News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by prepend on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @05:50PM (#16119886)
This is positive news. It seems like the more liberal approach taken when protocols were written is being challenged more by young users who grew up under more stable rules that accepted terms of service as very strong.

When I was growing up you went by what the protocol allowed. If an http response came back you have access, if it prompted for credentials, then you didn’t have access.

The mere idea that a web server gives you info and then you have to check a TOS that you might not even know exists is foreign to me. But when I talked with a young programmer they kind of agreed with Oracle saying “otherwise you could just request everything from every possible address.” They were unfamiliar with war drivers or even how early web crawlers started.

Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by justinjlynn on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @06:01PM (#16119959)
It's not that young people grew up with stable rules. It's that young people grew up under the influence of industrial information warfare tactics and propaganda. As someone that was prevented from distributing Linux at high school because the administrators thought that any copying was piracy (thanks to the Software Publishers Association and the friendly local Microsoft rep), this conditioning to get kids (and less intelligent adults, sadly) to believe in the supremacy of illegitimate authority has been going on for a while now. Now those kids are starting to become adults. So, of course, you're starting to see bullshit like the CFAA1986 (and it's downright laughably broad definition of a 'protected computer') and the DMCA (likewise) starting to be abused like they are. The "don't copy that floppy" music video was the thin edge of a wedge that continues being driven into the heads of kids and adults alike, even today.
Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by busterarm on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @07:56PM (#16120594)
It might be that...

I also like to think that young people just don't really understand the full picture of how all of this actually works...they just think they do and that google/SO/wikipedia contains the answers they they don't have to know.

Our abstraction layers are that good. You can write code in a framework, ship and make millions and suddenly you're a tech genius!

In fairness to them though, when I was starting out 20 years ago, if you could sling a few lines of HTML and make things appear in a browser, people certainly treated you like one.

Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by taneq on Thursday January 11, 2018 @08:28AM (#16123639)
It's always been this way (at least, since the start of the 70s, according to my mother). Those who are capable of reading the user manual (or documentation, or stackoverflow, or...) will be regarded with superstitious awe by those who are not.
Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by Stranger43 on Thursday January 11, 2018 @01:37AM (#16121856)
It's not just propaganda it's also an effect of formal vocational training being focused on teaching people procedures for doing a task rather then forcing them to learn by having to recover from failures the way most self taught people were, and lets not forget that doing the boom years practically everyone was self taught in an environment that haven't yet developed teachable procedures yet.

I don't think that it's as much a generation thing that is it a consequence of IT having grown to the point where it is no longer it's own semi-anarchic subculture.

Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by pwaai on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @07:32PM (#16120460)
> As someone that was prevented from distributing Linux at high school because the administrators thought that any copying was piracy

I remember having this discussion with in HS and also at work with people who were convinced pirating a PSX game is same as stealing, while not realizing there is no evidence that suggests a pirated copy means a lost sale (people can't afford it in places like Brasil where they still play Sega Genesis).

The level of brainwashing of my generation is appalling, but I'm glad people like us realize the ridiculousness of claims like downloading an mp3 is stealing from an artist (they clearly have no idea how much the industry leeches off the artist in first place).

Also, now that I've monies I ended up buying most of the games I use to play as a kid on a mod chip, and warez sites on Steam and the dreaded Playstation Store.

2018 is off to a good start.

Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by jeremy_wiebe on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @09:03PM (#16120927)
Equating “fair use” of a website to pirating software is a stretch. In the first case the method of access is at issue (not whether you can or not). In the second the company has not given you any _legal_ right to access.

I don’t see how affordability (or lack of it) is justification to the game.

Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by pwaai on Thursday January 11, 2018 @01:12AM (#16121762)
Stealing would mean the loss of property, but there are infinite copies of the digital good. Users for the most part do not read EULA agreements or Terms of Service of a website, the expectation is on the software company's side, it's not a a crime unless there is proof of damage (selling it for profit) from either copying that floppy disk or scraping a public website so hard you interfere with their operations.

So basically if you are poor, you deserve not to gain from the same things rich people can, even when no loss of property or damage occurs by having someone who can't afford it in the first place be your loyal fan. This doesn't apply in cases where there is explicit loss of property and damage that occurs as a result.

Mozart also got his ass arrested because he transcribed music he liked onto a medium which he was not authorized to do so. But we all know how ridiculous that was.

Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by davchana on Thursday January 11, 2018 @10:30AM (#16124539)
> Mozart...

