News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by nsxwolf on Monday October 09, 2017 @11:31AM (#15434668)
Middle America is not too keen on your "basic income" solution to all the problems you are creating. It brings to mind a future of living in a 300 square foot government apartment in some hideous Brutalist concrete block of a building, eating our daily Amazon rations, knowing that's just how life is going to be, forever, no need to have dreams anymore.

There will be torches and pitchforks coming for you.

Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by sctb on Monday October 09, 2017 @01:55PM (#15435962)
We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15434340.
Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by AnthonyMouse on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:03PM (#15435023)
> Middle America is not too keen on your "basic income" solution to all the problems you are creating. It brings to mind a future of living in a 300 square foot government apartment in some hideous Brutalist concrete block of a building, eating our daily Amazon rations, knowing that's just how life is going to be, forever, no need to have dreams anymore.

Except that all of those things are the exact opposite of what a basic income does. A basic income isn't housing projects and government cheese, it's cash money you can decide how to spend for yourself. Different people will choose to spend it on different things.

What's your alternative? Let corporations accumulate all the wealth generated by technology and subject everyone else to serfdom?

It's not as if people are going to stop inventing things.

Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by ng12 on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:22PM (#15435194)
And what happens when we inevitably converge on a price point where BI only buys you a concrete block and government cheese?
Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by AnthonyMouse on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:31PM (#15435256)
Housing projects and government cheese aren't terrible because they're inexpensive. The government spends a ridiculous amount of money on them. They're terrible because the buyer is the bureaucracy instead of the consumer. Which is a thing the UBI fixes.

If you have a UBI then you don't have to buy cheese. You can buy beans, pasta, carrots, potatoes, rice, bananas, it's your choice.

Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by aaron-lebo on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:43PM (#15435361)
You're presenting everything as ideal case. $12k a year means $1k a month to live. You'll be buying lots of cheap carrots and potatoes and rice because that's all you'll have money for. You won't have a choice. Go break down the budget at $1k a month. You'll find that people on government welfare often already live better than that.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/fact-checker/wp/2014/12/...

...earning $10,000 a year (which was about half the federal poverty level that year)...

The state with the highest total value of welfare benefits was Hawaii, at $49,175. The lowest was Mississippi, at $16,984. Welfare packages in only 10 states, plus Washington, D.C., exceeded Grothman’s threshold of $35,000.

Note, that's an article showing that a representative was exaggerating how much welfare recipients receive; those are the numbers refuting his claim.

Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by AnthonyMouse on Monday October 09, 2017 @02:03PM (#15436042)
> You'll be buying lots of cheap carrots and potatoes and rice because that's all you'll have money for. You won't have a choice.

You won't have a choice between all the different things you have to choose from?

> Go break down the budget at $1k a month. You'll find that people on government welfare often already live better than that.

And the same people are completely screwed if they want to do one dollar better than that because as soon as they get a job most of the benefits evaporate. Which is why they stay unemployed.

Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by thriftwy on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:50PM (#15435427)
If you are raising two kids, isn't it kinda obvious that your BI payout is 3 * $12k = $36k?

Anything different just doesn't make sense in my opinion.

You also seem to discard the value of work (on a 10 hr workweek perhaps)

Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by brandmeyer on Monday October 09, 2017 @01:16PM (#15435636)
That's not at all obvious. You'll have people screaming about welfare queens, for example. Never mind the fact that some of this screaming comes from a racist place of giving money away to brown people, it does need to be addressed in order to gain broad acceptance.

One way to defend against the welfare queen argument might be to recognize that there are economies of scale in child-rearing, and pay out adult/2 for the first child, adult/4 for the second child, etc, never going above one whole adult worth of BMI income no matter how many children you have.

Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by thriftwy on Monday October 09, 2017 @05:13PM (#15437513)
You see how you have solutions before you even recite a problem. It's usually like that.

WRT welfare queens, now it would make sense to have family intact.

Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by Klockan on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:52PM (#15435438)
> You'll be buying lots of cheap carrots and potatoes and rice because that's all you'll have money for.

You are kinda ignorant, your food expenses will be less than $1 a day if you only buy cheap food like that. I've lived on less than $1k a month most of my life, totally doable, you can buy good healthy food for around $4 a day if you cook yourself.

Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by ng12 on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:47PM (#15435393)
I don't think I ascribe to the reality where the bureaucracy is the worst part of being poor.
Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by thriftwy on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:52PM (#15435447)
In countries where you have e.g. gangs they can be worse than that, but if you're in a peaceful country, as a [working] poor, bureaucracy is easy your problem #1.

They can make all your savings disappear for a clerical error, for starters, and you are stretched on time to stay in lines to make things right.

Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by dna_polymerase on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:30PM (#15435254)
The idea behind BI is that you can still work, but if you don't work you still get to live. If you want more than the concrete block - fine. Go do something and earn money, but if not just STFU and live with what you get.
Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by matt_wulfeck on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:36PM (#15435292)
You realize that with our current entitlement programs that if you don’t work you still “get to live” right? There’s all sorts of safety nets, and many normal people use them.
Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by Chathamization on Monday October 09, 2017 @01:25PM (#15435706)
> There’s all sorts of safety nets, and many normal people use them.

