News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by llamaz on Saturday December 09, 2017 @01:35PM (#15887224)
How good you are at Go (or chess for that matter) has no correlation with your IQ. There are plenty of examples of people extremely good at chess that struggle, seriously, with academics (e.g. world champion Jose Raul Capablanca, and the youtuber and grandmaster Eric Hansen). Kasparov doesn't have 180+ IQ, which is a common myth. At some point he took the test and it turned out he had a respectable but definitely sub-Mensa IQ.
Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by DoreenMichele on Saturday December 09, 2017 @02:00PM (#15887372)
Richard Feynman, one of the most respected geniuses of our era, tested as only having an IQ of 125. IQ tests are far from perfect, to say the least. This means our concept of IQ is likely inherently flawed.

Feynman seemed to take glee in sharing his "low" IQ of only a 125. He was one of the smartest men on the planet in the last 100 years. Surely, we should defer to his opinion that the concept IQ is sort of a joke. ;)

Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by curun1r on Saturday December 09, 2017 @04:03PM (#15888132)
> This means our concept of IQ is likely inherently flawed

I'm not sure I'd say flawed so much as I'd say myopic. Which is absolutely still a flaw, but a very specific one that allows you to contextualize the results of an IQ test rather than discard them as worthless. IQ measures a subset of human intelligence pretty effectively, but misses the bigger picture. There's large parts of human intelligence that can't be measured using a test like that. A test can only provide stimuli for the mind and measure its reaction over the short period of time while taking the test. Among other things, it can't measure long-term recall or the ability to rehearse/learn information and skills over time, both qualities people would naturally associate with intelligence.

It's our need to have a single spectrum from mental retardation to genius-level that's led us to try to create a test which assigns a number to intelligence. But intelligence is multidimensional and an IQ test just fills in some of those dimensions.

Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by Houshalter on Saturday December 09, 2017 @07:40PM (#15889035)
>Among other things, it can't measure long-term recall or the ability to rehearse/learn information and skills over time

The vocabulary battery would seem to measure long term memorization ability. It actually correlates with IQ better than any other test. Also SAT tests are often used as a proxy for IQ because they correlate so well with it.

>It's our need to have a single spectrum from mental retardation to genius-level that's led us to try to create a test which assigns a number to intelligence. But intelligence is multidimensional and an IQ test just fills in some of those dimensions.

No, it's not. Please learn what you are talking about. It was once believed that intelligence was multidimensional. But then scientists realized all those different dimensions correlated amazingly well. E.g. people with better memory were much more likely to be better at puzzle solving. And a single factor, g, could explain most of the variance. IQ tests try to measure g, which is very predictive of general cognitive ability.

Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by barry-cotter on Saturday December 09, 2017 @11:17PM (#15889877)
> Also SAT tests are often used as a proxy for IQ because they correlate so well with it.

That understates it. The SAT is an IQ test, strenuously as the College Board May deny it. The test was originally the scholastic aptitude test and results from it correlate with other IQ tests just as well as results from IQ tests correlate with each other.

If anybody reading wants to know more about the broad field of which IQ is a small part the Wikipedia article on psychometrics is quite good.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Psychometrics

Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by wallace_f on Saturday December 09, 2017 @07:29PM (#15889006)
It's like predicting an NFL player's performance based on stats--40 time,bench press, etc. They do these rather arbitrary tests, and over a lot of players there is some limited positive correlation with performance, but individually it does not mean very much. There are people with amazing stats that do not succeed.

Then for baseball players, everyhing changes.

Intelligence or smart are low-information, high-emotional-signalling terms. It means more about social status than anything else. Everyone has a mix of abilities. Some of the best engineers are terrible writers. Some are incompetent fathers (Steve Jobs). Some people are great at consuming and regurgitating a lot of info, but bad at original/critical thought. Some who would thrive in one life circumstance may struggle in another.

Academically, IQ is supposed to correlate with g, general intelligence. In other words,we're just creatures making up nonsense terms to, at face value, signal about ability, but it's often more of a social construct.

Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by ralfd on Saturday December 09, 2017 @03:31PM (#15887938)
http://infoproc.blogspot.de/2008/07/annals-of-psychometry-iq...

