Re:Postmates Secures $141M in a ‘Super, Super Difficult’ Fun...
by gumby on Tuesday November 01, 2016 @01:00AM
(#12843532)
Really hard to see the defensible "moat" in the business models of these delivery companies. As the article says, Uber uses its balance sheet as its weapon, but the flip side of that is it will be hard for any new investor to get much of a return in any future round -- its hard to see its defence against a disrupting competitor. Even Lyft, which looks weaker, easily scoops up the same drivers as Uber.
All of which means it's not clear if this is a difficult fundraising market or not. It certainly is for these undifferentiated delivery companies, but for tech startups? Not seeing it yet.
Re:Postmates Secures $141M in a ‘Super, Super Difficult’ Fun...
by lgieron on Tuesday November 01, 2016 @05:36AM
(#12844367)
> Really hard to see the defensible "moat" in the business models of these delivery companies.
Couldn't the same be said about a lot of the "unicorns"? For example Dropbox or AirB'n'B don't have significant network effects and anyone with some cash can copy their software and directly compete with them (the same way Lyft is competing with Uber). The likes of Facebook and Twitter are an exception.
Re:Postmates Secures $141M in a ‘Super, Super Difficult’ Fun...
by pjc50 on Tuesday November 01, 2016 @06:45AM
(#12844581)
Dropbox has a mild network effect, as soon as people use it to share files with their friends and colleagues. Once Dropbox gets established inside a business (often because it's easier to use than internal IT), they're probably quite secure.
Re:Postmates Secures $141M in a ‘Super, Super Difficult’ Fun...
by gumby on Tuesday November 01, 2016 @11:40AM
(#12846733)
I don't see it, since people could list themselves on competing listing sites just as the same drivers list themselves on both Uber and Lyft.
Then again you could say the same for eBay, yet Amazon couldn't get a competitor off the ground. One small moat (eBay has vs Airbnb model) is that you can automate the sale on eBay (so you'd have a hard time listing the same item on two sites -- you might sell it twice) while Airbnb still has manual intervention.
Re:Postmates Secures $141M in a ‘Super, Super Difficult’ Fun...
by pfarnsworth on Tuesday November 01, 2016 @02:32AM
(#12843834)
The difference is that all these food delivery companies need to acquire both customers and drivers. Uber already has the drivers and the infrastructure for delivery. That makes it much easier for Uber to compete against companies like Postmates. I honestly don't think Postmates, Caviar, et al. have much of a chance over the long haul.
Re:Postmates Secures $141M in a ‘Super, Super Difficult’ Fun...
by gumby on Tuesday November 01, 2016 @05:24AM
(#12844322)
Sorry, I didn't mean to imply Uber as a competitor to Postmates-etc/DoorDash-etc/dry-cleaning-delivery etc. I just meant Uber as also being in a class which has only moderate barriers to entry. I agree with you that these delivery companies have little competitive advantage or particularly good business models.
I don't really see what advantage Uber has over Lyft, Didi etc except the balance sheet and using it in the hope of doing the largest, fastest land grab possible. To draw a tenuous analogy, it's hard to say that the 17th-19th century European land grabs worked out that well in the long term.
Re:Postmates Secures $141M in a ‘Super, Super Difficult’ Fun...
by x0x0 on Tuesday November 01, 2016 @02:06AM
(#12843760)
I think the thing to watch for Uber et al is Austin. If a good local alternative is created that is content to make $100m/year with no real ambitions of growing, then they will have to continue to fight city by city.
Re:Postmates Secures $141M in a ‘Super, Super Difficult’ Fun...
by dopamean on Tuesday November 01, 2016 @09:11AM
(#12845363)
I live in Austin and I'd be shocked if all the new ride share companies (Fare, Fasten, GetMe, RideShare Austin, etc) did 100mm a year in revenue combined. I think RideShare Austin has the best chance of sticking around here. They're set up to be a non-profit. So their intent is to follow local regulations carefully and stick around for the long haul. We'll see what happens.
That's a $212m run rate; with moderate growth a $350m+ run rate seems entirely reasonable. sf is about the size of Austin. If Uber keeps 25%, that's an $87.5m business. Some extra growth on top of that (run a local delivery service; do some transit deals for elderly/kids/handicapped; etc) and you've built yourself a nice $100m business.
