News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:OpenSC2K – An Open Source Remake of SimCity 2000 by willvarfar on Monday February 05, 2018 @04:06AM (#16307576)
Its very questionable to include the assets. The bottom of the readme says:

> Includes assets and graphics extracted from the original SimCity 2000 Special Edition CD. These assets are NOT covered by the GNU General Public License used by this project and are copyright EA / Maxis. I'm including these assets in the hope that because the game has been made freely available at various points in time by EA, and because it's 24 years old as of publishing this project that no action will be taken. Long story short, please don't sue me! Long term, I plan to add functionality to extract assets from the original game files within this project.

The normal way for these open-source engines work is to insist that the users get the artwork from another source.

Re:OpenSC2K – An Open Source Remake of SimCity 2000 by matte_black on Monday February 05, 2018 @08:04AM (#16308491)
I once wrote a building generator that could create SC2k pixel art buildings based off a simple floor plan and some settings. It could be used to generate a lot of assets in a hurry.
Re:OpenSC2K – An Open Source Remake of SimCity 2000 by VikingCoder on Monday February 05, 2018 @10:09AM (#16309181)
Yes, we'd love to see it!
Re:OpenSC2K – An Open Source Remake of SimCity 2000 by bringtheaction on Monday February 05, 2018 @08:16AM (#16308536)
Cool, got a link for it?
Re:OpenSC2K – An Open Source Remake of SimCity 2000 by matte_black on Monday February 05, 2018 @10:27AM (#16309309)
Unfortunately it was quite a long time ago when I was into game development as a hobby, two MacBooks ago. I’d have to see if I still have the hard drive it was on. I never thought it would be useful for anything.

In any case I wouldn’t be surprised if someone is inspired to write a similar tool, it’s really just laying down pixels and shapes in an isometric perspective, and a few other decorative touches.

Re:OpenSC2K – An Open Source Remake of SimCity 2000 by jagger27 on Monday February 05, 2018 @12:07PM (#16310170)
You've got my wheels spinning. Go's image processing libraries are calling to me.
Re:OpenSC2K – An Open Source Remake of SimCity 2000 by chungy on Monday February 05, 2018 @04:24AM (#16307655)
EA is actively selling SimCity 2000 at least on GOG.com. With that in mind, I think there can be no real gesture of goodfaith on the author's part.

It's lazy, maybe just the "easy way" to do it in the beginning, but when the game is being actively sold, it's also slimy.

Re:OpenSC2K – An Open Source Remake of SimCity 2000 by colechristensen on Monday February 05, 2018 @04:45AM (#16307730)
I don't think "bad faith" and "slimy" should really apply to 24 year old game assets.

I value useful creation much higher than dated intellectual property. Or in other words, I do not support long-tail profit and control of any creative work.

Re:OpenSC2K – An Open Source Remake of SimCity 2000 by MaxBarraclough on Monday February 05, 2018 @10:07AM (#16309168)
> should

I suspect virtually all of us here agree that copyright terms are too long, but this still looks like wilful copyright infringement.

Not that it would make any difference if EA stopped selling it on GOG. The idea of 'abandonware' has absolutely zero legal standing, as far as I'm aware.

Other games companies have been very unaccommodating about this kind of thing before, even when game assets weren't used - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chrono_Resurrection

Re:OpenSC2K – An Open Source Remake of SimCity 2000 by epicide on Monday February 05, 2018 @09:20AM (#16308857)
I agree with you in sentiment, but this is not a form of protest -- just laziness. Even if it were some sort of protest against copyright laws, it would be a pretty terrible one.
Re:OpenSC2K – An Open Source Remake of SimCity 2000 by meddlepal on Monday February 05, 2018 @07:31AM (#16308374)
That's fine, but when you get sued into oblivion don't come complaining that you didn't know it wasn't OK.

Lobby for law changes if you don't like the law.

