News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook hated as much as airlines, cable companies by lkozma on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @03:53PM (#1533256)
If the data is indeed valid, it might have less to do with the privacy concerns and the ads, I don't think mainstream users care about either that much. The site is designed such as to exploit some of the weaknesses of people, such as the fear of missing out or the compulsive hoarding (of friends).. As such, many users might feel addicted to it, but at the same time feel miserable for wasting time on it. That might show up on the survey as a vague negative feeling. Kindly argue why I am wrong before downvoting, please.
Re:Facebook hated as much as airlines, cable companies by potatolicious on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @04:36PM (#1533363)
I think users have real concerns about privacy - but not in the way that geeks tend to believe. The problem with Facebook in its current state is that it has no consistency, and is often a non-deterministic system.

To be more specific: what the hell makes it onto my news feed, and how? If I click this button, will it be broadcast to the world? I (and a few friends) were concerned when their use of the "Find a Friend" feature was openly touted on Facebook on my feed (e.g. "Mike found Bob through Friend Finder!") - where no notice was given.

People realize that whatever they post on their status, Walls, etc, are essentially public knowledge. But they do not expect simple clicks to be broadcast to the world (potential e.g., "Mike viewed Jane's profile 20 times this week!")... and while we'd like to think Facebook is smart enough to tiptoe around these use cases, evidence suggests they are not.

Re:Facebook hated as much as airlines, cable companies by GBKS on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @05:28PM (#1533502)
Agree with this point. It is the most visible among my friends that are teachers. They are incredibly scared that a student might somehow see something about them that the student's parents might not be too happy about. It's enough that a friend uploads and tags an old college picture where the teacher does a keg stand and somehow that picture ends up in a students feed.

Where Twitter is public by nature, Facebook is really inconsistent and doesn't give a clear message.

Re:Facebook hated as much as airlines, cable companies by glhaynes on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @05:41PM (#1533541)
I agree with you — that's dangerous ground for them. One nitpicky thing, though: all the ads I saw for Friend Finder only mentioned that the person had used it, not that they found a particular other person through it. That's a little more palatable.
Re:Facebook hated as much as airlines, cable companies by Unseelie on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @04:12PM (#1533298)
While the site is inherently predatory, and while a lot of the problem of facebook comes from those problems, outside of the teen bracket, persons are very much concerned with privacy issues, especially where their employment is concerned. That said, the most visible activity of facebook is the adds, and it does have a history of changing the site format.

Consumer opinion isn't often about root causes, but the most visible issues.

Re:Facebook hated as much as airlines, cable companies by MC27 on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @08:57PM (#1533982)
Indeed, Facebook's survival relies on user addiction and it's the reason I'm wary of using social networks.
Re:Facebook hated as much as airlines, cable companies by joe_the_user on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @04:23PM (#1533335)
I disagree with the idea that the average person is unconcerned with privacy. Only celebrities and up-and-coming rock stars want to share everything.

The average person might not know much about how privacy leaks happen and they might be willing to assume this or that thing they do is private, even without any evidence. But the average person is mortified at the prospect of their private business going out to the world at large. "The Internet" is a bugaboo to many, many people with privacy violation being a part of that bugaboo. This same dark, nameless fear is starting to rub-off on Facebook.

That said, I would agree that the other compulsive aspects of Facebook you mention probably also are factors. And the two factors work together rather than being dichotomies. A person may feel a need to have "friends" but simultaneous fear of sharing their information given the possibilities that it could go "anywhere".

Twenty years or more, I saw a Sci-Fi which described a future in which people had to pay not to be connected to the net.

I'd agree that the ads probably aren't a big factor though.

