I believe that sexual harassment is a serious problem women have to deal with, thanks to excellent studies like the one done by Pew on survey data in 2014(http://www.pewinternet.org/2014/10/22/online-harassment/). Calling this "absolutely convincing evidence" not only undermines your position(because it's easy to poke holes at it), but also diminishes the accomplishments of people who do put in the work to quantify and qualify harassment on the Internet.
I'll concede that my statement is to general. But the article to me is strong evidence that the women involved experienced a strong sexist reaction from her customers. Are you not convinced that she did?
The set up is as close to perfect for confounding variables as possible in an evolving production environment (as someone noted, it's basically A/B testing).
I'm not saying it's convincing on its own in a vacuum of course. The prior formed by all the other studies (including the one you mentioned) is important in making it convincing. But it's certainly as clear evidence as 99% of what get's posted here.
Put another way: If this was a blog post that shows that one configuration of a database leads to latencies consistently 10 times smaller than another configuration, with experiments run over three months of production use, I would call that convincing evidence.
It's certainly a lot more coherent than the post I was replying to which somehow argues that this is not objective because chat boxes are annoying. (????) Luckily it's no longer the top comment either.
Top comment: "Pop up chat boxes are really annoying. Also I don't know what objective means. But I have added a token: Not defending the sexism sentence."