As a man, I wouldn't never even think I have to hide my photo online. I've been using the internet for more than 20 years and was never harassed based on my sex (or anything else, really). I find it crucial that we understand these different experiences we're all facing when we go online, if we ever want it to be different.
As far as I see it, this is about educating our boys much more than it is about educating our web designers.
Even if the abuse were partly caused by the chat box popping up annoyingly, one could still conclude that a chat box popping up with a woman's name and face annoys people more than with a man's or a generic "team" one.
And, regardless of how annoying a chat box is, the findings of this article still stand...[This is Julia btw, the author of this post]
The rationale is given by Ling herself here:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-xZZ1c7diUI
I've written my own theory of the site (it is ... something else...) at Ello:
https://ello.co/ferdiz/post/p3wjs7hvw0zq-7qdrmyvea
(Also submitted to HN a ways back: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9574350 )
Nutshell:
One of the costliest elements for a car sales outlet is tire-kickers: people who come by, look at vehicles, tie up a salesperson's time, and don't buy anything. More to the point, they never planned to buy anything....
The auto dealership (online or off) wants to sort out the tire-kickers as quickly as possible. If you aren't currently and really shopping for a car, you're a liability. And the chances are the salesperson's missing out on one of the four people who might actually have a real interest in buying that day. The goal is to sort you as quickly as possible.(
Ling'sCars.com is optimized for driving away people who don't really, really, REALLY want to buy a car.*
Not saying you want to drive people away. But you also probably want to not spend much time interacting with anyone that's not really interested in your product.
...and also people who want to preserve their eyesight?
I leased a car from Ling's site once. She's actually very business-like in real-life. At the time she was doing deals way better than the competition - still the early days of business leasing back then. Not sure how competitive she is now but the site certainly looks the same?
Huh, okay. (Why bring up some other site?)
> Our website is a video editing tool, so we decided ..
I don't quite follow - how does that fact justify using this particular dark UI pattern?
>> how does that fact justify using this particular dark UI pattern? We just made a product call and decided that the benefits, both for us and for our users, of having a chat box outweighed the annoyance. When people have problems using our tool, they really want help, and it isn't that difficult for the rest of our site visitors to swipe away or ignore the chat box.
I disagree. Dark UI is manipulation of the user. For example, hiding 'X' buttons on pop-ups asking for a subscription. (Is refusing to pay for value provided a dark 'pattern' on the part of users?)
This pop-up does not manipulate the user. It is an honest value proposition. So is "Fifty Shades of Grey." I didn't buy it.
It's a classical sales tactics that builds on social pressure, here taken to a more dishonest level - the chat box was initiated by some code, in spite of what the text message implies.
Also it can make user feel uncomfortable, as if there is someone behind their back standing and looking what they are doing with the site.
This popup is also deceiving users. For example on the screenshot [1] we can see a human user thinking that a real person wrote a greeting to him and wasting time of his life replying to a bot.
You should check out Inspectlet.
Would you call that a dark sales pattern?
The popup being annoying (to which I personally agree) doesn't change anything about the incredibly clear results. People are placed into all kinds of situations in which they come across as annoying by their employers (inbound tech support being just one example).
The only long term solution is giving women the right to defend themselves in these kind of situations and not having to buckle down because of "business reasons".
We've denied perfectly fine clients because they were fucking misogynists to our all-female sales team, but we're a dime in a dozen.
I do find these real-time chat boxes useful, I just wish they'd stay discreetly in the bottom right corner so they're there when I actually want them :/
In any case, perhaps it makes the conclusion even more shocking: A male can piss someone off with little to no negative effect, a female can't. I fear for the results when taking this experiment into meat space.
Nobody gave a shit when it was the dude or the cat. This whataboutism is absolutely mind-blowing to me.
Top comment: "Pop up chat boxes are really annoying. Also I don't know what objective means. But I have added a token: Not defending the sexism sentence."
I believe that sexual harassment is a serious problem women have to deal with, thanks to excellent studies like the one done by Pew on survey data in 2014(http://www.pewinternet.org/2014/10/22/online-harassment/). Calling this "absolutely convincing evidence" not only undermines your position(because it's easy to poke holes at it), but also diminishes the accomplishments of people who do put in the work to quantify and qualify harassment on the Internet.
I'll concede that my statement is to general. But the article to me is strong evidence that the women involved experienced a strong sexist reaction from her customers. Are you not convinced that she did?
The set up is as close to perfect for confounding variables as possible in an evolving production environment (as someone noted, it's basically A/B testing).
I'm not saying it's convincing on its own in a vacuum of course. The prior formed by all the other studies (including the one you mentioned) is important in making it convincing. But it's certainly as clear evidence as 99% of what get's posted here.
Put another way: If this was a blog post that shows that one configuration of a database leads to latencies consistently 10 times smaller than another configuration, with experiments run over three months of production use, I would call that convincing evidence.
It's certainly a lot more coherent than the post I was replying to which somehow argues that this is not objective because chat boxes are annoying. (????) Luckily it's no longer the top comment either.
What's particularly frustrating with this one is that there is already a prominent speech bubble icon in the corner of the screen that suggests they have a chat feature - if I want it. It doesn't need to crack open after a second and slap me.
I am not defending the obvious misogyny here but I think an experiment that starts out by peeing off its subjects can not be fully objective?