Yeah, and they're often a mess. You often have to sign up in a bunch of different places and deal with a bunch of different broken bureaucracies, which isn't the ideal thing to have dropped on your plate when financial hardship strikes. It's not surprising that, for example, "Only about 1 in 6 people who are eligible for child care subsidies actually get it."[1] Simplifying the system and having it already active when people hit a hardship would be a huge improvement.

I was reading a story about one cities dilapidated homeless shelter. The people there were living in poor conditions - the building's infrastructure was falling apart, the food provided was terrible, etc. It was costing the city $4,680 a month to house the people there. The people would be much better off if the city simply handed them that money - heck, they'd be much better off if the city simply handed them half of that.

[1] http://www.npr.org/2016/08/21/490822086/the-financial-trials...

Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by aylmao on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:45PM (#15435372)
That's noble, but "living" shouldn't be the focus of discourse because there's much more to life than just "living".

It's already the case that if you don't work, you can "live". We should focus on making sure everyone can work if they want to, and their work will pay enough, which is the real problem at hand imo.

Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by mistercow on Monday October 09, 2017 @01:09PM (#15435594)
How do you propose that we ensure that everyone can work in an increasingly automated world? How will we employ a quarter of the population if, for example, nearly any job that can be done by a person with an IQ of 90 can be done more cheaply by a machine?

Do we crack down on automation? If so, how do we do that? And if we do, how do we stay competitive with the rest of the world?

The thing is, UBI has the potential to solve this. With a basic income, you're less likely to have to take a full time job you don't care about just to make sure the bills get paid. The labor market will shrink (and UBI allows that to be tuned), so there will be more jobs available, and there's no longer as much pressure to take an unfulfilling job.

This gives people options. Maybe instead of working a dreary office job full time, you work it part time (leaving hours open for someone else to fill), and spend the extra time with your family. Or maybe you take the extra time to foster a project you're passionate about. Maybe you tighten your belt and work on that project full time. And depending on how high the basic income is (which would be largely a function of how many crappy jobs we've automated), that passion project doesn't even have to be profitable. You can do what's rewarding instead of what puts food on your table.

This is, to me, the ultimate vision of humankind flourishing, sans-singularity. The only realistic alternatives I see are a massive increase in poverty, as we continue to convince ourselves that somehow price floors and retraining will save us, or a regulatory morass in which we try to stay one step ahead of the loopholes, preserving jobs that simply shouldn't be done by humans anymore.

Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by tome on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:55PM (#15435473)
If that happens you increase it, I guess.
Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by Zhyl on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:37PM (#15435304)
Why is it inevitable?
Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by richardknop on Monday October 09, 2017 @01:01PM (#15435521)
Instead of basic income wouldn't it make sense to have some sort of basic "lifestyle" provided by government. Out of the box you get a very small government built apartment (no rent or utility bills, all part of the package), vouchers for 3 meals per day (government run canteens in these government apartment buildings), free healthcare and education also provided by the government.

So you would get all these basic necessities as part of the basic government program. To actually make any money to buy nicer things (car, bigger apartment or house), you'd need to find a job.

This would make sense as the basic income would not work as free market would adjust and increase prices as reaction to the new source of free money to spend available every month for everybody.

Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by bzbarsky on Monday October 09, 2017 @02:32PM (#15436284)
You're presupposing a uniformity of needs that simply does not exist.

Do the government canteens have vegan options? Vegetarian? Nut-free? Just peanut-free? Gluten-free? Halal? Kosher? Why or why not? Which of those are "necessities" and which are "luxuries"? It may well turn out that your opinion on that last question differs from your neighbor's, which differs from that of the bureaucrat who actually makes the call. And at least in the US, having government-provided food facilities that are expected to be widely used but effectively discriminate on a religious basis in any way would end up in court on First Amendment grounds in a hurry...

That's just the food end. There are similar questions about housing. Should all the apartments involved be wheelchair-accessible? Should all the bathrooms be accessible by someone who is mobility-impaired?

(Healthcare and education have similar issues, though to a large extent people seem make the opposite choice on those, as compared to food.)

Anyway, one of my big takeaways from the history of the 20th century (both from nominally communist countries and the experience in the US with housing projects and urban redevelopment in general) is that uniformization schemes like what you describe tend to lead to a good deal of misery...

Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by AnthonyMouse on Monday October 09, 2017 @01:37PM (#15435812)
> Instead of basic income wouldn't it make sense to have some sort of basic "lifestyle" provided by government. Out of the box you get a very small government built apartment (no rent or utility bills, all part of the package), vouchers for 3 meals per day (government run canteens in these government apartment buildings), free healthcare and education also provided by the government.

The government is bad at operating a business. They aren't subject to competition. If they do something poorly they don't lose business so they just keep doing it poorly. There is no reason to ever have the government build housing or grow food instead of just giving people money to buy housing or food.

Government products also have another flaw. If the government provides $500 worth of free government housing, and you have $200, there is no way for you to turn that into $700 worth of housing. Improving your housing by $200 costs you $700. It's a poverty trap.

And allocating money to specific things has the same problems. Governments are bad at allocating things. Give someone a housing voucher and they'll buy housing, even if they don't need housing as much as they need something else. Many people would be better off to e.g. live with relatives and use the same money to pay for car insurance so they can drive to work. With a housing voucher they can't do that, so instead they waste the government's money on unneeded housing. And in the process raise both taxes and housing costs for everyone else.

