identical twins are not epigenentically identical to begin with, time in space and life in general will only tend to magnify that. In essence, the headline is doubly misleading.
Re:Astronaut’s DNA No Longer Matches His Identical Twin’s Af... by gabeiscoding on Wednesday March 14, 2018 @10:30PM (#16590053)
A much better source for those with an interest in the science is Chris Mason's slides from his recent talk[1] at genetics conference (AGBT) about this that he shared on twitter[2].

He's a great speaker, and a cool guy and tackles some of the most interesting (at least to hear about) science in genomics

[1] https://www.dropbox.com/s/sfg6rdmgxjwdpil/Mason_NEB_talk_AGB... [2] https://twitter.com/mason_lab/status/964151387687972864

Re:Astronaut’s DNA No Longer Matches His Identical Twin’s Af... by gus_massa on Wednesday March 14, 2018 @11:08PM (#16590171)
[I'll copy my comment from dupe story that didn't get any traction.]

The article avoids all the interesting technical details. In case you are wondering if this is possible and how much of this is an exaggeration, the title of the research article is "The Landscape of DNA and RNA Methylation Before, During, and After Human Space Travel (Twins Study - Mason) - 09.27.17" https://www.nasa.gov/mission_pages/station/research/experime...

Methylation is an usual process that the cells use for enabling and disabling genes expression. It's reversible, somewhat permanent and somewhat inheritable. If you like a bad analogy, it's like making a change in the bios setup of your computer or updating the configuration of the wifi-router. It's not a firmware upgrade or a hardware modification. More info: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DNA_methylation

Re:Astronaut’s DNA No Longer Matches His Identical Twin’s Af... by psychobabble on Thursday March 15, 2018 @12:01AM (#16590326)
Oh heck, me too - since I was responding to your only comment just minutes ago, here is again :)

Maybe, but what is really causing the DNA methylation? The article pins it mostly on epigenetics or environment, the 'stress of space travel', including dietary constraints and oxygen levels all of which are valid.

- https://theconversation.com/epigenetics-can-stress-really-ch...

- http://sitn.hms.harvard.edu/flash/2017/stress-induced-dna-mo...

- https://www.scientificamerican.com/page/sponsored/nestle/how... ooh, sponsored article, didn't catch that the first time.

However, the CNN article only briefly mentions 'radiation' as a factor and likely is lumping that into the 'stressful environment' case repeated several times.

Realistically, cosmic rays or radiation are far more likely to the be prevailing indicator for DNA disruption but are not plainly disclosed here. Despite much research having been done on this specific topic.

Wikipedia states: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Health_threat_from_cosmic_rays "The potential acute and chronic health effects of space radiation, as with other ionizing radiation exposures, involve both direct damage to DNA, indirect effects due to generation of reactive oxygen species, and changes to the biochemistry of cells and tissues, which can alter gene transcription and the tissue microenvironment along with producing DNA mutations."

From this paper: https://arxiv.org/abs/1406.6641 "In the present paper, we suggest the BNR as a cause of genetic “fails” in living cells, that is one of the possible origins of the so called spontaneous mutations. Cells exposed to the shower of electrons and ions, caused by the collision of a neutron and a proton of water, could be annihilated or experience a permanent damage, in particular, a damage in the DNA."

Cosmic radiation detrimental effects to DNA confirmed by NASA in this study: https://ntrs.nasa.gov/archive/nasa/casi.ntrs.nasa.gov/200800...

And more poignantly, from https://www.vencoreweather.com/blog/2017/6/26/1200-pm-cosmic... ( do not read full link if you are easily panicked ): "... there are other consequences of increasing cosmic rays according to “Spaceweather.com” including the penetration of commercial airlines, dosing passengers and flight crews enough that pilots are classified as occupational radiation workers. [Dose rates are expressed as multiples of sea level. For instance, we see that boarding a plane that flies at 25,000 feet exposes passengers to dose rates ~10x higher than sea level. At 40,000 feet, the multiplier is closer to 50x]"

Sorry for the data dump, I just happened to be researching cosmic ray effects the past few evenings and have collected many interesting facts on the topic. The most I have concluded at this point is that humans, as currently derived, are not made for space travel.

