News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by blub on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @11:05AM (#12901315)
Microsoft embraces open source because they found out that there are other methods to monetize and lock in customers. As a bonus people seem to like you when you give them stuff for free, even with the catch of privacy invasion.

In other words, they stopped copying Apple and switched their sights on Google.

The stuff that matters stays closed source. Infrastructure, tooling are published because they bring massive amounts of goodwill and developer mindshare while hindering potential competitors that now have to battle with a free offering.

Frankly I preferred the old Microsoft which wanted your money, not the new one that (also!) wants your data.

Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by nixos on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @01:04PM (#12902476)
They're not copying Google. They're taking the worst of both worlds.

Windows isn't free. It just happens to come with the cost of your PC, but the PC manufacturer pays for it (and passes the cost to you).

They just noticed that no one upgrades Windows (and why should they? When was the last time you were excited about a windows release? XP? 95? 3.1? Maybe 7 if you're coming from Vista?)

Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by baldfat on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @01:53PM (#12902890)
I have been using Linux for 13 years.

I fail to see the worst?

I personally was VERY excited for Windows 7 and it proved to be a very solid edition. VERY VERY excited for Ubuntu bash in Windows 10 in the preview edition.

> They're not copying Google. They're taking the worst of both worlds.

Google's model is advertising

Apple's is Hardware

Microsoft is selling services more.

I find it really awesome that Microsoft has really turned into a company I have a positive view of and glad that Steve Balmer is gone.

Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by nixos on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @02:17PM (#12903092)
> Microsoft is selling services more.

Maybe, but what I'm saying is that:

Apple costs, is closed-source but (somewhat) cares about privacy. Google is free, (somewhat) open-source but actively doesn't care about privacy. Windows costs, closed source and actively doesn't care about privacy.

In other words, with Google you're not the customer, you're the product. With Microsoft you're the product and you have to pay for the privilege to be a product.

Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by baldfat on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @02:39PM (#12903280)
I have a strong negative bias vs Apple and everything they make.

One thing is Apple is not a closed source company. Though it is a mixed bag they have made some good contributions to the Open Sources world. Though their Walled Garden is YUGE

https://developer.apple.com/opensource/

* Bonjour

* Webkit

* Swift

Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by rubber_duck on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @08:54AM (#12910227)
I think they are the biggest driver behind LLVM projects (LLVM/Clang/LLDB) as well which is a huge value to OSS too.
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by nixos on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @06:14PM (#12904816)
Though those contributions aren't strategic.

As of now, most of Android APIs are in AOSP. How many Apple APIs are?

Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by bpye on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @02:33PM (#12903247)
Microsoft is a lot more than just Windows.
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by michaelbuddy on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @02:51PM (#12913956)
Microsoft doesn't care about privacy? They stood with Apple against FBI so you know. They are more reliably data protective than Amazon or Google in their agreements. They don't know what your data is on the cloud for example. Amazon stole Target's data and used it against them.
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by nixos on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @04:17PM (#12904011)
> I personally was VERY excited for Windows 7 and it proved to be a very solid edition. VERY VERY excited for Ubuntu bash in Windows 10 in the preview edition.

You can't compare the need for Windows 7 vs XP and the need for 95 after 3.1 . There was a huge amount of software which simply required 95.

Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by baldfat on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @07:23AM (#12909657)
Windows 98SE was loved and slowly droped for XP.

One word about Windows 7

Vista

Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by AnonymousPlanet on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @12:37PM (#12902228)
And there is nothing at all stopping them from closing everything up again once they're back on top (which might be sooner than anyone thinks).
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by prplhaz4 on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @01:00PM (#12902439)
Are there any good examples of this strategy? I can't think of anyone successfully moving a leading open source product back to closed source...I think normally it's the fork of the open source version that lives on...
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by parennoob on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @01:15PM (#12902562)
Solaris?

The open source nature of it seemed to disappear overnight after Oracle bought Sun, but looks like Oracle's not doing too badly with it. I know there's the Open Source illumos (IIRC) but haven't heard of anyone using it in production.

Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by cthalupa on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @02:31PM (#12903225)
>I know there's the Open Source illumos (IIRC) but haven't heard of anyone using it in production.

Joyent? OmniTI?

https://www.joyent.com/smartos https://omnios.omniti.com/

SmartOS and OmniOS are both used in modern day production workloads.

Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by dozzie on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @01:27PM (#12902661)
This guy uses a derivative of Illumos in production: https://utcc.utoronto.ca/~cks/space/blog/
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by siebenmann on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @04:23PM (#12904068)
If people are interested, the specifics of our current OmniOS environment are here: https://utcc.utoronto.ca/~cks/space/blog/solaris/ZFSFileserv...

We have been broadly happy with it and it has been quite stable after some initial teething problems.

Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by dozzie on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @04:33PM (#12904133)
Oh. And I was wondering what nick do you have here :)
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by AnonymousPlanet on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @01:25PM (#12902645)
Off the top of my head: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MaxDB#Licensing

In case of Microsoft, you don't even have to be very imaginative: how much of the stack currently in use by .Net developers on Windows is completely open? How important and hard to replace are the parts that aren't?

And how much of a difference would it make in the end to have had Core open source in the past, when the new and closed version is the only one that works with those billions of Windows10 tablets and those popular Azure services that everyone needs for their startup?

Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by Kipters on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @06:14PM (#12904820)
You can run the open source .NET Core on Azure, also the new programming model for Windows (UWP) uses .NET Core, not the desktop .NET
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by aikah on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @10:59AM (#12901250)
My Windows license doesn't feel "Open by Default", nor SQL Server license audits ... I like the guy, he created Mono, Xamarin, Gtk and co. But only a tiny subset of MS products like the .NET ecosystem are open.
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by wmccullough on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @11:26AM (#12901518)
Obviously they are talking about projects going forward. The article makes that pretty clear.

"Microsoft is now open by default and you actually have to make a case on a team/peer review level if you feel something needs to be closed,” said de Icaza."

Should they stay guilty forever for the things done in the previous regime?

Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by sametmax on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @01:02PM (#12902461)
First, you have to give very strong evidences that they are not "like the previous regime", or that there is a "previous" at all. All I see right now is PR and strategic moves (let's do what google did, even a bit late).

Secondly, given the track record, it is fair that it will take a long time before their past is forgiven. At least the same number of years of doubt that they spent misbehaving. And again that supposes they are not doing it right now. Like patent trolling, or moving software you could buy to a rent-only model, or put spywares in their new OS.

I strongly believe MS is not getting better, just getting better at communicating. They are not in a monopoly anymore and they can't get away with a "linux is cancer" like they used to do.

The only thing that bother me is that the Gates are getting away with it. They detached them self from MS, and now make heavy communication on their charity, so everybody seems to think they are saints. People have very short memory.

Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by michaelmrose on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @01:29PM (#12902678)
With decades of bad behavior I don't understand why they would ever be trusted. Its not like Gates is dead and buried and there certainly is continuity between the old regime and new.
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by pm90 on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @01:37PM (#12902756)
I don't think that's a fair assessment; I'm going to judge them on their present actions rather than their past behavior, when the market, leadership etc. were all different. They seem to be trying to adapt to the new market reality where open source and dev friendly tools/software creates goodwill and promotes adoption.
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by irq-1 on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @12:02PM (#12901886)
Will the next versions of Microsofts closed/licensed software be open? Will someone have to make a case that they need to remain closed? Will they release new products that are closed/licensed?
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by cryptarch on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @12:57PM (#12902416)
I assume they'll make all Windows updates open-source from now on then?
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by nogbit on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @12:16PM (#12902021)
Yes, because their OS is now evergreen, there will never be another "Windows X" and it will be forever closed. If/when they make the OS open (and ideally their other products as well) only then can his statement be taken seriously.
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by Aldo_MX on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @11:02AM (#12901279)
My Windows 10 Telemetry settings really look "open by default"...
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by baldfat on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @01:55PM (#12902900)
"Microsoft is now open by default and you actually have to make a case on a team/peer review level if you feel something needs to be closed,” said de Icaza."

The Microsoft bias is to always bash them but give a pass to Apple. I think Microsoft has been the good guy for a bit but they still get hate mainly due to Steve Balmer.

Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by digi_owl on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @12:57PM (#12902410)
Actually he founded Gnome, GTK already existed (the G coming from GIMP).

Frankly the guy seems very similar to Poettering. Stuff he creates, for the most part, only really becomes usable once the leaves the project.

Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by deckard1 on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @03:17PM (#12903554)
No idea why you're getting downvotes. You're completely right.

I was there when GNOME started. Was working heavily with GTK+ and GIMP at the time. Most of GNOME was tossed together haphazardly in a mad dash to catch up with KDE. There were astroturfing campaigns against KDE/Qt, organized on the GIMP IRC servers. The hate on Slashdot towards KDE was crazy, and much of it coming directly from GNOME camp. GNOME 1.x was a total shitshow. The code was horrid, and nothing was stable at all. Luckily their poor standards of code quality never hurt GTK+ much, as the GIMP guys still knew what the hell they were doing.

Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by anonbanker on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @04:42PM (#12904211)
Remember that KDE/Qt were not licensed under anything GPL-compatible at the time, hence the reason GNOME was started in the first place.

KDE was indeed much better. GNOME 1.x was awful. I and others like me still used GNOME 1.x, because I wanted a free desktop environment.

You weren't the only one on #gimp; don't pretend GIMP had a much better class of developers. Remember GEGL used to refer to hairy parts of the codebase (Genetically-Engineered Goat, Large) that people were afraid of touching.

Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by anonbanker on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @04:39PM (#12904187)
your downvotes are alarming.

Miguel left GNOME before 2.0 shipped, and started working on Mono full-time. If you've ever used GNOME 1.0, it was barely more than a set of ORB-based applications you stacked on top of Enlightenment DR 0.15 (or Sawmill/Sawfish if you weren't cool/used RedHat after Raster left). The panel was awful, the fonts were awful. Themeing (once they moved to gdkpixbuf rather than imlib) was awful. It didn't even have Human Interface Guidelines until Eugenia Loli-Queru basically forced her opinion on the devs.

Sun Microsystems had to dedicate months of programming and useability testing to get the UI to a point that everyone didn't hate it anymore.

Once Miguel gave up the reins, others took GNOME where it is today. This is similar to Lennart Poettering, wherein NetworkManager and PulseAudio became much better/more stable/useable when he left.

Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by digi_owl on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @04:57PM (#12904310)
> Eugenia Loli-Queru

A name i have not thought about in a long long time, and why i stopped reading OSNews...

Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by shermanyo on Thursday November 10, 2016 @03:41AM (#12918724)
oh god, old network manager was my breaking point.

looking back, it was the first time I _really_ understood that sitting down and learning to manage the relevant config files manually was going to be easier than dealing with a GUI app. hell, I learned for both redhat _and_ debian based distros.

I don't know if I would have gone down the path I have if it wasn't for that. that's insane...

Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by bobajeff on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @11:16AM (#12901411)
Yes, DirectX is still looks closed to me, along with the NT Kernel and even EdgeHTML.
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by Ant5do on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @12:31PM (#12902175)
Isn't it clear from the article, like everyone else pointed out, that things going forward in Icaza's org are open? As in cloud and developer tools?

You're talking about older things.

Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by bobajeff on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @01:17PM (#12902572)
Sorry, I just read the title and commented.
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by gigatexal on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @12:32PM (#12902178)
Edge core got open sourced they even made a fork of nodejs that used it
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by ahochhaus on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @01:19PM (#12902590)
MS open sourced ChakraCore (the core of the Chakra JavaScript engine). EdgeHTML is still closed to the best of my knowledge.
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by bobajeff on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @01:18PM (#12902581)
I think you're confusing EdgeHTML with ChakraCore.
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by gigatexal on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @02:23PM (#12903139)
Yup I did. But I meant chakra. Thanks for clearing that up
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by zgramana on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @11:39AM (#12901636)
Miguel is clearly referring to Microsoft developer tools, since he's in the developer tools org.
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by maxxxxx on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @12:32PM (#12902186)
Then they should open source Visual Studio and TFS and make them free. Dealing with those licenses is a major PITA.
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by runjake on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @01:01PM (#12902445)
Visual Studio basically is free [1].

I imagine we'll see Visual Studio open sourced sooner rather than later, going off the hint-dropping from MSFT engineers. I assume they have some code cleanup, and intellectual property issues to deal with first.