Re:Postmates Secures $141M in a ‘Super, Super Difficult’ Fun...
by vosper on Tuesday November 01, 2016 @03:59AM
(#12844074)
I was in Austin just after Uber and Lyft had left. There was a company called Fasten which had promo codes on seemingly every lamppost in the city. It worked just like Uber, and I believe it pays the drivers better. I don't know if they're still around and still have the market to themselves, but if they do I imagine they could become entrenched there.
Re:Postmates Secures $141M in a ‘Super, Super Difficult’ Fun...
by qwrusz on Tuesday November 01, 2016 @02:21AM
(#12843806)
I agree, very bizarre way to claim profitable.
As for the other comments mentioning EBITDA. The Tax in EBITDA is income tax.
You cannot be taxed out of being profitable.
The tax rate is not >100% so if you are profitable before taxes you are profitable after taxes. Just less so.
I have no idea what postmates means here by "profitable, w/o tax-related expenses". Maybe something like sales tax they collected that must be remitted? (that's not technically an expense either but they don't seem to know what they are doing or saying at the moment).
Re:Postmates Secures $141M in a ‘Super, Super Difficult’ Fun...
by lathiat on Tuesday November 01, 2016 @04:00AM
(#12844080)
It's not clear to me which side of EBITDA we're arguing on, but as a generalized statement capital expenses for which you cannot claim a full immediate deduction could put you in debt -- the full tax claim is deferred over the life of the asset. You could earn $10,000 of revenue -- spend $10,000 on a server and then still owe some 20-30% income tax because you cannot claim the full $10,000 deduction in that first year. For my server example that may be 3-4 years, some plant and equipment can be much longer.
This is also based on Australian tax, I assume it's similar elsewhere but don't know the intricacies.
Re:Postmates Secures $141M in a ‘Super, Super Difficult’ Fun...
by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday November 01, 2016 @03:11AM
(#12843943)
> The tax rate is not >100%
Lol welcome to New York. Even ignoring the cost of preparing reams and reams of paperwork, a flat $4 tax on, say, bagels could very well flip margins negative.
Re:Postmates Secures $141M in a ‘Super, Super Difficult’ Fun...
by jdavis703 on Tuesday November 01, 2016 @04:40AM
(#12844190)
There can't really be a $4 bagel tax. And if there were wouldn't shops just pass the cost on to consumers (similar to the "Obamacare surcharge" many restaurants seem to be tacking onto bills currently)?
Re:Postmates Secures $141M in a ‘Super, Super Difficult’ Fun...
by qwrusz on Tuesday November 01, 2016 @09:32AM
(#12845534)
I live in NY. I think if a business is inside the profitability margin of error where a bagel tax or bureaucracy cost could very well flip it upside down then it's not profitable even if it is. These are the types of companies that will blame "bad weather" as the reason for a quarterly loss.
If conditions need to be perfect and regulations friendly and nothing bad can happen/everything must go according to plan for a company to be profitable, it's not profitable.
Re:Postmates Secures $141M in a ‘Super, Super Difficult’ Fun...
by digikata on Tuesday November 01, 2016 @01:37AM
(#12843653)
I think that it's the articles colloquial expansion of EBIT. EBIT (Earnings Before Interest & Taxes) is a somewhat common financial metric. I think it is useful to look at if you have a concern that a business has tax/interest portions of their balance sheet that might be skewing the other measures of profitability.
Re:Postmates Secures $141M in a ‘Super, Super Difficult’ Fun...
by orthoganol on Tuesday November 01, 2016 @04:51AM
(#12844223)
I can't conceive of mainstream success for Postmates outside of bubbles like SF and NYC - because it's just too expensive: Delivery fee (with very frequent 'surge pricing'), service fee, and prompts for tip. I've never placed an order under $30 for a meal just for me.
And that's fine if you make 6 figures and don't cook very often, why not be a regular Postmates person, but I just don't see how that works outside of certain neighborhoods in certain cities.
