News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by eximius on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @10:58AM (#15906496)
For better or worse, this sets a fairly clear precedent. Will be interesting to watch people try to get around it.
Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by deweller on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @11:18AM (#15906702)
I am a co-founder in the cryptocurrency space. Our lawyers were smart and advised us against releasing a utility token ICO because they predicted that these SEC actions would be coming.

Our approach to "get around" this is to file all the necessary paperwork for a legal security and then only sell the token to accredited investors.

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by 52-6F-62 on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @11:27AM (#15906811)
So basically, follow the existing law that governs securities and investments. I personally don't see a big problem with that, considering the laughable scams that have occurred over the past six months.

I am curious, though, how that works with proposed international investors. (I'm not well educated in the financial space)

I hope that these actions clear house of the scams, and open room for good projects to exist without some shade of doubt cast over them—at least not for the reasons there exists some kind of shade now.

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by erikpukinskis on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @11:38AM (#15906918)
> I personally don't see a big problem with that

It protects the monopoly the investor class has on investments like these.

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by itamarst on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @11:42AM (#15906961)
And by "investments" you mean "worthless and fraudulent garbage", if we're talking about ICOs. Honestly garbage is probably worth more, might be recyclable or compostable.

More broadly, there's a whole set of finance research showing that the investments that accredited investors get access to (private equity, VC, etc.) aren't any better that normal investments on a risk-adjusted basis.

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by sillysaurus3 on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @11:51AM (#15907055)
And yet, that worthless fraudulent garbage is one of the few ways to get rich.

If Oculus had done an ICO instead of a kickstarter, my $400 wouldn't have been merely a preorder. The $400 would've become quite a handy sum by the time Oculus got acquired.

That requires integrating ICOs into the existing startup structures, but it's worth trying.

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by ryanwaggoner on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @01:15PM (#15907947)
And yet, that worthless fraudulent garbage is one of the few ways to get rich.

Historically, this has not been true. Depending on your definition of "rich", very few wealthy people have gotten there by investing in other people's companies where accreditation was required. Most wealth is built by via ownership of your own company, real estate (which is a type of company), or by investing in public markets. These pathways are all still available to you, and almost certainly still represent a better long-term risk-adjusted return than ICOs.

If Oculus had done an ICO instead of a kickstarter, my $400 wouldn't have been merely a preorder. The $400 would've become quite a handy sum by the time Oculus got acquired.

This actually is an interesting point, but it does require some serious cherry-picking. I'd be interested to see the data behind a scenario where all the funded startups for the last decade had been ICOs instead of venture-backed. I doubt it'd look so rosy in that scenario, especially when you consider that many more failures would likely have been funded, based on how easy it is to raise money from an ICO based on nothing other than a pretty website template.

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by kekeblom on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @03:44PM (#15909290)
Considering that an ico in oculus’s case would mean that they would issue a token which could be exchanged against a device, I fail to see how the token could increase in value in any significant way.
Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by ryanwaggoner on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @04:31PM (#15909690)
I guess I was thinking more of Oculus as platform than as device.
Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by dreit1 on Wednesday December 13, 2017 @12:46AM (#15912312)
Getting rich by investing in public markets....come on. No non high net worth individual will get rich investing in public markets.
Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by tptacek on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @12:13PM (#15907284)
There is a reason you need to be an accredited investor to buy startup stock, and it isn't because the elite banksters are trying to protect their monopoly (startup venture capital for early-stage --- anything prior to, say, a B-round --- startups is a rounding error).

Changing the word "stock" to "coin" doesn't change any of the underlying dynamics.

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by philipodonnell on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @02:41PM (#15908780)
This perspective is... naive. When accredited investors became a thing it may have started as a paternalistic "protect the poor from themselves", but now it merely serves to limit the supply of investors (read:rich) to a relative few who can dictate more favorable terms to those seeking that capital (read:poor).

When the primary determination is whether you already _have_ money, rather than education, professional history, earning potential, or a history of demonstrated ability to make informed investment decisions... it becomes extremely difficult to argue that its anything other than an artificial class barrier.

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by tptacek on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @02:52PM (#15908855)
What I think is naive is the idea that opening investment in something up to the public would somehow harm the financial sector, rather than generating billions in profits for it.
Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by sillysaurus3 on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @03:03PM (#15908956)
http://www.paulgraham.com/divergence.html

VC funding will probably dry up somewhat during the present recession, like it usually does in bad times. But this time the result may be different. This time the number of new startups may not decrease. And that could be dangerous for VCs.

When VC funding dried up after the Internet Bubble, startups dried up too. There were not a lot of new startups being founded in 2003. But startups aren't tied to VC the way they were 10 years ago. It's now possible for VCs and startups to diverge. And if they do, they may not reconverge once the economy gets better.

This logic works in reverse, too: if funding becomes dramatically easier thanks to ICOs, startups have no reason to court VCs anymore. And that could be dangerous for VCs.

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by tptacek on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @03:31PM (#15909185)
Who cares about the VCs? VCs are an insignificant component of the financial system. I don't agree that ICOs would be harmful to VCs, but even if they were: the larger financial system would profit enormously from retail investment in fly-by-night startups.
Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by sillysaurus3 on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @03:46PM (#15909303)
This subthread was about class barriers and investors. You expressed ICOs might not be harmful to them, so I mentioned a way they might be. Not sure where the financial sector topic came from.

What exactly would the problem be with letting people crowdfund startups (i.e. equity)? Why not follow Filecoin's lead? I've been reading your arguments and you haven't really articulated your concerns; just persuasive cases that the status quo should be maintained.

The next Google/FB/Netflix might very well start using the model here, if you let it. But only if they have access to capital. And right now, that means VCs.

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by tptacek on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @04:06PM (#15909469)
Again: you're suggesting that when we talk about the interests of rich financiers, we're talking about the VCs. I'm sure not. If there's a financial power center to be concerned about, it's Goldman Sachs, not Sequoia. The fact that ICOs might somehow impact some tiny corner of the finance industry doesn't matter if it's going to juice things for the giant investment banks.
Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by jakelazaroff on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @03:45PM (#15909301)
Why would ICOs make startups less reliant on VCs, other than the fact that (for the time being) ICOs let startups skirt investment regulations they'd otherwise have to adhere to?