Re:Facebook hated as much as airlines, cable companies by gigafemtonano on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @04:09PM (#1533290)
Adding to your comment, it's my understanding that many people feel the site is poorly designed. I've often heard "I wish there were an easier way to..." in relation to facebook.
Re:Facebook hated as much as airlines, cable companies by Unseelie on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @04:19PM (#1533319)
And its so very buggy...
Re:Facebook hated as much as airlines, cable companies by indigoviolet on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @04:20PM (#1533324)
What are some other sites that lay people use and that do as many things as Facebook does?
Re:Facebook hated as much as airlines, cable companies by glhaynes on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @05:43PM (#1533548)
Yeah, I hear people (usually on Twitter, often right after proudly mentioning how rarely they use Facebook) commenting negatively about Facebook's UI, but it's pretty rare that I see somebody point to a site that does the same things and does it better.
Re:Facebook hated as much as airlines, cable companies by c1sc0 on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @05:04PM (#1533447)
Funny. I remember one of the main reasons for the adoption of Facebook vs. Myspace was "Cleaner looks, better usability". Last thing I heard Myspace is still around, and I guess so will be Facebook, once someone else takes over their lead.
Re:Facebook hated as much as airlines, cable companies by sophacles on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @04:30PM (#1533349)
I would bet this has nothing to do with Facebook itself. Look at the other things people hate: Airlines, insurance, the cable and fone companies. Like it or not these companies are infrastructure, basically things people are forced to use to function well in society. This breeds resentment, people hate the things they have to do whether that hatred is fair or not.

I don't like phones, and I hate that I have to pay to have a phone to maintain a large chunk of social interaction (there are alternatives, but they suck). This means I am far more demanding of what I want from the phone company, and far less tolerant when they do things I dislike. Yet I keep giving them money.

Facebook reaching this point means that facebook will be harder to unseat, due to it having "but whatcha gonna do about it" status, not easier because people hate them.

Re:Facebook hated as much as airlines, cable companies by tansey on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @05:38PM (#1533533)
If this were true, people would also hate Google. Certainly search is at least as necessary as a social network. However, most people love Google.
Re:Facebook hated as much as airlines, cable companies by bjtitus on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @06:27PM (#1533676)
I disagree with this. Yes, search might be necessary, but there are plenty of other options and it isn't as if there is anything stopping you from using another. (Bing has many of the same features as Google now)

Facebook is different because they are locking you in (perhaps inadvertently) by having all of your real life friends already in the network. People feel forced because it's the only network that is nearly ubiquitous.

Re:Facebook hated as much as airlines, cable companies by gsk on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @04:59PM (#1533428)
>function well in society

You are giving undeserved credit to Facebook by equating it to infrastructure. If facebook disappears tomorrow, people may miss it but they are not going to stop functioning well in society.

Re:Facebook hated as much as airlines, cable companies by kscaldef on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @05:23PM (#1533490)
I'm not entirely convinced. I have a number of actual, real-life friends who I communicate with almost exclusively via Facebook. I don't know their email address, and in some cases I don't know their phone numbers. If Facebook went poof tomorrow, I would be able to get new contact information via other mutual friends, but it would be a major pain.
Re:Facebook hated as much as airlines, cable companies by whakojacko on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @05:28PM (#1533503)
Exactly. Not to mention planning events and sharing pictures (the second one being significantly less important, but still useful). Sure there are alternatives, but they are far less convenient for everyone involved.
Re:Facebook hated as much as airlines, cable companies by sophacles on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @05:53PM (#1533578)
Not really my point... sort of the inverse actually. If I disappear from Facebook tomorrow, people may miss me, but even those that do know how to contact me won't think to contact me in a special way for many cases.
Re:Facebook hated as much as airlines, cable companies by GBKS on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @05:31PM (#1533514)
Just compare Twitter and Facebook and how different the public perception and tone of media coverage of those two services are. I don't think it can be solely attributed to a dependency problem.
Re:Facebook hated as much as airlines, cable companies by sophacles on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @05:46PM (#1533559)
90% of people who I know who are not tech workers don't even know what twitter is. On the other hand, they use facebook daily. They also hate facebook.
Re:Facebook hated as much as airlines, cable companies by GBKS on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @09:19PM (#1534031)
I was just talking about how the two brands are perceived and how differently they go about privacy.
Re:Facebook hated as much as airlines, cable companies by sophacles on Wednesday July 21, 2010 @11:32AM (#1535458)
Sure I get that, but to be a "most hated company", it first must be a "well used company" which facebook is, and twitter is not.
Re:Facebook hated as much as airlines, cable companies by whatusername on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @06:03PM (#1533606)
My mum and probably > than 90% of the people I know use facebook. My tech friends and random celebrities I follow use twitter.