Stephen Hsu argued there that Feynmans school iq test must have had a low ceiling. From what we know about the consistently high IQ scores of other incredibly bright theoretical scientists that sounds likely.

Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by DoreenMichele on Saturday December 09, 2017 @03:39PM (#15887984)
The reality is that most IQ tests do not go all that high. It is quite challenging to get an accurate IQ score above a certain range. It requires not only the right assessment tools -- ie tests -- but a trained professional administering it. Gifted kids mess with test administrators all the time, sometimes intentionally so. (Plus, to get a super high score, you need to test the child by about age 7. After that age, we just cannot reliably assert that someone's IQ is, say, above 200.)

If the test administered to Feynman only went to 130, as some do, then a test score anywhere close to that, such as 125, can be assumed to have "ceilinged the test." It can be viewed as a floor for the person's IQ, a minimum score suggesting it is at least that high.

Thus, Stephen Hsu's assertion that it must have just been a bad test with a low ceiling suggests to me that Mr. Hsu knows a great deal less about IQ tests than I know, so I see no reason to defer to his opinion.

Yet, also, IQ tests are strongly influenced by cultural knowledge, good scores in kids strongly correlate to kids coming from upper middle class families with well educated parents, etc. So I think there is quite a lot of room for saying that if you take any child and feed them excellently well, dote on them, invest a lot of parental and societal time, effort and other resources in them, they will tend to perform better than average, both on IQ tests and in life generally.

I am not just screwing with people here. I have studied the space and I think there are serious problems with talking about IQ like it is concrete, unchangeable, primarily inherited with minimal influence from environmental inputs, etc.

Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by WillPostForFood on Saturday December 09, 2017 @04:06PM (#15888149)
If the test administered to Feynman only went to 130, as some do, then a test score anywhere close to that, such as 125, can be assumed to have "ceilinged the test." It can be viewed as a floor for the person's IQ, a minimum score suggesting it is at least that high.

Thus, Stephen Hsu's assertion that it must have just been a bad test with a low ceiling suggests to me that Mr. Hsu knows a great deal less about IQ tests than I know, so I see no reason to defer to his opinion.

Maybe there is some nuance I'm missing, but those two paragraphs seem to be arguing the same point - that a 125 score was probably not accurate, but hitting the ceiling of the test? I.e. you and Hsu agree. Here is Hsu's full quotation (never said "bad").

To understand this score we have to remember that typical IQ tests (e.g., administered to public school children) tend to have low ceilings. They are not of the kind that Roe used in her study. One can imagine that the ceiling on Feynman's exam was roughly 135 (say, 99th percentile). If Feynman received the highest score on the mathematical portion, and a modest score of 115 on the verbal, we can easily understand the resulting average of 124.

Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by DoreenMichele on Saturday December 09, 2017 @04:16PM (#15888201)
TLDR: Stephen Hsu and I are coming from very different mental models. His mental model asserts that it is very, very important that we keep promoting this elitist intellectual stuff. Note how he has fancy degrees and is important enough to get interviewed, while I remain some big fat nobody, having walked away from my National Merit Scholarship and done the full time homemaker thing for a lot of years, in part because I could not stomach the toxic environment involved in being One Of The Smart Kids (that all the teachers trained everyone else to hate).

I elaborated some on my mental model in this paragraph:

Yet, also, IQ tests are strongly influenced by cultural knowledge, good scores in kids strongly correlate to kids coming from upper middle class families with well educated parents, etc. So I think there is quite a lot of room for saying that if you take any child and feed them excellently well, dote on them, invest a lot of parental and societal time, effort and other resources in them, they will tend to perform better than average, both on IQ tests and in life generally.

Part of what I am arguing is that we make up a measurement that validates that our "best" people -- like well educated, well heeled white males -- are best because they have this innate quality called high IQ and then we channel the "smart kids" from "good homes" into classes that cause them to test well.

The mental model that some kids are inherently more deserving of investment at school because they are smarter and do better than other kids winds up being self-fulfilling prophesy. Sort of like redlining of Black neighborhoods was self-fulfilling prophesy, causing Blacks to remain poor and their neighborhoods to remain not worth investing in by banks.

So, hopefully that clarifies it for you because I already said I am stepping away from this discussion.

Adieu.

Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by wavegeek on Sunday December 10, 2017 @05:52AM (#15890865)
> we make up a measurement that validates that our "best" people -- like well educated, well heeled white males

The only trouble with your theory is that IQ actually does a very good job of predicting how well members of various minorities will do in life. Half a century you could argue the cultural bias hypothesis but it no longer flies. The tests have been updated and taking "culturally biased" questions out actually made minority scores go down (possibly due to lower G loading on those questions).

> The mental model that some kids are inherently more deserving of investment at school because they are smarter

Of course the test would be "what is the marginal benefit of education to this person" a very different question from what is their IQ level.

You just seem to be making stuff up to fit your ideological preconceptions.

Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by WillPostForFood on Saturday December 09, 2017 @04:20PM (#15888227)
Your greater disagreement with Hsu seems to be clouding your view on narrow point that you actually agree with him on.
Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by DoreenMichele on Saturday December 09, 2017 @04:26PM (#15888248)
That feels to me a little like someone telling me "We both agree that this person is currently a slave, so let's not allow your heartfelt belief that slavery is immoral interfere with our use of this slave. Moving on."

And I imagine I will regret saying that, but I can't see letting that stand and saying nothing.

Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by WillPostForFood on Saturday December 09, 2017 @07:44PM (#15889048)
No. It is actually one person saying, that's a slave, and you responding, no you are wrong, that's a slave, and you are wrong because we disagree about slavery.

Hsu said there was a ceiling on the test, you said he was wrong, there was a ceiling on the test, and IQ is flawed.

Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by lucio on Saturday December 09, 2017 @05:40PM (#15888599)
>Yet, also, IQ tests are strongly influenced by cultural knowledge

Raven Progressive Matrices, I believe the most used IQ test today is not influenced by cultural knowledge. IQ has an amazingly high correlation with academic success and work success, see https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jSo5v5t4OQM it is worthwhile

Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by DoreenMichele on Saturday December 09, 2017 @06:57PM (#15888888)
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Raven%27s_Progressive_Matric...

Wikipedia says that people with autism and asperger's outperform other people on Raven's tests. Most people view ASD individuals as seriously cognitively impaired and they are often seen as low IQ, so I have trouble with your assertion. It suggests that people the world sees as highly impaired whose lives typically are harder than average are smarter than the rest of us. This completely flies in the face of every definition I have ever seen for IQ as a general predictor of competence.

Wikipedia also says the answers for Raven's matrices have been leaked, making them useless as an assessment tool.

Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by Houshalter on Saturday December 09, 2017 @07:52PM (#15889090)
>Most people view ASD individuals as seriously cognitively impaired and they are often seen as low IQ, so I have trouble with your assertion.

Popular culture stereotypes autists as being highly intelligent.

Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by DoreenMichele on Saturday December 09, 2017 @08:41PM (#15889298)
https://www.appliedbehavioranalysisedu.org/is-autism-associa...

The very existence of autism calls into question our historical conceptualization of intelligence and IQ testing.

I have two ASD sons. They are very bright. They also have some serious personal struggles.

So, which is it? Does IQ measure general competence or does it measure something else? Because this latest twist in the conversation seems just ridiculous.

Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by Houshalter on Saturday December 09, 2017 @09:29PM (#15889486)
I have no idea what you think this is supposed to prove. People with a weird brain condition have weird results on brain tests?

>Does IQ measure general competence or does it measure something else?

It's an Intelligence Quotient. It measures intelligence. No one said anything about "general competence", whatever that even means. I imagine intelligence is an important part of "general competence" though.

Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by sydd on Sunday December 10, 2017 @05:46AM (#15890844)
No, this is one of the biggest misundertandings about the IQ tests. It does not measure inteeligence, it measures something which we tagged with the name "IQ".

We cannot measure intelligence, since we cant even define it properly (in a way that we attach a measurement unit ot it).

Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by Houshalter on Sunday December 10, 2017 @06:17AM (#15890943)
It is called an intelligence test. Actual scientists talk about it and use it as such. It is a combination of measures of many different cognitive abilities. Which seems like a pretty good definition for intelligence to me.
Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by brailsafe on Saturday December 09, 2017 @11:12PM (#15889859)
Lucio in one of the parents proposed that IQ is highly correlated with general competence.
Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by DoreenMichele on Saturday December 09, 2017 @09:39PM (#15889526)
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15889035

You are contradicting yourself.

Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by Houshalter on Saturday December 09, 2017 @09:42PM (#15889535)
No, I'm not.
Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by ben_w on Saturday December 09, 2017 @04:47PM (#15888356)
> After that age, we just cannot reliably assert that someone's IQ is, say, above 200.

To add to all the other criticisms of IQ score, it’s defined to be mean-100-σ-15* — so nobody has an IQ of over 197, and only newborn anenephalactics ever score as low az IQ 3… and perhaps not even then if they score the same as the comatose.

* or σ-16, which changes the subsequent statements a little.

Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by barry-cotter on Saturday December 09, 2017 @11:25PM (#15889905)
IQ is fat tailed.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fat-tailed_distribution

I regret I can’t find anything on Bing but the below but Google’s blocked where I am.

https://blogs.sas.com/content/iml/2014/10/13/fat-tailed-and-...

There are some other cases where it is generally thought that the distribution is normal, but it is not (in real samples). IQ has too many people in both far ends and has a different shaped tail on the right and left (the maximum is 200 or so, but the minimum is about 40). Weight of adults also has too many in the right tail and is not fully symmetric, but its right tail is also long (unlike that for IQ).

Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by ben_w on Sunday December 10, 2017 @06:17AM (#15890945)
From https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intelligence_quotient

> When current IQ tests were developed, the median raw score of the norming sample is defined as IQ 100 and scores each standard deviation (SD) up or down are defined as 15 IQ points greater or less,

IQ itself — not intelligence or even score on an IQ test — is by definition not fat tailed. If a particular IQ test doesn’t produce a normal distribution, that test is wrong.

At least, wrong by the current standard definition of IQ; there have been others, and the very fact that it is flawed means there probably will be a new one in future.

Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by soVeryTired on Saturday December 09, 2017 @05:53PM (#15888663)
There's no guarantee that the normal distribution is a good model in the tails though. A former lecturer of mine would often assert that nothing is normal in the tails.
Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by gozur88 on Sunday December 10, 2017 @12:58AM (#15890191)
>Yet, also, IQ tests are strongly influenced by cultural knowledge, good scores in kids strongly correlate to kids coming from upper middle class families with well educated parents, etc.

Why do you assume that's cause and not effect?

Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by Houshalter on Saturday December 09, 2017 @07:35PM (#15889026)
125 is still in the top 5% of the population. Anyway Feynman gave the results of a childhood IQ test, and one that was taken before IQ tests were standardized. Feynman reported being exceptionally good at puzzle solving and math even at a very young age, so I am very skeptical of that.

IQ definitely matters. The average IQ of physics majors is like 2 standard deviations above average for instance. Suggesting some fields are very selective of IQ and low IQ people are much less likely to be able to do them.

Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by Gargoyle on Saturday December 09, 2017 @07:43PM (#15889046)
When there's an HN thread on IQ, you can count on two things:

1. There will be a number of comments saying IQ is outright meaningless.

2. There will be a comment saying Feynman only had an IQ of whatever it was.

Never fails.

Anyway, as I've said here before, Feynman's books are primarily collections of stories. What's presented in them was selected to maximize the impact and entertainment value of the story. And Feynman was very, very good at storytelling.

Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by DoreenMichele on Saturday December 09, 2017 @08:07PM (#15889159)
To be perfectly clear, I am not saying IQ scores are completely meaningless. I am saying they probably do not measure some sort of objective, DNA-based trait of "smarts". You cannot separate these scores from a very long list of environmental factors and I am very leery of the mental model we have that people who test well are some sort of innately superior beings rather than people who have benefited more than average from an accumulation of societal and parental investment of various sorts.

I am very leery of the power of IQ tests to justify entrenching The Haves and Have Nots. Our mental models have scary amounts of power to shape outcomes and this mental model seems to justify classism as a kind of manifest destiny.

One of the videos linked here in reply to me has some smart authority figure type asserting that university students all have IQs above average. That seems pretty well tautological to me. One would hope that those getting more schooling would do better on tests. But that fails to genuinely prove that what these tests measure is some fundamental personal trait unrelated to the fabric of your life experience.

