News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Zhou Youguang, creator of the Pinyin writing system, has ... by imjustsaying on Saturday January 14, 2017 @09:19AM (#13398457)
>I actually think it is quite fast. Grasping an entire languages phonology is a huge accomplishment and condensing it to its bare minimum is also impressive.

Absolutely. But I don't see how this statement could apply to pinyin. The work done on German's last spelling reform was impressive in this regard, but faulty pinyin was not.

Re:Zhou Youguang, creator of the Pinyin writing system, has ... by wodenokoto on Saturday January 14, 2017 @10:26AM (#13398784)
Care to expand on the faults of pinyin, and how they are more erroneous than say the German spelling reform?

My experience with pinyin is that it is very robust, and I don't remember ever encountering pinyin that was ambiguous about how it is read (unlike written English or romanized Japanese). I have also never heard of standard Chinese syllables that are lacking a clear mapping onto pinyin.

To me that is very impressive.

Re:Zhou Youguang, creator of the Pinyin writing system, has ... by em_te on Saturday January 14, 2017 @11:27AM (#13399094)
Compare "xi an" with "xian". One is 2 words and one is 1 word. But for some reason Chinese people don't like to put spaces in between words so "xi an shi" is often written as "xi'anshi" which is different from "xianshi".
Re:Zhou Youguang, creator of the Pinyin writing system, has ... by lacampbell on Saturday January 14, 2017 @07:33PM (#13401551)
Mandarin speakers are seem to be fairly sloppy with their own phonetic alphabets - you're supposed to have spaces in bopomofo and apostrophes in pinyin to handle cases like these, but they often don't bother.

It becomes clearer with tones I guess, "Xi1 An1" vs "Xian1". But again, proper pinyin with tones seems to be a foreigner thing... I don't recall seeing tone marks or numbers on street signs.

Re:Zhou Youguang, creator of the Pinyin writing system, has ... by FabHK on Saturday January 14, 2017 @11:31AM (#13399122)
But that's what you have the apostrophe for in Pinyin. Works fine.
Re:Zhou Youguang, creator of the Pinyin writing system, has ... by dilemma on Saturday January 14, 2017 @11:49AM (#13399229)
But pinyin isn't Chinese so your point just doesn't exist.
Re:Zhou Youguang, creator of the Pinyin writing system, has ... by emodendroket on Saturday January 14, 2017 @10:39AM (#13398836)
Well of course it's not ambiguous like English because they had no historical baggage. But properly romanized Japanese is also never ambiguous.
Re:Zhou Youguang, creator of the Pinyin writing system, has ... by wodenokoto on Saturday January 14, 2017 @04:44PM (#13400741)
"ene" can be えね and えんえ.

> But properly romanized Japanese is also never ambiguous.

What is "properly romanised Japanese" anyway? There are several modern systems in use [1] often mixed together (Even the government can't stick to the government mandated Kunrei-shiki). Some system represent ず and づ the same, some represent ティ and チー the same, some represent じ and ぢ the same. ō represents both O+O and O+U

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Romanization_of_Japanese#Moder...

Re:Zhou Youguang, creator of the Pinyin writing system, has ... by rangibaby on Sunday January 15, 2017 @01:54AM (#13402747)
えんえ should be en'e according to the govenment system. ティ is used exclusively in loan words anyway as far as I'm aware. Wouldn't you just write it in its original language?
Re:Zhou Youguang, creator of the Pinyin writing system, has ... by emodendroket on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @02:23PM (#13429456)
Also the other ones he mentioned are pronounced the exact same way.
Re:Zhou Youguang, creator of the Pinyin writing system, has ... by rangibaby on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @09:49PM (#13432557)
(you probably know this but) zu du and zi di do make a difference in terms of which kanji are used. The government has been reforming kanji readings over time though E.g. 藤 ふぢ → ふじ or 図 ヅ (look at the character in the box!)→ ず
Re:Zhou Youguang, creator of the Pinyin writing system, has ... by emodendroket on Sunday January 15, 2017 @08:18AM (#13403824)
Leaving out the apostrophe for えんえ is not standard in any of the three systems. Mixing and matching the systems is also not what I meant by "proper."
Re:Zhou Youguang, creator of the Pinyin writing system, has ... by singhblom on Sunday January 15, 2017 @04:50PM (#13406576)
I thought 花 and 鼻 were ambiguous in most romanizations - at least I would write it as "hana" in all romanizations I can think of, yet the pitch accent differs. No?
Re:Zhou Youguang, creator of the Pinyin writing system, has ... by emodendroket on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @09:22AM (#13417720)
There are systems (basically what looks like a long sideways L) but you're right that romanization doesn't record pitch accent. But there are big regional variations in pitch accent and people won't have trouble understanding you if you use the wrong one, mostly (and you could level the same complaint at hiragana or katakana, after all).