Re:Postmates Secures $141M in a ‘Super, Super Difficult’ Fun...
by madeofpalk on Tuesday November 01, 2016 @05:36AM
(#12844370)
Loads of people use alternatives here in Sydney and Melbourne (including Uber Eats). Doesn't hurt that Uber Eats doesn't charge a delivery fee and has no minimum (for now).
Not really sure if we count as 'the bubble', but people have shifted from calling restaurants (or Dominos) directly to using these services to 'upscale' and discover more restaurants.
Re:Postmates Secures $141M in a ‘Super, Super Difficult’ Fun...
by product50 on Tuesday November 01, 2016 @06:39AM
(#12844567)
Who are these people who have shifted? Are you living in a bubble yourself? I certainly haven't seen this shift happening among my group of friends.
I feel this is more of a he said she said kind of argument. Would love to see some data here (in terms of whether these deliveries are net additions vs. replacements of existing chains that deliver) but unfortunately, Postmates hasn't published anything yet.
Re:Postmates Secures $141M in a ‘Super, Super Difficult’ Fun...
by sargun on Tuesday November 01, 2016 @03:54AM
(#12844062)
I find Postmates competing primarily on food delivery quite odd. When I originally started using Postmates, it was for pretty much for everything but food. When I ordered food from it, it was for the likes of food trucks, where I just needed to dispatch a courier and make a free form order. Unfortunately, Postmates discontinued support for these features.
The kinds of things I ordered before the modernization of Postmates were USB-to-Ethernet adapters, Macs, soldering irons, and more. These were typically high priced goods that I needed in a short period of time to keep up some service.
Re:Postmates Secures $141M in a ‘Super, Super Difficult’ Fun...
by perryh2 on Tuesday November 01, 2016 @04:10AM
(#12844113)
My team of ~5 people orders from Postmates every weekday for lunch and our order is missing items about a third of the time. It's not uncommon for one of us to reorder via Caviar's Fastbite service, where the food is on-hand and delivered within 5 mins in SoMa. When we tried Caviar's non-Fastbite service, we noticed the same problem with missing items. Does this happen to anyone else? We've been having this problem for months and I'd think that one of these companies have got it figured out by now.
Re:Postmates Secures $141M in a ‘Super, Super Difficult’ Fun...
by Ntrails on Tuesday November 01, 2016 @05:34AM
(#12844359)
I find it bizarre that you're consistently using a service which is bad 33% of the time. I feel like I'd have given up after a couple of weeks - because honestly convenience is what you're paying for and only getting some of what you order is the opposite of convenient.
Re:Postmates Secures $141M in a ‘Super, Super Difficult’ Fun...
by Ntrails on Wednesday November 02, 2016 @06:43AM
(#12853481)
If it's me I'm annoyed and hungry, if it's someone else I'm annoyed and guilty.
1/3 of the time lunch is wrong and there is absolutely no excuse for it. If you went to a restaurant and they could only get your food served correctly a third of the time you'd stop going back pretty fast I reckon
Re:Postmates Secures $141M in a ‘Super, Super Difficult’ Fun...
by jdavis703 on Tuesday November 01, 2016 @04:35AM
(#12844176)
Never had missing items via Caviar. I order dinner about once a week from them, the only mistake I've had was a restaurant confusing pepperoncinis for pepperonis (I'm vegetarian so that's kind of a big deal to me), which I can totally see happening in a busy kitchen by mistake.
Re:Postmates Secures $141M in a ‘Super, Super Difficult’ Fun...
by danm07 on Tuesday November 01, 2016 @02:37AM
(#12843854)
It's going to be interesting to see where they allocate the money. They're in a very tough market: competing with Uber for drivers and Amazon for drone deliveries. Literally, the most inauspicious position to be in, second to competing with Google or Elon Musk.
It's funny that selling the company was their priority, and that they had to hire an investment bank to look for funders.
Re:Postmates Secures $141M in a ‘Super, Super Difficult’ Fun...
by scapecast on Tuesday November 01, 2016 @10:51AM
(#12846084)
It's not uncommon for start-ups at the more mature stage to work with an investment bank to pull together a round of financing (let's say post Series B), particularly when you get into the triple-$M range. For example, Box used JP Morgan in their later rounds.