Moreover, in any situation where that isn't the case, vouchers for necessities are equivalent to cash regardless. If you're buying $200 worth of food anyway, a $100 food voucher is the same as $100 in cash, because you use the food voucher for food and use the $100 you would have spent on food to buy whatever you want.

Which means that vouchers require a voucher checking bureaucracy that spends resources doing something which is completely redundant in every case that it isn't actively harmful.

It's far more efficient to just give people cash and let them figure it out for themselves.

Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by ganoushoreilly on Monday October 09, 2017 @01:39PM (#15435828)
While in principle it sounds great, the reality is it wouldn't function or scale properly and would be dangerously close to causing the same problems that many Communist countries face (from apathy of the populous to manipulation by those that have).
Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by richardknop on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:48PM (#15435397)
What about argument that basic income will cause prices to rise since people will be able to afford X spending per month. Wouldn't this be free market's natural response? Supply of money / disposable monthly income would increase therefor prices would go up?
Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by brandmeyer on Monday October 09, 2017 @01:19PM (#15435650)
Depends on how it gets structured. IIUC, basic income is implemented by progressive taxation (aka redistribution).
Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by aylmao on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:16PM (#15435130)
A different approach, one in which people can still work to get paid, but wages are reasonable.

Fulfillment is not all about the money and what you can buy with it. It's about feeling that your'e serving some purpose, and there's value to what you do.

Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by AnthonyMouse on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:20PM (#15435173)
That's what a universal basic income does. It lets the person whose labor is only worth $3/hour take a $3/hour job and still not starve to death.
Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by floatrock on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:36PM (#15435298)
I sympathize with the sentiment, but I think your statement could be misread as overly harsh.

I would emphasize that money solves all problems measured in money, but humans care about things not measured in money. So faced with a janitorial job making minimum wage $13/hr or a volunteer gig that can only afford a $3/hr stipend, it lets the person take the job that pays more in ways not necessarily measured in money -- it some evolved enlightened form of capitalism that frees us from the serfdom of capitalism itself or some such aggrandization nonsense.

But we've been dreaming about the cultured and creative paradise that only a life formed solely on the unlocked potential of leisure could afford since the dawn of the industrial age, so shrug Maaaaybe this time is different...

Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by aylmao on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:37PM (#15435310)
> It lets the person whose labor is only worth $3/hour take a $3/hour job and still not starve to death.

You'd still know that your labor is worth only $3/hour, and if you're not starving to death it's because you're on this safety net.

How is this feeling "you're serving a purpose" and that "there's value in what you do" as per my parent comment? Again, a job is about much more than the money, and "not starving to death".

Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by AnthonyMouse on Monday October 09, 2017 @01:03PM (#15435544)
> You'd still know that your labor is worth only $3/hour, and if you're not starving to death it's because you're on this safety net.

But your labor is worth only $3/hour. The only way to change that is for the person to improve their skillset, but if that was practical in a given case then it would happen regardless.

Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by aylmao on Monday October 09, 2017 @01:30PM (#15435744)
Value is not intrinsic to the object, but varies depending on the market and its rules. Go to another country and your labour might be worth more or less.

So your labor is not worth $3/hour, it's worth $3/hour in this market. The approach I think would be better for everyone is designing the market so that your labor holds some value.

Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by AnthonyMouse on Monday October 09, 2017 @02:49PM (#15436403)
> Value is not intrinsic to the object, but varies depending on the market and its rules. Go to another country and your labour might be worth more or less.

Sure, but the issue is the relative difference between what your labor is worth and what your costs are. Automation reduces unskilled wages, meanwhile the worker's costs for necessities like housing have if anything gone up over time.

You could try to fix this by artificially raising wages for unskilled workers, but that's counterproductive. Increasing costs will increase prices workers pay when they buy things or drive people to substitute with alternatives that cause workers to lose their jobs. Exactly the opposite of the desired result.

What you really want is to reduce the cost of necessities so the wages they actually earn will go further. Doing so using government subsidies brings us right back to a UBI, and you seem to want something else.

The something else is basically changing the laws around housing and medicine to increase competition and drive down prices. Doing that is a good idea but good luck with that. The incumbents have a ton of lobbyists and a vested interest in staying fat.

Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by bllguo on Monday October 09, 2017 @01:00PM (#15435519)
Sure, ideally everyone gets well-paid, fulfilling jobs...

So, when do we start talking about practical solutions?

Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by aylmao on Monday October 09, 2017 @01:19PM (#15435661)
A reasonable minimum wage
Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by bllguo on Monday October 09, 2017 @04:08PM (#15437040)
I do believe in raising the minimum wage, but how does that address the fact that outsourcing and automation have been reducing and will continue to reduce the supply of jobs?

Thousands of people have skills that are not worth enough, these days, to support the lifestyle they are used to. That's the problem here.

Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by AnthonyMouse on Monday October 09, 2017 @02:11PM (#15436116)
What about the people whose labor is not worth your minimum wage?
Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by matt_wulfeck on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:37PM (#15435307)
Or a $3/hour jobs becomes a $1 an hour job because markets are incredibly efficient at pricing in a new, free flow of money.
Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by AnthonyMouse on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:47PM (#15435391)
Except that the employee can walk away from an employer who doesn't pay enough and still keep the UBI.

And the demand for labor at $3/hour is huge. People making even $40K/year would stop doing their own laundry or washing their own cars if they could hire someone to do it for that price. Good luck convincing anyone to work for $1/hour when everyone else is paying more.