I am interested, and I googled Mozart arrested, Mozart arrested for Copyright, Mozart arrested for Music, but couldn't find anything, could you please post a link/story about Mozart getting arrested?

Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by taserian on Thursday January 11, 2018 @11:20AM (#16125090)
Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by indemnity on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @09:51PM (#16121105)
Interesting... In my high school (third world country), buying software at US prices simply wasn’t an option for local incomes, while we were hungry to learn and use the software (especially compilers).

Even the teachers copied software for us onto floppies that we’d “borrow” like library books.

Everyone pirated. Interestingly though most switched to Linux early on too.

And most of the members of our warez distribution BBS/IRC channels went on to great careers in technology, some becoming leading lights of the local and SV VC scene ;)

I think some of the early healthy disrespect for authority may have had a part in fostering our risk taking, questioning mindsets!

Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by kbos87 on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @10:27PM (#16121222)
A pirated copy doesn’t need to equate to a lost sale in order for it to be stealing. You took something of value that was created or owned by someone else. Whether it’s a physical or nonphysical good is completely beside the point.
Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by aidenn0 on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @11:17PM (#16121358)
English is certainly imprecise, but I would claim that if I commit some act X, and you have no less property than if I had not committed act X, then whatever else we can say about act X, I fell confident that it is not stealing.
Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by tedunangst on Thursday January 11, 2018 @02:22AM (#16122041)
And yet people get all worked up about "stolen" passwords. I still have my password. What's the problem?
Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by executesorder66 on Thursday January 11, 2018 @03:41AM (#16122303)
> "stolen" passwords

That's also wrong. What actually happened is that a database of password hashes was _copied_ not stolen. So yes your password wasn't stolen.

The problem is a security/privacy problem. If someone made a copy of your house keys, that's a problem, because now they can enter your house. But they didn't steal your keys, they copied them. Same with the password. They didn't steal your password, but they have a copy, so they can use it to log into your accounts.

Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by aidenn0 on Thursday January 11, 2018 @02:34PM (#16127030)
Identity "theft" is also one of those confusing terms. We already have a word for it: impersonation.

Though in fact sometimes things can be stolen via identity theft; in particular if someone abuses your credit it can deny you future credit, so they have stolen the good-will or trust of creditors in that case. This would be an example of an intangible good being stolen.

Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by jstanley on Thursday January 11, 2018 @01:09AM (#16121746)
> You took something of value that was created or owned by someone else.

A person who creates or owns a piece of information still has it after you "steal" it. That's the difference between a physical and a nonphysical good.

(I'm not saying distributing copies of copyrighted works is automatically OK, just that your justification for it not being OK doesn't hold water).

Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by andrewaylett on Thursday January 11, 2018 @08:25AM (#16123615)
Theft -- in UK law -- is the intentional taking of someone's property with the intent to deprive the owner of it permanently.

That's why there's a specific offence of "Taking Without Owner's Consent" when you steal a car to joyride in (and crash and burn, rather than sell on): otherwise it's too easy to claim you only "borrowed" the car and intended to give it back, at which point it's not a crime any more.

Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by asfdsfggtfd on Thursday January 11, 2018 @02:46AM (#16122120)
Look it's not stealing - stealing is a concept related to physical goods.

That doesn't mean that it is right. Piracy is still wrong even though it is not stealing.

And the GP seems morally confused. Sharing FLOSS software is very very different morally to pirating games.

Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by WillReplyfFood on Thursday January 11, 2018 @11:32AM (#16125187)
If i look at the effects of piracy - which is a humanity happy and busy without environmental damage, and the damage which is one guy not getting to buy his third yacht- yes, thats a good trade. Its also one of the reasons why most governments of this world are in so lackluster pursuit of piracy.

Why would one want to take away the opium from the masses?

Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by pharrington on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @11:36PM (#16121427)
Are you asserting that the salient moral property of theft isn't a party removing a thing from another party, but rather a party gaining a thing made by someone else?
Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by pwaai on Thursday January 11, 2018 @01:29AM (#16121829)
Unfortunately, this is what people who claim piracy is evil thinks.

You obviously can't afford Final Fantasy 7 or Megaman Legends so by deriving pleasure from an unauthorized copy, you are a thief and lacking in moral fiber Sir!

Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by executesorder66 on Thursday January 11, 2018 @01:35AM (#16121850)
> You took something of value that was created or owned by someone else.

