Wars of I BC century and Roman laws that put people into slavery for debts had brought hundreds of thousands of slaves into economy bringing cost of labour close to zero. Conquest of Egypt and North Africa flooded markets with cheap grain.
That market disruption made artisan shops and small farms unable to sustain/compete on the market with larger enterprises based on slave labour.
Majority of citizens of lower class had been then entitled to free food and free entertainment (bread and circus). It was necessary for keeping their votes and for keeping appearances of the republic. (Even what we call Roman Empire were still nominally a Republic with Senate and elections held for various offices every year at Fields of Mars).
I recommend everyone reading Rubicon by Tom Holland. https://www.amazon.com/Rubicon-Tom-Holland/dp/1400078970
I voted for Bernie personally -- not a full out socialist... but I do think single payer + ubi + free college makes sense -- take the stress out of living paycheck to paycheck... at least somewhat... Not saying make everyone a millionaire and inflate the crap out of thnigs...but there needs to be some equilibrium...
One good policy might be capped CEO pay at say 200 * average employee salary. In this way - for CEO to get a raise, average salary must go up -- this can happen either by raising across the board or by moving more people to management and increasing upward mobility. Any money the CEO makes over 200* from that company is taxed at 100% including benefits, stocks, etc...
I'm currently very impressed by the work of Prof. Richard Wolff, an economist that heavily criticizes Capitalism and tries to make actual practical changes in the lives of people starting from their workplaces.
Here is a talk he made in front of Google employees (the irony): https://youtu.be/ynbgMKclWWc
I do like UBI though along with (the pragmatist in me) believes gov't should work like agile dev teams... push changes up to a github like interface for bills.. the all bills should be VERY succinct and serve 1 goal, and that they should be repealable pretty easily like reverting a change on github... I think we have WAY too much bloat, and omnibuses just don't make sense at all and should be illegal.
Congressmen make very good money and benefits -- and have lots of perks so they should be required to work as hard as the next guy in America - -40 hours per week IN congress discussing bills and voting - -anything to 'market' themselves for future elections is NOT part of their job and outside their 'paid' duties and should be done on their own time.
I think automation, etc will disrupt the entire fabric of society soon, and honestly I hope we can move back to middle-age work days... they worked maybe 20 hours a week, if that and some weeks not at all - if farming the winter was pretty much just don't freeze to death... While their lives weren't long, I have to think they enjoyed life more than we do today.
If I could live for free (no rent, free food, free electricity, etc), I probably would quit. I don't have much savings and my quality of life would drop a little, but I would probably take 6-12 months vacation and just dick about, playing video games and concentrating on my hobbies.
That said, I agree with your point, just bad example.
The hoops some members of this forum will jump through to convince themselves that building CRUD apps is some zenith of intellectual might just continues to astound me.
Maybe if jobs for all skill-sets were still growing (in availability and compensation) it'd be easier to write off a good portion of the population as mentally inferior, but now that knowledge jobs are gaining a monopoly on living wages/salaries I don't think it's as easy to be that glib.
We need to do better as a society.
We're not that glib when it comes to children and early education, and I don't think we should change attitude just because a person has reached adulthood. Laziness and/or the attribution fallacy seems to get the better of a lot of us on HN.
Presuming we want people to have good lives who aren’t able or inclined to do jobs requiring much higher intellectual demands than janitorial ones (and I certainly do want us to presume that!), we need to figure out how to in the short term allow people doing those jobs to have good lives and in the long term allow them to have good lives while robots do those jobs.
Perhaps I’m misunderstanding your comment.
This economic system isn't working for the vast majority of Americans, hence the support for Bernie and Trump.
However, small sample size notwithstanding, I have been involved with mentoring in an outreach program targeted at people with little to no CS experience. And these students were coding circles around "CS" grads in under 6 weeks. Sure the theoretical foundations aren't there yet, but, do you really need that much math to stand up an app, build a website, or do any of the work expected of a junior dev?
