News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by fergie on Friday January 19, 2018 @07:15AM (#16185629)
"Work is badly distributed. People have too much, or too little, or both in the same month. And away from our unpredictable, all-consuming workplaces, vital human activities are increasingly neglected. Workers lack the time or energy to raise children attentively, or to look after elderly relations. “The crisis of work is also a crisis of home,” ... This neglect will only get worse as the population grows and ages."

This is the real message of the article. Its not about giving everybody a robot butler, its about reorganising society to allow us to do all of the things that need to be done. We don't need to have lots of people working long poorly paid shifts at Wallmart, but we do need people to look after the young and the elderly. At the moment we have a tendency to look at working class people who dont work as morally lacking, when often they have quite a lot of useful (non-paid) things to be getting on with. We need to change the way we think about what makes somebody a useful member of society

Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by swalsh on Friday January 19, 2018 @07:29AM (#16185696)
These conversations I feel always seem shallow to me. Automation is definitely helping to free us from a lot of work.. but the world we live in today feels like a preview of what an automated world feels like. In reality, our material lifestyle is still supported by a very large number of people working away in countries most Americans can't find on a map for extremely low wages.

If we're going to talk about "reorganizing society", it should factor in EVERY person in the world. Not just the lucky 10% in first world countries.

Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by clarry on Friday January 19, 2018 @07:40AM (#16185758)
> Automation is definitely helping to free us from a lot of work.. but the world we live in today feels like a preview of what an automated world feels like. In reality, our material lifestyle is still supported by a very large number of people working away in countries most Americans can't find on a map for extremely low wages.

I don't know about you but the homes, roads, cars, plumbing, healthcare, energy, food, and most other things vital to our lifestyle do not come from China or Taiwan. And even where Asian products are popular (e.g. big home appliances), European alternatives do exist.

I feel like people in the tech sphere can't look or see beyond smartphones, laptops, and other tech gadgets.

Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by carlmr on Friday January 19, 2018 @07:48AM (#16185806)
>And even where Asian products are popular (e.g. big home appliances), European alternatives do exist.

I can think of Miele. That's the only one that's propely German still. Bosch/Siemens are both very much Asian on the inside. They do some assembly in Germany as far as I know. Can't think of any other European brands in this space.

Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by clarry on Friday January 19, 2018 @08:24AM (#16185986)
How about Electrolux (AEG, Rosenlew, etc.), Liebherr, Gorenje/Asko/Upo, Festivo, Smeg, Hotpoint? If you want to avoid Asian products, we can buy American too.. e.g. Whirlpool.
Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by carlmr on Monday January 22, 2018 @03:01AM (#16202683)
They are all European brands, but they don't produce in Europe, at most there's some assembly or they outright buy from Chinese companies and rebrand.
Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by eeZah7Ux on Friday January 19, 2018 @12:56PM (#16188212)
In many countries plenty of construction material (paint, metal...) and chemicals come from very poor areas: China, Africa & so on.
Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by lbotos on Friday January 19, 2018 @08:24AM (#16185983)
I've been calling amazon prime a "hiding of the poor" to my friends and family. Hide the laborers in a far off insanely demanding warehouse, you just get the goods.

(I don't have prime, I don't use prime, and I don't want this to be our future.)

Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by Grimm665 on Friday January 19, 2018 @10:38AM (#16186990)
> Hide the laborers in a far off insanely demanding warehouse, you just get the goods.

Anecdotal, but I have visited a few of the Amazon warehouses in the Seattle area. I was surprised by the amount of effort Amazon went to to emphasize safety, work-life balance, healthy activities, and good work habits. There were free vending machines for PPE everywhere, and during the lunch hour each day, managers led workers in 20 minutes of organized exercise to keep people active and moving.

This is just one cluster of US-based warehouses, and probably doesn't account for the working conditions in all Amazon warehouses, but it was far from a sweatshop and workers seemed genuinely content with their jobs.

Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by Robin_Message on Friday January 19, 2018 @12:34PM (#16188026)
If I worked in a physical job, I don't think I'd want to give up twenty minutes of my break for a workout with my manager...
Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by Casseres on Saturday January 20, 2018 @10:00PM (#16196659)
> There were free vending machines for PPE

Employers are required by law to provide PPE for free.

Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by corey_moncure on Friday January 19, 2018 @08:37AM (#16186075)
Yes, this is exactly it. Slavery was distasteful so we used the modern economy to abstract the slavery out of sight, hide it under the rug. One click buy! Pay no attention to the machine behind the curtain.

Wish Amazon would offer an entirely "Made in first world with protected workers" store.

Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by cdoxsey on Friday January 19, 2018 @08:57AM (#16186185)
How does that help a poor worker in Bangladesh?

In many of these countries people voluntarily choose to work in these factories. They're terrible places to work, but apparently its still better than working in the fields.

A more effective strategy might be something like: https://www.ijm.org/who-we-are . They work within these countries to protect workers from the worst human rights abuses. (ie child sex trafficking and slavery)

Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by NoGravitas on Friday January 19, 2018 @09:42AM (#16186508)
You should read about [Enclosure][1]. Most people, historically, given the choice between traditional subsistence farming, and industrial labor, chose subsistence farming. So governments and property owners took away the option of subsistence farming. This was a 16th-19th century process in Britain, but is an ongoing process in poorer countries now.

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enclosure

Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by 52-6F-62 on Friday January 19, 2018 @10:12AM (#16186744)
This is pretty well what happened to my family pre-mid-1800's (not sure exactly when). The Highland Clearances resulted in them leaving Ayrshire to work in Broxburn/Uphall near Edinburgh which at the time were essentially towns owned by shale mining companies. They remained there at least 100 years until one member defiantly decided to move to Canada (mid 1900s).

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Highland_Clearances

Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by baursak on Friday January 19, 2018 @10:23AM (#16186864)
Here's a quicker, less dry article about it: https://www.nakedcapitalism.com/2012/04/yasha-levine-recover...
Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by beat on Friday January 19, 2018 @10:53AM (#16187106)
People "voluntarily choose" to not starve or wind up homeless.

That's a very narrow definition of "voluntary".

Show me people doing things they would do even if they weren't getting paid to do it. That's voluntary.

Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by nybble41 on Friday January 19, 2018 @03:51PM (#16189692)
> Show me people doing things they would do even if they weren't getting paid to do it. That's voluntary.

The presence of compensation does not preclude an action from being voluntary. Neither does the presence of universal biological imperatives like the need for food or shelter. These things are forced on us by nature, not other people, and are part of the basic human condition.

Providing necessary things for yourself is a voluntary action.

Interacting with others of your own free will to provide the things you need more easily than you could do on your own is also a voluntary action.

It only becomes involuntary when that interaction is forced on you, making you worse off than you would have been on your own (as always, from your own subjective point of view).

Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by snambi on Friday January 19, 2018 @04:00PM (#16189783)
what makes you think working in factory is better than working in the fields?
Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by Shivetya on Friday January 19, 2018 @11:29AM (#16187440)
but Amazon certainly did not invent the warehouse or the conditions some of us think deplorable. there were a few headline making stories but that is all they are. they revealed a job that many expected to not be fun but never really wanted to know the nitty gritty.

there are far worse jobs out there and no amount of automation will rid us of them. from friends that work as linemen; and they all seem to enjoy their jobs; to another who works as a vet; you want a job that not only soaks hours but heartbreak be a vet.

we have plenty of "not fun" jobs but that is exactly why we pay people to do them. there are those around you everyday, I love doing my lawn but have neighbors who don't want to.

modern economy hell, its gotten leagues better than it used to be. people don't realize how much better many jobs are because they believe the sensationalized stories of the day. I am not saying there is no room for improvement but just open your eyes to what was and realize how far we have come

Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by linkmotif on Friday January 19, 2018 @10:36AM (#16186960)
> In reality, our material lifestyle is still supported by a very large number of people working away in countries most Americans can't find on a map for extremely low wages.

