Anyway what’s abhorrent about the blastulation method? Furthermore, I don’t think there is a need to only let those with a large number of recessive deleterious alleles use it. It should be more open to let people edit the genome of the embryo to remove even one or two dominant or recessive deleterious alleles. There’s no reason that if the technology exists, is safe, and is regulated that it should be only used for people with a huge number of genetic defects.
And can’t you just sequence or test one of the cells from the morula stage?
As a living, thinking human, I am grateful for everything that was done so that I may live.
If the fertility lab had mixed chemicals differently, or deleted a propensity towards colon cancer, or changed my hair color, there's no way in hell I would have mourned my "unborn" mirror self. I would have been just as grateful to be walking and talking and living!
The slippery slope isn't on the action, it's on the intent behind the action. Designing blond babies isn't evil. Designing babies susceptible to drug addiction is.
So can we please stop with the deification of the default and get on with progress?
Well said! I fear, though, that a problem with this admonition is that some ascribe the default state to a deity.
However, I'm not sure that the characteristics you mentioned are of the same quality.
Hair color, gender, and other traits are neutral in quality - especially if there's risk in the procedure, it would seem wrong to select these superficial changes to fit the parents' preference. And while it would be nice to look into the future and determine what the human being created would prefer, we can't do that.
A propensity towards colon cancer or a propensity towards drug addiction being added or removed would be another class of traits, having a quality based on removing observed defects. I imagine this class is the most likely to be experimented with first.
The third class would be traits which are relative to baseline humans. Increasing intelligence, perhaps, would be the change that could most universally be described as an unalloyed positive change. What hypothetical future human would mourn their unborn mirror self and wish they were less intelligent? Perhaps the acuity of their vision and other senses would also be desirable. You might also consider changing aspects such as their respiratory or cardiovascular capacity - some humans like Chris Froome or Michael Phelps are extraordinary examples of not just training but innate talent, and wouldn't it be nice if we went beyond reducing the risk of heart disease to make everyone innately talented at breathing? And then you get into issues like whether or not to make them stronger (who's healthier, Froome or Phelps?), or taller, or more good looking (who decides what that looks like?).
It would be great if we could help our kids be healthier. And I (and most people) would like it if my parents had made me smarter. But the technology opens the door to dangerous possibilities.
Caution is merited, but inaction carries culpability in the preventable negative outcomes solved in a potential future that we deny through fear.
And not disagreeing with your content, as I agree and think it's well written, but statements like "nice to look into the future and determine what the human being created would prefer, we can't do that" are part of what doesn't parse with me about this debate.
As with the anthropic principle, life has no a priori preferences. It becomes and then it is. Before it is, it doesn't want anything. After it is, it wants to be as it is. Because what is it is its identity.
There's a caveat for physical disabilities, and yes, that's a slippery slope as you've outlined. But how could one want to be another?
If I told you that I could make you smarter, right now, with 100% certainty and safety, but that afterwards... you wouldn't be you as you are now... would you say yes? Possibly, but I feel there's a certain inherent unease with that question. What happens to me if I become other?
My point being that this works in reverse too. If I am now as I was made, how would I feel about the choices made in my making? My assertion is that I wouldn't particularly care, because I am the result. So to wish otherwise would be to wish for the termination of my current identity.
If there's a debate to be had, then let it be one the social or individual merits of the actual change sought, rather than in making changes or not.
This is silly. I don't become some other person when I drink alcohol or wear contact lenses, nor when I break a leg, exercise my muscles, or make any other permanent alteration to my body. A theory of self/identity that "breaks" under new medical advancements because it also breaks under everyday conditions is just a bad theory.
You might identify yourself with a particular functional aspect if your mind, but you're going to have to do a fair amount of scientific work to pick out which functional aspect. Just gesturing to the meat doesn't really pick out anything immutable or specific.
Besides which, the Neolithic Revolution was 10,000 years ago if some damned primitivist really wants to make appeals to the natural order, rather than to the potential benefits and detriments to human health and happiness.
Blond babies might be grateful to be born and not mourn their unborn non-blond selves, but there still exist plenty of less fortunate other babies who do get born non-blond and will suffer as a result.