Bankers have a much wider network of potential investors than founders, and they can also run the process much more efficiently. Raising $141M is different from raising $14.1M, it gets way more complex. And at that amount / valuation, what can be a financing can quickly turn into an acquisition, think what happened to Cruise Automation.
Frequently the bankers do a principal investment in the same round they are raising for the company, to show that they have skin in the game, but also to position themselves for a potential IPO or M&A transaction (which is the lucrative part, you get 2-3% of the total consideration).
Qatalyst is well known in the Valley, another firm is Allen & Co. Both companies do principal investments, and so do the bulge bracket firms like GS, JPM and MS. GS put money into Uber.
So it's probably not "had to hire" but "decided to hire", and a perfectly common practice.
Re:Postmates Secures $141M in a ‘Super, Super Difficult’ Fun...
by madeofpalk on Tuesday November 01, 2016 @05:22AM
(#12844315)
Uber Eats launched 4 months ago here in Sydney with free delivery and no minimum order "for a limited time" and it's been amazing - I immediately stopped using competitors like Foodora/Suppertime, Deliveroo, Delivery Hero, Eat Now and Menulog.
I guess this is exactly what he means when he says Uber is "using their balance sheet as a weapon".
Re:Postmates Secures $141M in a ‘Super, Super Difficult’ Fun...
by rkho on Tuesday November 01, 2016 @03:38AM
(#12844025)
In SF, UberEATS has a rolling $5 off per delivery for the month of November. Last I checked, deliveries were a flat $5 so this counteracts it. It's been that way for ~2/3 weeks now.
Re:Postmates Secures $141M in a ‘Super, Super Difficult’ Fun...
by ehnto on Tuesday November 01, 2016 @04:06AM
(#12844105)
All orders were $20 off including free delivery for the last week here. Still free delivery now that it's over.
Previous to that were free uber rides, free uber helicopter rides and all while still paying the drivers the same amount.
It is a shame to me, because we are a small city in a relatively remote location that had been incubating it's own smaller scale food delivery services. Some really cool platforms that could compete with Uber in all metrics but one: the ability to spend big to create incredible brand presence.
Everyone is now super excited about UberEats because it is cheaper and makes us feel like we're just like the cool kids in San Fran. Meanwhile these smaller companies will likely fizzle out, as our city just doesn't have the capital to invest and compete.
Re:Postmates Secures $141M in a ‘Super, Super Difficult’ Fun...
by rishabhparikh on Tuesday November 01, 2016 @02:53AM
(#12843896)
No it's free indefinitely. There's just no delivery charge whatsoever. Some items on menus are more expensive than they are at the actual restaurants though.
Re:Postmates Secures $141M in a ‘Super, Super Difficult’ Fun...
by nodesocket on Tuesday November 01, 2016 @04:06AM
(#12844103)
Honestly, I am shocked they were able to raise at all. I've used Postmates and Cavier a few times, but as soon as Uber Eats released, I haven't used either since. I exclusively use Uber Eats now and use it more frequently than I ever used Postmates or Cavier.
I have to guess the investors (Founders Fund - Thiel) know something I don't, because seems like a lost battle from my porch.
Re:Postmates Secures $141M in a ‘Super, Super Difficult’ Fun...
by CN7R on Tuesday November 01, 2016 @02:25AM
(#12843815)
I honestly don't think the 'boycott' was reflective the majority's opinion. Unless someone can compile a list of people who've said they outright weren't going to do business with Thiel.
Re:Postmates Secures $141M in a ‘Super, Super Difficult’ Fun...
by chronic6l on Tuesday November 01, 2016 @02:59AM
(#12843915)
People on HN like to complain (expected from the 18-25 year old crowd). But at the end of the day, they realize business is business and will do what's necessary to survive.
Boycott Thiel in front of your friends (a public position) but continue secretly dealing with him (a private) position. Sound oddly familiar...
Re:Postmates Secures $141M in a ‘Super, Super Difficult’ Fun...
by lathiat on Tuesday November 01, 2016 @04:03AM
(#12844088)
It's also entirely possibly you're legally obligated to do so.
As a simplified example; if they are the only option to get funding, it may be fiscally irresponsible to the other share holders to deny that option.