I agree with tptacek's general thesis here: there's not any inherent difference between ICOs and "normal" early-stage investing that justifies an utter lack of regulation of the former but not the latter.

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by spookthesunset on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @07:42PM (#15910964)
The accredited investor stuff exists not to keep the rich folk rich, but because the SEC doesn't give a fuck if rich people fall for scams. They care if Grandma living off a fixed income sinks her life savings into the latest ICO fad, loses everything and has to eat cat food for the remainder of her years -- not only does that fuck over Grandma, but it fucks over society. If Joe Millionaire falls for some dumbass ICO scam... too bad, so sad.
Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by dreit1 on Wednesday December 13, 2017 @12:48AM (#15912318)
And yet, in practice, it seems to do something completely different...
Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by mrep on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @11:24PM (#15912016)
If you have "education, professional history, earning potential, or a history of demonstrated ability to make informed investment decisions", then you should easily be able to make enough money to become an accredited investor.

Startups are one of the most risky investments you can make. By arguing for regular folks to invest in startups, you just convey your ignorance in the risks associated with them. Most startups fail which is why full time investors invest in many startups and due extreme diligence because it is such a hosh posh of scams and people overselling their company.

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by philipodonnell on Wednesday December 13, 2017 @09:14AM (#15914281)
> If you have "education, professional history, earning potential, or a history of demonstrated ability to make informed investment decisions", then you should easily be able to make enough money to become an accredited investor.

This is just not even remotely true. Plenty of people have those things but haven't yet been able to acquire the money to qualify as an accredited investor. This line of reasoning is like the oligarch's dream.

"If you were as smart as me you would have as much money as me and could invest like I do. Also, until you have as much money as me, I won't let you invest like I did to get all this money, because if you don't already have as much money as I already have you must not be as smart as me and clearly can't understand the kind of investing I do. In fact, I will make it illegal for you to invest like I did until you come up with as much money as I already have from doing those things that you are not allowed to do."

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by caust1c on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @03:39PM (#15909249)
> When the primary determination is whether you already _have_ money, rather than education, professional history, earning potential, or a history of demonstrated ability to make informed investment decisions...

This is the case because many regulations (Tax code, laws) favor the wealthy. If we didn't have the SEC regulations, then the clever and wealthy would prey on the poor and uneducated. This is textbook what happened in the 20s.

Honestly, the SEC is probably one of the last decent regulatory bodies of our government.

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by pishpash on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @02:05PM (#15908427)
Is there any access at all, even through other funds? If not then there is a problem. Maybe prohibiting advertising and soliciting is enough. Maybe place some limits. But there are no good reasons I can think of to blanket prohibit investment itself to the "non-accredited".
Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by tptacek on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @02:27PM (#15908649)
Yes; the money venture capitalists invest comes from other funds, among them things like pension funds.

A fact people seem to overlook in these discussions is that unless you can see the future, you can't just invest in Google and Airbnb; you invest in a sample of the whole tech startup market. And when you do that, by and large, you underperform the S&P 500.

Funds and endowments invest as VC LPs not simply because they want access to the insane deals that startups provide, but because they want decorrelated investments: they want some of their money allocated to investments that will perform differently than the market as a whole. When you have billions under management, it makes total sense to throw tens of millions at tech startups.

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by mbesto on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @02:04PM (#15908417)
> it isn't because the elite banksters are trying to protect their monopoly

To quote The Dude "Well, that's just like your opinion, man". I think your point is that the intention of the law is so that people are manipulated into buying securities they can't afford (e.g. scams). This is true, however some would argue that this legislation is yet another reason the rich continue to stay rich, which is a legitimate argument. So I wouldn't be so dismissive of that opinion.

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by tptacek on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @02:15PM (#15908518)
I do not understand the underlying logic of this argument. It seems to suggest that but for pesky SEC RegD rule, there'd be 10,000% appreciation opportunities for everyone, not just the wealthiest investors.

How do people making this argument think money works? People that can commit $20,000,000 to an investment with the stroke of a pen are going to get the best opportunities no matter how they're structured: they can offer better terms. Literally the only thing retail investors could conceivably offer to compete with them is "willingness to be screwed over without recourse".

Stipulate a future in which essentially no ICO is regulated, and most new venture raises happen with publicly traded ICOs. Follow that thought to its conclusion and explain to me how the best opportunities are going to provide 10,000% gains, rather than markets acting the way all logic in either direction about ICOs dictates they must act, and pricing risk and opportunity accordingly?

I see how, in the post- free-ICO world, you'll be able to bet that restaurant review coupons will 10x your money. Coupons for everything. 10x your money on dog washing and cat sharing; that'll happen too.

What I don't see is why the truly credible teams doing truly important work with a real chance of success are going to offer securities on those same terms. How does that work? How stupid would you have to be to look at a market where restaurant review coupons are worth $15MM because they're certain! to 9x your investment, and then go to market with the next generation of, say, the Cisco Catalyst 9400 switch on those exact same terms?

Aren't restaurant review coupons in some sense the ceiling on how too-good-to-be-true these ICO deals can be? I mean: that business is obviously not going to work. A reasonably sophisticated person can only put money on it in the hopes that someone dumber will buy it off them in a week or two.

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by erikpukinskis on Wednesday December 13, 2017 @12:26PM (#15915698)
> It seems to suggest that but for pesky SEC RegD rule, there'd be 10,000% appreciation opportunities for everyone, not just the wealthiest investors

Please refrain from aggressively straw manning me. We said nothing like that and you know that’s not our position. You’re trying to reducto ad absurdim us without actually doing the reducto part.

I see it this way: there are many different ways to structure a funding event: a bank loan, a bond issuance, an ICO, a partnership, a Series A, etc.

If we’re talking about a small scale, say $100k, but none of my investors have very much money, just a few hundred maybe, I am dramatically limited in the sorts of funding structures I can legally use.

If my investors all have millions of dollars and are putting in 10s of thousands, I can legally structure the deal however I like.

I think that’s an unfair limitation that makes it harder to start businesses that no rich person would ever care about.

I do care about protecting investors, but I think the wealth requirement is the laziest possible way to do that. Mandatory disclosure rules would be better. Requiring insurance would be better.

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by mbesto on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @05:18PM (#15910029)
> I do not understand the underlying logic of this argument.

Just because you don't understand the logic of the argument doesn't invalidate it.

