News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Does Sweden Have So Many Startups? by Loic on Saturday September 30, 2017 @04:45AM (#15371914)
The most important quote:

"Sweden’s impressive start-up record can also be attributed to some broader aspects of how the country is set up. Its social safety net, for instance, helps entrepreneurs feel safe to take risks. In Sweden, university is free, and students can get loans for living expenses, which allows anyone to pursue higher education. Health care is free too, and childcare is heavily subsidized. None of these benefits are contingent on having a job, which means people know that they can take entrepreneurial risks and still know many of their necessities will be covered.

“I think if you want to be an innovative country, you have to give people security so they dare to take risks,” Mikael Damberg, Sweden’s minister for enterprise and innovation, told me."

The second case, which is not present in the article is that in Sweden, working in a small company is considered a risky proposition and a such small companies are offering higher salary than big companies. It means that they tend to attract the best people too. In most of the rest of Europe (DK, DE, FR from my own experience), if you want the engineer path with good money, you need to get hired by a big company.

Re:Why Does Sweden Have So Many Startups? by flexie on Saturday September 30, 2017 @05:17AM (#15371984)
Other Scandinavian countries are also doing quite well, way beyond what their size would suggest.

But also well beyond other countries with developed welfare systems, such as France. I think these discussions always miss one key factor: Language.

If you don't speak English quite well at an early age (already at 10-13 years old) you are much less likely to get into software development at an early age. If you don't get into software development at an early age, you are much less likely to do a software based startup when you are in your twenties. There is a thousand times as much documentation, conferences, tutorials, courses, online fora etc in English as in other languages and this is how new ideas in IT spread. Only months or years afterwards, it's translated to Spanish or Chinese, and only if it has caught on. Just about everything new in IT spreads through English, whether it's AI or web development or anything else.

The Scandinavian languages are not that different from English, the countries are small and consume a lot of music, movies, TV etc from the US/UK. Movies and TV have never been dubbed, except for toddlers. So for the last 50-60 years or more, Scandinavians have been quite good at English. Your average 70 year old Scandinavian speaks English better than your average 20 year old Italian. A drunkard on a bench in Scandinavia is likely to speak better English than most academics I've met in Southern or Eastern Europe.

We live in an era of software driven startups. It's easy to forget that it was not always like that. There were times when successful businesses were driven by mechanics (GM), electronics (Sony), chemistry (Kodak), trade or other factors. Now it's software, and whether your language, framework, or library of choice is C, C++, Python, Lisp, Java, PHP, JS, HTML, CSS, Tensorflow, React, or almost any other tech that the unicorns are built with, the new developments in that tech will initially have spread from English speakers to English speakers. The fact that the largest software companies in the last two decades have all been American then reinforces that trend.

Re:Why Does Sweden Have So Many Startups? by elnygren on Saturday September 30, 2017 @08:22AM (#15372536)
I'm Finnish (the lang is nowhere near English) and I've begun coding in my early 20s and I'm a technical co-founder (who actually knows his stuff). I don't think language is the reason here.

Good education, smart people, good safety nets and a culture of doing things well & properly are IMHO better explanations.

About the culture thing: go to anywhere in Europe/World and you'll find out that the Nordic countries in general have very clean cities and all broken things like door knobs etc. are replaced faster. Design & architecture is very simple, functional and there isn't much "kitsch" to be found. I'd say this helps in startups too: you'll find people who really want to do their job well and build a solid product.

Re:Why Does Sweden Have So Many Startups? by danschuller on Saturday September 30, 2017 @08:48AM (#15372618)
Are you saying Frances broken door knobs and fondness for kitsch is holding them back?
Re:Why Does Sweden Have So Many Startups? by elnygren on Sunday October 01, 2017 @01:26PM (#15378801)
Well if you can't get out of the building and you're losing focus to all that useless stuff lying around in your office... ;)
Re:Why Does Sweden Have So Many Startups? by magnusjonsson on Saturday September 30, 2017 @10:04AM (#15372891)
That is not what he said.
Re:Why Does Sweden Have So Many Startups? by elnygren on Sunday October 01, 2017 @01:25PM (#15378795)
Thank you :D
Re:Why Does Sweden Have So Many Startups? by johankmagnusson on Saturday September 30, 2017 @05:53AM (#15372074)
I think you are right in this being one of the important factors as well. I'm Swedish and my toddlers never watched any YouTube content in Swedish. Pretty much all they ever watch is in English. I wasn't too surprised this summer when visiting some friends in England and I heard my 4 year old girl say complete sentences like: "yeah, I'm coming down Toby" to her English playmate. Thanks YouTube and Apple!
Re:Why Does Sweden Have So Many Startups? by tnzn on Saturday September 30, 2017 @07:26AM (#15372335)
France's safety net is shit for auto entrepreneurs so this could explain that.
Re:Why Does Sweden Have So Many Startups? by flexie on Saturday September 30, 2017 @07:53AM (#15372431)
Still doesn't explain why I can't name a hugely popular programming language, library or framework created by a French programmer but several by Swedes, Norwegians, Danes, and Dutch, all small countries but where English is a very strong second language. I'm sure there are great French programmers and programming languages, but doesn't is strike you as remarkable that there are not more?