Re:Astronaut’s DNA No Longer Matches His Identical Twin’s Af... by gus_massa on Thursday March 15, 2018 @02:08PM (#16595172)
I am not a biologist, so my answer may have a mistake ...

Radiation and cosmic rays produce random mutations, where one of the bases of the DNA is changed by another base. (IIRC the radiation breaks the old base, and when the copy or correction enzymes see the mess, they may make a mistake and use the wrong base.)

Methylation is on purpose. Some part of the cell "decides" to enable or disable a gen, and send the correct enzymes to add or remove the methyles in the bases of the specific part of the gene.

(There are also some arm races between bacteria and virus that attack bacteria. The bacteria has an enzyme that split the DNA at points with some specific patterns, to try to kill the virus that enter the cell. The parts of the DNA of the bacteria with this pattern are methylated, so the enzyme doesn't attack the DNA of the owner. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Restriction_modification_syste... )

Re:Astronaut’s DNA No Longer Matches His Identical Twin’s Af... by tofof on Wednesday March 14, 2018 @11:18PM (#16590198)
From the Nasa press release, 93% of the genetic expression pattern (very different than "DNA") remained the same before and after spaceflight, while 7% was altered.

Search for "93%" in https://www.nasa.gov/feature/nasa-twins-study-investigators-...

Re:Astronaut’s DNA No Longer Matches His Identical Twin’s Af... by sathackr on Wednesday March 14, 2018 @09:28PM (#16589863)
I don't understand why an identical twin was needed to learn this.

Couldn't an astronaut's DNA be sampled before and after a mission and compared?

Re:Astronaut’s DNA No Longer Matches His Identical Twin’s Af... by mikhailt on Wednesday March 14, 2018 @09:38PM (#16589915)
How would you rule out age-related changes since this specific astronaut was in space for a year? DNA is not fixed, they change all the time.

It is always better to have more data points to rule out several variables, especially considering that it is rare to have an astronaut with a twin sibling.

Re:Astronaut’s DNA No Longer Matches His Identical Twin’s Af... by lostlogin on Wednesday March 14, 2018 @09:48PM (#16589959)
So how did it ever match his twin? Not being facetious but echoing the parent comments confusion. Do the age related changes occur the same way in identical twins?
Re:Astronaut’s DNA No Longer Matches His Identical Twin’s Af... by mikhailt on Thursday March 15, 2018 @04:43PM (#16596381)
This article may explain better than I can: https://arstechnica.com/science/2018/03/scott-kellys-medical...

> As a result, the more relevant comparison (and one NASA did) is Scott's DNA before and after his time in space. That can tell us how many changes were picked up while in space. But as noted above, he would have probably picked up some mutations even if he sat here on Earth. And that's where his twin Mark, who did sit here on Earth, comes in. Mark's before and after gives us a sense of the normal background rate of mutation on Earth. Comparing that rate to Scott's tells us the important number: the degree to which this rate is elevated in the environment of low-Earth orbit.

Re:Astronaut’s DNA No Longer Matches His Identical Twin’s Af... by everly on Wednesday March 14, 2018 @09:53PM (#16589974)
"DNA is not fixed, they change all the time."

Then why is it significant that time in space changed it?

Re:Astronaut’s DNA No Longer Matches His Identical Twin’s Af... by mikhailt on Thursday March 15, 2018 @04:44PM (#16596388)
It’s the rate of change compared to his twin on earth. This ars article explains better: https://arstechnica.com/science/2018/03/scott-kellys-medical...
Re:Astronaut’s DNA No Longer Matches His Identical Twin’s Af... by tytytytytytytyt on Wednesday March 14, 2018 @11:20PM (#16590205)
It might have changed it more or in different ways.
Re:Astronaut’s DNA No Longer Matches His Identical Twin’s Af... by lithos on Wednesday March 14, 2018 @09:33PM (#16589889)
Some accounting for a year of aging. Though the news press is probably more scientifically significant.
Re:Astronaut’s DNA No Longer Matches His Identical Twin’s Af... by telchar on Wednesday March 14, 2018 @09:34PM (#16589891)
Well, consider the counterfactual of what would have happened to the astronaut's DNA if he hadn't gone to space. We don't know how it would have changed, so we can't compare it directly. Since we needed to do the experiment I'm guessing our knowledge DNA was not sufficient to predict that, so it makes sense to use a twin to get the closest proxy to the counterfactual that we can.
Re:Astronaut’s DNA No Longer Matches His Identical Twin’s Af... by 88e282102ae2e5b on Wednesday March 14, 2018 @09:33PM (#16589888)
Sure, but everyone is accumulating mutations all the time, so you need a control on the ground to see if space itself is affecting the mutation rate.
Re:Astronaut’s DNA No Longer Matches His Identical Twin’s Af... by mirimir on Wednesday March 14, 2018 @10:19PM (#16590014)
The article is muddled.