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by tptacek on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @05:27PM (#15910088)
That's obviously true, but doesn't get us anywhere.
Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by mbesto on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @06:50PM (#15910656)
I generally appreciate your commentary and authority on certain topics, but the "I'm right, you're wrong" / "I can't understand this rationale so I'm going to dismiss it" attitude here certainly isn't going to get us anywhere either.

I think we both agree that allowing anyone to invest without an accreditation is probably harmful, however don't you think it's worth discussing/investigating the negative externalities of such an accreditation?

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by tptacek on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @07:06PM (#15910754)
What are the negative externalities of accreditation?
Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by sillysaurus3 on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @03:33PM (#15909202)
Aren't restaurant review coupons in some sense the ceiling on how too-good-to-be-true these ICO deals can be? I mean: that business is obviously not going to work. A reasonably sophisticated person can only put money on it in the hopes that someone dumber will buy it off them in a week or two.

Your argument hinges on the assumption that the government should protect people from this outcome. If they make a bad bet, it's their bet to lose.

Right now, churches ask for thousands of dollars via mail. People send them with the hopes that they are "planting a seed" and to "watch that seed grow." All of this behavior goes on without society collapsing.

What's the key difference? Why do people need to be protected when suddenly they have a chance of winning real returns, however remote?

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by tptacek on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @04:07PM (#15909479)
View few people mortgage their houses and send the proceeds to a church expecting to pay for their kids college tuitions.
Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by cycrutchfield on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @02:36PM (#15908732)
The laws exist for a good reason, and it's because historically many folks with insufficient means lost their shirts due to such scams. A judgment was made that between restricting such risky schemes to those with the means to handle that risk ("the rich") and letting people lose their shirts, restricting such risky schemes was the lesser of two evils.

And I tend to agree.

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by tptacek on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @02:40PM (#15908772)
Can we be clear that the law does not restrict "risky schemes", but rather "schemes that refuse to follow disclosure laws"? There are thousands of publicly traded companies and a lot of them are batshit. What allows them to trade without SEC molestation is that they (a) register, (b) publish audited financials, and (c) follow the SEC's rules about promotion.

The difference between a restaurant review coupon ICO and a pink sheet biotech firm isn't risk. Both will almost certainly fail. The difference is that the ICO refuses to publish audited financials, and demands the right to shoot Youtube videos extolling a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to 9x an investment.

That's what the SEC is protecting retail investors from.

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by ShabbosGoy on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @12:29PM (#15907454)
Aren’t ICOs covered under Reg CF of the JOBS Act though? That was the whole point of the JOBS act: to provide access to capital that an entrepreneur normally wouldn’t be able to obtain.

An ICO is not a bad alternative to pre-seed funding.

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by tptacek on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @12:38PM (#15907564)
I don't know how many other restrictions apply, but apparently for RegCF, you can only take small amounts from non-accredited investors, and you have to raise less than 1MM.
Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by cstejerean on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @12:06PM (#15907189)
Why would your ICO have been worth anything at all during an acquisition? If it isn’t tied to equity in the company (to avoid securities violations) then what exactly would have given it value in an acquisition? Who would have bought it from you for more money and why?
Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by sillysaurus3 on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @12:17PM (#15907335)
I meant conceptually. If the startup ecosystem embraces ICOs, then that type of thing can happen.

Right now we'd just have to settle for "If Oculus got acquired, the price probably would have gone up." But you could imagine starting a company that promises to incorporate tokens into the structure somehow: Perhaps the founder would say they'll only sell to acquirers that are willing to offer token holders $x, where $x is based on the price over the last month before being acquired. Then it'd be in the founder's best interest to sell as little of the token as possible to cover operations, since otherwise it reduces their chances of getting acquired -- just like normal investment.

Also it incentivizes founders to make the company do well: if they can tap into funding when needed (because they have premined coins they can sell), they're less beholden to the valley. That means a smart 18 year old can single-handedly launch and fund a company; no permission needed from some cabal of investors.

Moot was 15 when he launched 4chan. If you believed in its future, you could've (a) supported it by buying their token, and (b) possibly made some return on that belief.

Obviously, all of the normal caveats apply: most investments don't work out. But everyone knows that.

If I want to put $2k into a company, why is the government stepping in to stop me? I can go waste $2k at the casino or squander it however I want. It's my money.

Bitcoin itself can be thought of as an ICO. When people buy Bitcoin, we're buying into Satoshi's vision for the future. It's not merely because it's useful. So why is that legal, but ICOs aren't?

The overall point is that this is a powerful model, and it could become even more powerful. The rest of the world is embracing it, so the US could find themselves left out by getting too draconian.

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by dkersten on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @12:37PM (#15907560)
If the ICO tokens are tied to some reward on acquisition, then how is it any different from other securities? May as well just sell equity at that stage (perhaps through something like seedrs, which accepts small investments too). If it’s basically just a security like any others, why should it bypass the regulations?

If it walks like a security and it quacks like a security, then everything else is just a technicality: it’s a security.

Also, what benefit does using a cryptocurrency even buy you here other than as a technicality to attempt to sidestep the laws?

Maybe the laws should be relaxed to open it up to more laypeople, but given how easily people get burned and scammed at this stuff, I’m not fully convinced (penny stocks anyone? Or even Bitcoin: yes some people got rich and others will get rich in the future, but there’s a very high chance that a lot of laypeople who bought in recently because of the price surge are going to lose a lot of money). The point of “accredited investor” is that they can afford to lose their investments.

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by DennisP on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @01:09PM (#15907901)
Someone with $800K in savings who makes $150K/year can easily afford to lose a $5K investment, but is not an accredited investor.

That's why we have the JOBS Act now. I'm hoping some ICOs start using it.

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by mikestew on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @12:21PM (#15907373)
And yet, that worthless fraudulent garbage is one of the few ways to get rich.

The worthless fraudulent garbage is an even a better way to get poor. Which is why there is a financial test to make such investments: “does this person have that kind of money to piss away?”

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by DennisP on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @01:10PM (#15907910)
But that should be a percentage of net worth, rather than a binary function that flips at an arbitrary $1M.
Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by mikestew on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @01:39PM (#15908181)
As Mason said to Dixon, “ya gotta draw the line somewhere”. Percentage of wealth as a measure misses one key aspect: accumulating a million dollars isn’t that hard. You can either work a middle-class job and not piss away every penny as fast it comes in, or you’re so loaded that a million dollars is what you keep in the checking account for emergencies. In the former case, you don’t get $1MM being an idiot at finances. Yeah, that leaves out the gal with $900K, but see first sentence. For the latter, you lose $500K, who cares? You’ll still eat tomorrow.