> I've been calling amazon prime a "hiding of the poor" to my friends and family. (I don't have prime, I don't use prime, and I don't want this to be our future.)

Amen, parent and grand-parent posters.

Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by aalleavitch on Friday January 19, 2018 @07:34AM (#16185720)
I agree, but I think we absolutely need to be thinking right now about how society is going to be functioning three or four decades from now. The rate of technological advancement hasn't slowed down, and depending on how closely you're following developments in a lot of these countries we traditionally think of as poor or underdeveloped you might find yourself surprised at how quickly they're starting to catch up.
Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by adrianN on Friday January 19, 2018 @07:41AM (#16185767)
Such improvements tend to spread from rich to poor. People in developing countries choose those horrible factory jobs because they're still better than subsistence farming. China is lifting huge numbers of people from abject poverty every year. Eventually wages rise.
Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by visarga on Friday January 19, 2018 @08:36AM (#16186062)
> Such improvements tend to spread from rich to poor.

Best example - the mobile phone. Even the poor can get one that is better than the best smartphone of a few years ago.

Access to content has seen a similar trend - we now all have access to massive amounts of information, videos and online conversation. No money needed, so the poor get immediately the same level of access as the rich.

Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by clarry on Friday January 19, 2018 @01:28PM (#16188482)
> No money needed, so the poor get immediately the same level of access as the rich.

Except for everywhere where poor connectivity and low data caps (+expensive plans relative to the income) are common.

Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by TuringTest on Friday January 19, 2018 @11:11AM (#16187259)
Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by nickthemagicman on Friday January 19, 2018 @07:42AM (#16185772)
Do you know that 8 people in the world have as much wealth as 3.6 BILLION people. That inequality is STAGGERING.

Where do you think the problem lies?

Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by throwanem on Friday January 19, 2018 @08:03AM (#16185894)
Well, using figures from http://time.com/money/4746795/richest-people-in-the-world/, if we take the top eight, sum their fortunes (conveniently expressed in billions), and divide by 3.6, we find that a maximally equitable redistribution would allocate, to each of the lucky recipients, the princely sum of $165.38 US.

So, I'm going to guess the problem may lie somewhere other than with eight really rich people. But we don't really need to do the math on this one, do we? It doesn't even pass the sniff test - "these eight people are LITERALLY THE WORST" is just far too uncomplicated a proposition to accurately reflect the reality of a human world which, though many things, is never simple.

Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by lmm on Friday January 19, 2018 @10:13AM (#16186757)
> So, I'm going to guess the problem may lie somewhere other than with eight really rich people.

Um, why? Because you're one of the lucky few to whom $165 is not a significant sum of money?

Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by narag on Friday January 19, 2018 @10:30AM (#16186917)
Because if this people gave away this money, the effect on the very poor might be noticeable for some months but not sustainable. In no time they would be very poor again and the ones that gave the money away would be unable to give more.

Paul Graham has an essay about this error, how people thinks that there's a fixed amount of money. Once you understand that wealth is created and how, you can't talk like that with a straight face.

Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by jamie_ca on Friday January 19, 2018 @05:53PM (#16190691)
A one-time gift of cash to the poorest may actually have more impact than you think.

https://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2015/09/we...

> a $150 cash grant to poor women in the northern part of [Uganda] doubled their earnings within a year, while one-off $382 transfers to 16- to 35-year-olds were associated with 40-percent higher earnings four years later.

Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by lazerpants on Friday January 19, 2018 @02:09PM (#16188811)
Paul Graham's article on income inequality was of terribly poor quality (not sure if that's the one you're referencing).

