News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dan Rather: Now, More Than Ever, We Must Stand Up for Sci... by CWuestefeld on Monday November 14, 2016 @11:23AM (#12950813)
These claims that we must do what science dictates are self-serving, and the ongoing chant is getting really tiresome.

Science does not lead inexorably to policy. Science is only the first step, in how it allows us to understand the world around us. What we want to do about that is an entirely value-based decision. Deciding to implement policy demands filtering that understanding through a lens of our collective values as a society. Those values are fluid, and very frequently in controversy. It seems like the demands to "follow science" are an attempt to sweep some of that controversy under the carpet.

In the case of climate change, it's pretending that there's cost/benefit analysis to be done. It ignores the possibility that the cost of doing something will exceed the likely damage expected. (I'm not saying that's the case, I'm just saying that folks are trying to skip that part of the conversation)

It pops up in other cases, too. Virtually every economist will tell you that free trade is almost always a net positive for all involved. It harms a few, but on net the entire society is much better off. If we stopped with the science, then we should remove all tariffs and be done with it. But before we do so, there's still a moral question to be resolved: if a few people are paying the price to improve our overall economy, do we owe any debt to them, to make them whole afterwards?

So stop pretending that a lack of the policy you want demonstrates that we're scientifically illiterate. Instead, recognize that the science can only inform our debate over the values.

Re:Dan Rather: Now, More Than Ever, We Must Stand Up for Sci... by tzs on Monday November 14, 2016 @11:49AM (#12951077)
> In the case of climate change, it's pretending that there's cost/benefit analysis to be done. It ignores the possibility that the cost of doing something will exceed the likely damage expected. (I'm not saying that's the case, I'm just saying that folks are trying to skip that part of the conversation)

In the case of climate change, we can't even get to the cost/benefit analysis part of the conversation because some people (including the presedint-elect, and important members of the majority party in Congress who lead the committees that where climate action would originate) say that climate change is not happening, or that if it is happening humans are not contributing to it and cannot do anything about it.

Re:Dan Rather: Now, More Than Ever, We Must Stand Up for Sci... by gwright on Monday November 14, 2016 @12:38PM (#12951579)
I hear this a lot and feel like it is a muddled response to a muddled understanding of climate change.

For what it is worth:

    * Science is clear that CO2 causes warming (pure physics), but so do many other gases (methane, water vapor, etc).
    * Science is clear that global temperatures are rising (even if you quibble about the 'pause')
    * Science isn't clear regarding what part of global temperature rise is due to human activity.
    * Science isn't clear on how much and how fast temperatures might rise.
    * Science isn't clear on how to model the climate. Climate models have incorporated a net positive sensitivity to CO2 warming and make predictions that have exceeded actual temperature gains. So the models are not accurately predicting the climate.
    * Science isn't going to provide a definitive policy response to increased temperatures. There are many options.
In particular, the warming due to CO2 physics is NOT the catastrophic warming that we see reported in the news. That warming is based on climate models incorporating a large positive sensitivity to the CO2 warming (as well as many other factors). The models are not "settled science". The actual sensitivity is not something that can be measured with today's scientific understanding of complex climate systems.

Even if the climate models were making correct predictions. It doesn't automatically follow that the policy solution is to reduce CO2 emissions to 0. The costs of clean energy have to be borne by someone and cutting off energy supplies (because energy is more expensive) to developing economies, for example, also has consequences. The negative affects of warming can be mitigated also via relocating people, communities, and changing our land-use patterns, etc. The correct policy mix is going to depend on many factors, most of which are going to vary from place to place. A single global policy proscription isn't likely to be feasible for lots of reasons.

Finally, criticism of policy proscriptions shouldn't automatically be interpreted and characterized as rejecting the climate change hypothesis. In many cases there are argument for or against policy proscriptions that aren't even related to climate change, such as improving air quality, increasing the efficiency of our energy systems, using market based approaches to avoid crony capitalism and favored industries, and so on.