I don't agree with your wholesale assertion that all of those who are unable to afford cosmetic surgery (larger breasts, hair implants...) are suffering, however.
But if cosmetic surgery made you smarter, then clearly all who couldn't afford it would suffer (relative to those who could). We don't worry about that because cosmetic surgery doesn't have that potential (or does it? I dunno), but with gene editing I think it's a very real potential.
That's not to say I'm wholesale against it, nor would I support banning research or anything along those lines. But I think it's clear that it will be a huge shock to society if/when this becomes practical, and I don't think our society is particularly good at dealing with this kind of change that can only exacerbate existing issues of inequality.
Let's hope that as a civilization we have enough sense to sort out making it available to everyone by then, at minimum in the most obvious areas (preventing disease, avoiding birth defects, etc...)
We should remember that it's not just the individual whose genome is edited that may be harmed, but all of their descendants.
> And can’t you just sequence or test one of the cells from the morula stage?
This isn't sufficient. It has been observed (in mice) that editing the germline by directly editing the embryo will result in chimerism in the fetus. This happens because the editing is not 100% efficient in one cell division. So while some cells have the desired modification, others do not, while others still have completely different off-target edits. The resulting fetus may have the right edits in most cells, but the wrong ones in some particular tissue. It could be perfectly healthy except that it carries some alleles that are lethal when they occur in the liver, heart, or brain. It is impossible to avoid this by sequencing a single cell from the blastocyst, and probably it can't be avoided by sequencing any small number of cells.
> There’s no reason that if the technology exists, is safe, and is regulated that it should be only used for people with a huge number of genetic defects.
This technique does not appear to be safe, and it is not easy to control. If it were, I'd think it would be pretty cool. But, I don't see how we could do one-step editing with many edits unless the efficiency of the editing process is ~100%. And, given that the technique involves cutting the genome and hoping that the repair systems of the cell correct the cuts to templates that we've provided, it is very unlikely that it ever will be, because much of the editing process is outside of our control.
I look forward to another editing technique that is more precise. Or, to growing humans from cell culture. Both of these methods would provide the precision and safety that is required.
This is an implementation detail to be overcome, not a problem with the general concept. And this study seems to have overcome it.
> The earlier Chinese publications, although limited in scope, found CRISPR caused editing errors and that the desired DNA changes were taken up not by all the cells of an embryo, only some. That effect, called mosaicism, lent weight to arguments that germline editing would be an unsafe way to create a person.
> But Mitalipov and his colleagues are said to have convincingly shown that it is possible to avoid both mosaicism and “off-target” effects, as the CRISPR errors are known.
What is really happening is that normal copies of the human genome are being incorporated. Which are then passed on to your sperm/ovum.
"Our award winning, holistic, proprietary life-experience program leads to superior outcomes, when compared to competing life experience programs. Doctors know it, children's services favor it. So, what kind of life experience does your future family deserve?" Enter perfect puppies.
Two households, both alike in dignity, In fair Verona, where we lay our scene, From ancient grudge break to new mutiny, Where civil blood makes civil hands unclean. From forth the fatal loins of these two foes A pair of star-cross'd lovers take their life; Whose misadventured piteous overthrows Do with their death bury their parents' strife. The fearful passage of their death-mark'd love, And the continuance of their parents' rage, Which, but their children's end, nought could remove, Is now the two hours' traffic of our stage; The which if you with patented ears attend, What here shall miss, our toil shall strive to mend.
Most problems with the world are because there are a lot of people who don't make decisions based on a right mind. A few are because of insufficient information or insufficient technology to open up other choices, but most problems in economics and politics are caused by people being jerks to each other.
And, for the time being, bags and bags of money! Which currently makes this a vanishingly hypothetical problem of ethics.
One particularly well-known instance: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Haemophilia_in_European_royalt...
As for more modern times, surely the wealthy are especially cognizant of genetics, right?