Re:OpenSC2K – An Open Source Remake of SimCity 2000 by chongli on Monday February 05, 2018 @08:27AM (#16308589)
I don't think anyone here is claiming that the author is legally in the right. This is a moral question and labels like "slimy" and "bad faith" are moral labels, not legal ones.
Re:OpenSC2K – An Open Source Remake of SimCity 2000 by Analemma_ on Monday February 05, 2018 @11:35AM (#16309877)
"bad faith" actually is a legal label, and the author of this almost certainly qualifies.
Re:OpenSC2K – An Open Source Remake of SimCity 2000 by Y_Y on Monday February 05, 2018 @09:04AM (#16308757)
> Lobby for law changes if you don't like the law.

Then you'll have two problems!

Re:OpenSC2K – An Open Source Remake of SimCity 2000 by epicide on Monday February 05, 2018 @09:23AM (#16308879)
You already have those problems. You'll be trying to fix two problems instead of just one.
Re:OpenSC2K – An Open Source Remake of SimCity 2000 by Y_Y on Monday February 05, 2018 @11:21AM (#16309767)
I think it's absurd for a private citizen to try to change a law by lobbying.
Re:OpenSC2K – An Open Source Remake of SimCity 2000 by epicide on Monday February 05, 2018 @11:28AM (#16309822)
I meant more trying to reduce/remove lobbying.
[dead]
Re:OpenSC2K – An Open Source Remake of SimCity 2000 by thephyber on Monday February 05, 2018 @04:57PM (#16312616)
> If powerful corporations or special interests want to influence legislation, make them convince the people that something is a good idea and have the people contact their representatives.

(1) A "special interest" is any strict subset of the population. There is no necessity that it be nefarious, as you imply.

(2) A republic, by definition, doesn't require the constant approval of the population for each action. That would be a democracy, which we in the USA don't have and never did. In fact, our founding fathers explicitly ruled out the idea of governance by "the mob".

(3) The problem with "powerful corporations and special interests" is that they have receive concentrated benefits with diffuse costs. The solution is for every elected representative to always vote "no" to every change to the status quo unless it meets a very high bar for diffuse benefits. That kind of government would get even less accomplished than the "Do Nothing Congress".

(4) It's simply unwieldily for elected representatives to talk to their entire constituency on any regular basis. The only time this does happen is when we have some sort of panic. Those with means figured this out and hired people that specialized in getting the attention of legislators, executives, and regulators.

(5) I'm all for rooting out corruption and eliminating it. I'm not for hanging people for doing something that is perfectly legal under current US law.

Re:OpenSC2K – An Open Source Remake of SimCity 2000 by ovao on Monday February 05, 2018 @01:55PM (#16311010)
The intellectual property in this case does not stand in the way of useful creation.
Re:OpenSC2K – An Open Source Remake of SimCity 2000 by indescions_2018 on Monday February 05, 2018 @08:20AM (#16308559)
Thanks for the link to gog.com - drm free classics ;)
Re:OpenSC2K – An Open Source Remake of SimCity 2000 by Feniks on Monday February 05, 2018 @08:04AM (#16308494)
Yeah there's still copyright on Simcity 2000 for 50 years and Simcity itself is trademarked.
Re:OpenSC2K – An Open Source Remake of SimCity 2000 by ryandrake on Monday February 05, 2018 @08:40PM (#16313846)
Doesn’t it seem ridiculous to anyone else that the copyright on most software will outlast the existence of any computer the software was designed to run on? Part of the intellectual property “bargain” is that the right will one day return to the public, who can finally benefit. The extreme length of time appears to circumvent that end of the bargain.
Re:OpenSC2K – An Open Source Remake of SimCity 2000 by alex_duf on Monday February 05, 2018 @04:47AM (#16307739)
That's what openttd.org has been doing.

When they grew in popularity they gathered to completely redraw new assets from scratch.

It's a good way to kick start an MVP.