Re:Dan Rather: Now, More Than Ever, We Must Stand Up for Sci... by jwatte on Monday November 14, 2016 @01:22PM (#12951971)

    * Science isn't clear regarding what part of global temperature rise is due to human activity.
    * Science isn't clear on how much and how fast temperatures might rise.
I believe science does have confidence intervals on the ranges, and even the lower ends are pretty bad. As in, it's not a question on "whether" the global food supply pipeline will collapse, but "when" -- 2035 to 2070, depending on the side of the confidence interval you pick.

    * It doesn't automatically follow that the policy solution is to reduce CO2 emissions to 0.
Nobody is arguing for reducing CO2 emissions to 0. Most of the majority arguments are actually quite tame -- leading to a reduction of profits in coal and oil industries, not a wholesale dissolution. Yet, even that, is seen as an unacceptable cost of increasing the chances of civilization survival by the right-wing party of the United States.
Re:Dan Rather: Now, More Than Ever, We Must Stand Up for Sci... by gwright on Monday November 14, 2016 @11:56PM (#12955704)
It isn't clear to me what a confidence interval is for a prediction from a complex climate model. What are the sources of error for a software model? How can they be quantified?

In any case, my understanding is that global warming increases that are at the low end of predictions is not catastrophic and that is actually where measured changes fall.

Here is a report from the NOAA that says: > The “pause” in global warming observed since 2000 followed a period of rapid acceleration in the late 20th century. Starting in the mid-1970s, global temperatures rose 0.5 °C over a period of 25 years. Since the turn of the century, however, the change in Earth’s global mean surface temperature has been close to zero.

https://www.climate.gov/news-features/climate-qa/why-did-ear...

That report is interesting because it argues against the pause indicating a true slowdown in global warming because the period of time is too short, that climate change works on much longer intervals. Perhaps that is true, and the 15 year pause is temporary. Time will tell.

Re:Dan Rather: Now, More Than Ever, We Must Stand Up for Sci... by alecst on Monday November 14, 2016 @01:59PM (#12952297)
Can you elaborate on this part?

    * Science isn't clear regarding what part of global temperature rise is due to human activity.
I just want to contrast the above with this statement by the IPCC [1]:

"Human influence has been detected and attributed in warming of the atmosphere and the ocean, in changes in the global water cycle, in reductions in snow and ice, and in global mean sea level rise; and has been extremely likely been the dominant cause of the observed warming since the mid century. In recent decades, changes in climate have caused impacts on natural and human systems on all continents and across the oceans."

[1] https://www.ipcc.ch/pdf/assessment-report/ar5/syr/drafts/SYR...

Re:Dan Rather: Now, More Than Ever, We Must Stand Up for Sci... by nonbel on Monday November 14, 2016 @02:14PM (#12952422)
>"[human activity] has been extremely likely been the dominant cause of the observed warming since the mid century."

This is worded strangely so that it doesn't mean anything. Of course human activity has been the dominant cause of humans observing something. Why don't they say CO2 emitted by human-made machines or something more specific?

Re:Dan Rather: Now, More Than Ever, We Must Stand Up for Sci... by alecst on Monday November 14, 2016 @03:03PM (#12952775)
That reply doesn't address my original comment, but the IPCC do say just that -- although not in that paragraph. You will find statements all over the IPCC about how climate change is nearly certain to be caused by people, and in particular, by people burning fossil fuels. If you go to the link I posted and search for "fossil" you will that in those notes. You can also read the official IPCC reports yourself to get a clearer idea.

Maybe I'm misunderstanding you, but there's no anthropic principle at work. It would be perfectly fine to say (although it would not be true) that "plasma fluctuations on the surface of the sun are extremely likely to be the dominant cause of observed warming since the mid century."