Really? So they no longer have it, because I took theirs?

Or, do they still have their copy, and I have mine, and I didn't take anything that was owned by them?

If I make an exact copy of your car and drive off in it, are you gonna complain that I stole your car?

Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by prepend on Thursday January 11, 2018 @06:56PM (#16129217)
They may not even know that you have it. So it’s like giving money a natural right and enforcing it.

A very odd mindset, but one I encounter frequently.

They did this class in my kid’s 5th grade where someone came in and said making tapes was illegal. And asked about parents who copied stuff. I was so pissed but the school got a tv or DVD player or something stupid.

Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by prepend on Thursday January 11, 2018 @05:34PM (#16128709)
This is an interesting philosophical point that I think needs to be debated and established in law. Stealing is based on natural law of depriving someone of a thing.

If I make a copy you may value that, but the copy doesn’t deprive you of anything. What if you whistle a tune and I think about it? I’ve deprived you of value you by paying nothing but thinking of your whistled tune over and over.

I don’t think it’s an accepted truth that just because someone creates something that they must be compensated. Especially if it costs money for society to enforce.

There’s tons of these mental exercises. If I add a TOS to this comment saying it’s worth $1k and by reading, you must pay; do you owe? Did you steal my value without my consent?

That’s why stealing is based on clear harm through depriving of property. And fair use was established to allow reasonable noncommercial use.

My biggest complaint is that IP maximalism is not something society as a whole agreed to. It seems that IP holders just decided for society.

Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by wu-ikkyu on Thursday January 11, 2018 @10:20AM (#16124387)
>You took something of value that was created or owned by someone else.

By this definition every website you visit on the internet that you did not create yourself is stealing.

Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by WillReplyfFood on Thursday January 11, 2018 @07:27AM (#16123230)
How dare him aquiring the same opportunitys and destroying the economic protectinon ring you errected around your kids.
Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by analognoise on Thursday January 11, 2018 @01:52AM (#16121920)
#this I can't believe people here don't think it's piracy or stealing, just because it doesn't deprive someone else of their object (as in the case of a physical good).

If I took your journal entries from your room, and copied them all, and put them on the internet - that's not stealing, because I returned the journal? No, that's still theft.

If someone stole bread, how would you feel about It? Screw that person right? What if they were stealing the bread from someone who would never notice the loss, and it was for their hungry kids? Suddenly it seems more reasonable.

So both of these examples show (pretty goddamn clearly) that the whole "it isn't depriving the original owner of a physical item" thing is total, and absolute, hogwash. Clearly that point is totally irrelevant to ownership.

Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by Endy on Thursday January 11, 2018 @04:26AM (#16122489)
> If I took your journal entries from your room, and copied them all, and put them on the internet - that's not stealing, because I returned the journal? No, that's still theft.

No, that's merely duplication and proliferation of media and information into the public domain; information wants to be free & media calls for an audience. The sole concern at that point would be how you gained access to the media - did you cause any provable harm? In other words, let's say you're my friend. You come in to my room, I leave my journal entries open and you surreptitiously copy them while I'm getting coffee for us. You leave the journal undamaged and make your duplicates public. The only harm you did was cause me to not trust you personally and no longer allow you in my home. If, on the other hand, you broke into my home, causing real physical damage in some way, as well as making me fear for my own personal wellbeing, then yes, you have provably harmed me in a legally actionable way.

In either case, nothing was stolen. Emotional and in the latter case physical damages were done because you have duplicated personal information without my consent. A piece of released or published software is decidedly not personal information. In fact, the number of abstraction layers between a user and the creator(s) of a game usually mean that pirated copies cause no emotional harm whatsoever to the author(s).

> If someone stole bread, how would you feel about It? Screw that person right? What if they were stealing the bread from someone who would never notice the loss, and it was for their hungry kids? Suddenly it seems more reasonable.

If you are depriving someone of a basic foodstuff, and their only means of procurement and providence is legally labelled as theft, then you are perpetrating an unjust society. That's my opinion on that.

Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by analognoise on Thursday January 11, 2018 @09:39AM (#16124101)
>information wants to be free & media calls for an audience

That's a nice bumper sticker, but also a bunch of shit.

So the nudes you take with your wife, demand to be free and an audience? The photos of your children in the tub demand to be free, and an...audience? Reality doesn't fit on a bumper sticker.