I 100% agree with you in that most people don't have the aptitude to become the next John Carmack, but, at least in my experience, that's not where the jobs are anyway. You don't need to be Linus to generate business value using Linux, and you don't need to be James Gosling to working Java enterprise apps. The jobs of the future need an army of people to modernize infrastructure and build using existing tools. These are the middle class anchors of the 21st century; I'd say look no farther than the "analyst" pipelines of the American finance industry to see this happening.
Have you ever been in any kind of teaching role, or observed some students at tutoring labs? Some people are just unteachable/not cut out for it.
then they can become janitors.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moravec%27s_paradox
but you're right, ubi is essential. not everyone can handle janitorial work. ;)
manufacturing went away, agriculture went away, mining went away, all through automation. coincidently, this corresponded to growth in the people working in tech and other intellectual labor. but it's sloppy thinking to say that automation causes growth in intellectual labor, which seems to be the presumption. automation causes whatever it automates to shrink. intellectual labor will be automated-- possibly before janitorial work.
If everyone had better options, fewer would be willing to be janitors, and the need for janitors would cause janitorial wages to increase.
Basically, society is partly competitive.
If a position does not pay well enough for someone to have a family and raise and educate two or three children, it can be said not to pay for itself: which is to say, not to pay for its renewal from generation to generation. This is the real standard by which we must consider the wages paid to those positions, like waiters and teachers and janitors, which are perennial.
Why is it? A job is better than welfare, therefore it has value. The requirement that jobs are 'renewable' is only required of the average job, not every job.
Accepting the idea that renewability is either slightly more than 1.0 or slightly less, if the "average job" is renewable it suggests most of the common jobs have to be renewable in practice.
We could argue this in another way, which is to say that the average "career life course" or let's just say "life course" has to be renewable. This is where we encounter the idea that people should be setting themselves up for promotions -- but most people don't get promotions. It's not how life works. Promotions don't address the concern for the average life course.
The main features of janitorial work is few barriers to entry. There is fair demand, but there is plentiful supply which is why it is relatively low paid.
If Janitors could only replace Janitors, then being "non-renewable" would reduce supply, increasing wage, and maintaining balance.
In reality, the main feature of Janitorial work is most people otherwise lacking qualifications can do it; i.e. anyone. So it's not true that the renewability of janitorial work has a direct affect on supply.
Instead, it depends on overall supply of unskilled labour.
I thought about this for a while after you wrote it.
In a stable setting, where there is not a large and pre-existing supply of prey, prey animals tend to have large broods. Many off their offspring are preyed upon or otherwise unable to reproduce, but just enough make it in each generation and likewise manage to have large broods.
This is not a behaviour that seems plausible with modern people. The amount of time required to educate someone prior to their entering workforce is enormous now -- we can't afford to do something like what prey animals do, with regards to work.
Where does the unskilled labor come from?
It's not the core job, it's the fact that there's zero growth or mobility even possible that is the issue.
If you're a contracted employee, there's zero investment in you as an employee. You come in, do the task, and leave.
In the Bay Area schools my kids attend, they are working hard to emphasize this growth mindset. I think it's huge component in job mobility, whether it be upward or sideways.
Not everyone is a 'striver.' Some folks just want to pay their bills and enjoy what time they can with their family and friends.
I think everyone deserves to be able to have vacation time, especially single parents.
An article that focusses on inequality due to low income should perhaps pick an example with a more typical family situation.
To live a life free of consequences? As in have more kids, same quality of life?
How will that work?
> everyone deserves..
And who pays?
To live a fulfilling life without the constant fear of not being able to adequately provide for yourself or your offspring?
>And who pays?
Since it'd be us, collectively, as a society who would benefit it'd make sense for us, collectively, as a society to pay.