Same thing happens with bankruptcies, mergers & acquisitions, etc all the time - stuff may be sold to a company that the founders or anyone else is very objectionte to but they may have absolutely no say in the matter whether through no control in bankruptcy or simply not enough voting power with multiple interests.
Makes you really think about contracts and other such sometimes, just because you trust this company and it's founders or leadership now doesn't mean you can trust them later if they lose control.
Re:Postmates Secures $141M in a ‘Super, Super Difficult’ Fun...
by venomsnake on Tuesday November 01, 2016 @04:35AM
(#12844175)
On the issues - as my HN comment history shows - I am firmly on the democrats side - pro abortion, pro gay marriage, for sensible gun ownership, taxes on the rich, investment in infrastructure and education, single payer health care and so on.
And yet - the zealotry and fanaticism on the left to extinguish any kind of "wrong" thoughts, deviation from the norm, or perceived transgression is extremely off putting - around the time the Eich drama unfolded - I realized that these people are at least as dangerous as the conservative Christians when they had the upper hand in the discourse. They are against all and any forms of discrimination - unless the people discriminated disagree with them.
Destroying someone's livelihood just because they don't have the "right" values showed me that the new cultural overlords are the same as the old one. So I support Trump just to piss them off.
So I would not be surprised if a lot of Trump/Thiel boycotters are Jedi in the streets, Sith in the sheets - because real hackers always have a rebellion streak in them - and right now the left is "The Man"
Re:Postmates Secures $141M in a ‘Super, Super Difficult’ Fun...
by potatosoup on Tuesday November 01, 2016 @04:25AM
(#12844148)
That's an unusual stance for someone who is a CEO of a company for "rekindling passion for public service in millions of local government employees" and is worrisome.
You wouldn't support people like these government employees to have freedom of political opinion?
Re:Postmates Secures $141M in a ‘Super, Super Difficult’ Fun...
by tyre on Tuesday November 01, 2016 @04:32AM
(#12844160)
It's not about political opinion or because he supports the Republican nominee. He has a plethora of public comments revealing a shocking lack of empathy or caring about the greater good.
As I choose investors, it's very important that they are aligned with the impact we want to have on the world. Thiel is, to be generous, no where fucking close.
Re:Postmates Secures $141M in a ‘Super, Super Difficult’ Fun...
by CptJamesCook on Tuesday November 01, 2016 @09:29PM
(#12851620)
Peter Thiel cares a great deal about the greater good.
And since you are attacking Paul Graham for not disassociating YCombinator with Thiel, why don't you put your money where your mouth is and refund the money you raised to YCombinator?
Re:Postmates Secures $141M in a ‘Super, Super Difficult’ Fun...
by potatosoup on Tuesday November 01, 2016 @04:37AM
(#12844180)
That's fair and respectable. E.g. Martin Shkreli would probably not be a suitable investor for you.
However: "He has a plethora of public comments revealing a shocking lack of empathy or caring about the greater good." Very much "citation needed." If anything, I've seen Thiel genuinely want to improve our world.
Re:Postmates Secures $141M in a ‘Super, Super Difficult’ Fun...
by notfromhere on Tuesday November 01, 2016 @12:28PM
(#12847357)
From his own blog: "Since 1920, the vast increase in welfare beneficiaries and the extension of the franchise to women — two constituencies that are notoriously tough for libertarians — have rendered the notion of “capitalist democracy” into an oxymoron."
He's mad that women can vote because they don't vote libertarian.
Re:Postmates Secures $141M in a ‘Super, Super Difficult’ Fun...
by toomuchtodo on Tuesday November 01, 2016 @11:42PM
(#12852097)
Anyone with money can influence the political process with money, regardless of their beliefs.
Are you going to limit speech to that with which you agree with? You either trust democracy or you don't, and quite honestly I don't. People are disinterested, apathetic, and uneducated on the issues.
Re:Postmates Secures $141M in a ‘Super, Super Difficult’ Fun...
by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday November 01, 2016 @03:26AM
(#12843985)
Which, if one is honest, is what makes America work.
I disagree with Thiel. Sixty percent of Americans see similarly [1]. But guess what: democracy depends on tolerating--and reconciling--different views.