Moreover, even if someone could only get a job for $1/hour, what is that supposed to change? Then they get a job at $1/hour + UBI, they don't starve, and the second someone offers $2/hour they trade up. Or they decide that their time is worth more than that to themselves and spend it volunteering to gain experience or going to school or whatever. Which one of these is supposed to be a problem?

Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by aylmao on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:39PM (#15435320)
Exactly, which is why even with UBI we need reasonable minimum wages.
Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by richardwhiuk on Monday October 09, 2017 @01:27PM (#15435725)
Why? Minimum wage is largely designed to stop people being exploited by a form of economic slavery, but the UBI should prevent that, and mean that the wage has to be attractive.
Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by matt_wulfeck on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:47PM (#15435396)
Why not take the next logical step and control prices on everything?
Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by thesagan on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:37PM (#15435306)
This would be preferable to me, which is maintaining some degree of power over my own destiny by being able to build my own economic value.

I wonder why this is not a well received idea?

Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by matt_wulfeck on Monday October 09, 2017 @11:39AM (#15434766)
I notice that some of the biggest proponent of basic income are work-aholics, not middle america that’s supposedly at the greatest risk of the incoming AI apocalypse. It’s the same people who eat soylent milkshakes because they don’t have any desire or time to cook for themselves. It’s no wonder they’d love it if the government came by and took away one more obstacle that keeps them from burying their heads in their computers.
Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by codemac on Monday October 09, 2017 @11:46AM (#15434830)
Or - it's that the work-aholics know that they're never going to get ahead.

Middle America thinks they'll get ahead soon. That it's their gumption and attitude that got them to where they are.

Which of course is a load of horse shit, and they're being used and abused as much as any SV work-aholic, if not more because of their lack of compensation.

Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by Terr_ on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:01PM (#15434993)
Perhaps because the first group doesn't have as much time/effort sunk into learning to use the current social safety patchwork, so changes to it are less scary.

Also, they don't need to keep up any self-denial that well-paying jobs will magically return for coal-mining or buggy-whip manufacture.

Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by leggomylibro on Monday October 09, 2017 @11:49AM (#15434864)
Middle America doesn't seem to be keen on much of anything these days, besides torches and pitchforks.

I'd rather put my money on the people trying to build solutions rather than more problems. Sure, it seems like the actual silicon valley location is mostly making solutions for problems that it created, these days. But there's plenty of tech outside of California.

And anyways, dire imprecations of fire and brimstone if we don't do things your way is so 1700s.

Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by TheAdamAndChe on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:17PM (#15435139)
> And anyways, dire imprecations of fire and brimstone if we don't do things your way is so 1700s.

You think if the majority of people in this country continue to experience a declining quality of life, there won't be riots in the streets?

This method of shifting blame from economic issues to social issues won't work forever.

edit: To those downvoting me, can you please explain why? Am I wrong in some way?

Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by leggomylibro on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:50PM (#15435430)
That has nothing to do with Silicon Valley; don't conflate issues. The widening wealth inequality in this country is a product of much larger forces, don't blame people simply because they've happened to have found a modern-day trade which lets them eke out a middle-class lifestyle in the current economy.

It seems like you're the one shifting blame, onto people who have no power to change the situation. How about taking a look at DC, Virginia, and NYC, where the real power is?

Nah, it's easier to complain, stoke divisions, and take potshots at people slightly higher up the ladder than you. Classic crab bucket mentality.

Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by TheAdamAndChe on Monday October 09, 2017 @01:00PM (#15435514)
> How about taking a look at DC, Virginia, and NYC, where the real power is?

Uh, SV is an area with a concentration of power, money, and influence as well. Think of the incredibly influential power a company like Google could have on a democracy. Think of how they are trying to shape popular culture to suit their needs. If you don't think it is powerful, then spend some time in rural Arkansas and see what a stark contrast there is.

If inequality triggers a war, then it will be a war against the rich. It wouldn't be a matter of creating change, it would be about getting screwed by the rich so they can make more money off of us.

Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by leggomylibro on Monday October 09, 2017 @01:17PM (#15435643)
So Google "could have" seriously influential impact eventually. And they "are trying to shape" narratives and policies.

I guess, but I'll keep focusing on institutions that "are having" serious impact, and that "are successfully shaping" those discourses for now. The stark differences that I see across the nation are more a product of those than any young, nascent, 21st-century forces.

Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by ameister14 on Monday October 09, 2017 @01:48PM (#15435902)
4 of the top 5 most valuable companies in the world are tech companies. Apple, Alphabet, Microsoft, Amazon. Hundreds of millions of people use their products every day.

You don't think that's power?

Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by leggomylibro on Monday October 09, 2017 @02:27PM (#15436240)
Sure it is, but it damned well isn't the power that drove and continues to drive this nation's staggering wealth inequality.

So why are they blamed for it?

Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by ameister14 on Monday October 09, 2017 @02:51PM (#15436428)
Because they are an obvious sign of that wealth inequality. It's like how someone will say something like 'this damn cough' when in reality the cough is just a symptom.
Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by dragonwriter on Monday October 09, 2017 @02:58PM (#15436470)
There are already riots in the streets, fueled by economic conditions.
Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by floatrock on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:42PM (#15435349)
A major people's rebellion (started for all practical purposes mostly with pitchforks and torches) against the tyranny and oppression of the wealthy noble-class in far-off lands happened in 1776 or somewhere around then...

couldn't help but notice the irony of using the 1700's in the above example.

Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by megaman22 on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:55PM (#15435479)
I think you mean 1789, if you're really meaning revolt against the ruling class.

1776 was a rebellion of bankers, wealthy landowners, merchants, and industrialists, against relatively minor tax hikes and slight imposition of oversight on long-neglected possessions...

Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by richardknop on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:52PM (#15435441)
Yes, and revolutions we had in US and Europe in 18th/19th century could happen again if the income inequality continues to grow and quality of life of middle class / working class continues to decrease. This is sort of extreme reaction a really stressed society would be capable of.
Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by snerbles on Monday October 09, 2017 @02:38PM (#15436318)
When the stresses exceed the salve of McDonalds and Netflix, we'll see the guillotines roll out again.

Many of the heads in the basket will be our own.

Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by touchofevil on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:00PM (#15434969)
Middle America generally lives in the suburbs and does not interact with homeless people everyday who are dying on the streets in front of them like those who live in SF, LA, and NYC do. Basic Income is meant as a "floor" that those people will not be able to fall below.
Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by maxsilver on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:45PM (#15435373)
> Middle America generally lives in the suburbs and does not interact with homeless people everyday

Sure they do -- there's plenty of homeless people in the suburbs these days, it's just a different interaction.

It's homeless people standing on the sides of freeway offramps and stripmall driveways, dying in front of them on the grassy lawn road medians. It's handing change to a homeless person in the stormwater road ditch while you wait at a red light.

Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by reaperducer on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:15PM (#15435119)
That used to be true, but the nation's very poor live mostly in the suburbs and rural parts of the country now. It shifted about 20 years ago. You can't go anywhere without encountering desperately poor people these days.
Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by poulsbohemian on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:36PM (#15435290)
This is true. I live in a 30,000 person town in rural America that is a popular tourist destination for upper middle class types. Despite the cold winters, there is a surprising amount of homelessness - the city finally set up a camp area because they were concerned with the visibility to the tourists. Apart from a handful of white collar jobs (a small college, a hospital, a couple law offices), everything else is just above minimum wage, meaning even if you aren't homeless, there is limited mobility. Thankfully real estate is still very affordable, but as coastal cities push more people out of the market, even that is changing, as people move inland to find something cheaper.
Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by santaclaus on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:20PM (#15435175)
> with homeless people everyday who are dying on the streets in front of them like those who live in SF, LA, and NYC do

You see very few homeless people on street or in trains, and zero tents, in NYC. Its kind of strange -- NYC has a larger homeless population than SF no matter how you slice it (total count, per capita, per square foot) but the issue seems way worse in the major California cities.

I have friends who visit Oakland from NYC and are amazed at the Mad Max quality of the Bay Area.

Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by lr4444lr on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:37PM (#15435302)
That's because the encampments are not tolerated in NYC.[0] There's lots of patchwork "solutions": shelters, hotels, housing vouchers, and roaming the subways (as long as they keep moving or don't congregate too many), but not long-term encampments. It's kind of like how spreading unwanted food around on your plate makes it look as though it's been eaten - is indeed weird how it affects the perception.

http://www.nydailynews.com/new-york/bronx-drug-lair-cleaned-...

Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by ihm on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:26PM (#15435222)
There are no tents, but you definitely see plenty of homeless people on the street or sleeping in trains in NYC. It does feel less dystopian somehow than SF though.
Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by thesagan on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:39PM (#15435325)
Here in the Midwest (MI) people beg for change on every other street corner. It's obvious to us here why things are falling apart politically. Whole cities have collapsed.
Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by Buttes on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:20PM (#15435167)
>It brings to mind a future of living in a 300 square foot government apartment in some hideous Brutalist concrete block of a building, eating our daily Amazon rations, knowing that's just how life is going to be, forever, no need to have dreams anymore.

If I don't have to work, sign me up.

Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by tmaly on Monday October 09, 2017 @11:46AM (#15434833)
I just thought of the trailer parks from the Ready Player One book after reading your comment.
Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by corndoge on Monday October 09, 2017 @11:52AM (#15434894)
the parent did not say anything about basic income, what exactly are you responding to?
Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by shortstuffsushi on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:04PM (#15435030)
They're referencing the article, I believe.
Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by nsxwolf on Monday October 09, 2017 @11:57AM (#15434946)
I was talking to Silicon Valley when I said "your".
Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by bradleyjg on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:11PM (#15435096)
In other words you posted a reply to austenallred's comment that had nothing to do with it in order to try to game the ordering system here. That's quite rude.
Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by nsxwolf on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:41PM (#15435338)
Not really. The comment I posted it under was very pro-Silicon Valley, claiming regular people just love SV and all the wonderful goodies they bestow upon us.

My comment was responding to that sentiment.

Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by api on Monday October 09, 2017 @11:36AM (#15434722)
It reminds me of the endless ghettoes of William Gibson's Sprawl trilogy (Neuromancer, etc.) where people are basically warehoused and left to jack into "simstim" and rot.

In reality the pitchforks will come out as you say and this endless ghetto will be paired with a total surveillance police state to contain the angry aimless masses. Perhaps not coincidentally this is exactly what Silicon Valley seems to be building.

Pro tip: cyberpunk fiction was largely dystopian.