Also the technology choice doesn't really matter, there's a sweet spot where the new features outbalance the nostalgia of running the original game. At least that's what I think when I play OpenTTD

Re:OpenSC2K – An Open Source Remake of SimCity 2000 by fyfy18 on Monday February 05, 2018 @09:03AM (#16308754)
On the other hand, OpenTTD was originally decompiled from a binary of TTD, where as this is being written from scratch.
Re:OpenSC2K – An Open Source Remake of SimCity 2000 by stuaxo on Monday February 05, 2018 @05:02AM (#16307807)
OpenTTD didn't actually include the assets, you had to use ones from the real game (until their project to draw their own had enough).
Re:OpenSC2K – An Open Source Remake of SimCity 2000 by jordanwallwork on Monday February 05, 2018 @07:03AM (#16308260)
That's what the dude just said
Re:OpenSC2K – An Open Source Remake of SimCity 2000 by bringtheaction on Monday February 05, 2018 @08:18AM (#16308545)
Phrasing made it seem like OpenTTD bundled the original assets. stuaxo was pointing out that they did not.
Re:OpenSC2K – An Open Source Remake of SimCity 2000 by titanix2 on Monday February 05, 2018 @07:15AM (#16308312)
OpenRA is reimplementation of the Red Alert game engine that support multiples games. They have their way to deal with the assets issue but I forgot what exact solution it is. At least RA is available for download for free for EA so its help too.

Edit: « OpenRA is 100% free, and comes bundled with three distinct mods. When you run a mod for the first time the game can automatically download the original game assets, or you can use the original game disks. »

Re:OpenSC2K – An Open Source Remake of SimCity 2000 by yincrash on Monday February 05, 2018 @02:20PM (#16311224)
The full games were released for free back in 2010. The assets are probably being downloaded under that freeware.
Re:OpenSC2K – An Open Source Remake of SimCity 2000 by amyjess on Monday February 05, 2018 @01:09PM (#16310641)
Reminds me of Forge, which is a fanmade computer implementation of Magic: The Gathering. It doesn't come with any card art, but after you start it up there's a menu item that'll let you download all the card art from a server.

(honestly, that probably isn't totally legal either, though)

Re:OpenSC2K – An Open Source Remake of SimCity 2000 by jl6 on Monday February 05, 2018 @06:00AM (#16308018)
How do these types of projects get around the fact that the new source code is clearly a derived work of the old game? I’m not saying they copied code, but they must be copying the design or the game would be a different game.
Re:OpenSC2K – An Open Source Remake of SimCity 2000 by klez on Monday February 05, 2018 @06:07AM (#16308050)
I'm not sure the design of the game is covered by copyright, otherwise you couldn't have clones of neither games nor applications.

Also, code that replicates the functionality of other code is not the definition of derivative work.

Re:OpenSC2K – An Open Source Remake of SimCity 2000 by ChrisSD on Monday February 05, 2018 @06:44AM (#16308201)
It can get dicey if you end up copying actual machine code, even if you translate it in to something higher level. One way round this is clean room design: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clean_room_design
Re:OpenSC2K – An Open Source Remake of SimCity 2000 by dr_zoidberg on Monday February 05, 2018 @08:20AM (#16308556)
Many EULAs state that there will be no attempt by the user to reverse engineering the workings of the program. How would that fit with clean room implementations?
Re:OpenSC2K – An Open Source Remake of SimCity 2000 by ClassyJacket on Monday February 05, 2018 @09:46AM (#16309018)
EULAs are just EULAs, not laws.
Re:OpenSC2K – An Open Source Remake of SimCity 2000 by pizza234 on Monday February 05, 2018 @08:59AM (#16308729)
Although this clone is clearly not the case, and I'm not aware any (high profile) cases, it is actually possible to patent the design of a game.

There is a very interesting read about a video game patent:

http://www.kmjn.org/notes/tapper_videogame_patent.html

titled (drum roll) "Video game in which a host image repels ravenous images by serving filled vessels".