From a country of 5 million (Denmark) you got the creators or cocreators of C++, C#, PHP, Ruby on Rails, Turbo Pascal etc. From a country of 60 million you got ...?

France is a a power house in so many other engineering fields like nuclear power, auto industry, aviation etc so they clearly have engineering talent. But in software, not so much.

Re:Why Does Sweden Have So Many Startups? by nnq on Saturday September 30, 2017 @08:50AM (#15372628)
There's a ton of French influence in software: Symfony, OCaml, lots of Java stuff...

But I treat "made in France" like a warning label for anything software, hard to explain exactly why :)

I guess it might be because they have very few self-thought people (probably because university is decent and free) that have that "intuition for how to simplify stuff and make it obvious and grok-able" (academic education tends to kill this "intuition" in people). Also, there's a kind of cultural "hate" for KISS and "complexity reduction" in general - they tend to view complexity as an asset somehow, quite a messed-up mindset imho...

Re:Why Does Sweden Have So Many Startups? by xfer on Saturday September 30, 2017 @02:29PM (#15374272)
Yes, PHP is a very well-thought language compared to Ocaml, right? Really KISS principle. /s

There are lots of incredible good software and research (mostly out of INRIA) from France.

Re:Why Does Sweden Have So Many Startups? by nnq on Sunday October 01, 2017 @07:16AM (#15377316)
...and also, ugly as it may be as a language, PHP is a great tool at reducing complexity if you think higher-level (deployment, scaling): the shared-nothing, each requests runs from scratch (and in an isolated process) architecture makes lots of things 100x times simpler. Of course, this wonderfully simple architecture turns 100% against you if you have the bad taste of trying to write a big and "properly engineered" framework on top of it.

I kinda love PHP as long as I don't have to read/write any of it myself ;)

(Oh, and you made me realize what's the core of my "french software" stereotype: getting complex-vs-simple completely backwards! ...of course, it's just a funny stereotype, the real people I've actually known are all smart and cool and understand trade-offs even when we don't agree on architecture and organizing stuff :P)

Re:Why Does Sweden Have So Many Startups? by nnq on Saturday September 30, 2017 @03:12PM (#15374543)
Did I say anything about PHP?! I mentioned Symfony but that's contrary too the point (and a fine example of over-engineering, btw...).

And Ocaml seems cool, though Haskell people see it like "eager Haskell with too many features and complexity and syntax on top". I took a look at the Ocsigen Ocaml web framework long ago though, and I was like "jeeez, wtff"... the language may seem cool, but that thing... ugh... But I can't really have an opinion on that since the only truly functional languages I've really played with were dynamic (Clojure and Erlang), static + functional is not really my area of experience.

Re:Why Does Sweden Have So Many Startups? by xfer on Saturday September 30, 2017 @07:50PM (#15375612)
Haskell people see Ocaml as a language with too many features and complexity? really? Haskell, a language with a billion extensions? Have you ever tried compiling ghc?

I don't know about ocsigen(i don't do web development), but i guess all web frameworks are more complex than they need to be.

I haven't even mentioned all the formal verification stuff(coq, a verified C compiler, frama-c etc.) that come from inria. I mentioned PHP because the GP was saying languages like PHP that comes from denmark etc., but nothing from France.

Re:Why Does Sweden Have So Many Startups? by tome on Sunday October 01, 2017 @04:02AM (#15376873)
A lot of Haskell extensions actually increase simplicity (by removing fairly arbirary restrictions) not complexity.
Re:Why Does Sweden Have So Many Startups? by rjsw on Saturday September 30, 2017 @08:16AM (#15372518)
How about OCaml, .NET, Interface Builder for NeXTSTEP/OSX.

There are French programmers in all the opensource projects that I'm involved in.

