Re:Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorder...
by boomboomsubban on Saturday December 09, 2017 @07:21PM
(#15888963)
>How is this different from people trained in administering IQ tests?
Repeatability, you can do the test multiple times and expect similar results. Not identical, and outliers exist, but similar.
I am not a fan of current IQ tests as a measure of intelligence. I am not trying to change your mind, nor do I doubt you believe these things. This article is careful to distinguish intelligence from IQ test results, and the link is interesting without trusting IQ tests.
What bothered me the most was using the Feynman example without anything scientific in your argument.
There are people who claim to see auras. How is this different from people trained in administering IQ tests? The average person is just taking the word of some test taker that it means thus and such.
At some point, you simply have to trust the person telling you something. Even when people use machines -- and IQ tests are not measurable by machines like MRIs -- the person has to read the output. How do we know they weren't high on LSD that day?
I mean, this is veering into territory of "Zhuang Zhou dreamed he was a butterfly," * but I am being sincere here. I intend to step away from this particular thread because I don't think people think I am posting in good faith, or being sincere. So there is probably no good that can come from trying to further engage in discussion of a matter that I have thought a lot about and think is a serious issue.
* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zhuangzi_(book)