News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Britain is, and was, deluded about its negotiating power ... by marze on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @11:57AM (#15971299)
Why can’t the U.K. just leave? Say we are gone, we are not giving you any money, and unilaterally state a position on trade terms?

I realize this may sound naive, but I’m just curious.

Re:Britain is, and was, deluded about its negotiating power ... by sz4kerto on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @12:00PM (#15971341)
Because _everything_ that happens between countries (and between the UK an the EU) is driven by treaties and agreements.

Simple example: if UK leaves without agreements and treaties then there can be no flights from the UK to the EU. This sounds crazy but we have tens of thousands of bilateral agreements that drive even the most fundamental things, and they can be (and are) affected by e.g. the EU membership.

Or UK citizens would not be able to buy products from the EU because there would be no agreements in place that'd allow companies in the EU to export goods. Yeah, as soon as you BMW breaks down that's it, because no spare parts would be available.

Yes, it's this important.

Re:Britain is, and was, deluded about its negotiating power ... by tzahola on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @12:01PM (#15971353)
Buy a Jaguar then ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
Re:Britain is, and was, deluded about its negotiating power ... by ZenoArrow on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @12:10PM (#15971458)
Jaguar is owned by an Indian company.
Re:Britain is, and was, deluded about its negotiating power ... by jjoonathan on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @12:18PM (#15971566)
When did India join the EU?
Re:Britain is, and was, deluded about its negotiating power ... by ZenoArrow on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @12:26PM (#15971658)
Look at the context in which the comments were made. The point sz4kerto made was about issues surrounding the import of BMWs and BMW parts. tzahola followed up with a comment about Jaguars. Jaguar is known for being a British car brand. The suggestion of importing from non-EU countries was not made clear, the implication I took from it was that British people could buy British goods, so I made the comment about who now owns Jaguar. Make more sense?
Re:Britain is, and was, deluded about its negotiating power ... by mikestew on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @12:23PM (#15971625)
Cars are still built in Coventry regardless of who takes the profit.
Re:Britain is, and was, deluded about its negotiating power ... by jstanley on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @12:22PM (#15971612)
> Or UK citizens would not be able to buy products from the EU because there would be no agreements in place that'd allow companies in the EU to export goods.

This is where you and I fundamentally disagree about how trade works.

If I want to trade with a person in a foreign country, I don't see why our governments need to even know, let alone come up with some agreement. If the foreign person and I can agree a deal, why can't we trade without asking permission from our governments?

Re:Britain is, and was, deluded about its negotiating power ... by eropple on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @12:26PM (#15971645)
Because you have agreed, implicitly and in concert with your fellow citizens, to live in a polity with rules around how members of that polity interact with members of other polities in order to collectively wield the power of your polity for the aims of that polity.

You can try to change the direction your polity takes with its stances towards others. You can leave if you don't approve of those stances and see no signs of changing them. But the question belies a fundamental misunderstanding of...yanno...why polities, why politics, exist.

Re:Britain is, and was, deluded about its negotiating power ... by gandreani on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @12:29PM (#15971687)
You're absolutely right. There's no such things as tariffs, customs, border inspections, fines, fees or other such leverage a country can exact upon it's citizens and businesses to enforce foreign trade rules...
Re:Britain is, and was, deluded about its negotiating power ... by Anderkent on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @12:30PM (#15971694)
It works on reciprocity. If you never consider disallowing trade with some countries, you cannot use it as an argument when negotiating access to other country markets; and so you open yourself to exploitation via dues etc. And maybe if no one hindered trade in any way, everyone would be better; but you have no ability to decide what everyone does - only what you do yourself.

Plus, there's actual reasons to think completely open, unhindered, and uninspected trade is not desirable. Think human trafficking, etc.

Re:Britain is, and was, deluded about its negotiating power ... by jstanley on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @01:14PM (#15972180)
But we have open unhindered and uninspected trade within countries, and we don't have out-of-control human trafficking within countries. Why is it different just because it crosses an imaginary line drawn on a map?
Re:Britain is, and was, deluded about its negotiating power ... by tremon on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @01:39PM (#15972420)
If you really believe that trade within your country is unhindered and uninspected, then I fear that you are one of the deluded. There are quality controls in every aspect of your life, even if they're mostly invisible to you.

Although, if the British public really want the 2013 horse meat scandal and the 2017 Grenfell Tower disaster to become the norm rather than the exception, I guess now is the time to seize the opportunity.

