News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Project Gutenberg blocks access from Germany by jaakl on Saturday March 03, 2018 @04:29PM (#16511686)
> PGLAF is entirely in the US

PGLAF has awesome mission, but that base assumption is not really correct. With publishing content in Germany (or whatever country) over Internet (or otherwise) they have crossed physical and legal borders. You must obey local laws everywhere and US laws are legal in their soil only. The attitude that US laws are something globally applicable and Internet is something above local laws is naive and total blockage “revenge” is just plain childish.

Re:Project Gutenberg blocks access from Germany by JorgeGT on Saturday March 03, 2018 @04:52PM (#16511836)
But they are not publishing content in Germany? German citizens are contacting and downloading content hosted in US servers, aren't they? This is like saying HN is publishing in Spain and has to obey Spanish laws just because I'm connecting from here.
Re:Project Gutenberg blocks access from Germany by greenyoda on Saturday March 03, 2018 @05:48PM (#16512160)
> total blockage “revenge” is just plain childish

The article claims that they're doing it to protect themselves from future lawsuits, not as "revenge":

"Q: Why block all of Germany, rather than just those 18 books?

A: PGLAF's legal advisors disagree with all claims that there must be any blocking, or removal, or anything associated - censorship, fines/fees, disclaimers, etc. - for items that are in the public domain in the US. Period.[1]

Because the German Court has overstepped its jurisdiction, and allowed the world's largest publishing group to bully Project Gutenberg for these 18 books, there is every reason to think that this will keep happening. There are thousands of eBooks in the Project Gutenberg collection that could be subject to similar over-reaching and illigitimate actions.

PGLAF is a small volunteer organization, with no income (it doesn't sell anything), other than donations. There is every reason to fear that this huge corporation, with the backing of the German Court, will continue to take legal action. In fact, at least one other similar complaint arrived in 2017 about different books in the Project Gutenberg collection, from another company in Germany."

[1] For the reasoning behind this, see the quotes in my earlier comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16512068

Re:Project Gutenberg blocks access from Germany by sentenza on Sunday March 04, 2018 @06:51AM (#16514387)
> The article claims that they're doing it to protect themselves from future lawsuits, not as "revenge":

Then the article is disingenuous, because the same copyright period and liabilities exist in most EU countries.

Singling out Germany because a German company was first to sue is pure revenge.

If they wanted to protect themselves, they would block the whole EU and a whole lot of countries outside the EU, not just Germany.

Re:Project Gutenberg blocks access from Germany by zmmmmm on Saturday March 03, 2018 @05:59PM (#16512216)
> With publishing content in Germany (or whatever country) over Internet (or otherwise) they have crossed physical and legal borders.

This really goes to the fundamental nature of the internet and digital technology. Is it "push" whereby a web site "sends" the content to the visitor (therefore assumes the burden of copyright infringement, because they initiate a transfer out of their country into the visitor's) or is it "pull" where a visitor effectively goes to a country, gets the content and returns home, and the visitor is doing the international transfer and thus inheriting the liability of that?

To my mind the "pull" model is more persuasive because the visitor is clearly the agent in control of the transfer. This judgement seems to go against it though, and say that as a web site operator, you are the one doing the international transfer of the information.

Re:Project Gutenberg blocks access from Germany by quasarj on Saturday March 03, 2018 @04:34PM (#16511725)
Wooah careful there buddy, using the word "revenge" is not legal in my jurisdiction, and you just published it here by placing it on the internet!
Re:Project Gutenberg blocks access from Germany by coldtea on Saturday March 03, 2018 @04:44PM (#16511785)
You mock what the parent said, but yet, if something isn't legal in the USA, most would find it OK to be cut.
Re:Project Gutenberg blocks access from Germany by jaakl on Saturday March 03, 2018 @04:55PM (#16511867)
I dont say that such interpretation of international law over web content is practical, reasonable, etc, but it is as it is. Better be aware of this if you publish anything not trivial, otherwise your US (for example) lawyers will be happy to work on your hopeless case.
Re:Project Gutenberg blocks access from Germany by stale2002 on Saturday March 03, 2018 @04:47PM (#16511804)
> total blockage “revenge” is just plain childish.

It seems like it is working to get them publicity. If germany doesn't like that they are now being blocked, then they should change their laws.

It is their website, so too bad for germany.

Protesting ridiculous copywrite laws is perfectly reasonable.

Re:Project Gutenberg blocks access from Germany by freeflight on Saturday March 03, 2018 @05:14PM (#16511965)
> If germany doesn't like that they are now being blocked, then they should change their laws.

Sadly it ain't as easy as that, the copyright lobby is very powerful in Germany, with their very own special interest laws like "mitstörerhaftung" [0] and the "Impressumspflicht". It's stuff like that which prevents open WLAN easily being run and operated because in Germany the person running the AP is liable for everything that happens trough said connection.