I was briefly into the idea of basic income until I thought about it more deeply. It's basically consigning the bulk of humanity to the status of "surplus flesh." There's this idea that if you give everyone basic income they'll all turn into philosophers and artists and entrepreneurs, but it's not true. Humans are social beings. We are not going to become those things unless we are surrounded by other human beings who are those things and that only happens when we are surrounded by a lot of people who are doing things. That's not going to happen if there's nothing to do. Without a culture of opportunity and vision people turn inward to drugs (opiate epidemic), various forms of Skinner box masturbation (game and social media addiction), or lash out. The latter takes the form of disorganized lone nut mass shootings like Las Vegas or organized political fanaticism like ISIS or neo-fascism. People don't like to be worthless.

The solution is not basic income. The solution is a massive increase in our ambition as a species. Here are some real first world problems we could be tackling:

- Radically extending the human life span

- Exterminating mental illness through a deep and diligent study of the human brain, and also possibly increasing human intelligence in general.

- Colonizing the Moon and Mars

- Replacing our entire fossil fuel based infrastructure with renewables, storage, and possibly some nuclear in areas where those are not sufficient.

- Connecting all our major cities with high speed rail or maybe even more exotic things like underground hyperloop transit.

- Rebuilding suburbia with modern knowledge about design including the social impact of the built environment.

Options 3, 4, 5, and 6 would employ quite a few people.

... and so on.

Basic income is the conservative risk-averse option. The things I listed above (and more) are for civilizations who are not afraid to spend a little money and put people to work.

Part of the problem is the "developed world" narrative. Start with the premise that our children should properly regard us as un-developed, then commit a few trillion to becoming developed. If our children and our grandchildren do not look back at us as ignorant and backward we have failed.

"When I was your age we only lived on one planet, drove around manual cars that burned dead stuff, and we only lived about 80 years and had a 100 median IQ."

Edit:

I didn't vote for Trump but when he won I did hold out a little hope that he might be some kind of crypto-liberal who would actually make good on that "trillion dollar infrastructure plan" talk. (A trillion is too low but it's a start.) Alas it appears that this isn't the case and he really is as bad as he looked.

Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by nsxwolf on Monday October 09, 2017 @11:44AM (#15434810)
Interesting that you come along with a hopeful vision for the future where there's interesting and lucrative work for people to do, and your comment is turning grayer and grayer.
Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by api on Monday October 09, 2017 @11:52AM (#15434892)
I went back and watched some Star Trek TNG a while back. It's shocking. There is no way anything that optimistic could be written today. People literally can't even think it.
Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by mschuster91 on Monday October 09, 2017 @11:56AM (#15434938)
Well people can think of something like TNG but the (alt-)right will instantly crapstorm you for being a communist. Just look at how they're opposing healthcare for all, a society like TNG would be the ultimate enemy for them.
Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by api on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:00PM (#15434983)
The alt-right is the logical endpoint. It kind of combines all the worst ideas from liberalism over the past 50 years (postmodernism, identity politics) with all the worst ideas from conservatism (nationalism, racism, biological determinism) in the previous century.

I remember years ago having a discussion with a friend about "what's the worst ideology you can possibly imagine" and it kind of resembles what I came up with but (mostly) minus the theocracy (I pictured a pomo professor, a Christian Reconstructionist, and a fascist hashing out a synthesis). In some respects it's worse-- its obnoxious meme aesthetic is far trashier than anything I would have ever imagined. No dystopian writer could have come up with a fever dream as hideous as the collision of 4chan and Stormfront.

Maybe you have to hit bottom before things can bounce back. I have a tough time imagining anything worse than this, but I'm sure people will try.

Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by wutbrodo on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:19PM (#15435162)
> It kind of combines all the worst ideas from liberalism over the past 50 years (postmodernism, identity politics)

Not to be pedantic, but those are _illiberal_ ideas. You're conflating liberals and the left, which was mostly fine when they were in a coalition for a while. But if you're talking about identity politics et al, you're very specifically describing things that are almost definitionally illiberal.

Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by snerbles on Monday October 09, 2017 @02:35PM (#15436300)
It's tragic that some consider "classical liberal" an alt-right dog whistle.
Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by wutbrodo on Tuesday October 10, 2017 @03:42AM (#15440036)
Yea, liberalism just isn't in vogue anywhere on the political spectrum. The kind of people you're talking about are particularly intellectually dishonest and morally decrepit, but a rejection of liberalism seems to have taken root all over the place.
Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by Apocryphon on Monday October 09, 2017 @02:20PM (#15436170)
All countercultural movements are trashy. The alt-right certainly have hit a certain watermark for going for cheap shocks and taboo-breaking transgressive behavior, but that's because they're attuned to the standards of the current generation. In the '70s, punk was countercultural and the Brits banned "God Save the Queen" by the Sex Pistols just because the cover had Elizabeth II wearing a nose ring. What's considered trashy or taboo shifts with each generation.
Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by occultist_throw on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:18PM (#15435152)
But that's what is talked about in Star Trek DS9. Except we have the similar name, but very different meaning... Sanctuary Districts.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Past_Tense_(Star_Trek:_Deep_Sp...

Effectively, the governments at the time (USA), figured it was cheaper to ghettoize poor, sick, and others whom cannot support themselves. Wall them off, and keep them out of society. Out of sight, out of mind.