Re:OpenSC2K – An Open Source Remake of SimCity 2000 by matt4077 on Monday February 05, 2018 @09:09AM (#16308783)
That's patent, not copyright. Any patent on SimCity would have run out by now, as they last only 20 years.
Re:OpenSC2K – An Open Source Remake of SimCity 2000 by jamesgeck0 on Monday February 05, 2018 @10:57AM (#16309554)
SimCity 2000 even has a demo that includes most of the graphics assets. It wouldn't put much of a burden on the user.
Re:OpenSC2K – An Open Source Remake of SimCity 2000 by belorn on Monday February 05, 2018 @11:15AM (#16309701)
They could do what many propiratary software developers do and simply write a wrapper that download and extract the assets on the users side during installation and have the user do the "compiling". If that work to avoid creating a derivative gpl program, or simply put the legal responsibility on the user, then surely it will work here too.
Re:OpenSC2K – An Open Source Remake of SimCity 2000 by rage8885 on Monday February 05, 2018 @11:57AM (#16310078)
That's the plan here. Short term, it will include the ability to select and parse out the original assets - long term I'd like to do something similar to the approach that OpenRA has taken (in game asset downloader that makes it seemless to the user).
Re:OpenSC2K – An Open Source Remake of SimCity 2000 by rage8885 on Monday February 05, 2018 @11:55AM (#16310053)
I agree, but wanted to get something working out there first. I'm finishing up some code over the next day or two that will import the original assets from the game files without needing to include the assets within the repository.
Re:OpenSC2K – An Open Source Remake of SimCity 2000 by door2 on Monday February 05, 2018 @09:19AM (#16308845)
who cares? intellectual property law in the united states is irrational and immoral. i strongly support evading the law or fully exploiting gray areas / unenforced copyrights.
Re:OpenSC2K – An Open Source Remake of SimCity 2000 by sgift on Monday February 05, 2018 @09:39AM (#16308977)
That's easy to say if you are not the one who gets hit with a C&D plus some claim for x billion damages or whatever the going rate is these days. Life's too short to sit in courts and fight for something which is a hobby.
Re:OpenSC2K – An Open Source Remake of SimCity 2000 by arcticfox on Monday February 05, 2018 @11:11AM (#16309664)
Which part of a law against for giving away someone else's art for free immoral?
Re:OpenSC2K – An Open Source Remake of SimCity 2000 by door2 on Monday February 05, 2018 @10:48PM (#16314313)
simcity's IP is owned by EA, which is a multibillion-dollar publicly-traded company. this isn't just "someone's art". the only ones who benefit from strict enforcement of 25-year-old IP are EA's shareholders, not the artist, and certainly not the public.
Re:OpenSC2K – An Open Source Remake of SimCity 2000 by NKCSS on Monday February 05, 2018 @04:40AM (#16307709)
It's available online if you add 'abandonware' into the search. Not sure what the legal status is though.
Re:OpenSC2K – An Open Source Remake of SimCity 2000 by icebraining on Monday February 05, 2018 @06:22AM (#16308104)
Unless the copyright holders donated it into the public domain (fat chance), it's still under copyright for at least another 70 years.
Re:OpenSC2K – An Open Source Remake of SimCity 2000 by Spoom on Monday February 05, 2018 @09:08AM (#16308778)
Abandonware is nearly always technically illegal (after all, if it wasn't, and was formally released by the copyright holder, it would be freeware). As mentioned elsewhere in this thread, the game is still sold, so I'm not sure it even qualifies as "abandoned".
Re:OpenSC2K – An Open Source Remake of SimCity 2000 by djsumdog on Monday February 05, 2018 @11:12AM (#16309675)
Most of these sites depend on the copyright owner no longer caring or being hosted in countries that may have shorter copyrights or aren't subject to the DMCA.
Re:OpenSC2K – An Open Source Remake of SimCity 2000 by paulie_a on Monday February 05, 2018 @09:42AM (#16308997)
This is why copyright laws are terrible in the US. It is a game that came out in the 90s, copyright protection for it should be over at this point.

Personally I pretty much just ignore copyright. I don't have a bootleg factory, but at the same time I am not concerned about downloading a file like this

Re:OpenSC2K – An Open Source Remake of SimCity 2000 by viperscape on Monday February 05, 2018 @10:26AM (#16309301)
Copyright is pretty straight forward in the US. https://www.copyright.gov/help/faq/faq-duration.html This game is still under copyright and including the assets for public consumption is considered illegal, unless otherwise specified by the rights holder