There are a ton of law firms who solely generate their income by sending out bulk cease&desist letters to torrent seeders, people who don't have a proper "Impressum" on their webpage and a number of other "formal" reasons. Kindergartens and retirement homes have gotten c&d letters over singing Christmas songs amounting to "copyrighted content".

These letters pretty much boil down to "Pay this fine and sign that you won't do it again if you still do it again you are liable for several thousands of € in damages".

Most people just pay the "fine" (usually starting at around 500€ sometimes quite a bit higher depending on the content) as it's easier and less hassle compared to taking it to the court, which are quite often technological inept and thus are very likely to side with the claimant's version of "This is theft/piracy!". It's pretty much a very own sub-sector of law firms in Germany.

Most people often think practices like these are something reserved to the US, a while ago, but Germany has its fair share of copyright insanity going on too. At this point, I'd guess Germany is even a far bit crazier than the US.

[0] https://qz.com/694618/why-is-it-impossible-to-find-free-wi-f...

[1] https://www.rockit-internet.de/en/what-is-an-impressum/

Re:Project Gutenberg blocks access from Germany by lovich on Saturday March 03, 2018 @05:20PM (#16511998)
Then Germany as an entity can deal with the results of their society being structured in a way that allows those special interests to have that level of control. America has the same problems as well but it's be unreasonable to expect people in other sovereignties to make special accommodations for me just because my government is making me follow a different set of rules
Re:Project Gutenberg blocks access from Germany by freeflight on Saturday March 03, 2018 @05:26PM (#16512030)
> it's be unreasonable to expect people in other sovereignties to make special accommodations for me

Nobody is expecting PG to do anything like that, what is expected is that PG just removes these 18 books from German access, if they don't then the German publisher can cease&desist them over giving access to said books, which would have no effect at all on GP due to it being an entity that's registered in California, so German c&d letters have literally no effect on them.

GP is taking a stance here, which I very much appreciate as a German, but quite a few people here seem to be misunderstanding what's actually happening here or expected from GP.

Re:Project Gutenberg blocks access from Germany by lovich on Monday March 05, 2018 @01:53PM (#16523334)
Your expectation is that PG is going to go and add extra features and work to turn off specific items to comply with other people's rulesets. Why is PG expected to modify their behavior? It's certainly acceptable for Germany to not allow what PG does in Germany, but they don't get to pick and choose what's allowed if PG also doesn't want to play ball. PG is allowed to say it's a package deal
Re:Project Gutenberg blocks access from Germany by mcguire on Saturday March 03, 2018 @11:13PM (#16513227)
There is nothing in the decision about "German access".

"The defendants are ordered, on penalty of an administrative fine of up to EUR 250,000.00 or, alternatively, imprisonment of up to 6 months, for each case of non- compliance, said imprisonment to be imposed on the second defendant, to cease and desist from making the following works publicly available or letting them be made publicly available, namely:..."

Plus damages.

Re:Project Gutenberg blocks access from Germany by freeflight on Sunday March 04, 2018 @09:57AM (#16514884)
The fact that they are talking about Germany is self-evident because it's a German court and they even wrote it out plainly, if you'd bothered to read further than the part you quoted:

"via the website www.gutenberg.org (including its sub-pages) without the plaintiff’s consent, if and to the extent to which it is possible for internet users to access them (screen display and/or download) from Germany."

If you want to talk about national courts censoring content from the whole www then you need to talk to US courts and their "chilling effects".

Re:Project Gutenberg blocks access from Germany by Grollicus on Saturday March 03, 2018 @05:28PM (#16512039)
The Störerhaftung is not a special interest law for copyright. The idea is that you are at fault if others use you (/your stuff) to violate rights of a third party. For example if someone were to spray paint "freeflight sucks" on my house you could ask me to remove it and if I didn't, you could sue me.
Re:Project Gutenberg blocks access from Germany by freeflight on Saturday March 03, 2018 @05:46PM (#16512145)
Its interpretation in regards to online access is (was) very much special interest for copyright claimants and one of the major hurdles for getting free WiFi coverage in Germany.
Re:Project Gutenberg blocks access from Germany by jaakl on Saturday March 03, 2018 @05:15PM (#16511973)
Totally agree that bulk of the copywrite laws are unreasonable and unfit for the digital age. However, for me more interesting question is why they even went into the German court. In theory Germany could issue international warrant, but I doubt if they do it for minor cases, think of e.g. Snowden, Assange and Polanski cases. So at most they could have ordered blockage of the site/IP in their side, as long as book-specific ban is probably technically not doable. Also they may blacklist the offending persons from entering Germany/EU. Maybe US lawyers just saw big case with revenue and gave 'good' advice to go to the fight?

So if someone sues me due to this post, then good luck with that, unless you figure out where I am.

Re:Project Gutenberg blocks access from Germany by tyingq on Saturday March 03, 2018 @04:33PM (#16511710)
Perhaps if that’s the only action they ever take. In the short term, it’s possible it’s the only action they can safely take, if they want some time to analyze the situation.