News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by aikah on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @10:59AM (#12901250)
My Windows license doesn't feel "Open by Default", nor SQL Server license audits ... I like the guy, he created Mono, Xamarin, Gtk and co. But only a tiny subset of MS products like the .NET ecosystem are open.
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by wmccullough on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @11:26AM (#12901518)
Obviously they are talking about projects going forward. The article makes that pretty clear.

"Microsoft is now open by default and you actually have to make a case on a team/peer review level if you feel something needs to be closed,” said de Icaza."

Should they stay guilty forever for the things done in the previous regime?

Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by sametmax on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @01:02PM (#12902461)
First, you have to give very strong evidences that they are not "like the previous regime", or that there is a "previous" at all. All I see right now is PR and strategic moves (let's do what google did, even a bit late).

Secondly, given the track record, it is fair that it will take a long time before their past is forgiven. At least the same number of years of doubt that they spent misbehaving. And again that supposes they are not doing it right now. Like patent trolling, or moving software you could buy to a rent-only model, or put spywares in their new OS.

I strongly believe MS is not getting better, just getting better at communicating. They are not in a monopoly anymore and they can't get away with a "linux is cancer" like they used to do.

The only thing that bother me is that the Gates are getting away with it. They detached them self from MS, and now make heavy communication on their charity, so everybody seems to think they are saints. People have very short memory.

Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by michaelmrose on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @01:29PM (#12902678)
With decades of bad behavior I don't understand why they would ever be trusted. Its not like Gates is dead and buried and there certainly is continuity between the old regime and new.
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by pm90 on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @01:37PM (#12902756)
I don't think that's a fair assessment; I'm going to judge them on their present actions rather than their past behavior, when the market, leadership etc. were all different. They seem to be trying to adapt to the new market reality where open source and dev friendly tools/software creates goodwill and promotes adoption.
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by irq-1 on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @12:02PM (#12901886)
Will the next versions of Microsofts closed/licensed software be open? Will someone have to make a case that they need to remain closed? Will they release new products that are closed/licensed?
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by cryptarch on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @12:57PM (#12902416)
I assume they'll make all Windows updates open-source from now on then?
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by nogbit on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @12:16PM (#12902021)
Yes, because their OS is now evergreen, there will never be another "Windows X" and it will be forever closed. If/when they make the OS open (and ideally their other products as well) only then can his statement be taken seriously.
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by Aldo_MX on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @11:02AM (#12901279)
My Windows 10 Telemetry settings really look "open by default"...
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by baldfat on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @01:55PM (#12902900)
"Microsoft is now open by default and you actually have to make a case on a team/peer review level if you feel something needs to be closed,” said de Icaza."

The Microsoft bias is to always bash them but give a pass to Apple. I think Microsoft has been the good guy for a bit but they still get hate mainly due to Steve Balmer.

Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by digi_owl on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @12:57PM (#12902410)
Actually he founded Gnome, GTK already existed (the G coming from GIMP).

Frankly the guy seems very similar to Poettering. Stuff he creates, for the most part, only really becomes usable once the leaves the project.

Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by deckard1 on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @03:17PM (#12903554)
No idea why you're getting downvotes. You're completely right.

I was there when GNOME started. Was working heavily with GTK+ and GIMP at the time. Most of GNOME was tossed together haphazardly in a mad dash to catch up with KDE. There were astroturfing campaigns against KDE/Qt, organized on the GIMP IRC servers. The hate on Slashdot towards KDE was crazy, and much of it coming directly from GNOME camp. GNOME 1.x was a total shitshow. The code was horrid, and nothing was stable at all. Luckily their poor standards of code quality never hurt GTK+ much, as the GIMP guys still knew what the hell they were doing.

Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by anonbanker on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @04:42PM (#12904211)
Remember that KDE/Qt were not licensed under anything GPL-compatible at the time, hence the reason GNOME was started in the first place.

KDE was indeed much better. GNOME 1.x was awful. I and others like me still used GNOME 1.x, because I wanted a free desktop environment.

You weren't the only one on #gimp; don't pretend GIMP had a much better class of developers. Remember GEGL used to refer to hairy parts of the codebase (Genetically-Engineered Goat, Large) that people were afraid of touching.

Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by anonbanker on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @04:39PM (#12904187)
your downvotes are alarming.

Miguel left GNOME before 2.0 shipped, and started working on Mono full-time. If you've ever used GNOME 1.0, it was barely more than a set of ORB-based applications you stacked on top of Enlightenment DR 0.15 (or Sawmill/Sawfish if you weren't cool/used RedHat after Raster left). The panel was awful, the fonts were awful. Themeing (once they moved to gdkpixbuf rather than imlib) was awful. It didn't even have Human Interface Guidelines until Eugenia Loli-Queru basically forced her opinion on the devs.

Sun Microsystems had to dedicate months of programming and useability testing to get the UI to a point that everyone didn't hate it anymore.

Once Miguel gave up the reins, others took GNOME where it is today. This is similar to Lennart Poettering, wherein NetworkManager and PulseAudio became much better/more stable/useable when he left.

Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by digi_owl on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @04:57PM (#12904310)
> Eugenia Loli-Queru

A name i have not thought about in a long long time, and why i stopped reading OSNews...

Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by shermanyo on Thursday November 10, 2016 @03:41AM (#12918724)
oh god, old network manager was my breaking point.

looking back, it was the first time I _really_ understood that sitting down and learning to manage the relevant config files manually was going to be easier than dealing with a GUI app. hell, I learned for both redhat _and_ debian based distros.

I don't know if I would have gone down the path I have if it wasn't for that. that's insane...

Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by bobajeff on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @11:16AM (#12901411)
Yes, DirectX is still looks closed to me, along with the NT Kernel and even EdgeHTML.
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by Ant5do on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @12:31PM (#12902175)
Isn't it clear from the article, like everyone else pointed out, that things going forward in Icaza's org are open? As in cloud and developer tools?

You're talking about older things.

Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by bobajeff on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @01:17PM (#12902572)
Sorry, I just read the title and commented.
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by gigatexal on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @12:32PM (#12902178)
Edge core got open sourced they even made a fork of nodejs that used it
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by ahochhaus on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @01:19PM (#12902590)
MS open sourced ChakraCore (the core of the Chakra JavaScript engine). EdgeHTML is still closed to the best of my knowledge.
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by bobajeff on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @01:18PM (#12902581)
I think you're confusing EdgeHTML with ChakraCore.
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by gigatexal on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @02:23PM (#12903139)
Yup I did. But I meant chakra. Thanks for clearing that up
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by zgramana on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @11:39AM (#12901636)
Miguel is clearly referring to Microsoft developer tools, since he's in the developer tools org.
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by maxxxxx on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @12:32PM (#12902186)
Then they should open source Visual Studio and TFS and make them free. Dealing with those licenses is a major PITA.
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by runjake on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @01:01PM (#12902445)
Visual Studio basically is free [1].

I imagine we'll see Visual Studio open sourced sooner rather than later, going off the hint-dropping from MSFT engineers. I assume they have some code cleanup, and intellectual property issues to deal with first.

1. https://www.visualstudio.com/vs/community/

Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by maxxxxx on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @02:39PM (#12903286)
It's not free for companies from a certain size on. I am not even talking about the money but just the effort of tracking licenses.
Re:Microsoft Is Now 'Open by Default', Says Xamarin Founder ... by adrianlmm on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @11:01AM (#12901269)
Just waith and see.