Side note: we’ve known for years that hammering a battery day in day out causes problems, my wife and I have had our 6S phones for the same amount of time - I plug mine in as much as possible (over charging is not a problem anymore) and she runs hers into the red all the time. After 2 years my phone runs fine and, when needed, I get a days charge out of it but she barely gets 4 hours and is noticeably slower. If people looked after their batteries better this would be less of a problem.
If Apple fucked up, why should there be a 'win' situation for them?
The obvious solution would be Apple replacing the batteries for free. Instead Apple won't even let you pay them to replace the battery if it's not in EOL mode — despite throttling starting well before then.
Some components just wear and need to be replaced. Apple just provided a workaround that ensures your device doesn't crash due to the worn out component.
Honestly, it feels like people, who have grudge on manufacturers for making non-swappable battery, just need an excuse to bring the swapping topic afloat.
It is also important not to affect any potential lawsuits against Apple by implying, that swapping batteries on affected phones would solve the problem. Because it would not: Apple should also cover damages to people, who had to buy new iPhones after being misguided.
The whole thing is geared to make Apple more money, and consumers stupider.
Apple publicly claimed that it affects a limited number of 6s and Apple would replace the battery. That offer is still up today [1]. Then they quietly [2] released an update that applies the 'workaround' to a larger number of devices. That's a fuckup at every level.
[1] https://www.apple.com/support/iphone6s-unexpectedshutdown/
[2] https://twitter.com/jcenters/status/944330221083381761 (Tidbits editor explains)
Completely impartial decision. I call that a FRAUD. Apple can call it "caring for me". Either way, Apple made the choice that costs me $900 more than it could/should.
I'll keep using my (jailbroken) devices, and I am looking for the day that this "tweak" will be revered in Cydia, and Apple will never see another $1k from me.
I, for one, am definitely not asking for Apple to give me a free battery. I just do not trust them at this point :)
So the battery loses down to maybe 90% capacity very quickly, then falls a little more slowly to somewhere around 70% by the next year or so, and will much more slowly lose after that.
But engineers that choose the batteries and design the electronics know this, so they plan the phone around the battery having that 65-85% capacity, never the 100%. That's what I think Apple did knowingly wrong and against good conventions.
Apple designed those iPhones in a way that either prematurely decreased the life and ability of the batteries they chose to power them (evidenced by the shut-offs), or they used inferior batteries that unpredictably or improperly lost the ability to maintain the required draw. That they only issued the scaling patch after shut-offs became an issue tells me that this was an engineering failure, whether by Apple, ATL, or TLB- not user error.
I don't think you two are using the phone equally much (meaning using up the same loading cycles in the 5 days). Like for example, she charging 2 * 90% and you charging 4 * 20% and 1 * 10%.
My understanding is that "cycles" are used in discussing battery lifespan for the purposes of warranties and the like because they're an easy-to-define user behavior, not because they actually reflect how the batteries perform.
Part of what I was talking about was, for example, I believe the Mac system profiler counts a cycle as any change from positive to negative discharge (or at least it did once upon a time), regardless of discharge depth. This gives Apple employees more opportunities to pull up your information and say "nope, sorry, your battery is expected to be dead after this many cycles", and make you feel like it's reasonable that you need to replace the battery.
Not necessarily; cycle depth is a big factor, but the interval covered is very important as well. I.e. a few cycles to a high charge end voltage ages cells more quickly than more cycles to a lower charge end voltage. This obviously directly relates to the amount of energy stored. The correlation is approximately exponential: you get somewhere between two to eight times the cycles for lowering charge voltage by 50-100 mV. You very quickly get to zero cycles raising it.
Another factor is cycle length, i.e. cell current, and temperature, as always.
Could education be the answer? I've never bought an iPhone, do they include a few paragraphs about proper battery care?
Better would be a "check engine light" when a new battery is needed.
Best would be full transparency. I want coconutBattery functionality on the iOS device. I want the option of running the diagnostic utilities the Genius Bar uses.
> "they are making these devices that it's difficult to replace the battery for..."
No. It's free under AppleCare and a whopping $79 out of warranty, and you can do it via mail.
> "they are running them so close to the redline that they can only handle it for a year"
No source cited for this. There is no indication that iPhones are regularly degrading beyond 80% within or shortly after one year.
> [compares to volkswagen emissions cheat]
Seems reasonable. :-/
It's ironic that this guy invokes the specter of benchmark cheating when Apple actually has been one of the only manufacturers that hasn't engaged in it.[1]
[1] https://www.xda-developers.com/benchmark-cheating-strikes-ba...
> "they are running them so close to the redline that they can only handle it for a year"
As for this, he's citing the fact the iPhone 7 is affected - a phone that came out just over a year ago.
It's highly discouraging to replace an iPhone battery. Doesn't matter how much skill it takes. It appears daunting and unapproachable.
The average iPhone user needs a website like iFixIt just to feel confident enough to replace a battery on their own. Go back 10 years and replacing a battery on a device didn't require researching a 20-step guide, a community forum, and special tools.
Regarding damage: It depends what your goal is. Some people want to get as much performance out of the CPU as possible since they maybe upgrade after a year or two anyway. Some people even try to set records by using crazy cooling systems.
Now the way Apple handled it, silently, throttling performance without a configuration option is interesting. I think the benchmarks may not be truly representative of what is happening, and it's probably closer to a TDP limit on the CPU where it runs real fast until it realizes it can't then it ... doesn't. That comes across as maximally efficient in real life but slow in benchmarks.
This is all in the marketing. Either you can look at it as "iPhone find a way to squeeze every last bit of battery life out of both new and old devices" or you can look at it as "my phone slows down over time" -- the reality of the chemistry of lithium ion devices.
IMO this should be handled with a configuration switch and a notification when performance starts to become limited, though how many would be totally confused by this? That hundreds of millions of users took years to notice should be an indication this whole thing worked pretty well IMO.
People absolutely have been noticing, this has been a very popular and long running issue. It took years for Apple to admit it, not for people to notice.
I think this could have been better handled by throttling according to the actual condition of the battery, rather than controlling it via software updates. The former seems reasonable, the latter is pretty shady. (Maybe this is actually what is happening and the press has confused what is going on.)
The behavior in question was introduced in 10.2.1 which was first released in Feb 2017.
So no, it was not a conspiracy going on for years. The annual slowdown was just poor unoptimized software. Occam's razor.
This is especially true since the iPhone 7, with its two low power cores who's entire purpose is to extend battery life.
The uproar is strictly re: long-term battery life.
Basically, Apple chose to tune the phones to run at a dangerously high configuration to increase benchmarks, knowing that the battery will degrade like this (and that when the iphone X2 comes out, nobody will be talking about this, instead they'll be talking about how much faster the X2 is than the X).
His exact quote is that "they are running them so close to the red line that surely they must know, when they're shipping these things (Because it's not like LiOn batteries are especially new tech at this point, and Apple has done TONS of research in this field), Apple knows pretty much exactly what's going to happen with this, pretty much perfectly, and they're making the conscious decision to do this"
Before I heard this I thought "Oh come on, Apple truely is protecting your phone here", but after hearing his argument I changed my mind.