Re:Dan Rather: Now, More Than Ever, We Must Stand Up for Sci... by nonbel on Monday November 14, 2016 @03:16PM (#12952913)
I was just commenting on the strange word choice used for that statement. Almost like whoever was editing that section wanted a way to weasel out of the implications later, if need be.
Re:Dan Rather: Now, More Than Ever, We Must Stand Up for Sci... by gwright on Monday November 14, 2016 @03:52PM (#12953240)
"climate change" isn't caused by people unless you think the climate never changed before humans were involved.

The question is what portion of the change is contributed by recent human industrial activity and I don't think that is particularly well quantified.

Re:Dan Rather: Now, More Than Ever, We Must Stand Up for Sci... by randomgyatwork on Monday November 14, 2016 @05:01PM (#12953759)
This page has a graph that shows how global temperature changes are part of cycle that has existed longer than humanity.

http://earthobservatory.nasa.gov/Features/GlobalWarming/page...

Re:Dan Rather: Now, More Than Ever, We Must Stand Up for Sci... by gwright on Monday November 14, 2016 @03:49PM (#12953207)
I was pointing out that the human induced part of the rise isn't quantified very well (large error bars, lots of handwaving), not that there is no human induced warning.
Re:Dan Rather: Now, More Than Ever, We Must Stand Up for Sci... by alecst on Monday November 14, 2016 @05:21PM (#12953891)
That's alright. I just want to know why you say that it's handwavey. As far as I knew there was almost no dispute that CO2 had huge and well-quantified warming potential. Nor was there a debate about the origin of the CO2 in the atmosphere (from the ratio of carbon-14/13 to carbon-12, you can tell it's from fossil fuels.) Please correct me if this is mistaken, because it's not my field of expertise.
Re:Dan Rather: Now, More Than Ever, We Must Stand Up for Sci... by gwright on Monday November 14, 2016 @11:25PM (#12955571)
The amount of CO2 in the atmosphere is well quantified and there are estimates regarding how much of this is caused by human activity that don't appear to be source of too much controversy. The warming caused by CO2 is relatively clear, and not seriously disputed.

But the direct warming due to CO2 is not what triggers all the public debate about climate change. That comes from the indirect warming associated with hypothesized positive feedback mechanism within the Earth's climate. There is no settled science on this indirect warming so the net affect of human-activity (the measured CO2 in the atmosphere contributed by human activity) is unclear. The climate models have historically over-estimated this net affect when their predictions are compared to the actual measurements.

Re:Dan Rather: Now, More Than Ever, We Must Stand Up for Sci... by splawn on Monday November 14, 2016 @01:31PM (#12952052)
While this response seems 100% reasonable, I don't see how this it is any more effective in the face of "Climate change is a Chinese hoax" level absurdity. At this point with deniers it is religion so reason is out the door regardless.
Re:Dan Rather: Now, More Than Ever, We Must Stand Up for Sci... by btdiehr on Monday November 14, 2016 @01:43PM (#12952164)
You are misrepresenting the opposing argument being made.

The opposing argument is that people are making is as follows: 'climate-alarmists' misuse climate-science as a means of making political change.

It is not a denial of all climate-change science.

I don't care to argue this topic because I'm not expert nor do I care to pretend to be one on the topic of climate change, but this misrepresentation of the opposing views is part of the liberal-bubble so many people live in - all while smugly assuring themselves how much smarter they are than everyone else.

Re:Dan Rather: Now, More Than Ever, We Must Stand Up for Sci... by burkaman on Monday November 14, 2016 @02:40PM (#12952581)
Are you unaware of the hundreds of times Trump has literally claimed all climate change science is a hoax, or are you saying his view is unimportant?
Re:Dan Rather: Now, More Than Ever, We Must Stand Up for Sci... by btdiehr on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @05:22PM (#12962866)
I'm familiar with some of his statements, but I can't claim to know them all.

Could you please refer me to where he said that 'all climate change science is a hoax'? I would agree that would be a factually incorrect statement though I could not find anything where he said that. My interpretation of what I've read from what Trump has said, is that Trump believes that Climate Change Alarmists (from his perspective) utilize it to for political/policy reasons beyond the purely environmental reasons that they claim.