"Historically, populations of Qatar have engaged in consanguineous relationships of all kinds, leading to high risk of inheriting genetic diseases. As of 2014, around 5% of the Qatari population suffered from hereditary hearing loss; most were descendants of a consanguineous relationship." -- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inbreeding#Prevalence
I do see one argument, hinging on the difference between an embryo and an adult aged many years. If your argument is that better techniques may exist at the embryonic stage, then I submit to the medical community to ascertain the appropriate course. However, I don't think offsite mutations pose a significant enough risk that one can say that, on aggregate, gene editing won't "do some good".
This more recent work by Mitalipov's group dealt with single cell embryo and still ended up with mosaicism, which I was a bit surprised at first. But when you think about it, this single-cell embryo's genome is actively being replicated, so not 100% of the alleles will be edited.
A way around it, would be to reactivate Cas9 after every cell division event, or maybe applying Cas9 gene-drive to embryo development. Also, I have yet to see a CRISPR paper with ensemble sequencing showing no off-targets. Even all the enhanced specificity Cas9 variants had a small percentage of off-targets.
Many of the worst disorders are lack of function mutations where mosaicism would indeed fix it.
I would be more worried about unwanted edits than missing ones.
The same mosaicism phenomenon which cause tabby cat's coat (especially callico) can be seen in human and would cause that individual to sweat by plaques, instead of the entire body. So you could imagine a scenario where someone would like to select a specific eye, or hair, or skin pigmentation, and end up with inequal pigmentations or a patchwork. That actually sounds cool...
In the case of an autoimmune disorder, like type-I diabetes or a blood disorders like beta-thalassemia, you would absolutely need to hit the proper germline which is responsible for creating your diseased cells. So that's a hit or miss, there is no inbetween. If you do have a hit, then while this germline is dividing and differentiating, it would need to reach a threshold at which the disease becomes asymptomatic. I don't what that number is for any of two diseases I just mentioned, but I would think it is higher than 50% of your cells that need to be corrected, so you would need to successfully hit more than one allele in your succesfully hit germline population that will become blood making cells.
It's a lot of moving parts, which needs to align correctly. That being said, I am optimistic that we will eventually get there. I have some doubt about the scientific pertinence of that "breaking news", i.e. I just don't believe they have accomplished anything that wasn't obvious, but being an optimist, I am sure that not all the ink will be a waste.
Nice question.
It comes from the hippocratic oath. "I will apply dietetic measures for the benefit of the sick according to my ability and judgment; I will keep them from harm and injustice."
Not really:
"In a 2000 survey of US medical schools, all of the then extant medical schools administered some type of profession oath. Among schools of modern medicine, sixty-two of 122 used the Hippocratic Oath, or a modified version of it."
Like I said in my previous post, some schools use a modern rendition. The modern versions don't forbid surgery, the use of poison, abortive measures, or compensation for medical training--necessary features of modern healthcare.
I challenge you to find me one med school that uses the original oath.
Medical ethics these days follows a principle-based system. The most common framework employs four basic moral principles: respect for autonomy, beneficence, non-maleficence, and justice. The current system of ethics is far more robust than any of the pledges taken. The pledges are more about personal significance and have no legal or procedural weight.
Obviously it's net harm, not no harm at all.
Medical ethics is its own field precisely because overeager and overconfident solutions are fraught with problems.
But what about if somebody donates a kidney...? Hm
> It is often said that the phrase "First do no harm" (Latin: Primum non nocere) is a part of the Hippocratic oath. The phrase as such does not appear in the oath...
What? I encourage you to read about prescription drug side effects. If a drug were safe, it would be over the counter rather than prescription. Prescription drugs are exactly the kind of harm/benefit bundle GP is describing.
Assessing treatments on thereputic merit - does a treatment create significantly more benefit than it does harm (As chemotherapy is a standard bearing example), is, based on the evidence I've observed, the preferable approach.
A more realistic scenario would be to develop a human embryonic stem cell culture that has been edited as desired and then implant this into a developing blastocyst at a point at which it would take over the and develop into the fetus. This is done with mice and there is no reason it wouldn't work for humans. I think that most people would find this much more abhorrent than directly editing the germline. However, it would be much safer for the engineered proband and would not require a "perfect" editing system that we do not have.