1. https://www.visualstudio.com/vs/community/

Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by maxxxxx on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @02:39PM (#12903286)
It's not free for companies from a certain size on. I am not even talking about the money but just the effort of tracking licenses.
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by adrianlmm on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @11:01AM (#12901269)
Just waith and see.
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by sigzero on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @11:04AM (#12901300)
“There was no story at Microsoft for other platforms back in the day. But the world is full of heterogeneous connections now and I think Scott Guthrie [now Microsoft’s lead on Azure cloud platform] helped drive a lot of the openness. Microsoft is now open by default and you actually have to make a case on a team/peer review level if you feel something needs to be closed,” said de Icaza."

So it seems "new" projects not older ones are "open by default" with a caveat. That's still a lot better than they used to be.

Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by thr0waway1239 on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @03:24PM (#12903607)
I have started thinking that those who now work at Microsoft are blind to its flaws by default.

The classic example being Windows 10 - anyone who is actually not blind to the fiasco of the automatic upgrades/issues around further updates [1] notices that there is a certain brutality in the way the whole thing was carried out. After installing the unwanted Windows 10 OS on probably hundreds of millions of perfectly fine Windows 7 machines, they claimed that some 300+ million computers were now running on Windows 10. [2] My guess is, less than half of those were actually desired by the end users. And a few more iterations of these botched auto-updates, and "happy Windows 10 user" is going to become an oxymoron.

This episode went so much against the spirit of open source that these claims seem a little comical. It is probably true that MS had to make these choices to maximize shareholder profit, but lets just take it down a notch on the supposed openness.

To those who wish to still make this 'open by default' claim, I welcome MS to open source Windows 7 and Windows XP and see if they can sustain the same kind of growth after that point [3]

[1] https://hn.algolia.com/?query=windows%2010%20update&sort=byP...

[2] http://www.windowscentral.com/microsoft-300-million-active-d...

[3] http://www.computerworld.com/article/3054528/microsoft-windo...

Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by ocdtrekkie on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @04:39PM (#12904189)
From what I've seen, Microsoft employees have a keen understanding of both the issues with Microsoft as well as it's past. If you are seeing complete radio silence on something, like we see with both telemetry and automatic updates, that's when you know there's a corporate policy that's been laid down that nobody's going to risk their job to speak out against. You can see this sort of thing with a lot of companies, not just Microsoft.
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by SomeHacker44 on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @12:06PM (#12901924)
Somewhat OT: With the ad interstitial, and now an auto-play video with audio ad on the main article, and the article split into three pages... I just can't bring myself to read Forbes content online anymore. Even if I'm interested in what de Icaza has to say.
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by megous on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @04:06PM (#12903943)
Forbes looks like quote of the day website that's progressively enhanced to a online newspaper if you care about enabling JavaScript.

Progressive enhancement was nice while it lasted.

Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by whoopdedo on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @12:52PM (#12902374)
The exFAT patent is royalty-free now?
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by anonbanker on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @04:48PM (#12904255)
I wonder what kind of sit-down peer review was done to keep it closed?
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by m-p-3 on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @01:14PM (#12902551)
And thus a new cycle of Embrace, Extend and Extinguish is happening.
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by makecheck on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @11:26AM (#12901521)
Well, nothing like having to “log in” to a product to make it feel “open”, or have it randomly prioritize verifying its own license for 60 seconds over letting you launch and begin your work.
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by st3v3r on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @12:33PM (#12902196)
Cool. Where's the Windows and Office source? I've got some changes I'd like to contribute.
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by executesorder66 on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @11:08AM (#12901348)
They don't even have a closed source MS Office for Linux.
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by simonh on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @11:14AM (#12901392)
It's hard to see how a port to Linux would ever make back the cost of porting it in the first place.
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by notatoad on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @12:32PM (#12902189)
or how that really has any impact on the general "openness" of microsoft.
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by st3v3r on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @12:36PM (#12902221)
Well, if the company really is "open by default", they can open the source for Office, and the community can aid in the port.
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by cryptarch on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @12:59PM (#12902428)
And they could open-source all future Windows updates!

