When the primary determination is whether you already _have_ money, rather than education, professional history, earning potential, or a history of demonstrated ability to make informed investment decisions... it becomes extremely difficult to argue that its anything other than an artificial class barrier.
VC funding will probably dry up somewhat during the present recession, like it usually does in bad times. But this time the result may be different. This time the number of new startups may not decrease. And that could be dangerous for VCs.
When VC funding dried up after the Internet Bubble, startups dried up too. There were not a lot of new startups being founded in 2003. But startups aren't tied to VC the way they were 10 years ago. It's now possible for VCs and startups to diverge. And if they do, they may not reconverge once the economy gets better.
This logic works in reverse, too: if funding becomes dramatically easier thanks to ICOs, startups have no reason to court VCs anymore. And that could be dangerous for VCs.
What exactly would the problem be with letting people crowdfund startups (i.e. equity)? Why not follow Filecoin's lead? I've been reading your arguments and you haven't really articulated your concerns; just persuasive cases that the status quo should be maintained.
The next Google/FB/Netflix might very well start using the model here, if you let it. But only if they have access to capital. And right now, that means VCs.
I agree with tptacek's general thesis here: there's not any inherent difference between ICOs and "normal" early-stage investing that justifies an utter lack of regulation of the former but not the latter.
Startups are one of the most risky investments you can make. By arguing for regular folks to invest in startups, you just convey your ignorance in the risks associated with them. Most startups fail which is why full time investors invest in many startups and due extreme diligence because it is such a hosh posh of scams and people overselling their company.
This is just not even remotely true. Plenty of people have those things but haven't yet been able to acquire the money to qualify as an accredited investor. This line of reasoning is like the oligarch's dream.
"If you were as smart as me you would have as much money as me and could invest like I do. Also, until you have as much money as me, I won't let you invest like I did to get all this money, because if you don't already have as much money as I already have you must not be as smart as me and clearly can't understand the kind of investing I do. In fact, I will make it illegal for you to invest like I did until you come up with as much money as I already have from doing those things that you are not allowed to do."
This is the case because many regulations (Tax code, laws) favor the wealthy. If we didn't have the SEC regulations, then the clever and wealthy would prey on the poor and uneducated. This is textbook what happened in the 20s.
Honestly, the SEC is probably one of the last decent regulatory bodies of our government.
A fact people seem to overlook in these discussions is that unless you can see the future, you can't just invest in Google and Airbnb; you invest in a sample of the whole tech startup market. And when you do that, by and large, you underperform the S&P 500.
Funds and endowments invest as VC LPs not simply because they want access to the insane deals that startups provide, but because they want decorrelated investments: they want some of their money allocated to investments that will perform differently than the market as a whole. When you have billions under management, it makes total sense to throw tens of millions at tech startups.
To quote The Dude "Well, that's just like your opinion, man". I think your point is that the intention of the law is so that people are manipulated into buying securities they can't afford (e.g. scams). This is true, however some would argue that this legislation is yet another reason the rich continue to stay rich, which is a legitimate argument. So I wouldn't be so dismissive of that opinion.
How do people making this argument think money works? People that can commit $20,000,000 to an investment with the stroke of a pen are going to get the best opportunities no matter how they're structured: they can offer better terms. Literally the only thing retail investors could conceivably offer to compete with them is "willingness to be screwed over without recourse".
Stipulate a future in which essentially no ICO is regulated, and most new venture raises happen with publicly traded ICOs. Follow that thought to its conclusion and explain to me how the best opportunities are going to provide 10,000% gains, rather than markets acting the way all logic in either direction about ICOs dictates they must act, and pricing risk and opportunity accordingly?
I see how, in the post- free-ICO world, you'll be able to bet that restaurant review coupons will 10x your money. Coupons for everything. 10x your money on dog washing and cat sharing; that'll happen too.
What I don't see is why the truly credible teams doing truly important work with a real chance of success are going to offer securities on those same terms. How does that work? How stupid would you have to be to look at a market where restaurant review coupons are worth $15MM because they're certain! to 9x your investment, and then go to market with the next generation of, say, the Cisco Catalyst 9400 switch on those exact same terms?
Aren't restaurant review coupons in some sense the ceiling on how too-good-to-be-true these ICO deals can be? I mean: that business is obviously not going to work. A reasonably sophisticated person can only put money on it in the hopes that someone dumber will buy it off them in a week or two.
Please refrain from aggressively straw manning me. We said nothing like that and you know that’s not our position. You’re trying to reducto ad absurdim us without actually doing the reducto part.
I see it this way: there are many different ways to structure a funding event: a bank loan, a bond issuance, an ICO, a partnership, a Series A, etc.
If we’re talking about a small scale, say $100k, but none of my investors have very much money, just a few hundred maybe, I am dramatically limited in the sorts of funding structures I can legally use.
If my investors all have millions of dollars and are putting in 10s of thousands, I can legally structure the deal however I like.
I think that’s an unfair limitation that makes it harder to start businesses that no rich person would ever care about.
I do care about protecting investors, but I think the wealth requirement is the laziest possible way to do that. Mandatory disclosure rules would be better. Requiring insurance would be better.
Just because you don't understand the logic of the argument doesn't invalidate it.
I think we both agree that allowing anyone to invest without an accreditation is probably harmful, however don't you think it's worth discussing/investigating the negative externalities of such an accreditation?
Your argument hinges on the assumption that the government should protect people from this outcome. If they make a bad bet, it's their bet to lose.
Right now, churches ask for thousands of dollars via mail. People send them with the hopes that they are "planting a seed" and to "watch that seed grow." All of this behavior goes on without society collapsing.
What's the key difference? Why do people need to be protected when suddenly they have a chance of winning real returns, however remote?
And I tend to agree.
The difference between a restaurant review coupon ICO and a pink sheet biotech firm isn't risk. Both will almost certainly fail. The difference is that the ICO refuses to publish audited financials, and demands the right to shoot Youtube videos extolling a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to 9x an investment.
That's what the SEC is protecting retail investors from.
An ICO is not a bad alternative to pre-seed funding.
Changing the word "stock" to "coin" doesn't change any of the underlying dynamics.