And this comes, for free, with no obligations? What is the standard for a "fulfilling life"? One child? A hundred? If I think my life will be fulfilled by skydiving, or playing XBox, or hookers and blow - should the state pay for those as well?
> it'd be us, collectively, as a society who would benefit
What you are describing is a market, but with no feedback or control; When someone ends up a burden on society due to a poor upbringing, does "society" get a refund?
If we are paying for people to bring up children, it would make more sense if the we initiated it; rather than people self-select for parenthood and get child welfare as an individual right.
I meant a mistake by society, i.e. it's a mistake to put people in a dead-end job, functionally ever.
You and I, maybe we made the right decisions. I'm doing pretty well for myself as a software engineer.
But when I see the misfortune of others -- people who saw the bottoms fall out of their careers -- let's just say it makes me hesitant to whistle past graveyards.
Apologies to pick on you without addressing your main point, but this sentence is an example of an error I see a lot yet I rarely see addressed.
Specifically, you're claiming a chain of causation where by inequality causes poverty. But in fact the relation between these two isn't causal at all, but rather logical.
(Well, not actually. Inequality is independent of poverty -- you could have no poverty but lots of inequality, or no inequality but lots of poverty. The assumption that inequality and poverty are so closely linked seems to me to be be basically assuming that we live in a zero-sum world. But let's just continue with that assumption right now, because that's not the point I want to address.)
Point is, why put the arrow of causation that way? Why not the other way around? Of course either way you put it's still not actually a causal relation -- but I think putting it the other way around is a much more useful way of thinking (mathematicians still think in terms of things causing things, because it's a useful way of thinking, even though mathematics doesn't actually have causation). I think there's something wrong with the assumption that inequality is somehow primary, and poverty just an effect.
You see this a lot in other contexts too -- people claiming "A causes B" when in fact the correct relation is "B is an example of A". (OK, that's not exactly the same error as here, but it's closely related -- mistaking a logical relation for a causal one, and putting the arrow of "virtual causation" in the wrong direction. As if someone said "all-cause mortality causes accidental deaths"; how silly would that be?) Watch out for this!
>Apologies to pick on you without addressing your main point, but this sentence is an example of an error I see a lot yet I rarely see addressed.
You're not picking on me - you're picking on something I wrote. This is perfectly fine!
Would you think it more appropriate to talk of poverty and inequality being elements in a feedback loop?
This is relating to your parenthetical, not your quibble with causation, of course. But inequality of income is different to inequality of wealth, and there can be a causal link there.
However, take Monaco. There appears to be significant wealth and income disparity among residents of Monaco and yet nothing that we would reasonably identify as poverty.
That doesn't mean that this would make the world a better place.
The world should absolutely try and help the poor and solve their problems, but this has nothing at all to do with inequality".
But equality of opportunity seems a good idea.
The demand for, and productivity of, high-skilled workers is increasing rapidly, while the supply is not increasing very much. The masses have responded to these price signals by going to college more, but aren't actually coming out the other side with higher skills, or even diplomas, probably due to deficits in K12.
Notably, this is not a story about the top and bottom 1%. The premium has widened enormously across the board, i.e. between the 25th and 75th percentiles.
As you said it essentially comes down to 'they should've made better choices and got a better career path!' while having everything handed to them at birth. It's the sort of thing that really made it apparent how different my upbringing was from my coworkers because I experienced that sort of deep poverty.
1. The meritocracy tied into Christian belief - that person has sinned (whatever you interpret sin to be), therefore of course their life is like that.
2. The ignorance of never having experienced a life where your merit doesn't influence your personal success. One sickness, accident, etc, usually starts to 'cure' this mindset.
These highly individualist supermen don't need society or anyone else for their success. They stand alone. Celebrating themselves while seeing others suffer and blaming them for their suffering is simply the natural order of things. Empathy is completely absent in this impoverished binary world view of success and failure.