Re:Britain is, and was, deluded about its negotiating power ... by Anderkent on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @04:13PM (#15973874)
Because countries are the units that humans organise themselves. Why do laws differ between countries? Why is international policing difficult? Because within a country you have a fairly (not very, but to a functional degree) unified mode of operation; you have laws, organisations, policies. But coordinating those between countries is hard.
Re:Britain is, and was, deluded about its negotiating power ... by jjaredsimpson on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @12:27PM (#15971671)
This isn't a real argument. What if you agreed to buy slaves from a foreign person?

Governments obviously have a real interest in what their citizen do regardless of where that activity takes place.

Re:Britain is, and was, deluded about its negotiating power ... by dogma1138 on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @02:07PM (#15972695)
That’s a really bad example the US has a trade agreement with Mexico it doesn’t mean that one can buy cocaine from a Mexican cartel.
Re:Britain is, and was, deluded about its negotiating power ... by jstanley on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @01:13PM (#15972166)
What if I'm buying non-slaves from a foreign person? What if I tried to buy slaves from a non-foreign person?

I'd argue the former is fine and the latter is still not fine. So international trade agreements are surplus to requirements, since basic decency is enforced anyway.

Re:Britain is, and was, deluded about its negotiating power ... by polotics on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @02:14PM (#15972765)
Wow Stanley, where do you live? You really believe that (quote) "basic decency is enforced anyway" ?
Re:Britain is, and was, deluded about its negotiating power ... by jballanc on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @12:04PM (#15971398)
Because the U.K. is not self-sufficient. Actually, I'm fairly certain that no country in today's world is self-sufficient. That means that for people to get by, day-to-day, the U.K. will need to import "stuff". If they were to simply up-and-leave the EU, chances are that the EU would retaliate by:

* closing borders with the U.K.

* embargoing or imposing severe tariffs on U.K. exports

* raise prices on U.K. imports to cover the monies not paid by the U.K.

So the U.K.'s choices are to:

* pay, in effect, what they owe (in the forms of tariffs and penalties) with zero bargaining position

* find enough other countries to trade with (who are willing to also thumb their nose at the EU) to make up for the goods and services they had been getting from the EU

* negotiate a clean exit

Re:Britain is, and was, deluded about its negotiating power ... by toyg on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @12:18PM (#15971572)
> embargoing or imposing severe tariffs on U.K. exports

They don't even have to actually do anything to achieve that. WTO rules basically establish such tariffs already.

> raise prices on U.K. imports to cover the monies not paid by the U.K.

Same here. Also, additional tax revenues would likely be collected on business "redirected" from the UK towards internal companies.

I still hope we'll get another referendum before we reach a point of no return.

Re:Britain is, and was, deluded about its negotiating power ... by dragonwriter on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @12:14PM (#15971514)
> Why can’t the U.K. just leave? Say we are gone, we are not giving you any money, and unilaterally state a position on trade terms?

The UK can just leave—that’s what happens automatically with no deal, it leaves the E.U. and is in the same position as any other non-member country with no trade agreement with the E.U.

A lot of business in the UK has been dependent on its trade position in Europe, and there are even political stability issues tied in with that (the Irish border and it's relation to the situation in Northern Ireland, particularly.) So the UK can't afford to walk away, though they are perfectly free to do so.

Re:Britain is, and was, deluded about its negotiating power ... by interdrift on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @12:03PM (#15971370)
1. UK has obligations to the EU for the 2020 (already have deals & contracts), other than that they're free to leave. Of course you can just leave and end up with a chaotic situation where nobody knows how trading works, there are tariffs.

Opinion : UK is going toward vassal state status to the EU by not having a say but still having to follow their rules.

Re:Britain is, and was, deluded about its negotiating power ... by WhirlingBirdz on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @12:36PM (#15971763)
Similar to the other "vassal states" such as Norway and Switzerland.

I'm not sure that the debate here is very sensible or measured.

I think that Brexit is a tragedy, and dearly hope it doesn't actually happen. That is my opinion. But it seems difficult if not impossible to have a reasoned argument about any aspect of it; people are entrenched in their corners.

Re:Britain is, and was, deluded about its negotiating power ... by tremon on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @12:49PM (#15971916)
Well, that depends on what Britain wants. Norway and Switzerland still have to abide by the free movement rules of the EU (which also includes air space regulations btw), and I though that Britain didn't want that? Maybe read up on the EEA's Guillotine Clause [0] to understand the negotiation room that Britain will have when trying to curb free movement.