That actually sounds kinda fun, building your own Windows patches :')

Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by msh on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @01:06PM (#12902493)
Yes they do, you can get it on the google play store. Maybe not your preferred flavor of Linux, but Linux none the less.
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by adrianlmm on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @11:14AM (#12901402)
Not even Google is investing in Desktop Linux, where is that official Google Drive client?
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by benologist on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @12:27PM (#12902127)
Google builds two of the perhaps most popular desktop linux's ... Android and Chrome OS.
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by adrianlmm on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @01:09PM (#12902515)
And MS has the Linux Subsystem in Windows to run Ubuntu Linux binaries and is open source, so?
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by pritambaral on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @02:48PM (#12903367)
The Linux Subsystem in Windows is NOT open source. So what if they can run Ubuntu? So can VirtualBox!

And yes, I know the difference between virtualization and syscall emulation.

Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by adrianlmm on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @03:08PM (#12903500)
You are right, is not open source (yet), but you still can tun Linux binaries.
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by pritambaral on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @04:36PM (#12904152)
> (yet)

You seem hopeful of a thing few people are hopeful of.

> you still can tun[sic] Linux binaries

That does not make a platform open.

Also note that you can't run all Linux binaries. In this respect, my original comparison with VirtualBox gets even better, since with VirtualBox I can run whatever edition of Linux I want, with graphics and total, absolute control, and a faster filesystem.

Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by FT_intern on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @11:37AM (#12901620)
Google's main apps are web based and for the most part OS independent
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by ocdtrekkie on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @11:45AM (#12901710)
File sync is a behavior best done with a client app, as you can see with Drive apps for every other platform.
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by pera on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @11:26AM (#12901516)
Chrome works pretty well on Linux.
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by adrianlmm on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @11:30AM (#12901560)
So is Visual Studio Code, your point is?
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by datatapes on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @11:44AM (#12901691)
As FT_intern said, most if not all of google's services can be found on the web, through chrome or otherwise.

VS Code is nice but not a full gateway into all of MS's stuff/services.

To OP's point, office online is free without a 365 subscription.

Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by pera on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @03:19PM (#12903571)
The parent post was edited.
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by ergo14 on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @01:48PM (#12902853)
Did MS stop suing linux users already?
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by leandrod on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @07:07PM (#12905120)
De Icaza is now ‘gullible by default’, says Universe.
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by snippet22 on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @11:10AM (#12901362)
Who wants to use Windows? So now they are just repackaging open free software like npm and angular 2... Oh great... Again who wants to use Windows? Azure you can't even have it use anything that touches other servers without costing you. I think their focus on their base is what is hurting them. Sure they gained a little with azure but as tech people know, thatll be out if date if not already. Cause why learn how is all connected right?
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by moron4hire on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @11:13AM (#12901390)
I want to use Windows. No other OS has put the time and effort into ensuring stable, cutting edge support for the 3D graphics systems I need for my work.

Windows is still 90% of the PC market. If only 10% of those users are developers, that means there are more Windows developers than all macOS users combined. There are a lot of us out here, and I think we're starting to get fed up with being treated like we don't exist, just because of the shame that gets lumped on us from a small cohort of other developers.

Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by pmontra on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @11:52AM (#12901780)
> If only 10% of those users are developers

They are not. That would mean that more than 10% of the people sitting on chairs in companies are doing software development. That would fail to take into account jobs that don't have a chair, every PC outside an office and even non technical jobs in sw development companies.

Let's check some facts.

http://www.bls.gov/ooh/computer-and-information-technology/s...

Number of jobs: 1,114,000

http://data.bls.gov/timeseries/CES0000000001

All employees, end of 2014: 140,402,000

It's less than 1%, still much more than I would bet on. However I think that this figure is lower globally and Windows is sold globally. Hence, much less than 1% of PC users are software developers (Windows, Mac, Linux, anything) and having Windows the larger share its stats are close to the global figure.

Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by WayneBro on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @12:32PM (#12902180)
I think his primary point was that there are more developers on Windows than on any other OS.

Did you find any data relevant to that point?

I tend to think that it's true. There are more developers on Windows. Way more.

Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by AnonymousPlanet on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @12:44PM (#12902299)
There are the regular surveys from Stack Exchange http://stackoverflow.com/research/developer-survey-2016#tech... that has OS X, Windows, and Linux pretty close together, with OS X coming on top.
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by pmontra on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @12:52PM (#12902368)
All versions of Windows together are 22.5+20.8+8.4+0.4+0.1 = 52.2 %

OSX has 26.2, Linux 21.7.

They sum to 100.1. There should be some inconsistent rounding somewhere.