Re:Dan Rather: Now, More Than Ever, We Must Stand Up for Sci... by gwright on Monday November 14, 2016 @11:30PM (#12955584)
Trump and many other people don't seem to clearly understand the difference between the 'settled science' part of climate change and the 'unclear science' part. As such Trump and many others have very muddled and confused responses to those advocating various public policy changes due to climate change.

Some clarity about what is and isn't 'settled' would certainly improve the public debate on policy but I'm not holding my breath.

Re:Dan Rather: Now, More Than Ever, We Must Stand Up for Sci... by burkaman on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @09:49AM (#12958400)
I disagree, what has Trump been unclear about? He doesn't think humans cause climate change, but he also doesn't think the planet is getting warmer. He doesn't even seem to think that CFCs are a real problem. He wants to cut the EPA. He thinks asbestos regulations are pointless.

Trump has been clear and consistent for decades on this stuff, which I'm not sure you can say about any other belief of his. A new clarifying statement from the IPCC would not suddenly clear everything up for him.

Re:Dan Rather: Now, More Than Ever, We Must Stand Up for Sci... by thefastlane on Monday November 14, 2016 @01:32PM (#12952061)
i would love to dive into this further (both the science itself, and how we cross the bridge from science to policy), can you recommend any resources or papers (DOI if possible)?
Re:Dan Rather: Now, More Than Ever, We Must Stand Up for Sci... by guscost on Monday November 14, 2016 @12:07PM (#12951277)
> In the case of climate change, we can't even get to the cost/benefit analysis part of the conversation

Sorry? We were already at the "let's bribe farmers to grow extra corn and then burn it for fuel" stage, years ago.

Re:Dan Rather: Now, More Than Ever, We Must Stand Up for Sci... by novaleaf on Monday November 14, 2016 @01:43PM (#12952160)
keep in mind though, that was in part a geopolitical security strategy (energy security), as the USA was deeply reliant on foreign oil. (This was before the Alberta oil sands was viable, and fracking wasn't even a known option)

Of course, can't say that's a good reason to continue the subsidies today though.

Re:Dan Rather: Now, More Than Ever, We Must Stand Up for Sci... by guscost on Monday November 14, 2016 @05:54PM (#12954110)
Good point, some of those policies were sold as different things to different groups.
Re:Dan Rather: Now, More Than Ever, We Must Stand Up for Sci... by mattnewton on Monday November 14, 2016 @11:40AM (#12950988)
I think a lot of people don't need to infer scientific illiteracy from policy, they can take it from the horse's mouth.

http://edition.cnn.com/videos/politics/2016/09/26/mobile-cli...

http://www.msnbc.com/rachel-maddow-show/ben-carson-argued-ev...

Etc etc

Re:Dan Rather: Now, More Than Ever, We Must Stand Up for Sci... by jwatte on Monday November 14, 2016 @01:28PM (#12952020)
A lot of policies are quite scientifically illiterate or even disparaging. "Teach abstinence, not sex ed." "Don't coddle criminals, lock them up." "Trickle-down economics is the best way to create jobs." "Creationism makes just as good predictions as evolution, so it should be taught with equal emphasis."

It goes on and on, even if we ignore any one of the arguments, the problem is that many people, even people in power, believe that what they and their clique wants to be true is just as important as what can actually be demonstrated to be true. Or to put it another way: If someone says something to be true, that's equally powerful no matter what their basis (repeatable, predictable measurements, or plain dogma.)

Re:Dan Rather: Now, More Than Ever, We Must Stand Up for Sci... by millettjon on Monday November 14, 2016 @11:36AM (#12950955)
If a large portion of the population does not value or understand science, how can you have a rational debate on values?
Re:Dan Rather: Now, More Than Ever, We Must Stand Up for Sci... by nsxwolf on Monday November 14, 2016 @11:55AM (#12951148)
Let's say that eventually it is the consensus of the scientific community that things like consciousness, pain and free will are just illusions, and therefore, human rights are an outdated concept, and future policy decisions should reflect that consensus.