"If you are depriving someone of a basic foodstuff, and their only means of procurement and providence is legally labelled as theft, then you are perpetrating an unjust society."

Oh right, so every society that's ever existed. Gotcha. Glad that doesn't happen on whatever planet you live on.

Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by Endy on Thursday January 11, 2018 @01:51PM (#16126602)
> So the nudes you take with your wife, demand to be free and an audience? The photos of your children in the tub demand to be free, and an...audience? Reality doesn't fit on a bumper sticker.

If I have them stored via digital media and don't provide it with significant forms of security, then yes - and it's my own shame if something "goes wrong". Besides, why would I take pictures or video of that if I wasn't going to look at them later? That's part of why I never got up in arms about the Apple photo breach; people stored images on a remote server whose security they were unable to monitor.

> Oh right, so every society that's ever existed. Gotcha. Glad that doesn't happen on whatever planet you live on.

Never said there's been a just society so far.

Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by Mindwipe on Thursday January 11, 2018 @06:01AM (#16122876)
> In other words, let's say you're my friend. You come in to my room, I leave my journal entries open and you surreptitiously copy them while I'm getting coffee for us. You leave the journal undamaged and make your duplicates public. The only harm you did was cause me to not trust you personally and no longer allow you in my home.

That's not even remotely true (incidentally this would be illegal in the UK and a court would grant an injunction on publication under breach of confidence, precisely because it's such a shitty thing to do https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Breach_of_confidence_in_Englis...).

Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by asfdsfggtfd on Thursday January 11, 2018 @07:59AM (#16123403)
> That's not even remotely true (incidentally this would be illegal in the UK and a court would grant an injunction on publication under breach of confidence, precisely because it's such a shitty thing to do https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Breach_of_confidence_in_Englis...).

Yes but they would not charge you with theft. Which includes "the intention to permanently deprive"...

Copying someone's private data is not theft. That doesn't mean that it is morally or legally OK (it's not - it's another crime). It just means that theft is a specific crime based on taking fungible chattel with the intent to not give it back.

Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by analognoise on Thursday January 11, 2018 @09:27AM (#16124016)
So you narrowly redefine theft to not include intellectual property or any non-physical good.

IANAL - but I don't think this would fly in any jurisdiction anywhere. Is this definition specific to a country whose laws I'm not familiar with?

Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by dragonwriter on Thursday January 11, 2018 @09:31AM (#16124054)
> So you narrowly redefine theft to not include intellectual property or any non-physical good.

Theft in law generally only applies to tangible personal property, not intangible personally property and not real property. That's not a redefinition, just the long-existigng definition.

Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by analognoise on Thursday January 11, 2018 @09:41AM (#16124112)
Did you plug "intellectual property theft" into Google before you came to this conclusion?
Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by prepend on Thursday January 11, 2018 @06:59PM (#16129231)
Try it and look at laws vs non-laws.
Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by asfdsfggtfd on Monday January 15, 2018 @03:01AM (#16149229)
No I apply the actual definition of theft....

I never said that copyright infringement or copying and publishing personal data is OK morally or legally. I just said that they are different crimes.

Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by pharrington on Thursday January 11, 2018 @04:28AM (#16122507)
"If I took your journal entries from your room, and copied them all, and put them on the internet - that's not stealing, because I returned the journal? No, that's still theft."

Yes, the original taking of the journal is literally depriving someone else of their object. A future return of the object clearly does not mean the original deprivation never happened. The point you're making about unauthorized distribution of private thoughts is about violation of privacy. Violating a person's privacy certainly is a bad thing. Theft is a different bad thing. (The analogy you're looking for is copying someone's paywalled blog)

"If someone stole bread, how would you feel about It? Screw that person right? What if they were stealing the bread from someone who would never notice the loss, and it was for their hungry kids? Suddenly it seems more reasonable."

You're trying to move the goalposts by conflating the literal deprivation of objects with copying information that all parties are trying to proliferate. The emotional appeal, besides not being as agreeable as you think, has nothing to do with the issue. A plentiful, though limited resource is just that. (Yes, one of the many reasons theft is bad is because it invariably angers the thieved and violates their sense of justice - the difference in argument is postulating the emotional impact of an action vs instructing the reader to feel a certain emotion).

Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by analognoise on Thursday January 11, 2018 @09:50AM (#16124153)
My arguments are based on ownership - you didn't create the (game, book, journal entries, code, artistic item, music, whatever), but somehow because you've decided to take advantage of content creators by belittling their ownership to declare theft a victimless crime.