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guillotine_clause

Re:Britain is, and was, deluded about its negotiating power ... by Dayshine on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @12:02PM (#15971357)
For the same reason your friends will refuse to go to dinner with you if you skip on the bill.

There are literally hundreds of collaborations between UK organisations and EU organisations. If we just stop our promised contributions to all of them they're not going to trust us again.

Re:Britain is, and was, deluded about its negotiating power ... by gaius on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @12:03PM (#15971381)
For the same reason your friends will refuse to go to dinner with you if you skip on the bill.

What about if you refuse to split the bill for the next dinner, to which you aren't invited?

Re:Britain is, and was, deluded about its negotiating power ... by catdog on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @12:11PM (#15971483)
It's more like already having placed a binding order for that next dinner which is already in progress of being made but then refuse to pay.
Re:Britain is, and was, deluded about its negotiating power ... by 1undo on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @12:08PM (#15971446)
> For the same reason your friends will refuse to go to dinner with you if you skip on the bill.

What if you had very little choice on what was ordered for dinner? and ate almost nothing at dinner. You wouldn't want to pay right?

Re:Britain is, and was, deluded about its negotiating power ... by namelost on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @12:12PM (#15971491)
You say to your friends, "Let's share the cost of dinner". Then when you decide you don't like the dinner, walk out halfway through, leaving your friends to pick up the bill for what you ordered.

Once word gets round, not only your friends but nobody is going to go out to dinner with you ever again.

Re:Britain is, and was, deluded about its negotiating power ... by 1undo on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @12:18PM (#15971568)
Yes, I agree to "share the cost of dinner". But I don't get the food that I ordered, and eat very little of it. And I watch others eat a lot of food without contributing to the tab. I then want to leave the dinner which is only right
Re:Britain is, and was, deluded about its negotiating power ... by namelost on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @12:29PM (#15971690)
It doesn't matter. Once you have made a commitment to pay a share of something, you pay it.

What would you price the reputation of the UK at? I hope more than £39bn. All the other countries of the world are watching the UK's actions.

Re:Britain is, and was, deluded about its negotiating power ... by toyg on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @12:21PM (#15971603)
> I then want to leave the dinner which is only right

But you would at least pay for what you ordered. Anyone just upping and leaving would be considered very rude, and nobody would invite him ever again.

Re:Britain is, and was, deluded about its negotiating power ... by jstanley on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @12:24PM (#15971632)
But he's already paid for far more than what he's eaten. If anything, the others at the table should be giving him money back.
Re:Britain is, and was, deluded about its negotiating power ... by petraeus on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @01:04PM (#15972073)
The difference here is between how children react and how grown ups react. In the grown up world your words along with the SPIRIT of their meaning underpins your actions. in this case all the parties agreed on splitting the costs, not retro actively changing the rules to suit themselves.
Re:Britain is, and was, deluded about its negotiating power ... by Anderkent on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @12:34PM (#15971745)
Well, the dinner metaphor breaks down here. It's almost certain that the access to the EU workforce and trade markets have benefited the UK much more than the pocket change it pays into the EU; but it's hard to put an exact number on those things.
Re:Britain is, and was, deluded about its negotiating power ... by toyg on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @12:41PM (#15971827)
He paid for what he agreed to pay, looking at the menu and everything. If he's changed his mind, that's his problem.
Re:Britain is, and was, deluded about its negotiating power ... by daveid on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @12:15PM (#15971525)
Do you realize the EU was co-created by Britain and many EU laws and regulations were drafted by British politicians as well as voted on by them?
Re:Britain is, and was, deluded about its negotiating power ... by pm90 on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @12:17PM (#15971556)
No, you would state that you don't like the fact that you don't like what you're having for dinner before going, like a fucking adult.

If we expand on your analogy a little bit: its more like families going to dinner. The British family agreed with the dinner at first but due to some internal changes in the family, now says they didn't like what they ate before, don't like what they will eat in the future, and want to negotiate a different plan for dinner henceforth.