He fails to even begin to discuss capital, return on capital, and capital ownership as drivers in economic inequality. Basically it feels like a piece written by a smart guy who has no idea what he's talking about but feels emboldened because "economists are all idiots".

Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by nickthemagicman on Friday January 19, 2018 @08:09AM (#16185919)
You're not extrapolating.

Thats just the top 8 people...Take the sum of the rest of the the global 1% or even 10% and do your math...

OH nm, the math has already been done.

280 trillion in global wealth / 6 billion people = 46k per person

And the top 10% has 86% percent of it, and the inequality is just growing exponentially.

I'm not advocating that wealth should be equally distributed OR that capitalism is all bad..however, that in-equality is STAGGERING....unregulated capitalism with no income redistribution is a one way ticket to a third world PLANET.

https://www.credit-suisse.com/corporate/en/articles/news-and...

Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by patmorgan23 on Friday January 19, 2018 @09:10AM (#16186266)
Unregulated capitalism is not what's causing the massive inequality we see today. It's the financial and monetary policies. I'm not saying we shouldn't have regulations but the ones we have are centralizing wealth into the biggest corporations. If you look this modern massive growth of inequality doesn't really start until the 1970's after we whet off the gold standard and theirs an uptick in inequality every time the fed decides it needs to pump a bunch of money into the economy.
Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by coolaliasbro on Saturday January 20, 2018 @11:06AM (#16193800)
> Unregulated capitalism is not what's causing the massive inequality we see today. It's the financial and monetary policies.

Well, considering that financial and monetary policies are aimed at deregulation, and that financialization of the economy in developed countries is a thing, it would appear that unregulated capitalism is precisely what is causing massive inequality.

Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by nickthemagicman on Friday January 19, 2018 @10:01AM (#16186663)
Do you have examples of these 'financial and monetary policies' you're referring to?

What I see is that Wal-Mart makes a ton of money and their employees have to be on food stamps and still work 80 hour weeks while the owners reap all of the profit.

To me this is simply unregulated capitalism which nowdays has become thinly masked slavery.

Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by oreo81 on Friday January 19, 2018 @04:41PM (#16190107)
Walmart employees don't work 80 hours a week...that's absurd, most can barely handle a 4 hour shift. All in all people get what they're worth, want to earn more money? Bring more valuable talents to the table.
Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by nickthemagicman on Saturday January 20, 2018 @11:43AM (#16193998)
False.
Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by throwanem on Friday January 19, 2018 @08:23AM (#16185981)
It's not terribly controversial that anarchocapitalism is a bad idea. It's also an entirely different proposition from the one you previously advanced.
Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by nickthemagicman on Friday January 19, 2018 @09:58AM (#16186635)
What idea did I 'previously advance'?
Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by CuriousSkeptic on Sunday January 21, 2018 @06:45AM (#16197724)
But income redistribution only adress the symptom. The capital assets driving the inequality would still be firmly in their control. You must put a price on ownership it self to really make a difference.
Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by pasquinelli on Friday January 19, 2018 @11:44AM (#16187576)
i remember when the panama papers first came out there was a story of a guy who bribed the leadership of some third world country to basically rob the country of its mineral rights. so with that $165 you'd also get relief from the damage they actively do with their money.

i'm not saying we should do it, but your analysis doesn't account for any knock on effects, and so is itself far too simple.

Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by throwanem on Friday January 19, 2018 @12:56PM (#16188214)
Would you get relief? One government can buy another, too.
Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by coolaliasbro on Saturday January 20, 2018 @11:00AM (#16193770)
To be clear, the billions controlled by these 8 individuals are not in the majority held in cash. The notion of redistributing this wealth is about socializing the benefits and gains from capital investments. As such, a restructuring of this wealth would not look like handing circa $165 to every person on the planet.
Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by CuriousSkeptic on Sunday January 21, 2018 @06:41AM (#16197714)
A somewhat more interesting calculation would be what you get if you divide the total rental value of their capital assets.
Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by ciocan42 on Friday January 19, 2018 @08:44AM (#16186105)
I think this view of inequality is misleading. It put emphasis that the top richest should be not rich, or they are not good people. It's a defeating viewpoint that blames other for not having success.