Also, people are convinced by arguments they have an emotional connection to - not postulates. You're always instructing the reader how to feel - if the reader can't see what you're doing, and still consider your argument, they're uneducated. That's no sleight against them - as it is massively effective, and it is not permanent. Look at the last US election.

Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by pharrington on Thursday January 11, 2018 @02:31PM (#16127001)
If you're going to reply to a comment, reply to the words written. My comment doesn't describe anything as victimless crimes.

I have a rough understanding of human persuasion and decision making. Persuasion is not my goal. I am trying to engage with other people, read their knowledge and opinions, compare those to what I understand about reality, express my understanding, and when there are inconsistencies, attempt resolving them with some combination of verification of facts and revealing of core principles. Often times, this leads to me realize I had an incorrect thought about something, so I update my understanding of the world accordingly.

Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by untog on Thursday January 11, 2018 @12:25AM (#16121580)
Piracy isn't stealing... and besides, no one can afford the games anyway... besides, you should see what the industry does to the artists in the first place...

The gentleman doth protest too much?

Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by kaspiCZ on Thursday January 11, 2018 @01:45AM (#16121887)
Let's try to flip the perspectives. Let's say you created a game. Let's pretend you want to make money off of it, because you put quite some time into it. Time you could have used to make money by other means.

How would you go about it?

Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by Asooka on Thursday January 11, 2018 @04:49AM (#16122591)
I know why people pirate, having pirated a lot of software and games in my time, so I won't really feel bad about it. Most people will buy the game if they can, but the world economics are such that for 90% of your potential user base, 60$ represent an insurmountable financial investment. Which is partly why Steam with its frequent discounts and region-specific pricing is so effective at combating piracy.

So yeah, if I wanted to make money with games, I wouldn't. But if I really really wanted to, I would try to get popular, then start a kickstarter and open a patreon. Make sure people can support my art with as little as they can.

As just one example - consider game rentals. Consoles have incredibly low piracy rates, but a healthy (or at least used to be) game rental scene. If someone can only give me 5$ for my game, why should I snub that money? There's probably a million such people across South America alone. I don't see why I would spend time and energy trying to get money out of people who don't value my product instead of finding ways to let everyone who likes my product to support me.

Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by Mindwipe on Thursday January 11, 2018 @05:56AM (#16122851)
> Most people will buy the game if they can, but the world economics are such that for 90% of your potential user base, 60$ represent an insurmountable financial investment.

Bulllllllshiiiiiiiiit.

> As just one example - consider game rentals. Consoles have incredibly low piracy rates, but a healthy (or at least used to be) game rental scene. If someone can only give me 5$ for my game, why should I snub that money?

There's no game rental scene. Like zero. And consoles have incredibly low piracy rates because they have very effective DRM and closed platforms, which a certain contingent of Hacker News likes to pretend is the cause of piracy.

Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by Dudenoso on Thursday January 11, 2018 @06:21AM (#16122943)
>Most people will buy the game if they can, but the world economics are such that for 90% of your potential user base, 60$ represent an insurmountable financial investment. >Bulllllllshiiiiiiiiit. The third world is numerically bigger than the first world. 60$ is a lot for places without a strong currency. Have you ever lived in a third world country with a wage that wasn't above the richest 5%?

Yeah, I'm a long time lurker and created an account just for that.

Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by pennaMan on Thursday January 11, 2018 @06:04AM (#16122892)
Back when I was a teen 60$ was about 25% of my household income.

Since then and present day I still don't know a single console owning person that has not hardware modded it to work with pirated games.

Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by davchana on Thursday January 11, 2018 @12:12PM (#16125561)
$60 in my local currency Indian Rupees is about ₹3800, my one person, single's monthly food groceries bill.
Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by tedunangst on Thursday January 11, 2018 @02:20AM (#16122026)
I'd put my Twitter handle in the game to build a following so even more people download my next free game. Make it up in volume.
Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by asfdsfggtfd on Thursday January 11, 2018 @02:43AM (#16122110)
∞ × 0 = 0
Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by thaumasiotes on Thursday January 11, 2018 @03:25PM (#16127484)
∞ × 0 is one of the most bog-standard indeterminate forms, not 0.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indeterminate_form

Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by xrisk on Thursday January 11, 2018 @06:17AM (#16122931)
No that's just ill-defined.
Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by Mindwipe on Thursday January 11, 2018 @05:53AM (#16122838)
I think that's the joke, but yes.
Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by clarry on Thursday January 11, 2018 @03:22AM (#16122237)
> Let's try to flip the perspectives. Let's say you created a game. Let's pretend you want to make money off of it

I wouldn't have gone that far because I'm smart enough to tell that making money with a game is pretty damn hard (and it has nothing to do with piracy).