Re:Britain is, and was, deluded about its negotiating power ... by GlobalFrog on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @12:41PM (#15971819)
Reality would be closer to this: imagine you participated to the choice of the menu in the past, ate it, participate of the choice of the next menus in the future and commited to pay your share. You even eat some of the first courses in each menus, but before the end of the meal, you decide to get out and pay what you want of what you have started to eat and none of what you ordered next. Brexiters wanted to continue to eat without paying : that's not even close to what's needed to negociate with the EU.
Re:Britain is, and was, deluded about its negotiating power ... by juandazapata on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @12:00PM (#15971340)
Because relationships between countries don't work in the same way as relationships between teenagers?
Re:Britain is, and was, deluded about its negotiating power ... by selectodude on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @11:59AM (#15971328)
The negotiations are mostly the UK trying to maintain some of the trade and immigration agreements they had while in the EU. They're welcome to just go "fuck you" and leave, but they will be absolutely destroyed by doing so.
Re:Britain is, and was, deluded about its negotiating power ... by Zhyl on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @12:02PM (#15971360)
In the current parlance, this is called the 'No Deal'.
Re:Britain is, and was, deluded about its negotiating power ... by pm90 on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @12:10PM (#15971464)
You could say this about any treaty, any agreement. And technically, a Sovereign Nation, by its very definition, is allowed to do whatever the fuck it wants.

Before 20th century, breaches of treaties were grounds for war. Now we don't do that anymore, we simply cut off trade.

So the U.K would be ostracized, International companies would move out, it would probably face high tariffs on goods (or outright ban) etc.

Re:Britain is, and was, deluded about its negotiating power ... by yk on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @12:36PM (#15971762)
Details. So for starters, the EU currently regulates a lot of what may be sold as food, regulations that just no longer apply if UK leaves. So they have to go through all the EU regulations first just to determine which are necessary to keep safe food in British supermarkets.

Then you get the international problems directly connected to that, what can you import into Britain and at which tariffs. Plus, how do you cooperate between air traffic control across the channel and across the Irish sea. (While we are at it, is British Airways allowed to fly over France, without EU law?)

And that is just the things Britain has to figure out on their own. Ireland, France and the rest of the EU have interest in British tariffs and if Britain sets tariffs unilaterally they will respond in kind, a situation sometimes known as trade war.

So yes, in principle Britain could just state a position on terms of trade, a hard Brexit, but that would mean that the EU responds in kind. Neither the EU nor Britain wants to do that, but the thing is the EU is something like 10 times as big as Britain and so the EU can very comfortably wait for Britain, because Brexit only affects something less than 10% of the EU trade, not over half of all trade as for Britain.

Re:Britain is, and was, deluded about its negotiating power ... by Scorponok on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @12:00PM (#15971331)
Because the EU could then reject those terms and not having a trade deal would be vastly more damaging to the UK than the EU.
Re:Britain is, and was, deluded about its negotiating power ... by gaius on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @12:02PM (#15971358)
No it can't - it's as bound by Article 50 as the UK is.
Re:Britain is, and was, deluded about its negotiating power ... by PeterisP on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @12:29PM (#15971688)
Article 50 doesn't require a free trade deal to exist after the Brexit, the "no deal" scenario is what happens if Britain exits without a replacement deal, and it's considered (by both sides) an outcome that's bad for UK.
Re:Britain is, and was, deluded about its negotiating power ... by dragonwriter on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @12:15PM (#15971536)
Article 50 means that no deal happens without unanimity in the EU. The only way that binds the EU is in limiting the ability to make a deal, not obligating them to accept a unilateral UK demand.
Re:Britain is, and was, deluded about its negotiating power ... by Scorponok on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @12:14PM (#15971519)
So what happens if the EU and UK don't reach an agreement before the article 50 time limit expires? It doesn't make sense that the UK just gets to do what they like, otherwise they wouldn't need to negotiate at all.
Re:Britain is, and was, deluded about its negotiating power ... by gaius on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @12:17PM (#15971557)
As I say in other comments, WTO rules automatically apply - to both sides. The EU is fully bound by its own laws. It cannot unilaterally decide to reject WTO rules.
Re:Britain is, and was, deluded about its negotiating power ... by masklinn on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @12:16PM (#15971543)
> Why can’t the U.K. just leave? Say we are gone, we are not giving you any money

They can, but then travel and trade becomes ~illegal between the UK and pretty much everyone else, the powder keg of NI starts heating back up, you've got a bunch of britons illegally present in mainland EU and likewise mainland residents in the UK, …

Oh and the UK becomes known for having no respect for international deals, which makes their positions weaker in every future international agreement.

> and unilaterally state a position on trade terms?

And the EU unilaterally states "no" and then what?

Re:Britain is, and was, deluded about its negotiating power ... by dragonwriter on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @12:18PM (#15971573)
> They can, but then travel and trade becomes ~illegal between the UK and pretty much everyone else

Reverting to WTO rules and hard (but not closed) borders isn't trade and travel being illegal, but it is a lot less free than the state when the UK was in the EU.