Nevertheless, that's a fair point that I wasn't really thinking about.

Re:Zhou Youguang, creator of the Pinyin writing system, has ... by grzm on Sunday January 15, 2017 @05:00PM (#13406644)
I would think the parent is referring to unambiguous in terms of pronunciation. You're right in that you wouldn't know which character was originally used in isolation—or whether kanji was used at all.

As far as I know, there's little (any?) pitch accent that distinguishes between words in Japanese. What pitch accent are you referring to?

Re:Zhou Youguang, creator of the Pinyin writing system, has ... by emodendroket on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @09:22AM (#13417732)
Every word in Japanese has a standard pitch accent and some otherwise homophonous ones differ in pitch accent. However, from one dialect to another the pitch accents on the same word can be totally different so I don't think they're usually a big hindrance to communication. Pitch accent differs from English stress accent.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Japanese_pitch_accent

Re:Zhou Youguang, creator of the Pinyin writing system, has ... by grzm on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @04:41PM (#13421558)
To be clear, you're saying that pitch can change due to regional accent, as opposed to distinguish between homophones, which is which is what 'singhblom was implying, correct?

I thought 花 and 鼻 were ambiguous … yet the pitch accent differs. No?

Re:Zhou Youguang, creator of the Pinyin writing system, has ... by emodendroket on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @06:45PM (#13422658)
It does both things. Pitch accent is the only thing distinguishing some homophones (hana, hasi, ame, kumo) but it's also got variation in dialects including a handful where the Tokyo and Osaka versions have the same distinction between two words except with the opposite meaning (sorry, I don't have examples off the top of my head).

Fortunately there aren't that many sentences where it's equally plausible you meant both spider and cloud.

Re:Zhou Youguang, creator of the Pinyin writing system, has ... by grzm on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @07:05PM (#13422781)
Interesting. Admittedly not a native speaker, I never found pitch accent used to distinguish between homophones during my time in Japan, nor was it introduced in any of the courses I took on Japanese while I was there, including the examples you provide.
Re:Zhou Youguang, creator of the Pinyin writing system, has ... by emodendroket on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @08:35PM (#13423292)
I majored in Japanese and it wasn't really seriously introduced until I studied in Japan and I'd already been studying Japanese for three years. But while not learning it won't hinder your ability to communicate too much it can help you sound more natural. NHK publishes a dictionary of pitch accent in standard Tokyo dialect: https://www.amazon.co.jp/NHK-%E6%97%A5%E6%9C%AC%E8%AA%9E%E7%...
Re:Zhou Youguang, creator of the Pinyin writing system, has ... by grzm on Tuesday January 17, 2017 @08:56PM (#13423386)
Thanks for the reference! Could I trouble you to provide an example from that text that describes such a homophone (as opposed to regional dialect) distinction?
Re:Zhou Youguang, creator of the Pinyin writing system, has ... by emodendroket on Wednesday January 18, 2017 @09:05AM (#13426335)
The examples I gave upthread all have pairs with different accents in hyozyungo.
Re:Zhou Youguang, creator of the Pinyin writing system, has ... by grzm on Thursday January 19, 2017 @02:51PM (#13438910)
Okay. I was hoping for quotes from the text itself.
Re:Zhou Youguang, creator of the Pinyin writing system, has ... by hgfdhjtyd on Saturday January 14, 2017 @10:11AM (#13398694)
> but faulty pinyin was not.

Is this a real opinion or just a political stand against PRC? How is pinyin faulty, specifically with respect to Mandarin Chinese?

What Romanization system is better and how so?

Re:Zhou Youguang, creator of the Pinyin writing system, has ... by jason_slack on Saturday January 14, 2017 @10:51AM (#13398910)
OP elaborates more about this below.