But if I had done stupid anyway, I would blame myself.

I could "want to make money" off of my turd too, and put hard effort into it, that doesn't mean I'm entitled to success.

Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by otakucode on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @06:51PM (#16120234)
I don't think that it warrants a name so grand-sounding as 'industrial information warfare tactics and propaganda'. I don't even believe it was done entirely intentionally. When I was going to school in the 90s, schools were locking down more and more each year. Eventually, that produced Columbine and several other school shootings, intensifying their efforts (they were blind to the fact that they were the cause). Eventually they reached a fairly steady state of today, where learned helplessness is inflicted either before or early in adolescence, resulting in things like a 40% drop in the number of 16 year olds who have a drivers license between 2005 and 2015, many fewer adolescents having jobs during school, etc.

Why try, if you are going to be surveilled and get your hand slapped at the slightest violation, and have every rough spot or sharp corner sanded down off of your personality. If you don't want to get classified as a threat and separated and sent to remediation therapy and special schooling and things like that, that is. In the name of security, the teachers derision for the weird kids was given sharp teeth, eventually perfected. The tunnel vision that develops during schooling, the one that leads kids to kill themselves or each other over simple school problems because they can't even see themselves as human beings with a life outside of the school environment, extends further now, well into college, and perhaps soon far beyond.

Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by wutangson1 on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @08:04PM (#16120635)
wow, so if you believe there is systemic 'infliction of learned helplessness' on pre-adolescent children, then it does warrant a 'grand-sounding name'.
[dead]
Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by pjc50 on Thursday January 11, 2018 @07:11AM (#16123152)
Young people certainly have grown up with anti-abortion and anti-homosexuality propaganda, gradually shaking it off as it was revealed to be made of fear and nonsense.
Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by saurik on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @06:47PM (#16120217)
I continue to be shocked that Twitter convinced an entire generation of software developers that you need to obtain something called an "API key"--which can somehow be refused or even revoked once granted--in order to write a client for their protocol. "Back in my day", we just reverse engineered the official client and used whatever algorithm it used to talk to the server and called the war won :/.
Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by nothrabannosir on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @07:12PM (#16120339)
It should be illegal for companies like Twitter to forbid this. Users should be free to access their data, and free to use any tool to do so. The revered network effect is anti consumer and it must be broken.

This is the one regulation that could save a nation from FB, Twitter, Instagram and their ilk. Any politician to run on this could shoot somebody in the middle of a crowded street without losing my support.

Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by tomsmeding on Thursday January 11, 2018 @03:13AM (#16122204)
> Any politician to run on this could shoot somebody in the middle of a crowded street without losing my support.

That might be a bit overdone, but I get your point.

Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by nerflad on Thursday January 11, 2018 @10:04AM (#16124255)
It's a reference to a statement the current president made during his campaign.
Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by Endy on Thursday January 11, 2018 @04:29AM (#16122513)
I'd say it entirely depends on who they're shooting.
Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by RepressedEmu on Thursday January 11, 2018 @10:22AM (#16124424)
Its an (in)famous Trump line.
Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by alphaalpha101 on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @11:58PM (#16121492)
The one regulation that could save a nation from FB, Twitter and Instagram is to ban advertising. All of it. Ban all advertising anywhere for any reason.
Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by gregknicholson on Thursday January 11, 2018 @05:34AM (#16122766)
You may not advertise this proposed regulation.
Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by zaptheimpaler on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @07:35PM (#16120476)
I dunno about that.. controlling access to your server is much more important today because tech is ubiquitous, and a big target for bad actors. In the old days very few people would know enough and care enough to reverse engineer your protocol.. when a service has billions of users and valuable data, that changes.

If Twitter did not have an API key, they would spend 2x the money on absorbing & defending against DDoSes and security vulnerabilities. That cost would get passed on to us with frequent outages and many more ads in our feeds. Or a leak of someones DMs.

Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by benchaney on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @09:12PM (#16120958)
> If Twitter did not have an API key, they would spend 2x the money on absorbing & defending against DDoSes and security vulnerabilities. That cost would get passed on to us with frequent outages and many more ads in our feeds. Or a leak of someones DMs.