Re:Britain is, and was, deluded about its negotiating power ... by ZenoArrow on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @12:38PM (#15971796)
> "They can, but then travel and trade becomes ~illegal between the UK and pretty much everyone else"

That's bullshit. WTO trade rules would still apply if the UK left the EU without a deal, and freedom to come and go outside the EU could still remain unchanged regardless of what Brussels wants to impose.

Re:Britain is, and was, deluded about its negotiating power ... by pimmen on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @12:24PM (#15971627)
You absolutely can just leave!

Now, lets say the five times larger economy doesn't accept your unilateral trade position, who just happens to be by far your largest and closest trading partner, what do you think happens then to your companies who are reliant on the EU market? Even if you don't work for such a company, what do you think would happen to your employer's clients? And if you work in the public sector, what do you think will happen to the tax revenue from those companies?

More than 20% of the UK's GDP is made up of exports to the EU. What do you think will happen to the government that cost the country millions of jobs because of one stupid decision to appease populists come election year? That's why the government can't just leave because it would be extremely popular in the short term but within a few years bring about very dire consequences.

Re:Britain is, and was, deluded about its negotiating power ... by 317070 on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @12:07PM (#15971432)
The UK can do that. The most likely consequence will be the EU not accepting those trade terms. As a consequence, almost all trade with the UK will stop and trade with the UK will effectively be under near embargo due to the high tarrifs from parts of the world (the EU and areas it has trade agreements with).
Re:Britain is, and was, deluded about its negotiating power ... by AndrewDucker on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @12:00PM (#15971333)
Who would sign a trade deal with a country which reneged on its agreements?
Re:Britain is, and was, deluded about its negotiating power ... by gaius on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @12:00PM (#15971346)
Article 50 specifies exactly what will happen: WTO rules will apply.

I think most people now are assuming WTO and considering anything else to be a bonus.

Re:Britain is, and was, deluded about its negotiating power ... by Tomte on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @12:26PM (#15971660)
„WTO rules“ are just a framework for trading rules. Those rules itself still need to be negotiated.

For example, „which form do you have to fill with which information in how many copies, in order to export pastry?“.

That‘s much faster than a real trade deal, because it‘s mostly administrative, but it is still a hurdle to clear before you can trade under „WTO rules“.

And now do that for a gazillion sectors and special cases. With every trading partner.

Re:Britain is, and was, deluded about its negotiating power ... by interdrift on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @12:04PM (#15971394)
WTO deals can take years to negotiate. The U.K's land of heaven is lobbying in Brussels so they can get a fair to everyone deal. As my British friends say, can't have your cake and eat it.
Re:Britain is, and was, deluded about its negotiating power ... by gaius on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @12:10PM (#15971462)
No, it takes years of negotiations to change WTO rules, but the rules as they are will apply automatically in the absence of any other deal
Re:Britain is, and was, deluded about its negotiating power ... by neaden on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @12:03PM (#15971374)
Because the EU will say no and Britain will be screwed. It wouldn't be great for the EU either, but it would hurt them a lot less.
Re:Britain is, and was, deluded about its negotiating power ... by dboreham on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @12:01PM (#15971349)
Convention that you don’t break treat obligations (presumably because consequences of doing so would be very bad)?
Re:Britain is, and was, deluded about its negotiating power ... by 1undo on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @12:05PM (#15971409)
The European Union wants to maintain centralized power. A Country like the UK leaving weakens their authority. Meanwhile the uk wants to remain sovereign, but doesn't want to lose the benefits of the EU. Its essentially a power play. Freedom is the better choice imo
Re:Britain is, and was, deluded about its negotiating power ... by ubersoldat2k7 on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @01:42PM (#15972453)
Actually, the other way around. Without the UK blocking many integration policies, the EU will have an easier road ahead to approve them, like military, legal and tax integration.
Re:Britain is, and was, deluded about its negotiating power ... by goneri on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @12:25PM (#15971641)
This is a pure opinion based comment with no fact and a naive conclusion. This extremely complex topic deserves better, especially on HN.
Re:Britain is, and was, deluded about its negotiating power ... by junkscience2017 on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @12:35PM (#15971748)
and how does your jab advance that?
Re:Britain is, and was, deluded about its negotiating power ... by interdrift on Wednesday December 20, 2017 @12:18PM (#15971562)
You're portraying things a black and white and this is not even remotely the case.