When in fact top 10% richest helped much more people along the way than all average combined. And the consequence is being rich.

Instead of complaining about inequality (aka making the rich poorer), better to think about how to make the poor richer.

Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by andrepd on Friday January 19, 2018 @10:08AM (#16186708)
> top 10% richest helped much more people along the way than all average combined

That's complete bullshit. That's maybe how you wish things were. But it's not. I'm in the top 10%, and I've done nothing for it other than having been born in a wealthy country to middle-class parents, with my every need attended to by society. Had I been born somewhere else, I certainly would not be successful as I am now. Instead of being a physicist, maybe I would be boxing cheap plastic gadgets in a factory in Asia. I was born into the top rung on the current global economic arrangement, instead of on the bottom.

To put it this way: if hard work led to wealth every woman in Africa would be a millionaire.

In fact the top 10% keep the statu quo as it is because it benefits them. It benefits them that global economy is arranged in such a way that they are in the center, reaping the benefits of it, and keeping the "periphery" down and in their place, feeding them and their high standard of living. This means everything from stacking "democratic" governments with plutocratic cronies, to simply being a middle-class voter interested in maintaining things just as they are.

Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by bbctol on Friday January 19, 2018 @09:26AM (#16186385)
I appreciate how much the rich have helped other people along their way to, uh, being Sam Walton's kid.
Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by grasshopperpurp on Friday January 19, 2018 @09:14AM (#16186290)
But, when those extremely rich are siphoning money away from others (via paying for laws that favor them, exploiting workers, etc.), it absolutely makes sense to say, 'Hey, you don't need all that. You need to share more than you are.'
Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by coolaliasbro on Saturday January 20, 2018 @11:19AM (#16193861)
I completely agree with the drift of your comment, but would nitpick the notion of "sharing" in this context: since, as has been explained above, the system is effectively gamed to legitimize the capturing of value by those that already have most of it from those that produce it and do not, the current situation is tantamount to legalized theft by one class from another. I don't follow that a thief can share something he stole with the person from which he stole it.
Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by ojbrien on Friday January 19, 2018 @07:51AM (#16185826)
I find the use of this statistic really frustrating, if you're say an average westerner with $10,000 of debt and $2,000 savings - your net wealth is -$8,000. If on the other hand you sift through garbage somewhere in Africa and earn 50c per day your net wealth is ~$0. By this metric the garbage site worker is wealthier than the Westerner fresh from university.
Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by barrkel on Friday January 19, 2018 @08:32AM (#16186035)
Sure; it's not counting human capital, or basically the net present value of future income streams available to someone.

In this respect, having debt is a positive sign, because banks evaluate loans based on expected ability to repay, i.e. future income streams.

Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by anfilt on Friday January 19, 2018 @07:58AM (#16185865)
Well they are more wealthier till that debt is paid off. However, the metric does not include cash flow. The westerner has a greater cash flow than the person in Africa. However, what happen if that person looses their job? Suddenly, their quality life will probably drop. They might even end homeless unable to pay rent. However, the westerner is probably better off overall.
Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by goatlover on Friday January 19, 2018 @08:45AM (#16186110)
It's all the wealth around you including the infrastructure that you can partially take advantage of that the African probably lacks.
Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by anfilt on Friday January 19, 2018 @05:12PM (#16190333)
Henceforth, why I said probably better off.
Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by ComputerGuru on Friday January 19, 2018 @08:32AM (#16186028)
Perhaps the first derivative of net wealth is a better metric?
Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by andrepd on Friday January 19, 2018 @10:09AM (#16186724)
I think the point is that there are things that aren't captured by looking at wealth alone. Having a college degree, being inserted in a society that ensures peace, safety and well-being, all that has value.
Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by ComputerGuru on Friday January 19, 2018 @01:42PM (#16188591)
> all that has value

Yes, and (ideally) currency in an economy is a liquid representation of value. A college degree translates (after accounting for inefficiencies) to higher income potential, more efficient spending, etc.

