News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by ChuckMcM on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @02:27PM (#15908648)
That phrase, and the combination of 'monopoly' and 'investor class' tends to jar me because as I see it the truth is exactly opposite to the sentiment expressed. Rather than protect the 'investment class' it protects people who can't afford to lose all of their investment.

Part of the problem is a sort of systemic survivor bias where the accredited investors rarely talk about all the times they lost all of their investment, and instead focus on the ones where they made money (the more disproportionate the better). The reality is the most of the investment opportunities that are offered only to accredited investors lose money, and what that translates to is that most people, if allowed to invest in these things, would lose money they couldn't afford to lose.

It can be hard to see that when an angel investor crows about a huge payday from someone they helped get started. And in hindsight it is "easy" to see how that deal made perfect sense. But imagine if you were allowed in on Uber's last fundraising round and now they are in danger of a 40% 'down round' courtesy of SoftBank? That second mortgage you took out on the 'hottest startup in the bay area' starts looking like you're going to have to pay it back by your own labor.

Another argument I have heard made is "Hey, it's my money and who are you to tell me how to invest it?" (note told in the first person even though the 'you' reading this or commenting on it may have never made such an argument). I totally understand and resonate with that argument, but when you do invest it with someone who was very slick and had you completely believing that they could turn dog poo into gold, and it turns out after you lost your entire investment that they never really could and there was evidence in their books or history that, had you known, you never would have invested. Then you want them punished some how, but for what? Lying through omission and tricking you out of your money? And we have a system for that, its a bunch of regulations, imposed by the SEC, which allows the SEC to fine or jail people who violate them. And they include things like FD or Full Disclosure rules which demand they cannot lie to you by omission or it is on them. And if an investment is legit and they want to offer it to non-accredited investors, then the person selling the securities will go through the necessary hoops and there won't be an issue selling them to you.

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by hackinthebochs on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @02:56PM (#15908893)
> Rather than protect the 'investment class' it protects people who can't afford to lose all of their investment.

The problem is that this isn't a binary. To protect the hapless grandparents from losing their retirement, it also restricts knowledgeable but not rich people from making informed decisions for themselves.

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by spookthesunset on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @07:48PM (#15911002)
> To protect the hapless grandparents from losing their retirement, it also restricts knowledgeable but not rich people from making informed decisions for themselves.

Welcome to living in society. It is all give and take.

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by hackinthebochs on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @08:05PM (#15911090)
That's not an excuse for lazy policy.
Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by spookthesunset on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @08:28PM (#15911236)
Care to do better, taking into account the system that existed before it, the political climate at the time, the priority of the legislation vs other legislation, and all the other complex factors involved.

It’s easy to play armchair politician or legislator online....

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by erikpukinskis on Wednesday December 13, 2017 @12:35PM (#15915769)
How about:

- apply the same financial disclosure rules we use for public exchanges?

- or require insurance against failures to properly report risk

Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by ChuckMcM on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @08:01PM (#15911070)
I am not sure I understand your point. Do you feel that accredited investors that lose money on their investments are either not knowledgeable or not informed?
Re:SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO by hackinthebochs on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @08:04PM (#15911088)
My point was pretty clear I think. There are people who are knowledgeable and informed about various investment opportunities who are not in the >$1MM net worth range. There is no good reason that those people should not be able to rationally take on the risk of an early investment. There are better ways to protect the uninformed than a blanket cut off.