Of course there are numerous counter-examples. Rap artist M. C. Hammer comes to mind. A rich person can afford a bad investment or two, but not a string of them.

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by teraflop on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @03:27PM (#15909149)
> You can either work a middle-class job and not piss away every penny as fast it comes in

"Middle class", using the conventional definition of 67%-200% of median household income, is about $40k to $110k a year. The median within that range is about $65k. Let's say you pay about 25% in taxes, and manage to save 1/3 of what's left. That's about $16k/year, which means it would take that household an entire lifetime to save up a million dollars.

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by mikestew on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @03:53PM (#15909344)
which means it would take that household an entire lifetime to save up a million dollars.

Well, then, I guess they best not be pissing away what little they have on dodgy ICOs. I mean, perhaps I’m wrong on the math, but you still haven’t convinced me of the case that those making $65K/year should get to dump their retirement money into dodgy investments. Rather, you’ve furthered the case against.

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by jonknee on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @04:47PM (#15909821)
> That's about $16k/year, which means it would take that household an entire lifetime to save up a million dollars.

~23 years if you add $16k a year and compound at 8% (below average S&P return for our lifetimes). If you increase contribution along with pay increases the time to a million will be less, small changes in return % also make a huge difference.

Not exactly overnight, but also completely doable.

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by dabockster on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @01:16PM (#15907959)
The line of thinking here seems to be that, to get to $1M, you probably have learned a lot more than someone making only $50-60k a year. So not only would you have the capital, you'd also have the common sense not to make a poor investment.
Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by Gargoyle on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @04:24PM (#15909615)
People with a million dollars are no better at detecting bad investments than people without. If anything, they're worse because they imagine themselves to be far more sophisticated than they actually are. I've witnessed this time and again.
Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by saalweachter on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @03:17PM (#15909061)
Frankly I think there's also some sort of "sympathy level" in the law.

If a little old lady living on a fixed income loses all her meager savings to a huckster we feel a lot worse for her than if a Wall Street 1%er with three houses loses all his savings to the same huckster.

Which might not be the fairest or most logical way to legislate, but laws are about feelings as much as anything else.

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by crankylinuxuser on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @03:09PM (#15908990)
But it also continues the idea "Only the rich may get richer. These things are not for the little guy."

Unless we want to equate "Not having a great deal of money as someone who is too stupid to know how to invest."

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by s73ver_ on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @07:42PM (#15910974)
Except this entire discussion was kicked off by trying to evade reporting and disclosure regulations.
Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by zeroxfe on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @12:13PM (#15907280)
> And yet, that worthless fraudulent garbage is one of the few ways to get rich.

...for the founders of said fraudulent garbage and perhaps a small number of very lucky people.

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by Lazare on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @06:25PM (#15910492)
Everything you just said is shockinly wrong.

The issue with Kickstarter is that it gave you no ownership interest in Oculus. Your $400 was just a pre-order. But at least it's a pre-order! Whereas the issue with ICOs is that they give you no ownership interest. Your $400 is just a donation.

"The $400 would've become quite a handy sum by the time Oculus got acquired."

Only if you had purchased equity. An ICO is not equity. You're literally about being taken for a ride, and responding by wishing you could have been taken for a bigger ride, with fewer protections.

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by dabockster on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @01:13PM (#15907932)
> If Oculus had done an ICO instead of a kickstarter, my $400 wouldn't have been merely a preorder. The $400 would've become quite a handy sum by the time Oculus got acquired.

And Oculus could have just as easily took your $400 and vanished without a trace. Or you could have unknowingly purchased shares that were worthless to begin with.

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by jonknee on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @12:09PM (#15907244)
Or maybe your Oculus ICO would have been worthless because it wasn't an equity offering...
Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by wpietri on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @03:26PM (#15909136)
> And yet, that worthless fraudulent garbage is one of the few ways to get rich.

They are a much, much better way to get poor. There's a reason we have the laws we do: a long history of amateurs getting taken to the cleaners by professional fraudsters.

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by kordlessagain on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @12:19PM (#15907350)
> It protects the monopoly the investor class has on investments like these.

False.

If anything, it exposes consistently larger "chunks of value" to the risk involved in the investment. Given accredited investors are used to evaluating risk it simply allows the to participate freely in the unknown risks of these types of investment vehicles without getting smaller investors involved in the mix. (It also prevents them from using their position against lower investment amounts made by lower accredited individuals.)

The "protection" afforded here is to the common investor, who by definition does not carry a large store of value with them. By preventing them from investing directly, by way of limiting their involvement based on their stored values, the SEC is protecting the "collective stored value" of the lower classes. And, this makes sense, given the dollar's value is based in part on what people are willing to pay for a given set of objects. This is the responsibility of the Fed to US.

An analogy would be the Yap allowing their children to go and mine Rai Stones by themselves. No sensible society would allow this to occur, given the dangers. And, yes, I'm comparing lower accredited investors to children, when considering the amount of knowledge they may carry with them regarding risk.

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by njarboe on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @02:17PM (#15908545)
But you can bet $20,000 on the single spin of the roulette wheel and the expected value is negative.

If you are allowed to do investing when young and at low levels, like many other things in life, you could learn some great lessons and maybe you won't sell your 1/2 million dollar IRA investments for 1/4 million in a market downturn.

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by justrobert on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @12:56PM (#15907767)
And yet anyone can buy 3x leveraged ETF/ETNs and not understand how the products are structured. Some of those products, due to the structure, will always lose value over time as the futures used to replicate them are normally in contango.

So some financial products where they will always drift to zero are fine, but investments in companies that have a chance to profit aren't allowed.

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by tptacek on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @01:08PM (#15907881)
You can create a company that has ludicrously limited opportunities to return its capital, and sell those to the public. You simply have to comply with the SEC's registration and disclosure rules --- in particular, you have to publish quarterly audited financials confirming your limited prospects.

That is the difference between the "3x leveraged ETF" and the "company that has a chance at profit" in your example, not some weird value judgement the SEC is making.