Re:Why Does Sweden Have So Many Startups? by yannovitch on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @10:36AM (#15400717)
I don't have immediately all the examples in my head but one which comes to mind is Docker, created by a bunch of french people including Solomon Hykes. It's not like Docker appears every single day on Hackernews, uh ;) ?
Re:Why Does Sweden Have So Many Startups? by sambe on Saturday September 30, 2017 @08:01AM (#15372464)
Does England produce a lot of languages/frameworks? I encounter quite a few French developers internationally (with relatively bad English skills...)
Re:Why Does Sweden Have So Many Startups? by yen223 on Saturday September 30, 2017 @10:05AM (#15372892)
Off the top of my head, Haskell and possibly ML has British origins.
Re:Why Does Sweden Have So Many Startups? by flexie on Saturday September 30, 2017 @08:15AM (#15372512)
I can only think of Coral. But then again Prolog is French :-)
Re:Why Does Sweden Have So Many Startups? by valesco on Sunday October 01, 2017 @05:26AM (#15377030)
There's VLC too.
Re:Why Does Sweden Have So Many Startups? by galeaspablo on Saturday September 30, 2017 @08:07AM (#15372485)
Symfony.
Re:Why Does Sweden Have So Many Startups? by Iv on Saturday September 30, 2017 @07:43AM (#15372394)
Healthcare is still free. Let's stay a bit smug in front of our mainly US audience.
Re:Why Does Sweden Have So Many Startups? by jk2323 on Saturday September 30, 2017 @12:14PM (#15373549)
HTML was created in Switzerland. Linux in Finland. Not sure what "software" companies are for you. Google? Well, China has enough Internet counterparts (Tencent, Wechat, Alibaba etc.). Softbank (Japan) just bought ARM (UK). Regarding "software" companies like Microsoft, SAP (DE) is quite a decent size. Nokia (Fi) was once leading edge too. Sure you have not heard about Skype and Transferwise, but they do exist. Maybe you should come out of your little bubble once in a while?
Re:Why Does Sweden Have So Many Startups? by flexie on Saturday September 30, 2017 @01:19PM (#15373880)
HTML was based on the ideas of a British national, Tim Berners-Lee. He spoke English. So did Linus Thorvalds, and the founders of Skype and Transferwise.

ARM and Nokia are/were not mainly software companies, but producers of chips and cell phones (where software is a part).

Not sure what bubble you are talking about.

Re:Why Does Sweden Have So Many Startups? by jk2323 on Sunday October 01, 2017 @12:14PM (#15378470)
Zuckerberg speaks Chinese. What is your point? That being multilingual makes you a better programmer?
Re:Why Does Sweden Have So Many Startups? by mlevental on Saturday September 30, 2017 @07:50AM (#15372421)
>If you don't speak English quite well at an early age (already at 10-13 years old) you are much less likely to get into software development at an early age.

china and russia beg to differ?

Re:Why Does Sweden Have So Many Startups? by nnq on Saturday September 30, 2017 @08:32AM (#15372571)
The percent of English speaking people is probably like 4x in China or Russia vs. France or Spain. And you don't need "speaking fluency", just "advanced reading comprehension skills" to get most advantages...

I could read advanced academic papers written in English (not just technical, also philosophy and economics) well before my speaking fluency was good enough to make "live conversation" well.

Of course, there is a horrible side to it: coming from Eastern Europe and living in Western Europe, I need to "dumb down" my English a lot, and to force myself to talk slower in English when speaking with French/Italian/Spanish (French are the worse btw - never met people harder to communicate efficiently with than them... even when their language skills are ok they sprinkle that "context dependency" and "nonobviousness" into everything) people that speak "English" but are actually only fluent in a lifeless subset of "standard international business English"...

Re:Why Does Sweden Have So Many Startups? by flexie on Saturday September 30, 2017 @08:17AM (#15372520)
There are many great Russian and Chinese developers but little Russian or Chinese software has spread outside those countries. Except viruses, maybe
Re:Why Does Sweden Have So Many Startups? by CydeWeys on Saturday September 30, 2017 @09:49AM (#15372843)
I think the point is, though, that there's plenty of resources available in Mandarin and Russian to be able to get really good at programming from a young age, even if you don't learn English until later.

Contrast with, say, an African child of well-to-do parents who has access to computers and the Internet but who doesn't (yet?) speak English. Good luck finding lots of coding resources.

Re:Why Does Sweden Have So Many Startups? by thrownblown on Saturday September 30, 2017 @10:25AM (#15372965)
vue.js
Re:Why Does Sweden Have So Many Startups? by flexie on Saturday September 30, 2017 @04:17PM (#15374807)
Yes, that's one. A good one :-)
Re:Why Does Sweden Have So Many Startups? by jk2323 on Saturday September 30, 2017 @12:07PM (#15373517)
Why would this matter? There are more than enough books in the local languages about programming.

Formerly it may have mattered if you can afford a computer. But prices have come down so far that this is not an issue anymore. Hey, you could use a Raspberry with a keyboard and attach it to a TV to learn how to program.