Facebook is the thing that everyone has to use to stay in touch with people - that is overwhelmed by crap like farmville spam. Twitter is that weird thing that makes no sense.

Re:Facebook hated as much as airlines, cable companies by TheSOB88 on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @04:57PM (#1533421)
The reason people hate what I'll call "utilities" - insurance, cable, phone - is because they're crap services. They're all either monopolies or oligopolies (small number of competitors that collude to a degree), so they can stay crappy without fear of economic resistance.

So in a way it's due to societal expectations, but not directly. I don't think people would hate an insurance company that they thought treated them fairly.

Re:Facebook hated as much as airlines, cable companies by orangecat on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @05:30PM (#1533511)
I don't think people would hate an insurance company that they thought treated them fairly.

Exactly. USAA is awesome.

Re:Facebook hated as much as airlines, cable companies by sophacles on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @05:55PM (#1533587)
I like my insurance company, as far as insurance goes, my agent is pretty cool and whatnot. In the end tho, I would still rather not pay for most of the insurance I have.
Re:Facebook hated as much as airlines, cable companies by dvvarf on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @04:06PM (#1533284)
There is absolutely nothing about methodology on the ASCI site. Here is their official commentary on the results: http://www.theacsi.org/index.php?option=com_content&task... The MSNBC pretty much lifts sentences from there.

This is a bigger picture summary of how other industries fare to give some perspective: http://www.theacsi.org/images/stories/ACSI_TREE_07_10.pdf

It's hard to tell if these findings really mean anything, since this is social media's first year on the survey. And without more information, it's hard to say if a direct comparison across industries even makes sense.

Re:Facebook hated as much as airlines, cable companies by thinkinghard on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @07:32PM (#1533797)
If you look at the survey closely, you'll see that FoxNews has the highest satisfaction among all of the other brands that were analyzed.

I would take this data with a grain of salt.

Re:Facebook hated as much as airlines, cable companies by Agathos on Wednesday July 21, 2010 @10:35PM (#1537187)
Their methodology is a great mystery, but I think they poll people who hit the websites in question. In which case Fox News' score is no surprise. It's the most polarizing news source out there, and the other pole isn't part of the poll.
Re:Facebook hated as much as airlines, cable companies by arnorhs on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @04:56PM (#1533416)
I would love to know exactly what group was surveyed and how the score is put together. Was it an opt-in kind of thing, so only passionate/angry people would chime in. What were the questions phrased as? etc...

Traditional questions like "How much value would you say Facebook brings you?", "How valuable is FB to you?", "If Facebook were to stop existing, how bad would that be for you?" etc..

Those are the kind of questions even your average airliner or insurance company would have at least somewhat positive responses from, but since people feel like they're possibly wasting their time, the score might seem low.

btw. more info and stats: http://www.theacsi.org/index.php?option=com_content&task...

Re:Facebook hated as much as airlines, cable companies by Groxx on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @04:15PM (#1533305)
>“Facebook is a phenomenal success, so we were not expecting to see it score so poorly with consumers”

What, do they not talk to people? 9/10ths of the people I encounter / talk to / overhear (friends or not) on campus & otherwise house quite a bit of dislike for Facebook, "but all [their] friends are on there", so they feel obligated to stay. About 9/10ths of the remaining people have no strong feelings either way, and the left-over 1/10th actually like it.

edit: And yes, I do actually mean those ratios. In the past year or two, I have heard only a couple people say they like FB, and quite literally hundreds of dislikes. Nearly everyone on campus has an account, and that means you can sometimes catch a dozen or two (or more) remarks daily out of several thousand students if you listen for it.