I was homeless for nearly six years. A lot of people wanted to see me as stupid and incompetent during that time. Those classist perceptions helped deny me opportunities which helped keep me poor which helped deny me opportunities. I can never seem to get that across to well off people that their tautologies simply entrench class based outcomes and really say nothing about personal competence.

When we design a world that closes doors to people arbitrarily, we design a world that actively wastes human potential. This makes all of us the poorer.

Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by brailsafe on Saturday December 09, 2017 @11:37PM (#15889948)
I think you described this well. Doesn't really get brought up enough, perhaps because there is a bit of survivor's bias here and people don't have that perspective. After having failed numerous times at being a professional software developer, I found myself having to abandon my apartment and live out of my car while trying to get by. I've been out of work for a while, in part because of the stigma attached to being out of work a while. Being homeless also has a stigma attached to it that you simply do not see when you're doing well. Having grown up in a culture that actively embraces those stigmas, and now having returned to it — they are family—, I find it quite eye-opening how the people I once considered mentors have really isolated themselves in a bubble of not having to be conscious of these things.
Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by DoreenMichele on Saturday December 09, 2017 @11:50PM (#15889986)
Thank you.

I am trying to do some things to bring down those barriers. I was able to start making some earned income online while homeless. My lack of nice clothes or a recent shower did not matter. I am trying to foster that model as a thing that can help protect against sliding into homelessness, help you scrape by while on the street and be something that can help build a future that won't be taken away because you got better. Plus, it is not a homeless service, is open to anyone interested.

http://independentdigitalworkers.blogspot.com/

I was one of the top students of my graduating high school class. I got a lot of brainwashing that I was destined for greatness etc. It didn't go down that way. So I think these mental models are mostly propaganda and we need to guard against that.

Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by brailsafe on Sunday December 10, 2017 @12:34AM (#15890128)
You're welcome. That looks like a nice resource and I've bookmarked it. I think it'll help going forward as I figure out how to build an income remotely from a variety of sources. Thanks :)

With regard to your last statement, here's a (very) vaguely related post from Penelope Trunk who also writes about aspberger's and life. http://blog.penelopetrunk.com/2011/12/01/living-up-to-your-p...

Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by Houshalter on Saturday December 09, 2017 @08:35PM (#15889271)
Stop putting moral judgements on scientific facts. Either IQ measures intelligence or it doesn't. And there is an enormous amount of research supporting the former. And very little to support your assertion that it's "just schooling" or whatever. In fact there's mounting evidence that schooling affects outcomes a lot less than most people believe, e.g. http://slatestarcodex.com/2016/05/19/teachers-much-more-than...

Look, no one is saying your individual IQ test is the only thing that matters. There is random error on tests, and it's not like intelligence is the only thing that matters in a person. But if you go around denying that it exists at all, you are just spreading pseudoscience.

Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by fileeditview on Saturday December 09, 2017 @02:35PM (#15887604)
It always struck me as crazy to represent all that is intelligence in one number. Also AFAIK many things such as "social intelligence" are not tested at all.

I always smile at people putting that much weight into IQ numbers..

Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by 0xcde4c3db on Sunday December 10, 2017 @12:37AM (#15890140)
> Also AFAIK many things such as "social intelligence" are not tested at all.

As far as I've read about it (not an expert; I've just seen this debate more than once before and tried to educate myself on the basics), that's because every time someone proposes an actual objective test for one of the "other intelligences", it turns out to either be primarily dependent on training (i.e. measuring conditioned behaviors) or to correlate so strongly with IQ that the test is effectively an IQ test.

Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by Banthum on Saturday December 09, 2017 @04:38PM (#15888308)
The crazy thing you think people are doing is not actually being done.

IQ is not intended to represent 'all that intelligence is'. It is simply one way to measure a cross section of particular capacities that are valuable in a modern society and are easy to test.

E.g It doesn't attempt to measure the ability to track an animal, or remember the face of a person you met once last year.

This test is of interest because it is strongly predictive of other things we do care about, like educational attainment, criminal behavior, economic outcomes, etc.

Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by DoreenMichele on Saturday December 09, 2017 @02:37PM (#15887617)
I usually cringe.
Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by nzjrs on Saturday December 09, 2017 @02:55PM (#15887732)
> This means our concept of IQ > is likely inherently flawed.

Equally flawed, taking one outlier as evidence of something inherent.

Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by DoreenMichele on Saturday December 09, 2017 @02:58PM (#15887748)
FWIW, I have studied the space some. I was Director of Community Life for The TAG Project for a bit.

http://tagfam.org/

The last time I had this argument in a big way with people telling me I had no clue what I was talking about, some forum I belonged to was having a heated argument because they had the habit of posting ridiculous tests, like "What kind of dog are you?", and someone had posted an online IQ test and things were getting pretty ugly (in part because a lot of people felt it was scoring them too low).

I stated up front that it likely only went up to 140, then took the test to shut people up and scored a 140. I had training in test taking in my high school gifted classes, so I tend to do well on such tests.

But, whatever.

Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by boomboomsubban on Saturday December 09, 2017 @03:10PM (#15887810)
They aren't saying your wrong about IQ tests. Pointing out one outlier isn't proof that it is flawed.

Plus, this study doesn't care if IQ tests are a good way to rate intelligence, people who score well on them also are more likely to suffer disorders.

Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by DoreenMichele on Saturday December 09, 2017 @03:17PM (#15887851)
Mensa does not actually base membership exclusively on IQ tests, so your assertion doesn't accurately reflect the content of the study. There are other ways to get into Mensa, such as submitting your SAT scores. I was coached in gifted classes on how to take the SAT. Is it any wonder I did better than average? Should we not expect kids with training in test taking to perform better than those without, generally speaking?

If we are going to discuss some correlation between supposed high IQ and various disorders, is it meaningless to talk about how one ascertains IQ and what on earth that even means?

I think it is not terribly different from asking "What color is your aura?" but I am quite sure that if I went around asking that on HN (or, you know, posting articles about auras, chakras, etc), it would be flagged to death. Yet, IQ is equally invisible. You cannot look at someone and say "brown hair, 6 feet tall, IQ of 145." That just isn't a thing.

Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by boomboomsubban on Saturday December 09, 2017 @04:04PM (#15888136)
The article begins by labeling standardized tests of intelligence as IQ tests, I was following that definition.

The correlation is between people who do well on the tests and disorders. It could be that more preparation for the tests, the SAT classes for example, leads to both of these results.

Auras have no repeatable way of being measured. IQ tests show something, even if labeling that intelligence is wrong.

Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by DoreenMichele on Saturday December 09, 2017 @04:09PM (#15888167)
Auras have no repeatable way of being measured. IQ tests show something, even if labeling that intelligence is wrong.

There are people who claim to see auras. How is this different from people trained in administering IQ tests? The average person is just taking the word of some test taker that it means thus and such.

At some point, you simply have to trust the person telling you something. Even when people use machines -- and IQ tests are not measurable by machines like MRIs -- the person has to read the output. How do we know they weren't high on LSD that day?

I mean, this is veering into territory of "Zhuang Zhou dreamed he was a butterfly," * but I am being sincere here. I intend to step away from this particular thread because I don't think people think I am posting in good faith, or being sincere. So there is probably no good that can come from trying to further engage in discussion of a matter that I have thought a lot about and think is a serious issue.

* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zhuangzi_(book)

Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by boomboomsubban on Saturday December 09, 2017 @07:21PM (#15888963)
>How is this different from people trained in administering IQ tests?

Repeatability, you can do the test multiple times and expect similar results. Not identical, and outliers exist, but similar.

I am not a fan of current IQ tests as a measure of intelligence. I am not trying to change your mind, nor do I doubt you believe these things. This article is careful to distinguish intelligence from IQ test results, and the link is interesting without trusting IQ tests.

What bothered me the most was using the Feynman example without anything scientific in your argument.

[dead]
Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by mikestew on Saturday December 09, 2017 @03:56PM (#15888100)
Perhaps your point was poorly made such that even a smart person couldn’t figure it out.
Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by vostok on Saturday December 09, 2017 @03:17PM (#15887849)
To be fair, success has a lot to do with luck, circumstance, hard work, and political/social skills too.
Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by waster on Saturday December 09, 2017 @02:36PM (#15887610)
How good you are at academics actually correlates with IQ only up to a certain extent. When your IQ is more than 3-4 standard deviations from the norm, academic high performance is less likely, most likely because thinking and learning patterns in that segment of the population are so dramatically different from how material is taught (and from how it is learned by everybody else). Source: I've worked with a lot of the nation's (and world's) leading specialists on profound giftedness and twice exceptionality, especially in kids. There is literature and research on this, but sample sizes are (obviously, for statistical reasons) small.
Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by Recursing on Saturday December 09, 2017 @02:09PM (#15887430)
There is definitely a correlation, it's just not as strong as most people assume.