EDIT: typo, "liquid representation of value," not "wealth"

Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by barrkel on Friday January 19, 2018 @08:34AM (#16186052)
First derivative of wealth would be income or spending. I think it's better to go the other way: consider the integral of cash flows over time (i.e. net present value). It would still be pretty uncertain.
Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by ComputerGuru on Friday January 19, 2018 @01:48PM (#16188633)
Yes and no. I purposely chose the mathematical notation rather than the more common economical terms to convey a different idea.

If you look at the instantaneous\* derivative, it's not the fact that you owe the federal government $2M for that MD that counts but rather your monthly obligation. Debt doesn't matter, required repayment per unit of time does - so almost like cash-basis accounting.

Finding a $100 on the street or borrowing $100 from a friend are the same in terms of their addition to your instantaneous wealth, it's the fact that one needs to be repaid that detracts from your "actual" wealth, and the repayment period matters. Compare the lifestyle of two neighbors working at the same institution making the same amount of money that each took out $500k mortgages to buy their identical houses, only one took it out for 15 years and the other for 30. On day 1, they both take the same hit to their net worth, but that doesn't change their wealth derivative in and of itself, it's the rate of paying it back that you should be counting.

That explains why one college educated individual can get a loan for $1000 from the bank and at time 0 they are, under this metric, better off than someone that needed to hit up a payday loans place for the same loan but at a higher interest rate. They both "earned" the same amount of money, and may even "spend" it on the same thing at the same rate, but when you take the repayment period into account (let's say 1 year vs 2 weeks, respectively) you can see why the graduate student is measurably better off.

Just like stocks you hold aren't actually contributing to your day-to-day wealth (and as such aren't taxed) but it's when you cash out that you've either made or lost money.

\* let's define an "instant" as a month, just to make things easier.

Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by coolaliasbro on Saturday January 20, 2018 @10:38AM (#16193692)
> Do you know that 8 people in the world have as much wealth as 3.6 BILLION people. That inequality is STAGGERING.

This. This is the root of the issue in its entirety. As a civilized species (civilized in the sense that we "have" civilization) we should ban as a practice and ostracize those that propone the privatization of capital gains and the socialization of capital losses. Period. The figure posted by parent speaks volumes of the flaws of the currently dominant economic paradigm.

I hate to get too tangential and throw shade in a generically, but I've always felt like those of us that aspire to be millionaires, etc., are doing it wrong.

Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by desireco42 on Friday January 19, 2018 @09:32AM (#16186431)
I don't have the problem with people being rich, poor are the ones that are fairly easy to help, yet we are not doing it. And most likely not taxing the rich enough or the right way.
Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by ForRealsies on Friday January 19, 2018 @08:05AM (#16185903)
Exploiting cheap labor under the guise of free trade is a good start.
Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by aalleavitch on Friday January 19, 2018 @07:25AM (#16185678)
Our success at combating strict gender roles that kept women out of the workplace hasn't been matched with a social embrace of stay-at-home dads or other family members who don't work in order to focus on helping care for their loved ones. Unfortunately, instead we've ended up with a society where everyone is just expected to work all the time. There needs to be less stigma against people without jobs. We need to stop assuming that everything of value is always done for a profit.
Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by tonyedgecombe on Friday January 19, 2018 @08:34AM (#16186057)
I guess the market adjusts, in areas with constrained housing supply the prices rise to the level affordable by working couples, in other areas peoples material expectations rise.

In the end we have moved from women not being able to join the workforce to women not being able to not join the workforce. It doesn't seem an obvious improvement to me, although I should mention I'm not a woman.

Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by Radim on Friday January 19, 2018 @07:38AM (#16185744)
Do you mean to say "for a short-term, monetary profit"?