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by jrs95 on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @12:32PM (#15907502)
Who the hell in the "lower classes" is investing their money? Even a good share of middle class Americans have no investments at all or so few that their net worth is either negligible or negative. The idea that the SEC needs to be "protecting" these people when buying lottery tickets and cigarettes is legal is laughable.
Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by ChuckMcM on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @02:27PM (#15908648)
That phrase, and the combination of 'monopoly' and 'investor class' tends to jar me because as I see it the truth is exactly opposite to the sentiment expressed. Rather than protect the 'investment class' it protects people who can't afford to lose all of their investment.

Part of the problem is a sort of systemic survivor bias where the accredited investors rarely talk about all the times they lost all of their investment, and instead focus on the ones where they made money (the more disproportionate the better). The reality is the most of the investment opportunities that are offered only to accredited investors lose money, and what that translates to is that most people, if allowed to invest in these things, would lose money they couldn't afford to lose.

It can be hard to see that when an angel investor crows about a huge payday from someone they helped get started. And in hindsight it is "easy" to see how that deal made perfect sense. But imagine if you were allowed in on Uber's last fundraising round and now they are in danger of a 40% 'down round' courtesy of SoftBank? That second mortgage you took out on the 'hottest startup in the bay area' starts looking like you're going to have to pay it back by your own labor.

Another argument I have heard made is "Hey, it's my money and who are you to tell me how to invest it?" (note told in the first person even though the 'you' reading this or commenting on it may have never made such an argument). I totally understand and resonate with that argument, but when you do invest it with someone who was very slick and had you completely believing that they could turn dog poo into gold, and it turns out after you lost your entire investment that they never really could and there was evidence in their books or history that, had you known, you never would have invested. Then you want them punished some how, but for what? Lying through omission and tricking you out of your money? And we have a system for that, its a bunch of regulations, imposed by the SEC, which allows the SEC to fine or jail people who violate them. And they include things like FD or Full Disclosure rules which demand they cannot lie to you by omission or it is on them. And if an investment is legit and they want to offer it to non-accredited investors, then the person selling the securities will go through the necessary hoops and there won't be an issue selling them to you.

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by hackinthebochs on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @02:56PM (#15908893)
> Rather than protect the 'investment class' it protects people who can't afford to lose all of their investment.

The problem is that this isn't a binary. To protect the hapless grandparents from losing their retirement, it also restricts knowledgeable but not rich people from making informed decisions for themselves.

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by spookthesunset on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @07:48PM (#15911002)
> To protect the hapless grandparents from losing their retirement, it also restricts knowledgeable but not rich people from making informed decisions for themselves.

Welcome to living in society. It is all give and take.

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by hackinthebochs on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @08:05PM (#15911090)
That's not an excuse for lazy policy.
Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by spookthesunset on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @08:28PM (#15911236)
Care to do better, taking into account the system that existed before it, the political climate at the time, the priority of the legislation vs other legislation, and all the other complex factors involved.

It’s easy to play armchair politician or legislator online....

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by erikpukinskis on Wednesday December 13, 2017 @12:35PM (#15915769)
How about:

- apply the same financial disclosure rules we use for public exchanges?

- or require insurance against failures to properly report risk

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by ChuckMcM on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @08:01PM (#15911070)
I am not sure I understand your point. Do you feel that accredited investors that lose money on their investments are either not knowledgeable or not informed?
Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by hackinthebochs on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @08:04PM (#15911088)
My point was pretty clear I think. There are people who are knowledgeable and informed about various investment opportunities who are not in the >$1MM net worth range. There is no good reason that those people should not be able to rationally take on the risk of an early investment. There are better ways to protect the uninformed than a blanket cut off.
Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by antr on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @11:44AM (#15906980)
you call it "investor class monopoly" (if such thing exists), I call it protecting citizens who can be easily duped
Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by whataretensors on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @11:53AM (#15907063)
Yet they don't protect people from pay day loans or from gambling. They only 'protect' intelligent people from getting out of the system they've rigged.

They also don't protect workers from getting worthless secondary 'common' stock.

Keep regurgitating their lies. It's working for them.

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by tptacek on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @12:14PM (#15907297)
When you take out a mortgage to bring more capital to a craps table, literally everybody involved knows you have a problem. The same is obviously not true for securities and speculative assets.
Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by mrep on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @12:31PM (#15907490)
That's completely different. Those are regulated so you know the exact deal you are getting up front.
Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by option_greek on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @12:11PM (#15907261)
The common stock is one of the most direct way of screwing workers. I guess anything is okay as long as it is part of fine print.
Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by jMyles on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @12:06PM (#15907192)
It's basically "think of the children!" except you extend childhood to all of life. Perfect, really.
Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by tptacek on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @12:41PM (#15907607)
You can sell securities to anybody, including (presumably) children. You simply have to register them with the SEC and follow the disclosure rules all the other thousands of publicly traded companies have to follow.

Heck, after the JOBS Act, it got even easier to do this under Reg A+, which allows for a lightweight IPO for raises under 50MM --- which describes most ICOs.

What's happening in this thread is simply special pleading for a particular type of enterprise to be exempt from those rules.

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by vkou on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @01:39PM (#15908178)
It's mindboggling how people are perfectly OK with raising 50-200 million dollars with an ICO, when they don't have a team, or a working product, but they can't possibly afford the expense and hassle of compliance, auditing and disclosure.
Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by michwill on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @02:55PM (#15908888)
There are two things here:

* It's not OK to raise 200M with no team and product;

* Compliance only creates obstructions, not protection.

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by tptacek on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @03:29PM (#15909164)
RegA+ companies don't require SEC proxy statements, director and 10% stockholder reporting, SOX independent audits, SOX internal controls documentations, or SOX CEO certification. Pretty much all they're required to do is create a quarterly audited financial report. How is that "obstruction, not protection"? What kind of company that ordinary people should invest in can't produce an audited financial report? Charities and nonprofits product audited financials!
Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by vkou on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @05:10PM (#15909975)
Thanks for bringing this up. I didn't realize just how lax the rules regarding being a Regulation A Plus company are.

You don't need to be an accredited investor to invest in one. You just need to limit your investment to no more then 10% of your salary, or net worth, whichever is greater.

There are currently over 150 Reg A+ companies in the United States. I am eagerly waiting for people lambasting how the accredited investor rule keeps out little people... To explain why little people aren't falling head over heels to invest in RegA+ corps.