If the figures are representative of reality it's true that Windows is less popular among developers than it is among the general public.

Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by AnonymousPlanet on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @01:17PM (#12902578)
Ah, I was on mobile and it made a very different impression there for some reason. Thanks for pointing it out.
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by marcosdumay on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @01:35PM (#12902736)
It's probably not true.

If 1% of the desktop users are developers, that's the same as 50% of the Linux users, and a really big share of the Linux users are developers (really, I expected it to be more than 50% what, clearly isn't true). That's also circa 12% of the Mac users, and I bet a biggest share of them are developers than the Windows ones.

Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by emodendroket on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @01:55PM (#12902901)
> That's also circa 12% of the Mac users, and I bet a biggest share of them are developers than the Windows ones.

That seems unlikely.

The fact that there are a number of programs without real non-Windows equivalents (games, emulators, various commercial packages) probably does suggest a lot of people doing Windows development.

Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by marcosdumay on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @05:00PM (#12904335)
It means that WayneBro conclusion up there is nonsense. You can't claim there are so few users of other OSes that it's impossible that most developers are on them.

It does certainly not mean that there are no Windows developer. That would just be repeating the same flawed argument, but twisted on the direction where it's the most flawed.

Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by WayneBro on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @05:14PM (#12904443)
Meh. That stack overflow survey is definitely flawed. My conclusion is based on the fact that most businesses run Windows and as a consultant, I visit many many many enterprise shops. None of them are running Macs or Linux.

The people here on HN live in a bubble.

Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by pmontra on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @07:00PM (#12905095)
I'm probably in another country on another continent (Italy) but web development, both back end and front end, is a Mac business here. There are some Linux laptops (me too), many Linux VMs on Macs, very few Windows. But we're developing for Linux servers so why should we be using Windows? Every time I get to work junior devs out of university with Windows laptops I advise them to install a Linux VM or be prepared to suffer and google alone how to fix things there.

People are using Macs because it gives them a preconfigured and stable Linux like environment, almost 100% compatible with the server. Windows tend to have different toolings and different quirks. It doubles the effort. In my experience it's OK if you're using Java, which mostly hides the OS and it's obviously a must if you go with .NET. Basically only large companies use those two technologies, and not all of them. Everybody else is on scripting languages, JS, PHP, Python, Ruby. Btw, Java is almost always deployed to Linux too.

So, it could be a bubble but it's a large one.

Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by Spivak on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @11:32AM (#12901577)
> If only 10% of those users are developers

Your overall point stands on its own but are you really trying to argue that 1 in 10 PCs are software development workstations?

Also, you should not expect that having a 90% market share overall will translate into 90% market share among any particular subset of users.

Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by moron4hire on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @12:28PM (#12902139)
No, I'm not. My point is to only draw an illustration of just how small the overall marketshare for "non-Windows PC users" actually is. I go out to meetups all the time and everyone wants to act like I'm some sort of weird outlier because I'm the only person with a Windows machine in the room.
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by simonh on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @11:21AM (#12901469)
This is a fair point actually. I switched to the Mac a decade ago, but Mac hardware free-rides off the PC hardware market all the time. If we're honest, so does Linux. If Microsoft hadn't supported and grown the PC hardware industry for decades the whole desktop ecosystem would be a lot poorer.

Personally I'm very happy with the hardware options available to me on the Mac, but there's a whole world of hardware options over there in PC land I'll never take advantage of. Conversely Linux graphics card driver support is still woeful, but that's really not Microsoft's problem and if Linux didn't have the PC platform to run on it's hardware costs would be much higher. What would be the alternative, Sun-style workstations? It's not that Microsoft did this on purpose, but it's still a fact.

Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by pmontra on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @11:43AM (#12901681)
With no MicroSoft the PC industry would be as fragmented as it was in the 80s, with many operating systems and single vendor hardware/sw platforms running on different chipsets. We are down to Windows, MacOS, Linux, Android and iOS now, on either ARM or x86. Everything else is very minor.

However network effects would have given to another company the position that MicroSoft enjoyed for some 30 years. It could have been a slower growth or a faster downfall, but somebody would have been there. Not Apple because they are interested only in selling their own hardware. Probably some company out of nowhere, not necessarily on a x86 chip. Then everybody would have started building drivers for the OS of that company and Linux and MacOS would be running on the preferred chip of that OS.