Because there are other types of profit, more subjective ones, like feeling good, emotional well-being, long-term sustainability etc, which are more elusive by definition but nevertheless super important.

Because if you're really talking about a lack "profit" in the very general (aka inviting a straight loss), then the question simply becomes: Who will pay for this loss, and why?

Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by aalleavitch on Friday January 19, 2018 @07:44AM (#16185784)
I think you answered this question yourself: some forms of value are subjective. Some vitally important benefits to the people around you don't show up on a balance sheet. People will gladly pay to be a patron of the arts, or just to make someone they like happy, and it doesn't have to involve a quantifiable return on investment.
Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by Radim on Friday January 19, 2018 @10:24AM (#16186871)
I get your point, you're using the word "profit" in its narrowest accounting sense.
Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by jdietrich on Friday January 19, 2018 @09:06AM (#16186235)
There's only one problem with that - it's not true. The author cites no sources for his claim and every source I've found contradicts him. The average number of hours actually worked has slightly declined in the US and significantly declined in Europe over the past few decades. In the broader historical arc, there has been a huge increase in leisure; the average working week throughout the 19th century was well in excess of 60 hours.

Although most working parents report feeling rushed, the majority say that they spend the right amount of time with their children and that parenting responsibilities do not interfere with their career advancement. College-educated whites are, by some margin, the group most likely to report difficulties in balancing work and parental responsibilities.

We might feel like we're increasingly stretched by the demands of work and home, but that perception simply isn't supported by any data I've been able to find. I'm not saying that we've perfected work-life balance, but the overarching trend is substantially positive.

https://www.ons.gov.uk/employmentandlabourmarket/peopleinwor...

http://www2.econ.iastate.edu/classes/econ320/orazem/addendum...

http://eh.net/encyclopedia/hours-of-work-in-u-s-history/

http://assets.pewresearch.org/wp-content/uploads/sites/3/201...

Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by dalbasal on Friday January 19, 2018 @11:54AM (#16187671)
Inflation measures are supposed to control for improvement in product quality & quantity so that you can represent the GDP of 1852 in 2018 dollar terms.... In 1993, a macbook pro would have been very valuable.

If you have a time machine with 20 laptops in the boot, that's enough to let you live like Biff in the almanac timeline. Does that mean anyone with a macbook is a millionaire in 1992 dollars?

This is not a solvable problem. It works ok for YoY inflation (that's the point) but, the phrase '2018 dollars' gets meaningless as we try to represent earlier years. Saying we are n% more wealthy than people in 1300, is just cheesy journalism mostly.

Anyway (long preamble, sorry)....

Just like trying to adjust inflation by 70 or 700 years is difficult, trying to account for hours worked and/leisure is difficult. Too much has changed.

Woman joined the workforce. Children left it. Work got homework added. Training became more of a leisure time activity. Commutes got longer. Lunches got longer. The first one is probably the biggest.

Btw there's an illustrative thread running through both... Childcare and elder care. These were done at home (mostly by women) as non economic activity. Now these are jobs. The generate GDP, work hours... But, children were being raised before. They are being raised now. It just didn't used to be counted as GDP/work hours.

Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by bjourne on Friday January 19, 2018 @09:59AM (#16186641)
Though we work more than farmers did 150 years ago:

http://groups.csail.mit.edu/mac/users/rauch/worktime/hours_w...

This was especially true in the Northern European countries where snow and lack of daylight would make it virtually impossible to work during the winter.

Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by lordCarbonFiber on Friday January 19, 2018 @10:19AM (#16186819)
I feel like attempting to compare modern quality of life to 19th century farmers is a fool's errand. Maybe we're working through the winter, but, as a whole it's very unlikely to kill us so I'm inclined to take that trade.
Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by chillwaves on Friday January 19, 2018 @10:48AM (#16187069)
Does this data include commute times? Those are on the rise, which may not count as work but the time cost certainly should.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2017/02/22/the-a...

