News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by analognoise on Thursday January 11, 2018 @01:52AM (#16121920)
#this I can't believe people here don't think it's piracy or stealing, just because it doesn't deprive someone else of their object (as in the case of a physical good).

If I took your journal entries from your room, and copied them all, and put them on the internet - that's not stealing, because I returned the journal? No, that's still theft.

If someone stole bread, how would you feel about It? Screw that person right? What if they were stealing the bread from someone who would never notice the loss, and it was for their hungry kids? Suddenly it seems more reasonable.

So both of these examples show (pretty goddamn clearly) that the whole "it isn't depriving the original owner of a physical item" thing is total, and absolute, hogwash. Clearly that point is totally irrelevant to ownership.

Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by Endy on Thursday January 11, 2018 @04:26AM (#16122489)
> If I took your journal entries from your room, and copied them all, and put them on the internet - that's not stealing, because I returned the journal? No, that's still theft.

No, that's merely duplication and proliferation of media and information into the public domain; information wants to be free & media calls for an audience. The sole concern at that point would be how you gained access to the media - did you cause any provable harm? In other words, let's say you're my friend. You come in to my room, I leave my journal entries open and you surreptitiously copy them while I'm getting coffee for us. You leave the journal undamaged and make your duplicates public. The only harm you did was cause me to not trust you personally and no longer allow you in my home. If, on the other hand, you broke into my home, causing real physical damage in some way, as well as making me fear for my own personal wellbeing, then yes, you have provably harmed me in a legally actionable way.

In either case, nothing was stolen. Emotional and in the latter case physical damages were done because you have duplicated personal information without my consent. A piece of released or published software is decidedly not personal information. In fact, the number of abstraction layers between a user and the creator(s) of a game usually mean that pirated copies cause no emotional harm whatsoever to the author(s).

> If someone stole bread, how would you feel about It? Screw that person right? What if they were stealing the bread from someone who would never notice the loss, and it was for their hungry kids? Suddenly it seems more reasonable.

If you are depriving someone of a basic foodstuff, and their only means of procurement and providence is legally labelled as theft, then you are perpetrating an unjust society. That's my opinion on that.

Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by analognoise on Thursday January 11, 2018 @09:39AM (#16124101)
>information wants to be free & media calls for an audience

That's a nice bumper sticker, but also a bunch of shit.

So the nudes you take with your wife, demand to be free and an audience? The photos of your children in the tub demand to be free, and an...audience? Reality doesn't fit on a bumper sticker.

"If you are depriving someone of a basic foodstuff, and their only means of procurement and providence is legally labelled as theft, then you are perpetrating an unjust society."

Oh right, so every society that's ever existed. Gotcha. Glad that doesn't happen on whatever planet you live on.

Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by Endy on Thursday January 11, 2018 @01:51PM (#16126602)
> So the nudes you take with your wife, demand to be free and an audience? The photos of your children in the tub demand to be free, and an...audience? Reality doesn't fit on a bumper sticker.

If I have them stored via digital media and don't provide it with significant forms of security, then yes - and it's my own shame if something "goes wrong". Besides, why would I take pictures or video of that if I wasn't going to look at them later? That's part of why I never got up in arms about the Apple photo breach; people stored images on a remote server whose security they were unable to monitor.

> Oh right, so every society that's ever existed. Gotcha. Glad that doesn't happen on whatever planet you live on.

Never said there's been a just society so far.

Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by Mindwipe on Thursday January 11, 2018 @06:01AM (#16122876)
> In other words, let's say you're my friend. You come in to my room, I leave my journal entries open and you surreptitiously copy them while I'm getting coffee for us. You leave the journal undamaged and make your duplicates public. The only harm you did was cause me to not trust you personally and no longer allow you in my home.

That's not even remotely true (incidentally this would be illegal in the UK and a court would grant an injunction on publication under breach of confidence, precisely because it's such a shitty thing to do https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Breach_of_confidence_in_Englis...).

Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by asfdsfggtfd on Thursday January 11, 2018 @07:59AM (#16123403)
> That's not even remotely true (incidentally this would be illegal in the UK and a court would grant an injunction on publication under breach of confidence, precisely because it's such a shitty thing to do https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Breach_of_confidence_in_Englis...).

Yes but they would not charge you with theft. Which includes "the intention to permanently deprive"...

Copying someone's private data is not theft. That doesn't mean that it is morally or legally OK (it's not - it's another crime). It just means that theft is a specific crime based on taking fungible chattel with the intent to not give it back.

Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by analognoise on Thursday January 11, 2018 @09:27AM (#16124016)
So you narrowly redefine theft to not include intellectual property or any non-physical good.

IANAL - but I don't think this would fly in any jurisdiction anywhere. Is this definition specific to a country whose laws I'm not familiar with?

Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by dragonwriter on Thursday January 11, 2018 @09:31AM (#16124054)
> So you narrowly redefine theft to not include intellectual property or any non-physical good.

Theft in law generally only applies to tangible personal property, not intangible personally property and not real property. That's not a redefinition, just the long-existigng definition.

Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by analognoise on Thursday January 11, 2018 @09:41AM (#16124112)
Did you plug "intellectual property theft" into Google before you came to this conclusion?
Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by prepend on Thursday January 11, 2018 @06:59PM (#16129231)
Try it and look at laws vs non-laws.
Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by asfdsfggtfd on Monday January 15, 2018 @03:01AM (#16149229)
No I apply the actual definition of theft....

I never said that copyright infringement or copying and publishing personal data is OK morally or legally. I just said that they are different crimes.

Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by pharrington on Thursday January 11, 2018 @04:28AM (#16122507)
"If I took your journal entries from your room, and copied them all, and put them on the internet - that's not stealing, because I returned the journal? No, that's still theft."

Yes, the original taking of the journal is literally depriving someone else of their object. A future return of the object clearly does not mean the original deprivation never happened. The point you're making about unauthorized distribution of private thoughts is about violation of privacy. Violating a person's privacy certainly is a bad thing. Theft is a different bad thing. (The analogy you're looking for is copying someone's paywalled blog)

"If someone stole bread, how would you feel about It? Screw that person right? What if they were stealing the bread from someone who would never notice the loss, and it was for their hungry kids? Suddenly it seems more reasonable."

You're trying to move the goalposts by conflating the literal deprivation of objects with copying information that all parties are trying to proliferate. The emotional appeal, besides not being as agreeable as you think, has nothing to do with the issue. A plentiful, though limited resource is just that. (Yes, one of the many reasons theft is bad is because it invariably angers the thieved and violates their sense of justice - the difference in argument is postulating the emotional impact of an action vs instructing the reader to feel a certain emotion).

Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by analognoise on Thursday January 11, 2018 @09:50AM (#16124153)
My arguments are based on ownership - you didn't create the (game, book, journal entries, code, artistic item, music, whatever), but somehow because you've decided to take advantage of content creators by belittling their ownership to declare theft a victimless crime.

Also, people are convinced by arguments they have an emotional connection to - not postulates. You're always instructing the reader how to feel - if the reader can't see what you're doing, and still consider your argument, they're uneducated. That's no sleight against them - as it is massively effective, and it is not permanent. Look at the last US election.

Re:Courts: Violating a Website’s Terms of Service Is Not a C... by pharrington on Thursday January 11, 2018 @02:31PM (#16127001)
If you're going to reply to a comment, reply to the words written. My comment doesn't describe anything as victimless crimes.

I have a rough understanding of human persuasion and decision making. Persuasion is not my goal. I am trying to engage with other people, read their knowledge and opinions, compare those to what I understand about reality, express my understanding, and when there are inconsistencies, attempt resolving them with some combination of verification of facts and revealing of core principles. Often times, this leads to me realize I had an incorrect thought about something, so I update my understanding of the world accordingly.