In Evelyn Beatrice Hall words, "I disapprove of what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it" [2]. The same fraction of Americans who disagree with Trump agreed with interracial marriage as recently as the 1990s [3].
Democracy is messy. If you like overruling others with force, don't pretend to like our system. You're lazy, trading liberty for security, and in turn deserve neither.
Re:Postmates Secures $141M in a ‘Super, Super Difficult’ Fun...
by intoverflow2 on Tuesday November 01, 2016 @07:24AM
(#12844741)
I'm all for "business is business" but it just gets irritating when these startups pretend to have an ethical approach but then that approach goes out the window when money is involved.
Re:Postmates Secures $141M in a ‘Super, Super Difficult’ Fun...
by meritt on Tuesday November 01, 2016 @02:20AM
(#12843804)
I'm still boycotting Thiel and any of his significant investments. For example, we cancelled our corporate Asana account after the Republican Convention and cited that as the sole reason for cancellation.
After his egregious Trump support, I absolutely refuse to utilize any service or product of which he's a prominent private investor. I know it's just a drop in the bucket, but dammit, you have to take a stand at some point, even if it's effectively meaningless.
Re:Postmates Secures $141M in a ‘Super, Super Difficult’ Fun...
by meritt on Tuesday November 01, 2016 @03:13AM
(#12843951)
If Dustin and Justin wants to really come out against it, they'll come against Thiel explicitly. Continuing to take his money while claiming to supporting the opposite is hypocritical. They are playing the same bullshit card that Sam Altman is and trying to brush it off as mere politics while hedging their bets and playing both sides.
I view Trump as an existential threat to everything that America is founded upon and I will not stand idly while "leaders" in the tech community support him.
Re:Postmates Secures $141M in a ‘Super, Super Difficult’ Fun...
by jessaustin on Tuesday November 01, 2016 @10:00AM
(#12845750)
How can one see all of the shit we've seen from Snowden, Manning, all of the drug enforcement murders and imprisonment all of the wars all of the murderdeathdrone assassinations etc. and then decide Trump is a bridge too far? Is this the first political campaign you've noticed?
Re:Postmates Secures $141M in a ‘Super, Super Difficult’ Fun...
by meritt on Tuesday November 01, 2016 @11:15AM
(#12846374)
Because Trump is the first candidate in history who has promised to ban an entire demographic of people, expressed confusion on why we don't use nuclear weapons, and threatened to attack a country based on some rude hand gestures.
This goes far beyond simple political differences: He'll drag us into another world war.
Re:Postmates Secures $141M in a ‘Super, Super Difficult’ Fun...
by jessaustin on Tuesday November 01, 2016 @12:38PM
(#12847478)
I'm not voting for him, but Trump is just a troll. He just says shit that turns the media's crank. He's not really a businessman anymore; he's a lazy social media figure. He won't build one mile of his famous wall, he won't do anything to reverse offshoring of jobs, and he isn't going to start stupid wars for no reason. Clinton has already done that last one...
[since no one remembers, I'm talking about Libya... who's next?]
Re:Postmates Secures $141M in a ‘Super, Super Difficult’ Fun...
by tha234 on Tuesday November 01, 2016 @02:05AM
(#12843758)
Ugh, thanks for the reminder, I'll use Caviar, Uber Eats, DoorDash etc. Supporting UFO level insanity like Thiel's and other conservatives is just ridiculous.
All of which means it's not clear if this is a difficult fundraising market or not. It certainly is for these undifferentiated delivery companies, but for tech startups? Not seeing it yet.
Couldn't the same be said about a lot of the "unicorns"? For example Dropbox or AirB'n'B don't have significant network effects and anyone with some cash can copy their software and directly compete with them (the same way Lyft is competing with Uber). The likes of Facebook and Twitter are an exception.
Then again you could say the same for eBay, yet Amazon couldn't get a competitor off the ground. One small moat (eBay has vs Airbnb model) is that you can automate the sale on eBay (so you'd have a hard time listing the same item on two sites -- you might sell it twice) while Airbnb still has manual intervention.