You'd resist those policy proposals, and I think most people would. You'd base that resistance on your values - values, which in this case at least, you did NOT derive from the scientific consensus.

My point is there are non-scientific origins for value systems, and they are more real and valid than scientifically derived ones - science can only give you facts about the material universe.

Re:Dan Rather: Now, More Than Ever, We Must Stand Up for Sci... by whateveracct on Monday November 14, 2016 @12:36PM (#12951561)
> Let's say that eventually it is the consensus of the scientific community that things like consciousness, pain and free will are just illusions, and therefore, human rights are an outdated concept

That last part is a value statement that I doubt science could prove.

Re:Dan Rather: Now, More Than Ever, We Must Stand Up for Sci... by kazinator on Monday November 14, 2016 @12:42PM (#12951616)
Consciousness (and pain) aren't illusions because they correspond to external phenomena, and have a significant objective component. An illusion is something that nobody else can experience, even partially, other than the subject having the illusion.

Even if free will is rule-based at some low-level, that doesn't erase the concept of rights.

We have rights even among inanimate objects. For instance, some server instance has rights to access certain files.

Rights are not pinned to free will. They are mostly about declaring certain unwanted actions of others to be wrong and punishable. Whether those unwanted actions are the result of free will, or whether they are deterministic, is immaterial. At most, that consideration only influences how we regard a violation of right; we might be somewhat more lenient if we believe that it was inevitable.

This is why the criminal courts take a particular view toward defendants who are mentally deficient or insane; in effect, this is based on the belief that those people possess less free will. It is never declared, however, that whatever they did was OK.

Re:Dan Rather: Now, More Than Ever, We Must Stand Up for Sci... by stcredzero on Monday November 14, 2016 @01:19PM (#12951944)
We have rights even among inanimate objects. For instance, some server instance has rights to access certain files.

You're really positing this as actual serious intellectual output? Just because it uses the same word does not mean that "rights" in the context of a server instance has anything to do with rights in the context of human rights. <facepalm>

Re:Dan Rather: Now, More Than Ever, We Must Stand Up for Sci... by kazinator on Monday November 14, 2016 @03:32PM (#12953061)
I don't see the difference. Rights is just some security-related descriptor of an object, whether that be a human being or a Wi-Fi router or whatever. I generally don't equivocate over word semantics.
Re:Dan Rather: Now, More Than Ever, We Must Stand Up for Sci... by eveningcoffee on Monday November 14, 2016 @05:00PM (#12953754)
Perhaps you could provide few examples that relate to humans?
Re:Dan Rather: Now, More Than Ever, We Must Stand Up for Sci... by dwaltrip on Monday November 14, 2016 @09:54PM (#12955257)
A server instance has no legal rights. The human controlling the server has certain legal rights in how they are allowed to configure and operate it. For example, as granted by the first amendment, they can serve a large variety of content to visitors, etc.

This is a pretty important distinction.

Re:Dan Rather: Now, More Than Ever, We Must Stand Up for Sci... by hx87 on Monday November 14, 2016 @12:52PM (#12951699)
Your point is right, but your example is terribly flawed, because as whateveracct notes,

> and therefore, human rights are an outdated concept

is a value judgement that cannot be derived from scientific principles.

Re:Dan Rather: Now, More Than Ever, We Must Stand Up for Sci... by nsxwolf on Monday November 14, 2016 @01:17PM (#12951936)
That's the very point I'm making, that you can't derive values that way, and yet many people insist we do so anyway. Like climate change - we've proven man is responsible for global warming therefore we must do x, y, and z about it.

The fact that mankind is responsible from global warming has nothing to do with needing to do something about it, or what exactly should be done. But it's always spoken about in terms of "science insists we must do something/this about it".