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by michwill on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @03:52PM (#15909340)
Reg A+ is indeed easier than an IPO. I've seen some companies doing that, and it's 1 year pushback, to say at least.

One year is an insanely long time these days!

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by antr on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @12:24PM (#15907405)
Except the majority (let's say 99%) of all adults have zero financial literacy
Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by pishpash on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @02:10PM (#15908468)
Yet they are expected already to operate as if they do. What's one more thing?
Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by bdcravens on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @02:07PM (#15908440)
The "investor class" are prepared to handle loss. This isn't free money that oligarchy are keeping from the poor. Perhaps the floor is currently too high, but you should absolutely have savings before you consider investments where you stand to lose. In other words, an "investment class".
Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by igorgue on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @11:44AM (#15906982)
It's almost predictable how people will respond here to a comment like this...

You're 100% right.

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by bdcravens on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @02:11PM (#15908473)
Indeed. "Investor class" just means having enough saved, or enough income, that you are prepared to make investments where you can lose money. It's like saying those with FICO's over 480 have a monopoly on the ability to get a car loan, or that those with basic math skills have a monopoly on programming jobs.
Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by kodablah on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @03:40PM (#15909257)
> It's like saying those with FICO's over 480 have a monopoly on the ability to get a car loan, or that those with basic math skills have a monopoly on programming jobs.

Wrong. It's like saying there is a LAW requiring a certain credit score or a certain set of math skills. I don't have anything to add on whether investor accreditation is fair or not, but comparing federal law and regulations to loan or hiring opinions/choices is disingenuous. The comparison to predatory loan regulations or legal certification requirements for hiring would in fact be more apt.

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by bdcravens on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @04:30PM (#15909678)
That makes sense.
Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by indubitable on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @12:08PM (#15907222)
This also deters entrepreneurship from otherwise less established entities. The risk with regulations like this is that in attempting to keep out the scammers, you also end up keeping out smaller by otherwise completely authentic entities.

In the worst case you end up keeping out smaller players, yet the scammers find creative ways around the system. Take, for instance, patents. They were initially envisioned as a way for independent inventors to ensure their ideas were not stolen. But a century of absurdly complex rules and regulations paired with extreme fees mostly keeps out very small scale inventors. On the other hands, the scammers are seemingly as active as ever and completely inappropriate patents are still regularly granted. So what have we truly accomplished?

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by s73ver_ on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @12:21PM (#15907372)
If you're deterred by this kind of thing, then perhaps you're the kind of "entrepreneur" that should be discouraged. We absolutely do not need any more scammers in this space.
Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by indubitable on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @01:29PM (#15908088)
SEC compliance comes with extensive fees, delays, and a century of legalese. Coin offerings do not have to fall in the tens of millions of dollars. It's a practical way for smaller startups to raise small amounts of money. For instance the first company that started Musk's rise was Zip2 - and it was started with money that was in the 5 figures. A coin offering instead of angel investors could have been an interesting option for a similar company now a days. For companies on this scale, having to hire a legal team to ensure compliance is a significant burden.

How much do you think this will end up costing companies to comply with? Ultimately we'd all like to have 100% honest ICOs. But you have to balance the cost of compliance with the expected results. Many ICOs already block American investors and that was before this. How will this effect the rates of scams? How will this effect the rate of perfectly up and up ICOs that are not made available to US investors?

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by chickenfries on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @02:15PM (#15908519)
If an ICO is perfectly up and up they should abide by the same regulation as other securities. If you can’t afford the regulation then you can’t afford to sell securities. It seems like ICO boosters have a hard time believing that everyone isn’t a libertarian who wants there to be no regulation on ICOs.
Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by kodablah on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @03:44PM (#15909287)
> If you can’t afford the regulation then you can’t afford to sell securities.

People are growing tired of the pay-to-play barriers to entry. Why can't we have the regulations without the financial burdens? (Hint: the answer is not about following the regulations themselves, but artificially limiting supply to make for easier enforcement. Otherwise there are too many to meaningfully regulate.)

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by chickenfries on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @04:20PM (#15909587)
No I think people in general are quite happy with the SEC and pay-to-play barriers. The boosters looking to make money of ICOs and such may be tired of the SEC, but that's like saying unlicensed drivers are tired of the cops.
Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by kodablah on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @04:40PM (#15909774)
> I think people in general are quite happy with the SEC and pay-to-play barriers

I think you are probably right. But as crowdfunding (er, "crowd investing") becomes more available to the masses and the SEC cracks down on it more, a whole group of people that otherwise were unfamiliar w/ these rules aren't going to remain happy. I would not be surprised to see the barriers relaxed (but not the regulations of course).

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by s73ver_ on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @04:06PM (#15909467)
"Why can't we have the regulations without the financial burdens?"

If you can find people willing to work for your without pay, you can.

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by kodablah on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @04:18PM (#15909562)
I'm questioning the amount of work required as the burden, not the humans. IIRC, the SEC filings require multi-thousand dollar fees. Many government services do not (or not at that level). Do you believe all of those other government services are making people work without pay? I don't think it's fair that you blindly assume the fees are equal to the administrative costs when it seems clear to me they are set at a level to detract the action.
Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by chickenfries on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @04:23PM (#15909609)
How many government services require hours of work by lawyers per application?

If you can't cough up a few thousand dollars or take our a small business loan to hire some lawyers, why should I believe that you're trustworthy enough to skirt regulations?

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by kodablah on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @04:37PM (#15909752)
I'm saying the application shouldn't require hours of work by lawyers any more than filing for an LLC or my tax filings require individual lawyer review.

In my head, I read the last statement like "why should the law trust you if you don't have enough money, and why should you be allowed to do something without the law's trust?" I believe enforcement should be reactive on regulation skirting within reason. Akin to an audit, an arrest, or anything else. You agree to abide by laws, you may even sign something or fill out a form to that effect. That there is an extra step to see if you "really" agree seems to be a way to artificially limit filing counts. I admit I am not that knowledgeable on possible history where too many did fraudulent filings requiring this individual-lawyer-review preemption.

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by chickenfries on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @06:11PM (#15910374)
> I admit I am not that knowledgeable on possible history where too many did fraudulent filings requiring this individual-lawyer-review preemption.