I have coworkers doing 2 hours each way. A 4 hour commute each day would certainly eat into your time.

Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by baursak on Friday January 19, 2018 @10:32AM (#16186929)
From one of the links: "For example, in the CES a person working two part-time jobs of 20 hours a week is counted as having two 20-hour jobs, but in the CPS, the same individual is counted as one worker working 40 hours."

So both surveys include part time jobs, not sure how that contradicts the original point.

Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by JulianMorrison on Friday January 19, 2018 @07:32AM (#16185713)
Exactly. Right now, we aren't doing work. We are doing makework, because society won't give us the tickets to eat and have shelter without it.

My work is all the things I ought to be doing, but have to fit around the daily makework. Less of it gets done than I'd like.

Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by hycaria on Friday January 19, 2018 @08:42AM (#16186096)
I disagree.

I work a full week at one job + 2 nights per week. Feel that I do a lot of unpaid stuff (ie taking care of the household, cooking, ...) but still endlessly hear about how other people "don't have the time".

The useful non paid things that people actually do are greatly overestimated imo, because more often than not it will end up in the "don't have time for it" even though they could manage to find time for it if they really wanted to. Just a matter of priorities.

I'm far from perfect, and I don't do sports (which I also consider an useful non paid thing) for an example. Yet I wish I did, and I totally could if I had some discipline there. But it's not having more time, or less work, that would change it.

It's hard and everyone is lazy and tired, and there are so many easy ways out of the present moment, but the majority really doesn't push themselves much.

Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by psyc on Friday January 19, 2018 @11:32AM (#16187474)
I agree with you. Growing up, I never heard the end of it. How housework was a full-time job. My mother chanted "men's work is from sun to sun, women's work is never done" like a nursery rhyme, or a prayer. When I moved out, I discovered that working 40 hrs was pretty hard, but housework was a joke. Right now I probably spend around 10-12 hrs per week, max, on housework. And the overwhelming majority of that is just preparing food, which I could spend less time on if I didn't cook. And housework is easy, repetitive, and requires no thought. I mean, I can do laundry unconsciously while writing code in my head.

So since I moved out 22 years ago, my hypothesis has been that people who think housework is a full-time job are actually probably suffering from severe depression and/or anxiety.

Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by tc7 on Friday January 19, 2018 @02:11PM (#16188831)
Curious, do you have kids/family in the house? There may be a difference in the mental/physical load of "managing a household" vs "doing housework".
Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by hycaria on Friday January 19, 2018 @03:07PM (#16189320)
They can participate, way more than what we usually see (my own upbringing was too lax on this in my opinion). I wonder why parents don't make their kids part of the household.
Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by snarf21 on Friday January 19, 2018 @09:13AM (#16186283)
I agree with you that as automation takes all the jobs, child and elder care will be the work everyone shifts to. I think we should be doing more of this now. Better elder care would help keep people on their right meds and could greatly reduce healthcare costs. Better child "care" could be lots of things but will lead to healthier, smarter, more inquisitive children that will become self supporting and out of bad paths saving society more there as well.

I think one thing that people miss slightly is that some of this is our own fault. Everyone is heavy on the chase (me incl.) of things. We want full meals in a box at our door without the annoyance of doing any work for it. Some of our need for extra work and both adults working comes from our demand that we have a huge house and two new cars and two huge vacations and everyone has an iPhone X and on and on. You have to either work more or spend less and we've generally chosen work more. There is nothing intrinsically wrong with that but we need to accept the consequences.

Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by madengr on Friday January 19, 2018 @08:18AM (#16185957)
Like in Asimovs books, we’ll probably have decay without work (with robots automating it all). Humans will just do busy work.
Re:The radical idea of a world without jobs by banderman on Friday January 19, 2018 @11:25AM (#16187401)
A standard 35 hour work week could help with this.