Re:Dan Rather: Now, More Than Ever, We Must Stand Up for Sci... by whyaduck on Monday November 14, 2016 @02:24PM (#12952487)
You've skipped over a key part of the argument for taking action to reduce climate change: we've proven man is responsible for global warming, our models show devastating things a, b and c happening due to warming, therefore we must do x, y and z about it.
Re:Dan Rather: Now, More Than Ever, We Must Stand Up for Sci... by nsxwolf on Monday November 14, 2016 @02:42PM (#12952598)
Or, its possible to arrive at the conclusion that doing something about climate change would plunge billions back into poverty, starvation and death, and decide against doing those things.
Re:Dan Rather: Now, More Than Ever, We Must Stand Up for Sci... by hx87 on Monday November 14, 2016 @12:50PM (#12951687)
You can certainly have a rational debate on values without much understanding of science, but rational debate on policies to reach those goals would be impossible.
Re:Dan Rather: Now, More Than Ever, We Must Stand Up for Sci... by bitwize on Monday November 14, 2016 @12:01PM (#12951221)
You can either wait around for the market to catch up with reality and account for the externalities of environmental damage, or you can pass government regulations that help fix or mitigate the damage NOW. Case in point: the bans on CFCs and agricultural DDT.
Re:Dan Rather: Now, More Than Ever, We Must Stand Up for Sci... by SonicSoul on Monday November 14, 2016 @11:38AM (#12950971)
its hard to do an objective value based analysis because it's hard to put a price on environment. That's the problem with capitalism. Making the world better for our kids does not maximize shareholder value. We can at least be honest with ourselves instead of simply denying facts to justify our decisions
Re:Dan Rather: Now, More Than Ever, We Must Stand Up for Sci... by ancap on Monday November 14, 2016 @12:02PM (#12951230)
Capitalism has no problem with pricing the environment. It is governments which have prevented it from doing so. Privatize the skies, oceans and lands and you would clearly see the prices come into play. Now we could argue about the merits of doing such, but claiming a man tied to a chair is incapable of walking is incorrect.
Re:Dan Rather: Now, More Than Ever, We Must Stand Up for Sci... by jwatte on Monday November 14, 2016 @01:34PM (#12952081)
First: "captitalism" means "the ability of private property owners to gate access to their property to others." What you're talking about is "market economy," which is not the same thing.

Second: For a market economy to lead to the optimal outcome, it requires that rational actors make decisions based on perfect information.

We have large swathes of society set up to reduce the access to "perfect information," under the guises of "trade secrets" and "privacy" and a host of other values. In fact, as soon as there is any information assymetry, there is a very strong incentive to slant the market to favor the information holder, which leads to much less efficiency. We can fight that either by regulating, or by making it a crime to hide any information. Until now, we have chosen the former. I doubt that you are arguing that the latter would be better. That's the reality of the world we live in today.

Third: For the market economy to work, we also need "rational actors." We know from psychology that humans are nowhere near rational, and often act counter to their own self-interest. We also know from sociology that humans in larger groups are often easily misled from their own best-benefit path.

Re:Dan Rather: Now, More Than Ever, We Must Stand Up for Sci... by CWuestefeld on Monday November 14, 2016 @12:08PM (#12951284)
This is correct. The problem isn't capitalism, except in that we don't have enough of it. Our framework for private property won't recognize rights in air or running water, and so they become an easy sink for externalities.

If someone contaminates your land (say, by spilling heating oil), there's a well-defined path for recovering the damages. But since we don't recognize an owner of air or water, when those are contaminated, there's nobody who can claim damages.

By not fully recognizing property rights, we lose the ability to prevent polluters from externalizing their costs.

EDIT: s/Or/Our/

Re:Dan Rather: Now, More Than Ever, We Must Stand Up for Sci... by sliverstorm on Monday November 14, 2016 @12:42PM (#12951612)
The reason we don't recognize ownership of the air above your land is because we have no way to precisely track its flow and pollution. Land is easy to track, it doesn't go anywhere.

It's a technical problem. Capitalism can't value something if it isn't capable of measuring it.