So youre criticizing an institution while being ignorant of the conditions that caused that institution to come about? I suspect you’re not alone in this thread but this kind of ahistoricity makes it impossible to have any kind of reasonable civic discourse. Democracy demands that we educate ourselves. Read about the Great Depression, the creation of the SEC and why it was needed in the first place. The current situation with ICOs where you have some legitimate businessses and some scams advertising themselves to Main Street investors is very similar to the situation with securities before the SEC.

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by kodablah on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @07:28PM (#15910887)
Sigh. No, I specifically said I am not aware of the historical reason that preemptive gatekeeping was chosen in lieu of normal enforcement. I am unsure how you read it as why the SEC came about. Regardless, it was a tongue in cheek way to say it's an abnormal law enforcement approach not based on failure/need.
Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by chickenfries on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @08:05PM (#15911094)
I'm sorry, I didn't mean to read your claims uncharitably. I'm not sure I get your point now even though you've told me you were being sarcastic.

> I am unsure how you read it as why the SEC came about.

Visiting your original statement: > I admit I am not that knowledgeable on possible history where too many did fraudulent filings requiring this individual-lawyer-review preemption.

This "possible history where too many did fraudulent filings" is the history immediately preceding the creation of the SEC, the period before and during the Great Depression. Things like ICO scams are exactly what the SEC was created to respond to. Securities with no inherent value driven by speculation. I'm sure many will argue that this is unfair to the law abiding ICOs and that's true. But the SEC prevents a deluge of fraudulent securities from taking peoples money and doing the damage in the first place.

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by s73ver_ on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @07:07PM (#15910765)
"I admit I am not that knowledgeable on possible history where too many did fraudulent filings requiring this individual-lawyer-review preemption."

I feel you really, really do need to make yourself familiar with that before chastising everyone for not agreeing with your position on these regulations. And if you want to argue that they shouldn't apply, then you need to think long and hard about what makes this situation different, and not just because it's "on a computer".

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by kodablah on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @07:32PM (#15910902)
It's a bad way to enforce these laws. I didn't chastise anyone for disagreeing nor did I say anything was different because something happens on a computer. And I never said the regulations shouldn't apply, but that I think they should be enforced like, say, tax or employment regulations and punish the offenders instead of artificially limiting the players. Maybe you're referring to someone else's comment?

Can you help me become familiar with the historical SEC failure that prevents them from accepting applications for non-accredited investment without strict preemptive oversight? Or more simply why can't I register a security like I register a company? Because my historical understanding is RegD has been there since the beginning of the SEC.

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by s73ver_ on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @07:48PM (#15911004)
You can. Look at the JOBS Act. There is a provision allowing you to raise money with far laxer rules than going public. Really the only thing you need is a quarterly audited report. And if you can't get that, then no, you should not be raising money.
Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by kodablah on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @08:15PM (#15911166)
I had read that it costs several thousand per quarter for those audited reports. Still Title IV is a step forward, I agree. Granted others get to raise money from VCs or crowdfunding without those, just not securities.
Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by s73ver_ on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @04:48PM (#15909826)
If you've got evidence to back up that claim, feel free. Remember, however, that the people the SEC employs for doing this are expensive.
Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by s73ver_ on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @04:05PM (#15909461)
If you're only focusing on the costs of compliance, then you're looking at the wrong thing.

"Coin offerings do not have to fall in the tens of millions of dollars."

The amount of money does not matter; a scam is a scam.

"For companies on this scale, having to hire a legal team to ensure compliance is a significant burden."

That sucks for them. But the alternative is far, far worse.

"A coin offering instead of angel investors could have been an interesting option for a similar company now a days."

Why? If the only reason is that they don't have to comply with the reporting and transparency regulations, then it's not a good reason.

"But you have to balance the cost of compliance with the expected results."

Why? And, quite frankly, why should an ICO be treated any differently than any other security? They are exactly the same; and have absolutely nothing differentiating them from traditional securities.

"How will this effect the rate of perfectly up and up ICOs that are not made available to US investors?"

I'm going to say it won't. Perfectly up and up ICOs will be able to get compliance, and will thus be open to all.

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by gst on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @12:08PM (#15907212)
> I hope that these actions clear house of the scams

Wouldn't the scams just get launched from other countries that don't have to care about the SEC?

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by abritinthebay on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @12:32PM (#15907494)
Sure, and they’ll join Nigerian Email Scams where they belong
Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by thrill on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @12:30PM (#15907470)
Just like the valid entrepreneurial efforts will.
Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by tarsinge on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @11:45AM (#15906994)
Good projects which will then be only available to accredited (i.e. already rich) investors? This defeats the purpose for me
Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by sdenton4 on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @12:22PM (#15907379)
If you're smart enough to tell a good investment from a scam, why don't you have enough money to be an accredited investor?

Or, in other words, by the time the plebes are jumping in on crazy new financial scheme X, you're well enough into bubble phase that restricting investment is probably fine.

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by tarsinge on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @01:54PM (#15908304)
Have you seen the requirements to get accredited? How do you get there starting with a modest capital without taking insane risks?

But beyond that I don’t understand why regulation on investment is seen as ok, but regulation in loans to prevent people to drown in debt (which is kind of worse) is frowned upon. I’m not even the most liberal person, but if people are free to lose more than they have (or buy guns, or destroy their health with sugar, or what else) then why are they not free to put their money where they want?

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by chickenfries on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @02:18PM (#15908554)
Because lots of people losing all of their money on bad investments has effects on the whole economy, see the Great Depression.
Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by tarsinge on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @02:33PM (#15908705)
But when it’s institutions like in 2008 it’s ok?
Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by chickenfries on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @02:41PM (#15908784)
No, that's a problem too? Why does everyone respond with "oh so you think payday loans and subprime mortgages are OK?"

Do you actually want to go back to a time before the SEC. That's how you get a Great Depression.

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by hackinthebochs on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @02:15PM (#15908523)
>If you're smart enough to tell a good investment from a scam, why don't you have enough money to be an accredited investor?

Do you not see the obvious chicken-and-egg problem here?

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by sdenton4 on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @09:20PM (#15911505)
You're a smart guy, solve it.
Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by subroutine on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @12:16PM (#15907316)
You mean, exactly like authorized shares of common stock?

How is this any different than traditional corporate capitalization?

Did you set aside a large pool of tokens for a potential investor who prefers convertible equity?