This literally is the thoughts of the Right-Wing. Ive seen that justification here, on HN. Why bother with the poor? They have no money! Better to keep them 'away', as 'We' are better. Of course, right now we have White-Nationalists beating on their drums. But the real war here is against the poor. Black people are.. disdained by the Conservative elite because they are primarily low income (by way of discrimination, but thats aside the point!). Ideally, all poor trash should be taken out, white, black, asian, native - you name it. No money = no livelihood = no choice = no living.

EDIT: Seriously? -1's? Am I wrong? I would love to see the conservative plans to boost people from poverty, medical maladies, and systemic discrimination. So far, what I see are attacks on any programs trying to assist with poverty, medical, and discrimination. And these attacks are done by the "ruling party", Republicans, with their base plans being as such.

This article is a great internal view of how Republicans support white supremacy values. https://www.thenation.com/article/exclusive-lee-atwaters-inf...

Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by snerbles on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:03PM (#15435013)
The fictional history of Star Trek did have a global nuclear war in the 21st century.
Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by iak8god on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:37PM (#15435308)
Not that I agree with everything you’ve said here, but I just wanted to say that I really appreciate this comment and the ensuing thread.

> The solution is a massive increase in our ambition as a species. Here are some real first world problems we could be tackling: …

There must be some way to get people to work on all this without dangling homelessness and starvation constantly over their heads. Can’t we have a basic income to at least take care of the basics, and still motivate people to participate in these projects using some carrots like a) desire to be a part of something bigger than oneself, or even b) consumerism?

Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by floatrock on Monday October 09, 2017 @01:06PM (#15435569)
Hold up there for a sec. Things like:

> Exterminating mental illness through a deep and diligent study of the human brain, and also possibly increasing human intelligence in general

There's been waaay too many stories of how technology like this will only be available to the rich and privileged, furthering their already-sizable inherited wealth and privilege.

That's kinda the... not condescending, but dismissive?... attitude that the article is talking about.

We kinda need to find ways of how to just start having conversations about this stuff, let alone suggest how to avoid going down the dystopia route. Agree with your other comments that something like TNG couldn't even be written now -- look at how the new one is about an unprovoked war with a primal-looking warrior civilization. Yeah, we got interracial female leads, but the conversation being had is about nothing more than space sword fights with space explosions.

> The solution is a massive increase in our ambition as a species.

That part is well-said though. Cheers.

Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by unhinged_wanker on Monday October 09, 2017 @01:24PM (#15435696)
god what conservative bullshit. you must labor for others or else you are useless! just, no.

>There's this idea that if you give everyone basic income they'll all turn into philosophers and artists and entrepreneurs, but it's not true

No one says that you disingenuous weasel. Basic income is so that people can survive without being forced to hold a job. This is especially important for those that cannot hold a job - children, elderly, sick, disabled - or those that have lost jobs through automation, where there IS no more job to have.

> "put people to work"

Most people already work (95%+) and those that don't - children, elderly, sick, disabled - those people aren't ever joining your work programs. They make up a huge percentage of the total population and you just.. ignore them like they don't count. But i guess in your eyes 'work or starve' is better so there are no 'moral' issues, right?

Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by iak8god on Monday October 09, 2017 @03:52PM (#15436904)
> god what conservative bullshit

> No one says that you disingenuous weasel

Is there any reason you're being so rude and hostile? It's very off-putting, distracts from your point, and is not in line with HN comment guidelines:

"Be civil. Don't say things you wouldn't say face-to-face. Don't be snarky. Comments should get more civil and substantive, not less, as a topic gets more divisive.

When disagreeing, please reply to the argument instead of calling names..."

~ https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by catern on Monday October 09, 2017 @02:13PM (#15436134)
>Most people already work (95%+) and those that don't - children, elderly, sick, disabled - those people aren't ever joining your work programs. They make up a huge percentage of the total population and you just.. ignore them like they don't count.

I'm confused, what is the "95%+" then?

Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by brandnewlow on Monday October 09, 2017 @11:48AM (#15434863)
Your argument is very similar to yesterday's discussions around stock buybacks as a conservative, risk-averse way for companies to control their stock prices and enrich top executives without giving more power to labor.
Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by api on Monday October 09, 2017 @11:58AM (#15434953)
The core problem is that we are hard-wired for scarcity. Our brains think we are on the African savannah 100,000 years ago. When things get a little tough we clutch and build fortresses. This can make sense as an individual, but collectively it hasn't made sense since the industrial revolution (and maybe even a bit earlier).

Today the proper collective response to depression is to double down. Economy failing? Double spending. Things look stagnant and bleak? Increase our ambition by at least an order of magnitude.

The problem is that we are thinking too small. A civilization of our scale should be thinking beyond the planet, beyond history, and beyond the current biological definition of human. Anything less is a waste of our effort.

Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by occultist_throw on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:04PM (#15435028)
> It reminds me of the endless ghettoes of William Gibson's Sprawl trilogy (Neuromancer, etc.) where people are basically warehoused and left to jack into "simstim" and rot.

> In reality the pitchforks will come out as you say and this endless ghetto will be paired with a total surveillance police state to contain the angry aimless masses. Perhaps not coincidentally this is exactly what Silicon Valley seems to be building.

Too true. But that was Gibson's way of showing the "bad result" of society. There's plenty of places where scifi authors use constructs of absolutism to show very bad places policies go.

