News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple faces lawsuits after admitting it slows down aging ... by canuckintime on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @04:43AM (#16013831)
> This feels like a no win situation for Apple...

If Apple fucked up, why should there be a 'win' situation for them?

The obvious solution would be Apple replacing the batteries for free. Instead Apple won't even let you pay them to replace the battery if it's not in EOL mode — despite throttling starting well before then.

Re:Apple faces lawsuits after admitting it slows down aging ... by ako on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @06:45AM (#16014206)
Why should apple replace batteries for free? Do you expect a car company to replace car-batteries or tires for free?

Some components just wear and need to be replaced. Apple just provided a workaround that ensures your device doesn't crash due to the worn out component.

Re:Apple faces lawsuits after admitting it slows down aging ... by mmjaa on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @07:13AM (#16014299)
Apple decided to not let the consumer have the choice or ability to swap their own batteries. They've painted themselves into a corner here - and I think they should pay for this, indeed. Its clear that these moves were made solely to maximise profit for Apple, not to protect the consumer and provide them the best-quality experience.
Re:Apple faces lawsuits after admitting it slows down aging ... by lostmsu on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @03:25PM (#16017736)
Why do you keep insisting there's a problem with a battery? There's no problem with the battery, it behaves like any other battery in any other phone. The problem is that phone's compute ability stops matching its advertised value soon after purchase.
Re:Apple faces lawsuits after admitting it slows down aging ... by ddlsmurf on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @03:43PM (#16017858)
Because before apple came along, batteries were considered the consumable and were user replaceable. Now apple wants the whole phone to be the consumable. This not good for users nor the planet. Only people who would want a marginally thiner phone in exchange for buying a new one every year and apple's profit margins benefit.
Re:Apple faces lawsuits after admitting it slows down aging ... by lostmsu on Thursday December 28, 2017 @02:20AM (#16020816)
I fail to see why is it relevant to the current issue. Its not like you know 100% that if the battery would be swappable easily, they would suddenly decide to tell you instead of silently slowing the phones down.

Honestly, it feels like people, who have grudge on manufacturers for making non-swappable battery, just need an excuse to bring the swapping topic afloat.

It is also important not to affect any potential lawsuits against Apple by implying, that swapping batteries on affected phones would solve the problem. Because it would not: Apple should also cover damages to people, who had to buy new iPhones after being misguided.

Re:Apple faces lawsuits after admitting it slows down aging ... by mmjaa on Thursday December 28, 2017 @04:34AM (#16021139)
The point is that we wouldn't have a need for these slow-downs if we could just replace the batteries ourselves.

The whole thing is geared to make Apple more money, and consumers stupider.

Re:Apple faces lawsuits after admitting it slows down aging ... by lostmsu on Thursday December 28, 2017 @08:48PM (#16026880)
I understand your point, but now you can see how my fear of talking battery replacements came true. Probably millions of people bought new iPhones this year because they were deceived. Next day after my comment and all the discussions Apple announces they will make replacements cheaper. But those millions are still basically f*cked. And Apple will get away with it because most people complained about replaceability of the battery, while the only real issue is straight up illegal deception. Talking about battery swappability only serves Apple by driving conversation away from it. They will never make battery swappable unless there's a regulation to force it.
Re:Apple faces lawsuits after admitting it slows down aging ... by ddlsmurf on Friday December 29, 2017 @08:51AM (#16029450)
I disagree this is "straight up illegal deception", in fact, I find the slowing down perfectly rational and a desirable feature. The problem isn't the slowing down, but it is shining light on the irreplaceability, which IMHO is the true crime against the planet. That our legal infrastructures haven't caught up to it is irrelevant, planned obsolescence is a cancer, and if this is the only time people will notice, damn straight I'll use it
Re:Apple faces lawsuits after admitting it slows down aging ... by lostmsu on Friday December 29, 2017 @11:10AM (#16030131)
It's quite selfish to assume what's OK for you is ok for everyone else in a same situation.
Re:Apple faces lawsuits after admitting it slows down aging ... by ddlsmurf on Saturday December 30, 2017 @02:34PM (#16037012)
It is, but I don't think I did here. I'm saying it's bad for the planet because of the ecological cost of making an iphone being artificially pinned to that for a battery, in spite of their having very different lifetimes. If people in general thought those lifetimes should be equal, there would be no uproar to this revelation (the slowing down thing).
Re:Apple faces lawsuits after admitting it slows down aging ... by mmjaa on Friday December 29, 2017 @03:56AM (#16028465)
They're going to have to suffer some way, before they'll change their attitude. And they've got a few billions of dollars worth of buffer between them, and suffering, so .. you may indeed be right. Lets see.
Re:Apple faces lawsuits after admitting it slows down aging ... by konceptz on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @08:53AM (#16014728)
It shouldn’t be hard for Apple to “prove” that there are benefits, outside of maxing profit, to having a sealed battery.
Re:Apple faces lawsuits after admitting it slows down aging ... by mmjaa on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @11:11AM (#16015549)
Its also not hard to prove that it was a big mistake and they shouldn't have devolved this feature.
Re:Apple faces lawsuits after admitting it slows down aging ... by canuckintime on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @09:13AM (#16014821)
You should expect Apple to freely replace the battery of a phone that may unexpectedly shut down because that's already what Apple said you should expect.

Apple publicly claimed that it affects a limited number of 6s and Apple would replace the battery. That offer is still up today [1]. Then they quietly [2] released an update that applies the 'workaround' to a larger number of devices. That's a fuckup at every level.

[1] https://www.apple.com/support/iphone6s-unexpectedshutdown/

[2] https://twitter.com/jcenters/status/944330221083381761 (Tidbits editor explains)

Re:Apple faces lawsuits after admitting it slows down aging ... by HenryBemis on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @08:02AM (#16014507)
The fault is Apple decided on our behalf that we spend $1000 to replace the phone instead of spending $100 to replace the battery.

Completely impartial decision. I call that a FRAUD. Apple can call it "caring for me". Either way, Apple made the choice that costs me $900 more than it could/should.

I'll keep using my (jailbroken) devices, and I am looking for the day that this "tweak" will be revered in Cydia, and Apple will never see another $1k from me.

I, for one, am definitely not asking for Apple to give me a free battery. I just do not trust them at this point :)

Re:Apple faces lawsuits after admitting it slows down aging ... by simonbarker87 on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @12:14PM (#16016163)
Can’t you pay them £79 for a new battery whenever you want and they will do the swap for you?