Saying that there's lots of great chess players with low IQ doesn't mean the two things are not correlated

For some actual numbers, see https://www.researchgate.net/publication/307874653_The_relat...

Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by otalp on Saturday December 09, 2017 @02:05PM (#15887402)
Interestingly in analysis of both children and grandmasters, IQ was negatively correlated with chess skills amongst elite players in the group.
Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by Recursing on Saturday December 09, 2017 @02:09PM (#15887437)
Can you provide a source for that?
Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by thaumasiotes on Saturday December 09, 2017 @03:43PM (#15888012)
There's really no need; that's exactly what you would expect to see in a thresholded population ("elite players").
Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by lgas on Saturday December 09, 2017 @04:43PM (#15888334)
Maybe I'm just not that bright but I would expect to see a positive correlation between IQ and exceptional chess ability.
Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by thaumasiotes on Saturday December 09, 2017 @06:45PM (#15888845)
There is a positive correlation between IQ and chess ability. That does not imply that there should be a positive correlation between IQ and chess ability in a group that has been selected for strong performance in chess.
Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by 0xcde4c3db on Sunday December 10, 2017 @12:44AM (#15890156)
Is this Simpson's Paradox, or something else?
Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by thaumasiotes on Sunday December 10, 2017 @01:22AM (#15890244)
Something else. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Statistical_conclusion_validit...

> Restriction of range, such as floor and ceiling effects or selection effects, reduce the power of the experiment, and increase the chance of a type II error.[5] This is because correlations are attenuated (weakened) by reduced variability

If you want to try this for yourself, try generating some fake SAT scores: (a,b) pairs where a and b are normally distributed with mean 500 and sd 100, and where a and b correlate at about 0.8.

Then, from your unbiased data set, select all the pairs for which 1600 >= a + b >= 1300, and check the correlation of a with b in the new, smaller data set.

Just examining this as a thought experiment, you can see that someone with an 800 math score might have a verbal score anywhere from 500 to 800. If we lower the math score, our expectation for the verbal score rises -- someone with a 600 math score will have a verbal score between 700 and 800. That is the basis of the negative correlation in the subgroup, but it's purely an artifact of the way we chose to label data points as being in or out of the subgroup.

Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by thaumasiotes on Sunday December 10, 2017 @04:29AM (#15890658)
Past the edit window: the 600 math score will of course imply a verbal score between 700 and 1000; the data I described has no caps on individual scores.
Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by jcranmer on Saturday December 09, 2017 @05:31PM (#15888544)
I'm assuming he's referring to regression to the mean.
Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by thaumasiotes on Sunday December 10, 2017 @04:21AM (#15890647)
Regression to the mean would only be relevant if you sampled something twice.
Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by gleb on Saturday December 09, 2017 @04:24PM (#15888244)
Please elaborate
Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by thaumasiotes on Saturday December 09, 2017 @06:42PM (#15888837)
On the assumption that IQ and "chess skills" both contribute to "chess performance", then everyone achieving a threshold of "chess performance", such as being an "elite player", has been selected to have at least a certain sum of "IQ + chess skills".

This means that, given high IQ, it's not necessary to have good chess skills to be in the elite group, whereas given low IQ, it is necessary to have good chess skills to be in the elite group. This will establish a negative correlation between "chess skills" and IQ within the elite group even though they are positively correlated overall.

Similarly, SAT math and verbal scores tend to be negatively correlated within the student population of any particular university, because universities will reject applicants whose total scores are low, despite the fact that the math and verbal scores are very strongly positively correlated in the larger population.

Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by gleb on Sunday December 10, 2017 @09:14AM (#15891441)
Thank you, this makes a lot of sense
Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder... by tzahola on Sunday December 10, 2017 @05:25AM (#15890807)
Imagine a scatterplot of two correlated variables. Overall there’s a clear tendency for samples to be around the diagonal. Now zoom on the top 1% of the plot and surprise, you’ll see no apparent correlation.