But life and human beings cannot just be reduced to a primitive ideology of success and failure, especially when the successful are riding on generations of privilege. It's obscene for those starting a 100M race at 90M to lecture others on achievement.
While these self centred achievers stroke their egos millions if not billions of human brains are wasted just trying to survive, their intellectual output never given the opportunity to shine. And its not just their loss but a social catastrophe because its only leisure and stability that allowed our tryst with science to begin.
Luckily, most of the things we as a society value as being a "good" thing to do are in fact really good things to do as an individual looking out for one's own self interest.
Have you or I benefited greatly from the work of Jobs & Woz, Gates, Einstein, Pasteur, etc? I'd say yes.
Would it stand to reason that we would benefit significantly from future contributions from similar people?
Well, if that is true, we should probably support social programs like good access to education and healthcare, so that those potential innovators have fewer obstacles in their path.
Does a society that revolves around mass production tend to innovate faster when the masses have stronger spending power? Makes sense - so perhaps fiscal policies that mitigate income inequality would be wise - from an innovation standpoint (completely ignoring the moral case).
Yes, there are dumb people out there who read Rand and overlooked (a) that she was reacting to having lived through the awful aftermath of the Russian revolution and (b) was writing fiction in dystopian universes (before she got a bit too cray cray and just started writing philosophy). You can read Orwell and not think there's actually talking animals. And a lot of the proclaimed Randians happen to forget that in her most nuanced work, Atlas Shrugged, the populist movement was the lesser villain to the larger villian of crony capitalism, lobbying, and government intervention on behalf of those interests.
It's actually quite refreshing to look at socialist policies from a perspective of selfishness, because if you ask yourself the question of "will these policies benefit me even if I'm not a direct beneficiary?" - the amazing thing is that the answer is"yes" given a long and broad perspective. We shouldn't as a society make the case for these policies because of moral arguments, but can and should make the case on the basis of their impact on economic growth and the rate of progress.
Most investors prefer reinvestment to dividends for long term holdings. And that's exactly what social programs, and policies addressing income inequality, are. They are a reinvestment into the country instead of a dividend (aka tax cut) paid out annually. Let's make that case using the language and reasoning they already understand.
I am not a follower or a fan of Ayn Rand but I really don't see any other category within which to place:
Steve Jobs, Arnold Schwarzenegger, Elon Musk ... perhaps even Donald Trump ? George Lucas ?
They seem to fit the archetype ...
I think this is a structural problem. When your only source of wealth is your own time and labour, there's a limit to wealth creation and accumulation. The rich isn't limited to just their own time or labour, but is able to take many people's time and labour as part of their own.
One of the essential patterns of history is the vacillation between freedom and equality as societal ideals. A freer society is a more unequal society, and vice versa. It's a fairly paradoxical and nuanced idea because we (particularly Americans) don't tend to think of those principles as existing in tension with one another.
Furthermore, once a civilization reaches a certain threshold, it follows that a great majority of people become unproductive deadweight. Technology accelerates that deterioration.
These aren't terribly inspiring human truths, but I find they do hint at the futility of bemoaning the condition or hoping for emergent and sweeping policy solutions.
Better to empathize where possible, feel eminently thankful for our good fortune, and donate whatever surplus of time and capital we might have to a helpful cause.
That's doing some reductio ad absurdum on your argument but you are saying we should just give up trying to fight something that bad and give some minor help when possible, correct? We can try to do better
I'm saying more broadly that we're all probably at the mercy of an inescapable cycle that may not end until humanity is willing to cooperate perfectly at the global/species level of abstraction.
'The Lessons of History' also comments that competition is also inherent to our biological nature. There's a passage about how we usually only cooperate in order to compete at plural granularities (e.g. families, corporations, nations, religions). This has obvious implications for the tradeoff between freedom and equality.