> To better understand the genetic dynamics of each twin, Mason and his team focused on chemical changes in RNA and DNA. Whole-genome sequencing revealed that each twin has more than expected unique mutations in his genome -- in fact, hundreds.

So both experienced hundreds more unique mutations? But OK, let's say that it was Scott Kelly who experienced more mutations. But which tissues did they sample? Sperm?

> Preliminary results from NASA's Twins Study reveal that 7% of astronaut Scott Kelly's genes did not return to normal after his return to Earth two years ago.

This is about gene expression, not necessarily mutations. And it's the key take home. Given that we've known for some decades that radiation causes mutations.

Re:Astronaut’s DNA No Longer Matches His Identical Twin’s Af... by make3 on Wednesday March 14, 2018 @09:34PM (#16589892)
"Answer a question in this survey to continue reading this content" Really? no thanks
Re:Astronaut’s DNA No Longer Matches His Identical Twin’s Af... by skookumchuck on Wednesday March 14, 2018 @10:22PM (#16590021)
More likely aliens have replaced him with a pod person to infiltrate NASA.
Re:Astronaut’s DNA No Longer Matches His Identical Twin’s Af... by gowld on Wednesday March 14, 2018 @09:35PM (#16589900)
> 93% of Scott's genetic expression returned to normal once he returned to Earth,

How much was abnormal during the trip?

Re:Astronaut’s DNA No Longer Matches His Identical Twin’s Af... by lithos on Wednesday March 14, 2018 @09:31PM (#16589878)
That really clever they put the ask for notifications button over the top of the close ad button.
Re:Astronaut’s DNA No Longer Matches His Identical Twin’s Af... by tyingq on Wednesday March 14, 2018 @09:23PM (#16589832)
Sounds like the genesis for a new sci-fi movie.
Re:Astronaut’s DNA No Longer Matches His Identical Twin’s Af... by zaroth on Wednesday March 14, 2018 @10:02PM (#16590001)
Anyone else getting the “Congratulations you are a winner” ad spam / malware which takes over the page and forces a redirect?

I run into this on news sites several times a week. I assume these are ads which are sneaking by the ad networks filter and running scripts on the page, just not sure how they are so damn pervasive?

If these ads aren’t being paid for with stolen credit cards, then why aren’t they people buying them getting slammed with CFAA charges? Is it that hard to track these clowns down?

Re:Astronaut’s DNA No Longer Matches His Identical Twin’s Af... by dahdum on Wednesday March 14, 2018 @10:24PM (#16590032)
I get these frequently too, especially on IOS devices. If you wipe your browser history it stops happening, so I assume they are doing some checks against Ad Network filters.
Re:Astronaut’s DNA No Longer Matches His Identical Twin’s Af... by zaroth on Thursday March 15, 2018 @01:22AM (#16590575)
Yes, this was on my iPhone. I always hav Safari set to Private mode so I think there is no history.
Re:Astronaut’s DNA No Longer Matches His Identical Twin’s Af... by namanyayg on Wednesday March 14, 2018 @10:22PM (#16590025)
Are you sure you don't have malware on your system? I haven't experienced a redirect ad in basically forever.
Re:Astronaut’s DNA No Longer Matches His Identical Twin’s Af... by dahdum on Wednesday March 14, 2018 @10:27PM (#16590045)
It's super rare in Chrome for me, but I've seen it happen the first day on a new iPad / Safari just a few weeks ago.