Maybe in an alternate reality Visicalc built their own OS to run their spreasheet on a large screen (by the time standards) 8086 computer and replace MSDOS and Microsoft as the OS and sw company of choice. We'd be talking about VisiOffice and Vindows now :-)

Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by rbanffy on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @12:25PM (#12902111)
> with many operating systems and single vendor hardware/sw platforms running on different chipsets.

We could have gone the slightly-less-compatible route with CP/M-86. Network effects would make the industry gravitate towards a standard platform, but not necessarily a company.

I remember tons of GUI software running on proprietary Unixes on vastly different architectures, all written aiming POSIX compatibility and an X graphics environment.

Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by pmontra on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @01:00PM (#12902440)
I remember them, but they cost a little fortune (both hw and sw). They were still popular in the 90s but the first cheap and good enough alternative started to make a real dent into their professional market. It was Windows 3.1 and 80486 in 1992. But don't forget Autocad in the 80s.

Yes, CP/M-86 could have played to role of MSDOS but people really needed to buy a box with a floppy disk to install from or a preinstalled OS on their new PC. MS did that right.

Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by rbanffy on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @02:18PM (#12903098)
A 386 was a reasonable Unix host at the time. I first experienced Unix on a 68020 box attached to dozens of terminals. There were a couple Unix like OSs that were relatively inexpensive but I don't remember any that had a GUI.

All that is not very relevant. Had Microsoft never existed, it'd have been an ecosystem too different to make any valid prediction. We'll have to eventually restore the universe and run a different path to see.

Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by pjmlp on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @01:04PM (#12902478)
That "POSIX compatibility" was quite interesting in the late 90's.

Just like it happens with any standard, we ended up with lots of #ifdef, because many APIs might had the same name, but not the same semantics.

And like in UNIX like OSes, all the cool goodies weren't in the POSIX APIs anyway.

It is quite sad that despite some of the cool GUIs like on NeXT and Sun OpenWindows, the best that they could settle on as a standard was Motif.

Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by anonbanker on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @05:05PM (#12904372)
> Maybe in an alternate reality Visicalc built their own OS to run their spreasheet on a large screen

Well, we did have Richard M. Stallman, Emacs author, not only create an OS (GNU), but also extend Emacs to the point that it might as well be an OS. More pointedly, Miguel De Icaza created Gnumeric (a fantastic Excel clone) before he started the GNU Network Object Model Environment (GNOME).

Corel attempted something similar to what you were saying, as well; Their Wordperfect/Office/Draw empire was leveraged against Microsoft's Embrace/Extend/Extinguish in order to promote their (debian-based) linux distribution.

Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by anonbanker on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @04:56PM (#12904301)
Unless you're using Wayland on NVidia chipsets, graphics driver support is pretty damn good nowadays. I was able to install NVidia and ATI proprietary drivers during my graphical linux install of Calculate (Gentoo) linux. I'd be shocked if Ubuntu or Fedora were somehow more obtuse than this.

As for free drivers, the only one lagging behind is Nouveau for Nvidia users. AMD's free/open driver has made some serious performance improvements in the past few months, and Intel's driver (or just plain modesetting) has performance parity with their windows driver.

I remember 2008, and fighting with AMD/ATI drivers, and occasional reboots on my NVidia systems that led to X not working anymore. I've had exactly one instance of that in the past 4 years (under Arch). Can we stop spreading 2008-era misinformation in 2016?

Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by cryptarch on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @01:01PM (#12902453)
Isn't it mostly that no other OS has graphics drivers that are put as much time in by graphics card makers?

Because Microsoft has the largest market share and porting drivers from Windows to Unix systems is basically a full rewrite, which doesn't happen?

Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by moron4hire on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @01:58PM (#12902926)
No, it's also that OpenGL had long been a joke compared to Direct3D.
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by cryptarch on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @06:08AM (#12909211)
What do you mean by "a joke"?

My personal experience with OpenGL is that all Valve games run faster on it than on DirectX (both on Windows, but I heard Linux + OpenGL also has better perf than Windows + DirectX), but that's about the extent of it.

Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by anonbanker on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @04:50PM (#12904264)
> ensuring stable, cutting edge support for the 3D graphics systems I need for my work.

So how is Vulkan support on Windows these days?