“Because, if you’re honest with yourself, if you step away and look at what this world is and what it’s becoming… we’re really not far from a reality where everyone is condemned to the pits. Everyone is lost. Maybe not this generation. Maybe not the next. But surely, somehow, if you cherish anyone, anything, any legacy at all, you can’t let them win, destroy it all, and erect some… mockery in its place. Rewritten history, modified, subjugated, and broken people.”
[0] https://twigserial.wordpress.com/2017/08/26/crown-of-thorns-...
Organize a small band of hardened cadres and wait for your opportunity. Major war not going as well as planned or other crisis, few million frustrated citizens with arms and your small cadre have a chance to take over largest country on Earth.
Combine both - thirty years of exhausting war plus new religion and you can take over everything from Afghanistan to Morocco in just few years.
Refuse violence and keep repeating your arguments despite oppression - it might take shorter then you think - like British leaving India or Soviet Union leaving Central Europe and Central Asia.
Just few examples of impossible and unthinkable happening.
The sad reality is that this is not actually possible. This kind of inequality is a constant and cannot be changed. There is a segment of society that cannot pull themselves up by their bootstraps so to speak, and the way a society treats and cares for these people is the true yardstick of compassion and fairness.
Human life has positive ROI, as evidenced by the fact that our species has done better in the world over time. The largest returns are highly unpredictable too - the majority of "origin" stories for the greatest contributors to moving our species forward have come from modest beginnings.
So disadvantaging large swaths of the population with poor access to quality education or healthcare biases the system against the masses, and as a result, reduces the productive potential of that population segment. A janitor today may not be the next Steve Jobs. But his kid might, if given access to a good education and not burdened by needing to accept a "safe" work choice to support his parents.
In addition, that janitor is likely putting a much larger portion of his wealth back into the economy directly by purchasing "things." And in a global economy that revolves around mass production, it would make sense that economic policies favoring the spending power of the masses would be a key factor in the pace of innovation and moving industry at large forward.
If only Wall Street can afford 4k TVs, they'll be watching a lot of upscaled 1080p content. It's not until the janitors, electricians, etc (i.e. the masses) can afford the sets that they'll see the majority of content switch over to 4k. (This is a knowingly superficial but illustrative example of a larger principle).
Even in my own case - I have a pre-existing medical condition. If it weren't for Obamacare, I wouldn't have been able to co-found my startup, which last year (first operational year) did $350k in sales, and this year looks like it may hit $700k. I'd have needed a job that provided good group health insurance, and our company simply wouldn't exist.
We like to talk in the entrepreneur community about the need to take risks to be successful. But too often the community turns a blind eye to the fact that if you cut away enough of the public safety nets, the only people that will be taking risks are the people that either (a) have a personal safety net already, or (b) have such poor judgement in risk assessment that they are destined to fail.
Social programs and policies aren't "entitlements" or things we should be doing from simply a moral standpoint - they are economic "growth" programs and make a great deal of sense if you look at the broader picture and with a perspective of 10, 50, 100 years instead of fiscal quarters.
Income inequality unchecked is going to destroy our national competitiveness the same way an executive cutting themselves a massive salary and underfunding corporate reinvestment is going to drive that company into the ground. We're cutting national reinvestment in order to further advantage the previously successful (several generations past in many cases), at the cost of the potentially future successful.
If all super rich people were magically erased from the earth, would the poor have it any better?
The only other option I can see is that some tiny percentage of the country or of Apple would disappear. But what part, specifically?
This comment to me is characteristic of thinking of ownership in far too simplistic terms. Very rich people don't actually own productive things, they just own rights to income streams.
There are certain exceptions, such as the Koch brothers who do own their companies. If those companies disappeared that would also be a net benefit to US citizens.
"It can't be helped, the poor sods should have made better life choices to avoid ending up as janitor" is the attitude by which the matter is dismissed - as if requiring everyone to be a member of the educated elite just to be able earn a decent living.
There is so much wealth out there. This wealth is the product of society's common strive. Why not try to change the world instead of just submitting to the way things are?