This is complete nonsense. Attackers aren't going to follow your TOS, so what possible benefit could asking your users to do it on little more than the honor system provide?

Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by a_t48 on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @10:45PM (#16121264)
Stopping a DOS is easier if you can tie whatever expensive operations that are happening to a single user.
Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by benchaney on Thursday January 11, 2018 @12:35AM (#16121626)
Except you can't actually figure out which user it is.
Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by rpedela on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @11:23PM (#16121378)
API key != TOS
Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by benchaney on Thursday January 11, 2018 @12:34AM (#16121624)
The TOS is the reason that people use API keys instead of just reverse engineering the protocol (which is what an attacker will do).
Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by rypskar on Thursday January 11, 2018 @02:29AM (#16122068)
No, CSFR tokens, validating API keys, restricting the origin of request, etc is how to restrict access to the API. TOS is only text to keep the honest honest, the security layer is to keep the attackers and others without access out. A TOS is the web-site telling how it want you to behave, and all it can do if you don't behave that way is to do its best to not let you in. Nothing of this stops you from trying to reverse engineer the protocol.

The best part with using an API is that, at least in theory, it is stable and will not have changes that breaks your integration with it

Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by Sniffnoy on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @07:09PM (#16120314)
Is this system of "API keys" why Pidgin doesn't handle all these new IM protocols, and why there's no other good old-fashioned multi-protocol clients for them (that I'm aware of)?
Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by keldaris on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @07:50PM (#16120555)
Because reverse engineering some IM protocols is far from trivial. Skype, in particular, is a nightmare of obfuscation, as I understand (second hand knowledge from having wanted to replace it with Pidgin in the past, I haven't tried reverse engineering it myself).
Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by Sniffnoy on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @07:57PM (#16120600)
Skype I know is infamously hard, but I'm wondering about the more general case -- are the problems there similar to the problems with Skype, or are they due to something else?
Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by keldaris on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @08:50PM (#16120885)
As far as I know, they're a combination of it being hard work and there just not being enough of a qualified developer community around Pidgin etc. to put in the effort required. I think people generally underestimate the sheer amount of work involved in reverse engineering an IM protocol, even one that's not particularly well obfuscated.
Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by Sniffnoy on Thursday January 11, 2018 @12:27AM (#16121595)
But what about other projects? Back in the day there were multiple multi-protocol clients. Pidgin (or rather Gaim back then), Trillian, and others; now there's... maybe Franz, as cosmie mentions? Simply saying "Pidgin kind of died off" doesn't seem like enough of an explanation here; why aren't there more such projects popping up?
Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by user5994461 on Thursday January 11, 2018 @03:27AM (#16122249)
They never worked properly. It takes years to develop and it's broken anytime the owner will change anything in their implementation.

Even if you had the ultimate multi chat clients, noone cares about it. People use the official client that works just fine.

Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by quotemstr on Thursday January 11, 2018 @03:29AM (#16122255)
And you've hit the nail on the head: there's just a lot less _demand_ for multi-protocol clients these days. Official clients are much better than they were in the 1990s. Like piracy: undesired use of a protocol is a service problem, one that modern IM clients are actually addressing.
Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by jopsen on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @10:52PM (#16121283)
Back in the day when protocols ran over HTTP it was also a lot easier for amateurs to pick up wireshark.

But if we know that the company is going to respond by changing the protocol. Then who wants to spend time reverse engineering it?

Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by Sniffnoy on Thursday January 11, 2018 @12:19AM (#16121550)
That hardly seems like much of an explanation. Look at the old protocols Pidgin and other clients of the time (e.g. Trillian) spoke -- AOL, MSN, Yahoo... those didn't run over HTTP. More importantly, the companies did respond by changing the protocols; the client-writers kept up all the same. So that's not something that's different between then and now.
Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by cosmie on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @08:26PM (#16120764)
Franz[1] is the closest thing I’ve found to a client around newer IM protocols.

[1] https://meetfranz.com/

Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by gsich on Thursday January 11, 2018 @02:05AM (#16121974)
Includes a Monero miner.
Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by cosmie on Thursday January 11, 2018 @02:52AM (#16122137)
Interesting. I hadn't realized that before. In the Windows version, there's no reference to it anywhere. And I no longer have a Mac to check that out (although it did trigger the dedicated GPU in the MBP, I attributed that to the FB Messenger plugin).