I don't really see what advantage Uber has over Lyft, Didi etc except the balance sheet and using it in the hope of doing the largest, fastest land grab possible. To draw a tenuous analogy, it's hard to say that the 17th-19th century European land grabs worked out that well in the long term.
http://www.businessinsider.com/uber-revenue-rides-drivers-an...
That's a $212m run rate; with moderate growth a $350m+ run rate seems entirely reasonable. sf is about the size of Austin. If Uber keeps 25%, that's an $87.5m business. Some extra growth on top of that (run a local delivery service; do some transit deals for elderly/kids/handicapped; etc) and you've built yourself a nice $100m business.
I would be happy to see a worker owned co-op emerge in a city like Austin. It would probably be better for the city and for the drivers.
That's a bizarre interpretation of "profitable".
As for the other comments mentioning EBITDA. The Tax in EBITDA is income tax.
You cannot be taxed out of being profitable.
The tax rate is not >100% so if you are profitable before taxes you are profitable after taxes. Just less so.
I have no idea what postmates means here by "profitable, w/o tax-related expenses". Maybe something like sales tax they collected that must be remitted? (that's not technically an expense either but they don't seem to know what they are doing or saying at the moment).
This is also based on Australian tax, I assume it's similar elsewhere but don't know the intricacies.
Lol welcome to New York. Even ignoring the cost of preparing reams and reams of paperwork, a flat $4 tax on, say, bagels could very well flip margins negative.
If conditions need to be perfect and regulations friendly and nothing bad can happen/everything must go according to plan for a company to be profitable, it's not profitable.
And that's fine if you make 6 figures and don't cook very often, why not be a regular Postmates person, but I just don't see how that works outside of certain neighborhoods in certain cities.
Not really sure if we count as 'the bubble', but people have shifted from calling restaurants (or Dominos) directly to using these services to 'upscale' and discover more restaurants.
I feel this is more of a he said she said kind of argument. Would love to see some data here (in terms of whether these deliveries are net additions vs. replacements of existing chains that deliver) but unfortunately, Postmates hasn't published anything yet.
Source: https://www.ozbargain.com.au/node/272512
The kinds of things I ordered before the modernization of Postmates were USB-to-Ethernet adapters, Macs, soldering irons, and more. These were typically high priced goods that I needed in a short period of time to keep up some service.
1/3 of the time lunch is wrong and there is absolutely no excuse for it. If you went to a restaurant and they could only get your food served correctly a third of the time you'd stop going back pretty fast I reckon
Edit: I think a big part of the problem is they don't read the order notes
It's funny that selling the company was their priority, and that they had to hire an investment bank to look for funders.
Bankers have a much wider network of potential investors than founders, and they can also run the process much more efficiently. Raising $141M is different from raising $14.1M, it gets way more complex. And at that amount / valuation, what can be a financing can quickly turn into an acquisition, think what happened to Cruise Automation.
Frequently the bankers do a principal investment in the same round they are raising for the company, to show that they have skin in the game, but also to position themselves for a potential IPO or M&A transaction (which is the lucrative part, you get 2-3% of the total consideration).
Qatalyst is well known in the Valley, another firm is Allen & Co. Both companies do principal investments, and so do the bulge bracket firms like GS, JPM and MS. GS put money into Uber.
So it's probably not "had to hire" but "decided to hire", and a perfectly common practice.
That said, I appreciate this startup's continued hustle.
I guess this is exactly what he means when he says Uber is "using their balance sheet as a weapon".
Previous to that were free uber rides, free uber helicopter rides and all while still paying the drivers the same amount.
It is a shame to me, because we are a small city in a relatively remote location that had been incubating it's own smaller scale food delivery services. Some really cool platforms that could compete with Uber in all metrics but one: the ability to spend big to create incredible brand presence.
Everyone is now super excited about UberEats because it is cheaper and makes us feel like we're just like the cool kids in San Fran. Meanwhile these smaller companies will likely fizzle out, as our city just doesn't have the capital to invest and compete.
I have to guess the investors (Founders Fund - Thiel) know something I don't, because seems like a lost battle from my porch.
So much for the Silicon Valley boycott of Peter Thiel.
I wonder if they would have raised from Thiel if they were in a position of strength, and had other options.