And if you think TV was the great pacifier, then just wait till VR and AR really take off. Live in a 15'x15' room and feels like a mansion.

> I was briefly into the idea of basic income until I thought about it more deeply. It's basically consigning the bulk of humanity to the status of "surplus flesh." There's this idea that if you give everyone basic income they'll all turn into philosophers and artists and entrepreneurs, but it's not true. Humans are social beings. We are not going to become those things unless we are surrounded by other human beings who are those things and that only happens when we are surrounded by a lot of people who are doing things. That's not going to happen if there's nothing to do.

No, basic income was a way to provide the basics of living plus a bit more, so everyone has the innate rights of: water, food, electricity, communication, lodging. To not have this covered for every human should be abhorrent. The converse to this is that some people just don't deserve food, or water, or shelter, or electricity, or communication. And especially with food/water/shelter, we see semi-significant efforts to try to stem those.

Solving lack of food is solved by... providing food. Same with water, but thankfully we don't see coin-op water fountains. We do have homeless shelters, but many have barriers for the people to use. Drug usage is rampant along with mental illnesses. And many a time they have oppressive "closing hours" so homeless cannot simply take any job.

A UBI would provide money in so that people could put it where they need it. Many a times, these are cashflow problems which can be solved by cash.

> (List of many non-UBI things that can be done)

Without the requisite resources for #1, it seems torturous to say you can lengthen life spans without the means to keep someone alive respectfully. This seems more like "Keep the rich living 2x-3x life span while the rest of us die in our 60's".

The extermination of mental illness is something I would heartily support. The only problems with those are well cited - you need permission from the very people whom you want to treat. And many times, their illness has them not give permission. This has been well discussed in the homeless/jail/mental health discussions on many places, including HN and Reddit.

But I believe that you have posted UBI as a "UBI -or- Multipoint plan". I disagree with the postulate of "A or B". Both can be done. With people freed from the monotony of tiring drugde-work, people could start working on the very societal things you mention. Not everyone will, of course. But that's the nature of freedom: people can and should be able to choose their destiny. Right now, that's bound by threat of hunger, lack of shelter, being divorced from social net, and poverty.

Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by s73ver_ on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:14PM (#15435110)
"It's basically consigning the bulk of humanity to the status of "surplus flesh.""

It only does that if a recipient decides to do nothing but sit on their ass. Otherwise, it provides the opportunity to explore things that one wouldn't have the time to do if they were spending most of their day laboring to afford food and housing.

"Options 3, 4, 5, and 6 would employ quite a few people."

Would they? Or would robots be doing most of that work?

"The things I listed above (and more) are for civilizations who are not afraid to spend a little money and put people to work."

Work how?

Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by aylmao on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:26PM (#15435224)
> It only does that if a recipient decides to do nothing but sit on their ass. Otherwise, it provides the opportunity to explore things that one wouldn't have the time to do if they were spending most of their day laboring to afford food and housing.

Regardless of wether I do nothing or go out and explore, it would mean I'm not essential. Working is not only about the money; is about finding a place in a community and having some sense of identity and purpose.

> Would they? Or would robots be doing most of that work?

Could be either, as necessary.

> Work how?

Work on the projects he listed

Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by s73ver_ on Monday October 09, 2017 @02:09PM (#15436100)
"Regardless of wether I do nothing or go out and explore, it would mean I'm not essential."

You never were. Neither am I.

"Working is not only about the money; is about finding a place in a community and having some sense of identity and purpose."

And now, since you're not forced to get a job to support yourself, you can go and find that identity and purpose with something you actually want to do, rather than something you must do to survive.

"Could be either, as necessary."

Doubtful. Most of those projects will largely be done by machines. So the jobs available will be small.

"Work on the projects he listed"

I mean work how, as in, most of the work on those projects won't be done by people. So how are most people going to work?

In much of the country, the number 1 job is truck driver. But we're working on driverless technology more and more, and eventually that will be phased out.

Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by davesque on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:03PM (#15435019)
Were you responding to the right comment? The point you're making is not relevant to the OP.
Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by Frondo on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:09PM (#15435071)
If middle America wants to blame someone for the changes that have hit rural life in the last 50 years, they'd do better than to look at Silicon Valley.

Uber isn't the reason Big Ag took over the family farm, and Google isn't the reason their daughter moved to Brooklyn and is now dating a girl.

But actually, I think the rural folk will be the first to adopt the "basic income" (scare quotes and all), because in a lot of ways, they're already doing it, just under a different name. SSDI, for example, is huge in rural West Virginia, whether you're disabled or no. Doctors there are in on it, as an act of compassion, because the work simply isn't there and there is no other safety net.

So, all middle America needs is appropriate framing. Call it the Real America Dividend instead of "basic income" and they'll line up for it.

Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by aylmao on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:19PM (#15435164)
SV is a symptom of the same problem; a system that allows wealth to concentrate and companies to become monopolies.
Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by richardwhiuk on Monday October 09, 2017 @01:29PM (#15435740)
It's difficult to imagine a more off-topic comment. If you are choosing basic income as a poster child of Silicon Valley, you need to be much clearer about that.
Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by wbl on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:07PM (#15435056)
My advice to those people: Git gud. There are lots of services and goods that can be created. If you want to help the homeless, or devote your life to the works of Bach there is plenty of meaning to be found doing that.