In looking for references to the miner, people seem to mention Rambox[1] as an alternative. I can't say much about that as I just came across it, but it looks promising as well.

[1] http://rambox.pro/

Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by Sniffnoy on Thursday January 11, 2018 @12:20AM (#16121557)
Huh, interesting. Its website isn't very informative though. I can't find a list of protocols, annoyingly.
Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by cosmie on Thursday January 11, 2018 @01:34AM (#16121845)
It has a plugin architecture. Most of the core services it supports are listed in the Franz Plugin repo[1]. Note that it's not just about IM protocols, but rather a one-stop messaging app in general (so supports things like Gmail). And there are quite a few third-party plugins floating around, as well. And a good number that haven't been ported from Franz 4 to Franz 5.

[1] https://github.com/meetfranz/plugins#example-recipes

Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by quotemstr on Thursday January 11, 2018 @03:21AM (#16122233)
Huh? Based on the code, it looks like this thing just embeds stock web clients in some kind of webview and uses a little bit of JS injection to extract message counts. It's nowhere close to actually reverse engineering any protocol.
Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by quotemstr on Thursday January 11, 2018 @03:23AM (#16122239)
Right. I've definitely noticed a certain technical meekness lately, and honestly, I'm worried that it's connected to the broader cultural trend toward deference to authorities. Break some rules!
Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by lovich on Thursday January 11, 2018 @09:29AM (#16124035)
In the past you could break rules on the internet and people would treat it as a joke or cool implementation of a technique at best and annoyance at worst. Now if you break those rules the system breaks you.

It's not meekness so much as the economics have changed and breaking rules isn't worth it for as many people anymore

Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by downandout on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @11:12PM (#16121343)
I write bots for various purposes all the time. For the exact reasons you mention, I rarely bother even looking at APIs anymore and go straight to mimicking HTTP headers from a web browser for the functions I need.
Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by matte_black on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @09:53PM (#16121117)
It's still common to reverse engineer clients. Unless you're planning to build a legit business and can't have the liability, there is no reason to not use private APIs.
Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by prepend on Thursday January 11, 2018 @07:04PM (#16129270)
It’s quite lame. Think about how there aren’t even Facebook 3rd party clients and they actively block any scraping. Google also isn’t developer friendly for using the stuff they don’t want you to. Few APIs to their sites.

These companies are pretty different than the old school put up an api.

If DNS was designed by Facebook or google it would make a dedicated client and refuse some people who used too much.

It seems the war of protocol vs systems is going poorly for protocols.

Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by eugenekolo2 on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @06:36PM (#16120162)
I don't think it has anything to do w/ age. I believe that most people just see rules and laws as very firm, and unquestionable.
Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by askvictor on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @08:52PM (#16120890)
What does young/old have anything to do with this? If anything, I'd put it the other way around: I'll bet it's primarily old and conservative people (who don't know how the internet thing operates and want to police digital assets like physical ones) who push for this kind of restriction/law, while so many young people have grown up in an era where they share everything.
Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by Asooka on Thursday January 11, 2018 @05:06AM (#16122655)
Maybe web servers should come with a TOS that outlines that you can't control access to content via freeform text, but must do so via the technical access control means supported by the server itself.
Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by joatmon-snoo on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @09:49PM (#16121097)
> But when I talked with a young programmer they kind of agreed with Oracle saying “otherwise you could just request everything from every possible address.”

Generally n = 1 is not a good sample size.

Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by lurr on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @08:04PM (#16120637)
yes, we young people are a completely uniform group. Thanks.
Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by trisimix on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @09:40PM (#16121071)
Dude most young people pirate like, everything.
Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by matt4077 on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @08:47PM (#16120875)
Or, maybe, this young generation grew up with the internet being a tool with actual power. Where before, it was pure novelty, with no real-world consequences of destructive behaviour.

This young generation, based on a study of history, prefers to be governed by agreed-upon rules, rather than "might is right".

Note that I, and probably the vast majority of every generation, agree with this court's decision that ToS are not enforceable.

But the reason is not the challenge to enforce such ToS through technical means. It is the fundamental unfairness of a process that would allow such one-sided contracts to be drawn.

As a counter-example: your philosophy of "I can do whatever I can do" would allow limitless collection, use, and sale of personal information. But I would hope that most people actually do see value in Facebook not being allowed to sell your private images and messages to the highest bidder if they ever choose to.