Boycott Thiel in front of your friends (a public position) but continue secretly dealing with him (a private) position. Sound oddly familiar...
As a simplified example; if they are the only option to get funding, it may be fiscally irresponsible to the other share holders to deny that option.
Same thing happens with bankruptcies, mergers & acquisitions, etc all the time - stuff may be sold to a company that the founders or anyone else is very objectionte to but they may have absolutely no say in the matter whether through no control in bankruptcy or simply not enough voting power with multiple interests.
Makes you really think about contracts and other such sometimes, just because you trust this company and it's founders or leadership now doesn't mean you can trust them later if they lose control.
And yet - the zealotry and fanaticism on the left to extinguish any kind of "wrong" thoughts, deviation from the norm, or perceived transgression is extremely off putting - around the time the Eich drama unfolded - I realized that these people are at least as dangerous as the conservative Christians when they had the upper hand in the discourse. They are against all and any forms of discrimination - unless the people discriminated disagree with them.
Destroying someone's livelihood just because they don't have the "right" values showed me that the new cultural overlords are the same as the old one. So I support Trump just to piss them off.
So I would not be surprised if a lot of Trump/Thiel boycotters are Jedi in the streets, Sith in the sheets - because real hackers always have a rebellion streak in them - and right now the left is "The Man"
You mean like suing Gawker out of existence?
the left is "The Man"
I get the impression from a lot of the alt-right that what they object to is not so much "the man" as "the woman".
You wouldn't support people like these government employees to have freedom of political opinion?
This isn't about politics. We're specifically apolitical (https://octopoedi.gitbooks.io/employee-handbook/content/Comp...).
As I choose investors, it's very important that they are aligned with the impact we want to have on the world. Thiel is, to be generous, no where fucking close.
And since you are attacking Paul Graham for not disassociating YCombinator with Thiel, why don't you put your money where your mouth is and refund the money you raised to YCombinator?
However: "He has a plethora of public comments revealing a shocking lack of empathy or caring about the greater good." Very much "citation needed." If anything, I've seen Thiel genuinely want to improve our world.
https://www.cato-unbound.org/2009/04/13/peter-thiel/educatio...
"Most importantly, I no longer believe that freedom and democracy are compatible."
"The best argument against democracy is a five-minute conversation with the average voter." -- Winston Churchill
He's mad that women can vote because they don't vote libertarian.
I don't see the problem with this unless he's proposing a constitutional amendment to have their right to vote removed.
Are you going to limit speech to that with which you agree with? You either trust democracy or you don't, and quite honestly I don't. People are disinterested, apathetic, and uneducated on the issues.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tyranny_of_the_majority
I disagree with Thiel. Sixty percent of Americans see similarly [1]. But guess what: democracy depends on tolerating--and reconciling--different views.
In Evelyn Beatrice Hall words, "I disapprove of what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it" [2]. The same fraction of Americans who disagree with Trump agreed with interracial marriage as recently as the 1990s [3].
Democracy is messy. If you like overruling others with force, don't pretend to like our system. You're lazy, trading liberty for security, and in turn deserve neither.
[1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-fix/wp/2015/09/14/si...
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Evelyn_Beatrice_Hall
[3] https://mechanicalbrain.files.wordpress.com/2012/04/interrac...
Not sure how they expect us to swallow it.
Looks like Thiel came to the rescue when Postmates was not able to raise fund from anywhere else.
>I wonder if they would have raised from Thiel if they were in a position of strength, and had other options.
Seems like Postmates did try raising from somewhere else first - at higher valuation perhaps, but maybe they were getting devalued?
After his egregious Trump support, I absolutely refuse to utilize any service or product of which he's a prominent private investor. I know it's just a drop in the bucket, but dammit, you have to take a stand at some point, even if it's effectively meaningless.
Especially as the founder of Asana is spending millions supporting Clinton against Trump
I view Trump as an existential threat to everything that America is founded upon and I will not stand idly while "leaders" in the tech community support him.
This goes far beyond simple political differences: He'll drag us into another world war.
[since no one remembers, I'm talking about Libya... who's next?]
Just delete him from the cap table?
What exactly would you do?