A reserve for an option pool? How will employee stock options..erm..sorry..'token options' plan work?

If your company is successful, and a great offer comes up to exit, what's the plan for M&A using tokens?

Most importantly, why would investors want coin over stock? Are they given all the same legal company equity rights as traditional stock?

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by Alex3917 on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @11:25AM (#15906776)
> Our approach to "get around" this is to file all the necessary paperwork for a legal security and then only sell the token to accredited investors.

How does this square with the SEC commissioner's statement yesterday that not a single ICO has registered to do a security offering?

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by Kubuxu on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @11:37AM (#15906910)
By requiring all investors to be accredited you are exempt from the long registration process with SEC. The law in question is "Rule 506(c) of Regulation D", see: https://www.sec.gov/fast-answers/answers-rule506htm.html
Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by sillysaurus3 on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @11:25AM (#15906781)
Can you give a brief checklist (or notes, or anything at all) regarding the necessary paperwork? What's involved?
Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by dangero on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @12:13PM (#15907285)
But how are you going to make the coin available for liquid trading in the future?
Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by s73ver_ on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @12:15PM (#15907313)
Can I ask why you'd still go ahead with a token after all that, instead of doing a normal security? With all the same reporting and other regulations as a security, what does being a token get you?
Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by Lazare on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @06:22PM (#15910463)
It's slightly sad - and quite funny - that "following the law" is seen as a novel, intriguing approach that can set you apart from the competition. :)
Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by homakov on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @11:23AM (#15906761)
What are the steps and costs to do same? Who is accredited investors btw?
Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by tptacek on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @11:25AM (#15906784)
https://www.sec.gov/files/ib_accreditedinvestors.pdf

Generally: earning over 200k/yr, or having a net worth over 1MM excluding your house.

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by whataretensors on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @11:56AM (#15907089)
tldr; 10000% returns are limited to club members only
Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by tptacek on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @12:45PM (#15907659)
tldr; exemption from SEC disclosure laws that protect investors of all classes are limited to club members only.
Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by komali2 on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @12:11PM (#15907259)
Wait, and people are arguing that this process isn't an arbitrary class lock out?
Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by tptacek on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @12:16PM (#15907319)
I don't know what "class lock out" means, but the restriction is pretty obviously there to prevent people from staking their livelihoods and financial futures on unvetted offerings.

The idea is that people who have high incomes or high net worths (a) either are financially sophisticated, or can trivially afford financially sophisticated advisors, and (b) are unlikely to be staking so much on a single deal that their long term outcomes will be at risk.

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by komali2 on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @12:48PM (#15907692)
How do you correlate existent material wealth with any of your claims?

What's to stop an inheritor from making a poor investment with all their capital? Or a lottery winner? Or ANYBODY with that kind of money, really?

Why is it presumed that at "arbitrary net worth 1 million," a person is "financially sophisticated?"

If the sec wants to I guess "protect people from themselves," why don't they have an actual certification system that is based on a demonstration of knowledge?

Finally, why aren't people with a net worth of under 1 million protected from other poor financial decisions, since in your mind they are not "financially sophisticated" and thus are more likely to engage in payday loans or other predatory financial institutions?

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by dahdum on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @02:18PM (#15908553)
> 'Why is it presumed that at "arbitrary net worth 1 million," a person is "financially sophisticated?'

It's not so much proving they are financially sophisticated as it is saying they have enough that "they are on their own". For instance, I can't recall many people caring about the wealthy who lost so much in the Madoff scandal. Most opinions seemed to be "they should have known better".

> 'If the sec wants to I guess "protect people from themselves," why don't they have an actual certification system that is based on a demonstration of knowledge?'

You can actually be exempt from the income/wealth requirements if you are an investment advisor / registered broker. I believe you can be an executive at the issuer and be exempt to.

> 'Finally, why aren't people with a net worth of under 1 million protected from other poor financial decisions, since in your mind they are not "financially sophisticated" and thus are more likely to engage in payday loans or other predatory financial institutions?'

SEC doesn't regulate those. I agree predatory lending should be reigned in though.

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by tptacek on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @12:53PM (#15907741)
Actually, I agree that the RegD numbers are arbitrary. They should be much higher: they haven't tracked inflation. A person with 200k in annual income in 2017 is by no means necessarily in a position where they can safely invest in securities that have exempted themselves from disclosure requirements to their investors.
Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by DennisP on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @01:18PM (#15907985)
On the other hand, someone with $150K income and $800K net worth can easily afford a $5K investment, and is probably sophisticated enough to not be completely stupid about it. It makes more sense to use percentages rather than a fixed cutoff (and in fact that's what the JOBS Act does).
Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by tptacek on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @01:55PM (#15908315)
And, in fact, even if you make $50k a year, you can invest up to low-thousands in RegCF regulated issuances, or even more in a Reg A+ mini-IPO issuance.

By and large, the entities pursuing 8-figure ICOs are those that (a) don't want to spend $10,000-$20,000 to engage with the SEC and adhere to their disclosure rules, and (b) aren't credible enough to raise from accredited investors.

What's crazy to me is the notion that a business venture that can't scrap together $20,000 should somehow obviously be entrusted with $15,000,000 of retail investor money.

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by cptaj on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @04:13PM (#15909535)
What I don't like is the "accredited investors" part. That just means its going to be just as hard as getting stock which is prohibitive to a lot of investors in the world.
Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by dreit1 on Wednesday December 13, 2017 @12:45AM (#15912305)
Is this possible? Hold ICO, sell like 5% to accredited investor. The rest is reserved for team. Sell 35% on the open market at a fixed price.
Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by Nursie on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @12:41PM (#15907605)
Yeah that doesn't sound so much a workaround as it does "doing things properly"
Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by IncRnd on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @11:37AM (#15906905)
Did they discuss Title IV of JOBS with you?
Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by bluesign on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @01:52PM (#15908277)
Will be easy, i think to evade:

- setup a system that looks like it will increase value of your token over time

(as MUN case: “As more users get on the platform, the more valuable your MUN tokens will become”)

- don't make any promises about increase in value/income about your token.

- let people discover and share, or promote on side channels.

IANAL but as far as I searched, I guess as long as you don't make any value increase claims etc, you are totally safe

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by pmarreck on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @12:13PM (#15907288)
Good news: ICO's are now technically a security!

Bad news: ICO's are now technically a security!