Re:Facebook hated as much as airlines, cable companies by fuzzmeister on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @04:38PM (#1533368)
I think most people will say they dislike Facebook, mainly due to the time commitment involved, but they would feel quite disconnected if they were suddenly unable to use it to keep up with their friends.

It's not that people are using Facebook "because everybody else uses it" (that is, because of peer pressure), but because people have come to need a service that "everybody else uses."

Re:Facebook hated as much as airlines, cable companies by Groxx on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @04:42PM (#1533381)
Isn't that kind of the definition of peer pressure? You need to do something to stay in group A. Do it or be removed.

Or maybe an addiction? One can dislike what they're addicted to, and still be strongly pressured to use it.

Except this group A is the biggest & most connected group the world has ever seen => potentially the biggest & most powerful peer pressure the world has ever seen (depends on what value you assign to those connections, and what value they assign, and the availability of other options (i.e.: none, for most people, however incorrect that belief is)).

What people want is something like Facebook. Clearly. But that doesn't mean they have to like Facebook to keep using it; it's just the only real option.

Re:Facebook hated as much as airlines, cable companies by fuzzmeister on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @05:02PM (#1533435)
Almost all of the complaints I've heard about Facebook from college students stem from the amount of time "wasted" on it. However, all of this time is spent interacting with other people on the service, actively or not. So, it is hard to see how one could make a Facebook-esque service where the problem of time being "wasted" is solved without destroying the very point of the service.
Re:Facebook hated as much as airlines, cable companies by Groxx on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @05:04PM (#1533448)
Oh certainly, I'm not claiming it's an easy fix. It's kind of an inherent quality/flaw of social tools.

That said, Facebook has aimed 180 degrees away from productivity. The whole site is designed to be addictive and encourage more pages / more time. (I mean, duh. That's how they make their money. It just ends up sucking for users.)

Re:Facebook hated as much as airlines, cable companies by orangecat on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @04:12PM (#1533295)
Sounds about right, in all three cases there's essentially no competition. Airlines are uniformly awful (with the partial exception of Southwest), cable companies have a combination of natural and government-granted monopolies, and Facebook is the poster child of dominance via network effects. Satisfying customers doesn't have to be a high priority for any of them.
Re:Facebook hated as much as airlines, cable companies by tokenadult on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @06:17PM (#1533645)
I actually don't hate on airlines, even though I used to be a frequent flyer in what is still one of the most one-company airline markets in the United States. The only dealing I have with cable companies is letting my Internet signal come into my house on a TV cable that has never been used for TV. I'm not sure the comparison in the article fits me.
Re:Facebook hated as much as airlines, cable companies by Unseelie on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @04:18PM (#1533318)
Well, that and the facebook customers are not the users, they're the corporation buying adds and information..
Re:Facebook hated as much as airlines, cable companies by GavinB on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @05:18PM (#1533480)
This isn't really a fair comparison. More people use Facebook than they do any individual cable company.

I don't have an opinion on airlines that I've never flown or cable companies that only exist on the west coast. It would be more interesting to take a sample who use both Facebook and, say, Comcast, and see which was more hated.

Re:Facebook hated as much as airlines, cable companies by kierank on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @05:41PM (#1533544)
Ryanair is the classic example of a company that is supposedly "hated" yet people use en masse nonetheless because it provides a service that people want.
Re:Facebook hated as much as airlines, cable companies by marknutter on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @08:47PM (#1533968)
I really just think hating Facebook is in vogue and the fad will pass. It's the best way to keep in touch with people you don't see that often, bar none, and people will continue to use it because that's where everyone is.
Re:Facebook hated as much as airlines, cable companies by balding_n_tired on Wednesday July 21, 2010 @09:07AM (#1535059)
Right, but people aren't switching to Greyhound or going back to broadcast only.
Re:Facebook hated as much as airlines, cable companies by rblion on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @06:50PM (#1533715)
told you so. you fags negged me for calling it before it happened.