Re:Why Does Sweden Have So Many Startups? by cabalamat on Saturday September 30, 2017 @01:49PM (#15374045)
> There are more than enough books in the local languages about programming.

Depends what you're looking for. E.g. for many libraries/APIs there is documentation in English and no other language.

Re:Why Does Sweden Have So Many Startups? by jk2323 on Saturday September 30, 2017 @12:04PM (#15373503)
"In most of the rest of Europe (DK, DE, FR from my own experience), if you want the engineer path with good money, you need to get hired by a big company."

This is true. Unfortunately this has likely very little to do with your skills. To get hired by a big company there are three options:

1. You have family connections 2. Your professor in the university has connections 3. You work for a start up that get's acquired by a big company.

Exceptions confirm the rule. Also this may not be the case for companies like McKinsey or BCG.

I once applied for a job Germany at BASF. Job location would be Asia. Based on my resume I was very well suited for the job. I filled out the shitty SAP application interface. They really got back to me. "We received your application. Please also upload your 'letters of recommendation' (something that is provided to you in writing for every job you had in Germany)". I emailed them that I got my PhD in the US and worked in the US and that I don't have this but that I am happy to provide references. They emailed: " If you don't have letters of recommendation then we don't need you. We deleted you application!" This was a multinational company.

Re:Why Does Sweden Have So Many Startups? by thcsa on Saturday September 30, 2017 @07:11AM (#15372292)
Austria also has a very good social safety net, free universities and subsidized childcare - and we have very few startups, because people just don't like to take risks here.
Re:Why Does Sweden Have So Many Startups? by Jommi on Saturday September 30, 2017 @10:50AM (#15373079)
The article's point is not very strong, from personal experience (Finland, experience in Nordic startup "ecosystem").

Like you said, working at a Startup in the Nordics is considered risky, which doesn't make sense at all. Like the article underlines, Nordics countries have a insane social safety net, that even if your company fails, you're no where near as fucked as if the same thing happened in the US for example.

Yet, comparatively a very small amount of startups come out from the Nordics. Yes, Sweden has some, but if welfare = more startups were true, Denmark, Norway, Finland should all be top startup countries.

What I actually believe happens, and this is backed by personal experience, is that this safety net actual promotes doing nothing. Nearly all the gains/positives outsiders see of the system are wasted on the actual habitants. Nobody here thinks for a second longer about healthcare being free. It's taken for granted. So no, I don't think this is the reason for Sweden's success.

(Sorry for going on a tangent! Just wanted to write some of my thoughts)

Re:Why Does Sweden Have So Many Startups? by danek on Saturday September 30, 2017 @12:06PM (#15373508)
Counterpoint: I wouldn’t think of starting a startup in the US but I would seriously consider it in Sweden. Healthcare is one of the issues for me.

Maybe it’s not right to say it’s the reason for Sweden’s success but it could be an enabling factor.

Re:Why Does Sweden Have So Many Startups? by victor106 on Saturday September 30, 2017 @05:53AM (#15372075)
What are some successful startups that are based out of Sweden?
Re:Why Does Sweden Have So Many Startups? by ajpkco on Saturday September 30, 2017 @06:00AM (#15372100)
I'd say Spotify, Skype and King (Candy Crush) are good examples. I'd count Mojang (Minecraft) too.
Re:Why Does Sweden Have So Many Startups? by johankmagnusson on Saturday September 30, 2017 @07:21AM (#15372317)
And Tictail and Truecaller. I would also count Skype as Swedish and also Soundcloud even though I think they moved to Berlin pretty early on.
Re:Why Does Sweden Have So Many Startups? by amigoingtodie on Saturday September 30, 2017 @08:38AM (#15372591)
I thought Skype was initially based in Estonia?
Re:Why Does Sweden Have So Many Startups? by taysic on Saturday September 30, 2017 @01:33PM (#15373968)
According to the Wikipedia article: "Skype was founded in 2003 by Niklas Zennström, from Sweden, and Janus Friis, from Denmark.[30] The Skype software was created by Estonians Ahti Heinla, Priit Kasesalu, and Jaan Tallinn. "
Re:Why Does Sweden Have So Many Startups? by zurn on Saturday September 30, 2017 @06:25AM (#15372176)
Lots more game companies too, from AAA companies like DICE and Paradox to indie games.
Re:Why Does Sweden Have So Many Startups? by henrikschroder on Saturday September 30, 2017 @06:13AM (#15372145)
Yubico, Klarna, iZettle...
Re:Why Does Sweden Have So Many Startups? by peralmq on Saturday September 30, 2017 @04:17PM (#15374806)
For instance all the companies mentioned in the article ;)